Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts & Bolts of CEQA (California Environmental Quality Act) and Recent Executive Orders
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to today's program, Nuts and Bolts of
- 0:09CEQA, California Environmental Quality Act, and
- 0:12recent executive orders. I'm Alla Policastro,
- 0:16CLE advisor of the Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 0:18and I'm delighted to introduce this afternoon's
- 0:21speaker, Steve Valivas. Steve is a well -respected
- 0:25land use and environmental law attorney with
- 0:27over 24 years of expertise, advising and representing
- 0:31public agency and private clients in administrative
- 0:34proceedings and before state and federal trial
- 0:36and appellate courts. Steve has extensive advisory
- 0:39and litigation experience with and works daily
- 0:42on projects addressing complex legal issues spanning
- 0:45the California Environmental Quality Act, the
- 0:49National Environmental Policy Act, and the Federal
- 0:52Powers Act, and the California Coastal Act, as
- 0:54well as the state and federal legal and regulatory
- 0:57frameworks governing clean water, clean air,
- 1:00endangered species, and electricity generation
- 1:03and transmission. He's a frequent speaker and
- 1:06author on issues related to land use and planning
- 1:08and especially CEQA. Steve, we can't wait to
- 1:11hear what you have to share with us today. Thank
- 1:14you so much, Alec. Can you hear me? Excellent.
- 1:19My screen is PowerPoint's visible. Correct. Okay,
- 1:23great. Thank you. Welcome everyone. I really
- 1:25appreciate you joining today. Nicely introduced.
- 1:33We're here to give a nuts and bolts. An introduction
- 1:36101 into SQL, but there's a lot to cover even
- 1:41in the introduction or nuts and bolts discussion
- 1:44we're going to be having. So I think we should
- 1:46just get right into it. Just a little bit briefly
- 1:51about myself. I grew up and went to high school
- 1:56and college in Ohio, and then I got the heck
- 1:58out of Ohio. And after a couple of years of working
- 2:02for some federal natural resource agencies in
- 2:06the Rocky Mountain region, and also doing a fair
- 2:08amount of skiing, I went to Vermont law school
- 2:12to study, specifically study environmental law.
- 2:15and then made my way back out to California after
- 2:19also passing the bar in Colorado. I've worked
- 2:24for a number of different organizations and firms,
- 2:28including a non -profit environmental organization,
- 2:32small law firm, a mid -size private law firm,
- 2:38as well as now, since 2011, I joined Burke, Williams,
- 2:42and Sorensen. As you can see here, I'm part of
- 2:44numerous practice groups, but I really enjoy
- 2:49working at Burke because I get to work both for
- 2:52public clients, we have many city, county, and
- 2:55special district clients, but also private side
- 2:58as well. With that background, I literally have
- 3:02been on what I call all three sides of the SQL
- 3:05coin, and we'll get into that a little more.
- 3:08I'm going to move forward here. Just a little
- 3:11brief agenda for our discussion today. I'm going
- 3:15to give you an overview of CEQA, and then we're
- 3:19going to jump right into the CEQA process and
- 3:23its requirements. As you'll see, I break it down
- 3:26into four critical essential steps of the CEQA
- 3:31process, and they're sequential, and we'll go
- 3:34over that in a minute. I did want to mention,
- 3:37maybe it's in the chat. I really would like to
- 3:40get your questions. We'll save them and I'll
- 3:43address them at the end, but just put them in
- 3:45the Q &A box at the bottom and we'll get to those
- 3:49at the end. But after the SQL process, then we're
- 3:52going to talk a little bit about SQL litigation
- 3:55and judicial review. Then at the request of BHBA,
- 4:04they had asked me to cover and summarize. some
- 4:07of the executive orders that have been issued
- 4:10and pertain to efforts to recover from the LA
- 4:15wildfires. Like I just mentioned, we'll end with
- 4:18some question and answer. Without any further
- 4:23ado, let's get into the SQL overview. I apologize
- 4:28if some of you know this already, but I just
- 4:31wanted to start. I know that this was advertised
- 4:35as an introduction, so I wanted to kind of start
- 4:38from the beginning. So the what, why, who, and
- 4:40where. The what is it's CEQA is the California
- 4:44Environmental Quality Act. It was enacted in
- 4:481970. Following the passage of the National Environmental
- 4:58Policy Act, or NEPA, by the federal government
- 5:01in 1969. Why? Why was CEQA enacted? What are
- 5:07its purposes? You boil it down to really two
- 5:12critical fundamental purposes. The first is to
- 5:14ensure informed decision -making and public participation
- 5:19in that decision -making. I've got the trifecta
- 5:24here, the bold underlined and highlighted. The
- 5:27second purpose is to avoid or reduce environmental
- 5:31impacts whenever feasible to do so. I've emphasized
- 5:36that second purpose because it is the teeth of
- 5:42Sikwa, and quite frankly, it's what sets Sikwa
- 5:45apart from almost all of the other, certainly
- 5:49from NEPA, but there's a number of other states
- 5:52that have similar environmental review or policy
- 5:57acts, but few have the type and the strength
- 6:01of the teeth that CEQA does, which really does
- 6:05require impacts to be reduced, avoided whenever
- 6:10it's feasible to do so. And we'll talk about
- 6:12that a little further as we go forward. So who
- 6:16has to comply with CEQA? burdened by the onerous
- 6:21obligation to comply with it. It applies to almost
- 6:25all public agency decisions to carry out, fund
- 6:30or approve projects that could have an adverse
- 6:34effect or impact on the environment. When I use
- 6:38the word effect or impact, those are interchangeable.
- 6:41They essentially mean the same thing, but it
- 6:44means a substantial adverse change in the physical
- 6:47environment. the where. CEQA itself, the statute,
- 6:53was enacted by the state legislature and amended
- 6:56many times, and these days almost every year,
- 6:59but it's located in the public resources code,
- 7:03sections 2100 at SEC. And there are also extensive
- 7:08regulations which are called the CEQA guidelines,
- 7:13and they're adopted by the California Natural
- 7:16Resources Agency. And those are found in 14 calcode
- 7:21regs section 15 ,000 at sec. OK. So I wanted
- 7:30to continue with the SQL overview. Those of you
- 7:33that are familiar with SQL and practice SQL regularly
- 7:39certainly already know this, but the SQL table
- 7:42is often quite crowded. And this is just a graphic
- 7:45to explain that the main agency that makes the
- 7:49decision and has to comply with SQL, and we'll
- 7:51get into this, is called the lead agency. They
- 7:54have to deal with all of these green boxes or
- 7:58entities that immediately surround them as they
- 8:02process project applications or propose their
- 8:08own projects. And then after approving or denying
- 8:12a project subject to CEQA, if there's a legal
- 8:15challenge, the courts will take over and handle
- 8:22those challenges and decide them afterwards.
