Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / who created wolverine pt 2 with roy thomas and mark waid
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to Word Below the count Book Conversation show. John suntris here.
- 0:05You know that who created Wolverine controversy continues to rattle back and forth online,
- 0:12not only podcasts, but certainly posts on Facebook all over social media. Who
- 0:17created Wolverine? Everyone used to believe that it was a close subject, Lenn
- 0:22Ween Herb Trimpy, that's your writer and artist that did the three issues of
- 0:26Incredible Hulk, the story that introduced Wolverine. But now all of a sudden,
- 0:31the editor at Marvel at the time, Roy Thomas, is putting in
- 0:35his claim. It's not a new claim. Actually, I had Roy on
- 0:39Word Balloon back in twenty eighteen on a convention panel explaining his belief on how
- 0:45he co created Wolverine. Well, again, the controversy continues. I wanted
- 0:51to go to somebody who might have a different point of view from their own
- 0:56personal experience as a writer and editor and publisher, and the first name that
- 1:02came to mind was Mark Wade. So I had this great conversation last night
- 1:06with Mark about the creation of Wolverine and Roy Thomas's claims. And I'm gonna
- 1:15start the show with about six minutes of Roy giving his side of the argument,
- 1:21and then you'll hear the rebuttal from Mark Wade. So I think it's
- 1:23going to be a pretty interesting episode today, Mark Wade and Roy Thomas talking
- 1:27about the creation of Wolverine on today's word Balloon. Word Villain is brought to
- 1:32you by Alex ross Art dot com. Alex is a good friend of the
- 1:36show, and I am honored that he aligns himself with word Balloon and good
- 1:42lord, we all love his iconic art, whether it's for DC Marvel things
- 1:47like Bonnie Python, the Monkeys, David Bowie, so many other great license
- 1:52things the Beatles. If you go to Alex Rossart dot com, you will
- 1:56find great value for your dollar, whether you can spring for something like original
- 2:02cover art or pages to lithos and posters. Every price point you can imagine,
- 2:10you will find something at a beautiful image from Alex Rossart dot com.
- 2:16Word Balloon is also presented by my listeners, the League of Word Balloon Listeners,
- 2:22the help that I get via contributions from Patreon Patreon dot com slash word
- 2:28Balloon. You hear the entertainment that I provide from word Balloon every day that
- 2:31I do a new episode I am very fortunate to have the great creators of
- 2:38comics and pop culture willing to come on and give you great entertainment. I
- 2:44hope you will consider making an actual cash contribution via Patreon, even on dollar
- 2:50a month. But really, if word balloon is worth the price of a
- 2:53comic book a month to you, it would be greatly appreciated if you slide
- 2:58that extra money you would put on an issue of a comic book. Two
- 3:00word balloon via Patreon, Patreon dot com slash word balloon. Thank you,
- 3:07League of word Balloon listeners. Okay, before we get started with Mark Wade,
- 3:14here is that portion of my conversation with Roy Thomas and Susanna Flores where
- 3:20Roy lays out his claims of co creating Wolverine. I mean, I'll take
- 3:25whatever credit I feel. You know, I'm deserved, and I don't want,
- 3:29you know, and I owe him more, all ahead of lifting on
- 3:32the character, you know, after its basic content was done first by well
- 3:38John Vida designing a hostage. Okay, sure, earlier, Lynn is the
- 3:44writer that I asked to do it because he had to help roaming around.
- 3:47I thought he would be easy for him to get up to Canada. And
- 3:51to do a story there, which he did very quickly. And of course
- 3:54then Herb Trippy is the artist who actually had to take that one drawing or
- 3:58sort of wolverine and make it later on other people had a Dave Cockran brought
- 4:02in like a face because you know, John Reader didn't design a face on
- 4:05him, and Cockran used the face of another character who I guess had been
- 4:11called the wolverine that he had showed me before. Had no connection with the
- 4:14thing I did. It was some character getting made up for d C for
- 4:16the Leach of the Superherol. So it meant nothing to me because you know,
- 4:20I mean I knew what a wolverine was since I was like five,
- 4:24you know, I was always interested in animals, and and also I had
- 4:28thought about it. Well, we'll tell you what happened. What happened is
- 4:30that we were doing all these books. This is like A seventy four and
- 4:35that's who long Moore I quit his editor get it, suddenly curt me one
- 4:39day that we had we had I don't know, five percent, ten percent
- 4:43whatever of our readers. You know, certainly several percent where I'm in Canada.
- 4:47You know they read English. They you know they were their clothes.
- 4:50They got some of our comingues, and you know, we should have a
- 4:54Canadian character. I had already made up for Exen with the intention with the
- 4:58artists of course, the Ma and Sheep and Sunfire, you know, with
- 5:01Irish and Japanese backgrounds. But I thought, you know, we should have
- 5:04a Canadian character. So I called lenin and I see, you know,
- 5:09if len hadn't been available, or you know, something or somebody else would
- 5:12writing in the hall, he would have been the Burst or whatever. But
- 5:15Lynn was like, you know, one of the couple of very best you
- 5:17know writers in comics. So he worked out very well. And I called
- 5:20Himim and I Bunny and said, there just four things. His name's Wolverine.
- 5:25I thought about calling him badger. You know. I wanted an animal
- 5:29that lives up in a part, you know, the boose, you know
- 5:34her to say that it was awful but well, but what found a sign
- 5:40was not I didn't remember the name of, you know, the character that
- 5:45they've had. But the thing is that, or else I wouldn't have thought
- 5:47of the badger. But the thing is that a badger, you know,
- 5:51as a verb, just sounds like somebody's annoying you you're badgering somebody. Heesn't
- 5:56have that right sound, even though it badger is a very fierce freet shirt
- 5:59and wolverine. Nobody knew what that was either. John Bravida said that when
- 6:02he's when he saw the name, he thought it was a female wolf,
- 6:05that he had to look it up to the picture of black Repeto. But
- 6:10I liked it because it sounded like wolf. You know, anything that sounds
- 6:13like wolf a good word for a character. It's a wolverine. It was
- 6:15good. So I just said I wanted to call the wolverine, you know.
- 6:19They dropped the later, but that was the original thing. And he
- 6:23was Canadian. And Leon had done Brother Voodoo, another character concept of mine,
- 6:30a little not quite as memorable as Wolverine, and and I liked the
- 6:34way he had done the accent for that character. Hated Haitian character. Of
- 6:38course, he gave a Jamaican accent, but it's still was an accent.
- 6:42So I said, you can do a Canadian accent, you know, and
- 6:44so weird, which I guess bet putting the word ad and the other two
- 6:48things, which is when he kind of forgotten and he sort of rediscovered the
- 6:51wheel by let himself. But I told him, I said, he's got
- 6:54to be short, because I want to you know, wolverine is a small
- 6:57animal, which I like because all the heroes they're all six foot something tall,
- 7:01and I wanted to hear that was shorter saying hot his knee say or
- 7:04something. You know, there weren't that many of those. So and the
- 7:08other one that he would be very fierce because the wolverrade was noted for attacking
- 7:11the animals several times in size. And with that I set it off.
- 7:15The lead and everything else was either done by Len with the artists, or
- 7:18else. A little later, after just a couple of stories by lend by
- 7:23Chris Claremont, who really developed the character of the most I forget, you
- 7:27know myself, whether it's lead or what some of them gave him. I
- 7:31didn't tell him give him clause specifically, or let them let him known adam
- 7:35Antium clause. I'm happy he is, since I had also created adam ACiE,
- 7:40so it was nice. But that was shugarly either Lynn or part Chris,
- 7:44and it was probably Chris in conjunction with Dave Cochran originally and later John
- 7:47Burne but especially with the early days of cockr that developed that character. After
- 7:53what he really became the breakaway star of the Accident and one of Marvel's you
- 7:58know, I'm happy to say, even though I don't on the piece of
- 8:01y one of Marvel's you know, handful of most popular characters. But you
- 8:05know, as I said, it was other people that did it all.
- 8:07I just sort of my job was to kind of get things going. It
- 8:09wasn't even to create characters. But once in a while when I had an
- 8:13idea, I would either do it myself or get somebody else to do it.
- 8:16And that was basically but I was afraid that you know, it would
- 8:20unfortunately you know, lend her alonger with this. But you know, they
- 8:24were the ones that you know, really got it, got it, Billy.
- 8:28It is interesting that, as you say, it started from a Dave
- 8:31Cochrane drawing for the Legion of superho said, there is timber Wolf who's very
- 8:35similar to Wolf Ringe. Yeah, but basically I don't. I don't think
- 8:37it started from that drawing at all. Oh, but I just think he
- 8:41did it first, I said, And I saw it, but I saw
- 8:43about ten characters. And as I said, when I started for the day,
- 8:46I started to think of just animals, and I thought of Wolverine and
- 8:48Badger and Moose and maybe a couple other animals. But what Dave did that
- 8:54later was when when Wolverine takes off his mask sort of, he gave him
- 8:58the head I think that he had had for this billion version of Wolvery.
