Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Neo Nazis - (Chapter 5 - Definitions & Fascism)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserve listeners. This is chapter five and our deep dive on Neo
- 0:04Nazis. This is the Psychology in Seattle podcast. I am your host,
- 0:10doctor Kirk Honda. I am a therapist and a professor, and my name
- 0:14is Umberto Castna, and I hunt for rocks and tall tall grass. So
- 0:19I thought we would start off today's chapter with let's ground ourself in the definition
- 0:25of Nazism as the experts see us, but kind of in our own words,
- 0:30because I think, even for myself before doing this deep dive, I
- 0:35might have had a hard time exactly defining it. When people use that in
- 0:40rhetoric in the news or on Twitter or something. I feel like it means
- 0:44a lot of different things, but I feel like it's important to specifically define
- 0:48it. And neo Nazis are adherent to these ideas. You know, we
- 0:54might think of them as just general racists or xenophobic, but true neo Nazis
- 1:00and a lot of the neighboring groups will absolutely hold to these ideas, which
- 1:07is bizarre really when you think about it. So, in reading a lot
- 1:10of the literature on Nazism and neo Nazism, I came up with the following
- 1:14three categories of elements and characteristics of Nazism and Neo Nazism, and those those
- 1:21three elements are white supremacy, racial cleansing, and authoritarianism. So let's talk
- 1:26about white supremacy first. So Berto, what do the Nazis and Neo Nazis
- 1:33hold, believe adhere to regarding white supremacy. Well, as we mentioned in
- 1:38previous episodes, the actual Nazis in Nazi Germany, their belief was somewhat supernatural,
- 1:46that they were a descendant descendants of a superior race of pure quote Aryan
- 1:55ancestry, even though that was a misnomer, and that therefore or they were,
- 2:00you know, ideally to be kept within that race and not polluting the
- 2:05blood and blah blah blah. So that was the belief. More generally though,
- 2:08because I think most of the modern neo Nazi movements or racist white supremacist
- 2:15movements in this country, they don't necessarily hold well, some might, but
- 2:21they don't necessarily hold the same mystical supernatural beliefs including Atlantas, etc. Etc.
- 2:25But they definitely believe that the white Aryan Caucasian brand of skin color and
- 2:32other traits is just better it's smarter, it's more accomplished, it's more capable,
- 2:39and it's just nicer and funner whatever, and therefore everyone else needs to
- 2:45not be there, right, Okay, So then the second idea here is
- 2:51racial cleansing, and this has a lot of different elements to it. I
- 2:54wrote down some of what the experts we'll talk about in terms of white purity,
- 3:00meaning that there's no non white blood in one's veins, so to speak.
- 3:07So they would hate you and I. They would hate you and me.
- 3:09And also the idea of eugenics. Can you explain eugenics? Oh?
- 3:14And sorry? And by the way, I would have already been in trouble
- 3:16because my ancestors, being from Spain, the Spanish whites, would have already
- 3:23been like, oh, well, they're not quite as arian as we want
- 3:27them to be. And now they've gone and mixed with these like neo Asian
- 3:31races. That ah, right, Like that would be bad anyway, Sorry,
- 3:36what was here? Your question? Explain eugenics? And I guess how
- 3:42the Nazis saw it. Ironically, there were there were these like hardliner and
- 3:47then non heart what's the opposite of hardliner soft liner? There were more moderates
- 3:53in the Nazi movement that's thought that, well, the way to achieve our
- 3:58racial purity, in our ethnic cleansing and kind of our white white power is
- 4:04through breeding. So as long as we don't allow the bad races and the
- 4:11lesser individuals that have afflictions or mental dis or whatever, if we don't allow
- 4:15them to breed, we have to like stop that, like by any means
- 4:18necessary. Uh, then we'll be fine. It might take a generation or
- 4:23two, but we'll be good. And those are the moderates that was the
- 4:27compromised, like, hey, we're not here to you know, we just
- 4:30want to castrate all of you, you know, just we right, we
- 4:33just want to like you, not you sterilize, right, we just want
- 4:39masterilistic. But we're not killing you guys, right, So we just don't
- 4:42want you to breed because you know, yeah, yeah, right. So
- 4:46the history of eugenics is complicated, of course, and predates the Nazis by
- 4:54decades, and I have a limited understanding of that history. But the way
- 4:59that I interpret and there's no way to know why it became a movement that
- 5:03was so popular. It was very popular around the world, particularly in the
- 5:08white world in South Africa and Europe, United States. And I interpret it
- 5:15as you know, there was a time when the majority of humans worked on
- 5:19farms and would have a lot of contact, daily contact, and dependence on
- 5:27genetics regarding their livestock and their crops. Right, there would be a strain
- 5:32of wheat that would be more susceptible to rot, or there would be a
- 5:38breed of cow that had twice as much milk production. Right. Centuries and
- 5:43centuries of successful experiments basically, right with animals and vegetation, right, Yeah,
- 5:50prior to understanding anything about DNA or biology in that way, there were
- 5:57a lot of successful inadvertent like with dogs, for example, and more advertent
- 6:03like with wheat and corn and that sort of thing. And it was kind
- 6:06of intuitive to them, to them meaning all those previous generations that well,
- 6:12I don't know, I seem to have grabbed this animal that looks this way,
- 6:15acts this way, and I this one in there. They both similarly
- 6:16trade and their kids happened to have a similar all right, That's how it
- 6:20works. Right without knowing the DNA piece, You didn't need to know that
- 6:23part, right, And so you could argue that our entire civilization is based
- 6:29on this technology. US becoming a non hunter gatherer society that could build cities
- 6:35and societies and fund science and research and armies and governments. Is all dependent
- 6:42on agriculture, which depends on this idea and this knowledge. And like I
- 6:46said, the vast majority of humans were involved some way in this technology.
- 6:53Daily everyone basically understands this idea and lives within it all the time. And
- 6:58then you have the emergence of industrialization and of the ability to travel more freely
- 7:05between areas and regions and nations across oceans, and you start seeing this mixture
- 7:12of different shall we say, you know, people from different regions, because
- 7:16the word race is problematic because we're all the same species. So you have
- 7:21this mixture, and you also have wars, and you have poverty because of
- 7:27industrialization, and you have all these social ills. You have you know,
- 7:31the bubonic plague, and you have the Black death, and you have the
- 7:35flu. You know, just a lot of concern about outsiders and jobs and
- 7:42economy and war. And in addition, so we were saying something in one
- 7:47of the previous episodes about how we were kind of debating whether in the future
- 7:53folks would all look the same or whether there would still be differences based on
- 7:56geographic location. And you made some good points that maybe the geographic location wouldn't
- 7:59matter much because of science, but in the past, not only did the
- 8:03different geographic location matter for developing more pigment or less pigment and other attributes,
- 8:09but there was also because sections were isolated from each other. There was different
- 8:13language, there were different cultures, there were different you know, norms and
- 8:18things. So there were so many reasons and this is still true today.
