Latest / The Brief / Challenging the Moratorium
Transcript
- What happens when a public health emergency collides with private property rights, and the rules stay in place long after the emergency fades? Today’s episode sits right at that intersection.
- Not as a policy debate, but as a firsthand account.
- This is our third interview-style episode of The Brief, and our guest is Bill Cullen, a longtime Minnesota housing provider who challenged the state’s COVID-era eviction moratorium.
- And today, Bill is sitting down with Aubrey to walk through what led him there—what the lawsuit was really about, and what this moment revealed about housing policy under pressure.
- It’s a conversation about leadership, limits, and who ultimately bears the cost when emergency policies outlast the emergency.
- That conversation starts now on The Brief.
- This is The Brief.
- You're listening to the Brief, a podcast from the Minnesota Multi-Housing Association.
- Whether you're a property owner, manager, maintenance pro, product/service partner, or just curious about the industry we've got fresh insights, and quick takes, to keep you informed and ahead of the curve.
- No fluff.
- No filler.
- If it affects your residents, your business, or your bottom line.
- You'll hear about it here.
- This industry provides more than buildings.
- It offers Minnesotans a solution for home That solution is multi housing.
- Welcome to MHAs, The Brief.
- This episode of The Brief is proudly sponsored by our founding partner, Citizens State Bank.
- Rooted in the Upper Midwest with a growing presence in Minnesota, Citizens State Bank is deeply committed to supporting the region’s housing providers and small businesses through personalized financial solutions.
- Whether you're financing a new property in the Twin Cities, refinancing in Rochester, or expanding your operations across the state, their experienced team is here to help.
- Citizens State Bank specializes in property management banking solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of Minnesota’s property owners and managers.
- From commercial real estate loans, competitive deposit accounts, and a state-of-the-art business online banking suite, they provide the local insight and resources you need to keep your business moving forward.
- Experience the difference of working with a bank that understands Minnesota communities.
- Visit csbnet.net
- to learn how Citizens State Bank can help you achieve your goals.
- Member FDIC.
- Equal Housing Lender.
- Thanks to Citizens State Bank for backing this podcast and helping us bring valuable industry insights to Minnesota and beyond Week after week.
- on the brief, we're joined by Bill Cullen.
- has been a Minnesota housing provider for more than 30 years and was the plaintiff in the federal lawsuit challenging Minnesota's, COVID era eviction moratorium.
- So Bill, I'd like you to introduce yourself to our listeners.
- Who are you, how did you get into housing, and what led you to where you are today? Thanks, Aubrey.
- First of all, I appreciate your time and a little bit about me.
- I was drawn into real estate.
- I cannot explain it.
- My family has no history in real estate.
- There was something inside of me.
- If I go all the way back to my twenties, you know what I did for fun is I'd drive around the Twin Cities and look at HUD foreclosures.
- I'm sure that sounds crazy to most people, but for some reason I loved it.
- I started buying distressed property.
- I'd repair it, and then I'd rent it or sell it, and it took decades, but it became my full-time job.
- I grew to having 450 units I never used investors.
- I always used my own money and then just grew it through buying distressed property that I could clean up and make better as a real estate market.
- Started to stall in 2006 I changed and, and became a commercial broker.
- That allowed me to continue to generate revenue while the market went south.
- And then in 2021 I added first select property management to the brokerage.
- I decided it's time.
- I wanna slow down and I'm slowly unwinding my business now.
- So rather than having this brokerage and management company, I'm back to self-management and I'm enjoying it.
- I'm enjoying being back in the field.
- But, you know, other things I've done, I've always been active in the industry.
- I served twice on the MHA board.
- I'm currently serving as the first vice chair on MHA and I was a three term president with Sparrow, so I've done a lot.
- I love the industry and, and it's a blessing to be here.
- So let's talk about the pandemic, but specifically the moment when stopped being something you could absorb as a business owner and manager yeah.
- It was terrible, right? In, in March of 2020, we were all scared.
- I was scared.