- 9:01But of course that had nothing to do with his creation, because you know
- 9:05he didn't have that. But that's the thing, you know, you start
- 9:09creating things to some characters have one creator. Bill Erett created the submaror nobody
- 9:13else, probably Carl Berger has created human Torch. I started to say,
- 9:18Bob Kana Batman, we know that isn't true, and anyway, our Doctor
- 9:22Bolton and Wonder Women, that's not true. But you know a few things
- 9:26have one creator, but mostly they often they have two or or in the
- 9:31case of some four or five or six, And with Wolverine, you'd have
- 9:33to have at least three or four before you could even I got annoyed when
- 9:37they I think they left her Trippy's name off of the Logan movie they have
- 9:41don't get it. I just really annoyed, absolutely because the guy who did
- 9:46But and yet when they've got Luke Cage on Netflix, they give George Tuska
- 9:50the credit and his his role in Louke Cage would a bit exactly what hers
- 9:54was. Surely characters had one drawing and you know, and then do that
- 9:58story from a plot, you know, some you know, they do the
- 10:00best they can with these credits. You know, it's hard to and you
- 10:03know it's hard to figure out who did it because if you ask, you
- 10:05know, everybody did it, you know. So that's Roy Thomas explaining his
- 10:09co creation of Wolverine. That's his claim. And now let's get into the
- 10:13rebuttal from a man who has been a writer, an editor and a publisher,
- 10:18Mark Wade, Welcome back everybody time again for word Balloon, the comical
- 10:22conversation show. John Centrists here, always happy to welcome Mark Wade. Well,
- 10:28feelings mutual, son, you know that, and good Lord a big
- 10:31flap And it's right there in the title. The question of who created Wolverine
- 10:37is a current topic, brought upon by the original editor at Marvel, Roy
- 10:43Thomas, who told Herb Trimp or well, yeah, Herb Trippy and Len
- 10:46Wayne, Hey, how about a Canadian character for the Hulk to fight,
- 10:50and we know we're made. A senior designed the costume R and we know
- 10:54her herb drew the original two part story. Lent Wain wrote the two part
- 10:58story. But now Roy is claiming a co creator credit, and Disney and
- 11:03Marvel our acquiescing, I guess in the in the new Deadpool Wolverine movie.
- 11:09Now you're a guy that's been a writer and an editor like Roy, and
- 11:11a publisher, publish and a publisher. So so yeah, your thoughts on
- 11:16the topic. Nope, let me just cut right to it. No,
- 11:22it's the job. That is the job of an editor to throw an idea.
- 11:28I mean, I don't know any editor in this business. And believe
- 11:31me, we have been talking a lot among us the last couple of weeks
- 11:37on any editors in comics who haven't thrown that ideas. Here's a name,
- 11:41here's an idea for character. You know, here's something you could here's a
- 11:45scene for your story, here's you know. I've ghosted entire you know,
- 11:48pages of stories I've I've edited it. Just that's that's what you do with
- 11:54You're a staff editor. You give notes, you help shape the story,
- 11:58you create the story. That is your job as an editor, and if
- 12:05you want to have bragging rights, have that absolutely. And don't you know,
- 12:11no one is getting their nose out of joint because Roy walks around saying,
- 12:16you know, I helped create Wolverine. You know what, you say
- 12:20it all you want, put it on your tombstone. I don't care.
- 12:22You know, I've fine, And I think we're all universally agreed on that
- 12:30as well. Like it's not it may be a will go sometimes depending upon
- 12:33the credit, depending upon your involvement, but no one's going to be grudge
- 12:37of that. But it's the it's the official thing. It's the you know,
- 12:41contacting lawyers, making sure it's there on the on the film, making
- 12:46sure it's it's officially in the credits, you know, making sure that you
- 12:50know, if there's any revenue from it, you know, I get a
- 12:52piece. That's just it's it's stolen valor is as I think, what has
- 13:03everybody really pissed off? We all love Lent? I mean yeah, people
- 13:09who even fans who didn't really know Len and never met Len, really liked
- 13:13Lent. It just was so personal a guy. His work was so warm.
- 13:16He was such a creative person and always won by the way to give
- 13:20credit wherever it was due. And it's just I've never seen anything like this.
- 13:30I've never seen an editor come, you know, fifty years down the
- 13:35road after everybody else is dead, to can test it and say, you
- 13:37know, I should be officially credited as part of the creation here. That's
- 13:43the job. Dude. Have you ever been in that capacity where you if
- 13:48using the Roy Thomas scenario and say, oh yeah, by the way,
- 13:52you know, would you mind vocalizing any it sounds trivial because compared to Wolverine,
- 13:58all of it sounds trivial, right, But you know, and I
- 14:01don't And I'm being I'm being circumspect here only because I don't want it to
- 14:07sound like I'm treading on the credits of the people who actually did the writing
- 14:11and the drawing. So let's just say their their characters, their allegiant characters
- 14:16there are you know, Brian Augustine was always really good about giving me verbal
- 14:22credit for you know, helping with Gotham my gaslight, and I was his
- 14:26editor. It was my it was my basic notion. He expanded it,
- 14:31said, Brian Hey Batman one hundred years ago in you know, Victorian Gotham
- 14:37go which is not a whole lot different than Canadian guy named Wolverine go.
- 14:46It would never occur to me to ask BC for some official credit on this.
- 14:52It would never occur to me to, you know, make sure that
- 14:54my name is in the film credits of the adapted you know, animated or
- 14:58whatever. And that's just one example. And that's just me, and there
- 15:03are and yes, I've been an editor and a publisher forever often on could
- 15:09I spend a lot of time in that chair, And there have been plenty
- 15:13of instances like that where you're just throwing ideas back and forth. Is trying
- 15:20to get the book out the door, and you're having fun knocking ideas back
- 15:24and forth, because that really is part of the fun of the job for
- 15:26most of us, is the volleying the ball back and forth, you know,
- 15:31the can you top this? That's part of the real fun of being
- 15:35in comics and in any kind of creative pacity, even if you're an editor.
- 15:39So all this to say, yes, you know, and I've spoken
- 15:43to other editors who have similar stories and it's not there's their stories are not
- 15:48mine to tell, but but you know they did this or they created this.
- 15:54You know they quote unquote created this character. They they did as much
- 15:58on this, They did more on this than then you're supposed to do as
- 16:03an editor. Really, I suppose you know, I gave this guy the
- 16:06concept for the for the series, that kind of stuff. But I've yet,
- 16:11I mean, everyone in comics has been talking about this for a couple
- 16:15of weeks, right, Yeah, hundreds and hundreds of creative people past and
- 16:21present weighing in on this. No one, no one has taken Roy's side
- 16:29on this. That should tell you something. And like I told you,
- 16:36I told you before we started, I don't This is not me teeing up
- 16:40to just, you know, beat on Roy for half an hour, because
- 16:42that's I I nothing's accomplished by that at this point. It's not like Marvel's
- 16:48going to change their mind. It's like it's going to change his mind.
- 16:52It is. It is about the fact that Len deserves that credit. Those
- 16:57are the standards by which we have done business in mainstream comics since nineteen thirty
- 17:03five. Have there been exceptions every once in a while, I'm sure there
- 17:07have, you know, are there? You know? Would I argue about
- 17:11them too? Probably? One that I wondered about back in the fifties when
- 17:15Showcase four came out, the Bury aalt Flash, right, and you know
- 17:21again, written by Robert Canneger, drawn by Carmine Infantino. But I know
- 17:25Julie Schwartz obviously started with, hey, let's update the Flash. Yeah,
- 17:30you know, and again, I don't know further than that. And I've
- 17:33also known, reading things like Roy Thomas's own Alter Ego magazine, that it
- 17:37might be a little murky in terms of how much Julie did. I don't
- 17:41know if you ever and I do not only did you ever talk to Julie
- 17:44about it, but even further given the fat Flash TV show and the Flash
- 17:48movie, I don't know. I'd have to go back in Zapruder film the
- 17:52credits and see if Julie is listed as a I mean, they don't even
- 17:56call them co creators in those instances, always special thanks or whatever, right,
- 18:02But yeah, don't. I don't know, But that was the closest
- 18:04thing that immediately came to mind when this Wolverine thing came up. I think
- 18:07that's plenty fair. I don't really see much difference between hey, we need
- 18:14a new Flash and hey, you need a character named Wolverine. I don't
- 18:19really see much difference there in terms of that is the function of the job.
