Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Bitcoin’s Wall Street Takeover: ETFs, BlackRock & The New Era with Eric Balchunas
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of that business, 1974198792972000
- 0:17and whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same
- 0:20thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when. We sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK, I say when we sell. This week we sat down with Eric
- 0:34Balchunas from Bloomberg. Great episode, was looking
- 0:37forward to it for a number of weeks.
- 0:39Eric delivered. We talked about his 20 years of
- 0:41Bloomberg, his first point of contact with Bitcoin back in
- 0:462013. And then we went up to 2023
- 0:49talking about where he started to cover with his colleague
- 0:52James the filings for the Bitcoin ETFs and then fast
- 0:55forwarding 24, the launch of them.
- 0:58And then to the present really 18 months later, the most
- 1:01successful ETFs ever launched. So we talked about institutional
- 1:04demand, their retail appetite, where the ETFs are bridging the
- 1:07gaps. We also talked about where the
- 1:09ETFs are falling short. Michael and Eric exchanged a lot
- 1:12of thoughts there just on counterparty risk and how
- 1:15investors need to think about that while also balancing access
- 1:19and really just enjoy this one. I like I said it was there was a
- 1:22fun one. We had shared a lot of laughs
- 1:25and also a lot of signal, which, you know, I wasn't surprised
- 1:28given Eric Eric's background and since I've been following him
- 1:31since 2023 or so, he certainly delivered.
- 1:34And so to tie that all together, as I mentioned, we talked about
- 1:38the trade-offs as it relates to different products.
- 1:41And so ultimately, if you're someone who's serious about
- 1:43Bitcoin, whether you have a material position already or
- 1:45you're looking to build, 1 certainly would encourage you to
- 1:48speak to our team at Onramp. We'll walk you through a multi
- 1:51institution custody, inheritance, insurance, Bitcoin
- 1:54back loans, etcetera. Really, we're focused on helping
- 1:57to protect our clients, whether it's an individual, a business
- 1:59or institutional investor for the long term, for decades to
- 2:03come. So just give us a call, head to
- 2:05our website, book a consultation, speak with me or
- 2:08someone else on the team. And I hope you enjoyed this
- 2:10episode. It was a good one.
- 2:11All right, welcome back to the last trade.
- 2:13I'm excited for this one. I'm excited for many of our
- 2:16episodes, but I am particularly excited for this one as well
- 2:19because we have Eric Balchunis joining us from Bloomberg and
- 2:22I'm joined by my Co host Brian Cabela's and Michael Tanguma.
- 2:26So Eric, before we get into your background, I do just want to
- 2:29say I appreciate the work that you're doing.
- 2:33Yeah, it seems like so. The three of us, Brian, Michael,
- 2:36myself, we've been building in the Bitcoin space for a while
- 2:38and I came across your name first as really the leading
- 2:43source of information as the Bitcoin ETF's started to
- 2:47actually have some momentum even before approval and then after
- 2:50approval. And so I would say for anyone
- 2:52who's not familiar with your work, definitely check out
- 2:54Eric's ex profile because Eric, it's, it's a breath of fresh
- 2:58air, I must say, because there's so many accounts on acts that
- 3:01just post like crazy stuff all day.
- 3:03All caps. They don't actually read
- 3:05anything that they're posting. And you kind of take the
- 3:08opposite approach where you post signal and you have some of the
- 3:11best research reporting on the ETF complex for Bitcoin inflows,
- 3:16AUM. And really we're Bitcoin since
- 3:19today, the ETF complex or I've been in particular, being the
- 3:2320th largest ETF. So, Eric, really appreciate your
- 3:26work. Thank you for joining us today.
- 3:29It's it's an honor. Yeah, no thanks.
- 3:31I'm glad you enjoyed that account.
- 3:34I enjoy doing it. So it's mutual.
- 3:38Awesome. Well, yeah, let's get into it
- 3:40then. So I think for the three of our
- 3:43sake in the the audience sake as well, Would love to just hear a
- 3:45little bit more about your background.
- 3:46I know you've been at Bloomberg for a long time.
- 3:48It seems like you've had this meteoric rise in popularity with
- 3:52covering the Bitcoin ETFs and you've probably seen how much
- 3:55fervor and passion there is in the space.
- 3:57So we'd love to hear just quick snapshot of your background at
- 4:02Bloomberg and then take us to kind of the time when you
- 4:05started to have more of your eyes on the Bitcoin ETFs kind of
- 4:10around the approval etcetera and then we'll get into where we are
- 4:13today. Yeah, I started at Bloomberg in
- 4:16public relations, believe it or not.
- 4:19I was went to college for journalism.
- 4:21And then after 911, I moved to Jersey and I wanted to transfer
- 4:29to the New York office. And the only thing they have in
- 4:31Jersey is Princeton, and that's the data office.
- 4:33So I went from PR to data, which I still think I'm the first and
- 4:37only employee to ever make that move in history.
- 4:41You know, there was a writer, I forget his name, from the 70s,
- 4:44and he talked about going from Harvard into the Army.
- 4:47And I feel like this was a similar move.
- 4:49You know, you think you're like going on to all these parties
- 4:52and PR is a great way to get like near the top of the firm
- 4:57quickly. You know, and then data is like
- 5:00literally like the factory. You know, that is where the
- 5:03terminal was made. So it was actually a really good
- 5:06move from my ego and also to learn how the company was made.
- 5:11You know, you got to put the data on the terminal.
- 5:13That's what we sell. So I spent 15 years in data.
- 5:16I'm surprised, I, I'm surprised I made it that long.
- 5:19It wasn't totally a perfect fit. But ultimately I then got into
- 5:24research, which is a combination of data and PR and journalism.
- 5:28So I'm actually using all of my facilities in research.
- 5:31And the research group was starting at Bloomberg maybe like
- 5:3315 years ago and it was stocks and bonds.
- 5:36And then like, I don't know, when we, we bought the Barclays
- 5:39index unit and they got us some headcount and the guy who ran
- 5:41Bloomberg Intelligence had seen me around doing TV and being the
- 5:46ETF guy internally and said we why don't you cover for
- 5:48research? So since then I've been doing
- 5:50ETF's. And then I obviously got
- 5:52introduced the Bitcoin and crypto first in 2013 when the
- 5:57Winklevoss filed for their Bitcoin trust.
- 5:59People forget they filed when it was under $100 a Bitcoin.
- 6:04I should have just bought a shit load of Bitcoin then.
- 6:06And I wouldn't be talking to you.
- 6:07I would be, or I'd, I'd be on with a with a complete face
- 6:11covering and sunglasses. So you wouldn't know my
- 6:13identity. Maybe then I would give the
- 6:15interview. But I would, I, I, I blew it off
- 6:19like everybody else. I, it was like the way I look at
- 6:23pickleball, you know, it's for other people.
- 6:26I just don't get it. And ultimately though, I kept
- 6:31covering the saga of the approval.
- 6:33And then when BlackRock filed in 2023, that was a meteor moment,
- 6:37moon landing moment. If you're an ETF analyst, you're
- 6:39like, what the hell just happened?
- 6:41And from then on there, it was off to the races.
- 6:43And, and as Jackson pointed out, I used Twitter a lot and I found
- 6:47quickly that a lot of people had stopped covering crypto since
- 6:52SBF. Like there was a dearth of
- 6:54coverage in both the reporter and the analyst world from in
- 6:58the mainstream. There was only the trades, it
- 7:00seemed like. And I found a, a James and I say
- 7:04James Hayford on my team. We found a huge opportunity to
- 7:06develop this new audience by giving like real information
- 7:09about, I call it ETF splaining and SEC splaining because
- 7:15there's wack jobs out there who just say anything.
- 7:18Literally I'm like, I'm like, where's your source?
- 7:21And then they don't even reply. And so people would look to us
- 7:26for like the truth. And we also had good sourcing
- 7:30and we also were, we had a good feel for what was going to
- 7:36happen and how big it would be. And then when the ETFs came out,
- 7:39the flows were on to that's, that's really where we
- 7:41specialize. And so we were able to provide
- 7:44not just the data, but also like really experience color on what
- 7:49it meant. You know, why relativity, you
- 7:54know, those kind of things are powerful from someone who's been
- 7:57in the industry for 20 years. And so I think that's that's
- 8:00sort of where you we probably, you know, you probably probably
- 8:04followed me after I started covering the crypto stuff.
- 8:07It got to the point where I would post about like a dividend
- 8:10ETF and the crypto people would be like, dude, what's this?
- 8:15So it was, it was mostly a blessing, but a little bit of a
- 8:18curse, but I've enjoyed it. It's a great, it's a it's a
- 8:21really younger, more it, you know, it's just a very diverse,
- 8:28younger energetic industry. And I, I think it's given ETFs
- 8:35this like new jolt of energy. So I, I, I know for me covering
- 8:38it 20 years. That's why I like covering ETFs
- 8:41though, because it sends you to every place in the world.
- 8:44But this was like a really massive, interesting journey to
- 8:49this world. I mean, this was like a whole
- 8:50new asset class being on boarded into ETFs and it's really been
- 8:56exciting. Yeah, I think the to Jackson's
- 9:01point, I think you and James have a very like tempered take
- 9:05from this that really helped in tempered in both directions.
- 9:08Like being open to the to the craziness and and looking at it
- 9:11from their vantage point and saying, well, let's think about
- 9:13it from the everyday or the grand wall, like you can't do
- 9:16this stuff. But also not being like kind of
- 9:18stuck in the mud, as we've probably seen where, you know,
- 9:22the vanguards are the easy ones to pick on of like there's no
- 9:24interest or demand for this. And it's an interesting that
- 9:28whole notion of the mimetic nature of the world we live in
- 9:31and in the meme stocks. But then in particular is like
- 9:34been a big substrate of bitcoins growth for 15 years.
- 9:38Think about Trump, like how much he appreciates and enjoys that
- 9:41engagement, similar to yourself on Twitter, Like there's some
- 9:44serotonin hit and yeah, it's just been fascinating to watch.
- 9:48And then like the easiest example, there's probably you
- 9:50could go through a whole hundreds over 100 and a list of
- 9:54uh, crazy like misconceptions. But the most recent one with the
- 9:57in kind redemptions, it's like people think they're going to be
- 9:59able to park Bitcoin and yeah, send, send it out and it's like
- 10:03completely nonsensical from a pure logistics perspective like
- 10:06Fidelity or Coinbase isn't sending Jackson his ETF shares
- 10:10in a harbor wallet. Like from a compliance and OFAC
- 10:12perspective it's so insane but that's what people believe when
- 10:15they see this and then everyone posting all caps of this stuff.
- 10:18Yeah, yeah, I know. I also learned over the approval
- 10:23process, there is just such a demand for hopium that there's
- 10:30not enough hopium to fulfill the demand.
- 10:33And so the tweeters and the trade publication people end up
- 10:38leaning into offering hopium and the remember that COIN Telegraph
- 10:43tweet that said the Black Rock ETF was approved and like the
- 10:46price went up and it was all like some intern read something
- 10:49on a telegram or something. This is like, so there is, I've
- 10:54seen it first hand in both the headlines in the trade
- 10:56publications and then also with the tweeters.
- 10:59On the flip side, the mainstream media leans negative and just
- 11:04continues to see I, I think they underrated and underestimate it.
- 11:09So this interesting dichotomy, I feel like James and I are in the
- 11:11middle and I, I find it feel we feel comfortable there.
