Latest / Two PhDs on a Pod / Are There Universal Superfoods?
Transcript
- speaker-0: Okay, Momo, let's play a game. Welcome to the Precision Diner. And today's special is the Ultimate Influencer Lunch, which is a big spinach salad with some nice sliced almonds on top, a side of roasted broccoli, and a tall glass of artisanal kombucha. Man, I think I have a... a little bit of you know, worrying happening in my mouth when I think about a meal like this. Okay. But this meal may not be the best for everybody. Okay. I'm going to give you the molecular results of a Viome test from three different customers who walk into Precision Diner. And of course this test is based on their RNA activity in their gut and so forth. Your job as the resident biochemist is to debug this menu so we don't accidentally harm them and make sure that they're healthy and only eat the things that are good for them. Love this game. Happy to play it. I've got my lab coat on, so bring on the data. Awesome. So here's customer one. This person's Viome test shows that the microbiome has very high hydrogen sulfide production. So their gut is basically like a sulfur refinery. What are we going to do to their plate? All right. So first of all, the broccoli has to go immediately. And that's because cruciferous vegetables, which broccoli belongs to, are packed with compounds called glucosinolates. So these are molecules that have sulfur in them. And many of the gut microbiome bacteria will actually convert those glucosinolates into a biological gas bomb, which is hydrogen sulfide that can cause rapid emptying of their intestines. So we're going to swap. Broccoli with asparagus Asparagus has a similar fiber content similar micronutrient content But we prevent that we prevent that sulfide producing bacteria from too much party All right, so that's one customer. No broccoli next one Okay customer number two also has one test results, but in this case it shows a severe inability to process oxalates Okay, the pathways are clogged And the data is basically showing that they may even have some joint pain and kidney stress and so forth. What would you do? Yeah. So unfortunately they're going to have to remove spinach from their, ⁓ from their salad. And that's because spinach and almonds as well have some of the highest oxalate content of all foods. And so because they're both rich in oxalates, they're going to have to basically give those two foods away to someone else. And for these kinds of people eating that salad is like swallowing microscopic shards of glass. These oxalates can make crystals that can damage joints and kidneys and cause kidney stones. we're going to swap those two and we're going to swap spinach for arugula. And arugula is a great base for a salad. And then we're going to swap almonds with pumpkin seeds and pumpkin seeds are packed with very healthy oils. and very healthy protein, including some very healthy amino acids. And they'll have a very similar texture, crunch, and very similar vitamin profile with zero oxalates essentially that will not have any negative effects on joints and kidneys. Ooh, that still sounds super tasty. I would have this arugula salad. Yes. And last one. Okay. Customer number three. Okay. For this person, the viral results show a spike in their immune system activation. Okay. Their system is highly inflamed and it's showing some kind of a histamine overload. So what would you do for somebody like that? Yeah. For those people, they're going to have to skip the kombucha. Fermented foods are great for some people, but if they're high in histamines and so giving kombucha to an inflamed histamine sensitive gut is basically like pouring fuel on a fire. And so the swap is that instead of drinking that fermented tea, which is kombucha, they should be drinking iced peppermint or mint tea or ginger tea to actually soothe the GI tract unless they have other sensitivities to these specific foods. Exactly. So that's literally the point of this episode, right? We can take the healthiest meal on the internet and how we cannot really serve it as is to three different people with three different individual biologies. That can be a disaster for them, right? Turns out that If you run that meal with the spinach and almonds and the broccoli and kombucha through our algorithm, based on that microbiome data, about 20 % of the population would just not be able to eat it because of one of these problems that you just mentioned. So the point is there's no such thing as a universally healthy food. There's only food that matches your individual biology or it doesn't match your individual biology, right? Today we're going to teach you how to stop eating like this average human and start eating like a precise, individually fine-tuned biology that is you. That is great, Guru. Okay. I'm Momo, a biochemist. And I'm Guru, an AI expert. We're two PhDs on a pod. All right, Mo, let's get on with the next section. What's on your radar right now? Ooh, okay. I have a lot of things going on on my radar, but I'll just highlight a couple. So last week I was at the Precision Medicine World Congress. It's a big conference in Santa Clara, California. And I really, really enjoyed all three days. These are top scientists. This is one of the best conferences in that they bring literally the top scientists in the world, including some Nobel Prize laureates typically, including this year. And there are many, many takeaways. I can spend an hour reviewing all of the great science that was presented. There was a lot of oncology focus. There was a lot of longevity focus and a lot of multi-omics focus. I'd just like to highlight two characters from that conference that I really liked. One was David Sinclair, whose company has a FDA green light to enter human clinical trials. ⁓ And so that's really, really important. And then Michael Snyder from Stanford, who presented his great platform for multiomic profiling on human beings and identifying very, very early signs far, far before any symptoms would set in of multiple chronic diseases that point to this need for basically digitizing the human body and finding biomarkers well before any symptoms onset. And that's of course what we are focused at Viya. So it's basically the same ⁓ wavelength. And we're going to have Michael Snyder on our podcast in one of the future episodes. So that's sort of on the professional side. On the fun side, I just recently made over the weekend, my favorite crepes. And for the audience members who've never tried these kinds of crepes, I am absolutely crazy over them. And so I make crepes with soy milk because I cannot have dairy, but they taste just like normal crepes. And then the filling is the key. The filling is basically melted sugar and the sugar just melts from the heat of crepes. And then it is ground up walnuts and then whipped cream. And because I cannot have dairy, I use cocoa whip, which I think it's even better than the normal whipped cream. And so you just fill the crepe with a little bit of sugar, quite a lot of walnuts and a lot of whipped cream and fold it into a very large cylinder. And that's just one of my favorite desserts. So maybe we'll be making those on one of the future episodes. I'll tell you what's on my radar related to to foods. I showed you one of the really neat features of the Viome app, which is that