- 18:27Again, it's the reason that we're all talking about it still is that
- 18:32it is from an outside perspective. I think from a layman's perspective, maybe
- 18:37a little more complicated, because you can say, yeah, if Roy was
- 18:41at home at ten o'clock at night and suddenly this idea popped into his head
- 18:45and he wasn't behind the desk of the time, then yeah, sure,
- 18:48you know he's co created or whatever. But again that that's a function of
- 18:55something else all together, is not the custom by which we do stuff in
- 18:57comics and hasn't been Set's a really dangerous precedent because great, well, then
- 19:04should I go after stuff? You know, should other editors go after stuff
- 19:08that they chipped in? You know, Dan Raspboor I'm sure had a few
- 19:12ideas for Kingdom come you know, let is he filent suit? You know,
- 19:18to have his name on the book. It's it's just it also rankles
- 19:25I think creative people like myself because Roy is an agent of the company.
- 19:30And this is when we've been fighting so hard for creative people, freelancers to
- 19:37get credit. Where it is deserved to some degree. This also feels like
- 19:41a clawing back of the rights because you know, we had to fight this
- 19:48so hard to get here, and Roy as an editor of the company,
- 19:51as a staff editor, is you know, is clawing back. Well obviously
- 19:56job as Creed agrees with you, the create I said, to fight so
- 20:00hard for decades to get this recognition. Then you have Roy trying to clod
- 20:04back for the company, and a couple of other comments from specifically Bob Brido,
- 20:08who agrees with you and says editors add value shouldn't get co credit more
- 20:12like I suggested the name and that he be Canadian, which is co creating.
- 20:18I think where I think, here's what I would give. Here's what
- 20:22I would give you. If you look at other things that Roy has taken
- 20:27some credit for, Brother Voodoo, Louke Cage, Ghostwriter, the Vision.
- 20:34Yeah, yeah, if you go back, and if you go back and
- 20:37look at those books as I did, and look at the original credits,
- 20:41every one of them has a little arrow beside the credit box that says with
- 20:45creative contributions from Roy Thomas and artist or whatever. You know what, that's
- 20:52to me, that's to me, that's even that's over the line. But
- 20:56I'm not going to die in that hill. Like if that's you know,
- 20:57that doesn't really bother me that much. It's it's still not industry standard.
- 21:03But it goes to the idea that Roy is very credit conscious. Yeah,
- 21:11and again we mentioned those other characters that have been exploited in TV and film,
- 21:15and Roy has admitted in that Forbes article that Bob rob Sealkowitz did that.
- 21:22Yeah, you know, he was compensated for those things, and that's
- 21:25what that's t it. And listen, man, much like yourself, I
- 21:26have tremendous respect for Roy Thomas, the editor and the writer and I and
- 21:32all he created and contributed to both both universes Marvel and DC. So it's
- 21:37like, you know, why why now? Yeah, this is one of
- 21:41the things that actually genuinely saddens me is that here is a guy and I've
- 21:48known Roy for forty years, and I've known Roy as a creative person just
- 21:52sitting on the you know, sitting under a tree reading comics for fifty five
- 21:56years or whatever. Yeah, here's a guy who was pivotal in comics history
- 22:03so many times. You know, the I think the biggest contribution was probably
- 22:07Star Wars, right, bring in the Star Wars proper to get some Marvel
- 22:10comics at a time when they desperately needed something, and nobody thought anything of
- 22:15it, and it ended up being this amazing home run. Right that just
- 22:19it really changed the game for Marvel and for the industry. Awesome, good
- 22:25on you. You know Conan, same thing, you're bringing Conan into comics.
- 22:30Nobody thought this would work. Stand didn't think it was going to work.
- 22:33It didn't work for the first couple of three months, but it caught
- 22:36on. And now, look, there's a billion jillion Conan comics out there
- 22:40and that's made a lot of money for a lot of people. And I
- 22:42think that's good on you. So you know you created Ultron with you know,
- 22:48with with John you Simmer or Barry winsor Smith, I forget which one
- 22:52of the two. And yeah, you know you created, you co created
- 22:56the vision, you co created you know so many of these characters. That
- 23:00is, no one can take that away from you. No one can take
- 23:04that that. Let that be your legacy. Let that be your legacy,
- 23:08not the You don't want to leave people with the last memory of your career
- 23:15being uh yeah, he came along with a shovel and tried to dig up
- 23:18Len Wi. You know, I'm with you, man, No, it
- 23:22really and and again yeah, Royce in his eighties and it's it's not a
- 23:26good look. And again for a guy whose body of work needs no apologies,
- 23:30and of course we all, we all give it up to him.
- 23:33A couple more comments from everybody, Henry says, in my opinion, only
- 23:37Roy Thomas and John Remta Senior first created Wolverine's design, Len Wing and Herb
- 23:42Trippy used the character and expanded on him and Hulk one eighty through hoc on
- 23:47eighty two. All four should share credit. Okay, well again, I
- 23:52understand you're not alone. I've seen other people, you know, since bringing
- 23:56up this subject, I republished a panel I did a terrific kind of few
- 24:00years ago with Roy and Susannah Flora as a psychologist, and you know,
- 24:04got again Roy laid out his claim. Now that was even six years ago,
- 24:08it's like twenty eighteen or twenty nineteen, so yeah, it was kind
- 24:11of kind of interesting. Sterling Gates, Hey man, how long have Lynn
- 24:15been dead? Then? Exactly? Man? And then and Herb too,
- 24:22And I you know, I forget when Herb passed away. But two real
- 24:26gentlemen, man and just the sweetest down earth guys, Lenn and Herb.
- 24:30And you know it doesn't make sense. Sterling Gates says, the Flash movie
- 24:34did a detailed honestly which read the original both read the Flash created by Harry
- 24:40Lampert and Gardner Fox. Obviously that's the Jake Eric version, and then the
- 24:44Barry Allen version by Robert Cannecker and Carmin and Fantino again makes sense. And
- 24:48by the way up top, they were in the opening credit, it's not
- 24:51the closing credits. So I'm so impressed by everyone. I was behind that
- 24:55decision. And also I remember, and forgive me, but I remember the
- 24:59red carpet that Hugh Jackman did, and and and Roy was there and he
- 25:04had Roy stand up, and and you said, I would not be here
- 25:08and would not have the career I have if it wasn't for that man.
- 25:12And thankfully, because well we both know Len had that fire at his house.
- 25:18And also Len was always in really poor health. God bless him.
- 25:21Ye and Marvel did write by him. And I don't know how much money
- 25:25you gave him, but they definitely gave him a significant amount of money.
- 25:27Yeah, yeah, it's yeah, I wonder some people are writing in And
- 25:34again I appreciate that comment that the fella made about All four or whatever.
- 25:40Yeah, and again we're it probably sounds like we're splitting hairs to people who
- 25:45aren't in comics. But do they get bragging rights? Yes? Do they
- 25:51get official co credit? That's a different issue. I'm with you, you
- 25:56know, Mike Jones, and I like this analogy. He says it seems
- 26:00similar to script doctor roles in movie making. The unwritten code is they don't
- 26:04get credit. Chris macquarie has repeatedly said he will not discuss movies he had
- 26:08that role on. Well, I know comedians that were script doctors for things
- 26:12like Ratatuoy and things like that that it's like, oh, no, I
- 26:15helped, And it's literally it's just I helped. You don't see the names
- 26:19on the screen. They obviously got paid for whatever contribution they made. But
- 26:23yeah, it's like, no, you don't. You don't get that co
- 26:26creator credit. I think a more apt analogy. And I have to give
- 26:32Purbusic some props on this one. I'm going to paraphrase and mangle it.
- 26:36But you know, if I hire a contractor to build me a new driveway,
- 26:41and I need it to be this wide and this long, and I
- 26:44wanted to have gold bricks. And I want to make sure that you don't
- 26:47uproot the oak tree in the middle of the yard when you build the thing,
- 26:51and it's got to come in this semi circle in form of my house.
- 26:53I don't get to say that I co built the driveway with you.
- 26:59Yeah, no, I get it, man, absolutely. Caesar says,
- 27:03I've never heard of an editor getting co created a status Jim Riddle. I
- 27:07saw where a kid had submitted a Wolverine character to film. Yep, Thomas
- 27:11said it. I didn't hear about that. Yeah, let's break Oh,
- 27:14let's break this down. Let's break this down. Are you aware of this?
- 27:18Yeah? Yeah, phone named Andy Owens Fan. Back in the day,
- 27:22FOOM was the in house Marvel fan magazine Friends of Old Marvel Ful exactly.
- 27:27So that was you know, if you were a big fan of Marvel,
- 27:30you get a subscription to this magazine that was produced in house by Marvel.