- 11:16But I also have gone to a couple conferences and I think I
- 11:19recommend people who cover this. I'm like, you should go to these
- 11:22conferences because you're going to see massive energy.
- 11:27I went to token 2049 in Dubai. There were like 15,000 people
- 11:31there. The average age was probably
- 11:322930. I mean, I felt like the boomer.
- 11:35They call me on Twitter, like they call me boomer and suit all
- 11:39the time. And I'm like, hey, I why?
- 11:41I do wear a suit on Mondays for the TV show, but otherwise I'm
- 11:44not wearing a suit. I'm Gen.
- 11:45X and honestly, I try to tell them ETFs are pretty punk.
- 11:50I mean, Wall Street doesn't love ETFs.
- 11:52They're cheap. They don't make any money for
- 11:54Wall Street. So when I go to the crypto
- 11:56conferences, I sort of try to present ETFs as like you should
- 12:00be careful not to underrate the power of the ETF.
- 12:04It is a kick ass vehicle that's going to be hard to disrupt,
- 12:07especially for the tokenization stuff.
- 12:10That said, this is that industry is just full of it's young,
- 12:15international, vibrant and real tech oriented.
- 12:19And I felt going there similar to how I felt when I first went
- 12:24to ETF conferences in like 20, 2006, 2007.
- 12:28And since I was like, this is kind of the future.
- 12:31And so that really helped bring me on in terms of being someone
- 12:36who takes it totally seriously. But at the same time, the
- 12:39industry itself is good of making fun of itself.
- 12:43Like when I would get into a fight with somebody on Twitter
- 12:46and like, I could see people jump in and be like, oh, yeah,
- 12:50this guy's insane. You know, Like, or when the
- 12:52price of Bitcoin goes down, like like let's say it has a sell off
- 12:55of like 20%, people will put a McDonald's hat on themselves in
- 12:59their profile picture. And so I do enjoy that self
- 13:03deprecating humor that is mostly there.
- 13:07You don't find that as much in Tratify.
- 13:09So I like that there's some features of it that I'm, you
- 13:13know, find that fit my personality.
- 13:17That said, I do think that that there is a large that under
- 13:22appreciation for how much has happened over the past 30 years
- 13:25in traditional finance to bring costs down.
- 13:29So I think the crypto assets themselves are like really
- 13:34powerful and interesting. But the you know, the
- 13:38intermediaries, I think they have their hands full with, you
- 13:43know, BlackRock and Schwab, these companies are live in a
- 13:47terror Dome of the ETF world, which is it's tough place to
- 13:51compete. So I think there's like, I think
- 13:54I think both sides, you know, it's almost like a generational
- 13:58gap and a cultural gap as well. And I've really enjoyed going
- 14:01between. I think both sides under
- 14:03appreciate things about the other sometimes because they do
- 14:06get into somewhat of a tribal state of mind.
- 14:08But there's a bleeding in they're coming together there.
- 14:12It's like a a marriage, whether you like it or not, Especially
- 14:15since Trump won and I, I feel like we're going to find a lot
- 14:19of blending of the two worlds over the next 20 years.
- 14:22Yeah, one thing to call out because Inter Jackson has a
- 14:24number of ways to take this buddy.
- 14:26There's a theme that's playing out here when you reference
- 14:28going from PR to the data room or try to fight a crypto.
- 14:31And this is how we built this business.
- 14:33It's like in it, this is a crude version of when 2 disparate
- 14:36ideas come together and collide. That's when they have set like
- 14:38when they have sex, like that's when the magic happens later.
- 14:41That's the beauty of life. It's like you have to have
- 14:42different parts of your brain working together to really like
- 14:45come from a frame of reference that the market has never seen.
- 14:48So there's a lot of alpha in what you're describing.
- 14:49How do you actually build the right way?
- 14:51And we've been in the early hobbyist phase.
- 14:53This is like what jobs really picked up on early is there was
- 14:55people putting computers together, but it was like, how
- 14:57do I actually make the most like democratize the access to a
- 14:59really nice power machine? And that's where we're at.
- 15:02And then we're still early like 1990s and the, and the Internet
- 15:05in this boom. And there's just no shortage of
- 15:07ways to like democratize and provide exposure to people.
- 15:11Yeah. It feels like I started my
- 15:14career in the mid 90s. I'm pretty old and I feel like
- 15:22this is Internet stocks, at least the block chains.
- 15:26Bitcoin is kind of a unique special thing, although that
- 15:28kicked off the block chain, you know, companies, but it's all
- 15:33feels like the 90s Internet where you know, these companies
- 15:38are, you're not quite sure who's going to grab the most market
- 15:40share, especially within the block chains, the area, you
- 15:45know, Bitcoin is such a unique thing.
- 15:47That's again, I, I separate the 2.
- 15:50That's another thing that there's this tribal warfare
- 15:53sometimes, especially with the Maxis where if you say crypto
- 15:58and, and you actually mean Bitcoin in there, they get, so
- 16:02they get so pissed off. They're like, like, it's like
- 16:06I'm trying to think of a metaphor where like they're
- 16:08like, don't do you dare call me that?
- 16:14Don't push me with those plebs, you know, Anyway, it's really
- 16:19funny. Like the, that, that thing.
- 16:22But I, I do use crypto to mean everything and then I'll use
- 16:26Bitcoin separately. But I do agree with them that
- 16:30Bitcoin is kind of a special case.
- 16:33Yeah, 100%, Eric. So, yeah, there's a lot that we
- 16:37could talk about, a lot of different directions we can go
- 16:39in. I think important though, so you
- 16:42do mention your Gen. X in your Twitter bio.
- 16:45Is that because people are calling you a boomer so often on
- 16:49Twitter? But actually I've put that in
- 16:51before because I like, you know, if you're reading these Wall
- 16:56Street Journal or Financial Time, any time they write about
- 16:59generations, it's always millennials and boomers and they
- 17:02might mention Gen. Z.
- 17:03It's like we're just forgotten, like Gen.
- 17:06X. It's like, you know, I was like,
- 17:08dude, look at all of the great music we produced, the great
- 17:12artist artists, the great athletes, Tiger Woods, Tom
- 17:15Brady, like we've produced the greatest shit.
- 17:18You know, between it's people who really came into this work,
- 17:21you know, to came into the prime from 90 to 2000, like the 90s.
- 17:26I just feel like Gen. X is, I'm proud of my generation
- 17:29and it just feels like underrepresented.
- 17:31So I throw that in there. That way people also know to to
- 17:34get ready for some of my metaphors, which tend to be 80s
- 17:36and 90s heavy. Awesome.
- 17:40I love it. So all right, so you took us
- 17:41like 2013 Winklevoss twins. Dismiss Bitcoin as most people
- 17:46do on on the first pass. And then so you kind of took us
- 17:49to your rise in popularity because you had the background
- 17:53and professionalism to cover the Bitcoin ETFs.
- 17:56I'm curious when the ETFs are starting to get momentum and you
- 17:59guys are tracking ahead of approval.
- 18:01So summer 23 and then into approval 2024, what was your
- 18:06thoughts like? Were you already kind of
- 18:08convinced on Bitcoin as an asset class, as an investment?
- 18:11Did you understand the thesis or did you kind of have to
- 18:13understand that in real time as you were digging deep into the
- 18:17ETF complex? Yeah, real time.
- 18:20James knew more than me, so I could always lean on him a
- 18:22little bit. But sometimes, you know, again,
- 18:26he's he's a millennial, he's in, doesn't have the same reference
- 18:29points, but he's really good. But ultimately I've had to learn
- 18:32in real time everything. Like I used to do a show called
- 18:34ETF Friday every Friday and I just was covering ETF starting
- 18:38in 2007 and they'd be like, oh, we're not going to cover small
- 18:42caps today. We're going to do VIX because
- 18:43the VIX went up. I'm like, what shit?
- 18:45So I'd have to sometimes be a quick study on like, what is the
- 18:48VIX? What are VIX futures?
- 18:50So I ultimately in my coverage of ETF's, I would just download
- 18:52books from Amazon constantly. So I did that with Bitcoin and
- 18:56with the blockchain stuff and it just became a quick study enough
- 19:00to get me by and then over time going to conferences, you know,
- 19:04context clues. So I, I really learned it all on
- 19:08the fly. And I think I underrated a
- 19:13couple things with Bitcoin. I underrated how much Satoshi
- 19:18was standing on the shoulders of giants.
- 19:21You know, I've written a book about ETFs and I've written a
- 19:24book about Vanguard. And in both those cases, a lot
- 19:28of shit happened. You know, you talk about that
- 19:33connection of two ideas. In each of those cases, a bunch
- 19:37of stuff happened before that that idea was able to happen.
- 19:42And there were, you know, there were a lot of technological
- 19:47advances. There was a community, a scene.
- 19:51These were smart people. They were real libertarians.
- 19:56And so when Bitcoin was birthed, it was almost like it had, it
- 20:00had just taken like 80% of what was out there, added 20% and
- 20:04that was it. That's why it became the one.
- 20:07Same thing with spider spies, the first ETF there were.
- 20:10Index participation shares, there were multiple attempts at
- 20:14similar things and obviously index funds that existed for 20
- 20:17years. And so in each of these books
- 20:20I've written, it has that same consistency.
- 20:23When something is a big hit, it's never someone hitting their
- 20:25head in the toilet. Like I think the average person
- 20:28thinks like this dude, Satoshi just threw put a magical coin on
- 20:33the Internet. It's so much deeper than that
- 20:36and it's honestly a real, it's also a the indestructibility of
- 20:44it as a truly decentralized thing and how to make incentives
- 20:48work. There's so much go that goes
- 20:51into that design to pull it off and to pull off something that's
- 20:55decentralized and totally secure.
- 20:58It's worth them. It's worth something.
- 21:00I mean that alone. So I underrated that part for
- 21:04sure. And I underrated the scarcity.
- 21:06I guess I just never thought about it.
- 21:07But the idea that only 21 million Bitcoin can be mined and
- 21:11they were almost at that point, I mean, they're only like coming
- 21:14out in little tiny drips at this point.
- 21:16We'll just for all intents and purposes, like what is it?
- 21:1894% of the Bitcoin are done. So like that is powerful too,
- 21:23because in every other commodity there are, they have a way to
- 21:27get the commodity. This is 1 where you don't have
- 21:30that anyway. So those are some of the things
- 21:33I underrated about Bitcoin that I've evolved on a lot and it's
- 21:37made me take it even more seriously.
- 21:40And then with the flows into the ETFs, that's been, you know,
- 21:44something that has been pretty mind blowing as an analyst
- 21:47because they've broken like every conceivable conceivable
- 21:49record. But you could have those flows
- 21:52and have me still not respect Bitcoin, you know, I that's,
- 21:56that could happen. And I think there's probably ETF
- 21:58analysts out there that feel that way.
- 22:00They're probably like, oh God, I wish this wasn't a hit.
- 22:04I, I'm, you know, but for me, I've, you know, something else
- 22:08that we've noticed again, James and I are working on a book
- 22:10about this, but we've interviewed all these people.
- 22:13Two things we've noticed. It's rare that someone goes deep
- 22:16into studying it and doesn't increase their allocation.
- 22:20Like, I've never seen somebody go, yeah, you know, this is
- 22:22fucked up. I'm, I'm going to go buy back to
- 22:25stocks. They typically get more into it.
- 22:28It's like there's a direct correlation between the amount
- 22:31you learn and the amount you allocate.
- 22:33The other thing is even people who say to recommend 1 to 2% for
- 22:38a normal person into Bitcoin, they themselves are like 20% or
- 22:43more. And this reminds me of ETF.
