Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Color Vision, Depth & Size: How We Perceive a 3D World
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. Go ahead
- 0:02and pull up a chair to our virtual study session.
- 0:05Yeah, grab your notes and grab a coffee because
- 0:07we have a lot of ground to cover today. We really
- 0:10do. So today, our mission is to decode all that
- 0:14incredibly dense material from chapter 10 on
- 0:17color, depth and size, which is definitely going
- 0:20to be a huge part of midterm. So, you know. Pay
- 0:22attention. Exactly. We are going to help you
- 0:25prep for the midterms by breaking down how our
- 0:27eyes and brains actually construct reality. And
- 0:31we'll give you some handy memory tricks along
- 0:33the way. I definitely need those memory tricks.
- 0:35Right. But before we jump into the textbook definitions,
- 0:38I want to pose a slightly mind -bending question
- 0:40to you. OK, lay it on me. Look around wherever
- 0:43you're listening to this right now. you know,
- 0:45look at your room, the library, wherever. How
- 0:48much of the world that you see right now is actually
- 0:50real? And how much is just like a hallucination,
- 0:54your brain completely made up on the fly? I mean,
- 0:57it honestly sounds like the premise for a science
- 0:59fiction movie. Totally does. But from a strictly
- 1:01neurological perspective, that really is the
- 1:04fundamental question of perception. We intuitively
- 1:07assume our eyes are just, you know, passive video
- 1:10cameras recording an objective reality. But the
- 1:13underlying mechanics are so much weirder. Yeah,
- 1:16way weirder, and far more active than that. So
- 1:18let's start with Chapter 10's first big topic,
- 1:21the biological and, um... moral purpose of color.
- 1:25Yeah, before we can understand exactly how we
- 1:27see color, we really have to understand why the
- 1:30visual system evolved to see it in the first
- 1:32place. Right, because color isn't just this aesthetic
- 1:35bonus feature of the universe. Exactly. The literature
- 1:38breaks down the evolutionary function of color
- 1:41into four main uses. And the first one is object
- 1:44detection. Which I like to think of as nature's
- 1:46marketing department. Like, its entire job is
- 1:49to hijack your attention. That's a really good
- 1:51way to put it. Because if you think about like
- 1:53a bright red stop sign or a red poisonous berry
- 1:56in a green forest, red naturally commands our
- 1:59visual system. If stop signs were painted, I
- 2:01don't know, a pastel blue. We would all just
- 2:03crash. Exactly. They'd blend into the sky and
- 2:06we'd have a lot more accidents. Yeah. It directs
- 2:08our attention, tells us what to eat. Like you
- 2:10eat the yellow banana, not the teal one. Right.
- 2:12And that flows perfectly into the second use,
- 2:15which is scene segmentation. Breaking things
- 2:17apart. Yeah. When you look at a really complex
- 2:20environment, say, a vibrant orange flower against
- 2:23a background of green leaves, those hue differences
- 2:27allow your visual cortex to instantly slice that
- 2:31scene up into distinct objects. So it separates
- 2:34the foreground from the background. Exactly.
- 2:36And it does it without your brain having to process
- 2:38the physical shape of every single individual
- 2:41leaf. Which saves a ton of processing power.
- 2:43And that brings us to the third use, which I
- 2:45think is where the implications get incredibly
- 2:47fascinating, health and mating. Oh, yeah, the
- 2:50biological billboard. Right. Across basically
- 2:53all species, color is a billboard for genetic
- 2:56sickness. A peacock flashes those bright saturated
- 2:59feathers to show off superior genetics. And we
- 3:02humans do this, too. We are super sensitive to
- 3:04the color of human skin. If someone looks slightly
- 3:07greenish or incredibly pale, we instantly perceive
- 3:10them as unwell. Our visual system is acting as
- 3:13a rapid diagnostic tool. Right. It's looking
- 3:15for blood oxygenation levels, which show up as
- 3:18really subtle shifts in skin tone. But OK, doesn't
- 3:21this raise a huge philosophical issue, like a
- 3:24moral pushback here? What do you mean? Well,
- 3:26if our brains are biologically wired by evolution
- 3:29to judge another living being based purely on
- 3:33visual health cues, literally judging a book
- 3:36by its cover based on the wavelength of light
- 3:38bouncing off them, Are we morally responsible
- 3:41for our visual biases? Oh, I see what you're
- 3:43saying. Because we are biologically programmed
- 3:45to make these snap judgments about the fitness
- 3:48of other people. That is a really interesting
- 3:50point, but I think we have to be careful not
- 3:53to confuse a biological heuristic with a moral
- 3:56destiny, you know? Fair point. Like yes, our
- 3:59eyes feed us data that demands a rapid judgment,
- 4:02because that's how we survived out on the savanna,
- 4:04but recognizing a biological reflex isn't an
- 4:07excuse for prejudice. Right, it's just a statistical
- 4:09shortcut the brain uses. Exactly. And interestingly,
- 4:13that deeply subjective experience of color is
- 4:15what drives the fourth use the text Burr mentions,
- 4:18which is aesthetics. Just finding things pretty.
