Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S3 Ep9: GRD037: How Should I Adjust My Spending in Retirement to Stay on Track With My Goals?
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the saver, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic.
- 0:22With the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:29You, a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:33each side of the debate to your own personal situation to decide
- 0:36what's best for you and your family.
- 0:38So here we go.
- 0:39Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 0:44Ed, move a little this way.
- 0:46Yeah, what?
- 0:47Okay, sit up a little higher.
- 0:48Okay, now smile.
- 0:50Perfect.
- 0:51That's it.
- 0:51Sometimes, Ed, it's the little adjustments that make all the difference in the world.
- 0:57Yes, that's right.
- 0:58Today, Ed, we're going to talk about adjustments.
- 1:00More specifically Is this a chiropractor thing?
- 1:05Different type of adjustment.
- 1:06We're going to talk about spending in retirement and what sort of adjustments
- 1:10people can make and or even what sort of processes people can go through to help
- 1:14them make sure that they don't run out of money before they run out of life.
- 1:18Right.
- 1:19I don't know about you, Ed, but for me, even people with significant wealth,
- 1:22that tends to be the number one question they have when they hit retirement.
- 1:25Yeah.
- 1:25Everybody asks, you know, the 4 percent rule and all of that, how much can I take
- 1:29out and when will I run out of money?
- 1:32And I always ask them the same question.
- 1:34When will you die?
- 1:35You know, you give me the date of death, I can give you the exact calculation.
- 1:38So you already brought up one with the 4 percent rule.
- 1:41So really when I think about retirement spending, right?
- 1:44I just say that because everybody says that.
- 1:46Yeah.
- 1:46Yeah.
- 1:47No, it's a prominent rule for for those You know who are not aware
- 1:51which I think most people would be aware if they're listening But the 4
- 1:54percent rule made popular by planner Bill Bengen years ago where he
- 1:58researched he said what what's the?
- 2:01The largest percentage that someone could take from their retirement portfolio and
- 2:06not run out of money over a 30 year span.
- 2:09Now, of course, he used historical returns, right?
- 2:12And so there's no guarantee that those same historical returns would,
- 2:16you know, would still be true today.
- 2:18But what he found was if you took 4 percent out, of a retirement account or
- 2:22really just 4 percent of your assets each and every year that you would not run out
- 2:26of money in any of the, you know, in any of the periods of time that he analyzed.
- 2:30But again, that doesn't mean that the same would hold true today.
- 2:32So, so just to put numbers on it, it's not that much.
- 2:35Uh, you'd have to have a million dollars just to generate 4, of income.
- 2:39Correct.
- 2:39Now, of course that You know, it's separate and apart from any
- 2:42social security someone might have.
- 2:43No, just on that.
- 2:44But yeah, exactly.
- 2:45From your portfolio, that, that's generally what the 4
- 2:47percent rule would assume, right?
- 2:49Which doesn't seem like a lot.
- 2:50It doesn't.
- 2:50It doesn't.
- 2:51But if you're trying to make dollars last for 30 years, and the other thing
- 2:54is to inflation adjust those dollars.
- 2:57In other words, 40, 000 year one, Ed, but in year two, you know, maybe
- 3:0241, 000, year three, 42, 000, and so forth to make sure that you're.
- 3:06You're keeping up with inflation.
- 3:07That's kind of what the research showed.
- 3:09Now, it's fair to note, though, that 4 percent was the percentage he found where
- 3:17it would, it was the highest percentage where there were no failures effectively.
- 3:22But that means to your 90s and so forth.
- 3:25Well, uh, for a 30 year period, right?
- 3:27But but what was interesting or what you think about that?
- 3:29That means that every other scenario except the worst case he analyzed
- 3:33Someone made it through those 30 years and ended up with money, right?
- 3:37In fact in many of the cases he analyzed someone would have started let's say
- 3:40retirement with a million dollars started taking the 40, 000 inflation adjusted
- 3:45it each year and maybe ended retirement when they died after 30 years with 5
- 3:49million left, 6 million left, way more than they started with, which may or may
- 3:54not, you know, comport with their goals.
- 3:56If their goals, I'd like to leave my kids a big inheritance.
- 3:58It's pretty good.
- 3:59If your goal is, I hate my kids and I want to spend every dollar,
- 4:02you've done a bad job if you die with five billion dollars, right?
- 4:04I just don't think, we've talked about this before, anybody can bring themselves
- 4:08to spend their last dollar as a plan.
- 4:11It definitely is.
- 4:12Well, that, that gets to the heart of our discussion today, Ed, which is
- 4:15how do you think about adjusting your spending in retirement to stay on track?
