Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Crowning transference, Bob’s therapy, and DBT study
Transcript
- 0:00So Bob as you were heading over, and I walked upstairs to unlock the
- 0:06door for you so that you could just walk in. I always wanted to
- 0:10live in a house like that, where your friends just walk in the house
- 0:14instead of knocking on the door. That's the house we grew up in as
- 0:17a child. Our door was never locked. Even when we left the house
- 0:22for like a week, we wouldn't lock the door because I don't know if
- 0:27we knew where the key was. Because when you're six people in a small
- 0:33neighborhood, but close knit neighborhood, you know, every house in my neighborhood
- 0:38had kids my age, and we just would run in and out of everyone's
- 0:43houses, right And dogs didn't know leashes. Dogs just roamed as well,
- 0:48which led to the occasional stepping in some dog shit every now and then.
- 0:54And I like that kind of vibe. My wife isn't so into it,
- 0:59but I I want people just to walk in. Plus it makes it so
- 1:03much easier with the dogs, because if you just sort of burst in that
- 1:07it takes the dogs like half a second to realize that you're here, and
- 1:11then they ramp up and attack you after you've come in the house. But
- 1:17if I go, if you knock on the door, then they go berserk.
- 1:21And then I go to the door and I open up, and you're
- 1:23trying to get in. The dogs are rushing out the door to get It
- 1:29creates so much more chaos. So it's so much better if you if you
- 1:33just walk in, you know. And I don't know, I just kind
- 1:36of like that feeling of like you're like family, you know. Thanks anyway,
- 1:41So I walk upstairs and I unlock the door, and I think,
- 1:45what a wonderful life that I have that for work. This is a work
- 1:49day. It's Monday morning right now, Right on a Monday morning, on
- 1:55a workday, my best friend comes over and we can just talk. And
- 2:00that's my job. That's what I get paid, and you get paid.
- 2:04We get paid to do this. And I can sit here in my jeans
- 2:08and my rim shirt, and you can sit here in your jeans and your
- 2:14Penn State sweatshirt. And I can drink my coffee out of my psychology in
- 2:21Seattle merch Tumblr. That you know is a quote that I have said.
- 2:28It's my own dumb quote. If being healthy means being corny, then be
- 2:34corny is on here and it's like etched in. Yeah, I don't know.
- 2:42It's just I'm just so fortunate. Yeah. I don't have to fight
- 2:46a commute, I don't have to sit in some fluorescent office, I don't
- 2:52have to deal with some asshole boss or anything. I could just sit here,
- 2:59put my feed up and talk with my best friend and get paid for
- 3:01it. Because of the listeners. That's true. It's because of them.
- 3:07So let's get into it. What do you say, Bob? Sure,
- 3:10let's get into it long term anonymous patron, He says, Hi Kirkibob,
- 3:15I find myself very attracted to my therapist. She's very compassionate, carrying,
- 3:20and supportive. Basically everything i'd like in a partner. Compassionate, carrying,
- 3:24and supportive. I also tend to idolize, idealize her, idealize her.
- 3:30For the record, I am preoccupied. Given how perceptive she is. I
- 3:36feel like she can tell and it makes me feel embarrassed and ashamed. What
- 3:39do you think I should do? Thank you for making the world a better
- 3:43place? Bob? What do you think? Oh? You know what I
- 3:45think? I say the same thing I always say, which is, oh,
- 3:49you should definitely talk about this. I mean I've talked about my sexual
- 3:52feelings towards my therapist. I'm not even gay, so yeah, you should
- 4:00just talk about it. Have you talked about that on the podcast? No,
- 4:03not here. No, I never mentioned it. I don't think I've
- 4:04ever mentioned it to Colleen. Just happened to mention it right now. Well,
- 4:10tell us about it if you want to know. I don't want to
- 4:12talk about that any further, Thanks very much, but that you have it,
- 4:15yeah, and notice it in this and you frame it in the same
- 4:18way you would if a client had that, if another person had it,
- 4:23of how do you frame it. It's just a transferential response. It's not
- 4:28that big a deal. I mean, it always feels like a big deal
- 4:30to us because we're in the middle of it, right so the person that
- 4:32wrote in and then me with when my feelings come up. So yeah,
- 4:36it always feels like a big deal. But in the land of therapy,
- 4:40it's pretty standard. Therapists understand this stuff. Why does it happen? I
- 4:46think it happens because people either do or want to feel safe, and we
- 4:49are sexual creatures and it's not we have a narrow view of when sexual attraction
- 4:56will show up and we are weird when it comes to the sex. Were
- 5:00really rigid and stupid, and so this is just normal. It's just normal,
- 5:06psycho sexual whatever. It's just normal, and it happens, and your
- 5:11therapist is not going to be surprised. It's hard to say if they know
- 5:15or not. They might know, or they might just sort of expect it
- 5:17that it's there. Sometimes I would doubt that she would know the specifics though,
- 5:25I mean, unless he's just drooling over her with a giant boner,
- 5:30I imagine that it'd be hard so to speak to know, you know,
- 5:35he's saying that. See, I find myself very attracted to my therapist now,
- 5:42idealizing her. She probably does feel that to some extent. And if
- 5:48you're talking openly about being preoccupied attachment given you know, well, depending on
- 5:56what sort of orientation she is as a therapist, she probably expects it to
- 6:00happen. But I'm guessing that this embarrassment and shame is a product of not
- 6:09only society for being sex and negative and being weird about these sorts of things,
- 6:14but also just the you know, the reason why you're preoccupied is because
- 6:18you had caregivers that were insufficiently attuned and perhaps abusive or off putting or humiliating
- 6:26or shaming of you. And as you become more seen, you become more
- 6:31embarrassed and ashamed because that's what happened to you when you were young. And
- 6:35so that's the sweet spot, that's the corrective experience. I've seen the sexual
- 6:42attraction to therapists slightly differently over time, pretty much all in the same camp,
- 6:48but slightly differently. And I can't imagine that my point of view is
- 6:54unique. But the new place that I kind of see it is that.