you get personalized recipes on your app based on your individual superfoods and your avoid foods are of course not into it in any of the recipes. But overall you get a collection of I think up to three thousand recipes that are going to be ranked based on your specific food recommendations. So you can pick and choose which ones you like and it'll tell you which foods are your superfoods, which are your enjoy foods. And it'll not include the things that are either minimize or avoid as much as possible. But sometimes if it does, it'll kind of take the score down a little bit. And so you'll know what's going on with each of the recipes. But the recipes have been tested by chefs. And it's been shown to be very tasty in addition to being the right individually appropriate thing for you. I love this feature, Guru. I absolutely love it. It's a feature that a lot of our customers are going to use and I tested it. And it's not only what you said that there are plenty of recipes, there's a plenty of variety of recipes and that they give you a score, but also that there are filters built in so that you can actually filter those 3000 recipes. into subcategories based on how you feel today or your dietary preferences. So for example, you apply a vegan filter and we currently have 140 curated vegan recipes. So you can be cooking for many, many meals, a variety of vegan foods, and that's really impressive and they all taste great. So congratulations on that. Yeah, that's a great feature. And I have to thank the people on our team who came up with that idea and implemented it in a very quick timeframe on my personal side. I am super excited about a new movie that's coming out. It's actually one of my favorite, all-time favorite sci-fi books. It's called Project Hail Mary. I read that book several years ago when it first was written by Andy Weir. But I love that book because it has aliens in it, but those aliens are all biologically plausible aliens. And it's actually mind boggling how well written the book is, you know? First of all, since you're microbiologist, I just mentioned that there is a new kind of a microbial organism, a single celled organism called astrophage. Okay. It's super amazing. It actually can convert energy into mass and store it in its nucleus. And also it actually has the same type of biology. has a nucleus, it has all the organelles, including mitochondria and all of that stuff. So it's so great. to see how Andy Weir develops that concept. And that book has now been turned into a movie with Gosling. And I am so looking forward to seeing it next week. And this is a really, really exciting. ⁓ by the way, one of my friends just gave me a Lego set, which is to build the Project Hail Mary ship, which I'm super excited about building this weekend along with my daughter. That is super geeky. First of all, second of all, I am actually not a big movie goer, especially not going to the movie theaters, but because you've hyped this movie up so much, I'm actually going to go to the movie theater and watch this one because I trust you. uh, and it's interesting that they named this microorganism a phage because current phages, as we know them, have essentially none of those features. You know, they can of course not store. Energy into mass and they don't have mitochondria and they don't have all those things. So It's a sci-fi thing. But hey in the future and on a different planet. This is you know different a different world You could have phages that have all those features and they can still infect bacteria. So exactly, you know Infect stars, you know So anyway, it's super fun. Super fun. You should definitely watch it amazing, but let me come back to Something you said at the end of the last episode you said that you're gonna create a super quick, tasty and healthy dessert recipe. And you said that you'd show us how to make it. Do you have that? I do. I made that dessert. Yes. So I made it last night and it just took a few minutes to make it. We're going to roll the video now and it's a super nutritious, super delicious dessert that has about 18 grams of protein per serving. A dessert with 18 grams of protein per serving. And it's a vegan protein. Hey everyone. I'm going to show you right now how to make a very quick, very nutritious, and very delicious dessert. And this is going to be a chocolate pudding made with tofu. So it's also going to be vegan for those who are either dairy intolerant or who are vegans. We're going to have very few ingredients. have here 14 ounces or 400 grams of firm tofu, organic of course. We have some unprocessed cocoa powder. So that's not Dutch processed, which destroys some of the antioxidants. We have a sweetener of choice, which is maple syrup, but you can choose pretty much any sweetener you like. And we have vanilla. That's it. Those are all the ingredients. So here I've taken out the tofu. from its watery container and then we're going to dump it in here. And then the rest of the recipe is going to be very subjective. It's going to be however you like it. If you like dark chocolate, for example, like I do, you're going to want to add a lot more cocoa. If you like milk chocolate, you don't want to add a lot of cocoa because it's going to be kind of bitter. So we're going to add some cocoa for now and you are going to adjust your sweetness however you like. So I'm going to add a little bit of maple syrup. And then vanilla is a very subjective thing again. It's based on your likes and dislikes. And I'm just gonna add about half a teaspoon. So about two and a half mils or so, think, of vanilla. Well, that's it. Those are the ingredients. We are now going to start blending this. and see how it goes. And we may need to add a little bit more water if the texture is not right. You want to use a very powerful blender if you can. This is a Vitamix, which I love, but there's many others, I'm sure. just going to bring everything down because it splattered all over the sides. and the thickness looks good, but we may need to add a little bit more water because it'll thicken a little bit as it sits in the fridge as well. It's always easy to add water. It's once you add too much water, that's very difficult to restore. Okay, so you can try it here the first time. I like a little bit darker, so I'm gonna add a little bit more of that. I like it a little bit sweeter. just completely, you adjust that based on your likes and dislikes. And now we're gonna go back to. Okay, that's it, we're ready to serve. The dessert is ready. Boila! That's a vegan chocolate pudding with tofu. Very high protein content and super creamy and super tasty. And you can adjust the amount of chocolate or the chocolate flavor and the amount of sugar and the type of sugar and the amount of vanilla. Everything is fully adjustable. Momo, that looks amazing. You need to that for me when I'm in Seattle, This is what could be one of my favorite desserts. So I hope you love it. Yeah. I mean, it's super creamy. It's you're going to fine tune the taste to be exactly the way you like it. So we're going to experiment with you. When you come to my house, we're going to make it the way you like it, because maybe you like it more chocolatey or less chocolatey. Maybe you're like it less sweet or more sweet. Maybe you like it thinner or thicker. We'll figure it out. I already