- 22:45So I would interview these institutions about their usage
- 22:49of hedge funds and all these like expensive type stuff.
- 22:52And I would say, what do you do? You use these this stuff in your
- 22:55personal account? They'd be like, no, for my
- 22:56personal account, I used to use cheap ETF's by Vanguard, but
- 22:59they wouldn't do it at their job.
- 23:01And I love those disconnects. And I find it here with some
- 23:05people, I think they're afraid to tell anybody to like follow
- 23:09them into being like 2030% because just in case it blows up
- 23:14or there's a problem, they don't want to hear it.
- 23:15But it is interesting that there's that gap.
- 23:18So those things also, you know, make me respect it and
- 23:26understand it more. But I am the classic case of, of
- 23:30somebody who, you know, kind of got at least half orange peeled.
- 23:33I, I don't think I could be fully orange peeled because I am
- 23:36a Bogle head. I wrote about Jack Bogle and
- 23:40Vanguard and I'm a true index fund guy.
- 23:41I like cash flows. So by being a true index fund
- 23:45investor and really appreciating stocks, bonds, not so much, but
- 23:49mostly stock investing, especially U.S. stocks, I'm
- 23:52never going to sell all that. And so I do feel like being a
- 23:56Boglehead and understanding, you know, why stocks are good
- 24:00investments. It gives me some level of
- 24:02vaccination from being totally orange peeled and being like,
- 24:05I'm at, I'm done, you know, sell everything, put it into Bitcoin.
- 24:09I'm not, I'm not anywhere near there.
- 24:11So that's where I'm where I am now.
- 24:15There's so much there and this is like watching, I would have
- 24:18said Boomer, but you said clearly said Gen.
- 24:21Xer. This is watching Gen.
- 24:22Xer in real time get orange filled and go through that
- 24:25because a couple things you referenced and Jackson pulled
- 24:28up, there was a Cornell study and this is something that we
- 24:30need to get better on our side about is like most people do.
- 24:33They've heard of Bitcoin, but they've never they don't know
- 24:35there's only 21 million and that's like foundational to the
- 24:39whole thing that the finite scarcity.
- 24:40So the second most people hear that there's only 21 million, it
- 24:44naturally means that there's some value there, potentially
- 24:46value if it's valued at 100K. And then it's just like
- 24:49underwriting that. Personally, the thing you
- 24:51mentioned about the one way St., there's a lot of weight because
- 24:54I've been in this space professionally since 20/19/20,
- 24:58but then was trying to get in back in 2018, was interviewing
- 25:01with a lot of the Genesis guys back in the day and they're all
- 25:03still around somewhere. Like so not only is it mental
- 25:06and personal capacity from a balance sheet, but also
- 25:09professional capacities. Like people don't come into the
- 25:11space and leave like it's just there.
- 25:14And where that ties into there's the component of everything you
- 25:20described about the shoulder of giants.
- 25:23You can basically, if you switch the word, it's gold.
- 25:26Like what we're what we're watching today is gold.
- 25:29If you think about thousands of years when people figured out
- 25:32gold had relative value, well, it didn't happen overnight.
- 25:34There was all these different people trading different rocks
- 25:37and then other people were trying to scam them out of other
- 25:38rocks. And then ultimately money has
- 25:41this liquidity profile and the more liquidity begets more
- 25:44liquidity and it's the ultimate market or the ultimate protocol.
- 25:46And so that's what we're talking about here is that you only get
- 25:51that once that finite scarcity. And so to your point about not
- 25:56being the ultimate maxi, where I was joking is like, that's where
- 25:59you will get because all you're going to want is equity that
- 26:01delivers more Bitcoin. So we have a whole venture arm
- 26:04that's just Bitcoin denominated. We only invest in companies that
- 26:07produce more Bitcoin and deliver it back.
- 26:09And that's where you get at the when you go far enough down this
- 26:11rabbit hole as you're like, oh, wait, I want more Bitcoin.
- 26:14And so you're ultimately invest in things that deliver more
- 26:18Bitcoin because that's kind of just the rational thing to do is
- 26:21if you're long Bitcoin as so anyway that that kind of is,
- 26:25it's very interesting how you've kind of gone through that and
- 26:26you're probably right there in the middle, but there will be a
- 26:29part when you come out the other side because you're honest with
- 26:31yourself, which is amazing because most people aren't
- 26:33honest in your shoes. And they're like, and this
- 26:34thing's just an asset. And I just need 4%.
- 26:38And to your point, a lot of people don't tell people to do
- 26:40anything more than that simply because most people can't handle
- 26:42the volatility. And so if they don't have the
- 26:45level of knowledge and and research you've done, then
- 26:47they're going to sell or they're going to sell when it double S
- 26:49when we know this is like a longer game than that.
- 26:53I also think the, I think the volatility shook out a lot of
- 26:57the casual tourists who bought it because Tom Brady advertised
- 27:00it in FTX and that whole last and I don't think they're coming
- 27:04back just yet. I think a lot of the newer
- 27:07investors are from the more up, you know, intelligent retail
- 27:12wing and advisors who buy the ETFs because ETFs are usually
- 27:15bought by smart people, not like dumb GameStop type investors,
- 27:19but more like intelligent logical retail.
- 27:23And so I think bitcoins getting better owners and I think it
- 27:26will bring the volatility down, not that it won't ever have a
- 27:29huge sell off. I'd have to it had to be have
- 27:31some Black Swan event. I think I don't see anything in
- 27:33the future that is such a huge wall of worry.
- 27:38It's mostly good narratives, but there, you know, you can't rule
- 27:42out a Black Swan. But I do feel like most people
- 27:44who buy it through the ETF probably are like 2-3 percent
- 27:48and in in which is good is because they have this boring
- 27:51core of Vanguard funds that they consider for like the real
- 27:55stuff. So this is like a small hot, I
- 27:57call it hot sauce on top. And I think that gives them more
- 28:01intestinal fortitude to withstand some of the
- 28:04volatility, even if they're not orange peeled.
- 28:06If they don't get this, I you know, I also think there's a
- 28:09place for Bitcoin if you're just somebody who gets pissed if you
- 28:14missed out later. It's almost like I don't even
- 28:17understand it, but I don't want to have FOMO later.
- 28:19And that's fine. You know, people invest in
- 28:21certain stocks and there's thematic ETFs that are the same
- 28:24thing, like uranium, like, OK, it's not really represented in
- 28:27my S&P 500, but like, I don't want to have FOMO.
- 28:30If we go completely nuclear for energy, I'll buy a uranium ETF
- 28:33just so I don't kick myself later because I had that idea.
- 28:36So I do think. We call those we call those
- 28:39spike corners. Spike corners.
- 28:42Spike corners because you, you brought it up before we jumped.
- 28:47So what happens? What happens if Yeah, I got a My
- 28:52mother-in-law was a Spike coiner because she couldn't, she
- 28:55couldn't let it work. Out there's a guy we interviewed
- 28:57for the book who is definitely a spike coiner.
- 29:00I mean, yeah, he that's really good.
- 29:04That's spike coiner is really good.
- 29:05We have a section of the book called Suit Coiners which is
- 29:09like which you can guess what that is Spike I.
- 29:11Wouldn't consider you a suit coiner.
- 29:13I think you you you passed the after this combo.
- 29:15You're you're not a suit coiner for sure.
- 29:18But real quick though, what happens if North North Korea
- 29:21hacks Coinbase? Yeah, no, this is the cut.
- 29:24That's a Black Swan in my opinion.
- 29:26Now this Coinbase issue is interesting.
- 29:30At some point if a, if somebody hacks, you know, XYZ third rated
- 29:36Ethereum exchange, that's the exchange's problem and the
- 29:40investor's problem. But if Coinbase is almost the
- 29:43size where it's, it would be everybody's problem.
- 29:47The government would have to step in, I think.
- 29:51And print more Bitcoin. I don't know, they'd have to.
- 29:56There's a point where I think if something gets.
- 30:00How would they print more Bitcoin?
- 30:04Well, let's go over this. If somebody hacked Bitcoin
- 30:08Coinbase, first of all, in this day and age, don't you think
- 30:12they'd find them pretty quickly? I mean, I just watched that.
- 30:17I mean, can't they can trace the wallets?
- 30:22You don't think? They What if they hacked it and
- 30:24burned the keys like in Iran? I mean, this is a lot of money.
- 30:29Like would the people never spend the money?
- 30:35What I meant like burn the keys like I know.
- 30:38This is, in other words, tackling.
- 30:39Just burn the keys and never use.
- 30:41Yeah, yeah, just for fun. They they were just for fun.
- 30:44Would this be like an Ethereum maxi who just wants to fuck?
- 30:48I'm joking emotionally, just. Mayhem.
- 30:52Yeah, No, no, I'm partially joking just because that's that
- 30:55that's a a thing. I think the overarching deal,
- 31:01and this is a real philosophical thing that the suit coiners
- 31:04don't get is there are no bailouts in Bitcoin like full
- 31:09stop. Now if if you have a certain
- 31:12size, then you might have the balance sheet of somebody to
- 31:16step in. But the core idea is everyone's
- 31:19long term view of the asset is up into the right.
- 31:22So at a certain point your balance sheet can't step in.
- 31:25And so the bailout is the government printing more dollars
- 31:28to buy Bitcoin in the open market.
- 31:30It's kind of like a proxy for FDIC.
- 31:32It's like, sure, you'll get made whole on your 250, but they're
- 31:34going to have to print a bunch of money.
- 31:35So you're really losing out in purchasing power.
- 31:38This is. Why the OK first of all, would
- 31:41this hack be the cold storage of Coinbase or the hot wallet?
- 31:47Well, it doesn't necessarily have to be Coinbase, like
- 31:49Fidelity is another great example because if you say like
- 31:51Fidelity holds 20% of the ETFs and the market cap goes to
- 31:55$1,000,000 per coin. So what does that put us at 10X
- 31:59from here? So it's $20 trillion.
- 32:01Well, Fidelity holds, let's just say they hold 20% of that 20
- 32:05million. So they have 4 million, $4
- 32:07trillion, Fidelity loses the assets, right, Fidelity?
- 32:12Let's go over the losing of the assets.
- 32:14You're saying somebody's going to hack into the cold storage?
- 32:18You got to be careful Eric, because I'm going to tell you
- 32:19that six months ago Fidelity lost all their clients data.
- 32:22It's all like all open, the most secure thing that they would
- 32:25have. So again, but in your scenario,
- 32:27are we talking about hacking into cold storage?
- 32:31Well, there's multiple levels of hacking in the cold storage.
- 32:34There can be collusion because the idea is the the core idea is
- 32:38like an ROI return increases with time, meaning it can be a
- 32:4310 year game. Like there's a lot of different
- 32:47and the easy example probably is simply we've never seen an
- 32:50exchange last longer than X. Yeah.
- 32:55I mean, look, I, over time there will be a dilution of the
- 33:00custodians because Coinbase was early and like the most
- 33:03legitimate at the time that all the ETF started.
- 33:06But Fidelity is doing, I think their own and somebody else.
- 33:09And like Schwab is going to let actual just crypto trade on the,
- 33:14that they're going to trade. The banks can now custody it.
- 33:18And the custodian fees for Coinbase.
- 33:20I, I, they don't print them, but I believe they're pretty hefty.
- 33:23So in the ETF world, they're always competing on like cutting
- 33:26fees. And like we've seen on the
- 33:28stocks and gold world, an issuer will move from like, I don't
- 33:33know, JP Morgan to State Street to save like 2 bits.