- 8:26And so just a little more detail on these parties,
- 8:29who are the CEQA players? Again, the lead agency
- 8:31is defined here in the CEQA guideline sections
- 8:3615050. and 15051. Essentially, it's the agency
- 8:41that has the principal responsibility for carrying
- 8:45out or approving the project. Now, I say carrying
- 8:48out because it applies when an agency, and I
- 8:52oftentimes will revert back to just saying city
- 8:56as the type of agency because I most frequently
- 9:00represent cities. I say carrying out because
- 9:04CEQA applies if a city is proposing its own project,
- 9:08whether it's the construction of a new city hall,
- 9:12the development of a new city park, or anything
- 9:15in between. That's carrying out a project, and
- 9:18CEQA applies there. But it also, and perhaps
- 9:21more frequently, applies when the agency is receiving
- 9:26a request for funding or a permit, and they have
- 9:30to approve a project. And so the lead agency
- 9:33decides how to proceed under CEQA. and it has
- 9:36the ultimate responsibility for complying with
- 9:40CEQA and going through the process. And then
- 9:44as you'll see, the three types of CEQA documents
- 9:49that are possible if a project is not exempt
- 9:53from CEQA is a neg -deck, that's what I refer
- 9:56to here as an ND, a mitigated negative declaration
- 10:00or an MND, or an environmental impact report
- 10:03or an EIR. The lead agency has to consult with
- 10:07responsible and trustee agencies when it's processing
- 10:12an application for a project that requires one
- 10:15of those three documents. So the responsible
- 10:18agency, that's another agency other than the
- 10:21lead agency that also has a discretionary approval
- 10:25power or permit that it has to issue for the
- 10:29project. And that's defined in CEQA guidelines
- 10:3215381. The biggest takeaway here is that a responsible
- 10:38agency has to rely on the lead agency's CEQA
- 10:43document. Like I said before, the lead agency
- 10:47has to consult with the responsible agency. If
- 10:50the responsible agency has a problem with or
- 10:53thinks the CEQA document doesn't comply with
- 10:57the law, it has to tell the city. or sue the
- 11:01lead agency to challenge the document if it thinks
- 11:04it's inadequate for its own purposes. That's
- 11:07pretty rare, but I just wanted to point that
- 11:10out because the lead agency is in the driver's
- 11:13seat and the responsible and trustee agencies
- 11:16have to use that CEQA document. The trustee agency
- 11:20is a state agency that has jurisdiction over
- 11:23natural resources that might be affected by the
- 11:26project. holds those resources in trust for the
- 11:31people of the state of California. Two most common
- 11:34examples of a trustee agency is the California
- 11:36Department of Fish and Wildlife and their role
- 11:40in jurisdiction over the state's waters and wildlife
- 11:44and fish, and then the State Lands Commission
- 11:47and its role in jurisdiction over the bed and
- 11:51banks of waterways and coastal, coastlines in
- 11:56California. Lastly, this is actually rarer than
- 12:02a dispute between the lead agency and responsible
- 12:05agency over the adequacy of a CEQA document,
- 12:08but sometimes there's a dispute over which should
- 12:11be the lead agency. And so the CEQA guidelines
- 12:14address this and cover how to address that in
- 12:1715053. Essentially, it says that the agency that
- 12:21will act first or issue the first discretionary
- 12:24approval will be the lead agency. And if there's
- 12:27still a dispute over who it should be, there's
- 12:30a process for applying to the state office of
- 12:33planning and research and having it decide who
- 12:37the lead agency shall be. Okay, so just rounding
- 12:41out the SQL players, you also have NGOs, non
- 12:45-governmental organizations, nonprofit groups
- 12:48that work independently of a government. to address
- 12:51issues that are near and dear to their heart
- 12:53and their members' hearts. Best example here
- 12:56would be the Sierra Club, who is obviously active
- 12:58in California and participates in comments on
- 13:02many CEQA documents. There are also adjacent
- 13:06affected landowners, and these are people who
- 13:10live or work near sites that are, development
- 13:14projects are proposed. You've probably most certainly
- 13:17heard the term NIMBYs. That's attributed to these
- 13:21types of SQL players who often get involved and
- 13:26raise concerns and oppose development because
- 13:29they don't like changes in their backyard. That's
- 13:33what it stands for, not in my backyard. Increasingly,
- 13:37in response to the state's prolonged housing
- 13:39crisis and the numerous and growing efforts to
- 13:43promote housing, There are also groups called
- 13:46yimbies now who fall under the mantra of yes
- 13:49in my backyard, and they really want housing
- 13:53to proceed quicker and in more locations as soon
- 13:57as possible. Rounding out the political players,
- 14:01you also have business competitors, entities
- 14:04that perhaps are in the same business as the
- 14:07project proponent, and they get involved to primarily,
- 14:10quite frankly, advance and protect their own
- 14:13business. Interestingly, the requirement to analyze
- 14:19a project's potential urban decay impacts grew
- 14:23out of SQL litigation by such groups. One of
- 14:29the most prominent cases there is called Bakersfield
- 14:32Citizens for Local Control versus the city of
- 14:35Bakersfield way back in 2004. smaller city grocery
- 14:42stores were challenging a project that was going
- 14:45to put into Super Walmarts. Super Walmarts are
- 14:48Walmarts that actually have large grocery store
- 14:51sections. They complained about that under using
- 14:54CEQA, and they argued that the Super Walmarts
- 14:58could put them out of business, which would result
- 15:01in the grocery stores closing and staying closed
- 15:05for a long period of time such that they would
- 15:09come and follow the disrepair with graffiti or
- 15:11lack of maintenance, and that would be the environmental
- 15:15impact that needed to be assessed. Under CEQA,
- 15:20economic and social impacts are not pertinent.
- 15:24They aren't part of the CEQA process. But if
- 15:27it would indirectly relate to environmental impacts,
- 15:31like a store closing and then falling into disrepair
- 15:35with graffiti and other deferred maintenance,
- 15:38That's where urban decay became a thing from
- 15:43judicial, judicially created impact that needs
- 15:46to be assessed in CEQA documents. Another example
- 15:49is the Plastic Bag Coalition versus the city
- 15:53of Manhattan Beach in 2011. That was a case that
- 15:56ultimately went to the California Supreme Court.
- 15:58But essentially, plastic bag industry members
- 16:02challenged to sued to challenge the Manhattan
- 16:07Beach's plastic bag ban ordinance. I point these
- 16:12out because business competitors are often CEQA
- 16:17players and CEQA litigators, and that has been
- 16:20deemed to be okay, primarily because CEQA has
- 16:24a low threshold, beneficial interest standing
- 16:28requirement, and allows unincorporated associations.
- 16:33to bring SQL lawsuits. As you can see from the
- 16:38names of those two cases I cited, Save the Plastic
- 16:42Bag Coalition was such an unincorporated association.