- 27:33They did a character creation contest for fans and one kid wrote in with
- 27:40a character named Wolverine, and they used the illustration and they gave him a
- 27:45boney you know, they gave him a shout out in the magazine Good for
- 27:49you It did it look like Wolverine? No? Was it a you know,
- 27:53a guy named Wolverine with Claus. Yes, that was you know,
- 28:00about a year and a half before we have Wolverine. I'm not saying there
- 28:07are so many. There are a lot of people who are rushing to that
- 28:08going see see it all came from there. It all was stolen from Andy
- 28:11Owans. I'm not going to go you that far. I'm not going to
- 28:15give you that necessarily because I know how creative stuff works in comics, and
- 28:19it's it could just be coincidence. It really genuinely could people come up with
- 28:25we we're we have to come up with ideas rabid fire every minute of every
- 28:29day, and we don't all read Foom magazine, you know, or what
- 28:33have you. It's and there's you know, there's been plenty of times and
- 28:37I've had an idea, but somebody else across town has had the same idea
- 28:40at the same time it happens. So there's that. But people are launching
- 28:45onto this. So there was a side online that I don't want to name
- 28:47because there. They do a good investigative job about this stuff, but there
- 28:52is an element of smug arrogance to the site that makes my teeth hurt.
- 28:59So if you want to go look, you can find them. But they
- 29:04ran an interview with Andy Owens and I read it actually this afternoon, and
- 29:08and he's like, you know, statute of limitations. There's nothing they got,
- 29:14big lawyers. I've made my peace with it it. You know,
- 29:18what are you going to do? And so people are running him, trying
- 29:21to gin him up into, you know, being a champion. He's like,
- 29:25look, dude, that was fifty years ago. I was a kid.
- 29:26You know, I have my own job. Now things happen, and
- 29:30I love that attitude about it. I mean, how correct in a world
- 29:36in which everybody is scrabbling to get at exactly a little bit of the little
- 29:40bit of the domg Absolutely, and yeah, and you know, I can't
- 29:44blame them, especially if you're going up against like Disney or Warner Brothers.
- 29:47Brother take all the money you can. But yeah, So that's yeah,
- 29:52that's the Andy o One story. That's interesting, you know. And sadly,
- 29:56I think this person and I'm not gonna name him, I really hate
- 30:00the way that he does business, but I believe someone that works for UH.
- 30:03Roy also made the claim that that Ben Cooper Spiders h Christ and a
- 30:10birch Bark canoe. Yes, I was prior to Stan and Steve did go
- 30:17creating Spider Man. This lecture from this guy, and if anything illustrates my
- 30:22point better than saying that just because something somebody said something over here in nineteen
- 30:26sixty two doesn't necessarily mean that somebody copied it in nineteen sixty six. Is
- 30:30that one of Roy's guys cornered me at a convention showed me a Ben Cooper
- 30:37Halloween costume from the late fifties or maybe sixty or whatever it was. It
- 30:41was certainly before Amazing Fantasy fifteen that was Spider Man, and it kind of
- 30:48looked vaguely like it had spider webs. Because again, if you're going to
- 30:53be a character named Spider Man, sure there's not many sartorial choices to make
- 30:57here, you're going to use the webs and convinced man. Convinced Man convinced
- 31:04that dit Co lifted the design from the character off of this Ban Cooper costume,
- 31:12presuming so just you have to get yourself in the in the headset,
- 31:15in the mindset that there is Steve Ditko handing out candy one Halloween, which
- 31:25already or beyond my imagination, but handing out Canyon. And then some kid
- 31:30steps up with a Spider Man costume and as he's putting you know, milk
- 31:33duds into this kid's bag, he's like, hey, maybe you got something
- 31:38here, kid, I'll file that away. Bullshit off it is. It
- 31:45is so, it is. Everybody's rushing to be It was always rushing to
- 31:51be the guy who found something out about history that nobody knew before. Right,
- 31:56Everyone wants that credit all I found something that nobody ever found out before.
- 32:00It is rampant in comic spandom when they find older characters from like Stan
- 32:07and Jack's Mystery books or you know, horror books that are that have a
- 32:12name that twelve years later was reused by somebody else in some other comic,
- 32:16and it becomes well, that character was a prototype of this character. No,
- 32:22No, that that presumes that somebody was paying attention. Now, that
- 32:25presumes that this was some sort of official test run on a character. No,
- 32:30it's not a prototype. It just meant that people have ideas. We
- 32:34crank out hundreds and hundreds of stories among them. In this industry, that's
- 32:42gonna happen. So it always tackles me when it's like, well, Aunt
- 32:45May and Uncle Ben they were characters in the Steve Dicko story, so clearly
- 32:49they were prototypes of Aunt Man and Uncle Ben and Spider Man several years later,
- 32:55or or somebody just like the names Ben and May. I'm with him
- 33:04a jodge. You know, it's crazy, and this is more dead on,
- 33:08and I kind of wish Rodney Daingerfield was still alive. But comedy nerds
- 33:14know his real name was Jack Roy. And I was listening to an old
- 33:17Jack Benny show from the forties, well before Jack Roy was doing stand up.
- 33:24I don't even know what Jack Roy was doing in the forties, but
- 33:30he was in Palm Springs and there was an EMC on a stage and I
- 33:34want to introduce one of our favorite stars of not only radio but the movies
- 33:38as well, Ladies and gentlemen, Rodney Dangerfield. And that blew my mind
- 33:44because I had never heard prior to seeing Rodney on the Tonight Show, but
- 33:49there was and there was a character named Rodney Dangerfield. Maybe that's where Jack
- 33:52Roy got it, but I'm sure whatever that Jack Benny Ryder was will not
- 33:57go yeah, I created Rodney Dayeers. Of course it is. It's it
- 34:02is. It is human nature to try to make connections between things that don't
- 34:07seem to be connected. If that, if that nature didn't exist, conspira
- 34:12theories would not exist. There is that nature. It is comforting to be
- 34:16able to think that things connect when they don't really, especially in a world
- 34:22that gets more tumultuous and less fact driven every single day. The idea that
- 34:27you can connect two things together that maybe nobody else is seeing, but you
- 34:30can take credit for making that connection. I get that. That's human nature.
- 34:35I'm so, but you know, I really I would. I would
- 34:40bet my life that at no point did Steve did go see a Halloween costume
- 34:50on this front porch or at Cresky and go eureka, I'm with you,
- 34:58then Dan Jurgen's so, Dan, it means a lot that you're watching great
- 35:01chat. Absolutely would add that Roy could have suggested new character named Wolverine Canadian
- 35:08background to ten different writers and it would have resulted in ten very different characters.
- 35:15Also, creation is not linear. Ideas move all over the place with
- 35:19often with nuance until realized suggestion is not creation ever. Well, in fact,
- 35:23I remember when did go you know, when the first Spider Man movie
- 35:28came out, to go have that essay where he's like, an idea is
- 35:32not creation until it manifests, especially in comics as a fully formed illustration and
- 35:39story. That's when creation happens. And you know, yeah, and that
- 35:45was his one and only, I think comment on creating Spider Man in recent
- 35:50you know years. I mean that was twenty years ago or whatever. Reverse
- 35:53that in reverse that in Stand's point of view. If I can read a
- 35:57quote real quick Stan's this is a quote from an interview talking about Stan says,
- 36:04Stan talked about people like Stephen J. Canal and television staying at Canal
- 36:07came up with a general idea and wants a few people running around doing this
- 36:12and that, and calls on the a team. He's created that it says
- 36:15created by Stephen Canal. And I said yes, and again I'm quoting the
- 36:19interview and I said yes, but that's a function of power, not of
- 36:22creativity. It means Stephen Knell has the power to say he created that thing
- 36:27alone, and other people want into that by agreeing to sell their work for
- 36:31work for hire or for other financial deals. But it doesn't mean he really
- 36:36created the whole thing just because it says so on paper. That's a legal
- 36:39thing. It's caused by his power. You either play by his rules or
- 36:43you don't. End quote Roy Thomas. Interesting, Absolutely, that very so
- 36:50very you don't get it both ways, Roy, Absolutely. Bob Bridle says,
- 36:54Mark, what has an encyclopeedic brain? That Well, that's what I'm
- 36:57talking on. That the the fan name from an old issue of Foom.
- 37:01Absolutely, that's that's great. No, I I really I hear you,
- 37:07man. And let's see, Mike, did you have a pre oll uh?
- 37:10And again Stanley says, why was this address? Why wasn't this addressed
- 37:15decades ago? I know, I know, I know, because Len wasn't
- 37:16dead yet, that's why. Well that's true. Well, and that's another
- 37:20thing, truly, Mark, that so many people have done research reading Comics
- 37:24Interview, likely Amazing Heroes, some of the other great comic interview magazines that
- 37:31we've discussed that you were a contributor to in the Amazing Heroes and know there's
- 37:37chapter and verse from herb Trimpy from land Wain from Roy himself saying, and
- 37:43again I'm paraphrasing, but essentially, yeah, I gave the idea to Lend
- 37:46but Lennon Herbert who carried the water, you know, and then they're the
- 37:50ones who really did it. And I mean contradictoring what he's what he is
- 37:53now saying, yeah, it makes me how to sharp your memory can suddenly
- 37:57become fifty years on. Absolutely that Henry didn't. Kirby also say that he
- 38:06created Spider Man. It looked like a Captain America guy with no shield and
- 38:09a web gun. Well, yeah, and in fact, I know a
- 38:12book that I want to say, Joe Simon's son, there was a silver
- 38:16Scaab character and you tell me if I'm wrong and correct. Yeah, but
- 38:21you got to go go go and yeah and that, and it's like,
- 38:23yeah, so you know, in fact, you know that's where Spider Man
- 38:27came from. Well we also know that that cover image from Amazing Fanity fifteen
- 38:32was a Jack Kirby cover, right that Stephen drawn a cover that Stan didn't
- 38:37like, and so Jack came in at the last second. Reader of the
- 38:39cover, I think that you know this is again a murky area. Did
- 38:45did did Jack really create enough of what you would consider to be Spider Man
- 38:52to be to have a co credit creator in the thing? I don't know.