- 6:58And like I said, it's just a very on things I've said before.
- 7:00But the metaphor that I'll say it's like, have you ever suddenly you walk
- 7:06in the door coming home from doing errands or something, and all of a
- 7:10sudden you have to go number two or number one, Like, all of
- 7:13a sudden, it's like this overwhelming urge. I guess the more poignant example
- 7:18is number two, where that's more of an involuntary kind of thing. All
- 7:24of a sudden, you're crowning, as they say, you're dilating, and
- 7:30it's an emergency. So biologically, the stool, if you will, was
- 7:39knocking at the door for a while. I mean, I don't know the
- 7:43I'm not a suddenly your poop moved what thirty feet down through and it must
- 7:47have been waiting there in the wings and all of a sudden, coincidentally,
- 7:55as soon as you come home, No, it's an association, your butt
- 7:59smells your own toilet and says, all right, I've been waiting. Now
- 8:03it's time. I was letting you off the hook because I didn't want you
- 8:09to shit your pants on the way home. But not gonna lie, it
- 8:15was close to shitting your pants on the way home, So now is the
- 8:18time to have that urge and you and you know, And sometimes people will
- 8:24report shitting their pants on the way to the toilet. It's like but when
- 8:28they were in the car, they didn't notice anything, you know. So
- 8:33it's the same when it comes to being sexually attracted to your therapist. For
- 8:37a lot of people, I think there was this overwhelming urge to attach but
- 8:43also to feel safe sexuality, to get that need met. Not only to
- 8:50have your sexual interaction needs met, you know, to have sexual interactions with
- 8:54people, but we also have a need to feel sexual, to feel sexual
- 9:00energy. It's important for us to have that you know that arousal in that
- 9:07urge, right, and it's been knocking at the door in this imperceptible way
- 9:15because it's waiting to come out, and it needs to come out. It's
- 9:20a biological necessity for most people. And then you know, living life and
- 9:26and you're not safe. You're essentially driving around or you're in the mall,
- 9:30and your sexuality is saying, well, we're nowhere near a toilet that we
- 9:37feel safe with. This metaphor is terrible. You know, there's toilets at
- 9:43the mall, but but they're not your toilet. But they're not your toilets.
- 9:48God knows what's going on in those bathrooms, and so your your butt.
- 9:54No, it's all subconscious. It's not a you're not you're not consciously
- 9:58suppressing, and the sexual urge is not being consciously suppressed, but it's being
- 10:05suppressed out of your awareness. And then all of a sudden, you feel
- 10:11safe with someone and it comes rushing out because it's been waiting in the wings
- 10:20to be excreted. That's a metaphor. So bad. Oh, it's so
- 10:26bad. Yeah, I guess I should retract what I said earlier and say
- 10:33that in all likelihood, I did invent this way of seeing it, because
- 10:37it's not like the other people see it. The sweat Well, it's got
- 10:39a lot of Freudian stuff to it, you know, and maybe some sensory
- 10:43motor you know, early development something, yeah, you know, sort of
- 10:48wrapped up along inside parallel to the metaphor. It's definitely anal retentive, anal
- 10:54expulsive metaphor is at least parallel to this. And that's how I see it,
- 11:01you know, the way that normally I would frame it is the more
- 11:05kind of standard is that, And I still believe this to be a worthy
- 11:09way of seeing it. Is of that when you finally find a safe person,
- 11:13not only does your attachment needs pour forth, but all of your feelings
- 11:20and needs pour forth because you finally feel safe with someone, which I think
- 11:24is a viable way of seeing it. But I and lovely, Yeah,
- 11:28but I also see it as this like specific sexual retention that has been subconsciously,
- 11:35you know, sphinctered, if you will, for maybe a lifetime,
- 11:41and then all of a sudden you get home and your your boner smells the
- 11:46toilet. So yeah, Bob, you're saying, maybe you should tell your
- 11:56therapist. Yeah, they have, it won't be the first time they've heard
- 12:01it. It's totally cool and safe and nothing weird about it. And the
- 12:05benefit to you is to be found in the telling, in the not holding.
- 12:11Yeah, what do you mean, in the being accepted by the other,
- 12:16being held in you know, decency and kindness. That's that's where the
- 12:22benefit is. I'm reminded of a story my first therapist told me a thousand
- 12:26years ago when she was She's a single mom to two kids little at the
- 12:33time, and she had a good friend and friend had a son. So
- 12:39she has two daughters son. They're little, like three, four or five,
- 12:41some of those ages, and at one point they chucked them all,
- 12:45all the kids in the bathtub to take a bath because you know, they
- 12:48were dirty or whatever. And the boy, the little boy, he stands
- 12:54up and he is humping the spicket with his little heart on while they're you
- 12:58know, I think you told me the story. Yeah, it probably did.
- 13:01I mean, I don't keep this one a secret, and you know
- 13:05it's clearly just really enjoying himself, really just feels that feels really good.