thought of one modification I want to make, which is I will probably put some cardamom in there. ⁓ wow. Okay. I mean, I love cardamom, but not in desserts. So I guess, yeah, we can personalize this dessert for you. There's lots of Indian desserts which have cardamom in them. So I'm going to try that. you said something during that video, you said that this is tasty and healthy. Yep. dessert definitely looks like it could be, you know, I wonder though, whether it's going to be healthy for everyone. Yep. Yep. It's a good question. That is the main topic of this episode. Is there such a thing as a universally healthy food, right? So let's see the ingredients, right? You had tofu in there. Generally healthy. Which is really healthy generally. Right. But I think it may not be super healthy for everybody. That's right. And we want to talk about that. Yep. And then there's cocoa, there's maple syrup, there's vanilla. Those are small components which may not make a huge difference. Well, but cocoa... has very important antioxidants. When it's not processed, cocoa has very important antioxidants. So it's very healthy again, generally. And there are now randomized controlled trials showing the dark chocolate, but not milk chocolate due to the higher cocoa concentration actually has many health benefits. But again, for the average human. love dark chocolate. So I think I'm going to read up on all those benefits and maybe take advantage of them. Okay. But let's talk about all of these foods with two people we want to bring on to this podcast who are clinical nutrition experts, Dr. Grant Antoine and Janelle Thrunel. Let's bring them on and talk to them about this dessert. Woohoo! Okay, let's talk about these foods with our two special guests and clinical nutrition experts that have joined us, Dr. Grant Antoine and Janelle. Connell, Grant and Janelle are leaders in our clinical nutrition team at Bio. Welcome to the episode, Grant and Janelle. speaker-1: Thanks for having us. We're excited to be here. speaker-0: Thanks Guru. Hey Momo. Hey there. Alright, I'm going to jump right into it, okay? Momo just showed us a really tasty looking dessert that he prepared. It does look great and yummy, it has tofu as the main ingredient. And I'm not sure that tofu can be a great healthy food for everybody in our audience. Yeah, so... Mostly fermentation is a good healthy process for us, right? We don't do it again. These microbes in our gut do it for us thinking about fibers. We can't break down some of these fibers. We rely on those microbes again to do the work. But when they do that, they actually, they produce beneficial molecules and nutrients for us that then we use both in the gut and throughout the body. And they're really important signaling molecules, right? So typically fermentation is a good thing. But If we have a dysbiotic picture, maybe we have IBS symptoms, folks can be really sensitive to that fermentation and that gas that's produced, and it can irritate the gut lining and cause symptoms. Right? So the low FODMAP diet and all FODMAP stands for, they're just basically fermentable carbohydrates. Right? And let me see if I can do this. Fermentable oligo dye and polyols, right? Polyols? Which are just a bunch of hydroxides on carbohydrates. But anyway, microbes can take those carbohydrates, ferment them and produce gas. So if you're sensitive to that gas, we pull back. actually there's a lot of evidence for the low FODMAP diet, at least initially for helping to improve IBS symptoms, right? So we don't want to do that for the longterm. Remember that those fermentable carbohydrates, they're beneficial for us. But if we want to have an impact on someone's day-to-day upfront, we'll pull back on those FODMAPs, reduce their pain and discomfort. And then we'll work on supporting the microbiome and the gut. to where we can slowly reintroduce those foods to get the benefits. Grant, that's super interesting. And Momo, as a biochemist, I wanted to ask you, I'm the non-biologist here. So I'm going to ask you, what is this process of fermentation? What is the microbiome doing to your food that we call fermentation? Yeah. Let me just add a little more information here. Thank you, Grant, for all those explanations. So tofu is a complex food in that There are two different varieties of tofu. There is the normal tofu that you buy at the grocery store and that one is not fermented. There is a fermented version, but that is typically not found in the United States and it's called stinky tofu. And that's probably the main reason it's not found in the United States because Americans wouldn't buy it. But I actually tried it in Taiwan and it was absolutely delicious. There's also something called bean curd, which is basically fermented tofu that mimics blue cheese. It actually tastes very similar to blue cheese. So if you're lactose free or like dairy free, and you want to taste something that tastes like blue cheese, you can go for that and find it at local Asian stores. So fermentation can happen upfront, meaning during food preparation and fermentation can also happen inside the intestines. so fermentation basically means that microbes are feeding on a food in the absence of oxygen. And so when they're doing that, they're producing specific gases and specific molecules. that in some cases may be beneficial to us and in other cases may be harmful to us. So, Robbo, there is, correct me if I'm wrong, but there is no oxygen in your gut, correct? That's a normal state. So a healthy state in the large intestine. So in the colon, there is no oxygen and that's where we support fermentation of microbes. But in the small intestine, there is oxygen and there's very few microbes there for... various other reasons as well, mostly because of bile acids being very highly antimicrobial. Got it. Got it. So, Grant, thank you. That's super helpful for us to know. So I always thought that tofu is great for everybody and it has so much good profile of proteins and tastes great for me. And you could make it in such a flexible way in so many different ways and so many different dishes. But really there's a bunch of things that you need to watch out for. That's right. mean, really you just need to test. need to test to know your own microbiome, what it's capable of, where your imbalances are. And then now you can make personalized food choices based off that information. Right. Perfect. Yeah. That's pretty much the key takeaway. Right. So for anyone listening to us, do you know whether you're on the left side of that chart or the right side of the chart? Actually, it's very difficult to know unless you test. So that's the reason why it makes sense to test your microbiome and see what's the activity and the functions that are going on, right? So let me move on to the next topic. And I want to bring up a kind of an endless debate that happens online about whether meat and specifically red meat is a superfood or it is heart attack fuel. Let's call it that, right? Janelle, when I look at the population data again, that same 50,000 people that we've made recommendations to in Viome, I see that the data is a little bit of a mess because it's definitely not what I expected it to be. let me show you that data. look, this profile looks like about under more than a half of the people can actually enjoy or even maybe