- I was scared for my team.
- I was scared for my family.
- I was scared for my residents.
- People were literally dying, right? We remember that.
- And the University of Minnesota came out and estimated that 2 million Minnesotans could die.
- So government response varied around the world and from state to state.
- But what we need to do is kind of drill in as to what happened here in Minnesota in the eviction plan.
- That's what I wanna talk about.
- Well, we had the CDC eviction plan.
- That eviction ban was very narrow.
- You had to be a resident that lost income or were financially damaged due to COVID.
- You had to reach out to get help, and you had to be denied help.
- Now, the Minnesota eviction ban went in the exact opposite direction.
- It was extremely broad.
- They stopped evictions entirely.
- You could not evict at all.
- The courts were closed.
- You could only evict if the resident was a threat to another resident.
- So they, they stopped all evictions for behavior that wasn't even addressed in the CDC eviction ban.
- It even stopped lease termination.
- So ultimately what, what the Minnesota eviction ban did is it completely shifted the balance of power.
- There was no balance of power between the housing provider.
- And the resident.
- And so if a resident was troublesome or the resident could do anything that they wanted and there was nothing that the housing provider could do.
- What was the moment when you realized this wasn't just difficult, this was something that needed to be challenged? Yeah, of course.
- Try to adapt.
- I mean, we all did, and in fact, at the beginning I supported this.
- I came out and I.
- Said, look, I get it.
- I understand how, you know, again, people were dying at the beginning of this.
- But as we learned more and more about COVID, we realized, wait, there are ways to manage this.
- And other states were making other decisions, other nations were making other decisions, and Minnesota had this very strict eviction ban.
- So what happened to me, I have, I have this, this Lily 11 unit building up in Columbia Heights.
- That's how the lawsuit ended up being Heights versus wa.
- So it was up in Columbia Heights, one of the 11 residents.
- It got outta control.
- Animal House is the only way I can describe it.
- Parties, 24 7 drugs, traffic noise, unauthorized guests.
- It was so bad that the majority of my residents in the rest of the building gave notice to leave because they didn't want to live in an animal house environment.
- But the band gave us nothing that we could do.
- The good residents that were moving were calling me and saying.
- You gotta do something, you gotta stop this.
- Well, I had no authority in the eviction ban.
- There was nothing I could do.
- I went to the resident and sell 'em.
- You can't do this.
- You're violating the lease, but what's the teeth behind that? I'm gonna remove you.
- I'm gonna terminate your lease.
- I'm gonna evict you.
- Now it's banned.
- So this 11 unit building became.
- Mostly vacant and I was instructing my management team to not lease the apartments because we felt the environment was frankly uninhabitable.
- I wrote a letter to Governor Waltz.
- I explained the situation.
- I asked him for a remedy, I asked him to try and end the eviction ban, change the eviction ban, give us something that we can do for behavioral problems, and I got no response.
- So let's talk about the case itself.
- In plain terms, what were you actually asking the court to consider here? It's so hard to talk about that because, you know, courts don't consider narratives.
- This is the narrative that this, that the eviction ban isn't working, but courts don't hear that, so you have to go in and talk to the courts.
- Legally.
- So the legal terms was private property taken for public use and the impairing the obligations of contracts.
- That's a legal phrasing that went in.
- Well, Walt's countered with that this ban is necessary to save lives.
- And so we actually, Aubrey, we never got.
- To tell that narrative, to tell the story.
- I spent three years and five court hearings arguing if the case should even be heard.
- Talk a little bit about what a takings is.
- I know you talked about the legal jargon, but maybe for our listeners, what is a takings.
- Well, if the government takes private property for public use they have to compensate the individual or the entity that they took the private property.
- So that's the nature of it, is that they took private property, they took the rights of our ability to manage our private property away from us, and that we were due compensation due to that.
- So you've seen a lot of the impacts of this the years, and it sort of impacted self-managed owners versus smaller owners versus larger operators differently.
- Talk a little bit about how that differed.