- 16:46It wasn't brought by a specific plastic company
- 16:49or plastic bag company, but that's how they can
- 16:53get their nose under the tent and bring and maintain
- 16:57SQL lawsuits. I'm going to move on now. focusing
- 17:02on the SQL process itself. So we've just talked
- 17:05about what SQL is and who the SQL players are.
- 17:08Now let's get into the nitty gritty of what the
- 17:11process entails. Now, SQL has been around since
- 17:141970. And the statute is very long and complex.
- 17:20And we have over 50 years of case law, judicial
- 17:24opinions, interpreting and applying and resolving
- 17:28disputes over CEQA claims. It's not surprising
- 17:35that many are wary of CEQA in all of its acronyms
- 17:40and length. I wanted to assure you that anyone
- 17:45and everyone can become proficient and become
- 17:47a CEQA expert. This is one way to really do it.
- 17:51go get down to basics and keep it simple. And
- 17:55the simplicity is in these four steps. So let's
- 17:57get into them. The four steps are, the first
- 18:00step, determine if the proposed activity is a
- 18:03project that's even subject to CEQA. If the answer
- 18:08to that is that it is a project subject to CEQA,
- 18:11the next step is to determine whether the project
- 18:14is exempt from CEQA. Then, If the activity is
- 18:19a project and is not exempt from CEQA, you move
- 18:22on to the third step. Here's what most folks
- 18:26think is the CEQA process. This is where you
- 18:30conduct substantive impact analysis, usually
- 18:34by preparing an initial study, which will determine
- 18:37what type of environmental document is required,
- 18:40a neg -deck, mitigated neg -deck, or EIR. quickly
- 18:47point out that oftentimes many folks in communities
- 18:51like to say that if a city or an agency only
- 18:56did the first or second step that they didn't
- 18:58really do CEQA and they gave it short shrift.
- 19:02That's not true. If the CEQA process ends after
- 19:07the first and or CEQA step and those steps are
- 19:10done properly, that is appropriate CEQA review.
- 19:15a full analysis and full -throated impact analysis
- 19:21document isn't always required, and we'll get
- 19:24into that. Technically, the fourth step is a
- 19:28separate animal, but I wanted to include it because
- 19:31this is where if after you've gone through all
- 19:35three steps, you've prepared, say, a full EIR,
- 19:38you've certified it as being adequate, and you've
- 19:41approved a project, the fourth step will come
- 19:44into play. If there have been changes made to
- 19:49the project and another discretionary approval
- 19:53is required, that's when this subsequent SQL
- 19:56review step applies. Let's dig a little deeper
- 20:00into all four steps now. Before we do, sorry,
- 20:05a critical point to understand is timing. When
- 20:10must you comply with the SQL process? And so
- 20:14no matter how many steps of the one, two, or
- 20:17three, or four, or type of SQL document is required,
- 20:23SQL compliance has to be completed before approval
- 20:26of the project. So that focuses in on what qualifies
- 20:32as a project approval. Approval is defined in
- 20:36the SQL guidelines section 15352. It essentially
- 20:40means a decision by a public agency which commits
- 20:43the agency to a definite course of action in
- 20:47regard to a project intended to be carried out
- 20:50by any person. Here I have citations to two of
- 20:53the leading cases, Save Terra and Cedar Fair.
- 20:57Save Terra came first. It was a California Supreme
- 21:02Court case. It essentially held that that case
- 21:05which was a In all of these cases, this question
- 21:08usually comes up when the approval at issue is
- 21:12really on a preliminary project feature or document,
- 21:18like a purchase and sale agreement or a negotiation
- 21:22agreement or something that's not the actual
- 21:25end permit. The question is whether that initial
- 21:29approval or expression of support for a project
- 21:33qualifies. as an approval such that you have
- 21:36to do SQL before taking that step. So Save Terra
- 21:40involved facts and involved the holding that
- 21:45said under the facts of that case, the approval
- 21:49that was given was an approval for SQL purposes.
- 21:53The West Hollywood hadn't done SQL review, and
- 21:57so it overturned that approval and sent it back.
- 22:00to make sure that SQL was done before project
- 22:03approval was done. Some of the factors there,
- 22:06the city was doing some preliminary agreements
- 22:11that were going to help facilitate a housing
- 22:14development. But at the same time, they were
- 22:17loaning money to the developer, making deals
- 22:19with the developer. And in fact, we're already
- 22:21starting to give notice and relocate residents
- 22:25at the project site. And those, as well as some
- 22:29others, were facts that swayed the Supreme Court
- 22:31to say, in that instance, it was a project approval
- 22:34and sequel compliance had to come before that.
- 22:38On the flip side, Cedar Fair, that involved a
- 22:41preliminary agreement that was going to facilitate
- 22:44the eventual development, construction, and operation
- 22:47of the new San Francisco 49ers stadium in Santa
- 22:51Clara. But there, that was not a Supreme Court
- 22:55case, but the Court of Appeal said that the facts
- 22:58of that case found that no, it wasn't an approval
- 23:03for SQL purposes. And read together, those two
- 23:07cases tell us that while there's no bright line
- 23:10test for determining when an agency action constitutes
- 23:14commitment of a project, the key question you
- 23:17need to be thinking about and answering in your
- 23:19analysis is whether the agency has retained discretion
- 23:23to impose mitigation measures adopt an alternative
- 23:27or even disapprove the project altogether once
- 23:31it does get around to doing CEQA review. And
- 23:34in Save Tara, Tara, the facts that I mentioned
- 23:38led the court to believe that the city had gone
- 23:42too far down the road such that when it eventually
- 23:46did CEQA, it was hamstrung if not prohibited
- 23:49from actually saying no or imposing mitigation
- 23:52measures. because it had already taken those
- 23:55steps that I described. Whereas in Cedar Fair,
- 23:58there was a lot of terms, including one that
- 24:00escrow couldn't close until SQL was done and
- 24:04any mitigation measures that came out of that
- 24:06project were incorporated into the project. So
- 24:09that's a critical point to know and understand
- 24:12the timing when SQL compliance has to be done.
- 24:16And this is the concept before project approval
- 24:19that is important to know there. So back to the
- 24:25first step, is the proposed activity a project?
- 24:29A proposed activity is a project that's subject
- 24:32to CEQA. If it's something that's undertaken,
- 24:36funded, or permitted by a public agency, it requires
- 24:40a discretionary approval. And most importantly,
- 24:45it has the potential to result in a direct or
- 24:48reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change
- 24:51in the environment. It's important to note that
- 24:53this includes a reasonably foreseeable indirect
- 24:57physical change in the environment. For example,
- 25:00if the activity in question was just a parcel
- 25:02map that was going to subdivide one parcel into
- 25:0610, well, the approval of the map is not going
- 25:11to lead to any physical changes on the ground
- 25:14in the environment. parcel and all the resulting
- 25:1910 parcels that we result from the parcel map
- 25:22are in a single family residential zone that
- 25:25allows at least one home and maybe an ADU or
- 25:29an ADU and a junior ADU on each site. By right,
- 25:34well, then you also have to include that development
- 25:38of those homes and any infrastructure to support
- 25:41them in the activity. There you can see that
- 25:45such a subdivision map would be a project because
- 25:49it has the reasonable foreseeable chance to lead
- 25:53to indirect physical changes in the environment.