- 33:36So I think over time, Coinbase will lose some of that business.
- 33:41So I do think they'll be a natural dilution in the gold
- 33:44world. What they do like GLD stores the
- 33:47assets in London, but IAU came around and said, hey, we're
- 33:51going to store it in London, Toronto and New York.
- 33:54So like they're they'll be probably a time where they
- 33:58evolve into storing it into different places just to
- 34:01minimize that outside Black Swan risk.
- 34:05The other thing is most of the Bitcoin is in in a cold storage,
- 34:08not a hot wallet, which I think the last hack, I forget the name
- 34:12of it, but it was a hot wallet that got hacked, not it wasn't
- 34:15in cold storage, which is I think easier to hack.
- 34:18Again, I'm a little out of my area here.
- 34:20But ultimately though, I think when it comes down to this, if
- 34:24you're an ETF investor, you have to look at the track record of a
- 34:27Black Rock and Fidelity. And yeah, they're not perfect,
- 34:32but you either trust them or you don't.
- 34:35And I think for the most part, people trust.
- 34:37That's why them coming in was so big, because they are lending
- 34:41their brand and trust to this area and they're not fucking
- 34:44around, man. I mean, they're not like going
- 34:48to, they're going to take every precaution necessary.
- 34:52But yeah, it's definitely something.
- 34:53And then Quantum obviously is a risk down the road.
- 34:57And there's just like, you know, it's a, it's something that
- 35:01people have to consider. And so if someone wanted to go
- 35:05and get their own wallet, we totally advise that.
- 35:08Like if, if this is something that even worries you a little
- 35:11or if you're in Bitcoin because you think there's going to be a
- 35:14societal collapse and we're going to go into Mad Max world,
- 35:17you want your own wallet. So we tell people if you are one
- 35:21of those people, gold has the same thing.
- 35:23There are gold bugs and there are they truly paranoid and
- 35:27there's actually an ETF that lets you get your gold delivered
- 35:30to you. They do have retail redemptions
- 35:34and there's a gold that stores the gold in Switzerland only
- 35:37because just in case these other Western countries have known to
- 35:41take the gold. So I think the Bitcoin ETS space
- 35:44will evolve to kind of account for some of what you're saying
- 35:48and to appeal to possibly like the real hardcore paranoid.
- 35:52Yeah. So I think we're both probably
- 35:55saying the same thing because I think we do trust, you know, I
- 35:58think Fidelity and Coinbase being hacked and all that's very
- 36:01long tail risk. I think the best mental model to
- 36:05use is what we're describing is like if we were using e-mail and
- 36:09we're explaining the Internet and it's like, well, I don't get
- 36:13it. And it's like, well, yeah,
- 36:14because we don't know what it looks like.
- 36:15And so the angle I'm referencing here is today the way you're
- 36:19talking about ETFs and how most people talk about ETFs is the
- 36:22pre coiner person buying 123 percent.
- 36:25But if we go down the logical progression year in the middle
- 36:28of you ultimately will have anywhere between 20 to 80 plus
- 36:31percent of your wealth and Bitcoin.
- 36:33And when that happens, it's the same thing of if you bought fire
- 36:36insurance on your house like this is the progression of like
- 36:38how this plays out because. Your progression?
- 36:41Is this the person increasing the allocation on their own, or
- 36:44just that Bitcoin went up so much it actually ate up their
- 36:47portfolio? Both because they're looking
- 36:49basically how it's performing against everything else.
- 36:51But so let me just finish the the thread.
- 36:53So that's the logical progression for like you said
- 36:57that most people as they get more educated, they increase
- 36:59their exposure. And So what happens there is
- 37:02very similar to like why you buy house insurance.
- 37:04You don't expect for your house to burn down, but if it does,
- 37:07you can't get knocked out of the game into the logical
- 37:09progression for the hardcore people.
- 37:11And This is why half of the 2 trillion sits on those hardware
- 37:14devices. I'm not saying that's the right
- 37:15move. I'm just explaining to you the
- 37:16rationale is because for 15 years, the only way to actually
- 37:20know that your house wasn't going to burn down was to sever
- 37:22the Internet connection. And if somebody's holding 80% of
- 37:25their wealth, the rational thing to do is not to leave it with a
- 37:28single custodian because even if there's .01% that that could
- 37:31happen, if it happens, you lose all of your wealth.
- 37:34The last thing I'll say is we've never seen digital scarcity in
- 37:37our whole entire life. So we actually don't know how to
- 37:39manage it. And two trillion is
- 37:40fundamentally different than 20 trillion.
- 37:42So to expect that some firm like a BlackRock knows how they're to
- 37:46do it is just kind of doesn't make any sense or Fidelity.
- 37:49Yeah, I don't know. It wouldn't go that far.
- 37:51Like BlackRock and Fidelity have both hired people from the
- 37:53crypto world. But also the other thing is,
- 37:57again, this is something that has been totally a worry with
- 38:00gold. When gold ETFs came out, they
- 38:02were, they were thoughts they would like rob the trucks or
- 38:05people. People didn't think the gold was
- 38:07there and then the gold. Well, the government robbed all
- 38:11the gold. That's the point.
- 38:12Well that was in the 20s, but the gold isn't like or about
- 38:18100. Years, 100 years later.
- 38:20No, I get you. Like that's what I'm saying.
- 38:22If you go and and if you're somebody who even like starts to
- 38:26talk about how FDR confiscated gold, get your wallet, get your
- 38:30own wallet like you, you should do this on your own.
- 38:33You should and then print the phrases on dog tags and then
- 38:37bury them in three different spots in three different
- 38:39countries. That's the route that there is a
- 38:43Bitcoin investment path for everybody.
- 38:46But to your point, as if we look in a world where it's like 80%
- 38:50of most people portfolios, I'm sorry, that's that's, that is
- 38:54the America's problem. Hang on.
- 38:58Like it almost becomes too big to fail at that point.
- 39:02So can I start in here for a second?
- 39:05But I don't, I don't like disagree.
- 39:07I I I probably give a little more faith to the Black Rock
- 39:12infidelities of the world simply because they do have a track
- 39:15record, but. You're not really trusting Black
- 39:17Rock or Fidelity, you're ultimately trusting who they've
- 39:19outsourced it to which. Is why, of course, yeah, but
- 39:21you're I'm trusting them to pick good partners that I mean real
- 39:30quick at the end of the day, you know and I we've gone over this
- 39:33for years and ETFs every now and then there's like the huge sell
- 39:36off and like some ETF sees a discount.
- 39:39That's not normal because a market maker wouldn't make the
- 39:42market. And so over the years I have
- 39:45come to this conclusion that the ETF is but the thing here and
- 39:49beneath it is a whole ecosystem that has to that works everyday
- 39:53using market makers and APS and all this shit.
- 39:56And at the end of the day, the ETF gets the blame even if
- 40:01something over here was the problem and they know this.
- 40:05So I think we're like all kind of on the same page here.
- 40:08And I also would say that this is just the function of Bitcoin
- 40:12being a newer technology, a newer asset class, right?
- 40:15So we're still in the early stages of figuring this out.
- 40:17I think we should remember as well that the ETFs have only
- 40:20existed for 18 months and prior to that, right, people were
- 40:24telling what Eric said. You you stamp your seed phrase
- 40:27and steal and you distribute it in multiple different
- 40:30geographies or you just leave your Bitcoin on a Coinbase
- 40:33account. I think what we need to do
- 40:35though is kind of go back to what I think is one of the
- 40:38biggest stories in finance right now and would be very remiss not
- 40:42to talk about it. And that is just the meteoric
- 40:47rise of the Bitcoin ETFs. Like we kind of we kind of
- 40:50jumped over what I think is one of the most critical stories and
- 40:54what most people outside of this Bitcoin ecosystem and you know,
- 40:59investment community are talking about.
- 41:01So, Eric, I would love to go back to this maybe before we go
- 41:05into more discussion around custody and you know, in kind
- 41:08redemption, some of the things we wanted to talk about because
- 41:11you, like I said at the top of the episode, you and James have
- 41:14done a phenomenal job of tracking all of this.
- 41:17And so you've covered extensively the success of IBIT,
- 41:21in particular, the fastest growing ETF by a wide margin in
- 41:25terms of major milestones for assets under management.
- 41:29It's now the 20th largest ETF. Yeah, that's a great chart, 20th
- 41:33largest ETF. And I don't think we need to
- 41:35move that much higher in the Bitcoin price for it to be the
- 41:37top 15, top 10. So I'd love to just hear your
- 41:41thoughts, like, can you help contextualize the success of the
- 41:45ETFs? Because I still think it's not
- 41:47fully appreciated. And I think you're the perfect
- 41:50person to kind of take us from January of 2024 to about 18
- 41:55months later, July of 2025. Yeah.
- 41:59So I can't understate overstate it.
- 42:03It was the greatest launch in the history of ETFs since day
- 42:06one, really just out of the gate.
- 42:09I, I'll give you like maybe two or three stats and then you
- 42:12know, I won't over talk it because the stats will do the
- 42:15most the talking. But the Bitcoin ETFs have 153
- 42:18billion, OK, That's just almost as much as gold ETFs have.
- 42:21And they've been out 20 years, right?
- 42:24That's just about where gold is. And that's 1.5 years.
- 42:28So that right there gold to me would be their bogey because
- 42:33it's a very similar type of trade store of value.
- 42:37So to be tied about with gold, there was a time where it beat
- 42:40gold and gold had to run. But they're they're kind of in
- 42:42the same ballpark already, right?
- 42:45We think they'll triple gold ultimately.
- 42:48The other thing is I bid alone is the fastest ETF to $80
- 42:55billion. It did it in 341 days.
- 42:58The next fastest was like 1600 days.
- 43:02So we're talking over 4 times faster than any other ETF.
- 43:05And the other ETFs that got there that are around that 1600
- 43:08day mark are from Vanguard and BlackRock, right?
- 43:10These are like mega ETFs. There you go.
- 43:14Vu IFAI mean these are studs. Those are both in the top 10 all
- 43:18of all ETFs. So if your if your record is if
- 43:23you're that much faster than than these studs, It's not like
- 43:26those other ETFs were flashes in the pan.
- 43:27They were like they're legit legends still, so that's a good
- 43:32sign. It means you are four times
- 43:34faster than a legendary ETF. The other stat is now as you
- 43:39said, I bits no 20th in in the top is the 20th biggest ETF.
- 43:45And that is interesting because of the other 19 on the list, the
- 43:51the next youngest is like 12 1/2 years old and I bits 1 1/2 year
- 43:56old. So it's like a toddler hanging
- 43:58out with teenagers. That's insane.
- 44:00And then to add more around the 88 billion mark, which is where
- 44:05IBIT is now, it becomes the most profitable ETF that BlackRock
- 44:09has #1 it's rate or you know, let's just assume it goes to 90
- 44:14in the next couple weeks, it will be the most profitable.
- 44:17And then they have 1100 ETFs around the world.
- 44:21So that's insane. So those are all just very the
- 44:25other, the other stat that's really fascinating is if you
- 44:27look at the holders, the only people who we know hold it have
- 44:33to file A13F, which is you have to have over $100 million.
- 44:36So it's like medium to big size fish half the file amongst those
- 44:40filings. The I bit has like over 1000
- 44:45filers represented in only the first five quarters.