- 38:55I wasn't there. You don't know. You weren't there. They're all
- 38:58dead, We don't know. But no one wants to take anything away from
- 39:04anybody. Look, I say this often, which is that credit is not
- 39:09a finite resource, which sounds paradoxical given what I've been arguing here. But
- 39:15when I say credit is not a finite resource, I generally mean that.
- 39:20Look, if you if you help me do something, you know, I'll
- 39:23give you credit. If I help you do something you know, it's just
- 39:28kindness. It's just general kind of give me, give me credit as it
- 39:31is doing. And if you don't, that's fine too. But if you
- 39:35do, that's nice. But it is better given than taken. Right.
- 39:42It's it's one thing to give credit to somebody it is. It is a
- 39:46different thing to go the other direction and take it, even if you think
- 39:53you deserve it. It is just I told you coming in the door,
- 40:00I really didn't want to just be, you know, a dog pilon on
- 40:02this guy for an hour, and I really don't because again, nothing's accomplished
- 40:07by it. Nothing's going to change. All we're doing right now is just
- 40:15inventing our spleens as a comic because it's not you know what's going to happen
- 40:20out of this. People are more editors are going to you know, if
- 40:23they're going to be new rules laid down, I don't probably not. You
- 40:27know, what do you want to come out of this? Nothing's going to
- 40:30come out of this? So it just I think also legitimately, those of
- 40:37us who have enormous respect for Roy's career and his contributions are disappointed by this.
- 40:45Yeah, man, no, I'm absolutely with you. And it's funny
- 40:47because Astin says, Jack Kirby has so many important creations already, forcing a
- 40:52new connection is unnecessary against him. Could be said about Roy Thomas dozens of
- 40:57important characters for Marvel and DC that he can hang us head on and say
- 41:01I did that, and we all stand back and applaud. I mean,
- 41:05that's the thing that sucks, Like I man, literally first year nineteen years
- 41:10of Ward will in come May tenth. Roy Thomas was always on my wish
- 41:15list. Stuff. Please, I want to talk to this guy. I
- 41:15finally did a couple of times, and I'm really glad I did because from
- 41:21a being aware of what he wrote. I mean, I bought that Treasury
- 41:23edition Avenger reprint print that had the Vision story and the Ultron story. That's
- 41:30probably the first stuff I read of Royce and being an Invaders fan as I
- 41:35was in the seventies, that fantastic series, an all star Squadron and it's
- 41:39again so many things that he created. Man Well, questioning the number of
- 41:45creators involved in the birth of the character could lead to an infinite loop,
- 41:49absolutely as layers continue to be added to the characters by a subsequent artist.
- 41:53DJ roy worked for the media company. The suggestion to freelancers by the editor
- 41:58is not creation. He's getting paid to work weekly. Freelances are not and
- 42:02Mike Jones, Apart from the very distasteful side of this is the wider impact
- 42:07that the precedence opens up the floodgates for every editor to do the same thing.
- 42:14And there, I guess, I guess if you know every editor who
- 42:16has deep enough pockets where they feel like taking over taken on Disney or Warner
- 42:20Brothers, or have a you know, I saw Goodman lawyer who's willing to
- 42:24work on a contingency. Yeah, you know, I wouldn't be stunned to
- 42:29see other claims come out of this. I would, But man, if
- 42:34if you care anything about leaving a good taste in people's mouth when they say
- 42:39your name, then you knock it off. Yeah yeah, man, No,
- 42:45it's it's gonna be uh. I think it's gonna be a very interesting
- 42:47few months for although the jet certainly outside of our comic fans sphere, nobody's
- 42:53gonna give a ship. I mean, you know they're gonna see you go
- 42:58okay, great, and even you know, in conventionnaires are going to be,
- 43:01oh, it's got to create co create a Wolverine, great, fantastic
- 43:05whatever. No, explain it to my fiance and her eyes glaze over.
- 43:13Let's let's break this down on another level for a second. It's not endemic
- 43:17to Roy. But this is also something I've been noticing in the last ten
- 43:22years or so, as I, you know, reach an age where it's
- 43:28like, you know, maybe I don't have to do this forever. There
- 43:32is a yearning on everyone's partner, right John, When you die, you
- 43:39want word balloon to be a legacy thing for you. You want people to
- 43:44mention that when they talk about you. You want people to remember you because
- 43:49of the things you have done. It's all of us want that. Everyone
- 43:52wants that. Sure, And the older you get, the more mindful of
- 44:00you are, the more conscious of it you are, the more it begins
- 44:04to be a reality that you know you're not going to be here forever,
- 44:07and you'd like certain things to be on your tombs thumb other than you know,
- 44:15he wrote Kingdom, come my my tombstone inscription is going to be He
- 44:23didn't think it through. That's just that that that's long decided. But Mark
- 44:30Wade, he didn't think it through. But it's so it is. It's
- 44:35again we get back to human nature. I'm trying to be kind. I'm
- 44:37trying to be understanding. I get that in your twilight years, as I
- 44:45will be before I blink. You know, you want to feel like you
- 44:51left a footprint. Yeah, yeah, And it's just what's maddening is do
- 45:00you already left an enormous footprint, the enormous footprint. The only you know,
- 45:05the only thing you're doing here is you're, you know, putting your
- 45:07shoe in somebody else's footprint. Yeah. No, I'm with you, man,
- 45:12absolutely Jurgen's good good point. Martin Goodman takes if Martin Goodin takes note
- 45:16of Justice League sales numbers and tells stan Lee to create a book with a
- 45:21team of superheroes. Does that make him a co creator a Fantastic four?
- 45:24Of course not? Yeah? Yeah, right, Hey, Dan, Certainly,
- 45:30Mike Harlan, in all your years working on Superman must have thrown out
- 45:36a character name, an idea, a plot notion. He must have.
- 45:39That's the job. Was there any I'm asking so you can type in your
- 45:44response, but was there anything that Mike said I deserve official Coke credit on
- 45:49this thing? Sure? Sure, whether it's Gangbuster or you know whatever.
- 45:54Yeah, during that during that period where where Dad, Barbara Kiesel and Luise
- 45:59and and everybody was writing Superman. No, that's a very good point,
- 46:02Dan. I hope you will comment on that in the chat because I would.
- 46:06I would love that answer. By the way, the Batman Part two,
- 46:10his Black Label story with Mike Perkins, came out this week, and
- 46:15God, I love that story. It's so good and it so feels like
- 46:19nineteen thirty nine. It really could have been an in between story between Detective
- 46:24twenty seven and twenty eight. It really is a good reason. Really.
- 46:28By the way, I got to tell you something, John, the reason
- 46:30that all of us professionals join your program halfway through like this is because we're
- 46:34actually hoping for a plug all that. So I'm just I'm giving, but
- 46:45I love them. Really, it's but it's praise well to serve. Mike
- 46:47Perkins doing great job. I wish I were smart enough to remember the colorist
- 46:52name off the top of my head, but also splendid work so well.
- 46:55And I'll be honest, man, and I asked both Dan and Mike this
- 47:00without any meanness attached to it. But I'm like, with the copyright,
- 47:05with the public domain thing coming up, it's kind of smart that DC is
- 47:08doing this because I think it's gonna make things that much harder for somebody to
- 47:15walk over and go, well, here's my generic Batman Bruce Wayne Detective twenty
- 47:19seven story, and DC's can go, yeah, that's cute. But nine
- 47:22years ago we made this and the copyrights right there, so now what And
- 47:25in fact I wonder I remember that great and I know you do too.
- 47:30That Tom de Haven Superman book essentially takes place in thirty eight and thirty nine,
- 47:35and it's like God, and I love that book. It's a fantastic
- 47:37If people haven't read that, you got to take on Superman yet? But
- 47:42I wonder if yeah, yeah, and I wonder if with I don't I
- 47:45have no idea what level of success this Batman story is having as a black
- 47:50label story. But it's like God, I would love to see them do
- 47:52the same thing with Superman. Yeah, I don't know, I don't know.