consider lean beef as a superfood, which is great news for a lot of people because they love eating beef. Right. But then a little less than half of the people should really watch out because that red segment over there, which is just a little less than a quarter, they may have cardiovascular risk because of the contents, the ingredients of red meat. And then another little less than a quarter may have some kind of digestive disruption. So explain to us, Janelle, what's going on over here with lean beef. speaker-1: Yeah, I love that you have this graph because I think it actually really highlights the controversy, right? So for a long time, red meat in particular was kind of villainized and we're staying away from it because of heart disease risk. And I would say more recently, we've seen kind of a comeback, even now in the USDA guidelines, it's highlighted a little bit more. ⁓ But the truth is, is that it's really nuanced, right? It's not. in the green zone for everyone. And it's important to understand where it lands for you. There's benefits. And I always say this, you know, with any, anyone I work with that like every whole food has a benefit, but it's not always beneficial for you maybe at this moment. So we're going to get not only like protein from beef, but we're getting B vitamins that help with our energy. We're getting things like CoQ10, which again is really important in producing energy for our cells. So there definitely are benefits to consuming it. There's also some downsides. And I would say, you know, similar to, to us, like it comes from an animal and that animal is what it eats, right? We are what we eat as well. So we want to think about that when we're choosing like beef or even eggs, I would put into that category. ⁓ things that are going to be more like pasture raised, grass fed, organic, things like that are going to have different nutrient profiles than conventional. So, so think about that. We want things with more omega-3 content and just better quality when possible. But I'm really glad that Momo highlighted what's happening in the gut because that's part of the picture here with beef. Beef is really rich in a nutrient called carnitine. And. What can happen in our gut is those bacteria take that carnitine and they can metabolize it into something called TMA, it's trimethylamine. TMA then goes to our liver and it's converted to TMAO. And what we see in the research is that TMAO is associated with heart disease risk and arterial plaques. So we want to be really mindful of that, but like the nuance here is that some people's gut... produce a lot more TMA than other people do. They might eat the exact same amount of meat, but someone's going to produce more than the other person. And that's really just dependent on the composition of their microbiome. speaker-0: You know, let me ask you, is the TMA going into the liver involved crossing the gut barrier? And is this because of leaky gut also, or is this independent of leaky gut? This is just a normal process that happens from your gut to your bloodstream. speaker-1: Yeah, good question. More things get through when we have leaky gut all the way around, right? But this is part of a normal process and we're always going to have some TMA produced. But when we're having excess amounts is really when it gets harmful. And I would say that's kind of across the board in our gut. You highlighted methane gas on there and it's the same. Like our guts are going to produce some gas, right? We're going to, those microbes are going to ferment things. We're going to make gas from it. But when it becomes harmful is when we're producing too much. So same story there, like if we have this imbalance of microbes in our gut, ⁓ that carnitine from the red meat can be converted into methane gas by certain microbes with androgens. And some people just have more of those and more active ones than other people. Now, the problem with that is it's going to say that methane gas is going to... slow down our digestion, right? Our muscles that can tract along the way to move food through the digestive tract. Methane gas will actually slow that down and then food sits in our system longer. We might feel bloated. We might feel constipated, but it also leaves more time for potentially harmful metabolites to sit on that gut lining and cause some damage and get through. So. It's a double-edged sword and you want to know what your gut is doing with those nutrients and things like red meat to say, how often should I really be having this in my diet? Is it helping me or is it more harmful for me? speaker-0: Yeah, that's a great description. Thank you. And I have to ask you also about the portions that people eat, right? Actually going back to the tofu as well as the beef. When something is not great with your gut, meaning that you cannot process it the way you would want it to. Does it mean that you can still eat like smaller portions or do you kind of need to stop for a little bit, let your gut rewild and recover from whatever issues it's having, and then start eating. What is your recommendation for that? speaker-1: Yeah, that's a good question. generally with some of these things, we'll recommend trying to avoid it as much as possible. But we have to note, some of these nutrients, Grant brought up oxalates, they're in a lot of different foods, right? We're not going to be able to avoid all of those foods. Carnitine is in a number of different foods. So being mindful of those foods that are highest in that thing that's harming your gut. And we're going to pull back on those, maybe avoid them, minimize, reduce portions when you do have them is going to be the strategy. And then see how the gut responds, right? Can we heal it over time and then reintroduce those foods again? speaker-0: I think you guys both mentioned a number of sort of scientific principles in your description. So if there are good papers that can support some of these points, we will definitely put those up in the show notes down below. So you'll have links to those papers and you can look them up and read this on your own. I'd like to comment on this topic. Go for it. Yeah. So I have two One is that as you can see from your pie chart, it's very obvious that some people benefit from beef and other people can be harmed in various ways. And when people read the literature, the general nutritional literature and ask the question, is beef good for me or not? All of those papers and all of the studies and trials are going to ask one question, which is, is beef good for all people or is it bad for all people? And when the reality is that it's good for some and bad for others, what is going to drive their result is going to be which people they actually pull into their trial. If they by chance pull in more people that benefit from beef, then their trial is going to show beef is good for humanity. But if another trial pulls in more people for whom beef is bad, they're going to come out with a completely different result. And at Viome, we completely break those barriers and we know that different people will react differently to beef. And therefore we actually know by testing who's going to react positively and who's going to react negatively. So those are very important takeaways for people to understand is this applies not just to beef, it applies to