- 13:09God, it does not sound like it feels good. It's not my thing,
- 13:13But do you know what I mean, like it feels scratchy. No,
- 13:16no, the water, not the spicket, the water, Oh,
- 13:18just the I thought you meant the actual yeah, right there, like the
- 13:24pipe, yeah, oh, the stream of water. Yeah, he's yeah,
- 13:28humping away at that. And they didn't. They just sort of,
- 13:33you know, I guess enjoyed him, and we're very careful not to shame
- 13:37him for this thing. But imagine that you're you're with your family. These
- 13:41are the people that you're safe with. You're four years old. You know,
- 13:46you're not thinking in terms of you know, Victorian weirdo sexual moral nonsense
- 13:52stuff that we sort of foised on on everybody. You're not thinking about any
- 13:56of that. Ship. You're just being four. And this is what you
- 13:58do when you're unless you're shamed, in which case do you go to therapy
- 14:05as a grown up and you have sexual transfers. I'm kidding, it's totally
- 14:13normal. Yeah, and you proceed to metaphorically hump the attachment security that's pouring
- 14:22out of him. You hump the couch metaphorically. How would you feel if
- 14:28a client not only told you because you've had clients tell you this before,
- 14:33right, What if a client told you that they masturbate it to you.
- 14:37How would you feel. I think I'd be a little bit surprised. My
- 14:43thought is you can do better, and I'd be like, wow, was
- 14:48it? What do you want me to know about it? This is interesting?
- 14:52What would be your hope as you talked about My hope is that they
- 14:56just don't feel bad about it. It just doesn't matter. It doesn't matter.
- 15:01So that'd be my hope, and that would be my aim, as
- 15:05you know, sort of a Catholic person who has his own weirdo, you
- 15:11know, ideas about sex. Very careful not to shame my client passed that
- 15:16on any of my own shame careful not to but I hope hopefully not get
- 15:20in the way of just basically being candid. And it's a little bit funny,
- 15:24not not like laughing at my client, but just it's just it's all
- 15:28just kind of funny. Yeah, what about this very rare situation? Sure
- 15:35that a colleague of mine told me about that. You notice that the client
- 15:39is actually humping the couch as they're talking to you. Wow, I don't
- 15:46know. Let's see. Still same goal, don't want to shame, but
- 15:50at the same time, that's outside my own limits. Like like, I
- 15:54was sitting with a couple the other day, and you know, they were
- 15:58actually feeling affectionate towards one another, And I said what I often say,
- 16:02which is I don't really have a whole lot of rules here except you have
- 16:04to keep your clothes on. I have to keep your clothes on because that's
- 16:07just my limit. So just because I have a limit doesn't mean I'm going
- 16:11to shame somebody for it. I think if somebody was humping my couch,
- 16:15I probably asked them to stop, and because it's uncomfortable for me and talk
- 16:22about it, like what's up, what's your body doing? You know,
- 16:26you might be in your own autopilot to some degree, or you know,
- 16:30maybe you're behaving seductively. Maybe you're wanting to arouse me. You know people
- 16:36do that, and so you know, it's just an acting out of something.
- 16:41But it's an acting out of something. It's not like the way we
- 16:45idealize our therapist. That is not our therapist. That's an idealization. We
- 16:49don't actually know our therapists very well. We project on them quite a bit.
- 16:55And I'm not talking about that blank screen nonsense that you know, the
- 16:57Freudians, you know whatever, or I'm just talking about We project all the
- 17:02time on everybody. We're always in the matrix. The matrix is the view
- 17:07of reality that I have, the glasses that are over my face that I
- 17:10can't tell her there, that color and shape, the way that I see
- 17:14the world, what I pay attention to, what stands out to me in
- 17:15the stories I tell myself. It's all projection most of the time. So
- 17:22if I'm in a therapy session and I'm humping a pillow in front of my
- 17:26therapist, I'm acting something out that has to do with my narrative and zilch.
- 17:33Probably zilch to do with the actual person of the therapist, and a
- 17:37therapist's job is to work with that. But you know, like, yeah,
- 17:44it's okay to have limits, Like you have a limit that would be
- 17:47mine, I'd be like, yeah, you can't do that here. So
- 17:49with couples, are you saying that they have or well, I guess,
- 17:55are you saying that they have been physically sexually ex express it to each other?
- 18:00No, because you said you just have this. It's a way to
- 18:04encourage you. Guys can do whatever you want. You want to kiss,
- 18:08You're setting the bar so far away from what they would likely have an impulse
- 18:14to do that you're saying, look, it would take a lot to bother
- 18:18me. So if you want to hug or kiss or hold hands like,
- 18:21that's not that's a good thing. I see. So so they did,
- 18:26they wanted to have a kiss, and they took the camera and just pointed
- 18:27it in the other direction. I was like, it's really good not watching
- 18:30you guys kiss. And these people had like a makeout kiss or a kis
- 18:34kiss. I don't know, I didn't see it. And these people have
- 18:37been affectionately as strange from one another since I met them and so long before
- 18:44that. So for them to actually get to a place where they're having affection,
- 18:48genuine, playful, lovely affection, we're doing great. Yeah, it's
- 18:52not something that is emphasized enough in couple therapy that so much can be repaired
- 19:00and communicated and established through physical touch that you could never do in conversation.