- 44:49And if you add them, all of them together, all the Bitcoin ETFs,
- 44:52it's something like 1600 different institutional filers
- 44:56represented. If you take some other ETFs
- 44:59launched in January 2024, they're going to have like 10 to
- 45:0420 filers, right? It that's almost more impressive
- 45:10because it's easy to get little retail investors to bite on
- 45:14something new. It's like getting, you know, if
- 45:16you're ever going fishing, it's easy to get minnows and small
- 45:18fish to bite, harder to get the medium sized fish and really
- 45:22hard to get the big fish. It's the same thing for ETFs.
- 45:25Big fish need volume and like legitimacy and big brand.
- 45:29It takes a lot, but these ETFs have gotten medium fish early
- 45:33and a couple big fish and that normally doesn't happen until
- 45:36you're 3 or 4. So a lot, all, everything that
- 45:40would normally happen in like 10 years has happened in a year and
- 45:44a half. Hope you're enjoying the
- 45:46episode. If you could just do us a favor
- 45:49and drop a like and leave a comment on YouTube, that really
- 45:52helps a lot. If you're not subscribed
- 45:53already, please do that as well. We really appreciate it on
- 45:57Spotify, Apple five star rating. All these things help.
- 46:00We spend a lot of time booking guests and then actually
- 46:03preparing for the episodes to make sure it's a good use of
- 46:05your time and then recording, of course, editing and distributing
- 46:10them. So please, if you can, just
- 46:13leave a like a comment doesn't take too long and it goes a long
- 46:16way for us. And we hope to have Eric back
- 46:19on. So show him some love if you can
- 46:21in the comments section. Leave him a like we want to have
- 46:24him back on, especially as his book is published.
- 46:27And we'll want to reassess how Bitcoin is growing maybe the
- 46:31next six months or so where the ETF's are tracking.
- 46:34And yeah, hope you enjoy it the rest of the episode.
- 46:37Also, if you're not subscribed, check out our research on
- 46:40rampbitcoin.com/research. Yeah.
- 46:43I mean, that's a great recap there and one thing too.
- 46:47So it ties into what you just one of the points you just
- 46:49mentioned about Black Rocks ETF being the most profitable ETF
- 46:53and you said over 1000 ETF's in their complex as a firm.
- 46:57And then something you mentioned earlier is about incentives,
- 47:00right, and how Bitcoin aligns incentives over time.
- 47:03And I'd just be curious your thoughts on Larry Fink, not him
- 47:08in particular, but him as an edge case or an example where
- 47:11seven years ago, right, Bitcoin is an index for money
- 47:15laundering. And now whether he actually
- 47:18understands Bitcoin or he believes in its merits as an
- 47:21investable asset, he is a proponent of it because it is
- 47:26the most profitable ETF that his firm offers.
- 47:28So just curious like what you're input, what you think the
- 47:30implications are for this for traditional finance?
- 47:34And I'll just tie this in right before I hand it over.
- 47:36I'll tie this into one thing that Brian flagged ahead of this
- 47:41call as well, with T Rowe Price doing layoffs more recently, and
- 47:46they're a firm that really hasn't adopted Bitcoin in any
- 47:48meaningful way. Not to say that's the sole
- 47:50reason, but I'm curious to hear the dichotomy in your opinion
- 47:53between firms that embrace it and firms that choose to
- 47:55continue to ignore it. Yeah, you actually just gave me
- 47:58an idea of Bitcoin could could help.
- 48:03So OK, Sorry. Thank you for that T row.
- 48:09By the way, is is is Bitcoin would have helped T row, you
- 48:13know, or something, but they were late to the ETF game and
- 48:17they were late to find an answer to passive and Vanguard.
- 48:21Some of these old legacy 1990s mutual fund companies were just
- 48:26late to deal with the massive disruption that was Vanguard low
- 48:29cost in ETFs. That said, they stocks these
- 48:33mutual funds own going up a lot and have offset a lot of the
- 48:37outflows. So T row still makes a ton of
- 48:39money, but they lose customers because a lot of the assets
- 48:43become more mirage assets than actual new customers.
- 48:46Fidelity is probably a good example of somebody who got hit
- 48:48by that same problem, but they did go heavy into crypto and I
- 48:51think it's helped them. They also went heavy into some
- 48:54other things and saying Fidelity and BlackRock are two examples
- 48:58of firms where because of the Vanguard effect.
- 49:00And you know, I wrote a book called the Bogle effect.
- 49:02That's the guy who started Vanguard because so many people
- 49:05have gone to cheap index funds for their like stocks and bonds.
- 49:09It's Rob Wall Street of a lot of money.
- 49:11And so over the years, the firms that have thrived and managed to
- 49:15deal with the Vanguard effect best are ones that have been
- 49:17real aggressive. I call it hustle points.
- 49:20You know, they're diving for loose balls and Larry Fink is
- 49:22the ultimate hustle point CEO. I would say BlackRock is the
- 49:27equivalent of like a 12 year NBA All Star who still dives for
- 49:30loose balls. That is how you handle dealing
- 49:34with Vanguard. That's how hard Vanguard is to
- 49:36deal with because they're basically a nonprofit anyway.
- 49:40BlackRock, I think went into Bitcoin be for two reasons.
- 49:44One, opportunism. But you know, they have this
- 49:47public stock. You know, BLK is the ticker.
- 49:49They have to appease shareholders.
- 49:51So as they cut fees to appease to investors, they got to also
- 49:55make money to appeal to shareholders.
- 49:57They've got to serve 2 gods at once.
- 49:59And Bitcoin allowed them to get a new source of revenue because
- 50:03a big thing they were into that died, died down a lot was ESG.
- 50:07And so Bitcoin became like a new opportunity set for them.
- 50:11They also, I give him credit for just keeping an open mind
- 50:14because there's other people who have the same goal, but either
- 50:18their brains are closed or their politics is so strong.
- 50:23They're just, they still crap on it.
- 50:26At least Larry Fink was like, let me let me rethink about
- 50:30this. Let me listen to some of the
- 50:31younger people because there's one guy in his firm, Robbie
- 50:34Bitchnick, who by all accounts deserves a lot of credit.
- 50:38He came from XRP, but it took him like 7-8 years internally
- 50:42there. I think he was.
- 50:43I want to say he was hired in 2013 or 2015, something like
- 50:47that. So he, he was there for a long
- 50:50time before they followed for a bit, but I'm sure he was in
- 50:54people's ears talking about it. And so ultimately though,
- 50:58BlackRock was smart to hire him, right?
- 51:01That was pretty good foresight to hire somebody from that world
- 51:05and just bring them on board. So I think BlackRock deserves a
- 51:08lot of credit for being flexible and having, you know, that
- 51:11mental liquidity. But ultimately I don't, I don't
- 51:15know, I can't peer until Larry Fink's brain to see if this was
- 51:19how genuine this was. But I will say one thing that I
- 51:22have in my slides when I do Bitcoin presentations at these
- 51:25conferences is I show I, I talk about BlackRock being massive.
- 51:30And it wasn't just the ETF. Larry Fink himself went on CNBC
- 51:34and Fox Business. And the stuff he was saying was
- 51:37seemingly radical coming from Larry Fink.
- 51:39He was like, hey, if you think the government's, you know,
- 51:42totally debasing your currency or if there's going to be like,
- 51:45like, this is a way to protect your money.
- 51:46I mean, that is pretty crazy. And then you've got these
- 51:51wholesalers like Jay Jacobs, I'm telling you, who could sell ice
- 51:54to Boomer Eskimos. He's like down in Brazil talking
- 51:59about Bitcoin with that purchasing power of the dollar
- 52:02chart, you know, since the Fed came out.
- 52:04I mean, he's like, this is like serious orange pill type type
- 52:08stuff, but he's delivering it through institutional language
- 52:13and boomer tones and boomer dress.
- 52:16That's why the, I think the term Sue Corners is perfect.
- 52:19And that to me is very powerful. And that is also what you don't
- 52:24see with gold. I don't see anything like that.
- 52:26You know, I go to all the conferences.
- 52:27I don't see any, nowhere near the excitement and wholesale
- 52:31firepower aimed at gold. They all have gold ETS, but
- 52:35there's nobody talking like this and nobody doing this.
- 52:38So you can't overstate the importance of BlackRock, in my
- 52:42opinion. Bitcoin, you know, and again,
- 52:45you could disagree with this. It has two errors.
- 52:48It's almost like BE and AE before ETF and after ETF, but
- 52:52you could almost say BB before BlackRock.
- 52:55When that filing hit, the price was 28,000 or something.
- 52:59It immediately caused this by the rumor rally of 100% so that
- 53:05it doubled just on the filing. Then when the ETF came out,
- 53:08people thought, OK, that's it, it'll be the sell the news and
- 53:11can't you know, it went back up. So I did the math.
- 53:13It's up something like 280% since that filing, and it never
- 53:18looked back. And I think the ETF also
- 53:20legitimized it because remember when the filings were out and it
- 53:23hadn't been approved, there was a question of whether any APS
- 53:26would be willing to name themselves in the documents.
- 53:29Because if you can't have an AP, you wouldn't get it approved.
- 53:31But Jane St. stepped up and you got to thank them because they
- 53:35filled in that AP slot. That was crucial.
- 53:38After the Bitcoin ETF came out and it was hugely successful,
- 53:41the other big banks were like, you can put our names in there
- 53:43now too. And so, you know, Christian
- 53:46Laettner has a great phrase in that 30 for 30 documentary
- 53:50called I hate Christian Laettner because he was like kind of a
- 53:54prickly guy on Duke in the 90's, the basketball player.
- 53:58And he was like winning cures all.
- 53:59Like you may think I'm a Dick at practice, but when we won that
- 54:03championship, like we were all friends again.
- 54:05And this is sort of what Bitcoin I think is doing.
- 54:09It's kind of cured a lot of the skepticism and like second
- 54:12guessing. Then you throw in the Trump
- 54:15election and it's a done deal. I think ultimately it's been
- 54:18completely mainstreamed. It's there's no stigma attached
- 54:20at all. And really, I think the only
- 54:23people who are continuing to crap on it or not use it are
- 54:26just, you know, either they've just made an investment decision
- 54:31that they do think it's going to eventually go down, which is
- 54:33fine. Or there's a anchor bias issue
- 54:37where they attach it with Trump and they don't like him, where
- 54:40they attach it with SBF and they think there's just too much
- 54:43fraud. And that's, you know, that's
- 54:47their problem, I guess. But the big BLOB of like
- 54:50financial mainstream ecosystem is pretty much diving in.
- 54:56And I think the ETF started that snowball.
- 54:59Yeah, I think we tend to agree. There's the notion of nobody
- 55:02wants to catch a falling knife, especially institutional capital
- 55:05or wealthy capital. And the ETF was that first like
- 55:08signal that this is coming. I think it's kind of remarkable
- 55:12when you think about we got to $2 trillion market cap with no
- 55:15regulatory clarity and it's starting to to get clearer.
- 55:18How do you think about the ETF exposure and then what we're
- 55:21seeing this past year with the Treasury and public listing
- 55:25exposure and just thinking through, you know, how is that
- 55:28proxy happening? Is, you know, the, the
- 55:30assumption or the thing we kind of go with is the notion of it's
- 55:33hard to put Bitcoin in a bucket, right?
- 55:35You have a 6040 and then you have this commodity sitting
- 55:38there. And some of the assumption is
- 55:39that it's easier to put in equity with Bitcoin exposure
- 55:42into that. And that's some of the demand.
- 55:44Is that what how you think about it?