- 4:21Yeah. Certain highly saturated color combinations
- 4:24evoke a really profound sense of beauty, which
- 4:27is a uniquely complex cognitive response. So
- 4:30to recap for the midterm. The four uses are object
- 4:33detection, scene segmentation, health, and aesthetics.
- 4:37Got it. But we should probably clarify a technicality
- 4:39here that the research emphasizes. The difference
- 4:42between true color blindness and color deficiency.
- 4:45Oh, yeah. That is a really vital distinction.
- 4:48True color blindness is incredibly rare. It's
- 4:50basically seeing the world entirely in grayscale.
- 4:53Yeah. It usually only happens if someone is a
- 4:55raw monochromat. which means they are born without
- 4:58any functioning color receptors called cones
- 5:00in their eyes at all. Or I think it can happen
- 5:02from a traumatic brain injury. Right, if you
- 5:04damage the specific color processing centers
- 5:07in the visual cortex. But what the vast majority
- 5:10of people call color blindness is actually just
- 5:12color deficiency. Which perfectly transitions
- 5:15us into the second big section, hardware versus
- 5:17software, or how the eye actually processes color.
- 5:21The great color theories. Historically, There
- 5:24was this massive academic turf war between two
- 5:28competing theories of color vision. There really
- 5:30was. So back in the 19th century, you had the
- 5:33trichromatic theory, which was championed by
- 5:36Thomas Young and Hermann von Helmholtz. The Helmholtz
- 5:39theory, yeah. They argued that our eyes contain
- 5:42exactly three types of receptors, and each one
- 5:44is tuned to a different wavelength of light,
- 5:47red, green, and blue. So they hypothesize that
- 5:50every single color we experience is just a mathematical
- 5:53mixture of those three signals. Exactly. But
- 5:55then Ewald Herring comes along and throws a massive
- 5:58wrench into that with his opponent process theory.
- 6:00Right, because he pointed out that if vision
- 6:02is just a mix of red, green, and blue, why are
- 6:06there certain colors we literally cannot imagine?
- 6:09Yeah, the impossible colors. Like you can imagine
- 6:11a yellowish red that's just orange, but try to
- 6:14imagine a reddish green, or like a a bluish yellow.
- 6:18You can't. It literally breaks the brain. A hearing
- 6:21also pointed to after images, which is my favorite
- 6:23part. If you stare at a false colored image,
- 6:27the textbook uses that classic illusion of the
- 6:30Canadian flag. Right, where the maple leaf is
- 6:32green and the background is black. Yeah. If you
- 6:35stare at that for 60 seconds and then you look
- 6:37away at a blank white wall, you don't see white.
- 6:40You see a glowing red and white phantom flag.
- 6:43And the trichromatic theory couldn't explain
- 6:44that at all. Not even a little bit. Hearing realized
- 6:48that our vision has to work in opposing pairs.
- 6:51Red is pitted against green. Blue is pitted against
- 6:54yellow. Black is pitted against white. So if
- 6:57you stare at that green maple leaf for a minute,
- 6:59you physically exhaust your green receptors.