- 8:22It's just like it's a little less. But so you're sitting there in your
- 8:26little country area and you all kind of look, I mean, not the
- 8:30same, but you look similar, you know, and you all follow the
- 8:33same traditions and culture, and you speak the same language, say the same
- 8:37god, same God, exactly Like all of a sudden, these people come
- 8:41and they don't quite look the same, They definitely don't speak the same,
- 8:46they don't even believe in the same god. They everything's different. So it's
- 8:50not only challenging, and so yeah, like there's the surface level because a
- 8:54lot of times people you know, will say, well, it's just a
- 8:56skin color, and it is. But to the these ideologies, it's way
- 9:01more than justice, skin color, it's the whole package. It's the whole
- 9:05Enchilada. They don't like they want their little corner of the world intact and
- 9:09pristine without those polluted elements. Yeah, so there's nefarious, evil elements to
- 9:16this, and there's just normal reactivity of hey, I don't understand you,
- 9:24or no one understands me. If you wander into another area where no one
- 9:30speaks your language, it's very inconvenient, you know. So there's some normal
- 9:35aspects to it and some evil aspects to it. And then you have the
- 9:41coincidence or the circumstance or the random nature of the geopolitical industrial complex of the
- 9:50eighteenth century or the nineteenth century, and you have, by chance, a
- 9:54lot of white people and nations and governments and groups have a lot more power
- 10:01than other people. There's this emergence of colonialism and everything. You know,
- 10:07hence, you know, because you emerge from colonialists Spanish colonials in South America
- 10:15and me, I'm half white and all my white ancestors came to North America,
- 10:20and so you have this concern with what's going on with poverty and with
- 10:28crime, and with difference and ideas of intelligence and culture, you know,
- 10:35the white people. Of course, we all know this, that they would
- 10:37look at the Native Americans and the you know in South America and in North
- 10:43America as being savages, unintelligent, different sorts of creatures, a different species,
- 10:50right, they're not really human, they're subhuman. Or black people they're
- 10:52subhuman, they're not actually human. And then you have slavery, of course,
- 10:56which correct me if I'm wrong, didn't involve some genetic manipulation. They
- 11:03would, oh yeah, right, Like, as you know, the slave
- 11:07trade and the buying of slaves was like buying cattle, and buying cattle absolutely
- 11:13involves eugenics and absolutely involves picking the best specimen with the best attributes and then
- 11:20having breeders and having like of course, yeah, I mean, do you
- 11:24know if that was specifically discussed, like okay, that would be a good
- 11:28person to breed with this other person because of this attribute. Yes, percent,
- 11:33okay, Yeah, so you already have eugenics occurring, meaning the purposeful
- 11:39minute. I don't know the exact definition of eugenics, but I so I
- 11:41should probably look it up. But to me, if I was to take
- 11:45a guess at it, I would say it's a purposeful manipulation of human attributes
- 11:48in DNA, and you know, the study of how to arrange reproduction within
- 11:52a human population to increase the occurrence of heritable characteristics regarded as desirable. Yeah,
- 11:58and it's interesting that. I mean in there the definition is like specific
- 12:01to humans, but that must be just or is there a more broader term
- 12:07that applies to all organisms, like I think it's just breeding. Yeah,
- 12:11okay, but in either case, even today, we actually do eugenics by
- 12:16policy, even in this country. In many countries, for example, you're
- 12:20not allowed to marry a direct relative. And the reason you're not allowed to
- 12:24marry and breed with a direct relative is because we want to prevent genetic defects
- 12:30in that case. Right, Well, yeah, I haven't thought about that
- 12:33absolutely. I imagine that there were people, say, you have some richer
- 12:39landowner in the United States who is maybe a leader, maybe a politician,
- 12:45and is struggling with trying to solve certain problems of racial tensions and of crime
- 12:52and of poverty because you don't know anything and the research isn't available, or
- 12:58you just make up your own ideas based on bias. You start thinking of,
- 13:03well, if we can only just get rid. How do we get
- 13:07rid of poverty, Well, we can do these kinds of things. How
- 13:09do we get rid of crime? We could do, but you know,
- 13:11the white people, this is all false, but it's the perception. You
- 13:15know, white people, they don't commit the crimes, and they don't become
- 13:16poor people, they don't become degenerates, or maybe even not even white people,
- 13:20just certain types of people, refined people, intelligent people, smart people,
- 13:24regardless of race or whatever. Then you could imagine someone thinking, well,
- 13:30when it comes to like horses, we will tend to breed horses that
- 13:37are easier to train, and when you get a horse that's really wild and
- 13:41hard to train, we tend not to want to breed with that horse.
- 13:46Well, what if we just did that to humans? And it might it
- 13:50might not grow into an idea of genocide or of wiping out an entire gene
- 13:54pool. It's just a kernel of a thought of like, what if we
- 13:58could create the perfec society. And there's a lot of talk around this,
- 14:03the perfect society. How do we build it one that is this, you
- 14:07know, golden city on the hill that has it all, no crime,
- 14:11no poverty, everyone's smart, you know, total literacy and so and so.
- 14:15You could imagine someone having that thought without any evil in them. Now,
- 14:20they wouldn't have the ability to enact any kind of policy, but you
- 14:24know, you could imagine someone having that thought. Now, of course you
- 14:28take that thought and run with it, or you have a fascist government that
- 14:31wants to galvanize their population and will fear longer. Then you have World War
- 14:37two and you have the Nazis and you have the Holocaust. I mean,
- 14:41so you're kind of drawing ven diagrams and there are definitely those people right the
- 14:46catches that like the Hitlers and these folk they do. In fact, they
- 14:52would probably be like, yeah, that's all I'm trying to do. And
- 14:54you, oh wait, maybe we have a misunderstanding because you like rounded up
- 14:58all the people kicked out mass murder. Oh yeah, no, no,
- 15:01no, well duh, Like what you're describing is definitely what I want to
- 15:05do. But we're certainly not starting with any of those races like that.