- 55:46Or how do you think about the fervor?
- 55:47Because it feels like it's just pick, it's just starting.
- 55:49We're only at. 100 and. 20K we have a lot more room to run
- 55:52there. Well, you know, MicroStrategy
- 55:55filled the void that was there for because there was no ETF.
- 55:59They became the surrogate ETF for a while.
- 56:01Makes total sense. And strategy is just like this
- 56:05very unique situation. These other treasury companies,
- 56:08though, I, I do wonder how much I don't totally get it given
- 56:14there are ETFs unless you're just a fan of the CEO.
- 56:17But I've heard one thing where it's a way for like O GS to kind
- 56:21of like get their Bitcoin off chain a little bit and then get
- 56:27get shares of the company and then they can like better manage
- 56:30cashing out a little bit if they want to rather than like moving
- 56:32old coins. I don't know, I've heard that is
- 56:35one reason to do it, but I don't see any of them getting too big.
- 56:39I think MicroStrategy will be like dominant and these other
- 56:42ones will, you know, I don't know.
- 56:45There's my only thing is like leverage is a double edged
- 56:49sword. So if you're going to have
- 56:51leverage, it's it'll help on the way up, but it'll hurt on the
- 56:54way down. And I do worry about that a
- 56:57little bit. Now the other side of it is I
- 57:00think most people will pick an ETFI mean if you look at the
- 57:03assets, I mean the ETFs as a whole have 1.4 bit million
- 57:08Bitcoin as a group. I think MicroStrategy is only
- 57:11half that. The other treasuries are nickel
- 57:13dime rounding errors. So they have double all of those
- 57:18already. So I think most people prefer to
- 57:20get one. For one, I want to buy the ETF
- 57:22and just have a track Bitcoin and that's always been the case
- 57:25in ETS. People love that direct
- 57:27physically backed exposure if they can get it.
- 57:29That's why the Bitcoin futures, ETF's weren't really that big of
- 57:32a deal. And so I think those will
- 57:34dominate. But I where are they in the
- 57:36portfolio? That's a great question.
- 57:39There's a lot of answers to this.
- 57:40Personally I think a lot of people are losing faith in bonds
- 57:43because the ag bond index hasn't kept up with inflation, doesn't
- 57:47even hedge you that well and sell offs anymore.
- 57:50So I think bonds may take a little haircut.
- 57:52Also if you are trying to hedge inflation this could be seen as
- 57:56a store of value and be in your alternative bucket if you have
- 57:59that. But it's a little volatile still
- 58:01so it also could be replacement for some mag 7 stocks.
- 58:05Bitcoin is just highly unique in that regard.
- 58:08Personally, I would probably trim my equity portion just to
- 58:13be safe because I, I don't know, you cannot rely on it as a, as a
- 58:17hedge for your whole portfolio or if the stock market implodes
- 58:21it, it may go down just as much. And so I think you have to look
- 58:25at it as a hedge for the global money printer and a
- 58:28technological opportunity and that and because it's
- 58:32volatility, I think you'd have to put it in alts or equity.
- 58:35But there are certainly other parts of the portfolio they're
- 58:38losing some of their appeal and namely bonds.
- 58:41And so there's a lot of opportunity right now, I think
- 58:44for these this whole world to sort of get into that 6040
- 58:47portfolio in the next several years.
- 58:50But generally speaking, we have this chart called the Modern
- 58:54Portfolio and we have it, it says 85% cheap beta, which would
- 58:58be like stocks and bonds and Vanguard index funds for like 3
- 59:01basis points. So it's like beta, you know what
- 59:04I mean? You know what beta is, right?
- 59:05OK. So cheap beta and then 15% hot
- 59:09sauce. And that would be like, I think
- 59:12crypto would fit in there perfectly.
- 59:13You could put, you know, single stock investing in there.
- 59:16You could put like thematic investing.
- 59:18There's things that you just want to speculate on that aren't
- 59:20covered by that cheap beta that give your portfolio a little
- 59:24spice and a little flavor. And to me, Bitcoin, that's why
- 59:29Bitcoin I think is stronger than gold in the modern portfolio
- 59:33because it can play that role of store of value, but also play
- 59:35the role of hot sauce, which is in high demand right now because
- 59:39a lot of people have married Vanguard index funds and are
- 59:43committed to wait 30 years. But in the meantime, they do
- 59:46want to make it a little more interesting because that's kind
- 59:48of boring to wait 30 years to compound.
- 59:50So to me, Bitcoin actually checks two boxes.
- 59:54And that's why I think it's got more appeal than gold for the
- 59:57time being. That gold had a good first
- 59:59quarter, though, you can't lie, but that's why we think it'll
- 1:00:02triple gold. But those are all good
- 1:00:04questions. But I don't think the treasury
- 1:00:06companies. Are going to like grow that big
- 1:00:11relative to MicroStrategy or the ETFs in my opinion, but it is
- 1:00:15interesting. Yeah, the the bucketing
- 1:00:18conversation is an interesting one.
- 1:00:19I think you you described it well and that like it is you
- 1:00:23know a multidisciplinary multi faceted asset.
- 1:00:25You can look at it in various ways.
- 1:00:27And I think that has been, you know, a driving factor in the
- 1:00:32sort of traditional finance persona being unwilling or just
- 1:00:37struggling to comprehend, like, where does this fit?
- 1:00:40How do I look at this? And then typically the, the, the
- 1:00:43answer is just like, I'm just going to ignore it and, and
- 1:00:45pretend it doesn't exist. And I think, you know, going
- 1:00:48back to what you were saying around the willingness to have
- 1:00:51an open mind about it like that, this is something that's always
- 1:00:55fascinated me about Bitcoin because like everyone's heard
- 1:00:59about it over the past decade. At some point somebody said
- 1:01:01something to you about Bitcoin and you probably just brushed it
- 1:01:04off and then it 10 XS, you hear about it again.
- 1:01:08That creates a real psychological bias in your brain
- 1:01:12that you missed it. And well, now I can't buy it now
- 1:01:14at 10X. So I'm going to continue to
- 1:01:17ignore it. And I think that proclivity or
- 1:01:19that psychological bias is even stronger in the trad 5
- 1:01:23professional brain because they have an air of sophistication
- 1:01:28about them. And in many cases, rightfully
- 1:01:30so, they're, you know, they're it have invested for a living
- 1:01:33and some of them have been, you know, very successful in their
- 1:01:35own right and various other asset classes.
- 1:01:38And so that seeing it, missing it perhaps multiple times
- 1:01:43creates this ingrained bias against it.
- 1:01:46And it takes a real sort of you humility and and shot to the ego
- 1:01:51to say maybe I was wrong. And Larry Fink is an example of
- 1:01:55this. Whether you think he, you know,
- 1:01:56genuinely believes it or not, that's at least how he's talked
- 1:01:58about it, is that I had this realization.
- 1:02:00I realized I was wrong. Most recently, there was
- 1:02:04Philippe Lafont from CO2 who had a very similar commentary around
- 1:02:08it. Just like, you know, the most
- 1:02:10important quality you could have it as a successful investor is
- 1:02:13the willingness to say what it. What if I am wrong about this
- 1:02:16thing? And I think that is the biggest
- 1:02:18thing holding back the Triadfi brain is they're not willing to
- 1:02:21say what if I was wrong about this?
- 1:02:22Because to your other earlier point, if you actually look into
- 1:02:26it in a, in a, you know, genuine way, you come out the other side
- 1:02:30whining exposure. And so I think that's just a
- 1:02:33fascinating thing about Bitcoin because that is the adoption
- 1:02:37story. That is what drives price over
- 1:02:40time is education, people realizing what this actually is.
- 1:02:43And we know the supply is finite.
- 1:02:44So as that education increases, demand increases and the price
- 1:02:48goes up. Like that is the whole story in
- 1:02:49my in my brain. So it's fascinating to just, you
- 1:02:52know, think through how that evolution is is occurring and,
- 1:02:56and how the psychological factors at play, you know, are,
- 1:03:00are. Progressing one quick note to
- 1:03:02that, that is if you just view it as hot sauce or like a tech
- 1:03:07stock you missed out on. I do think there's another
- 1:03:10component here which is debt and the money.
- 1:03:15Like, you know, if you really dive into the amount of money
- 1:03:20that's printed and how we left the gold standard in the 70s and
- 1:03:24then how it really escalated in the past 20 years, you, you can
- 1:03:30get pretty scared If you look at that, you're like, you know,
- 1:03:33because everybody knows governments are irresponsible
- 1:03:36and they're going to throw money at any problem.
- 1:03:38Like, who wants to be like held back by like the amount of money
- 1:03:41you can print and the amount of money that it takes to pay off
- 1:03:46just the interest now on the budget is like the second item
- 1:03:49once you get there. I think that's a front door for
- 1:03:54anybody, regardless of what the price is at that moment.
- 1:03:57Because if Bitcoin is attempting to solve that problem, then,
- 1:04:01well, that's why it matter. It it's more than just you, then
- 1:04:05you didn't miss it because we're just the beginning of a lot of
- 1:04:08this. So I find that if, if, if you're
- 1:04:12like an MMT person, like Keynesian on steroids, you
- 1:04:17probably look at Bitcoin as like, you're like a novelty of,
- 1:04:24you know, a Ponzi scheme, whatever.
- 1:04:27But if you look at that currency debasement and the potential for
- 1:04:30inflation and, and what happens to money.
- 1:04:33And because stocks are a little long in the tooth, they've had a
- 1:04:3620 year rally pretty much. And there are the valuations are
- 1:04:39really stretched to historical levels.
- 1:04:41He kind of opened up your mind like, well, I know the
- 1:04:44government's never going to stop adding to the debt.
- 1:04:47I believe that those couldn't, you know, those came along and
- 1:04:52like gave it a good shot. There was a lot of political
- 1:04:54will. It couldn't even do it.
- 1:04:56And so you're like, well, this will, this will something that
- 1:05:00is scarce and hard and the government can't get its grubby
- 1:05:03hands on it like it, it cannot dilute it.
- 1:05:07And just something, just something, anything that is
- 1:05:10undilutable by the government is a powerful proposition.
- 1:05:15If you go through all that, that it, then it then it becomes
- 1:05:19something we're like, well, maybe the price isn't that high.
- 1:05:21So I, I do because you're like, the debt is just getting
- 1:05:24started. We don't even know how crazy
- 1:05:26this is going to get because the, the amount that grows per
- 1:05:28year is crazy. And in America it's not even
- 1:05:30that bad. The other countries, it's like
- 1:05:32crazy. So I really am somebody who I'm
- 1:05:36not a full like hawk, but I do think this experiment of running
- 1:05:41up this much debt, irregardless of how much GDP we have is, is
- 1:05:44not something I'm really comfortable with.
- 1:05:47And so Bitcoin and gold or something like that, or even
- 1:05:51like art or real estate to a degree, these are these hard
- 1:05:55assets that I think help people have some comfort.
- 1:05:58But the thing with all those other assets, it's really hard
- 1:06:00to get those unless you're a lot of those other assets are a pain
- 1:06:04in the ass or for really, really rich people like who has access
- 1:06:08to like a Picasso painting. So I think Bitcoin is like a
- 1:06:11democratized version of one of those sort of real assets that
- 1:06:16can be UN dilutable by the government.
- 1:06:19And that to me is the front door where you don't blow it off
- 1:06:25anymore in in my opinion. I mean, I, I, you know, people
- 1:06:28have other theories on this, but that that alone is enough.