tofu, like we discussed, but it also applies to almost every food. And we're going to highlight many of those over our podcasts, but that is a key differentiator between Viome and most of the other nutritional community that we understand different responses. So that's one thing I wanted to mention. The other thing I wanted to mention was Janelle alluded to this, that some TMA is not that bad for your health. In fact, there are studies that showed that some TMA is actually healthy. It's only when there's too much of it produced that it's bad for you. And so here we have a very typical example where these molecules that are produced by the gut microbiome can actually support a healthy physiology, but if they're overproduced, then they're obviously going to harm us or they may harm us. so going back to this minimize or eliminate, you know, in this particular case, I would say that minimizing is probably a better choice unless the production of TMA is absolutely huge. And that's, that can be all quantified using our Viome test. And that can be very precisely determined. And that's why we have two different food categories, minimize and avoid so that computer algorithms can actually make that determination instead of someone trying to guess. Great points, mama. Thank you. And again, you're going back to your first point about some significant proportion of the people having benefits and the rest of the people having detrimental effects. That is the problem we mentioned also in the previous episode, which is that you don't want to look at the averages for a population because that average may not apply in this case, you know, for lean beef, it might just turn out to be no effect, you know, so you do keep doing what you're doing, but it turns out that for half the people, it's bad, for other people, it's good. So you need to know what your specific physiology looks like and then determine what your diet is based on that. So that's our key point throughout over and over. moving on to the next topic, I wanted to bring up another set of data for the volume population and a question related to that. So I pulled up here. A number of the foods that are commonly discussed about whether it's good or bad for you. We already talked about lean beef, but I also brought up here broccoli, black beans, turmeric, cashews, tuna, et cetera. All of them have this good for some people, not good for some people type of a profile. I wanted to particularly pick up on turmeric, which is a generally known good food. But it turns out 33 % of the volume population is recommended to minimize or avoid turmeric. So happens I was one of them. So, you know, I'm from India, so I use turmeric in many of the dishes. So it was a pretty big hit for me, but maybe I was overdoing it. So Grant, was I overdoing it and are other people overdoing it? That's why it should be minimized or is there something else going on? Well, likely you weren't overdoing it, but maybe your microbes were. Let me explain. So tumeric, it's actually, it's an herb and it's a cologog, meaning it produces or stimulates to production of more bile in the liver and more release of bile into the gut. produces stronger contractions of the gallbladder. So when you eat your food and your body detects fat in that food, it will tell the gallbladder to contract, to release. those bile acids to help come in as an detergent to help you digest and metabolize those fatty acids that are in the food. Normal process, Tumorix supports that. And a lot of times we can use that medicinally to support gallbladder flow for folks that have a history of gallstones and inflammation of the gallbladder. But on the flip side, as we're releasing those bile acids, the microbiome can actually take those bile acids and metabolize them as well. And it turns out that these bile acids are very important signaling molecules for our bodies. They trigger immune responses, they trigger metabolic responses, actually changing our gene expression in the liver and how we respond and control both blood sugar and blood fats, blood cholesterol. And the microbes in our gut play a huge role in influencing how those signals are received by our body. Okay. At Viome, we have a bile acid metabolism score that'll actually look at those factors influencing that metabolism and whether the overall balance is a net benefit or net harm based off the score and that microbiome activity, right? So those microbes are going to take those bile acids that are released and convert them into other types of molecules that then have either deleterious effects or positive effects, right? So if we're taking turmeric, that's going to increase the amount of bile that's being released. So if we already have an overproduction of these negative bioacids, these secondary bioacids, we call them, then we're just adding gas to the fire, right? We're just adding more flame to that inflammation and those downstream immune and metabolic processes. So if we pick up on that activity, we're going to pull back on turmeric and we can bring other foods in to help influence this activity as well. it's really, you know, like all biology, it's really a Goldilocks, right? Momo just mentioned with TMA, a little bit is good and bile acids, certainly a little bit is good. And some specific bile acids are more beneficial than others, which are more harmful, right? So coming in and being able to modulate that and balance it, we've been able to do that with intermittent fasting. It's been shown through influencing circadian rhythms. We can do it with other foods. Capsaicin is one. It actually blocks the enzymes that bacteria use to do the work, to do that conversion. And it's shown to lower. those negative bile acids in blood. That's important because whether it's controlling our metabolism, protecting our liver, protecting our colon, because these are also genotoxic, as some of these bile acids are, we want to be checking in on this microbiome activity to make sure the net result is a benefit and not a harm. And so we can pull back on that microbiome activity, bring us back into that Goldilocks zone. So we get the majority of benefit and that's going to support our health for the long term. makes sense to me. Momo, any questions before we move on to the next topic? No, I think this was very well done. Turmeric is such a super food, but not for everyone. Sorry, you're not able to eat it. Well, I'm I'm back from that. You know, I actually cut it down and then I tested again and we'll talk about that benefit of testing again and so forth. And now I've bounced back. I can bring back turmeric in my life. That's the beauty of it. Yeah. These aren't forever recommendations. It's very important for folks to realize where these aren't allergies or sensitivities. This is microbiome activity that we're trying to improve and we can. Yeah. So not a forever recommendation at all. I'll mention again that for the key scientific papers, we're going to post them down below in the show notes. You can always look it up, read, ask questions in the comments, and we'll be happy to answer questions from the audience anytime you want. Yeah, let's talk about wheat, a highly controversial food. So Janelle, would you like to discuss benefits and harms of wheat, please? speaker-1: Yeah. I'm glad we're throwing this one in the mix because I actually