Latest / The So What? / On Satellites, South Africa and Starlink
Transcript
- 0:04Hello, and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jplandman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:26Hello, and once again, a very warm welcome to
- 0:29the So What podcast. This one goes with JP's
- 0:33newsletter dated the 27th of July, 2026, and
- 0:37the heading is On Satellites, South Africa and
- 0:41Starlink. We have to start with Starlink because
- 0:46they were the first mover in low Earth orbit
- 0:49satellites, right? Yes, absolutely. Seven years
- 0:52ago in 2019, Elon Musk launched the first 60
- 0:56satellites into low Earth orbit. It was a new
- 0:59thing then. A couple of years later, in 2021,
- 1:03three years later, he had 1 ,500 satellites in
- 1:07orbit, low Earth orbit. And that's when he started
- 1:10launching an internet connection service from
- 1:13the satellites. And five years later, by 2026,
- 1:18Starlink has got 10 ,000 satellites in orbit,
- 1:22and it provides an internet connection in more
- 1:26than 150 countries across the world with some
- 1:299 million subscribers. Are there other players?
- 1:34Yes, I think it's important. Look, there's no
- 1:36question. Elon Musk and Starlink are the market
- 1:39leaders. They were the first movers, and they
- 1:41are by far the brand name which is really widely
- 1:46recognized. But yes, there are other players.
- 1:48The first one is Amazon. Jeff Bezos, he launched
- 1:51Amazon Leo. He launched it also in 2019 when
- 1:56Elon Musk started. He called his company then
- 1:59Kuiper. Kuiper is the name of a star constellation
- 2:04very far into the universe. It's not the Northern
- 2:07Cape Municipality. No, it's not the Northern
- 2:09Cape Municipality. But he changed that name later
- 2:13from Kuiper to Amazon Leo, presumably because
- 2:17he wanted to capitalize or he wants to capitalize
- 2:19on the brand name Amazon. So Amazon Leo, Amazon
- 2:23Low Earth Orbit, is also a company that is being
- 2:27set up, but it's not operating yet. They've got
- 2:30regulatory approval to broadcast in Nigeria,
- 2:34in the UK, and of course, the United States.
- 2:36And very recently, they've announced that they're
- 2:39coming to South Africa in 2027. Well, they're
- 2:43already here, but the service will be available
- 2:45by 2027. So yes, Amazon Leo is one competitor.
- 2:50So from the US you have two. You have Starlink
- 2:53and Amazon Leo. And China, surely they are also
- 2:57playing in this field? Absolutely. There are
- 3:00already six Chinese companies busy with satellites.
- 3:05But two of them really stand out as the two most
- 3:08important ones. The one is called the Space Sail
- 3:11or the Thousand Sails Constellation. The other
- 3:14one is called China Satellite Network Group,
- 3:17also known as Guwang. Now, they only started
- 3:20in 2024, but they took off much, much faster.
- 3:23And between them, they will probably have 25
- 3:26,000 low -earth satellites in low -earth orbit
- 3:30by 2030. The one company, SpaceSail, is already
- 3:35operating in China, of course, in Brazil and
- 3:38in Kazakhstan. And the service will be rolled
- 3:41out in five more countries. Neither of the companies
- 3:44operate in South Africa, but what has come out
- 3:46in the recent arguments that there were about
- 3:50the Resolve Communications and the DA and so
- 3:52on, Communications Minister Solly Malatsi, who
- 3:56is also a DA minister, has revealed in legislation
- 3:59that many people, including China Satellite Network
- 4:03Group, has been in contact with him, has come
- 4:06to see him to talk about the industry. So it
- 4:08looks as if that company may come into South
- 4:10Africa. What's happening in Europe? Europe is
- 4:14very interesting. There was a company called
- 4:16OneWeb who launched its first low -earth orbit
- 4:20satellites also in 2019. And then by 2023, they
- 4:24merged with another European company called Utelsat.