- 1:06:32And then you think, well, if if more people think like me and
- 1:06:35they buy it for a store of value and the volatility comes down,
- 1:06:38then it has a shot a fighting chance to be a currency too.
- 1:06:42But I will say that the, the interface has to get way better,
- 1:06:45you know, to, to go get a wallet and then they got to make it
- 1:06:48like, and it's also expensive. I'm sorry, but even 40 basis
- 1:06:52points to like exchange your dollars for Bitcoin is a, is a
- 1:06:55RIP off. I'm used to one basis point in
- 1:06:58the Triadfi world. So I think as the exchange rates
- 1:07:01come down and the volatility comes down and the interfaces
- 1:07:05are as easy as using fantasy football, then you might be
- 1:07:08having a talk about it being a global currency.
- 1:07:11So I think this store of value is like maybe the first step.
- 1:07:15So that's why in, you know, this project we're working on, one of
- 1:07:18our thesis is that the ETF it, it isn't responsible for all
- 1:07:24this. And obviously it didn't make
- 1:07:26Bitcoin, but it, it kicked off what is could be this nice chain
- 1:07:31of chain of chain reaction of making it legitimate.
- 1:07:35You know, the adults are here, you can feel safer.
- 1:07:38And then the IT got more mainstream, better owners, seems
- 1:07:43the store of value volatility comes down and ultimately it's a
- 1:07:46currency. This is not definitely going to
- 1:07:50happen. But if you trace it, it's you
- 1:07:52could honestly have this pretty logical chain of events that
- 1:07:57started with the BlackRock filing.
- 1:08:00So we don't have to not to go back there, but you can't do any
- 1:08:03of that if it's in the ETF, you can't use it as a currency.
- 1:08:05But either way, but the core component if you went through
- 1:08:09the logical correct progression that is absolutely correct.
- 1:08:13As long as Bitcoin enforces a fixed supply of 21 million, like
- 1:08:16that's the rational outcome. Is that so like as long as that
- 1:08:19stand? Do you, how would that change?
- 1:08:21Would you? Wouldn't you need 96% of people
- 1:08:24to say? Let's it won't change because
- 1:08:26it's just not the rational thing.
- 1:08:27Like we all don't want our money to be debased, so it won't
- 1:08:30change. And so, but you're one just easy
- 1:08:34quick because it's an easy one to dismiss.
- 1:08:36But it makes logical sense is in the same way like when you
- 1:08:39transact for gold or any fixed asset, there's like whether it's
- 1:08:42operations compliance or you want the security around it.
- 1:08:45So you naturally are going to pay something because nothing in
- 1:08:47the world's free. There's a reason where whether
- 1:08:50it's transaction fees or custody fees cost more today nominally
- 1:08:54than they will in the future because the delta between your
- 1:08:56cost versus the appreciation is nom like it makes zero sense to
- 1:09:00like bite over 40 bits when the price is appreciating at a CAGR
- 1:09:03of 49% year over year. So as the market grows, not only
- 1:09:09just like the Internet, everything will become a lot
- 1:09:11easier to use. All those costs will be easy.
- 1:09:13And this is the part of the the suit corners is sometimes the
- 1:09:16pejorative in the sense of like it's shit corners with suits.
- 1:09:18So like they're going to steal your money.
- 1:09:20And the reality is it goes back to crypto.
- 1:09:24Like the idea is have enough humility that not you, but just
- 1:09:26in general, if we got to 21 million finite scarcity, like
- 1:09:29that's the zero to 1 moment of similar how gold came about
- 1:09:32after being built on whatever happened before that, that you
- 1:09:35can figure out everything else, meaning how do you transact?
- 1:09:38How do you secure it? You don't create other ones like
- 1:09:41that. And so anyway, I'm just kind of
- 1:09:42sharing with you. I think you know these things,
- 1:09:43you're coming through it in this book, but this is the rational
- 1:09:46outcome and the alpha is in this middle part of saying this is
- 1:09:49where the market's going. You can't tell people to put a
- 1:09:52dog chain dog tag on it because that's not commercial and
- 1:09:55feasible. But also when you get far enough
- 1:09:57down the other side, because you've already worked through
- 1:09:59this, you're mentioning government and unsustainable in
- 1:10:01debt, but you also said before they're going to bail out
- 1:10:03Coinbase. Like those two things are
- 1:10:05completely juxtaposed. And so anyway.
- 1:10:10Not really. I mean part of the IT would be
- 1:10:12ironic if if there was a Bitcoin bailout given that, but how
- 1:10:16would that? Look.
- 1:10:19Given that Bitcoin was birthed, you know, in the middle of the
- 1:10:22bank bailouts. But no, I'm just saying that,
- 1:10:26you know, in in the case of like a hack at the size that you're
- 1:10:31talking about, which would be it would be the biggest robbery in
- 1:10:34the history of the world by like what, 50 fold?
- 1:10:38I just think the press and the government and the FBI and the
- 1:10:41amount of resources that would be put on that would be so
- 1:10:46monumental that it would overwhelm the situation.
- 1:10:50They would they would it would be it would this be it would be
- 1:10:54front page headline for for weeks.
- 1:10:58This would make it an an emergency.
- 1:11:00That's what all I'm saying. I'm not because like in that
- 1:11:04hack with the lady who was doing the rapping crocodile tear,
- 1:11:09whatever, what's her name? Lady Crocodile.
- 1:11:12I forgot. Her name, I know who you're
- 1:11:13talking about. Yeah, the couple, the Bonnie and
- 1:11:15Clyde couple that like, first of all, they only hacked, I think
- 1:11:19it was a couple billion, which is still a lot, but, and it was
- 1:11:24from some, it wasn't a mainstream exchange, but they
- 1:11:28ultimately couldn't spend their money The they, they, they
- 1:11:32couldn't really get the Bitcoin out.
- 1:11:35Ultimately though, they did some things that were traceable and
- 1:11:38they got busted and that made really big news.
- 1:11:43And that was only a couple billion.
- 1:11:44So you're talking about a trillion dollar theft that I
- 1:11:49just, you know, in the ETF world for 20 years now, people have
- 1:11:52been worrying about ETFs, this, that and the other.
- 1:11:55And some people be like, well, ETFs hold junk bonds and the
- 1:11:59junk bonds could go illiquid in a huge crisis and the ETF would
- 1:12:03then trade at a discount. And I'm like, OK, OK, fine.
- 1:12:06It trades at a 2% discount. And then but I'm like, no, what
- 1:12:09if it's a prolonged? I'm like, dude, at some point
- 1:12:12you're creating a picture of World War 3 and we're gonna have
- 1:12:15bigger fish to fry than the fucking junk bond ETF.
- 1:12:18So like you could take these scenarios to a point where
- 1:12:22they're so big and crazy that they would become such a bigger
- 1:12:28problem than just should I use the ETF or not?
- 1:12:32I think, I think the I think the easy example just to make it
- 1:12:36more rational is because you said this earlier.
- 1:12:38I forget the number, but it was like 5 to 10 X.
- 1:12:42The largest robbery in human history happened in the digital
- 1:12:46asset world that nobody talks about.
- 1:12:47It was the Bibit hack. It happened the past 12 months.
- 1:12:49It was 1.75 or roughly billion. The largest other hack was Iraq,
- 1:12:53Iraq, gold in Iraq, and then some painting in Paris, which
- 1:12:56were like 30 to 50 million. And this one was, you know, 20X,
- 1:12:59I think 20X. Point being is if we all agree
- 1:13:02this grows, then that means sovereign adoption grows.
- 1:13:05We're going to start settling trade and oil and other things.
- 1:13:08It would just be a sovereign that would take it.
- 1:13:09What are we going to go like we're going to start a nuclear
- 1:13:11war with Iran or whoever took it?
- 1:13:13Like there's a lot of progressions where it doesn't
- 1:13:16have to be an individual not worrying about stealing it
- 1:13:18because that's where this all goes.
- 1:13:20And again, it's not to say like this is crazy.
- 1:13:22It's more of the rational thing for investors as their exposure
- 1:13:25goes from 3 to 25%. You just if there's 10 percent,
- 1:13:292% point 1% that's I'm just I'm mainly sharing like this is
- 1:13:34going to become more. Of a narrative.
- 1:13:36As Coinbase goes from 800 billion to 1.8 billion because
- 1:13:40you already hear it in your 1.8 trillion.
- 1:13:41You hear it in your circles. People's uncomfortability with
- 1:13:43Coinbase's concentration. Imagine the price double S
- 1:13:46that's just going to increase and there's not that many world
- 1:13:48class custodians to actually pick up the scraps.
- 1:13:51You don't want a net new custodian to do it either
- 1:13:53because they don't have a track record.
- 1:13:54Yeah, 2 counterpoints, 1. I think if it grows and gets to
- 1:13:57be bigger part, I think the regulations will adapt to that
- 1:14:01because it'll be more, you know, people, even the people in
- 1:14:03Congress be like shit, this is like 50% of My Portfolio.
- 1:14:07I think, you know, you have to have faith in the system a
- 1:14:10little bit to sort of adapt to some of that change.
- 1:14:13The second thing is, you know, whether one of the thing about
- 1:14:17having your own storage now, I know if you are doing it for
- 1:14:20somebody and you're like putting their stuff in really safe
- 1:14:24places, I think there's always going to be a market for that.
- 1:14:26I mean, there's a market for Swiss bank accounts to this day.
- 1:14:30But for somebody to have a little bit of Bitcoin in a cold
- 1:14:34storage and then walk around with it, I think a like, I think
- 1:14:39in the LA fires, some people lost their Bitcoin forever.
- 1:14:42There's Bitcoin and the one guy who's trying to get his Bitcoin
- 1:14:44out of the Scottish dump for like 10 years.
- 1:14:48The ETF does fix that, you know, you know, I would say your firm
- 1:14:52fixes that also. But if you get too big and
- 1:14:57people know you have Bitcoin, then you get like a safety
- 1:14:59issue. Like you said, you want to get
- 1:15:00your finger chopped off. So I think there is this tension
- 1:15:04between wanting to not have, wanting control like safety over
- 1:15:12yourself versus safety of your Bitcoin.
- 1:15:15But I think that's a personal decision.
- 1:15:17It's subjective. It also depends on how much true
- 1:15:19trust the system and BlackRock and these other companies.
- 1:15:22And I think everybody will make the choice that's right for them
- 1:15:24and businesses will pop up to to like sort of cater to different
- 1:15:28types of people with different needs.
- 1:15:29So I just, I'm a little skeptical on a situation where
- 1:15:34Bitcoin is 80% of like normal people's portfolios.
- 1:15:37Coinbase gets hacked. It's a $4 trillion hack, which
- 1:15:41would be like what, 8,000,000 times the biggest robbery ever?
- 1:15:47Something like. That.
- 1:15:48So I think to be fair, before it gets to 80%, I can promise you
- 1:15:51it'll be figured out because nobody's going to park 80% in
- 1:15:53that scenario. To give you a little sneak peek
- 1:15:57from the regulatory, specifically SEC, when this next
- 1:16:02cycle, call it four years from now, three years from now,
- 1:16:05something like this will. And it doesn't have to be any of
- 1:16:07these people. The key holders didn't even have
- 1:16:09to be this firm, but this will effectively be the way it's set
- 1:16:12up because we've had ETF providers, Bitcoin ETF providers
- 1:16:15behind those doors tell us this is bulletproof.