- 19:07And yeah, that's true. We don't talk about that as therapists, you
- 19:11know, we talk about emotion and expression and communication and trust and those are
- 19:18all important, but for some people everything, For some couples, you can
- 19:25have atrocious communication. But if you can hug and kiss and cuddle and have
- 19:32eye contact and perhaps never verbally validate each other or verbally resolve any conflict,
- 19:41there's a there's a world in which that couple is the most healthy couple on
- 19:47the planet. So much can be communicated and so much can be felt differently,
- 19:52you know, just think about and and given our touch phobic society,
- 19:59one we avoid those kinds of things not only just as people but also in
- 20:03our field. But also we don't value it, we don't understand it,
- 20:10but it's happening, right, Like if my wife and I were to have
- 20:15some bickering throughout the day or something, and then I were to go to
- 20:22her, she would or come to me and just silently hug meaningfully, and
- 20:30just hug meaningfully. That's it. Just slow, nice, warm, quiet,
- 20:36silent hug for two and a half seconds. Then we're good like that.
- 20:42Repaired verbally, we could also work it out, but it would be
- 20:48like, Okay, let's sift through this. What did you mean by that?
- 20:52I'm sorry for that. That's all great too, It's all great too.
- 20:55But a two and a half beatingful, full frontal hug if that also
- 21:00can do it, then it's a timesaver at the very least, and it
- 21:07gets to the core of who we are as biological animals, which is the
- 21:14neurological and physiological reality and effects of that. When we are verbally talking,
- 21:22we're trying to indirectly affect that biology and that neurology. But if you can
- 21:27just circumvent the whole silliness and just go straight to the biology, then sometimes
- 21:34that's all you needed. And for me, when that happens, it's so
- 21:40weird. I'll shift from this needs to be resolved two two and a half
- 21:47seconds later, I'm just like, I don't give a shit about any of
- 21:49the things that have been happening. It's all in the past, what happened.
- 21:53I don't even care anymore. Yeah, it's magic how that works.
- 21:59We can get so locked in. It's just like, I need you to
- 22:03acknowledge that this happened and that you are wrong. You must acknowledge it,
- 22:07you must take responsibility. And then you just hug them and is uh what,
- 22:11No, I'm good, I'm cool, I'm good, and you're not
- 22:15suppressing You're just like, we're not baseline cognitive verbal creatures. We're emotional biological
- 22:26creatures. At some point in our evolution we develop language. Some hypothesize like
- 22:33accidentally, it's a product of other things that we needed to survive, and
- 22:38language just emerged secondarily to that. And it's not the end all be all
- 22:48verbal and that lends itself to all the creative arts therapies and the movement therapies
- 22:52and the experiential therapies. Anyway, let's take a break. What do you
- 22:56say, Bob, Yes, all right, we're back from the break.
- 23:03So let's do an opp These people became patrons all the way back in two
- 23:11thousand and twenty one. Yeah, so we have patrons at the mug level
- 23:21they received a mug and oh I have a mug if they gave us their
- 23:26address on patrion because sometimes they don't list their address. No mug, no
- 23:30mug. Sam and Renata both are there. And then at the ten dollars
- 23:38level we have Sahana from Vancouver, BC, Amanda from Port Coquitlam, British
- 23:48Columbia, Port Coquitlam, I feel like I should know how to pronounce that.
- 23:53Oh, these are all Canada people. By the way, we have
- 23:56an Es from Surrey, British Columbia. There we have Sandra from Quebec.
- 24:03We have Christine from Montreal, I've been there. And then we have Teresa
- 24:08from Czechoslovakia. Cz It was Czechoslovakia, then it was Czech Republic. Now
- 24:15it's Czechia. What was it before it was Czechoslovakia, the Austrian Empire.
- 24:22Oh, David from Frankfurt, Deutschland or Germany. Lucy from Great Britain call
- 24:29me from Manchester, Great Britain. These are all patrons from other countries,
- 24:34middle tier patrons that became patriots at the end of twenty twenty one. So
- 24:40thank you so much. All right, question Bob, a therapist and patron
- 24:45from the UK. Oh, she says, Dear Kirkabob, I'm a psychotherapist
- 24:48from the UK who has been tuning in for a long time to the podcast.
- 24:53I recently had a lull in my personal growth and personal therapy and wanted
- 24:59to re out to let you know the impact your open discussions have had on
- 25:03me. Oh, I deeply appreciate the vulnerability that you share between each other
- 25:07and with us. It is inspiring to hear these presented so sensitively. When
- 25:11listening to Bob talk about his relationship with his own therapist. It has given
- 25:17me the inspiration and confidence to approach my own long standing therapist and tell him
- 25:22what I wanted and needed from them. Well, it has allowed me to
- 25:27find the courage to push myself further and into scary territory. Relationally, this
- 25:33has benefited me although it has been terrifying, but more important to me,
- 25:40it has benefited the clients I work with, who I now feel more open
- 25:45with. Just chiming in, that sounds like something you would say. It's
- 25:49like, my therapy has helped me emotionally, but more importantly, it's helped
- 25:53me to serve other people, which is great to serve other people. But
- 25:57I'm just saying it's like, well, I think i'd prioritize you over your
- 26:03clients. That's it's important to prioritize the clients, but just to add a
- 26:08question to them into the mix. So that's therapist the patron from UK just
- 26:15wanting to be complimentary to you, Bob. It's nice, thank you,
- 26:19just to add a question. I'm wondering what has helped you be more honest
- 26:22or push yourself further in your personal therapy journeys, whether it was a theory
- 26:27or a person or purely a therapist that you have. So I think what
- 26:33she's asking is, how do you you know? Because that's what she's doing,
- 26:37She's having to push herself further. And so therapist, the therapists,
- 26:44what do you do? What have you done to push myself as a client
- 26:49in therapy right Well, one of the things I've done is accept feedback about
- 26:57the focus of therapy, wherein I used to think a good therapy session is
- 27:03if I, you know, talk about my mother, you know, and
- 27:06complain about some of her inanity or or or talk about a conflict with Colleen,
- 27:10and you know, like probably complain about something about Colleen, and you
- 27:14know, anyways, And what my therapist does pretty consistently is he won't tell
- 27:18me not to talk about a thing, and he often will say if it's
- 27:22what you want, then great, if it's what you want, and he'll
- 27:26encourage me to declare I want, I want to talk, I want to
- 27:30tell a story, I want to talk about that, you know whatever,
- 27:33and the focus is on what's happening between him and me right now. So
- 27:44those the reason that's important to me is because those are smoke screens. They're
- 27:48often pseudo pseudotherapy. I guess it's a maybe a. It's not a word
- 27:52he would have used, but it's a bids indirect bids for closeness. Yeah.