- 4:27And now you have Utelsat OneWeb. Now, the point
- 4:30is OneWeb does low -earth orbit satellites and
- 4:34Utelsat does... what you can call high -Earth
- 4:38orbit satellites or geosatellites, geostationary
- 4:41satellites. The difference being that low -Earth
- 4:44satellites are between 450 and 600 kilometers
- 4:48above Earth, and the geosatellites are sitting
- 4:51in a stationary position at 36 ,000 miles. So
- 4:55there's a big difference. And UTELSAT -1Web offers
- 4:59both those services. For the satellites sitting
- 5:02at 36 ,000, but also for the ones sitting at
- 5:06500, 600 kilometers from Earth. Why is this coming
- 5:12into being? Why do we have low Earth orbit satellites?
- 5:16Well, the main thing is it cuts the cost of satellite
- 5:19communication enormously. Satellite communication
- 5:22or internet connection via satellites have been
- 5:25with us for a long time, but it's very expensive.
- 5:28The point about low -earth orbit satellites is
- 5:30they've cut that cost by between 60 % and 70%.
- 5:33That's the big differentiator. And the reason
- 5:37why we use satellite communication is in remote
- 5:40areas where you don't have fiber lines and in
- 5:44remote areas where you don't have strong cell
- 5:46phone towers or no cell phone towers, it is the
- 5:50only way of establishing internet connection.
- 5:54So it's about isolated places, rural areas, high
- 5:57seas, that sort of thing. And it's about getting
- 6:00it at a cost which is reasonable. What are the
- 6:03business models? How do the satellite services
- 6:06reach their customers? Basically two models.
- 6:10The first one is the Starlink model. They sell
- 6:12directly to end customers. So you buy a satellite
- 6:16dish from them and they broadcast directly to
- 6:19your satellite dish in your house or in your
- 6:21office or wherever you are. and you are in connection.
- 6:25The other model is where satellite providers
- 6:29like UTEL, SUD, and Amazon, Leon, and so on,
- 6:32make space available on their satellites. They
- 6:35rent it out to what you can call a wholesaler,
- 6:39and the wholesaler then sells it to the retailer,
- 6:41to you and me. So it's two different models.
- 6:44The one is direct, and the other one is via a
- 6:47middle company. Now, Starlink is the only one
- 6:51with a direct service to retail customers. The
- 6:55other work through what I call wholesale companies.
- 6:59How does it compare with fiber? Well, look, fiber
- 7:03is much cheaper and fiber can carry a much bigger
- 7:06volume. So in cities and in towns and between
- 7:10towns where you have fiber lines, that is what
- 7:13you will go for. But where you don't have fiber
- 7:17lines, and as I've said, where you don't have
- 7:18cell phone towers or not reliable cell phone
- 7:21towers, there it is cheaper. No, not cheaper,
- 7:25but it's better to go to satellite technology.
- 7:29Like, as you said, on the high seas. On the high
- 7:32seas, and there's a very interesting example
- 7:34about that, which we will... But in South Africa's
- 7:38context, basically rural areas, areas far away
- 7:41from the city, city centres, outside towns, that's
- 7:44where you want to use a satellite connection.
- 7:47Do we know anything about price points yet? Not
- 7:50for Starlink because they haven't published anything
- 7:52in South Africa. But what we do know is that
- 7:55in neighbouring Eswatini, you can buy at an initial
- 8:00cost, you can buy a modem or a... or a receiver
- 8:03for, I think it's about 6 ,500 bucks. And after
- 8:07that, you pay, I think, 900 grand a month for
- 8:11ongoing service. So that is there. The other
- 8:14company that does operate in South Africa is
- 8:17QCon, and they work through UTELSAT and OneWeb,
- 8:21or OneWeb UTELSAT. They don't have retail packages
- 8:26available. They will quote you whatever. your
- 8:30needs are and where you are and so on, and then
- 8:32give you a price. So it will settle over time.
- 8:36We don't really know yet. It will settle over
- 8:38time. And as more people enter, you will get
- 8:40more competition and hopefully better price points.