- 15:07We got we just get rid of those for yeat eugenics. Those we just
- 15:11wiped out or either at least kicked out, if not just fully out wiped
- 15:16out. Now we're talking about like within our little German population. We're gonna
- 15:20do eugenics because guess what, the blonde hair is better. And I see
- 15:24a lot of Germans with dark hair. Don't look at mine, and blonde
- 15:30like blonde eyes or blue eyes are better. And we know what's superior and
- 15:33symmetrical, and that's what we want. We want carbon copy, genetically defective,
- 15:39essentially in bred populations of people. But that so it's funny, not
- 15:45funny, it's horrific, But it's funny that what you're describing is I swear
- 15:50if you had interviewed Hitler or any of those people, they would have said,
- 15:54yeah, no, that that's all we're trying to do. We just
- 15:58want a better population. It's just asterisk and we already got rid of all
- 16:02these people viciously, right, right, So you match up that perhaps just
- 16:07non malevolent idea of genetics and a misunderstanding of how behavior is related to genetics
- 16:15or to race, because you know, it's all based on this notion that
- 16:18or at least you know for many that black people are inherently stupid, Black
- 16:22people are inherently criminal, black people are inherently debauched and promiscuous or something,
- 16:30and so you know, you match up these two ideas racism and all the
- 16:36ideas that uphold that, and then you have this idea of genetics or of
- 16:40breeding, and you get eugenics throughout the country. And again it's not just
- 16:45Nazis. We think of this as being a German thing. It was not
- 16:48a German thing. It was a very you know, you're going to get
- 16:51into in the history of the United States. But anyway, so with Nazis
- 16:55in particular, they wanted racial cleansing in general, and they believed in white
- 17:00purity. They were utilizing the ideas of eugenics specifically to wipe out the people
- 17:07that they thought were subhuman or bad for the genie pool, specifically Jews,
- 17:15the Romani people or what the slur word is Gypsy. I believe right,
- 17:18you have disabled people, LGBTQ people, Polish people, Slavic people, and
- 17:23black people. It wasn't just Jews, it was you know, a lot
- 17:27of different groups. There were just a lot more. I think there were
- 17:30two factors. One, they were a lot more focused on the power that
- 17:34Jews could wield, whereas all those other groups you mentioned were definitely definite minorities
- 17:40and didn't have any power and not that the Jews had a whole bunch of
- 17:41power. But at the very least before World War Two, Jewish families were
- 17:47starting to thrive in their own way. They had and even though they were
- 17:51denied a lot of certain professions, they had banking, and they had arts,
- 17:55and they had and so this was a threat. Yeah, yeah,
- 18:00And the third is authoritarianism. But let's take a break. What do you
- 18:03say, Let's do it all right, back for the break. So I
- 18:08thought we would talk about the third element, major element of Nazism. In
- 18:14addition to white supremacy and racial clinching, we have authoritarianism. And we can
- 18:18use words like nationalism or fascism. And to be specific about what fascism is,
- 18:26because it's another word that I think is thrown around a lot in today's
- 18:30Twitter sphere, and I want to drill down on exactly what is fascism.
- 18:36So I'm pulling this from Umberto Eco, who is an Italian historian and philosopher
- 18:42who actually died recently. He wrote a famous essay on the fourteen points of
- 18:48fascism titled Eternal Fascism that was published in nineteen ninety five. So the fourteen
- 18:55points and this is just a brief overview of them. We have the cult
- 19:00of tradition. Ambardo talked about this, not Embarto, well, Embardo Echo,
- 19:03Embeddo Echo, and Amberto Casciina talked about the cult of tradition, specifically
- 19:07the idea of cultural syncretism, which is the cobbling together of various past traditions.
- 19:14You know, you talked a lot about that one of the past chapters,
- 19:18and so apparently for fascists it's almost always the case that they will cobble
- 19:22together various past traditions as a way of galvanizing the cult, as a way
- 19:29of telling a narrative that justifies the authority, that justifies the in group out
- 19:34group differences. And also that Embardo Echo talks about how often this cultural syncretism
- 19:42is wildly contradictory internally, you know, And we talked about that with this
- 19:48whole idea of Atlantis and the Aryans. What were some of the specific contradictions
- 19:56with Nazis. Yeah, So, for example, the fact was that the
- 20:00Atlantis myth that they co opted was let alone, that it was likely never
- 20:04even a thing like it was probably just an allegory from Plato. But but
- 20:07but even the folks that believed that it was a thing. The common belief
- 20:11was that it was in the it was in the warmer areas of the world,
- 20:15and they was populated by dark skinned people, and yet they had somehow
- 20:19like made it. No, but we're from Atlantis and they because we look
- 20:22like this, they must have looked like us, but even better. Right.
- 20:25Also the whole Aryan race thing where they're like, well, yeah,
- 20:30I know they call themselves Arians, but actually we read this one little passage
- 20:33that says that there were invaders from the north that were white. We are
- 20:36the true Ariants. Like also, why do you need the term, Like
- 20:40why not just come up with a new term Caucasian, same thing, Caucos
- 20:42mountains, or just make up a new way. It's just like what just
- 20:47come on? Because Arians specifically were from a region of the world in which
- 20:52they would not be light skinned or blonde haired, right, right, they're
- 20:56they're they're towards India and Tibet, right Yeah, and so yeah, stuff
- 21:00like that. But essentially, oh and then you know the Christian part,
- 21:03like, well, Christian's a Jewish religion, but christ was jew But we
- 21:07hate the Jews. But you know, it's like, but it's a little
- 21:11like you're saying like, well, we'll grab this piece and we'll rub this
- 21:12piece and rub this piece. I don't kind of makes sense, right,
- 21:17and all in the purpose of trying to tap into ideas that people already kind
- 21:23of know and tuget certain strings within people, because if you just make up
- 21:30a whole new religion with no familiarity, people are going to be like,
- 21:34huh, yeah. I always think about QAnon with this, because QAnon emerged
- 21:41out of nowhere in the mid tens and right mid tens, early tens.