- 25:56I have some key cases here that give you some
- 26:00guidance. They're both Supreme Court cases, Union
- 26:03of Medical Marijuana Patients and Muzzy Ranch
- 26:06that hone in on this definition. of when an activity
- 26:11qualifies as a project subject to CEQA. It's
- 26:14also defined in the guidelines in 15378. OK,
- 26:20so we've decided that an activity is a project
- 26:23subject to CEQA. The second step is to determine
- 26:25whether it's exempt from CEQA. A lot of focus,
- 26:31increasing focus, is placed on this exemption
- 26:35analysis. for a number of reasons. One, quite
- 26:40frankly, it's costly and time consuming to go
- 26:42forward into step three, but also because the
- 26:45legislature in recent years has adopted more
- 26:48and more exemptions from CEQA to facilitate housing
- 26:53projects, climate change friendly projects and
- 26:59the like. And so there are a lot of exemptions.
- 27:02Let's talk about them. What I would call the
- 27:06top of the heap would be what are referenced
- 27:08as statutory exemptions. These are created by
- 27:12statute, by the state legislature, and they are
- 27:15absolute, meaning there's no exception to them.
- 27:18And interestingly, they're often created for
- 27:20projects that will certainly result in environmental
- 27:23impacts. But the legislature, in its wisdom and
- 27:27balancing things other than just in the environment,
- 27:30decided that they should be exempt from CEQA.
- 27:34They're mostly found in the CEQA statute itself,
- 27:36but they are also in other codes, such as the
- 27:38water code and a government code. And so the
- 27:43CEQA guidelines also has a good list of a majority
- 27:47of those statutory exemptions. Some examples
- 27:50are, again, one reason why I emphasize the fact
- 27:56that a CEQA project has to involve a discretionary
- 27:59approval is because one of the statutory exemptions
- 28:02is for a ministerial approval or a ministerial
- 28:06action. And that's one that includes no subjective
- 28:12thinking or decision making. And you can't impose
- 28:16conditions on the approval. You just follow essentially
- 28:20kind of a checklist of requirements. And if they're
- 28:22met, you issue the approval. That's a ministerial
- 28:25action. It also applies statutory exemptions
- 28:29include for emergency projects. street re -striping,
- 28:34rooftop parking lot solar. If you're going to
- 28:37disapprove a project, you don't need to do CEQA.
- 28:40Another good example is to facilitate Olympic
- 28:44games. There's also, while technically not truly
- 28:48a statutory exemption, it's close enough. The
- 28:52exemption in CEQA public resources code 21083
- 28:55.3, and it's mirrored in CEQA guidelines 15183,
- 29:00for a project that's consistent with a general
- 29:04plan or a community plan for which an EIR was
- 29:07certified, can exempt a project entirely from
- 29:12additional CEQA, or more frequently, it's a form
- 29:16of tiering that allows just a limited amount
- 29:19of environmental review to be done. The concept
- 29:23of tiering goes a little bit beyond an intro
- 29:26or a nuts and bolts presentation. happy to cover
- 29:30it in a future CEQA 201 seminar, if you'd have
- 29:36me. Moving on, there are also categorical exemptions.
- 29:41There's 33 classes of categorical exemptions.
- 29:45These are regulations that are adopted by the
- 29:48Secretary of Natural Resources Agency. They are
- 29:52adopted as categorical exemptions because that
- 29:56agency determined that generally, these 33 classes
- 29:59will not have a significant effect on the environment.
- 30:03They're found in CEQA guidelines 15301 through
- 30:0715333. There's a list of examples here. These
- 30:13are the most common. The first one, it's called
- 30:17the existing facilities categorical exemption.
- 30:21The third one for new construction or conversion
- 30:24of small structures is very common that covers
- 30:27the categorically exempts the development of
- 30:31up to three homes in an urban area. Also increasingly
- 30:36important and increasingly used is the categorical
- 30:44exemption for infill development. Interestingly,
- 30:48of all 33 categorical exemptions, the infill
- 30:51development exemption is the only one that actually
- 30:55has criteria that asks whether the project will
- 30:59have an environmental impact. It's limited to
- 31:02air, water, traffic, and noise, but it does include
- 31:08those potential impacts as a criteria for the
- 31:10exemption. Bottom line, the most important takeaway
- 31:16when you're understanding categorical exemptions
- 31:19is that there are exceptions to them and you
- 31:23cannot rely on a categorical exemption if one
- 31:27or more of the exceptions apply. The exceptions
- 31:30are found in CEQA guidelines section 15300 .2.
- 31:35And there are exceptions for projects that are
- 31:38in a sensitive location that have environmental
- 31:41hazards, like in the coastal zone, Esha, or critical
- 31:47habitat for other wildlife and so forth. There's
- 31:50also exceptions for projects that will have cumulative
- 31:52impacts. The most significant and the most used
- 31:57applicable exception is the unusual circumstances
- 32:01exception. I have an asterisk here. Please go
- 32:06read the Supreme California Supreme Court decision
- 32:08in Berkeley Hillside, which addressed and covered
- 32:14the unusual circumstances exception. It's actually
- 32:16a two -part test. For this exception to apply,
- 32:20there have to be unusual circumstances and there
- 32:23has to be the possibility of a significant environmental
- 32:27impact due to those unusual circumstances. It's
- 32:32a unique two -part test with also two -part standard
- 32:39of review that applies. Berkeley Hillside case
- 32:42can give you the specifics on that. There also
- 32:48is a catch -all. It's called the common sense
- 32:50exemption. Your activity might not fit squarely
- 32:54under any of the statutory or categorical exemptions,
- 32:58but it can be seen with certainty that there's
- 33:01no possibility the activity will have a significant
- 33:04impact on the environment. The onus there is
- 33:08if you're going to rely on the common sense exemption
- 33:10is that the lead agency has to demonstrate that
- 33:13in the first instance. point to facts to supporting
- 33:17the finding that the common sense exemption applies.
- 33:21Last two points on exemptions are that you can
- 33:25stack or bundle them in a belt and suspenders
- 33:28approach, meaning it's OK to use and combine
- 33:31multiple exemptions to cover portions of a single
- 33:36project if, taken together, all the exemptions
- 33:40that you're relying on will cover every aspect.
- 33:42of the project at issue. This is also really
- 33:47important, this final bullet point is you cannot,
- 33:50the way I like to say this, you can't mitigate
- 33:53your way into an exemption or out of an exception.