think this is probably one of the most villainized foods out there. So many people, know, are on the gluten-free bandwagon who maybe don't need to be, right? And we need to think about that. Momo said to us earlier that wheat is like taking a multivitamin if you're having whole wheat. And there's some truth to that, right? It's got a lot of B vitamins, got a lot of different minerals in there, but you're also going to get some things like antioxidants. antioxidants that are good for your vision, right? That we don't always think of when we think of having like a whole wheat bread. So there's, there's so many benefits. And I always want to highlight to the fiber content. I think that fibers may be not sexy to people, but like to us here at Viome, fiber is very sexy and your microbes love it. And it's got so many good benefits for you. So wheat is a superfood in that sense. Now there's obviously our people who have celiac disease or who have gluten sensitivity and don't react well to wheat or to other grains that have gluten in them. And for those people, of course, it should be avoided because it's causing a reaction for them. The other group of people that I'm mindful of when we think about wheat is people that we look at and see that they have a leaky gut. And now our gut is lined with cells and we like them to be like really tight and close together and be a good barrier, right? They're like our wall of defense, like from the outside world coming in. We want to be able to regulate what's coming into our body and not allow everything in there. Unfortunately, due to a number of things, right? It can be our diet, stress, a number of things that impact our body can cause those cells to kind of loosen. And we call that leaky gut because then things can pass through our gut lining and our body gets an immune response to them and we can experience that in a lot of different ways. There's some evidence that shows that a certain protein in gluten grains can cause some of that gap, right? In those tight junctions of our cells. And so if you... have leaky gut, we might want to be careful, right? We want to reduce gluten and whole wheat for a period of time and see if we can strengthen that gut lining up a little bit and then reintroduce it slowly and look at that response. I'll say though that there's a number of things that can help our gut lining. So just being mindful of gluten is not the only piece. Like Grant was saying, we can introduce things and Different types of fiber are so important because our microbes can use those to produce butyrate. Butyrate strengthens our gut lining. And so we can attack it from different angles if that is an issue. But again, it's not an issue for everyone. For some people, maybe we're going to be a little bit careful of it. For other people, wheat has so many nutrients and so much value that we want to include that in the diet. Now with wheat... Be really careful about what you're choosing, right? It needs to be whole grain and flip over those food labels. Look at the ingredient list. If it just says wheat, it is not whole wheat. It's got to say whole wheat or a hundred percent whole wheat. Look at the fiber content. You should see like two to three grams of fiber per serving ish. speaker-0: And multigrain is not whole wheat, just want to say as well. They try to trick you, right? They tell you it's multigrain. It's not necessarily a whole speaker-1: Yeah, yeah. Not necessarily whole grains. And sometimes there are, right? So there's like that fancy stamp now, that whole grain stamp that will be on the front of the labels. And that can even be deceiving too, because the whole grain stamp only has to have half whole grain, 50%. If the stamp says 100%, then it has to be completely whole grain. So you've got to look for those little differences in there to make sure you're getting a 100 % whole grain product. speaker-0: That is amazing. wasn't aware of that. When is that being rolled out? speaker-1: That's out now. You can see that on the front of food packaging. speaker-0: Okay. That's great. That's super helpful because the vast majority of breads you find at the grocery store, they will have names such as whole grain bread or multigrain like Grant was saying, right? But then you look at the ingredients list and whole wheat is like eighth ingredient down the list. And so that's not really helpful. What you want is you want the word whole wheat to be the first ingredient. If it isn't the very first ingredient, then they just basically sprinkled some whole wheat and then They have a reason to call it whole something, but it really isn't. And all the benefits that Janelle outlined earlier are really mostly there in whole wheat. If you strip away the parts of the wheat that have those ingredients and you're eating white wheat, then that's just basically starch. It's like eating rice and the benefits are significantly reduced. So be careful what wheat you eat. Again, just like going back to carbohydrates, know, are carbs good for you or bad for you? there are phenomenally healthy carbohydrates and phenomenally unhealthy carbohydrates. So asking the question of are carbs good or bad is not really sensible. And in this case, when we discuss wheat, only when we discuss whole wheat and only for the population that's not sensitive to it, do we really need to consider all the benefits. And even then there's a possibility that some people will not benefit from wheat depending on what kind of microbes they have and what their activities are. Yeah, I wanted to go back to one of the points that came up multiple times in our conversation so far, which is this concept of leaky gut. And I wanted to ask you guys, especially from the clinical practice standpoint, Grant, maybe this is a question for you. Is there an easy way for someone to know whether or not they have leaky gut, and if so, to what extent? ⁓ I don't know what you mean by easy, but there are tests for intestinal permeability, right? That we can perform clinically. And there's a quite a number out there. ⁓ but the, the lactulose mannitol test, I'm going to say is the gold standard. You basically ingest these carbohydrates. One of them is normally absorbed, right? Through normal digestion. The other one is not, we cannot metabolize that and we do not absorb it. But if there's damage or in high, or intestinal permeability where that carbohydrate can get through. Now we'll see it in the bloodstream. So you do this injection of the carbohydrate and then we do a blood or urinary tests and we look for the levels of these carbohydrates in the blood and then that ratio of the two carbohydrates, one being absorbable and non-absorbable. Now we have a measure of intestinal permeability and Momo knows more about that than I do. He can speak more to that science. But yeah, definitely we can test. With Viome, we don't do those direct intestinal permeability tests at this time, but we do look at... microbiome activities that we know are either harmful or beneficial for the gut lining. And then we get the net sum of all those activities, inflammatory activities, biofilm, chemotaxis, violence pathways. We sum all that activity together and then report on your gut lining health score for you. But it's not a direct measurement of the permeability of that gut lining. Yeah, I'd like to add some things