- 8:44So what is the situation in the South African
- 8:48market at the moment? Who are already here and
- 8:52who can we expect? Yeah, there's really, the
- 8:56bottom line is at the moment, there is only available
- 8:59UTL -SAT -1Web. They've got low -earth orbit
- 9:03satellites, and they work through a couple of
- 9:05South African companies. The most important one
- 9:08is called QCon, which is based in Centurion,
- 9:12and they have linked up with a UK company, Avanti,
- 9:15and they get their satellite feed from UTL -SAT
- 9:19-1Web, and they sell it here in South Africa.
- 9:22Now, what is interesting about QCon, is that
- 9:26they've already connected a primary healthcare
- 9:28clinic in Lampopo in a very isolated spot. So
- 9:32that clinic has now got internet connection,
- 9:34which other people in the area won't have. They
- 9:37have also connected some spa stores and some
- 9:40spa distribution centers and given them internet
- 9:43connection. And they are giving what is called
- 9:46a backhaul service to MTN in rural areas, basically
- 9:50a backhaul service. It's just where the MTN towers
- 9:53are not strong enough. Then they give a backhaul,
- 9:57a backup service to make the signal better for
- 10:00people who connect via MTN to the internet. So
- 10:03QCon, in cooperation with Avanti, is operating
- 10:07in South Africa. Avanti is very ambitious. They
- 10:10have an office here, they have staff here, and
- 10:13they want to expand their footprint, and we will
- 10:15probably hear more from them. But there are also
- 10:18other companies. Two others are Seacom and Paratus.
- 10:21Seacom is known for the undersea cable that connects
- 10:25South Africa to Europe and the outside world.
- 10:27But they, because there are now so many of those
- 10:29cables, they want to expand their business and
- 10:33also provide an internet connection service to
- 10:35some of their clients. And Paratus does the same
- 10:39thing. They operate in Africa, south of the equator.
- 10:42They use the UTEL SatOneWeb satellites. and they
- 10:47sell their internet connection to customers in
- 10:49Southern Africa. What about Amazon Leo? Yeah,
- 10:53that's the big announcement that came through
- 10:55a week or two ago. Amazon Leo in South Africa
- 11:00is teaming up with a company called Yerotel.
- 11:02Now, Yerotel is part of Massive. Massive is a
- 11:06subsidiary of Remgrove and Vodacom. All the fiber
- 11:10interests of Vodacom and Remgrove are located
- 11:14in Massive. They took over Yerotel. The Competition
- 11:18Commission agreed to that. And Yerotel has got
- 11:21a unique approach. They focus on rural areas
- 11:25and isolated areas. And so they are servicing
- 11:28at the moment something like 550 towns in South
- 11:31Africa through 120 offices. I assume it will
- 11:35be small operations. It won't be big offices.
- 11:38But their footprint is rural. The isolated areas
- 11:43of South Africa. So that fits the Amazon Leo
- 11:45business model perfectly. And they have now teamed
- 11:49up. You can start registering to get the service
- 11:52from them now in 2026, but the service will only
- 11:56become effective or only become operational next
- 11:59year and in 2027. So the bottom line is that
- 12:03UTILSAT OneWeb is currently really the only active
- 12:07Leo network. supplier in South Africa and Amazon
- 12:10Leo through Herotel will be with us soon. Yes,
- 12:14that's the bottom line. Why is Starlink not yet
- 12:18operating in South Africa? We hear a lot of noise,
- 12:21but it's often not very clear for the casual
- 12:24reader. No, indeed. Starlink hasn't applied for
- 12:28a license yet. That's the first point. To operate
- 12:30as an internet provider via satellite, you need
- 12:34a license from all territories. It's not a South
- 12:37African thing. And they haven't applied for a
- 12:39license. Now, the reason they haven't applied
- 12:42for a license, we think, is because of BE requirements.