- 34:00The Salmon Protection Watershed Network and Azusa
- 34:04cases, go read and study them if you want to
- 34:09really understand this concept. But generally,
- 34:12When you're finding a project exempt, you can't
- 34:14point to and impose or rely on mitigation measures
- 34:19to conclude that a project satisfies the criteria
- 34:23of an exemption. But you can point to, if there
- 34:27are generally applicable existing legal or regulatory
- 34:31requirements, those are not considered impermissible
- 34:35mitigation measures that would run afoul of this
- 34:38rule. One example is as many air districts have
- 34:41regulations that require dust control for project
- 34:45construction. That entails a lot of things, keeping
- 34:49speeds on trucks down, watering surface of areas
- 34:54during grading so that the dirt doesn't turn
- 34:57into dust and blow away. Those are the types
- 35:01of generally applicable existing legal or regulatory
- 35:04requirements that you could point to and say,
- 35:07There won't be any construction impacts because
- 35:10grading is going to be short and they have to
- 35:12comply with these types of requirements. So there'll
- 35:15be no air quality impacts related to dust or
- 35:19what they call particulate matter. So that's
- 35:22an important concept. I see a lot of agencies
- 35:25that don't understand this concept and they'll
- 35:30say, the project's exempt because we're going
- 35:33to impose all these conditions on the project.
- 35:36Those are usually impermissible mitigation measures,
- 35:39and I have to work with them to try to find and
- 35:42see if any of those are actually rooted in existing
- 35:46or legal regulatory requirements. If not, you
- 35:49can't rely on exemption. When you can't rely
- 35:54on an exemption, you need to go to the third
- 35:56step. Before we do, I just wanted to make the
- 36:01point here that, again, as I made at the outset.
- 36:05If under either the first step or the second
- 36:07step, you find that the activity is not a project
- 36:10or that the project's exempt, you're done with
- 36:13CEQA. Now, obviously, you have to, you, if you're
- 36:17a lead agency or a staff at a lead agency, you
- 36:20have to document, it'd be best if you documented
- 36:23and supported those findings with citations to
- 36:28the facts, the substantial evidence, but you
- 36:30stop at that point. and you file what's called
- 36:34a notice of exemption. You file it with both
- 36:39the county clerk and with the state clearinghouse.
- 36:43Then both the county clerk and state clearinghouse
- 36:46have to post that notice of exemption or NOE
- 36:50for 35 days. If they do that, that triggers a
- 36:56very short 35 -day limitations period within
- 37:00which any CEQA lawsuit must be brought. If a
- 37:05CEQA lawsuit is filed beyond that 30 -day limitations
- 37:09period, it can be quickly and easily dismissed
- 37:12as a mandatory dismissal if you don't satisfy
- 37:17the statute of limitations period. You've gone
- 37:21through steps one and two, and you concluded
- 37:25that you have a project that is not exempt from
- 37:28CEQA, then you have to conduct impact analysis.
- 37:33Most agencies do so by conducting an initial
- 37:37study and using the initial study checklist that
- 37:42is located in Appendix G of the CEQA guidelines.
- 37:47That checklist requires you to essentially describe
- 37:53the project and its location. identify the existing
- 37:58on -the -ground environmental conditions, which
- 38:01is called the environmental setting or the baseline,
- 38:04then you superimpose the project over the baseline
- 38:08and you compare the baseline plus the project
- 38:11conditions and analyze whether the project may
- 38:14cause any potentially significant impacts based
- 38:17on thresholds of significance that the lead agency
- 38:20would identify for It's crazy to think, but now
- 38:2520 environmental resource areas. I took this
- 38:34screenshot from the initial study checklist so
- 38:37that you could see all 20 of those environmental
- 38:41resource areas that SQL requires substantive
- 38:44impact analysis of. The red checkboxes, I've
- 38:52placed those checks there because I wanted to
- 38:55emphasize a point. 15, 20 years ago, SQL used
- 39:00to be simpler, kindler, and gentler. In addition
- 39:05to all the new rules and requirements that come
- 39:08out of the judicial opinions, these four areas
- 39:11with the check marks have either been introduced
- 39:15newly into SQL, or have been significantly modified
- 39:19by the legislature in the past few years. For
- 39:22example, greenhouse gas emissions wasn't part
- 39:25of CEQA analysis until a law, SB7 passed in 2007,
- 39:31required the CEQA guidelines to be amended to
- 39:34require greenhouse gas or GHGs to be analyzed
- 39:39and those amendments to the guidelines became
- 39:41effective in 2010. GHG impact analysis has been
- 39:46part of CEQA since 2010. Similarly, in 2018,
- 39:53a major update to the CEQA guidelines was done.
- 39:58In that major update in 2018, both the transportation
- 40:03and wildfire was introduced. Wildfire was introduced
- 40:10for the first time as a CEQA subject and transportation
- 40:15impact analysis went through a significant change.
- 40:19Prior to that update, traffic impact analysis
- 40:23was done by way of a level of service methodology.
- 40:27You probably heard that before. It was a relatively
- 40:29simple grading exercise, A, B, C, D, E, or F.
- 40:36great, F, terrible, which gauged the level of
- 40:40delay at either a roadway intersection or a roadway
- 40:44segment. But these CEQA updates in 2018 to the
- 40:48guidelines completely transformed how that impact
- 40:51analysis does. It got rid of the level of service
- 40:54methodology and replaced it with a VMT, vehicle
- 40:59miles traveled methodology. And to be honest,
- 41:03lead agencies CEQA consultants and seasoned attorneys
- 41:07like myself are still somewhat struggling to
- 41:11understand exactly what VMT impact analysis requires
- 41:15and what is adequate under it. So that exercise
- 41:19continues by all of CEQA practitioners. Lastly,
- 41:24tribal cultural resources was never a specific
- 41:28topic. under CEQA. Cultural resources always
- 41:31have been, but those were generally limited to
- 41:34historic or paleontological resources. But in
- 41:402014, through AB 52 passed by the state legislature,
- 41:46tribal cultural resources were defined and sections
- 41:49of CEQA were added to require that they be impacts
- 41:53to tribal cultural resources be analyzed in the
- 41:56CEQA process and that consultation with tribes
- 42:03affected by projects occur to help with that
- 42:07tribal cultural resource impact analysis. The
- 42:12results of the initial study will determine which
- 42:15CEQA documents required. If the initial study
- 42:18shows that there'll be no significant impacts,
- 42:21then the appropriate document is a negative declaration.
- 42:24If the initial shows that there's a potential
- 42:27for significant adverse impacts, but they can
- 42:30all be reduced to a level of insignificance or
- 42:33a less than significant level, then a mitigated
- 42:38negative declaration is the appropriate document.
- 42:42If the initial study says, well, there's some
- 42:46difficult impacts that aren't easily mitigated,
- 42:48you have to go on and prepare a full EIR. Whichever
- 42:53of those three documents your initial study tells
- 42:55you is required, there's public notice and public
- 43:00review and comment periods have to be provided.