- 4:19And staying on track is about spending and to, to help achieve your goals.
- 4:26If your goal, again, is I want to, uh, leave a significant inheritance behind,
- 4:31then dying with a lot of money inside your accounts, and when I say dying with a lot
- 4:34of money, I don't mean like unexpected at a heart attack, I mean living a reasonable
- 4:38life expectancy, going, you know, things going quote unquote according to plan.
- 4:43Uh, then you, you, you might have to adjust upwards your spending in
- 4:47order to account for that if your goal is just to enjoy your retirement
- 4:51to the fullest extent possible.
- 4:53Now the old school people, I know Mike, my parents generation, the
- 4:57World War II generation, they always said, never touch principal.
- 5:01Yeah, that's very good when you have an interest rate.
- 5:03And we're finally back to a meaningful interest rate today, but for a long time.
- 5:07People do think like that.
- 5:09Well, I never want to see that go down.
- 5:10Yeah, well, uh, Again, if your goal is to leave an inheritance behind.
- 5:16That's not a bad idea.
- 5:18No, the goal, forget about beneficiaries.
- 5:20I think in those cases, their goal is they never want to leave themselves
- 5:24in case there's something that comes up, big cash, you know, medical,
- 5:28whatever it is, they never want to go.
- 5:30They want to have that cushion.
- 5:31But, that cushion effectively means if you never go below your principle,
- 5:34you are theoretically going to die with the amount that you started with,
- 5:37which, again, Well, that is, that is.
- 5:39But that, if your goal is not to leave behind an inheritance, you've,
- 5:42you've, you've shortchanged yourself.
- 5:45No, that, you can have both.
- 5:48I mean, they're going to get the inheritance, but that wasn't driving it.
- 5:51The thing that was driving it, as you get older, you worry
- 5:53about running out of money.
- 5:55Yes.
- 5:55And they never want to see that balance go down.
- 5:58So if we think about like ways in which people structure their retirement
- 6:02distributions today, I can think of like three or four different ways
- 6:05that people set up their accounts and think about taking distributions.
- 6:09Like one of them would just be, uh, you know, a, a fixed dollar amount, right?
- 6:14So they start and they begin taking Let's say a hundred thousand dollars a
- 6:18year beginning the year they retire, and they take a hundred thousand dollars,
- 6:22exactly that amount, every single year.
- 6:24Effectively, you know, this is the classic annuitization.
- 6:27Now you can do it with a real annuity, or you can just kind of pseudo
- 6:31annuitize your own money, if you will, and just take the same dollar amount.
- 6:34The, uh, the, the nice part, if you will, is if you use an annuity, you
- 6:40have some protection, right, Ed?
- 6:42Right.
- 6:42You have guaranteed payments for life.
- 6:44I have those myself.
- 6:45So, there's some benefit there.
- 6:47The downside to, like, let's say a, a regular annuity that is fixed over
- 6:53an annual basis where there's no increases is that you can't No, you
- 6:57won't keep up with inflation over time.
- 6:59Yeah, but they, they have riders and stuff like that.
- 7:00And you pay for all of those things.
- 7:01You do, so if you, you can certainly add inflation adjustments to an annuity, but
- 7:07I think there's two things worth knowing.
- 7:08Like, today, well one, if you add those riders, it means you're taking less
- 7:12income day one than you otherwise would.
- 7:14Right, that's what I mean, you pay for it somewhere.
- 7:16Yeah, it's always going to be there.
- 7:17And the second thing is, there's actually, uh, there used to be
- 7:20products, I think, Um, but I know today for a fact that we don't have
- 7:24any true inflation adjusted annuities.
- 7:27You can get a 2 percent or 3 percent every year, but it won't actually take into
- 7:31consideration the true cost of living because the insurance carriers are worried
- 7:35about that type of risk taking it on.
- 7:37So, but that's one way, right?
- 7:38Is, is taking a fixed annuity.
- 7:39over the course of your life.
- 7:41And that's like the worry free way.
- 7:43Well, worry free, it might feel good.
- 7:46But again, if you live a long time, 20, 30 years, 100, 000 in 20 or 30 years is not
- 7:51going to be worth what 100, 000 is today.
- 7:54So the benefit there is that you have the guarantee of income.
- 7:58The downside is Lifetime guarantee.
- 8:00That's right.
- 8:00Lifetime guarantee, potentially, right?
- 8:02But the downside is you're losing some, uh, inflation protection.
- 8:05Yeah, spending power.
- 8:06Yep.
- 8:07You know, another possibility would be to take, let's say, a fixed percentage
- 8:11each year, a la, as you brought up before, the, the 4 percent rule.