- 28:00Yeah, that's a nice way to put it. Yeah, exactly.
- 28:02So what he wants to do is just put that on the table and make
- 28:04it, make it explicit, right over and over and over again. Instead
- 28:10of I want to talk about Colleen so that I get you to validate and
- 28:15be with me and not judge me, you can say I just want you
- 28:19to validate me and not judge me, and maybe even more directly, I
- 28:23want you to be a safe person that loves me. Right. Well,
- 28:29yeah, that sounds good. What do you mean? Well, I haven't
- 28:32thought about it before. It's like, what do I want? You know,
- 28:34like he'll just continually pose the question, but it never occurred to me.
- 28:37I actually might want something like what you just said. It never occurred
- 28:41to you. I thought we talked about that. Maybe we did. I
- 28:44don't know. Huh yeah, yeah, I don't know. Does that feel
- 28:48right? Yeah? How so? Well, what else would it be?
- 28:52I don't know. I mean the things well, I mean, do I
- 28:56really want to help with the problem? Do I really want him to vow
- 29:00and say, yeah, she's a jerk bibb. Yeah, probably not,
- 29:03but ostensibly that's what I might ask for or hint at ostensibly, but you
- 29:08know what's really wanted. I don't often know what's really wanted. I don't
- 29:14often have words for it. And like I was saying the other time we
- 29:18were talking about this, it's worse, like I don't want to pay attention
- 29:23to what I want. I don't want to notice. I freeze up.
- 29:29I am really just tonic about wanting in general, and I don't don't don't
- 29:37want to. So I'm in therapy lately. I am frozen and upset and
- 29:47ashamed and probably scared. Yeah I think scared. It's sad, and have
- 29:53no words. And his one of his working theories is that I'm, you
- 29:59know, some kind of verbal trauma thing going on for me or whatever,
- 30:03and it's very uncomfortable. I really hate it, but you know, that's
- 30:08what it is right now. So that's what it is. Uh So the
- 30:12question is how do I push myself? That's how I don't even know what
- 30:17kind of answer that is, but that's what I got. If you think
- 30:22about the understandable desire to be loved and safe, loved by him. If
- 30:30you think about that, does that help if you acknowledge that in your head?
- 30:36I don't want to acknowledge that for some reason. Another whiny right now,
- 30:41Uh, why don't you want to acknowledge it? I don't know.
- 30:42I don't want to give him a satisfaction or you mean a satisfaction? Yeah
- 30:49why not? Why me? Well you're the one who said it, But
- 30:53what what why would it be my satisfaction? Yeah? Yeah, right,
- 31:00I know, right well, it is shameful to me to want so,
- 31:03Like Colleen's like, you know, I have chronic insomnia, right, you
- 31:06know this about me? And she'll be like, well, you know,
- 31:10why don't you put on a podcast and listen to a podcast. That's a
- 31:11good way to go to sleep. She listens to dateline shows, you know
- 31:15Dateline You know Keith Morrison. Oh he's got a great voice, but oh
- 31:19he's such a tool. I think that's part of why he has that job.
- 31:23Anyways. So but she's like, yeah, I get how this works.
- 31:29If I suggest it, that's the last thing you're gonna do. And
- 31:32it's sort of like, yeah, I am kind of like if I don't
- 31:34come to it on my own, I don't really accept influence her feedback very
- 31:38much so, and she might actually be right that listening to a podcast is
- 31:44a good way to go. And I think it's because she's the closest person
- 31:48to me. I have the hardest time accepting any influence from her whatsoever.
- 31:51And I know it drives her nuts sometimes and so so, but I don't
- 31:57like being caught wanting. It's like being caught with my hand and a cookie
- 32:01jar. You know, I'm not supposed to want a cookie, So if
- 32:05I get cookies, I usually have to buy myself and keep it a secret
- 32:08or literally. Yeah, it's not metaphorically not cookies. It's this time it's
- 32:15Tony's Milk Chocolate Bar. Oh, they're so good. Tony's Milk Chocolate Bar.
- 32:19You, Tony's Chocal Lonely. Let me let me go these now.
- 32:22Tony's dark chocolate very good. And lately I've been on a milk chocolate kick
- 32:28and Tony's Chocal Lonely milk chocolate is really good. Choko lonely, Choco Lonely.
- 32:32It's kind of a sad name. I know, I don't get it.
