Latest / Thacher Report / Purge Progressives - identity politics don't work
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, this is Zachary Thatcher from the Thatcher Report. It's been such a long time.
- 0:05I know you're probably sick of hearing podcasts that start that way,
- 0:09but I'm glad you're back to listen to my latest essay.
- 0:12So this is from Processing the Events of Last Night, which was the election,
- 0:18which apparently Trump won the Electoral College and the popular vote.
- 0:22So for me, pretty shocking. For others, they were anticipating it,
- 0:27but nevertheless, it sucks.
- 0:28So my latest essay, which you can find on my Substack Thatcher report,
- 0:34is called Purge the Progressives, Return to Unity.
- 0:39Looks like identity politics and anti-Semitism don't win elections.
- 0:43There's a lot to say and feel and emote after last night's popular and electoral
- 0:47election of Donald Trump in the U.S.
- 0:49And Bibi Netanyahu's firing of the defense minister during a seven-front war,
- 0:54apparently in part to protect ultra-religious Israelis for serving in the army that protects them.
- 0:58This is referring to the Haredim in Israel who don't have to go to the military,
- 1:03but get a lot of welfare support for their schools and housing and more.
- 1:07So it really feels, to me at least, like democracy is committing seppuku.
- 1:11I mention that because I just finished watching the Shogun miniseries a little
- 1:14late in the game. Ritual sacrifice is on the mind.
- 1:18So yeah, it's bleak. There's a lot to process.
- 1:21But the one thought I want to share is about the Democratic Party hopefully
- 1:24course correcting, because I think they've driven us headlong into a wall. Twice.
- 1:29I'd like to actually get somewhere next time instead of a smashed forehead.
- 1:34Here's the thing where I think I'm in the minority of the party at large.
- 1:37The combination of identity politics and toxic anti-Semitism,
- 1:42which is cloaked as social justice, aren't a great combination.
- 1:45Certainly not if you want to be a moral person and win elections.
- 1:49Can we have both, please?
- 1:50So let me say it clearly. As a Jew, and as I always thought I was a liberal,
- 1:55I'm certainly an American.
- 1:56I sincerely, deeply, profoundly believe that all people are created equal.
- 2:02In the terms of Jews, we believe that all humans are literally made in the image of God.
- 2:06What we mean by this isn't anything anthropomorphic. To paraphrase Maimonides,
- 2:12biblical language that attributes God with human characteristics or features
- 2:15is simply low-level, sub-intellectual methods to enable us as people to begin
- 2:21to sort of barely approach kind of an understanding of the supreme majesty and transcendence of God.
- 2:27That's not literal. What is literal is free will.
- 2:31Humans are enabled with the ability to destroy or to build.
- 2:34We can conduct grievous crimes, or we can support someone in need who can never repay us back.
- 2:40Where this theological reasoning gets you to, once Christian European culture
- 2:44caught up to it a few thousand years later, is the Enlightenment,
- 2:47then nationalism, and citizenship.
- 2:49We're all equal. Equal vote, equal rights, equal participation.
- 2:54The simplicity of this observation, I think, is beautiful.
- 2:58Unfortunately, it's not happening anymore in mainstream liberal culture.
- 3:02There's a deification in modern progressivism that says, oh,
- 3:06wow, person X is running for office, and they are, insert, fetishized group
- 3:09of the moment, and can string a few sentences together so they have my vote.
- 3:14I think that needs to end. It's just bigoted thinking.
- 3:17Person X is more deserving than person Y due to some measurable genetic attribute,
- 3:22be it their melanin content, gender, sexuality, physical ability,
- 3:26or whatever else is going on with them since birth. That is not a good way to think about people.
- 3:31And let me just take a step back in case you think I'm being naive.
- 3:35I think it's important and necessary to right the wrongs of slavery,
- 3:40sexism, antisemitism, homophobia, to name just a handful of flaws in this country.
- 3:45But if by righting those wrongs, you seek to elevate a person or group at the
- 3:49expense of another group, you've just painted yourself into a moral corner.
- 3:53Who says that anyone should have more advantage than anyone else?
- 3:57Sure, proportionately, most black people are poorer, less educated,
- 4:01and further from housing and healthcare resources than most white people.
- 4:05So that's just an observation that's true. And I think it's wrong.
- 4:09But if you attempt to right this by disadvantaging some other white people,
- 4:13then you're draining the tub, not raising the tide.
- 4:16I think there is a way to improve opportunities for people that doesn't involve
- 4:22grievance Olympics or impossible to solve equations of privilege which pit people against each other.
- 4:27On a deeply human level, from my perspective, it's very obviously wrong to say,
- 4:34you don't get food if you're hungry because someone else who doesn't look like
- 4:37you is also hungry. Let's feed both.
- 4:40The Democratic Party and essential, key, vital academic and media institutions
- 4:45seem to have rejected this basic human moral insight for many decades now.
- 4:51And I'm as guilty as the next liberal for promulgating this for all that time.
- 4:55I believed in affirmative action.
- 4:57I believed in diversity efforts to make college campuses and boardrooms more
- 5:01reflective of our country's population.
- 5:03I wandered around the West Village of Manhattan in a reverie on the afternoon
- 5:07of November 5th, 2016, after having voted for a woman to be president.
- 5:12I enjoyed that feeling of awe for standing on the precipice of a changed nation
- 5:16that just had a two-term Black president and soon a two-term,
- 5:19hopefully, woman in charge.