- 7:03So when you finally look at a neutral white wall,
- 7:05the red receptors spring into action because
- 7:07their green opponents are just too tired to fight
- 7:09back. So you get a red afterimage. It's a literal
- 7:12tug of war. So the scientific community argued
- 7:15for decades over who was right. Young and Helmholtz
- 7:19with their three colors or Herring with his opposing
- 7:22pairs. And the answer turned out to be both of
- 7:24them. Yeah, they had to reconcile it. I like
- 7:27to think of this using a computer analogy for
- 7:29study purposes. The trichromatic theory is the
- 7:32hardware. Your retina literally contains three
- 7:35physical types of cones. They're the RGB pixels.
- 7:39Right. But the opponent process theory is the
- 7:41software sorting that data into rival teams.
- 7:44It's a really helpful analogy, though I'd push
- 7:46back just a little bit on the word software because
- 7:48it's still very much wetware. Oh, sure. It's
- 7:50physical biology. Yeah. What happens is the raw
- 7:54signals from those three RGB cones are fed into
- 7:57specialized neurons called retinal ganglion cells.
- 8:00And those cells act as the opposing team. Exactly.
- 8:03They subtract the signals from one another, computing
- 8:05the differences along those red -green and blue
- 8:08-yellow axes. So the computation is built right
- 8:10into the wiring. And when that initial hardware
- 8:13is missing a component, that's when you get color
- 8:15deficiency. Right, which breaks down into three
- 8:17types based on which cone is missing. So how
- 8:20do we memorize these for the test? Well, there's
- 8:23protanopia, which is the absence of the long
- 8:25wavelength cone. That one detects red. Then deuteranopia
- 8:29is the absence of the medium wavelength cone,
- 8:32which detects green. Both of those make it super
- 8:34hard to distinguish red from green, right? Yeah.
- 8:37And interestingly, they mostly affect men because
- 8:40the genes coding for these specific photopigments
- 8:43are located on the X chromosome. Okay, and then
- 8:46there's tritanopia. Right. That's the lack of
- 8:49the short wavelength cone or the blue one. It
- 8:51makes distinguishing blues and yellows really
- 8:53difficult, but it's exceptionally rare. By the
- 8:56way, if you ever need to remember these for the
- 8:58midterm, just look at the Greek prefixes. Oh,
- 9:00that's a good study trick. Yeah. Pro means first,
- 9:04and red is the first color in the visible spectrum,
- 9:07the longest wavelength. Deutero means second.
- 9:09Green is the second primary wavelength. And trito
- 9:12means third. Blue is the third shortest wavelength.
- 9:15So pro, deutero, trito. One, two, three. Red,
- 9:19green, blue. Exactly. That homology makes it
- 9:21so much easier to conceptualize. So we have this
- 9:24incredibly sophisticated hardware and wiring.
- 9:27But moving into section three, the text shows
- 9:30how it's incredibly easy to fool. Oh, completely.
- 9:32Context is king. Our visual system does not measure
- 9:36absolute truth. We don't see absolute color or
- 9:38lightness. We only see relative color. And this
- 9:42is where the hallucination aspect really kicks
- 9:43in. The textbook example is simultaneous contrast.
- 9:47Right. If you take a medium gray square and place
- 9:50it on a pitch black background, it suddenly looks
- 9:52brilliant and light. But if you move that exact
- 9:55same gray square onto a bright white background,
- 9:58It looks dark and murky. Your brain literally
- 10:00alters the lightness of the object based entirely
- 10:02on its neighbors. Which is wild. What is the
- 10:05mechanical reason for that? It's a phenomenon
- 10:06called lateral inhibition. In your retina, when
- 10:10a neuron fires in response to light, it doesn't
- 10:12just send a signal to the brain. It also sends
- 10:14a signal sideways to explicitly silence its immediate
- 10:18neighbors. Wait, why would it silence its neighbors?
- 10:21To create contrast. The visual system doesn't
- 10:23care about a flat wall of gray. It cares about
- 10:26edges, boundaries, and shapes. So by inhibiting
- 10:30its neighbors, a stimulated neuron artificially
- 10:32sharpens the edge of whatever you're looking
- 10:34at. So a gray patch next to white is getting
- 10:37heavily inhibited by all that bright white light,
- 10:39making it look artificially dark. But then you
- 10:42have illusions that totally break that biological
- 10:44rule, like white solution. White solution is
- 10:47a masterpiece of visual hacking. I stared at
- 10:50that picture in the book for like 10 minutes.