- Yeah, you.
- I, I know I'm not a small operator anymore with 450 apartments, but I still consider myself a small operator.
- But when you talk about a real small operator, the difference is it's really in percentages, you know? So I have 450 apartments.
- I had during that period about a 15% economic vacancy.
- So that means 60 apartments with no income.
- Well, that's like $60,000 a month.
- It's a ton of money.
- So I'm losing money every month.
- I'm writing a check for the privilege of owning owning and operating apartment buildings.
- But I know that if I can delay capital improvements and I can shift some expenses around, I have runway to survive.
- I can't survive like that forever, but I have runway to survive.
- Throughout this lawsuit, my name would get out there and other housing providers would call me for updates and, just to gimme advice.
- And there's one call that frankly I'll never forget.
- It was from a single woman that owned one rental home.
- And her resident had not paid her for a year.
- So granted, she only had one vacant.
- I had 60 vacant, but her percentage was a hundred percent vacant.
- She had no income at all.
- She could not pay her bills.
- She had cashed out her 401k to survive.
- So here she is, frankly ruining her future to pay the bills for somebody else.
- She cried to me for an hour, Aubrey, and I didn't know what to say.
- She wanted to know how we could speed up the lawsuit or make it go faster, but there's no way to do that.
- The courts move on their own pace.
- It's heartbreaking.
- We have the luxury of 2020 hindsight.
- So let's use that to figure out who benefited and who lost? I believe that housing providers lost big.
- I mean, I lost a lot of money.
- I was unable to do capital improvements, and candidly, Aubrey, I'm still trying to catch up on capital improvements.
- The market has not been good, and so I have not been able to maintain.
- My own buildings in the manner that I would like to maintain those buildings.
- And because of that, the residents that actually paid their rent, you know, they deserve a certain quality.
- They deserve to have their building properly maintained and properly updated.
- I was unable to provide that to them.
- So the residents that actually paid their rent.
- Did everything on time.
- I think that they got poorer service for something that wasn't their fault.
- But the thing that people don't understand is that I believe a lot of the residents that took advantage of the ability to not be evicted, that didn't pay rent during that period, I think a lot of them were harmed too.
- I mean, just in the last month, Aubrey, I've had two applicants, four apartments.
- Right now.
- And those two applicants had money due to housing providers back in the COVID era that they never paid back.
- And both of those applicants, I reached out to 'em and I said, what's going on? These, by the way, the housing providers are people, you know, I could, if I, I'm not gonna say their name 'cause I probably shouldn't, but, but they're, they're good housing providers here in town.
- And I asked them why they haven't paid that back.
- And their answer was, well that was, that was COVID.
- In their mind, they didn't have to pay it back, or that somehow justified them not making those payments.
- So here I have in, in that case again, just in the last month, two families said I declined solely because they owe previous housing providers a lot of money.
- So who did win? I mean, every, people still talk about eviction bans, like there's something great.
- So who did win? The only people that won, I believe, were residents that ultimately got funded.
- Buy, rent help.
- That's it.
- And that group met certain criteria to be approved by rent help.
- And that criteria looks a lot like what CDC had, which is prove to us you are actually damaged.
- Those residents did benefit.
- So why don't we start there and say, well, let's find a rent help like solution and pay people's rent that actually show a need.
- This was a very public and personal challenge for you and a leader in the industry, a leader in our community.
- What did this experience teach you about leadership? When the stakes are high, like you said, people's lives.
- Yeah.
- You know, Aubrey, when I started this, I, I really, I wasn't.
- I wasn't trying to lead.
- I just wanted to be able to run my apartment building.
- I wanted to be able to provide a nice home to all 11 residents and not have this thing overwhelmed by one animal house.
- And I thought, naively, now that I look back, that the case would be relatively easy.
- A lot of eviction bans around the nation were being thrown out.
- Wisconsin's had just been thrown out.
- I thought, well, we'll go in, we'll get a quick injunction.
- Everything will go back to normal.