- 43:03This is what causes this process to be somewhat
- 43:07lengthy and oftentimes costly, is the level of
- 43:11notice and the level of public review and comment
- 43:14period that has to be followed, and the documents
- 43:19that have to be created. Even mitigating NGDEX
- 43:24and EIRs today can approach hundreds, if not
- 43:27thousands of pages with appendices that are equally
- 43:31voluminous. So it can definitely be complex.
- 43:35I just wanted to go through a little bit more
- 43:37about the EIR process. Once you get to a requirement
- 43:40to do a full EIR, you have to do that whenever
- 43:45there's evidence in the record that supports
- 43:47a fair argument. that a project may have a significant
- 43:51effect on the environment. I'll touch on that
- 43:53fair argument. That's the name of the standard
- 43:56of review that applies if a loss is challenging
- 44:00the adequacy of a NGDEC or a mitigated NGDEC.
- 44:09That's an important point to focus on here. I'm
- 44:15going to move along so that we can cover everything.
- 44:19Here's the purpose of an EIR. Again, it's similar
- 44:22to the overall purpose of CEQA. It's to inform
- 44:25the agency and the public and explore ways to
- 44:28avoid or minimize impacts. Some unique substantive
- 44:33requirements to EIRs are a fulsome cumulative
- 44:40impact analysis and the development of a reasonable
- 44:44range of project alternatives. so that you can
- 44:48look for mitigation measures and actual project
- 44:52alternatives if you have significant impacts
- 44:54that can't easily be mitigated. And for those
- 44:58that don't know, a cumulative impact is something
- 45:00that would result from the impacts of a proposed
- 45:06project plus all reasonably foreseeable projects
- 45:10that are going to occur together or in the near
- 45:13future alongside the proposed project. While
- 45:18your project may have an impact that doesn't
- 45:21exceed a threshold and isn't significant, if
- 45:24there's three other projects like it in the area
- 45:27and combined, they're going to result in an impact
- 45:31that's significant. That's something that has
- 45:34to be identified and mitigated as well if it's
- 45:36significant. Now, I remember I told you a CEQA
- 45:41is important because it's probably the most impactful
- 45:44and has the most teeth out of any environmental
- 45:47review law in the country. That's true, but those
- 45:51teeth are not impenetrable, totally impenetrable,
- 45:54so to speak. You only have to reduce those impacts
- 45:58by imposing mitigation measures or selecting
- 46:00a project alternative if it's feasible to do
- 46:04so. Feasible is defined as capable of being accomplished
- 46:07in a successful manner within a reasonable period
- 46:11of time, taking into account economic, environmental,
- 46:15social, technological, and legal factors. If
- 46:20you find that a potentially significant impact
- 46:24that there's no way to feasibly mitigate it and
- 46:27that there's no feasible alternatives, then CQA
- 46:31does kind of get out of jail free card. And it's
- 46:36in the form of what's called a statement of overriding
- 46:39considerations. If you have a project that has
- 46:42an impact that can't be mitigated, that's a significant
- 46:45and unavoidable impact. You can still go forward
- 46:48and approve the project if you adopt a statement
- 46:51of overriding considerations. And in essence,
- 46:53it's a finding that points out that the project
- 46:57has several benefits. and that the decision -makers
- 47:00believe those benefits will override those significant
- 47:04and unavoidable impacts. And that's really a
- 47:07policy. If the hard work is done to demonstrate
- 47:10that there are no feasible mitigation measures
- 47:13or no feasible alternatives, courts will defer
- 47:16to what are the state's motor riding considerations,
- 47:19which is essentially a policy judgment, so long
- 47:22as it is supported by substantial evidence. moving
- 47:29along. So this EIR process, again, this is why
- 47:33it can take a year or more and cost several hundreds
- 47:37of thousands of dollars, starts with scoping
- 47:40where you give a notice that you're going to
- 47:42prepare an EIR and you give agencies and oftentimes
- 47:47the public as well an opportunity to comment
- 47:50on the scope of the EIR. Then you get into the
- 47:54hard work and you actually prepare the initial
- 47:56draft EIR. This is the the biggest and most substantive
- 47:59stage. And this is where you'll prepare a document
- 48:03that's hundreds or thousands of pages. Then you
- 48:06have to have a public review period of at least
- 48:0830 days, often 45 and upwards of 60, where the
- 48:14agencies in public can review and comment on
- 48:16the draft EIR. Then there's a final EIR, where
- 48:20the lead agency has to prepare written responses.
- 48:23to every comment that raises significant environmental
- 48:27issues. An important point here is oftentimes
- 48:31the final EIR will not only respond to those
- 48:34comments, but will make changes to the draft
- 48:37EIR that are consistent with their responses
- 48:39to the comments. That's fine, but if you revise
- 48:44the draft EIR at this final EIR stage, by adding
- 48:49significant new information, which is defined
- 48:51as information that discloses a new or a more
- 48:56severe impact that wasn't identified or analyzed
- 49:00in the draft EIR, you have to go back to square
- 49:03one, in essence, and recirculate that revised
- 49:06draft EIR for another public review and comment
- 49:10period. I guess the takeaway there is make sure
- 49:13you get the draft EIR mostly correct in the first
- 49:17instance. Lastly, before a project can be approved,
- 49:22the Lead Agency has to certify the EIR that it
- 49:26represents their independent judgment and that
- 49:29it complies with CEQA, and then they have to
- 49:31make specific findings for each impact, including
- 49:35the Statement of Overriding Considerations finding
- 49:37if the EIR does conclude that there are significant
- 49:41and unavoidable impacts. Lastly, just like the
- 49:45exemption, if the project is approved, the Lead
- 49:50Agency would file a Notice of Determination,
- 49:53same with the County Kirk and the State Clearinghouse,
- 49:56and that, if filed and posted correctly, would
- 50:00trigger a short 30 -day statute of limitations
- 50:03to file a SQL lawsuit. The fourth step is just
- 50:09Again, like I mentioned, subsequent SQL review.
- 50:12If after doing all of that, preparing a voluminous
- 50:16EIR, certifying it and adopting findings to approve
- 50:21a project, if there are changes proposed by the
- 50:24project and that a further subsequent discretionary
- 50:29approval is required, then you need to go and
- 50:32analyze whether subsequent SQL review is required.
- 50:36The detailed requirements for this subsequent
- 50:40CEQA review are laid out in CEQA guidelines 15062
- 50:45through 15064. But essentially, the test is that
- 50:50if project changes or changed circumstances or
- 50:54new information that has come to light since
- 50:56the initial EIR and project approval disclose
- 51:00a new or more severe impact, then you have to
- 51:04actually do subsequent secret overview and prepare
- 51:07either a supplement or a subsequent EIR. But
- 51:11if your analysis shows that the changes will
- 51:15not result in a new or more severe impact, you
- 51:18can document that in what's called an addendum
- 51:21to the prior MND or EIR. Some SQL litigation
- 51:29topics before we get to some questions at the
- 51:32end. A SQL lawsuit is filed in the form of a
- 51:38petition for writ of mandate. It is a civil action
- 51:41and all the civil code of procedural rules apply,
- 51:48but it's its unique animal in a number of respects.