- 47:55Uh here, Dan says, you're right, like any good editor,
- 48:00Mike, like any good editor, offered many great thoughts and no didn't ask
- 48:06for credit, and there they did. I've outed you all and women because
- 48:14Gail Gail does it too, and every now and then some of the other
- 48:16women creators will pop it guys and women. I cannot tell you how much
- 48:21it delights me that you guys can pop in and make a comment. Well,
- 48:24I'm talking to somebody else. It means a lot, It really means
- 48:27a lot. So that's what we just want your attention. So he always,
- 48:34I think, tell me if I beat I think we've beaten this horse
- 48:37to that at this point. So and I'm going to go to something else.
- 48:39Caesar and I didn't realize this. Are you wrapping up your Shazam run
- 48:44or have you already done it? I have already wrapped up alas Dan was
- 48:47going to move on to something else, and he, even Dan, who
- 48:52is faster than light, can only draw a couple of books a month at
- 48:57best, And so Shizam had to go. And if Dan was leaving,
- 49:00I felt like my best work was going to be with Dan. You know,
- 49:05I did. I did, you know, work on three issues after
- 49:07Dan with terrific artists. But by that time the decision was kind of already
- 49:13made by me. Anyway. It just you know, I don't I don't
- 49:16want to be the guy who gets the book canceled twelve issues in and people
- 49:20go, oh, well it was all Dan, you know, so how
- 49:24many issues? Then when you're when you were finished, is it twelve?
- 49:27I did? I did nine? All? I did nine all together.
- 49:31Josie Campbell, Oh God, please God, please let it be Josie Campbell
- 49:35that I just said my name. God Please, he's taking it over from
- 49:37here. He's gotta let it be. Let it let that be the right
- 49:42name. You know what. I We're gonna look right now, We're gonna
- 49:45look live on the air as to who wrote the Shazam that came out last
- 49:52week. Uh, and if any of your readers can join in here and
- 49:55help me and save my ass, that's a oh my god, while you're
- 50:01while you're looking it up, I want to acknowledge Salkowitz and Rob. We
- 50:06assure you we did. Uh. We did mention the Forbes article, which
- 50:09was fantastic coming in like catching up, great conversation. Rob, We're due
- 50:14for a new talk and I'm glad you're watching, so thank you, and
- 50:16I'm glad you're out there because you always have a great, honest, critical
- 50:22eye on the entire nerd sphere. So and I can and I applaud you
- 50:28for going to roy and even and again because I want to hear Royd's side
- 50:32of the story. So I mean that is that is you're doing the right
- 50:36thing, and yes it is Josie Campbell, thank god hoof. But all
- 50:40that is back to Rob for just a second. Yeah, you're wrong on
- 50:44NFTs, but other than that, you've gone exemplary in your reporting on comics
- 50:50and it's valued. Rewinding back Gamp a little bit, Josie Campbell takes over
- 50:54Shazam with a your ten just came out last week. Really good, really
- 50:59fun, thoroughly enjoy what she's doing. That's that's fantastic to hear. Uh
- 51:07Salabanati joining us a representative of Alex Ross. Thank you Mark for your amazing
- 51:12contribution to our Kingdom Come documentary. Can't wait to see it everybody. Also,
- 51:16thank you John for your magnetum of the interview. Oh that means a
- 51:20lot. Yeah, I'm a talking head on that thing too. That your
- 51:22Oh seriously like Alex and Sale are incredibly kind to me when it comes to
- 51:29access to Alex and then Sinkevitch and others that Sal represents. So all,
- 51:35that's great. Man's screening coming in. Wow, I'll be looking for my
- 51:39invite. I awsome wait to see it. Great, that's fantastic. Oh
- 51:45man, No, I'm very very excited for those of you who are those
- 51:47who are listening and not watching. Sala just announced that they're going to premi
- 51:52it. They hope to premiere the Alex Ross Documented the Kingdomcome documentary at San
- 51:55Diego this year. Absolutely, yes, thank you for covering. I asked
- 52:00with No, that's that's amazing. Let's see here. Mike Jones to Marvel
- 52:07the seventies early eighties was rife with writer editors. Very true, very very
- 52:10true in the nineties, right, And you know what, if you're a
- 52:15writer editor, I'll give you that too. If you wrote the story,
- 52:20I'll give it to you. There you go. Yeah, so people are
- 52:24excited for the Kingdom Come documentary and all. That's good to hear, man,
- 52:28because I don't know if I'm doing so that's that's wonderful to hear.
- 52:32Yeah. No, I'm very excited for this. I want to ask you
- 52:36while we got tons and everybody's please jump in if you've got questions about other
- 52:39things that Marcus currently writing, or greatest hits or whatever. But you know,
- 52:45fifty two, I really think that was such a significant story. And
- 52:51you know, you Jeff Grant and Greg all working in concert, I mean,
- 52:58you know that that was such a good Lord. It was such an
- 53:00epic story. And they've tried to do other weekly stories since, but there
- 53:06really was something about it being I guess, I mean, at least first
- 53:08in my perspective, I can't think of anything that was like that. Nothing,
- 53:14well, the continuing Superman story that the Superman group were doing during and
- 53:21post doomsday, so there was that the difference just being that this was in
- 53:28envision to be a story with a concrete beginning, middle, and end.
- 53:31And boy, what a left turn you took here, John, But that's
- 53:36okay, it's screech fifty two. That's okay, I'll talk about it.
- 53:43But yeah, it's the missing I tell you the missing ingredient here. And
- 53:47this is to cast zero expersions on any editors who worked following Steve on this
- 53:53book or any or any of the other Weekly books. But Steve Whacker was
- 53:59our editor on that book, and that was the secret sauce Man, because
- 54:02you get four of us in a room and we all have ideas and we're
- 54:06all jamming well together. I mean that, Thank god, there was no
- 54:09ego in that room at all, which was so pleasant, made everybody open
- 54:14and very eager to throw out ideas. And Keith Gibbon was there, and
- 54:17you know, and Jaj Jones was there throwing in every once in a while.
- 54:23But what made that room work and what made that book work, is
- 54:27that Steve comes from improv. That is his background, improv comedy. And
- 54:31what is the rule of improv, John, It is yes, and it
- 54:37is yes, and what comes next? Yes and yes those two no,
- 54:43which is a screeching halt, and nobody in that room ever said no.
- 54:47It was just you know, yes, and you run the idea out until
- 54:51it either it becomes brilliant or it flames out, and then you move on
- 54:53to something else. But that was the magic that Steve brought to the room,
- 54:58that tied it all together. Understood. No, that's great, and
- 55:04I know Siglayn obviously took over. Yeah, ins between did did a great
- 55:08job's it was a thankless job. He did a Steve set the tone fair
- 55:14enough. That's cool, you know. I know that, and it's driving
- 55:17me nuts. Uh. He's been working with Hickman and Company on Hickman's whole
- 55:22sci fi universe that he created at Substack and everything. And yeah, I
- 55:25haven't end I haven't at Steve on for a long time. And it's like,
- 55:29dude, please come back. Oh yeah, I talked to him.
- 55:32I will, I will remind him that he needs to come back on.
- 55:35Well, thanks, brother, No, I I appreciate that. Oh,
- 55:37Alex Sanchez, all right, let's talk about something new. Yeah, how
- 55:39did Absolute Power come about? Your new your new event? There you go.
- 55:44We can talk about this because we've already anounced it in previews and stuff.
- 55:46Speaking of things that Dan was going to move on to do other than
- 55:50Shazam, that would be this, And the idea was sort of the basic
- 55:57idea was just stated by oh uh oh, the basic idea was just dated
- 56:01by DC editorial. Uh oh, Yes, I guess, I guess.
- 56:05I know who gets credit now, creators yesterday. I hope my co creators
- 56:08on this book. You know, it just it would bounce back and forth.
- 56:15Ships at Arsky had been tinkering with it, and a bunch of other
- 56:21DC writers, everybody who you know, Tom Taylor, Tom King, everybody
- 56:25you know, Scott Snyder, everybody had sort of taken a shot at this
- 56:29thing and couldn't wrestle it to the ground for whatever reason. And I'm not
- 56:34saying that I'm Hercules when they aren't wrestling the line to the ground, and
- 56:37they aren't. What I'm saying is they they solve so many problems for me
- 56:43that by the time I got to this story, I was able to,
- 56:47I think, wrestle it to the ground and make something of it with that.
- 56:51And you know, the basic idea is Amanda Waller wins. Amanda Waller
- 56:58who has been out to get rid of superheroes for a long time. She
- 57:02finally wins, taking all their powers, taking all their resources taken off.
- 57:07She knows their secret identity, she knows everything. She has every bit of
- 57:10leverage to hold over them. And that's where our story begins. And then
- 57:15it is a story of Okay, well what happens now? What are heroes
- 57:21in the DC universe if you don't have heat, vision and super strength?