- 21:45Yeah, And it is a bizarre cultural syncretism of America. You have the
- 21:55Illuminati, you have Christianity, and specifically like dark medieval Christianity, because if
- 22:03you just look at Christianity, fundamentally, there's no discussion of demons, or
- 22:07there's some discussion, but not in the way that eventually in medieval Europe they
- 22:11started to this is full on, like no demons are real, they're here,
- 22:15that's a demon, yeah, right, uh, And it's like a
- 22:18Marvel movie of some kind, you know, with like battles and swords,
- 22:22and in fact there are like like heroes and anti heroes, right, and
- 22:26then you know the Satanic panic and you have Satanic ritual and blood sacrifice and
- 22:33a little bit of biology thrown in there, you know, of like the
- 22:37you like, what is it, the thetans or whatever they have in there,
- 22:41well, the the the But in the Q movement there's something like that,
- 22:47the blood that they drink that makes the adreno chron a dream of cre
- 22:52yeah, and right, right, and that's right because they're trying to live
- 22:56forever. That's why Hillary Clinton looks younger and younger every day. That's why
- 23:00Biden it's great, right because Biden is supposed to be drinking the medichlorians and
- 23:04the thetans from the little babies to live forever and get younger and younger.
- 23:10But they also say how old and decrepit he is and how he can't even
- 23:14form a sentence, right, So it doesn't appear to work very much.
- 23:18So that gets so we'll get into that actually in the other thirteen elements.
- 23:23Okay, so you have the culture tradition, and then the second thing here
- 23:26is the rejection of modernism, meaning the rejection of the Enlightenment of science,
- 23:33and the way that they typically will talk about it is that ever since the
- 23:36Enlightenment or ever since modernism. Western society has descended into depravity. And I
- 23:41suppose for neo Nazis it would be something like ever since civil rights or something.
- 23:47It might not necessarily be the Enlightenment, but especially because kind of key
- 23:52differences in And I didn't deep dive, so I don't know enough about Mussolini,
- 23:56but I do know that he came first, and Hitler idolized what happened
- 24:00in Italy that they took over by force. He tried to do the same.
- 24:03It failed. But however, there were some key differences because the Nazis,
- 24:07especially Hitler, but all of them, really were obsessed with culture and
- 24:11science. Like they actually valued like high art and high music and all these
- 24:17things, and they believed science was very important to their plans and their future
- 24:23victories and things like this. But kind of like what you're saying is like
- 24:30they also needed to make sure that the cultural parts, like the traditions of
- 24:34the German, proper folklore, the songs, the flags, like the foods,
- 24:41all that stuff, that was what we needed to preserve because ever since
- 24:45all these people have arrived, things are getting ugly. Streets are getting ugly,
- 24:51everything's getting ugly. The third thing here is the cult of action for
- 24:55action's sake, and they described this as action is of value in and of
- 24:59it itself and should be taken without intellectual reflection. The fourth thing is disagreement
- 25:04is treason, and this is a cult mechanism as well. The other element
- 25:11here is fear of difference, which fascism seeks to exploit and exacerbate, meaning
- 25:15that people tend to have a fear of difference, either naturally or because of
- 25:19culture, and fascism will always capitalize on that fear. Also the appeal to
- 25:26a frustrated middle class, which you will hear politicians of all walks of life
- 25:32will tend to do right. You know. It's like the squeezing of the
- 25:36middle class or the oppression of the middle class, or there's no more middle
- 25:38class anymore. So. The other element here is the obsession with a plot,
- 25:45meaning that the enemy is plotting against us, and so we have to
- 25:49be vigilant. Another element is the enemy is both strong and weak. That's
- 25:56what I would say about Biden. It's like he's this devious, like head
- 26:00of the worst mafia family in history and eating babies to stay alive and young.
- 26:04He's also decrepit and he's lost all his marbles and he can't form a
- 26:07sentence exactly. Another element here is that pacivism is trafficking with the enemy because
- 26:14life is permanent warfare, meaning that there must always be an enemy to fight,
- 26:18because without an outgroup, then you don't really have an inn group and
- 26:22you can't control the masses. And really, you could argue for a majority
- 26:29of Americans after nine to eleven, Nine to eleven was utterly terrifying. Yeah,
- 26:33it seems quaint because it's so long ago, but at the time,
- 26:40we've talked about this before, just how utterly scary it was to think that
- 26:45airplanes could just be hijacked and used as missiles to kill people and destroy I
- 26:51mean, it just felt like at any moment they were going to get us.
- 26:53Right, it turned out not to be the case, but that was
- 26:56their purpose. That was their purpose they were They did that in an effort
- 27:00to scare us, and it fucking worked. And in that moment, the
- 27:07approval rating for George W. Bush skyrocketed, meaning that a lot of Democrats,
- 27:11people that hated him and voted against him in the election the previous year,
- 27:18or even you could I guess it was eight months prior or ten months
- 27:21prior was the election. The country was divided. It wasn't. You could
- 27:26argue it's more divided now, but it wasn't like we were all kumbaya in
- 27:30the past. And yet a lot of people after nine to eleven were standing
- 27:34behind and approving of George w Because when you have an outgroup, then you
- 27:41know, the enemy of my enemy is my friend. Right, So all
- 27:45of a sudden we're thinking, well, I hate George Bush, but I
- 27:48don't want to die from terrorism because of whatever sort of threat this al Qaeda
- 27:53is. You know, that was the first time I'd ever even heard of
- 27:56alcat No, I guess I'd heard of al Qaeda prior with the other also,
- 28:00us hadn't. Right. And so when you are trying to control and
- 28:04you need authoritarianism to work, then you need your people that give you power
- 28:11to love you, regardless of your views or their own lives, because they're
- 28:18terrified of a threat that you have defined and made. By the way,
- 28:22imagine if we could make the outgroup global warming, or greedy bankers or master
- 28:30criminal worldwide, actual criminals that are you know, or ticket master well,
- 28:34and along those lines, there are groups that will do that there are eco
- 28:40terrorists that you and I would agree with some of their points, but not
- 28:45of their tactics of using letter bombs to blow up professors. I mean the
- 28:51unibomber was actually along those lines, right, I mean it was a techno
- 28:56terrorist. Yeah, he felt that technology was going to do us all.
- 28:59Yeah, I'm guessing there's some points in his manifesto that you and I would
- 29:03say, like, well, actually that's true, but it doesn't mean that
- 29:07you can people just you know, send letter bombs to professors and other kinds
- 29:11of people. That's that's not okay. Now, Unibarmer was a cult of
- 29:15one, but there are small there are actual groups and cults that use the
- 29:21global warming as a right. But like, what if instead of going killing
- 29:23people, we're like, let's get rid of this, let's regulate, let's
- 29:26pass laws, let's make sure these companies are held liable, Let's make sure
- 29:30like we don't over consume. Let's make like don't stop chopping those streams.