- 10:53Same. So imagine gray rectangles layered over
- 10:56a background of alternating black and white stripes.
- 10:59Some gray rectangles have their long edges touching
- 11:02the white stripes, and others are touching the
- 11:04black stripes. Right. And according to the rules
- 11:06of lateral intonation we just discussed, the
- 11:08gray rectangles touching white should look darker.
- 11:10But they don't. They look lighter. Which completely
- 11:13defies the bottom -up wiring of the retina. So
- 11:15why does it do that? Because of top -down processing,
- 11:18your brain steps in and overrides the retina.
- 11:21It just vetoes the eyes? Pretty much. It looks
- 11:24at the scene and assumes, oh, this gray patch
- 11:26belongs to the white stripe. It groups the surfaces
- 11:29together based on depth and continuity. So the
- 11:32local contrast at the edges is bottom -up data,
- 11:35but the sense of what belongs together is a top
- 11:37-down assumption. Exactly. Your perception of
- 11:40lightness is heavily dictated by what your brain
- 11:43believes about the geometry of the scene. Okay,
- 11:45here's a philosophical thought for you, bringing
- 11:47it back to morality. If our visual system literally
- 11:52invents lightness and darkness based entirely
- 11:55on what is sitting next to it, isn't that essentially
- 11:58like moral relativism played out in our neurons?
- 12:01Oh, that's a compelling parallel. Because we
- 12:03struggle to make absolute judgments. And action
- 12:06might seem right or wrong depending entirely
- 12:08on the context it happens in or what group we
- 12:11feel it belongs to. Yeah, neurologically speaking,
- 12:14we are terrible at absolute judgments. We are
- 12:16difference engines. Our neurons provide very
- 12:18weak baseline responses to massive uniform fields
- 12:22of color. They only really scream when they detect
- 12:24a boundary or a contrast. The brain is just always
- 12:26contextualizing. Always. And we see that with
- 12:29color constancy too. Right. Like if I take an
- 12:31apple from a harsh blue fluorescent kitchen out
- 12:34into a warm orange sunset, The actual physical
- 12:37wavelengths hitting my eye changed drastically.
- 12:40But you still see the apple is red. Right. My
- 12:42brain uses prior knowledge and chromatic adaptation
- 12:45to essentially edit the live feed in real time
- 12:48just to keep the world looking stable. Stability
- 12:51is the ultimate goal, but You know, color and
- 12:54lightness are just the surface. The real magic
- 12:57trick of the visual system is space itself. Adding
- 13:00the third dimension, this is the craziest part
- 13:01of the whole text for me. It's a huge shift in
- 13:03how you think about vision. Yeah, because the
- 13:053D world out there is projected onto a totally
- 13:08flat two -dimensional sheet of cells at the back
- 13:11of your eye. You do not have 3D receptors. There
- 13:14you go. Your brain has to guess depth. from a
- 13:17completely flat image. It's a massive inverse
- 13:20problem. And to solve it, the brain uses this
- 13:23whole arsenal of depth cues. It starts with oculomotor
- 13:26cues, which are entirely physical. It's proprioceptive
- 13:28feedback, right? Yeah, your brain is actually
- 13:30feeling its own muscles move. When an object
- 13:33gets close to your face, the ciliary muscles
- 13:36inside your eye squeeze the lens to change its
- 13:38focal length. That's called accommodation. And
- 13:41at the same time, the muscles outside your eye
- 13:44rotate the eyeballs inward. to track the object,
- 13:47which is virgins. So the brain is literally measuring
- 13:50the mechanical strain on the eye muscles, like
- 13:53a built -in range finder, to calculate distance.
- 13:55Precisely. But that only works for objects within
- 13:58a few feet of your face. For everything else,
- 14:00we rely heavily on monocular depth cues. Which
- 14:04are cues you can process with just one eye open.
- 14:06Right. For the midterm... I think the easiest
- 14:09way to conceptualize monocular cues is the painter's
- 14:12toolkit. Ah, I like that. Because imagine you
- 14:14are a painter staring at a flat canvas. You only
- 14:17have a 2D surface. So how do you trick the viewer
- 14:20into seeing a three -dimensional mountain range?
- 14:22Well, you use relative height. Things painted
- 14:24closer to the horizon line look further away.