- 51:51One is that it's not a complaint, it's a petition
- 51:54for writ of mandate. There's two kinds, traditional
- 51:57mandamus or administrative mandamus in these
- 52:01two separate Code of Civil Procedure sections.
- 52:05As I already discussed, if an NOE is filed after
- 52:09an exemption, a project's approved on an exemption,
- 52:12there's a 35 -day window to file a timely SQL
- 52:15lawsuit. If an NOD is filed after approving a
- 52:20project based on an NGDEC MND or EIR, there's
- 52:24a 30 -day period to file a SQL lawsuit. If the
- 52:28lead agency, after approving a project, fails
- 52:31to file the NOE or an NOD, then there's a fallback
- 52:36180 -day statute of limitations period that runs
- 52:40from the date the agency actually approved the
- 52:43project. SQL lawsuit and really the assessment
- 52:50of whether you're going to prevail or not is
- 52:52what's judicial standard of review applies. If
- 52:55the SQL claims present pure legal issues, challenged
- 53:00compliance with procedural requirements, or involve
- 53:03statutory interpretation, it's a de novo standard
- 53:07of review. The court is going to rule that on
- 53:09its own based on what the law says those legal
- 53:13issues are or what those procedural requirements
- 53:16are. Here's where the fair argument standard
- 53:19comes into play, and it quite frankly is a low
- 53:22threshold challenger -friendly test. If someone
- 53:26sues to challenge the adequacy of a neck deck
- 53:28or a mitigated neck deck, and like I said, there
- 53:31is any argument to support a fair argument that
- 53:34there could be a potential impact. that NGDEC
- 53:39or MND has to be overturned and an EIR is required.
- 53:43This is a low threshold test because even if
- 53:46the lead agency has 10 pieces of substantial
- 53:48evidence to support its findings, if the record
- 53:52includes one piece of evidence that is solid
- 53:56and qualifies as substantial evidence that concludes
- 54:00the opposite, the NGDEC MND will not stand and
- 54:05must be overturned. This leads a lot of folks
- 54:09to either pursue exemptions if they apply or
- 54:14to conservatively go forward with an EIR because
- 54:19challenges to exemptions or EIRs are adjudged
- 54:23pursuant to the substantial evidence judicial
- 54:26standard of review. And this one is lead agency
- 54:29friendly because the courts will defer. to agency
- 54:34findings supporting exemptions or findings of
- 54:39the significance of impacts and the success of
- 54:42mitigation measures that might be in an EIR.
- 54:46So this substantial evidence standard applies
- 54:48in most exemption lawsuits and most EIR lawsuits.
- 54:54There is an asterisk there because a part of
- 54:58the test to see if the unusual circumstances
- 55:01exception defeats a categorical exemption as
- 55:05noted in the Berkeley Hillside case does partially
- 55:10apply that fair argument standard. Read that
- 55:13case to understand the intricacies of that. Substantial
- 55:19evidence is key here then to understanding whether
- 55:22you're going to prevail, especially if it's a
- 55:24challenge to an EIR. The guidelines define what
- 55:27substantial evidence is and it defines what it
- 55:30is not. Interestingly or importantly, it's not
- 55:34argument, speculation, unsubstantiated opinion
- 55:38or narrative, or clearly erroneous facts, or
- 55:41like I said earlier, evidence of social or economic
- 55:44impacts. Two final points to point out about
- 55:49SQL litigation. Unlike other civil cases, there's
- 55:54typically no discovery. The only relevant and
- 55:59visible evidence is what's included in the administrative
- 56:02record. And what goes in the administrative record
- 56:05is essentially all documents that were prepared
- 56:08by or received by the lead agency up to its final
- 56:13decision on the project. So it's really a documentary
- 56:16documents that form all the evidence. And absent
- 56:21certain exceptions outlined in the Western States
- 56:23case cited here. Documents outside the record
- 56:27are generally not admissible in a SQL litigation.
- 56:31That's critically important. It's really important
- 56:34because if you want to prevail in your lawsuit,
- 56:37whether you're a challenger or a lead agency,
- 56:40you need to make sure that the evidence supporting
- 56:42your arguments is in the administrative record.
- 56:45You can't rely on documents that are going to
- 56:47be created or arguments that are going to be
- 56:50daylighted for the first time after the approval
- 56:52is granted. Lastly, there's a unique standing
- 56:57requirement. It comes from a common law concept
- 57:00called exhaustion of administrative remedies.
- 57:03Now, exhaustion technically has two components.
- 57:05You literally have to exhaust your administrative
- 57:08remedies, meaning you can't go to court unless
- 57:11you've exhausted all your administrative appeals.
- 57:20as evidence tier and codified in CEQA in section
- 57:2421177, you also, there's an issue presentation
- 57:29requirement, meaning that you have to tell the,
- 57:32if you're gonna file a CEQA lawsuit, you first
- 57:34have to tell the agent, you have to object to
- 57:37their CEQA document or CEQA compliance strategy,
- 57:41and you have to tell them with some form of specificity
- 57:45why you think they're violating CEQA. If you
- 57:48don't do that, your SQL lawsuit can be easily
- 57:52quickly dismissed for failing to satisfy this
- 57:55exhaustion requirement. Interestingly, it also
- 57:58applies even if the SQL compliance was a determination
- 58:02that the project was exempt, so long as the public
- 58:06agency gives the public notice of the SQL exemption
- 58:09it intends to rely on and an opportunity to comment
- 58:13either in writing or at a public hearing before
- 58:16that. arguably exempt project is approved. Life
- 58:23of a SQL lawsuit, I know we're running out of
- 58:25time, it's filed, then notice has to be given
- 58:31to responsible and trustee agencies, generally
- 58:34just so that they can be kept aware and if they
- 58:37want to intervene in that lawsuit, if they had
- 58:39an interest or they could. Then there's also
- 58:45a mandatory early settlement conference that's
- 58:47required, along with typical case management
- 58:50conferences. Then that all important administrative
- 58:53record is prepared. That can often take a long
- 58:56time, especially because currently agency staff
- 59:00and decision -maker emails are supposed to be
- 59:03included in the administrative record, and that
- 59:05takes a long time to gather, review for privilege
- 59:08and relevancy, and include in the record. But
- 59:11once the record's filed, and answers are filed
- 59:15to the petition. And then merits briefing, an
- 59:18opening, opposition and reply brief, and then
- 59:21a CEQA trial. Now I put it in quotes because
- 59:24CEQA trials, there's no, remember I said no discovery,
- 59:27there's also no juries. It's a bench trial and
- 59:30it's really akin to a law and motion hearing,
- 59:33but it can take one, two, or several hours depending
- 59:37on the complexity of the case. Then the trial
- 59:40court would issue a judgment. and a writ ordering
- 59:43the lead agency to do something if it finds that
- 59:47the CEQA lawsuit had merit. Then you could even
- 59:50have additional years if there's appellate proceedings.