- 29:36Those are the outcome. Yeah, Well, I think the argument is that
- 29:40with fascism, it's not easy to actually have the greater good accomplished that you're
- 29:47saying, wouldn't it be nice if we created a fascist Well, not so
- 29:49much fat, just I'm just the idea that because it is a fact,
- 29:56humans seem to work well as a team when they feel like they're in competition
- 30:00with other teams. But like in sports, you don't go around murdering the
- 30:04other teams. Well, I guess it would depend on you see what I'm
- 30:07saying. Like with the environment, it would depend on how we define how
- 30:11you know, how we define the outgroup. And you could argue that the
- 30:15way that our group defines the outgroup might not actually be helpful. The way
- 30:19that might be helpful is to define the outgroup all of us. That if
- 30:23we just said it's it's a human tendency to use resources and not take into
- 30:30account the consequences down the line, especially if they are slow to develop the
- 30:37concept. You know, the climate change, it's relatively slow. It's not
- 30:38like you drive your car and someone punches you in the face. You drive
- 30:44your car and it you know, it emits this in terms of the overall
- 30:48percentage of greenhouse gases. It emits this miniscule, almost non existent level of
- 30:55greenhouse gases. But every car trip, every plane trip, all of the
- 30:59people, and so the who do you make the outgroup, because we're all
- 31:03doing it. So you could say the outgroup should just be that way of
- 31:08thinking or including other policies, because that's kind of how I see it.
- 31:14It's not like there's this enemy that we need to attack. It's the way
- 31:18that systems and humans like when you really zoom out, like when aliens look
- 31:23at us and analyze why we are descending into environmental disaster. I don't think
- 31:30they would necessarily point to a particular political movement or a particular group of people.
- 31:37I think they would say, all, y'all, due to your lack
- 31:41of group intelligence or systems thinking have a tendency to veer in a particular direction.
- 31:48When you aggregate every behavior and every knowledge point and the current state of
- 31:53technology, you know it's not a particular group. Of course, there are
- 31:56groups that are not helpful, corporations, paid off politicians, but anyway,
- 32:00so the other point here is that they have a contempt for the week.
- 32:07So every member of society is superior to outsiders by virtue of belonging to the
- 32:10in group. So for the Nazis and for other fascist groups, you don't
- 32:15have to achieve anything. You're just automatically within our in group, you're a
- 32:20valid member because of the identification that you're white and you're a part of the
- 32:25Aryan race. You're not one of those dirty white Spanish people or those dirty
- 32:30white Slavs or those dirty white Polish people. So as long as you can
- 32:35demonstrate that you have the heritage of a German, then you are automatically part
- 32:39of the in group and everyone else is weak. Another element is that everybody
- 32:45is educated to become a hero, meaning that it will elevate martyrs. Embardo
- 32:51Echo talks about the cult of death, about how the how the hero,
- 32:58and how this strong will sacrifice themselves for the greater good. And of course
- 33:05the people in power never have to participate in that death. It's always just
- 33:08it's like suicide bombers, right. Another is that they have this idea of
- 33:15machismo and weaponry, which is self explanatory, but also anti women, anti
- 33:22gay, anti pacifism, anti intellectualism. Also the idea of selective populism,
- 33:29meaning that the people are conceived of as a monolith having a common will.
- 33:34Are people, the Aryan people. The Nazis right, we have one way
- 33:38of thinking, and no one else disagree none of us in this in group
- 33:43disagree with that. You'll hear politicians, and really on various sides of the
- 33:47political spectrum, you will hear that we believe this right. It's a way
- 33:52of trying to establish in group outgroup. It's a way of trying to alienate
- 33:57people that might have a different point of view or a new wants point of
- 34:00view. It's a way of defining the in group. And if you're in,
- 34:04if you consider yourself to be an in group, and you hear like
- 34:06this we thing, then you're thinking, uh, oh, I'm going to
- 34:08be ostracized if I don't adopt that point of view. So I better start
- 34:13adopting that point of view. And there's a lot of other elements within this
- 34:16selective populism. So fascists use this concept to delegitimize democratic institutions that the accused
- 34:25that, you know, they accuse those institutions of not representing the people.
- 34:30They define what the people want, and the people listen, and because of
- 34:34the enemy, they say, well, I guess we have to believe that
- 34:37anyway. And then the final fourteenth element is that, you know, fascism
- 34:42will create new speak, you know, nineteen eighty four new speak of using
- 34:49limited vocabulary as a way to try to limit critical thinking and to try to
- 34:54appeal to the everyday person, everyday citizen. Right. And when you read
- 35:00all of these elements maga anti woke, Yeah, I mean, it gets
- 35:08freaking scary, right, Because one of the things that I remember, and
- 35:15of course I'm not the first person to point this out, is with Trump,
- 35:19the way that he talked it was very limited in vocabulary. And you
- 35:24just wonder did he read this essay and just follow you know, I was
- 35:30just wonder does it just naturally occur to people that it works? Because fascism
- 35:35works, is the thing, you know that that's why people do it.
- 35:37Well, remember his ex wife said he did keep a book of Hitler quotations
- 35:43next to his bed and he read it and speeches, sorry Hitler speeches,
- 35:47don't. I don't know. So certainly, I don't know to what extinct.
- 35:52I don't actually believe that that Trump is into mysticism or into any sort
- 35:59of like actual doctrine. But he if he's been anything in his life that
- 36:06was successful is his ability to like con people into giving him money or you
- 36:09know, and or following him or whatever, or thinking that he's a good
- 36:14person or whatever, and I think that that is a It's got to be
- 36:17a combination of paying attention to things like that and his own innate ability to
- 36:22do so. So yeah, I think all that stuff now. I also
- 36:27don't think he's got an extensive vocabulary. He's not well read any of those
- 36:30things. But it just doesn't matter. So when we all make fun of
- 36:35like when he says like, well, you know, we're very strong with
- 36:37the nuclear or whatever, and we're like, well, it's not afraid,
- 36:42Like, don't say it like that, there is a base that goes,
- 36:45Okay, I can relate to that. I don't need them fancy words like
- 36:50I don't need the college educator. I want someone who can relate to me
- 36:52and my problems. And if we know anything is that Trump really cares about
- 36:58the little middle class person, is really trying to help us, right yeah,
- 37:02yeah, So quickly going over some terms, I wanted to define Nazism
- 37:08so that moving forward, we have a foundation to discuss neo Nazis of today.