- 12:45And the position is fairly simple. The Electronics
- 12:48Communication Act, which dates from the 1990s,
- 12:51requires a 30 % black shareholding. Now, the
- 12:56government has made attempts to make it easier
- 12:58for foreign companies. And what they do is you've
- 13:01got an equity equivalent investment program,
- 13:03which means you don't have to give up equity,
- 13:06but you've got to do other spending. must make
- 13:08other investments which will help transformation.
- 13:12Now, Amazon, for example, has got a level 1 BE
- 13:16rating. Microsoft has got a level 1 BE rating.
- 13:19But other non -US companies like Samsung from
- 13:23Korea, Huawei from China and so on, also have
- 13:271 and 2 BE ratings. And the way that they can
- 13:31get it is by spending money, they can overcome
- 13:34this 30 % black equity. So that avenue may be
- 13:41open to Starlink, but I think the real problem
- 13:45there is, although these things are provided
- 13:47for in government BE codes, you have a piece
- 13:50of legislation, the Electronic Communications
- 13:52Act, which says, you know, you must have 30%.
- 13:55And a government regulation in a government gazette
- 13:58cannot rank higher than an Act of Parliament.
- 14:02So you'll have to change the Act. And so far,
- 14:04the Minister of Communications has not sent an
- 14:07amendment Act to Parliament yet. So that thing
- 14:10is in limbo. So Amazon Leo will also not be able
- 14:15to get it. No, but they are teaming up with Yerotel.
- 14:18They're teaming up with a local company. And
- 14:19that's the second way that Starlink could do
- 14:21it. They could team up with a local company like
- 14:24Amazon Leo has done and like Yerotel OneWeb has
- 14:29done. But I think the problem there is because
- 14:32they're selling directly to the end customer,
- 14:35it may not suit them to work through another
- 14:37company, to go through another company. I don't
- 14:40know, but I would think that would be the case.
- 14:42So that is, I think, basically why Starlink is
- 14:45not here. So you can kind of bypass the BEE requirements
- 14:49with the other investment. What is it called?
- 14:52Equity Equivalent Investment Program. That one.
- 14:56But not if you're an... An internet provider,
- 15:00because then you're dealing with the other act.
- 15:03Correct, but the way then to bypass it is to
- 15:06take a South African company, a South African
- 15:08partner, and that apparently Starlink doesn't
- 15:13want to do. What's happening in other African
- 15:16countries? Well, it's very interesting. In Namibia,
- 15:17for example, they also have a requirement. They
- 15:20go further than the 30%. They say 51 % of the
- 15:23shares in a satellite license must be held by
- 15:27Namibians. A foreigner can only hold 49%. So
- 15:31Starlink has applied for a license in Namibia.
- 15:33It was turned down for that reason. There was
- 15:36then a public outcry, petitions, and so on and
- 15:38so forth, but the decision stands. So Starlink
- 15:41can't operate in Namibia, more or less for the
- 15:43same reasons. In Ghana, Starlink has operated
- 15:47for, I think, the last two years already. They
- 15:49have a license there, but the Ghanaian authorities
- 15:51have now given them notice that they must take
- 15:54Ghanaian partners. Find some kind of a partner
- 15:58company in Ghana, otherwise the license will
- 16:00be cancelled. Zimbabwe is on the other end of
- 16:03the spectrum. They just gave Starlink a license
- 16:07without any local shareholding requirements,
- 16:10and Starlink is available in Zim. You say that
- 16:13satellite networks have become a geopolitical
- 16:18issue. Why? Two reasons, two examples rather.
- 16:23One happened in February last year when Reuters
- 16:26reported that in the negotiations between Ukraine
- 16:29and the United States government on the minerals
- 16:32deal with Ukraine, the American negotiator said
- 16:36to the Ukrainians, if you don't agree to this
- 16:38deal, we're cutting off Starlink. Now, Stalin,
- 16:41as you know, is playing a critical role in Ukraine's
- 16:44military operations against the Russian invasion.