- 1:16:18The problem is it melts brains because how do you go to the SEC
- 1:16:21and you go from explaining Bitcoin to explaining no
- 1:16:23institution has unilateral control and this skills
- 1:16:26proportionally. So don't get fixed on the number
- 1:16:28of keys because you can have 5 institutions have three or five
- 1:16:31have to agree before any assets move.
- 1:16:34It's just kind of like where we see the market going eventually
- 1:16:37when an ETF holds a trillion dollars, it's the rational.
- 1:16:40I mean, honestly, you should pitch this to the ETF issuers.
- 1:16:43I'm sure if an ETF came out and said, hey, we're going to be
- 1:16:46like IAU where they hold it in three different vaults, we're
- 1:16:49going to hold your Bitcoin with three different custodians and
- 1:16:52these custodians will have that may sell.
- 1:16:54I mean that that level of security may be a differentiator
- 1:16:57to the list of ETFs out there. I bet that you know I'm we we
- 1:17:01could see that. Yeah, I think when they're
- 1:17:03looking for marketability, I know we have to run.
- 1:17:05When they're looking for marketability right now,
- 1:17:07everyone, nobody got fired, nobody gets fired for going to
- 1:17:09Coinbase. So that's where we're at today
- 1:17:10in the in the process. Yeah, I I do agree.
- 1:17:14I think Coinbase, it's too it too much of the custodian
- 1:17:17market. I I would like to see it get
- 1:17:19spread out more. One other quick thing that that
- 1:17:21three keys that reminds me, I was like this guy Jamie
- 1:17:25Catherwood, I think his name, he's like a real historical
- 1:17:28financial guy. And we've had him on the show
- 1:17:32and every time we think something's new, he'll say no.
- 1:17:34That in the 1800s they your three key thing, they used to
- 1:17:38have these locks with gold or bonds in them, I think.
- 1:17:42And and they had three different keys and like 3 different banks
- 1:17:45would have a send a person like a three, you know, 3 lock.
- 1:17:49Yeah. That's what this is in digital.
- 1:17:51Form it is, yeah, no, they used to use that they.
- 1:17:53Explain it. Yeah, I love that.
- 1:17:57Yeah, anyway, to the to the. Boomers is like there's a lock
- 1:18:00safe or there's a safe and there's.
- 1:18:02Three, I could see a movie where the guy cuts the arm off of like
- 1:18:05the three the two guys with keys and then he, you know, you know,
- 1:18:08like some crazy shit. But there's also isn't there a
- 1:18:13movie where like multiple things have to be done at the same time
- 1:18:16to to? Maybe it's Mission Impossible,
- 1:18:19but this idea of like 3 keys going into the same lock at the
- 1:18:23same time is a powerful visual that I think people concern with
- 1:18:27security will respond to well. Unfortunately, we've had time
- 1:18:32and Eric, we're going to have to have you back on if you agree,
- 1:18:36if Michael didn't scare you away today, hopefully I'll have you
- 1:18:39back on in a few months. No, look, it's fine.
- 1:18:42Look, I I appreciate all this. This is keeping me sharper.
- 1:18:46And you know, almost everybody in the ET and the I do go on
- 1:18:50these podcasts where it's just straight like I own Bitcoin ETS
- 1:18:53made number go up. I love you.
- 1:18:55But some, in a lot of cases, like people do have businesses
- 1:18:58that compete with ETFs and they're not perfect.
- 1:19:01I just think they do check a lot of boxes for people.
- 1:19:04And we try to, you know, make sure that people know.
- 1:19:07But like, I will give you this one story thestreet.com ETFs got
- 1:19:12so big for like all these reporters were covering them and
- 1:19:15the media got a little ahead of itself and they write stories
- 1:19:18like here's 5 ETFs to play Amazon earnings.
- 1:19:21And I was like, you know what, just buy Amazon.
- 1:19:24It's OK. Like the ETF is not the salt,
- 1:19:27the solution for everybody. I love it.
- 1:19:28I dedicate my career to it. But there's going to be cases
- 1:19:32and things where people have different needs.
- 1:19:34You know, private equity is probably better in a different
- 1:19:39wrapper or something else. So, you know, there's.
- 1:19:42We, we personally believe ETFs, everything's good for Bitcoin
- 1:19:45and ETFs are ultimately good. And so we see that it's the
- 1:19:48gateway we can we kind of hold you to when this book comes,
- 1:19:52you're one of the first, this is one of the first places you come
- 1:19:54talk about it because. Yeah, sure.
- 1:19:57We'd love to have you on because it sounds, I think ETF is the
- 1:19:59beginning of the book and there's a whole progression of
- 1:20:02like how this. Yeah, it's like every part of
- 1:20:04society. And that's kind of where we we
- 1:20:06think it this all goes. Absolutely.
- 1:20:08We're, we're, we're focusing on the sense ETF cause all the
- 1:20:11other books written, there's so many books they didn't, they
- 1:20:14don't have any of that. So we're trying to cover the
- 1:20:15financialization of it, but it's like hitting a moving target.
- 1:20:20Whenever we hand it in, it's like 8 months little publish.
- 1:20:22It's like, my God, that's like 8 years and like Bitcoin years or
- 1:20:25whatever. And it's like, I'm not sure how
- 1:20:27we're going to deal with that, but we're doing our.
- 1:20:28Best we need a new chapter on the three keys.
- 1:20:30I know 3 keys. Yeah, I know.
- 1:20:32I mean, look there, there is a section on security and it's
- 1:20:36pretty small, but maybe you got me thinking, maybe I'll reach
- 1:20:39back out and try to evolve that a little bit because I do want
- 1:20:42the reader to know all the possible scenarios.
- 1:20:45Like, we're not it, you know, We're trying to give people
- 1:20:48every bit of information so they can be the jury for themselves.
- 1:20:52Yeah. The reason why I'm a stickler on
- 1:20:53this is because I've seen everything happen and everyone
- 1:20:56new comes in and they believe it can't happen again and it just
- 1:20:59continues to happen because, yeah, we've never seen digital
- 1:21:02bearer asset independent of if it's black.
- 1:21:04Rock, have you ever had a Coinbase person on your show?
- 1:21:08I worked at Coinbase for for 12 months Eric so.
- 1:21:10Oh, you did OK. It did, yeah, before joining on
- 1:21:13ramp. Are you like, so are you bring?
- 1:21:16Are you like the guy who was building the Death Star who gave
- 1:21:19the plans to be like, wait, the Death Star is actually like, you
- 1:21:21can blow it up, guys. What's scary about the Coinbase
- 1:21:25thing is I've talked personally to their head of institutional,
- 1:21:27very well known guy in the space he probably met.
- 1:21:29He has no idea how they custody the assets.
- 1:21:31When I explained what we did, what we do, he's like, why
- 1:21:33aren't we doing that? This is genius.
- 1:21:35And it's like we got to go you. Know.
- 1:21:38So yeah, I mean. It's a complex space, it's super
- 1:21:43nuanced. And so that's the problem is
- 1:21:45that like it just takes so much time and it's the whole notion
- 1:21:48of proof of work. You had a whole career to like
- 1:21:50dedicate pre ETF. So then you're coming up to
- 1:21:53speed on the Bitcoin and you're the best in the world to do it.
- 1:21:56There's very few financial institutions that also deeply
- 1:21:58understand Bitcoin. And so and then also when you
- 1:22:01think about the project, the trajectory and then ultimately
- 1:22:04what does an individual want? Because somebody that's holding
- 1:22:06like our type of client that has anywhere between millions to 1/4
- 1:22:09billion, they just need a, a number of different things
- 1:22:12because it's the majority of their wealth.
- 1:22:14And that's not how Triify builds.
- 1:22:15Triify builds omnibus wallets. And they say, hey, trust us,
- 1:22:18bro. And that's just not going to
- 1:22:19work in this world. And people are going to.
- 1:22:21That's how we're going to make all our money and the businesses
- 1:22:23we invest in. Yeah.
- 1:22:25I mean, you're the IT it you should say there's an outside
- 1:22:29possibility it may not work in this world.
- 1:22:31I think like it's a little different.
- 1:22:33I will make any bet publicly here and I'll give you 10 to 1
- 1:22:36odds, right? Why is your traction, your
- 1:22:38former company so much? I'll allow it.
- 1:22:41I'll allow it. Well, listen, you should have
- 1:22:43the, you know, you, you really need to have the Coinbase person
- 1:22:46on. We'd love to.
- 1:22:47I'd watch that. I love it.
- 1:22:50Eric Well, thanks for humouring us.
- 1:22:51This guy guarding the Coinbase Vault.
- 1:22:54Come on. See, you're actually, but you're
- 1:22:57helping because like there's no way on planet Earth, everyone,
- 1:23:00anybody knows how Coinbase custody.
- 1:23:02Is it in the same way Fidelity, in the same way Mount Gox,
- 1:23:04Celsius or Genesis? Because it's an operational
- 1:23:06security hazard for anybody to actually know how it's done,
- 1:23:08which by definition means you can't actually park all your
- 1:23:11money there. Interesting.
- 1:23:14All right, you. Give me enough time, Eric.
- 1:23:17If you give me enough time, you'll become a client and then
- 1:23:19you will have another chapter because you're going to realize
- 1:23:21I'm telling you, like the ETF providers have told us, this
- 1:23:23thing's bulletproof. It's just nobody gets fired for
- 1:23:25going with Coinbase. So everyone's going to do that
- 1:23:27to start. Well, listen, we're actually
- 1:23:30interviewing the Black Rock guy in a week.
- 1:23:33I'll, I'll, I'll definitely put this at least over to him and
- 1:23:37press him a little more than I probably would have.
- 1:23:40Yeah, and the reason why everyone won't will push hard
- 1:23:42against it because it goes back to the mental model of
- 1:23:44traditional finance. You got to have eyes and hands
- 1:23:46on the asset because then you can do the things you want with
- 1:23:48it. And so it's the same way the
- 1:23:50Internet. It's going to take a digitally
- 1:23:52native firm that understands Bitcoin deeply to build a new
- 1:23:55world in the same way it took Netflix the way to re change how
- 1:23:59media is distributed, not Blockbuster.
- 1:24:00It's really that simple. So there's no reason why
- 1:24:03BlackRock or Fidelity would win the new world.
- 1:24:05Like it's, it's really, if you think about this as that
- 1:24:07radical, that mental model is as simple as that.
- 1:24:10Like they're not going to win in the new space because they just,
- 1:24:12it's, it's, it's just not rational.
- 1:24:15Dude, I mean they, they BlackRock has the most Bitcoin
- 1:24:19besides Satoshi in a year and a half.
- 1:24:21I mean, that's pretty winning. But it's a $2 trillion.
- 1:24:24That's 2 trillion. That's winning dude.
- 1:24:26I'm sorry. I'm in.
- 1:24:28I'm at the long game. I'm at the long.
- 1:24:30Game, yeah, no, I, I, I would say this.
- 1:24:33I would say there's room for multiple winners.
- 1:24:37Of course that's true. This is a great this is a a
- 1:24:39great pod. I I appreciate Eric.
- 1:24:41Yeah. No, it's good.
- 1:24:42Humoring as a. Blast.
- 1:24:43Yeah, we'll, we'll have to have you back.
- 1:24:45Yeah, All right. See you guys.
- 1:24:47Good talking to you. I.
- 1:24:48Appreciate it. Bye.
- 1:24:50Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:24:52If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:24:54episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:24:57app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:24:59today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:25:02Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onramp Media is
- 1:25:04for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:25:07nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:25:10Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:25:12to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:25:16to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:25:19advisors.