- 37:15But also I wanted to just throw out some terms because we have been
- 37:19using a lot of different labels for Nazis. Neo Nazis, white, nationalists,
- 37:24fascists, white supremacists, and right wingers. So there's other words that
- 37:30we could use too, But all of these words are referring to different groups
- 37:36of people, but there's a lot of overlap. Right neo Nazis, they
- 37:40might not necessarily be nationalists, but they probably are. They're definitely white supremacists,
- 37:46right, But not every fascist or white supremacist is a neo Nazi.
- 37:51Not every right ringer is. It would be defined as a neo Nazi,
- 37:54particularly by themselves, but they typically are. So we're Do you know where
- 38:00right wing comes from exactly? The right wing? No? I don't.
- 38:05I didn't know either until I looked it up. It derives from the political
- 38:09assemblies of the French Revolution in the eighteenth century. End of the eighteenth century,
- 38:15and in the room you had these people on the left and people on
- 38:20the right of the room, and the people on the left supported the revolution
- 38:25and more radical political ideas and change, progressiveness, progressive, and the people
- 38:30on the right supported the monarchy and traditional institutions. And that's where the right
- 38:37and left came right. Not to mention that the right historically was the right
- 38:43was the good hand. Do you know that in Spanish and Latin. I
- 38:46guess the right is d estro or the estra, and the left is senest
- 38:54and the word sinister came from that, the left is sinister. Yeah,
- 39:00there was this idea that people who were left handed dominant were of the devil
- 39:07and they would actually try to break those children of their left handedness by forcing
- 39:14them to use their right hand and stuff. Frankly, some of the greatest
- 39:17minds in history happened to be left handed. Yeah, So briefly, just
- 39:22running through the different groups that we've been referring to as well, just kind
- 39:24of give you the lay of the land in terms of the groups of today
- 39:29that we are considering within the camp of Neo Nazis are related and there's really
- 39:32hundreds around the world. And that was one thing that I hadn't known was
- 39:37how many groups they're really fond of banding together and naming themselves. You know,
- 39:45there's just like tons of these. It's like a little click or a
- 39:49club or I had the clubs when I was a kid. When I was
- 39:52in fourth grade, me and my friends had a little in group with little
- 39:55secrets. I had secret notebooks. And then when I got into computers,
- 39:59we had little secret pies that we had little secret programs on. And yeah,
- 40:01in high school we had a group called the Ninja Assassination Unit, and
- 40:07it's it's just like that. And you could argue that in high school my
- 40:09group of guys were, you know, a pseudo gang, and people saw
- 40:15us that way. Actually I could go down a whole rabbit hole. But
- 40:20anyway, So there's thousands of these various groups around the world, and it's
- 40:23not just the United States. The neo Nazism thing. That was another alarming
- 40:27thing that I came upon was that I knew that there were neo Nazi movements
- 40:31in Europe kind of, but I hear much more about the American groups.
- 40:36But apparently this is a problem all over the white world, Europe, Australia,
- 40:42South Africa, South America. There's a growing upswell of these white nationalist,
- 40:50neo Nazi, fascist, militant, right wing movements. So the big
- 40:55ones though that I put a list together, she have the KKK still in
- 41:00existence. You have the Skinheads who were punk kids in the seventies. I
- 41:07believe that are also militant and right wing and often Nazis. You have the
- 41:15National Socialist Movement or NSM. That's a current group of people. You have
- 41:21the Proud Boys, who are right wing and extremists and violence and have all
- 41:29the belief systems that you would imagine that they would have in addition to being
- 41:32anti mask and anti vaccine. More recently, and a large percentage of those
- 41:37who got arrested for the January sixth, what are we calling it, the
- 41:44attempt to overthrow the government? Yeah, the insurrection. Yeah, A large
- 41:50percentage of those folks were Proud Boys because they were heavily involved in the planning
- 41:54of all that. You have Identity Europa. I believe it's a V instead
- 42:00of a U. So I don't know exactly how to pronounce it, but
- 42:01I sume that's one of the movements. Now. They reformed after the Unite
- 42:07the Right rally to the American identitarian movement. You have another large group which
- 42:13is the Adam Waffen Division. Have you heard of that? Oh, yes,
- 42:15yes, I've gotten many notes on them. Yeah. So these are
- 42:20people who want to try to collapse our civilization because they believe that we are
- 42:27depraved and run a foul of the foundation of human dignity or something. You
- 42:32also have the Nationalist Front it's another large group. It's sort of a loose
- 42:37organization of other neo Nazi groups. That was another thing that was kind of
- 42:42confusing. It's like in the past, when we were kids, you had
- 42:45the KKK and maybe other neo Nazis and white and skinheads. Maybe that was
- 42:50it, but now it's you know, because we were talking about in a
- 42:52previous chapter that if you believe that you have all the answers and you're completely
- 42:58intolerant, of course, in conversation and influence, then small differences between two
- 43:04chrismatic leaders will lead to at the very least non cohesion, right, and
- 43:10maybe even infighting. Right. So you have all of these tiny little groups
- 43:15that will begrudgingly ban together and thank god, because I think that actually plays
- 43:22into their weakness. I think if they actually were able to galvanize. And
- 43:29you know, in that clip that we saw in a previous chapter, that
- 43:31guy at the Unite the Right rally was talking about how he's waiting for that
- 43:36chrismatic leader. They're waiting for an Adolph Hitler. And he was talking about
- 43:38how Donald Trump might be that person, but probably not because he let his
- 43:43daughter marry a Jew. You know that whole thing, so God help us.
- 43:47I mentioned that interview with the KKK leader in the must have been the
- 43:52seventies where he was like, well, we're not Nazis, and there was
- 43:58that feeling of like because to be clear, the Nazi movement was a German
- 44:04nationalist and to start with, it wasn't even the little German boundaries that they
- 44:08had when the thing started. It was in their mind the larger German population,
- 44:14which absolutely included Austria and a couple other pieces. I also included the
- 44:19reclaimed territories from France, and it included a whole bunch of stuff all that,
- 44:22but that's not the United States of America, right, So there were
- 44:25certainly a lot of movements early on, including the KKA was like, well,
- 44:30I'm not gonna look, I'm not a Nazi. I just want you
- 44:34know what's here, And like I was saying, I don't want to kill
- 44:37them, just you know, they keep to their own, we keep their
- 44:39own, and let's close the borders because we don't want more of them things.