- 57:23What is the reaction of the man on the street to the idea that,
- 57:28yes, you know Superman is not around, which is terrible. On the
- 57:30other hand, you know, super Villain's finding out my neighborhood does not make
- 57:34my house collapse. So this is an issue too. You know, there's
- 57:37there's a lot of philosophical stuff we can build out of here. I don't
- 57:42want to give any more than that away, but I will say it's four
- 57:45issues for thirty page issues. Dan is just doing astounding work. It is
- 57:51a cast of characters rifling anything George Pear has ever drew. God saved Dan,
- 57:59and Dan is up to the task. And adding, here's the thing
- 58:02with that it is in common with George, which is that I will ask
- 58:06for fifteen people on this page, and I will get you because he just
- 58:10likes drawing catwoman or whatever. Like I haven't drawn Mento. Let's put Mento
- 58:15in here. You're awesome, great, love that about Dan. That's amazing.
- 58:21Man, When does it start? I want to say June. Let's
- 58:24say June. Okay, all right, there you go. Another guy.
- 58:29I got to get out, Dan Moore. And I know I've said that
- 58:30before as well, But there's a guy that you can help me connect with
- 58:34best. I mean, he's a he's and I know how this clearly.
- 58:37I yeah, because he's got a Kirby's stack of assignments that he has to
- 58:42do every month. At all he does is deliver. So that's that's amazing.
- 58:46He's a machine, this guy, what you know, that's and that's
- 58:50great. And I know we've been building towards h Waller and and having this
- 58:54this status quo moment. God, well, you know I I've giving it
- 59:00up to Ostranders so many times for creating her. And it's such a it's
- 59:04such a wonderful character. And I remember that fantastic Suicide Squad cover in the
- 59:08eighties where just like the Governor of Arizona, scolding Obama and stuff Amanda Waller
- 59:15right in Batman's face and just you know whatever, and it's like, yeah,
- 59:20man, don't mess with Amanda Walla. She you know. One of
- 59:25the things that everybody's been amenable to about this book is it's it's me writing
- 59:30the main book and some of the other side stuff, but you know,
- 59:31other writers obviously coming in and doing you know, a tie in here,
- 59:36a tie in there, and we're all on the same page about we were
- 59:40working hard to make Amanda not a mustache twirling villain. That's the easiest thing
- 59:45to do is to make is to make her just you know, absolutely or
- 59:49whatever. It's it's more interesting too. I have a line in one of
- 59:55the issues where some other villain says, okay, well, you know,
- 1:00:00we've you know, we've got the hero sho. We start targeting their their
- 1:00:02loved ones and their friends to keep them in line, and a man that
- 1:00:06says, those are those are people, those are civilians. We those are
- 1:00:10the people. We are trying to protect them on a sociopath and that that's
- 1:00:16really what we're trying to get out of Amanda is that it's not completely black
- 1:00:22and white with her, and that she's just a very definite vision of what
- 1:00:25a world with that superheroes would look like. But it doesn't mean she wants
- 1:00:30to be a super villain. I'm with you, No, I get it.
- 1:00:37I that's that's amazing. Now this is funny because I'm actually talking to
- 1:00:40Brian Hitch on Friday, but ASTON wanted to know if they're an update on
- 1:00:45Last Days of Lex Luthor coming along, coming up? Fair enough? I
- 1:00:51know I soon, I swear to God soon, you know. Yeah,
- 1:00:59yeah, and again I mean I you know, and I know, I
- 1:01:00know Hitches in the midst of Ghost Machine with uh with Jeff and what Jeff's
- 1:01:06going and everything. So yeah, he with the exception of a couple of
- 1:01:08weeks on a couple of panels, he's done. He's been done for a
- 1:01:10while, okay, And that's what I was wondering, and I said,
- 1:01:14right there, So Kevin Nolan has pages and he's he's chunking away and our
- 1:01:17call working on the second issue. Yeah, I mean we will not.
- 1:01:22We will certainly not see the delay between two and three that we've seen between
- 1:01:24one and two. It is to you know, boom, boom boom,
- 1:01:28get him out. We may even reprint issue one, you know, the
- 1:01:30month before, just to ramp up in them. I don't know, wouldn't
- 1:01:35hurt. Absolutely wouldn't hurt. Let's see. Uh, and who's editing the
- 1:01:38Absolute Power? Uh? That is sorry? Yep, drink swallow you can.
- 1:01:46I know I'm drinking. I cavra. I know. I know I'm
- 1:01:52bluffing because I've I'm freezing on Andrew's name. Oh my god, I'm just
- 1:01:58as horrible. I'm sorry. I don't mean to put you into bed,
- 1:02:01but boy, did you put me on a spot. Son of them?
- 1:02:05Got it? Mark, I'm telling you, I'm I'm I blank on names.
- 1:02:08I can't tell you how many times doing interviews it's like, uh,
- 1:02:13so I hear it. I'm just I'm so Andrew Marino. Oh great,
- 1:02:17Andrew. I'm really sorry. Andrew. I know your name and I know
- 1:02:22who you are, and I'm sorry, but if you remember the Legion Superheroes,
- 1:02:23I would remember your name instantly. Uh. And Mike, I agree
- 1:02:28with your real person. I'm gonna forget that, so go ahead. John,
- 1:02:30I'm sorry I was gonna say, uh, I agree with Mike Jones.
- 1:02:35Amanda's characterization in Justice League Unlimited had a great take on Waller. It
- 1:02:39sounds like Marcus writing a similar van. Yeah. C. C. Pounder
- 1:02:43a wonderful character actor, was a fantastic Waller and really brought the right voice.
- 1:02:49Not that Pam Greer wasn't great on Smallville as a version of Amanda Waller
- 1:02:54as well. We've been very lucky with our Amanda Waller. So right now,
- 1:02:59I'm blank, and I was it Viola Davis that yeah, was in
- 1:03:02the Snyder verse, says Waller and everything and the Peacemaker Show, yeah yeah,
- 1:03:07yeah, and of course on the Peacemaker Show, yeah yeah, yeah,
- 1:03:09very excited man. All right, and bred All is on Facebook giving
- 1:03:14us like all the uh, I guess probably what's in previous in terms of
- 1:03:19where the absolute power is going to be reflected. So yeah, Green Air
- 1:03:22thirteen, Suicides, Squad, Dream Team four, Superman fifteen, Superman fifteen
- 1:03:29leads directly into this summer's absolute power, and there's a countdown to absolute power
- 1:03:35as well coming, so it tie ins. Yeah, this is actually that's
- 1:03:39okay, good to know. Thanks how much? How much in concert?
- 1:03:45You know, because I'm glad you mentioned everybody by the way, right now,
- 1:03:49and I've said this before and I mean this. I think both companies
- 1:03:52are really well represented with the writers and artists they have. But given that
- 1:03:54you your home right now is DC. Yeah, it is so great to
- 1:04:00to really see everybody firing and and really you know, giving us really great
- 1:04:03stories and everything. I think it's a great time right now. As far
- 1:04:06as refer reader, I'm having a blast. I'm having a blast going through
- 1:04:10my cops every month, I really am. You know who you know whose
- 1:04:13books I really love is my editor Andrew Marino. He's such a good guy.
- 1:04:16This is every every It's like every episode you're gonna you're gonna stump the
- 1:04:23band once per episode by making me name somebody who I should know, like
- 1:04:27the back of my hand. Animal we know whereas I can tell you all
- 1:04:31of Crypto's ancestors by name. And again, this is why I love you.
- 1:04:34That's fantastic. You know. I was having on Mark l Aming the
- 1:04:38other day, labing pardon me, yeah, and I was asking him,
- 1:04:43uh, you know about something, you know, dream things that he'd want
- 1:04:45to do, and he's like, I would kill to do a Savage Land
- 1:04:48Marvel story. And he goes, They're just like, you know, the
- 1:04:53numbers aren't there to justify it. And of course I remember your fantastic case
- 1:04:57our story that you did with one of the c her brothers out and Andy.
- 1:05:02Yeah, cool, so good, I mean, and Andy just brought
- 1:05:06the heat that came from Andy and and and he says, you know,
- 1:05:11he left. Captain America's like, what do we want to do next?
- 1:05:14He says, why don't we do Ksar? And I'm like, that is
- 1:05:16the stupidest idea I've ever heard, because Kazer doesn't sell. And I have
- 1:05:20no empathy for Kazar whatsoever, because I am Fraser Cream. I am the
- 1:05:25guy who does his chair off before he sits down. And this is the
- 1:05:28guy who swings in the junk. There's a loin cloth. This is not
- 1:05:30my world. But we sat down, we talked about it. I found
- 1:05:33some things that I could key into, and we ended up making a book
- 1:05:40that was really fun. It was really fun and it's still in trade paperback.
- 1:05:44I encourage people have there to go grab it it. Love you,
- 1:05:47Yeah, it is gorgeous. And again this is what I love about you.
- 1:05:51Mark. You really I remember when you and Rucca were doing that Spider
- 1:05:56Man Punisher Daredevil story and You're like, I I don't know how to get
- 1:06:00into the Punisher. And you know, whether it was conversations with Greg or
- 1:06:03whatever, you guys found a way and it was a hell of a story.