- 8:15Now, the upside to this is that if you do this kind of on a regular
- 8:20basis, and you structure your initial percentage at 4%, or some reasonable
- 8:26percentage that you, you believe is going to last, you should be able to
- 8:31You know, make it throughout your entire retirement and not run out of money.
- 8:36And also to have a predictable income stream.
- 8:38Right, right.
- 8:39Obviously you, you have to figure in what, what your cost of living
- 8:43is, your expenses, and look at, look at that growing over time
- 8:46and with inflation as well.
- 8:48Now, the one thing that is challenging about that though, is
- 8:51if you just take a fixed percentage, uh, of your dollars each year.
- 8:55Then you, uh, you end up a fixed percentage of your
- 8:58initial dollars, I should say.
- 9:00You're, you're discounting any changes that occur in your portfolio.
- 9:03For instance, if it's a really bad market, you retire into a bear market.
- 9:06Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 9:07You know, taking the, the, that percentage, that flat
- 9:10percentage that you started with.
- 9:12Well, the challenge is you, it becomes a larger Yeah, but much higher percentage.
- 9:16Right.
- 9:16If you start taking 4% out of a million dollars.
- 9:19That's fine.
- 9:20But now if you go, let's say the market drops and just to make our
- 9:22math easy, let's say it drops by 50%, the same 40, 000 out of 500, 000.
- 9:27It's 8%.
- 9:28That's called sequence of returns risk.
- 9:31Indeed.
- 9:31One of the most important things that retirees should be mindful of,
- 9:35you know, those initial retirement years, the few years just before,
- 9:38the few years just after retirement, like a red zone of risk for retirees.
- 9:43The returns in those years.
- 9:45It's hard to come back from that.
- 9:46It is.
- 9:46The returns in those years have outsized importance.
- 9:49But it can also work to the upside, right, where if those first few years
- 9:52of retirement are really strong.
- 9:55Right.
- 9:55Taking out, again, a fixed percentage of those initial dollars may mean
- 9:59you're not taking out enough.
- 10:01Uh, again, it depends upon someone's goals, but that's you and what,
- 10:04that's where I said before, the goals mean has to cover your spending.
- 10:08Yes, that's exactly right.
- 10:09And but someone may say, I, Hey, if the markets do well, I wanna spend more.
- 10:12Well, if you're taking out this flat percentage, then that doesn't do it.
- 10:16Now you could say, well, I'll just, instead of taking out 4%, like
- 10:2040,000 year one and 41,000, year two, 42,000, year three, and so forth.
- 10:25You could say, well, I'll just take out 5 percent of my portfolio
- 10:29every year or something like that.
- 10:30The challenge there though, is you have a lot of variability in your income, right?
- 10:35For instance, if your account value is a million dollars
- 10:37in year one, that's $50,000.
- 10:39If in year two, the account has dropped to 700, 000, now you have 35, 000 to live on.
- 10:45Yeah, yeah.
- 10:46Um, one thing we haven't discussed, we, we're talking about this
- 10:49income as if it's all spendable.
- 10:51What about taxes?
- 10:53Yes.
- 10:53Well, taxes have to come out of that percentage, which is, you
- 10:56know, further going to erode that.
- 10:57That's going to cost a living.
- 10:59Absolutely.
- 10:59Yeah, and, and can significantly erode that further.
- 11:02So, you know, the So, you know what I did?
- 11:04What'd you do?
- 11:05Well, we talked about, uh, having guaranteed income for life and I always
- 11:09say this in my consumer seminars when I talk about annuities like you were
- 11:13talking about, I said the only thing better than, uh, tax free income for life.
- 11:18I think you were going to say the only thing better than income for life.
- 11:22Yeah, yeah.
- 11:22Let me explain to you what you were about to say.
- 11:24Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 11:24Yes.
- 11:24Here's what I always say.
- 11:27Except for right now that I did set it backwards.
- 11:29All right.
- 11:30The only thing better than guaranteed income for life.
- 11:32What is it, Ed?
- 11:34Guaranteed tax free income for life.
- 11:37You know, when I say that in seminars, people light up witty.
- 11:40In other words, you just keep all the money.
- 11:42Uh, I did it myself because I have annuities in my own Roth IRA.
- 11:47Not only do I have guaranteed income for life, but if I take it from there, it's
- 11:53guaranteed tax free income for life.
- 11:56Now, I haven't done the whole thing.
- 11:57I still have a stock portfolio in there, but it's a good cushion
- 12:01against a guardrail, a buffer.
- 12:04Yeah.
- 12:04And so, you know, that's one way in which you can make sure that
- 12:07you don't outlive your money.