- I lost the first hearing, and when I lost the first hearing I was surprised, so I went from thinking I'm gonna get an injunction to.
- How much do I wanna fight this? And what I decided was I needed to keep the pressure on the governor.
- There was only one other case going on in the state of Minnesota.
- Kelly Dorn had one in the state courts.
- I was in federal court at the time.
- I had this great attorney working with me, with Mike Kemp.
- I thought he was fantastic.
- He felt there was light, so we went ahead with the appeal, and we won the appeal.
- Not small, we want it big.
- Where in the appeal they said absolutely this is a taking.
- Absolutely.
- Housing providers such as myself deserve compensation and it should go back to court and determine damages.
- The decision didn't come down until the eviction ban was ending after, so it took about 16 months to get through the whole process.
- But we did get that decision that the eviction ban is a taking and that we are deserved compensation.
- So I won the case, but.
- The state went back and argued again and said, yeah, but they're immune in federal court.
- The 11th Amendment says that states are immune in federal courts.
- While the Fifth Amendment says If you take private property, you have to pay the individual for that private property.
- So all of a sudden this became a big constitutional issue.
- I just wanted an injunction.
- Then I wanted to keep the pressure on the governor.
- Now I'm facing this unknown area in the United States Constitution between the fifth and the 11th Amendment.
- And the case got national attention at that point so where it ended up is.
- It got dismissed again.
- They said, yep, the, the states are immune and they're not going to hear the case.
- So the federal courts declined to hear the case.
- I ultimately did take it back to appellate court again.
- That time the appellate court said, yeah, there's still ambiguity here, but they're not going to order the case.
- Heard.
- So my only final option was to go to the United States Supreme Court.
- And the message I got from all the experts across the nation is that the United States Supreme Court has no appetite for, for this argument right now that they have bigger fish.
- They wanted to fry so that they would not hear the case.
- We could have appealed it but the experts felt it wouldn't get a hearing.
- And there were similar cases that had been dismissed recently by the United States Supreme Court.
- So ultimately we never had a hearing on the facts.
- The story I just told you never got told to a judge and never got told to a jury.
- So the way it all ended up is I won, we were damaged, and Governor Waltz refused to pay 'cause he could have waived his immunity.
- And so the federal court declined to even hear the case, so it all disappeared.
- Well, I'm hoping that this interview provides a little bit of, a win for you because I think the story really resonates and your experience.
- And I think a lot of housing providers in the industry are really behind you.
- Yeah, I can't call it a, a financial victory, but it is a victory in that it ruled that eviction bans.
- Our a taking and that has changed, I think the public discourse around eviction bans.
- So I didn't get a financial reward, but I'm hopeful that eviction bans are slower to come, and I think it is having that effect.
- After everything that you experienced what still keeps you committed to this work and this industry.
- I still love this industry.
- I still love providing housing.
- I'm gonna keep doing it as long as it makes sense.
- Thank you Bill.
- Thank you for.
- Taking the time to sit down and tell this story, I think it's an important one not just the legal case itself, but the leadership decisions around it.
- And your perspective is, is great.
- So thank you very much.
- Well, thank you Aubrey.
- Coming up next, we're going to shift gears and head into Ask Mira.
- We asked a very practical question, one that's on theme with our interview today.
- What are the general steps to file an eviction in Minnesota? Then we'll shift gears into what's happening at MHA and.
- Denise and Logan will share details on an AI beginner's workshop that I'll be teaching at the end of April.
- The workshop is designed for anyone who wants to start using AI tools with confidence without feeling overwhelmed by technology.
- That's all ahead right here on the brief.
- Looking to refresh your flooring without the hassle? Bloomington Carpet One has you covered—with expert guidance, quality products, and solutions tailored for multi housing professionals.
- Whether it’s one unit or an entire building, their team helps you choose flooring that’s stylish, durable, and budget-friendly.
- Visit carpet-one-bloomington.com
- or stop by their Bloomington showroom to see the difference that local expertise and national buying power can make.