- 1:06:06And I think that's that's amazing. I you know, it's weird,
- 1:06:11and I want your coming on this real fast because I know where we're up
- 1:06:14against time. I I think Frank Castle might be the very first character to
- 1:06:21be to suffer cancel culture. And I understand the timing of it, right,
- 1:06:27and I understand what happened. And in fact, I just had David
- 1:06:30Peppos on to talk about the new Punisher that Marvel's created. But then I
- 1:06:33read that Born Again is going to have Frank Castle in it the Netflix via
- 1:06:40One Step Forward, One Step back. Okay, that's and yeah, I
- 1:06:44just you know, yeah, any any thought because my thing is, and
- 1:06:46I always say this, it's like they're fictional characters. I mean, the
- 1:06:50Punisher should be scary. I do understand that it's not great when the character's
- 1:06:57symbolism is co opted by that's the issue as much as anything else. That
- 1:07:01and and basically, you know, there's a difference between web shooters and in
- 1:07:08sixteen's you know, and and and the culture of gun violence has gotten so
- 1:07:13horrific in this country that you know, I can't speak for Marvel. I
- 1:07:15can that I can speak to conversations I've had in rooms. You know,
- 1:07:20maybe this is not the best foot forward for us at this time? Is
- 1:07:24it to to make everything about who can shoot the most bullets the fastest.
- 1:07:30But also, and you hit upon this, is that that puncture symbol is
- 1:07:33co opted by some truly, truly dreadful groups of people and in enormous numbers.
- 1:07:42Not the kind of thing you can ignore, you know. And if
- 1:07:45if Superman's emblem became became the standard emblem of the neo Nazis tomorrow, then
- 1:07:49I don't know what DC would do, but they'd have to do something you
- 1:07:54know, understood, understood. Back to the Kasar thing. Is there that
- 1:07:59kind of year D level character that if DC or Marvel were like, hey,
- 1:08:04whatever you want to do, Marcus fire with us? Is you know?
- 1:08:08Yeah? Is there? You know? As I think the last time
- 1:08:11we talked, I was telling you Ultra of the multi Alien was in my
- 1:08:15brain of of late and stuff. So yeah, there's some character on that
- 1:08:18level I got. I mean I think that, uh, I think that
- 1:08:25Metamorpho is clearly on that list. All the Metamorpho jokes I make. I
- 1:08:30think there's something there. I think that there's something to a lot of these
- 1:08:33characters that it just again, it's fun to spelunk. I've got to I've
- 1:08:36got a wish list. When I first started the World's Finest with Dan,
- 1:08:41I just sat down and went through all the who's who's and went throw my
- 1:08:43comics and just made a giant list of here's the people I want to see
- 1:08:45in this book at some point or another understood, understood, that's uh.
- 1:08:51I'm looking at the chat here to see if there's anything else real fast,
- 1:08:55because we're at our hour and we should go. Yeah, it's fine,
- 1:08:58steel steel door, not gonna shut or anything. All right, well you
- 1:09:00know whatever I mean. You know, it's smart, it's not going to
- 1:09:03be boom and boom, and it's yeah, we can we can. We
- 1:09:08can write it out naturally. If there's anybody else who has anything in the
- 1:09:11comments that could be addressed, If not, well God bless you, Cliff,
- 1:09:15thank you. Yeah there you go. Man. No, somebody given
- 1:09:17Mark props and Dan for a World Finals. Absolutely, so that's cool.
- 1:09:23Speed see is in I assume AUSTRALIAATA mates. Absolutely, hey recognize the arcade.
- 1:09:29I don't know what else you would call it, but he goes,
- 1:09:30cancel uter really what it comms remarked, well, I don't know what else
- 1:09:33you would call it, but that is I am. I am labeling that.
- 1:09:36And again, as we were just discussing, I understand the thing,
- 1:09:41and and I just find it interesting. That is not my judgment either way
- 1:09:45on Marvel making that choice. I just think it's interesting, you know,
- 1:09:49for what it's worth. You can't say this, but I'll say this.
- 1:09:51John is a stand up guy who is you know, dying the world,
- 1:09:57liberal guy with it, you know, who is not the kind of person
- 1:10:01to bitch about cancel culture doing this or that or whatever. We were using
- 1:10:05it in a different context, in a context that was actually pretty accurate.
- 1:10:11I mean, yes, in terms of what people perceive cancel culture to be.
- 1:10:16Yeah, then The Punisher was probably the first kind of book victim of
- 1:10:20that. Yes, But again, neither you nor I would ever use that
- 1:10:24term called cancel culture because it's it's crap. It doesn't really mean anything.
- 1:10:29No, although people are victims of that, of you know, that condition.
- 1:10:34I mean, good, look you know, got Trina Robbins past and
- 1:10:39I'm so holy smokes, did she your kidding me? It's just breaking news
- 1:10:45on social media. I already saw the tributes coming out and we were all
- 1:10:48heartbroken. She had she suffered that stroke. The last I had heard,
- 1:10:53she was still not able to speak, but was doing better, but you
- 1:10:58know up there, so I got to hope. If I'm incorrect, I
- 1:11:00apologize everybody, but I was shocked to see that news. Let's let's let's
- 1:11:06pull one out for Trina. I mean, she was a pioneer in underground
- 1:11:11comics. She was an exemplary artist, she was a terrific writer. She
- 1:11:16was a trailblazer for women in comics in the seventies, and her love for
- 1:11:21comics and her understanding of the history of women in comics, in particular female
- 1:11:28characters and female creators, is unrivaled. I mean, I can't I can't
- 1:11:31touch that. You know, she knows stuff that I've never heard, a
- 1:11:35new stuff that I've ever heard, and she and I had some delightful conversations
- 1:11:39about that, and it was always a joy to speak to her because I
- 1:11:42always learned something. So I agree, man, Yeah, I I never
- 1:11:46had her on the show, but I would see her in lobbies and you
- 1:11:50know, after hours at CODs, her aunt Steve Lailo or her wonderful partner,
- 1:11:55and that God, my heart goes out to Steve too, because one
- 1:11:58of the nicest people in comics agree. They were incredible. I think Salcowitz's
- 1:12:01confirming and he said, that's why I was late to the church. So
- 1:12:04yeah, that's that's rough. Conventions for you coming up. I know I'll
- 1:12:09see it terrific on in August. She means rific on in August. Going
- 1:12:13to uh if you're going to be in the neighborhood of Stockholm, Sweden at
- 1:12:16the end of this month, if you're dropping by, I'll be at a
- 1:12:19show there. Great month, my first time in Stockholm. Going to be
- 1:12:25a lot of fun. Got Oklahoma City coming up in May. You know
- 1:12:30what we're gonna go. Let's look at the calendar. Shall we look at
- 1:12:32the calendar? Why not look at the cant We've got Stockholm at the end
- 1:12:36of this month, we have we have Oklahoma City at the end of May.
- 1:12:42We have Hershey, Pennsylvania at the end of June. Okay, we
- 1:12:48have San Diego at the end of July. Obviously we have terrific on in
- 1:12:53August. We got Baltimore in September and then and then I get to rest
- 1:13:00for a couple of months. But yes, I'll be here. Yeah.
- 1:13:04Well, and I'm glad Europe is getting a taste of mark Way. That's
- 1:13:08fantastic, so to speak. Yes, I love it man, Well,
- 1:13:12dude, yes, always you're You're generous with your time. You know.
- 1:13:14I love just talking comic bs. I mean, yeah, you know,
- 1:13:17we always pumped the product and rightfully so, and that's good. But no,
- 1:13:21it's uh, it's it's when we do our uber nerd conversations that I
- 1:13:25get excited for and we talk about Crypto and the other What was the name
- 1:13:30of the super dog group that Crypto didn't he lead a group of the face
- 1:13:33canine patrol agents. You've been I know, shame, I know, man,
- 1:13:38I'm letting you down. You are the chess master, sir, I
- 1:13:41am but a student. You know what. I just said that to my
- 1:13:45buddy Rob Burnette, who's like that with Star Trek and everything. It's like,
- 1:13:47no, no, no, I'm the student, You're the master and
- 1:13:49everything. So that's great, man, I good lord, Well, thank
- 1:13:54you thank you for indulging me in this Wolverine conversation. My pleasure, and
- 1:13:59I'm gonna go off and now and do some work for my fabulous editor Andrew
- 1:14:01Marino, and I will talk to you soon. Brother sounds great, man
- 1:14:08Mark, Wait, everybody, thank you. We might do an a comics
- 1:14:12podcast tomorrow with artin Franco. I'm hoping trying to gather the boys together for
- 1:14:15a new chat, and then Friday afternoon talking to Hitch Brian Hitch. We're
- 1:14:21doing that midday to accommodate his UK schedule and everything. But yeah, look
- 1:14:27for a time and specifics Friday afternoon, and I hope everybody can join us.
- 1:14:32Great crowd, great conversation from everybody. Thank you very much. Until
- 1:14:36next time, Stay safe, stay happy, stay healthy,