- 14:26Exactly. And you use relative size. Painting
- 14:29a person smaller means they're further back.
- 14:33What else? You use occlusion. If you paint a
- 14:37tree that physically blocks part of a house,
- 14:39the brain instantly calculates that the tree
- 14:41must be in front of the house. You use shadows
- 14:44to give objects volume. Yeah. And texture gradient.
- 14:48Like, the cobblestones at the bottom of the canvas
- 14:50are painted with high detail, but they blend
- 14:52into a smooth blur as they recede into the distance.
- 14:56And my favorite one from the text, atmospheric
- 14:58perspective. Oh yeah, the hazy mountains. Right.
- 15:01If you look at a mountain range miles away, it
- 15:03looks hazy and slightly blue. That's because
- 15:06you are looking through miles of air, and the
- 15:09particles in the atmosphere scatter short wavelength
- 15:12blue light. So the painter mimics that blue haze,
- 15:15and our brain translates it as massive distance.
- 15:17It's a remarkable calculation, but of course
- 15:19we don't just have one eye, we have two spaced
- 15:22about two and a half inches apart. And that gives
- 15:24us the ultimate tool for depth. Stereo cues or
- 15:27binocular disparity. Because the eyes are physically
- 15:30separated, they each get a slightly different
- 15:32camera angle on the world. Exactly. and deep
- 15:35in your primary visual cortex, the V1 region,
- 15:38you have highly specialized disparity neurons.
- 15:41Which are basically tuned to measure the exact
- 15:43mismatch between the image from your left eye
- 15:45and the image from your right eye. Right. And
- 15:47this all hinges on a geometric concept called
- 15:49the horopter. Can you break down what the horopter
- 15:53actually is? I struggled with that one. Yeah,
- 15:55it's tricky. Okay, imagine holding a pencil out
- 15:57in front of you and staring directly at the tip.
- 15:59Okay, got it. Now imagine an invisible geometric
- 16:02arc passing through the tip of that pencil and
- 16:05curving back to pass through both of your eyes.
- 16:08That invisible circle is the horopter. Okay.
- 16:11Any other object in the room that happens to
- 16:13sit exactly on that invisible line will fall
- 16:16on the exact corresponding spots on both of your
- 16:19retinas. Oh, so it's the anchor point. Yes. Objects
- 16:24closer to than the heropter create what's called
- 16:26cross disparity, and objects further away create
- 16:29uncrossed disparity. When you're V1 neurons,
- 16:31do the complex trigonometry of measuring those
- 16:34disparities to instantly build a 3D map. OK,
- 16:37so the brain takes two mismatched 2D images,
- 16:41does the math, and fuses them into one 3D reality.
- 16:45But moving into section five, what happens when
- 16:48the two images are so different? that the math
- 16:51just breaks down. Then you get a phenomenon called
- 16:53binocular rivalry Which is such a cool name.
- 16:56It is. So if you've ever put on a pair of those
- 16:59old cardboard 3D glasses, the ones with one red
- 17:02lens and one blue lens. Yeah, the classic stereo
- 17:04displays. Right. And you look at an image where
- 17:06the left eye only sees a red dog and the right
- 17:09eye only sees a blue ice cream cone. Your brain
- 17:11doesn't fuse them into a purple blob. No, it
- 17:14freaks out. It oscillates. You see the dog and
- 17:16then the image wipes away. You see the ice cream
- 17:18cone and then back to the dog. Right. The geometry
- 17:21is impossible to fuse, so the visual cortex is
- 17:24forced to make a choice. It suppresses one image
- 17:27entirely to let the other dominate. But the neurons
- 17:29processing the dominant image quickly fatigue,
- 17:32so the suppressed image breaks through. Exactly.
- 17:34You get this endless perceptual tug -of -war.
- 17:37And while that's a fun parlor trick with 3D glasses,
- 17:40it can actually be a serious clinical condition,
- 17:42right? Like with strabismus. Yes. Strabismus,
- 17:45which is commonly known as crossed eyes, happens
- 17:48when the eye muscles don't align properly. So
- 17:51the left eye might be focused on a book, while
- 17:53the right eye is turned slightly outward toward
- 17:55the window. So the brain is constantly receiving
- 17:57two completely different, unfusable images of
- 18:00the world. And if that isn't treated early in
- 18:02childhood, it leads to amblyopia or lazy eye.