- 16:47So they're really dependent on Stalin. Elon Musk
- 16:50did deny the report. He did deny the report.
- 16:53But I think what the incident illustrates is
- 16:55that you are vulnerable. And the Americans are
- 16:57known as hardball negotiators, and it's very
- 17:00conceivable that that kind of power can be used.
- 17:03So that's the one example. The other more recent
- 17:07one is there's in French, shipping company called
- 17:12CMA -CGM. They operate 350 ships on the high
- 17:17seas, and they want to connect all their ships
- 17:19to satellite internet connection. And they've
- 17:22signed two contracts. The one is with Starlink,
- 17:24and the other one is with UTELSAT to provide
- 17:28low -earth orbit internet connections. And they
- 17:31argue that they will run with both systems for
- 17:33two years to see which one serves them best.
- 17:36If you have ships going all over the world, You
- 17:39want to make sure that they're connected all
- 17:41the time. But apart from running with two systems
- 17:44to choose the best one, they also said they didn't
- 17:47want to be dependent on just one provider in
- 17:50case that provider decides to cut off the service
- 17:52and then your ships are stranded, so to speak.
- 17:56A lot of information. Yes, it is a dense topic.
- 18:00It is a dense topic. A lot of work went into
- 18:02it. But it's a fascinating topic because it deals
- 18:05with technology. It deals with the Internet,
- 18:07which is so important in all our lives. Politics,
- 18:11technology, geopolitics, it's all in there. And
- 18:14that's why I thought it's a topic which may be
- 18:17of interest. In summary, so what? Well, I think
- 18:20what one can say is that the arrival of low -Earth
- 18:23orbit satellites have changed the game as far
- 18:26as satellite connection for the Internet is concerned.
- 18:29lowers the cost immensely. It is much more reliable,
- 18:32and the latency, the time that it takes to send
- 18:36the signal up and down, is much better than with
- 18:38satellites higher up in the air. But the cost
- 18:41is the big thing. It is a very valuable service
- 18:44to have in remote areas, and therefore in South
- 18:47Africa, for example, it speaks obviously that
- 18:50huge parts of South Africa will benefit, which
- 18:52do not benefit now from fiber or cell tower connection.
- 18:57Starlink was the first large LEO operator, but
- 19:00it's no longer the only one. There's competition
- 19:02in the US from Amazon, but there's also competition
- 19:06from Europe, and as we've discussed, competition
- 19:08from China. And it's particularly Chinese companies
- 19:11that are moving very aggressively and very fast.
- 19:14So for me, the issue is not whether Starlink
- 19:17is here or not. The issue is whether South Africa
- 19:19can have access to low -earth orbit satellite
- 19:22technology. That's the issue. And then with that,
- 19:25what are the prices? Is it affordable so that
- 19:29rural South Africa can buy into it? That's really,
- 19:32I think, the key issue. The key issue is not
- 19:34which company. The issue is the availability
- 19:36of the technology. There's no question that LEO
- 19:40networks in South Africa will increase rural
- 19:44access to the internet, and that will be good
- 19:46for everybody. And the more players we can have
- 19:48giving that service or rendering that service,
- 19:51the better the prices will become. Do you think
- 19:55that one single clinic in Limpopo is a forerunner
- 20:01of things to come? I certainly hope so. And yes,
- 20:03I think so, because nothing succeeds like success.
- 20:06When I'm quite sure in that particular area,
- 20:09people will start going to the clinic so that
- 20:10they can connect to the internet. And that's
- 20:12the way that it spreads. Thank you very much.
- 20:16Fascinating. Thank you. To our listeners, go
- 20:19well until we speak again. Thank you for listening
- 20:23to the So What Podcast. If you enjoy this content,
- 20:27please don't forget to leave a review and a rating,
- 20:29and please consider subscribing so you don't
- 20:32miss any future episodes. Also, tell your friends.
- 20:36Remember, you can find a written version of all
- 20:38JP's content at jplandman .co .za.