- 5:21To me, those are all good feelings and just outcomes, but many of the methods
- 5:26for achieving them seem wrong.
- 5:28Obviously, the two women selected by a very small group of Democratic Party
- 5:32insiders was the wrong choice. They didn't win.
- 5:36Obviously, making young straight men feel like they're on the wrong side of
- 5:40history simply for having been born the way they are isn't a great way to win popular elections.
- 5:46Okay, hold on. It's going to get worse. What's clear to me is that a racial,
- 5:51gender, and sexuality preferential checklist with winners and losers,
- 5:56it's clear to me that this inherently enables anti-Semitism to flourish. Let me be blunt.
- 6:02Genetic favoritism is inherently anti-Semitic. This is a very, very,
- 6:08very old Jewish observation of society stretching way back to the beginning
- 6:13in pharaonic times of slavery in Egypt, and certainly in ancient Persia for our Purim holiday.
- 6:18We have literally observed this dynamic of favoritism not working out well for
- 6:24us in every phase of human history that we've been participants in.
- 6:28When you punish one group of people based on a condition of their birth,
- 6:32like women in the book of Esther, soon you will punish another minority group.
- 6:36It's a when, not an if.
- 6:39Jews are the internal scapegoats, always and forever. This does not make us
- 6:45special. It just makes us really smart about the phenomena of blame.
- 6:49We've all seen this most manifest after the fall of 2023 with the Israel-Hamas war.
- 6:56Highly educated Ivy League students and faculty and administrators are not immune
- 7:01to the virus of antisemitism no matter how much they mask in public or preamble their pronouns.
- 7:06It's hopefully clear to my readers that this isn't surprising or a fluke.
- 7:11It's the logical extension of progressive values that teach their followers
- 7:15that some people are better than others, that people are inherently unequal
- 7:19and will teach you which ones we like more than others.
- 7:22For example, settlers are bad, indigenous people are good.
- 7:27Well, who counts as a settler and who counts as an indigenous person is kind of vague.
- 7:34These progressives will helpfully point it out to you. So folks,
- 7:38that's about as scientific as phrenology, which was part and parcel of Nazism.
- 7:43Seems like I'm overstating my case, doesn't it? Well, how many times have you
- 7:47heard someone white, male, and straight apologize for having a perspective?
- 7:51This sheepishness seems so minor, and it really is in many ways,
- 7:55but it's indicative of the larger system of selection privilege.
- 7:59This never goes well for vulnerable minorities, no matter how much money and
- 8:03power you think they have.
- 8:05That can all go away. Money is imaginary and can be erased. Same with power.
- 8:10But the sheer dynamics of population is ineluctable.
- 8:13There are more Black people in this country than Jews.
- 8:16If progressives say they value Black people more than other people and form
- 8:20coalitions led by writers like Ta-Nehisi Coates and politicians like AOC,
- 8:24than Jews by their very numbers, they're goners.
- 8:28And just hold on a second, I'm not saying we're in a race war of Blacks versus
- 8:32Jews or any other group, nothing like that.
- 8:35I'm simply observing the coalition dynamics that we're seeing on college campuses
- 8:39and on election booths and some of our cultural institutions.
- 8:42This is how it really goes. Jews small, others big, big smash small.
- 8:49We've lost another crushing election to an odious, malignant person who is also
- 8:54an identitarian, but from a progressive perspective, for the wrong side.
- 8:59His value of identity isn't the problem, their logic goes, it's just that he's
- 9:03the bad guy in our comic book story of the world.
- 9:06What I'm saying is that there are no sides to identity that leveled up to prosperity or morality.
- 9:11It's garbage thinking, which I can prove to you.
- 9:15For at least 4,000 years of political philosophy he has enshrined in Jewish
- 9:18wisdom that all people are equal under God.
- 9:21And if you don't believe or feel or wrestle with God, my point still stands.
- 9:26It's the people and how we treat each other that matters.
- 9:30God doesn't need us. People need us.
- 9:33I'm praying that the Democratic Party purges the progressive element that has
- 9:37become so twisted by selective preferences that just the other week,
- 9:41Barnard College and Ivy League School featured a speaker that our own State
- 9:45Department calls an anti-Semite.
- 9:47Why is an Ivy League college promoting an anti-Semite? It's really, really scary.
- 9:53And just to go there for a second, a little bit longer, remember the pro-Palestine
- 9:57movement is not pro-peace.
- 10:00It is not pro-human rights.
- 10:02It's simply for one group to destroy another group.
- 10:05They have one group that they say are settlers, another group they say are indigenous,
- 10:09and it's clear as day for them.
- 10:11If you're with the former, great, you win.
- 10:13If you're with the latter, you better fight real hard to keep breathing.
- 10:17What you get from this framework, what you get from this comic book conception
- 10:22of the world, what you get is war.
- 10:24I think that's where progressive values ultimately lead to, with anti-Semitism
- 10:29merely a rung in the ladder to the depths of human grievance.
- 10:33I'll take a walk instead.
- 10:35Listen, I want to win the next election, by a lot.
- 10:39Republicans have given us a gift by showing us how. Let's not squander it.
- 10:43Thank you so much for listening.
- 10:45Really appreciate your time. Feel free to follow me on Substack and reach out
- 10:51to me anytime on social media. Thank you.