- 18:06And this is where the brain acts in a way that
- 18:07feels almost ruthlessly utilitarian to me. How
- 18:11so? Well, it gets so overwhelmed by the conflicting
- 18:13data that it simply shuts off the feed from the
- 18:16misaligned eye. It sacrifices the vision of the
- 18:19weaker eye entirely just so the whole organism
- 18:21can navigate the world without confusion. It
- 18:23unplugs it for the greater good. Yeah, a biological
- 18:26utilitarianism. Sacrificing the minority one
- 18:29eye so the majority can survive. I mean, I wouldn't
- 18:32call it utilitarianism because the brain isn't
- 18:35making a calculated moral sacrifice. It's actually
- 18:38a direct consequence of neural plasticity and
- 18:41energy conservation. Oh, like hippie and learning.
- 18:43Exactly. Neurons that fire together wire together.
- 18:47The mismatched eye isn't providing coherent data
- 18:50that matches the motor feedback. So the visual
- 18:52cortex literally prunes those synapses. It just
- 18:56stops dedicating metabolic energy to a noisy
- 18:59channel. The result, though, is permanent stereo
- 19:02blindness if it isn't caught. Like, 5 % of people
- 19:05are stereo blind. But it can be treated if caught
- 19:07early, right? Very effectively. The standard
- 19:10treatment is placing an eye patch over the strong,
- 19:13dominant eye. Which forces the brain to use the
- 19:16weak one. Right. By entirely removing the signal
- 19:18from the strong eye, you force the visual cortex
- 19:21to desperately reach out and start accepting
- 19:23signals from the suppressed eye again. It physically
- 19:26rebuilds those neural pathways before the critical
- 19:29period of development closes. Which is vital,
- 19:31because without stereo vision, you lose true
- 19:33depth perception. Which brings us to the final
- 19:36piece of the puzzle, section 6, the intertwined
- 19:39web of size and distance. Because if your brain
- 19:41is constantly guessing at depth, that means it
- 19:44also has to constantly guess at size. They're
- 19:46totally inseparable. Yeah. Largely because retinal
- 19:49size, the actual physical space an object takes
- 19:52up on the back of your eye, is super ambiguous.
- 19:54Yeah, a tiny matchbox held one inch from your
- 19:57cornea and a giant semi -truck a mile away might
- 20:01cast the exact same size shadow on your retina.
- 20:04This relationship is defined by Emert's law.
- 20:07It states that your perceived size of an object
- 20:09is determined by its retinal size multiplied
- 20:12by its viewing distance. And there is a brilliant
- 20:14way to test this on yourself using a flash -balled
- 20:18after image. The textbook experiment for this
- 20:20is so cool. If someone takes a photo of you with
- 20:22a bright flash, it temporarily bleaches a circle
- 20:25of photoreceptors on your retina. You get a glowing
- 20:28ghost spot in your vision. And that spot is physically
- 20:30burned into a fixed number of cells. Its retinal
- 20:33size is absolute and unchanging. But if you look
- 20:35down at a piece of paper right in front of your
- 20:37face, that ghost spot looks incredibly small,
- 20:40maybe the size of a dime. Right. Then if you
- 20:42look out the window, So at a wall 100 feet away,
- 20:45the exact same ghost spot suddenly looks massive,
- 20:47like it's 10 feet across. Because your brain
- 20:49is crunching the numbers of Emmert's Law in real
- 20:52time, it knows the retinal image size hasn't
- 20:54changed. But your depth cues are suddenly screaming
- 20:58that the surface you are looking at is very far
- 21:00away. So the brain concludes the object must
- 21:03be huge and it literally alters your perception
- 21:06to match that math. And this mathematical reliance
- 21:09on distance is exactly what causes some of the
- 21:12most famous visual illusions in psychology. Like
- 21:15the Aims Room. Oh, the Ames room is a beautifully
- 21:18sinister piece of architecture. It really is.