- 44:44But but now it's gotten quite it's you know, so many years since
- 44:49now it's like, well, no, I think Hitler had was onto something
- 44:52and there's even folks like Variants that admire Germany literally and like no, no,
- 44:57I actually think Germany should have taken over. And I think but as
- 45:01you're saying, luckily, part of the curse of being a very large nation
- 45:07is you'll have all these movements bring up. But part of the blessing is
- 45:10that there's a lot of very variability, and hopefully that variability makes it so
- 45:15that the coalescing into one monolith is hard, yeah, and hopefully impossible,
- 45:21But yeah, I think about how in Dungeons and Dragons they will have the
- 45:25the alignment system. You know, you have the acxis between good and evil
- 45:30and the access between law and chaos. So you can have someone that's chaotic
- 45:37good because you know, that's like a Robin Hood person. Then you have
- 45:42someone that's lawful good, that's like a police officer, that's a good police
- 45:46someone that follows the law. And then you have someone that is lawful evil.
- 45:52And the common example here is like a mafia member. They follow a
- 45:58code and there's a there's a rule of law within evil like they want rules,
- 46:02they have specific things they can get right, and they're much more likely
- 46:06to be cohesive as a as an organization, right, But then you have
- 46:10the chaotic evil, which are individuals that want to do evil, but they
- 46:16don't have any sort of code and no loyalties, and they tend not to
- 46:21band together. It's more like full on nilus h or total selfishness or like
- 46:29some extreme libertarian positions. I guess, yeah, well where they really believe
- 46:34like there shouldn't even be a government, right, so we would say they
- 46:37would be on the chaotic side. You can have good libertarians and evil libertarians
- 46:42supposed, but with chaotic evil individuals, they are very easy within the Dungeons
- 46:49and Dragon system to fight because they don't band together. So yeah, we
- 46:52have the Nationalists Front, which is a loose organization of neo Nazis other groups.
- 46:58We also have the Aryan Nationalist Alliance. We have also the Area Nations,
- 47:04and we also have the Oath Keepers. So do you know about the
- 47:07oath Keepers. Yeah, basically the oath as in uh preserving because a lot
- 47:14of the things started related to the borders too, and they wanted to basically
- 47:19enforce the borders and so if I remember right, they would go down with
- 47:22guns and like patrol to make sure that no one would get through Yeah,
- 47:29in between the chapters, I've been doing more investigation deep dive wise, and
- 47:34you probably came across this, and we'll get to this when you get in
- 47:37your notes. But the proliferation of neo Nazism and white supremacy and fascism within
- 47:44the ranks of the military and the police, yep, yeah, and I
- 47:49hadn't known that. I mean, of course I knew that some police and
- 47:52military folks were neo Nazis, but you know, there are some therapists that
- 47:58are probably neo Nazis for all I know, it's just the Bell curve,
- 48:00but apparently there's a disproportionate number of military and police who are neo Nazis and
- 48:07extremists, not just like slightly racist, but like wanting to overthrow the government.
- 48:12You know, there were a number of January six individuals who were military
- 48:16and police and sometimes current military right with access to military grade weapons and have
- 48:25There's a lot of stealing of these weapons. You know, some of these
- 48:29groups, because of their ties to the military, their members will just walk
- 48:32out of the base with equipment and a lot of equipment, yeah, and
- 48:37material. The worst part about it for me is a well, first of
- 48:39all, yeah, because they've been trained. They've been trained in the military,
- 48:43right, So a lot of these folks are trained military ex members or
- 48:46sometimes active members. Two, there was a huge investigation done that concluded that,
- 48:54you know, like that there was an absolute problem in the military.
- 49:00The guy who did the investigation was essentially like shut down and he's no longer
- 49:07actively working for I think it was the CIA, and a lot of the
- 49:14right wingers are actively working to shut down any investigations into that in the military,
- 49:20right. I mean, it'd be one thing if there was a problem
- 49:22in the military with neo Nazis and the government was a united front against it,
- 49:30Yes, but it appears that it's not. It appears that there are
- 49:34people in power that are preventing all sorts of things, not just that movement,
- 49:37but also journalists from looking into it. And so the oath keepers are
- 49:43a lot of military and law enforcement people, and the oath that they're referring
- 49:47to is their oath. In the military, typically, you know, you
- 49:52will hear I don't know the legality or the specificity or the validity of this,
- 49:59but you'll see in movies that there will be a soldier that will be
- 50:04given an order by their superior, and the soldier will say, I can't
- 50:09in good conscience follow that order because it contradicts the constitution. Like if a
- 50:15superior in the military told a soldier to torture the enemy or something, or
- 50:20to kill an innocent you would have soldiers that would say, look, I'm
- 50:23in the military to follow orders, that's for sure, unless you give me
- 50:29an order that contradicts the Constitution or the American way or whatever. And so
- 50:36these oathkeepers are saying that society is giving them this order, or the government
- 50:42will step in and say we're going to take away your guns. That's another
- 50:45one of their big concerns. Or the government is telling you to get a
- 50:50vaccine or to tell your employees to get a vaccine or something, and they
- 50:54are saying, unconstitutional according to them, And so we keep our oath.
- 51:00So even though we're a hierarchy, you know, we're pro hierarchy. If
- 51:04you give me an order that is against the Constitution, then I'm not going
- 51:07to follow it. So that's their whole kind of stick. Yeah, And
- 51:09ironically they not necessarily them, but sometimes they will cite the Nuremberg Trials ironically,
- 51:20like, well, you see, like Nazi soldiers went along with the
- 51:22bad orders and that was not okay. That was found to be not okay
- 51:27by the international court. You know about this, right, Like how because
- 51:30the claim was all the Nazis that first went to trial, they were all
- 51:34saying, hey, I was just following orders. I was just following orders.