here. So, yeah. So we talk about gut lining in many contexts and let's talk about one specific one, is acrimansia mucinifila. So this is a celebrated gut microbe and people think of the early papers showing metabolic benefits of this bacterium. But what is also now known is that this bacterium degrades the gut lining. basically consumes, it feeds on the mucins that are protecting our intestinal lining. And so. If the bacterium, if we starve acrimansia of fiber, it will resort to consuming mucin and it'll basically strip away that barrier. And so to prevent it from doing that, you want to distract it with fiber. And if you provide it with fiber, then it's going to preferentially feed on the fiber and leave the mucin alone. And so those are some of the things that at Viome, we can measure those biological activities of these microbes and we can identify what biological activities they're performing and we can shift their dietary preferences basically, and give them what they want that's beneficial for us and withdraw things that, would harm us. And so that's, those are some of the knobs that we can turn. And going back to what Janelle was saying, that fiber is so important. This is just one of many examples where fiber can actually help you rebuild your intestinal barrier, but you have to do it carefully and you have to make sure to provide the right type of fiber for the right microorganisms and right activities. I was going to. just put some takeaways clearly in the show for today, unless someone else, any one of you have any other points to make. I want to make a point about the wheat just a little bit more, because this is a fascinating subject to me. So wheat, whole wheat is packed with nutrients and it's extremely healthy for a lot of people, but not for everyone. How do you know if you're not going to respond to wheat in a good way? You can do your celiac tests, which are available online. You can do your food sensitivity tests, which are currently available online from many vendors. And Viome is actually developing its own food sensitivity tests because they're very important to complement our normal metatranscriptomic tests. And then you can also look at the Viome leaky gut score and then consider the Viome recommendations as specific to wheat in order to at least test whether wheat might affect your leaky gut or not. So those are sort of... practical takeaways, but if none of those harms are in your way, obviously there are hundreds of thousands of people in the world who are very healthy and in their eighties and nineties who eat wheat every single meal. And so it is known to be a very healthy and nutritious food, but of course they are eating whole grain. They're not eating highly processed wheat products that we buy at the store. And I want to, I want to provide two takeaways in terms of what I do at home. We actually buy wheat groats. So these are literally wheat grain that you buy from a farmer. And we have that in our house. We buy it at the bulk section of the norm of the, of the local co-op. And then we grind it using Vitamix. So Vitamix comes with an attachment for grinding grains. so Guru and I will do a cooking show later when we are going to make uttapams and this is a South Indian delicacy. And when we make dishes, we will literally grind the wheat right there. and right before we use it. And we do the same thing for breads and for pancakes and so on. So that's one really interesting way to do it. Another extremely interesting way to process wheat at home that actually addresses some of these anti-nutrients that people talk about, like phytic acid, is to actually sprout the wheat. And sprouting wheat is super, super simple. And we will show you that in one of the upcoming shows how I do it. I've been doing that since basically I was a little boy. You sprout the wheat and during the sprouting process, that phytic acid is actually degraded. So even if you're negatively responding to that phytic acid, you can get rid of that by ferment, by sprouting wheat. You can also ferment wheat, like making sourdough bread, and that'll also get rid of phytic acid. So there are all these little culinary tricks that you can use to derive a maximum benefit from wheat and potentially remove some of the harms. And just one more announcement that we'll go through. making a specialty bread, is really interesting, where normally breads are made from flour where, you know, whole grain is ground, but you can also make bread by simply sprouting wheat. And when it's sprouted, wheat becomes so soft that you can basically turn it into a paste just by mashing it. And you can make wheat bread out of that, out of sprouted wheat. And it tastes amazingly well and it's super healthy. It is packed with nutrients and it has a great texture. Awesome Momo, you know all those great foods are making my mouth water especially the uttapam. I know my mom is going to be watching this and she's going to be thinking about all the good stuff that she taught me when I was a kid and say okay you know what that's all paying off now. Yeah she may like your uttapam recipe but she may cringe at mine because I've heavily modified it but it still tastes great. think she's also adventurous so she'll try new things no problem. Okay great. Listen, folks, I think we've had an amazing discussion for the last 30, 40 minutes. And I wanted to just summarize a couple of takeaways from my perspective. number one is that there is really no such thing as a universally healthy food. Pretty much every food that you look at, you're to have a segment of the population for whom it's going to be great. Or at least no harm. And there's going to be a segment of the population, sometimes small, sometimes larger, for whom there could be some detrimental effects depending on the biology of that individual. And I think today we have discussed a lot of microbiome related biology and we have not really spent a lot of time talking about the details of that microbiology, but guess what? Our next episode is in fact going to be about the microbiome. So we're going to get into the details of what is the microbiome? What does it do? How does it work? What's good about it? Et cetera, et cetera. And it's actually a great friend of yours that you cannot live without it. And so you better take care of it, right? So all of that stuff is going to happen in the next episode. But in this episode, we saw the impact of the microbiome on the foods that you eat. So that's another big takeaway for me. Momo, if you want to summarize any other takeaways, we can then close. Yeah. think just expanding on what you just said about personalizing foods, it's very easy to fall into the trap of finding a paper that describes a study where the food tested is beneficial to humans and justifying you consuming that food or finding another paper that says that that food is bad for humans and justifying not consuming that food based on your personal preferences and whatever beliefs you have. But the reality is that both of those papers might be wrong in that they asked the wrong question. And so they derived wrong answers. The reality is until you test, you really don't know whether that food is good for you or not. And as you age, your microbiome changes, your physiology changes, and what used to be good or bad for you could now flip. And