- Bloomington Carpet One.
- Beautiful made affordable.
- Power problems don’t wait for convenient timing.
- And in multifamily, neither can you.
- J.
- Becker partners with housing providers to keep communities powered, connected, and operating without interruption.
- From complex electrical upgrades and service troubleshooting to EV charging installations, J.
- Becker handles the heavy electrical work that keeps your properties running.
- We also provide low-voltage systems, security infrastructure, and preventative maintenance— working behind the scenes so your residents never notice a disruption.
- WE understand phased renovations.
- WE understand occupied buildings.
- And we understand that downtime costs MORE than money.
- Whether you're stabilizing an aging asset or planning your next capital improvement, J.
- Becker brings the expertise and responsiveness multifamily demands.
- Visit j becker .com
- to learn more.
- Built for multifamily.
- Ready when YOU are.
- We are, J.
- Becker and Associates.
- Alright—let’s shift gears and get practical with Ask mira.
- Yeah, because after everything we just heard in that conversation, a lot of listeners are probably thinking, okay… but what does the process actually look like today? So we asked mira a straightforward question: What are the basic steps to file an eviction in Minnesota? Mira breaks it down step by step.
- First—you need a lawful reason.
- Nonpayment of rent, a lease violation, holding over after a lease ends—those are the kinds of grounds the statute allows.
- Then comes notice, if notice is required.
- For nonpayment of rent, that means a written notice with a full accounting, required legal language, where to pay, and at least 14 days to pay or vacate—longer in some cities.
- After that, the housing provider files a complaint with the court.
- That includes information about the resident, the property, the reason for eviction—and attaching the lease and any supporting documentation.
- Once the complaint is filed, the court issues a summons, sets a hearing—typically within one to two weeks—and the summons and complaint must be properly served.
- Then comes the hearing itself.
- Both sides appear, and the judge decides whether possession is granted.
- If the provider prevails, the final step is enforcement—requesting a writ of recovery to regain possession.
- And mira made one thing very clear: missing a required step—especially notice—can result in dismissal and expungement.
- Which is why knowing the process matters—but so does having the right tools and understanding how to use them well.
- And that’s a good segue into what’s happening at MHA—because the tools available to housing providers are changing fast.
- At the end of April, Aubrey will be teaching a workshop called AI Basics Practical Applications for Housing Providers.
- This session is designed for housing professionals who want a clear, practical introduction to AI—what it is, how it’s already being used in rental housing, and where it can add immediate value.
- Participants will get hands-on experience with tools like mihra and ChatGPT, working through real-world scenarios from property management and leasing.
- It’s interactive, approachable, and ideal if you’re new to AI or want to build a solid foundation before moving into more advanced applications.
- The workshop takes place April 28th, from 9 a.m.
- to noon, at the MHA offices in Bloomington.
- Bring a laptop if you can—and if you don’t have one, just let MHA know ahead of time.
- We’ll link all the details in the show notes.
- And before we go— —today’s conversation is a good reminder that housing sits at the crossroads of policy, people, and responsibility.
- Whether it’s navigating legal process, adopting new tools, or speaking up when something doesn’t feel sustainable, leadership in this industry often shows up in moments of uncertainty.
- And those moments matter—not just for housing providers, but for the residents and communities they serve.
- Thanks for spending part of your day with us.
- We’ll see you next time on The Brief.
- This has been The Brief, an original podcast produced by the Minnesota Multi Housing Association.
- It is hosted by your two favorite AI voices—me, Denise Wilson… …and me, Logan Garcia.
- Our story editor is Todd Lillgenquist.
- Aubrey Albrecht is our showrunner and managing producer.
- The Brief’s executive producer is Sesil Smith.
- Follow and listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, mmha.com,
- and wherever you get your podcasts.
- And one more big thank-you to Citizens State Bank, our founding sponsor.
- Their support powers this podcast—and their team powers smart financial solutions for Minnesota’s housing providers.
- Visit csbnet.net
- to learn more.
- See you next time!