- 51:37And the Numberg trials found that, well, that's not okay. Just
- 51:40because you were following orders does not excuse it. So there's two things with
- 51:44it. One then that gets used as like yeah, you see, like
- 51:46that's not okay. The Nazis that was not okay. So therefore I'm not
- 51:51going to follow every order if the order goes against my core. Oh,
- 51:53like right, I'm going to stand in the way. Right, you would
- 51:57probably find someone who literally is a neo Nazi and is pro Hitler and all
- 52:02the things, and at the same time an oathkeeper who adheres to that notion
- 52:07that because people that went along with the Nazi orders were wrong to do so,
- 52:14right, Because which one are you gonna pick? Assuming because as we
- 52:16said, there's all sorts of cross sections. You can imagine most well,
- 52:22you know, I will okay, I'm gonna put out on a limb.
- 52:24Most of the folks that are members of these organizations probably still feel that if
- 52:29they believe that the Holocaust happened, that full on interment camps where they burn
- 52:36millions of people is not is too far and therefore, and you know,
- 52:39again, if they believe that it happened, right, but they might say
- 52:42like, well, a, I don't think it happened, but if it
- 52:44did, well, yeah, well that would be bad because you know,
- 52:46there's a lot of cognitive dissonance. Right, So no, no, no,
- 52:49no, listen, we're not We're actually the good guys. We are
- 52:52Christians, all they say. We just don't want our country to like blah,
- 52:55right, and therefore it's easy for them to I've heard this all the
- 53:00time, and a lot of the interviews I watched and on the research folks
- 53:04that are actually full on white suprematists, and they'll still say, like,
- 53:08the other side are Nazis, right, they'll accuse the other side of being
- 53:13Nazis. So that's the one part. The other part is that it's actually
- 53:17really confusing because how do you disobey an order? So they actually seem to
- 53:23stand on a good soapbox about this, like, well, listen, you
- 53:28can't just blindly follow orders and yes, I know that I'm supposed to have
- 53:32feilty to the president, but not if it goes against like the bigger,
- 53:37you know, greater good. So it's like they have almost a legitimate argument
- 53:40in their minds, you know. Yeah, yeah, absolutely, yeah.
- 53:45And we talked about in a previous chapter how some of them in interviews will
- 53:49say very nice versions of neo Nazism, like, look, we're you know,
- 53:54we're we're just we're a peaceful group. We don't want to kill anybody.
- 53:58But you go into the discord server and there's no talk of peace or
- 54:06working together or anything. You know, it's a lot of kill them all
- 54:10and burn them all and that sort of thing. Another group are the three
- 54:15percenters or the three percent or something? Do you know these folks? Yes,
- 54:20the yes, but I forgot what the three percent was, But I
- 54:23know that there are another movement that basically believes that they that they need to
- 54:29be there, they need to be there to defend the core Constitution and all
- 54:35that. Right. Yeah, it refers to the apparently there were three percent
- 54:39of Americans that fought against the British during the rights so and you could see
- 54:46that being an inspirational title. Right, it doesn't take many people to overthrow
- 54:54tyrannical government, right. And the British government and military was, you know,
- 55:00the biggest in the world, or at least one of the biggest at
- 55:01the time, and you have this small colony and only three percent of them,
- 55:06So they're a huge second amendment. All of these are, but especially
- 55:09because of that tie to like the revolution. Now, I want to be
- 55:15clear that these groups, these are not just neo Nazi light or militant light.
- 55:21These groups are terrifying. They train, Yeah, they have huge areas
- 55:25of land where they train. And by the way, the videos of them
- 55:29training, it just looks like war recreation nerds. You know, yes,
- 55:35it's it's scary, but at the same time, it just looks like cosplay.
- 55:38It is because you know, they're they're busting doors and throwing flash grenades,
- 55:45right, and they have all the accouterment, and you're and I'm thinking,
- 55:50when will this come into play? Well, but that's just said that.
- 55:52The scary thing is that, as much as it is, it does
- 55:55look funny. None of us when was the last time you went trained for
- 56:00these things? Uh? Uh? Never? Yeah? Right, So well,
- 56:05yesterday a lot of us, most of us on the left, think
- 56:08that it is ridiculous, but we don't have that kind of training either.
- 56:13Yeah, you're right. I when I was watching the footage, I had
- 56:15those two reactions. On one hand, I'm like, my god, these
- 56:20guys they have a lot of firepower and they're dying to use it and they
- 56:24have a target in mind. On the other hand, they're a bunch of
- 56:30middle aged guys out of shape. But that's the sad part, right,
- 56:34that they're It's sad in that. Well, Okay, I mean there's two
- 56:37perspectives. One is we you know, we all do weird things for fun
- 56:42and to pass the time. Yeah, so I guess fine if it's a
- 56:45hobby, but we know it's for fun and it's a hot you know,
- 56:46if we're playing like paintball, yeah, which I guess we're not. I
- 56:50play Age of Empires with my brother where I'm defeating other civilizations and killing everyone.
- 56:53Yeah, and I know it's just a game, right, it's for
- 56:58these guys they believe it's they're preparing for the end times or I don't know.
- 57:01I'm just trying to think, like, what room are you going to
- 57:05be throwing a flash granade into and clearing the way that you would in the
- 57:09actual military. Anyway, Oh, I have an idea. What okay,
- 57:13here's what I'll do. So when it all breaks out and they're all like,
- 57:15okay, now our training is finally going, I'll go online. I'll
- 57:17be like, hey, I'm an operative too. You can't see my face
- 57:21because I'm deep undercover, but I operate, and I have tons of tactical
- 57:25training of how to lead armies into battle and like how to manage resources and
- 57:30how to optimize different So I will lead you all, and of course it's
- 57:35all my Age of Empires training, but they don't know that I'm going to
- 57:37lead them all to their doom. We'reing an elephants or camels, that's right.
- 57:42Yeah, No, No, I have an idea, which is that
- 57:46we have to form our own paramilitary group, but it'll be within our belief
- 57:52system. Well, right, I guess there are LARPers, but I'm trying
- 57:58to think more general, like a pro environment, we're pro science, we
- 58:05are pro liberty. Also, we got to use science. We're pro diversity.
- 58:10And so maybe we would have a group that each specialist, right,
- 58:16you would have like the scientist and the environmentalists. I guess it would be
- 58:22like a nineties cartoon group of like what was that show? The Eco Captain
- 58:30Planet will fail because we'll be arguing about the proper terminology and how to not
- 58:34offend each other. That'll be the that'll be what we fight against the monster
- 58:40of pedantic what's the word for it, the political correctness run amuck sort of
- 58:51thing. Yeah, yeah, Bruto, let's take a break. What do
- 58:53you say, Let's do it. The