- 32:36Chocolate lonely. Yeah. Anyway, so you're saying that you buy these
- 32:40chocolate bars and you have to hide them because you can't be conspicuously wanting and
- 32:47consuming something in front of Colleen. Yeah, when you say it like that,
- 32:52it just sounds awful. I mean, it's very unfair that the internalized
- 32:58father is doing that to you. Oh, I was thinking it'd make her
- 33:00mad. Doesn't have anything to do with Colleen. Yeah, she wants you
- 33:06to have chocolate, Well does she? You know, certainly if she understood
- 33:12the context, she would want you to have fucking chocolate. Okay, then
- 33:15yes, if she thought that it had to do with you feeling, she
- 33:22wouldn't want to have the that foisted on her that you were hiding out of
- 33:29fear about her, even if she had a slightly negative like I don't know
- 33:34if that's the healthiest thing, but if she she certainly wouldn't say and therefore
- 33:39you can't have it, you asshole, or you better hide it from me,
- 33:44because you know, that's like a completely other like ballpark. So it's
- 33:50as I do with Colleen, has to do with your internalized father and mother.
- 33:53Really, Yeah, well that might mean more your mom in some ways,
- 33:59Like the sandwich example, the sandwichman's a sandwich. You came home and
- 34:04oh, yeah, the egg sandwich. Yeah, yeah, mother's milk if
- 34:08you will. Yeah, when I was in fourth grade. So let's see,
- 34:13you're how old are you in fourth grade? You're tensh It was nineteen
- 34:19seventy six, So it was the bi centennial in Philadelphia, right, so
- 34:22oh yeah, I mean it was a big deal in Seattle. I can't
- 34:24imagine Philadelphia. Yeah, yeah, I guess. Yeah. I only I
- 34:29remember it because we were studying it in fourth grade. And now I think
- 34:31about all that stuff and I'm like, oh my god, it's wake Gye
- 34:34history. But nonetheless, that's what we did. And so she took the
- 34:37day off work and she pulled me out of school and we went down to
- 34:39Philadelphia and walked around and went to the Franklin Institute, which is like a
- 34:44science museum, and walked around Historic Philadelphia, which is really really cool,
- 34:50and Betsy Ross's house is somewhere there, and they you know, nobody knows
- 34:53if she really made the first flag or whatever. You know. Anyways,
- 34:57and the Liberty Belt though we didn't actually get to see the liberty bell,
- 35:01but they were selling little souvenir liberty bells. Their pencil sharpener, and I
- 35:07asked for one and she said no, and so I didn't get one,
- 35:14and I didn't really think much of it. And then, let's see about
- 35:20fifteen years ago, maybe so I'm fifty seven. That was when I was
- 35:24ten, So about fifteen years ago, ish I went, I was visiting
- 35:30home and she pulled one out and she said, I always felt like a
- 35:34jerk. Wow, oh yeah, you have to not for not buying this
- 35:37for you know, it was seven dollars. And I don't know why I
- 35:40said no, but I did. I said no, and I always felt
- 35:43bad about it. And so I have this Liberty Bell pencil sharpener somewhere in
- 35:46my house. Yeah, well I forgot about that. That is strong evidence
- 35:54that she suffers from a similar shame spiral that you do. Oh yeah,
- 35:59my mom, it's very wrecked. And you know because presumably soon after she
- 36:05felt bad, but she sat with that for forty years. Yeah, yeah,
- 36:10that's just like a stude on it. Yeah, and probably you know,
- 36:15spend a bunch of that time denying herself, but also like beating herself
- 36:17up. Yourself yep, yep, yep, yeah, yeah, sorry,
- 36:21it doesn't. I think it's the only time she ever apologized to me.
- 36:24That's not her strong suit. Yeah yeah, so yeah, but it requires
- 36:32confidence and stability and non shame to apologize. That's the irony. Yeah,
- 36:43there's something about it that that bothers me. Like I probably told you this
- 36:45story about my my therapist I had a while back, not my current therapist.
- 36:49Really lovely, she was really I really like her. She was very
- 36:52cool. And she at the time had a kid who was twenty two daughter,
- 36:57and she sat her down one day and apologize for the things that she
- 37:01had done as a parent that she thought were a mistake and went through a
- 37:05list and you know, almost like a twelve step make amends kind of thing.
- 37:08But I'll just get twenty two. And her daughter laughed and said,
- 37:14oh mom, no, those things were okay. But this other thing that
- 37:16you did, that one that one bothers me. And my therapist a very
- 37:22gracious person, she said, yeah, you're right, I'm sorry and apologize.
- 37:27I have never heard of a parent doing that, and yet parents,
- 37:32I mean, I think it's probably the toughest job anybody ever took, is
- 37:36to raise another human. But and so you know, you screw up,
- 37:42you just screw up. And I don't know why. If you mess up
- 37:46at work, usually you can say you're sorry, Well maybe, I mean
- 37:51if you're smart, but by I get your point is like, look,
- 37:55if you can't apologize at work, a much bigger thing that you should be
- 38:00apologizing would be any deficits in parenting, right, which everybody has to some
- 38:07degree or other has screwed up and messed up their kid to some degree,
- 38:09probably everybody, mostly not Jeffrey Dahmer. It's fine on the one hand,
- 38:14But on the other hand, why wouldn't you Why wouldn't you apologize? Like
- 38:17that's your if you love the kid, you love the kid, right,
- 38:22you love the kid, and you know you messed up because all parents mess
- 38:25Why isn't I'm sorry part of a rite of passage around the age of twenty
- 38:30all throughout life or yeah, as it happens, and vice versa. If
- 38:36you love your parents, then why haven't you ever apologized? Right? You
- 38:40swiped a bottle of bourbon and you took the car in the middle of the
- 38:44night, you smushed into a telephone pole. Need to come get you to
- 38:46the cop shop? Right, I should probably say you're sorry? Yeah,
- 38:51yeah, I mean apologize is the bigger thing. Don't have to say the
- 39:00words I'm sorry. Like with my parents, I've said many times things along
- 39:07the lines of, oh, I was real, I was really a piece
- 39:10of work. I was such a snot nosed teenage, arrogant, know it
- 39:16all thirteen year old. I can't imagine what it was like to try to
- 39:20deal with me. I didn't say I'm sorry. I didn't say those words,
- 39:24but it's an acknowledgement, but it's an apology. Yeah, yeah,
- 39:29And I mean, I'll add to the list. My parents have apologized to
- 39:31me many times. That's good. Not in that sort of therapisty way.