- 21:21It's a physical room built with extreme force
- 21:24perspective. The floor slopes sharply up, the
- 21:27ceiling slopes down, and the back wall is positioned
- 21:30at a sharp diagonal angle. But it is meticulously
- 21:33painted and designed so that if you look through
- 21:35a specific people, all the depth cues align to
- 21:38make it look like a perfectly normal rectangular
- 21:40room. Right. And if you place two people of the
- 21:42exact same height into the opposite back corners,
- 21:44one person is physically much further away from
- 21:47the people than the other. But because the room
- 21:49is tricking your depth cues into thinking they
- 21:51are at the exact same distance, your brain applies
- 21:54Emmert's law incorrectly. The person further
- 21:57away has a smaller retinal image. Since your
- 22:00brain thinks the distance is equal, it assumes
- 22:03that person must literally be the size of a toddler.
- 22:06Meanwhile, the person closer to you takes up
- 22:09more retinal space. The brain assumes equal distance,
- 22:12so it perceives them as a massive giant. What
- 22:15I love about the Aims Room is what it proves
- 22:18about how heavily we rely on past experience.
- 22:21We have spent our entire lives inhabiting perfectly
- 22:24rectangular right -angled rooms. Right. That
- 22:27prior experience is so deeply ingrained in our
- 22:30neural wiring that when confronted with the Aims
- 22:32Room, our brain would literally rather believe
- 22:34that a full -grown adult has magically shrunk
- 22:36to the size of an apple than believe a room might
- 22:39have crooked walls. It perfectly illustrates
- 22:41the dominance of top -down processing. the brain
- 22:44overwhelmingly defaults to its prior knowledge
- 22:46and expectations, often just completely ignoring
- 22:49raw sensory data to do so. We see the same thing
- 22:52in the ponzo illusion, too. Right, where two
- 22:54identical horizontal lines are drawn over a picture
- 22:57of train tracks receding into the horizon. The
- 23:00line near the top of the tracks looks significantly
- 23:02larger because the converging lines trick your
- 23:05brain into thinking it's further away. So, synthesizing
- 23:08everything we've looked at today for the exam.
- 23:09Whether we are talking about lateral inhibition
- 23:12altering the lightness of a square, or the oculomotor
- 23:15muscles measuring distance, or Emert's law turning
- 23:18an after image into a giant. The visual system
- 23:21is fundamentally not a video camera. No. It is
- 23:24much closer to a detective trapped inside a dark
- 23:26room. Your brain sits in the pitch black vault
- 23:29of your skull. It only receives ambiguous, encoded
- 23:34electrical pulses from the outside world. Just
- 23:36a stream of data. Yeah. And from those weak signals,
- 23:40it has to make rapid, educated guesses about
- 23:42the geometry, color, and size of the universe,
- 23:46leaning heavily on context and a lifetime of
- 23:48past experiences to feel in the blanks. It is
- 23:50a highly sophisticated, real -time simulation.
- 23:53Which brings me back to our opening thought.
- 23:55And something I want to leave you to mull over
- 23:57before your midterm. We've established that your
- 23:59brain is constantly guessing, filling in the
- 24:02blanks, and literally altering the sizes and
- 24:05colors of physical objects based on context and
- 24:08past experience. It's constructing a top -down
- 24:10illusion of physical reality. A very persuasive
- 24:13illusion. But if our brains are wired to aggressively
- 24:16fabricate and edit our physical reality to make
- 24:18it fit our expectations, How much of our broader
- 24:21worldview is also just a top -down illusion?
- 24:24Oh, wow. Think about our personal, spiritual,
- 24:26or moral beliefs. How many of them are just the
- 24:29Aims Room of the mind? You know, heavily distorted
- 24:32by the context of our upbringing, our prior experiences,
- 24:35and our biases, but masquerading as objective,
- 24:38unshakable truth. That is heavy. If we can't
- 24:41even trust our own visual cortex to tell us the
- 24:44true color of a gray square, is anything we perceive
- 24:47truly objective? It's an epistemological nightmare
- 24:50if you think about it too long. We are entirely
- 24:53reliant on a sensory apparatus that prioritizes
- 24:55subjective consistency over objective truth.
- 24:58Something to keep in mind the next time you think
- 25:00you see something perfectly clearly. Thank you
- 25:03for joining our study session on the psychology
- 25:05undergrad. Good luck on the midterm and we will
- 25:07catch you next time.