- 59:55Lastly, they wanted me to briefly summarize some
- 59:59of the executive orders that were issued by the
- 1:00:02governor and the mayor to address the Los Angeles
- 1:00:06wildfires. I haven't had an opportunity to practice
- 1:00:09or implement or apply any of these. And so I
- 1:00:13don't have experience and I can't go into really
- 1:00:16covering them. I did list almost all of them
- 1:00:19here that were issued by Governor Newsom. And
- 1:00:22I highlighted the ones that really pertained
- 1:00:25to land use, environmental and CEQA and Coastal
- 1:00:28Act permits. Essentially, you could see here
- 1:00:31that the most significant executive orders were
- 1:00:34those that suspended. permitting and environmental
- 1:00:38review requirements under CEQA and the Coastal
- 1:00:41Act, but it did so only for structures that are
- 1:00:44going to be replaced in the same location and
- 1:00:48don't exceed 110 percent of the footprint and
- 1:00:51height of the structure that existed before the
- 1:00:53fires, same general confines for ADUs. It also
- 1:00:59applies and exempts necessary supportive infrastructure.
- 1:01:04Similarly, Mayor Bass issued upwards of nine
- 1:01:11executive orders. Here, the most significant
- 1:01:14seven, most significant of them are summarized,
- 1:01:17and you can easily go to the web page and find
- 1:01:21lists and actual copies of all of these executive
- 1:01:25orders. Lastly, I just wanted to give my contact
- 1:01:31information. I wanted to thank you for your attention.
- 1:01:34And I'm happy to stay and see if there's any
- 1:01:36questions that you all would like me to discuss
- 1:01:38or answer. So yes, there is a question in the
- 1:01:41Q &A. The question is, if a city has issued a
- 1:01:45CEQA negative declaration of a four lot tract
- 1:01:48map that has been granted and expired, is the
- 1:01:50city bound by it for another four lot subdivision
- 1:01:53application? I hope I understand the question.
- 1:02:05If it did the negative declaration for the initial
- 1:02:09track map and then there's a subsequent track
- 1:02:13map, they're not bound by the NECDEC. I think
- 1:02:17that this would put you in the supplemental SQL
- 1:02:19bucket and you have to assess whether there's
- 1:02:22any changes or new information or change circumstances
- 1:02:27that reveal an impact that was missed or not
- 1:02:31identified by the initial negative declaration,
- 1:02:34in which case you may need to do subsequent environmental
- 1:02:39review and prepare either an addendum to that
- 1:02:43initial NGDEC or a supplemental NGDEC or EIR.
- 1:02:48I hope that answers the question. Let me know
- 1:02:51if it doesn't. Great. That was the only question
- 1:02:56I see in Q &A. I believe that's it. Great. I
- 1:03:04see a question. Opportunity zones. Susan, I know
- 1:03:09that context comes up in several cases. Can you
- 1:03:12quickly follow up and type what SQL either process,
- 1:03:18what part of the SQL process or SQL document
- 1:03:20or what SQL specific aspect are you asking regarding
- 1:03:24opportunity zones? I'm sorry, I'm not exactly
- 1:03:33familiar with the term opportunity zone. I know
- 1:03:38I've heard it. I don't think that SQL has an
- 1:03:42express exemption for opportunity zones. Oftentimes,
- 1:03:48those are characterized as areas that are also
- 1:03:51qualified as infill development. And so the infill
- 1:03:56categorical exemption, would certainly be someplace
- 1:03:59I would look. But I am not aware of an express
- 1:04:06exemption in the statute or the guidelines for
- 1:04:11an opportunity zone. But I am going to follow
- 1:04:14up and look. And Susan, I'll find you a follow
- 1:04:17up if what I find is inconsistent with what I've
- 1:04:20told you. Great question by Sophia. It's interesting
- 1:04:29from a CEQA perspective, the most significant
- 1:04:35executive orders were Newsom's order, obviously
- 1:04:41temporarily suspending the permitting requirements
- 1:04:44of CEQA and the Coastal Act, and Mayor Bass issued
- 1:04:49similar and consistent local executive order.
- 1:04:55I was a little flippant in responding to those
- 1:04:59because quite frankly, CEQA and the Coastal Act
- 1:05:02already have existing essentially exceptions.
- 1:05:06Like I had mentioned already, there's a categorical
- 1:05:08exemption for up to three homes in an urban area.
- 1:05:13The Coastal Act has similar exemption for existing
- 1:05:19structures. However, the Coastal Commission,
- 1:05:25in response to the initial executive order, started
- 1:05:28taking and issuing guidance that was inconsistent
- 1:05:31with Newsom's order and was giving guidance that
- 1:05:36folks still did need to comply with some Coastal
- 1:05:38Act permitting requirements. And it prompted
- 1:05:41Newsom to revise and reiterate. his executive
- 1:05:46order demonstrating that. He really meant what
- 1:05:50he said in that there is a, albeit temporary,
- 1:05:53there is a suspension of the CEQA and Coastal
- 1:05:56Act permitting requirements for projects that
- 1:05:58satisfy the criteria in those executive orders.
- 1:06:05So I think that whether on the ground it's amounting
- 1:06:10to things, I don't know. I know there's a whole
- 1:06:14lot of factors with insurance and permitting
- 1:06:18that are complicating and delaying it. But from
- 1:06:25a perspective of making sure that CEQA or the
- 1:06:28Coastal Act aren't going to be impediments, then
- 1:06:31also the mayor went a step further and issued
- 1:06:34executive orders trying to create a one -stop
- 1:06:38permitting shop. either in the affected wildfire
- 1:06:41zones or near that required them to be staffed
- 1:06:45by city staff from planning, building works,
- 1:06:49water and power and so forth to try to help facilitate
- 1:06:53streamline quicker permits for rebuilding. I
- 1:06:56don't know. I'd love to hear from you all if
- 1:06:58it's had any impact to you or your clients or
- 1:07:01your acquaintances, but I hope that it has. That's
- 1:07:06all I have there. just looking through the. Yeah,
- 1:07:16so I think that about wraps up Q &A. Great, thank
- 1:07:21you all. I just want to take a quick moment to
- 1:07:25thank you for your time today with this presentation.
- 1:07:28It was excellent and I hope our attendees enjoy
- 1:07:29the rest of their afternoon. Thank you. Thanks
- 1:07:32everybody. You may be eligible for CLE credit
- 1:07:35in your state. Visit bhba .org slash podcasts
- 1:07:39for more information.