- 39:36Yeah, that's that's maybe not important. But my dad and my mom,
- 39:39that's great. And I know that they feel tremendous shame about their parenting,
- 39:45which is going way too far with the regret, like way too far,
- 39:54and I've you know, talked about it on the podcast with both of them.
- 40:00Yeah. Do you think it's an artifact of starting so young that they
- 40:02have it's an artifact of their childhood? Oh okayticulate my mom regular the same
- 40:08as you, abuse and difficulty, and then it just gets internalized and then
- 40:15applied where it doesn't apply. We are great disorders. Yeah, yeah,
- 40:22I think there's a lot of parents that apologize. But in fact, I
- 40:28know I know a lot of parents who will apologize to their four year old.
- 40:32I think that's great. I think it's more of the norm. Now,
- 40:37that's good. Yeah, that wasn't the norm for at least my norm.
- 40:42Yeah, that's the same. In fact, you know, some of
- 40:44the parents who I know have deeply apologized to their kids. They're currently parents
- 40:50now your friends, yeah, some of your friends that I know. Yeah,
- 40:53that's cool. Yeah, particularly dads. That's not the stereotype anyway,
- 40:59from fifty years ago. Well that's really great, man, But you deserved
- 41:02an apology. You had a slight apology there. Oh yeah, that's true.
- 41:08Yep, yep, yeah yeah. I was really surprised by that because
- 41:14it wasn't something that stuck to me. You know, I used to my
- 41:17parents saying no, but you remembered it. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 41:23I do remember it. Yeah. And conspicuous consumption. Yeah, that's
- 41:30not my that's really not my forte So finished the last of my Tony's last
- 41:36night, thinking I'm going to go there on my way home today. Such
- 41:38are Market's the best it is, it has everything it does. It has
- 41:43really good kimchi really yeah, wow, as the diekone kind that I like.
- 41:49The scallops have gone downhill, unfortunately, but everything else, even the
- 41:52frozen ones. Well, that's what we used to get is they used to
- 41:55have frozen ones in a bin and you just picked the ones out there you
- 42:00want. Now I don't know how they do it. I think they're prepackaged
- 42:04or whatever, and I've had them and they're just not as good as they
- 42:07used to be. And have you gone to the other scallops area, like
- 42:10in the freezer with the packaged scallops? Really, I don't know. Oh,
- 42:15I'm guessing there might be some in there. I should look. You
- 42:19should tell the butcher. They'd want to know that, Oh, I should
- 42:23ask. Yeah, I mean yeah. They pride themselves they got it all
- 42:29there, they do, they do. And it's a very good store.
- 42:30Yeah yeah. And by the way, it's not called Central Market anymore.
- 42:32It's called Town Country. I don't know why I'm going to call it Central
- 42:37Market because that's what I'm used to and I don't like change. Me too,
- 42:39Yeah, me too, Bob. They're building a pet hospital there now,
- 42:45and it's not what's building there and a chicken restaurant like a like a
- 42:49fast food chicken. Anyway, let's take a break. What do we think
- 42:52about krispy Kreme? Though they're cool, right, I haven't heard any reasons
- 42:57that you hate them? Okay, good? Do you like Krispy Kreme?
- 43:00And who's the other one? Top pot? They make up. The best
- 43:05donut experience by far that I've ever had in my life was so if people
- 43:12don't know, Krispy Kreme is a old school donut coffee place, mainly donut
- 43:20from I believe the East Coast. I'm guessing, I don't know. We
- 43:22never had him dunkin Donuts for him from Okay, well, we didn't have
- 43:24him in Seattle. Yeah, And they opened up I think at least two
- 43:30Krispy Kremes in Seattle in the year two thousand and two ish. It was
- 43:36such a big deal. And one of them was in Isaquah, and oh
- 43:40right, I mean there once. Me and my family, like the opening
- 43:45week it was there, decided to check it out and so we all stood
- 43:52in line. You know, there's a there's a there was a long drive
- 43:55through back up, but there was a physical line around the and it was
- 44:00in the middle of must have been Christmas. Time was cold, and it
- 44:05took like an hour and a half to get to the front of the line.
- 44:09But since we're family and we're just chatting and stuff, and what they
- 44:15did the Krispy Kreme workers to alleviate the annoyance of waiting in line so long
- 44:21is they would take these freshly made the kind of classic donuts where it's just
- 44:29glazed, just a simple, small glazed circle donut, you know, straight
- 44:35out of the oven. There was a glass wall that you could see the
- 44:40doughnuts being made, and this worker with those plastic gloves just emerges out of
- 44:47nowhere and hands me this glazed donut, and I'm like, oh, that's
- 44:53nice. It was orgasmic. Yeah, they're really good. I've never had
- 44:59a donut like that. I'm guessing five minutes later it lost ninety percent of
- 45:06its appeal. But right out of the oven, right out of the oil,
- 45:09I guess, because they, yeah, they fry them in oil.