therefore you really need to be testing longitudinally. And that's exactly what we've established as a technology company and as a platform. And really proud of that. Excellent, excellent. So Grant and Janelle, thank you so much. You guys are doing awesome work and your insights and your knowledge about the physiology, about nutrition and about clinical processes of different types. They're helping so many people. So we really thank you for that. And thank you also for joining us for the last hour or so and sharing those thoughts with our audience. Thank you, Gurud. Thank you, Muma. Thank you, guys. speaker-1: Thanks for having us. speaker-0: All right. That brings us to a new segment within this podcast that I'm excited about, and we're adding it to this episode, the bio monthly challenge. There will be a challenge and there will be a reward. And so we are going to post this monthly challenge. So that's going to be for the month of March. And that is we're going to, we're going to ask you to create or find. a nutritious and delicious recipe that costs no more than $4 for US dollars per meal. So keywords, nutritious and delicious. Those are the ones that we're gonna be judging by. And you need to explain how this meal can be prepared for less than $4 per meal. And then you need to make it in your kitchen and take photos of the finished meal so that we can see what it looks like. And that's going to be a part of the judging criteria. And then in the comments of this podcast, you would write the shortest version of the recipe that is sufficient for anyone to repeat and make that recipe. So it doesn't have to be one of those recipes where there's a long, long intro as to what this recipe is about and where it originates and so on. Write basically the shortest recipe and post a photo of that meal. then Guru and I will review this challenge. and decide who is the winner and go ahead and go to describe the reward. Yeah, you know, we look forward to seeing a number of entries in the comments down below this episode. And when we see those different ideas, different pictures and the recipes and so forth, one of them is going to be a lucky winner. That winner is going to get a free Viome full body intelligence test. This is like a 399 US dollar value. So this is not a small thing and you will get it at home so you can test with Viome. You can get your molecular insights. You can get your food recommendations. You can get all the things including that personalized recipe feature that I described earlier. All of those things will be in your hands. And the only way that you will qualify for this monthly challenge is to follow the instructions that Momo mentioned earlier, which is that you create a fine, nutritious and delicious recipe and should cost no more than four US dollars. So you should show us what the cost is and you make it yourself in the kitchen. Take a photo of the meal and put that photo in the comments, write a short version of the recipe. Believe me, this whole thing is going to be worth it for you because you're going to get this reward, which is going to be super fun. And then we can even explain your results to you maybe once you get your test and once you get your results and all of that stuff. That sounds amazing, Guru. mean, every time we mention the Viome tests, it's just such an amazing feeling for me because we started developing those tests in 2010. So it's been 16 years. And even today, 16 years later, the vast majority of academic researchers do not have access to this technology. It's simply too expensive, too complicated. And just too complex, basically. today someone is going to, well, not today, but next month, someone is going to get a test kit that does this metatranscriptomic analysis of stool blood and saliva. So that's a very nice reward, Guru. That's amazing. So now let's go to the last section, which is what's in the next episode. We want to announce the next episode because it's a very exciting one to me, especially. And so we have discussed a lot about the microbiome in this episode, and we will of course continue to discuss the microbiome, but there are still many people who don't know what exactly we mean when we say microbiome. And so what is going on with microbiome? What is it? What are the tens of thousands of biochemical reactions that it performs? And the next episode, we're going to dive deep into all of these questions of this fascinating world. and show you a lot of data from the largest microbiome data set we know. And that is our internal bio-micro-biome data set. And we actually just submitted a paper on that or one slice of our data set. So that's very exciting. Guru? Yeah. And maybe you'll bring some props. We'll definitely get some data on charts and stuff like that like I normally do. And you know what, Momo? You are the leading expert in this area. And I am going to be the student. Okay, my name is Guru, but I'm going to actually be the Shisha, which is a student and you're going to be the Guru next time, which is the teacher. And you will give us a glimpse into this world of microbiology that I know a lot of progress has been made over the last 10 to 20 years in the world as a whole, but I think no one has a bigger and more rich data set than what my own has today. So we got to bring. pieces of that data to show you what we can see in the microbiome. As many of you know, and I mentioned in the first episode, we have processed more than a million samples now from people from more than 100 countries. So that's a lot of data, both the breadth and the depth of the data is unmatched. So we're bring those data views in different ways and show you what exactly is going on. And to me, it's actually mind boggling how much stuff is going on there. We will break it down for you and show you some pictures that you will be glad that you saw. Amazing. Yeah. I mean, we're going to talk about different tests for microbiome that are available in the market and contrast that with biome tests. We're going to talk about the taxonomy of microbes, which is the composition. We're going to talk about the biochemistry of the microbiome, which is their functions, relationship to humans and human health and so on. And so in conclusion, Please don't forget the VIO Monthly Challenge. Please participate in that and follow the challenge and put your comments down in this episode. We really look forward to seeing you back here and please don't forget to subscribe because that's how you help us create more content and that's how you help yourself by being notified when we publish new episodes. And if you have any comments or questions, please post them in the comment section below because we will be picking some of those questions and answering them. in future episodes. please, if you have thoughts, if you have questions, doubts, whatever about anything we're talking about, please post them and we are happy to respond. yeah, I cannot wait for the next episode. love it. Yes. Okay. I am Momo. I'm Guru. We're two PhDs on a pop. speaker-1: two PhDs on a pod is a biome health science podcast production written and hosted by biome CTO Guru Banavar and biome CSO Momo Vujicic produced and edited by Lisa Schomo podcast art by Kevin Wu. If you enjoyed today's episode, like and subscribe for new episodes every other week. We'll see you next time.