- 12:09Another way and a way that was made possible or not possible, uh, popular,
- 12:14um, by a, uh, an article written a number of years ago, uh, Jonathan
- 12:19Guyton, the financial planner made this, um, largely, uh, You really
- 12:24raised this possibility was this thing called gutters and guardrails, right?
- 12:29The idea that you would put some bands around your your percentage distribution
- 12:35So that for instance if in year one you started out taking four percent you would
- 12:40make yourself some Decisions at that point to say hey as long as each year my account
- 12:45is You know, my distributions are between You three and 5 percent of my portfolio,
- 12:52I'm not going to change anything.
- 12:54But if on the chance that the markets do poorly, and my distribution
- 13:00is too high, then I'll adjust my income each year downwards.
- 13:05And the opposite too, saying, Hey, if the markets do well, and my
- 13:09withdrawal rate is too low, you know, that's actually, it sounds like a
- 13:12bad thing, a too low withdrawal rate, but that's actually a good thing.
- 13:15It means your account balance is too high and you're not taking out
- 13:17enough that you could take out more.
- 13:20And this, uh, this gutters and guardrails approach actually has a, A really, really
- 13:26profound impact on helping individuals to make course corrections throughout
- 13:31their retirement and not, um, not to, not only avoid running out of money,
- 13:38but to avoid drastic changes in their income from one year to the next.
- 13:41So definitely changes from time to time as markets move and account values change.
- 13:46But it, it, uh, one of the more effective ways, in my opinion at least.
- 13:51Uh, Helping individuals to make sure they don't outlive their money.
- 13:54But also spend enough each year.
- 13:56It's amazing what a few minor changes early in retirement can do and
- 14:01how much of an impact on a 30 year retirement spending pattern it can have.
- 14:06But again, you have to be able to manage your expenses and sometimes
- 14:10that's out of your control.
- 14:11Medical bills hit and things like that.
- 14:14Yeah.
- 14:14And, and, and those are the, those are the shock expenses
- 14:17that often derail a retirement.
- 14:19Um, for sure.
- 14:20Uh, long term care certainly would be one of them.
- 14:23Uh, probably, you know, that's probably the single biggest one
- 14:26that most retirees worry about.
- 14:28Um, you know, there are certain ways of mitigating that, whether it be long
- 14:31term care insurance or you know, in some cases, individuals who have not, uh,
- 14:35who have either not accumulated enough assets or have done certain planning
- 14:39to make themselves look like they have not accumulated enough assets, uh, can,
- 14:43you know, enroll in Medicaid, but that is more or less effective depending
- 14:47upon which state you're living in.
- 14:48Yeah, that's generally not a good plan, but it is the last plan for some people.
- 14:54Yeah, it's um, I think people prefer choice.
- 14:59And when you have Medicaid, you often lose a significant amount of choice
- 15:03over the type of care you can receive.
- 15:05Well, on that happy note,
- 15:08well, listen, the most important thing is that people, when they're
- 15:12looking at making their retirement decisions, right there, they're
- 15:15doing so with an eye on the future retirement for a lot of people today
- 15:18is, you know, is 20, 25, 30 plus years.
- 15:22And what you start with on day one of retirement very quickly changes.
- 15:27You know, I'm fond of saying when someone comes into the office, their financial
- 15:29plan is valuable, it's meaningful, um, and it helps us make good informed decisions.
- 15:35But at the end of the day, it's, it's already out of date by the time
- 15:38they have walked out of the office.
- 15:39Things change.
- 15:41We need to change to accommodate and so it's important to develop a
- 15:43spending pattern in retirement that helps keep track Uh that helps you you
- 15:48need to figure out how you're going to adjust your spending in retirement
- 15:52To make sure that you're going to not outlive your money Sometimes that means
- 15:56spending less today to have a little bit more buffer later Sometimes that
- 15:59allows you to spend a little bit more today because you have the buffer But
- 16:02you got to know what you're doing.
- 16:03Yeah.
- 16:03The problem is the unknown, like you were talking about the markets up.
- 16:07Uh, so the advice is retire into an arising market.
- 16:11That's right.
- 16:11Only retire when there's a good market into the future.
- 16:14We're going to leave it at that.
- 16:15Hopefully you're a clairvoyant and you've picked up some stuff here today
- 16:18from the great retirement debate.
- 16:19Ed, always a fun time with you.
- 16:22Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 16:26This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and should
- 16:29not be construed as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice.
- 16:32Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information
- 16:35which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 16:38Third party information is deemed to be reliable but its accuracy and
- 16:41completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 16:43The topic discussed and corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 16:46and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth Partners.