- 45:15I just was like, oh my god, this is so good. Right,
- 45:22And I've been chasing that dragon ever since Colleen got me into old fashioned
- 45:27donuts. So if we take a break, can we get donuts let's take
- 45:32a break. All right, we're back from the break. So patron Mary
- 45:40from California, she has an important question Bob. Okay, She says,
- 45:45I'm curious what Bob and Kirk think about this article that was featured in the
- 45:50Atlantic recently. She provides a URL and she says, to summarize, a
- 45:59thousand Usustralian teens were put into a study. Half got regular health curriculum and
- 46:06the other half received a DBT based mental health program. So a thousand Australian
- 46:13teens half get a regular health curriculum and the other get a DBT based mental
- 46:20health program. Who are these who are the subjects? They just random,
- 46:22They just pick a whole school or something. Why are you asking that question?
- 46:28Well, I'm giving therapy to people who don't don't want therapy or don't
- 46:32need therapy is kind of weird, right, and particularly DBT. Yeah right,
- 46:38So Mary says, plot twist and then quotes the article the therapy.
- 46:45The DBT therapy seemed to make the kids worse immediately after the intervention. The
- 46:51therapy group had worse relationships with their parents and increases in depression and anxiety.
- 46:58They were also less emotionally regular and had less awareness of their emotions, and
- 47:02they reported a lower quality of life compared with the control group. And then
- 47:08Mary says, what do you think about this surprising outcome? The article cited
- 47:14participant age reluctance and suggests that focusing awareness on negative thoughts might have actually created
- 47:21worse outcomes based on your experience, what can explain this? How might we
- 47:25think about helping adolescents manage their mental health? Bob? What do you think?
- 47:31Yeah? Well, one possibility is part of imagine. What they're doing
- 47:36is teaching DBT skills. They're not doing DBT therapy, but they're teaching DBT
- 47:39skills. Okay, fine, And if one of the modules is going to
- 47:45be about assertiveness, then perhaps children at home are practicing the skills that they're
- 47:50learning and running into homeostasis where the system doesn't want to change. The system
- 47:55hasn't been prime to change. There isn't buy in from the the members of
- 48:00the system to actually do the change, and so you've got a squeaky wheel
- 48:05who's gonna get Well, no, no, no, that's the wrong metaphor.
- 48:10But anyways, perhaps they're they're met with anger or resistance or frustration or
- 48:21irritation or shaming or whatever at home if they're doing something that's you know,
- 48:25new, just because they learned it. Like I remember, we had a
- 48:29very mild, meager assertiveness class when I was in seventh or eighth grade,
- 48:36like really dumb. My teacher was a oh my god, he was such
- 48:39an asshole. Anyways, I tried using some of that with my mother once
- 48:45and there's ninth grade, I guess, and oh she got really angry with
- 48:49me. So I could imagine something like that might happen in people's home life,
- 48:53which is going to have an enormous impact on you know, the things
- 48:57that got measured their quality of life and whatever their momotion regulation. Yeaha YadA
- 49:00YadA. So I mean, the only thing I could conclude is we shouldn't
- 49:07give therapy to people who haven't asked for it. That's not that's that's sort
- 49:12of true. I mean I think that's true, but that's it's only partially
- 49:16related to this particular thing. Yeah. Yeah, I'd have to look at
- 49:21the study, and I'm too lazy to do so. But there's a lot
- 49:25of possibilities. I mean, the notion that somehow DBT harms kids is ridiculous.
- 49:32There's been study after study after study showing And the other thing is DBT
- 49:37isn't rocket science. It's it's emotional awareness and regulation. That's all that it
- 49:44is. It has a particular style of radical acceptance and mindfulness by opponents,
- 49:52right, huh, their components. Yeah, but it's it's just emotional awareness
- 49:58and regulation. And when you learn the actual curriculum it, you could see
- 50:05how it has particular effectiveness than other kinds of programs, or at least it
- 50:10would be one of the better ones. But it's not strange. It's not
- 50:15provocative. Particularly, it's not avant garde. Elements of it might be considered
- 50:22that. Like if you see the facilitator with one of those meditation bowls,
- 50:30you think that you gong or something one of those. It's just a noise
- 50:34maker. That's just a noise maker. It just makes a pleasant noise that's
- 50:37supposed to demarket something, you know, like now is the time that we're
- 50:42in class, or now is the time that you quietly practice mindfulness or whatever.
- 50:47Yeah, that's exactly right. It's not calling upon the ancestors or devil
- 50:52or whatever. I don't know, But the point is is that that's all
- 50:57that it is, so something went wrong. And also you know half of
- 51:04the you know, the control group was that they got a regular health curriculum.
- 51:08Well, the regular health curriculum could also have a lot of emotional awareness
- 51:13and regulation in it. Yeah, who knows what's in that, right,
- 51:15maybe a pretty good one. Also, if we're talking about a thousand Australian
- 51:21teens were put into a study and it sounds like, well, I guess
- 51:23I would wonder who were the DBT facilitators Because if you just randomly grabbed high
- 51:30school teachers and trained them on it, then something weird could happen. At
- 51:35the very least, you could have teachers that aren't really bought into the model,
- 51:38right, But and at the worst, you could have people that have
- 51:43no idea what they're doing. Oh yeah, you know, because Bob has
- 51:49shown me that you know, through you describing your DBT teaching approach, that
- 51:55it takes charisma and wisdom and therapeutics skill in years to convey these ideas and
- 52:05to get people to buy in and to inspire people and to adjust to certain
- 52:09questions. You can't just like walk through the curriculum without having that very specific
- 52:17therapeutic skill. I mean I'm guessing that the average therapist, if you'd even
- 52:22train them on DBT, that if you just threw them into especially a bunch
- 52:28of teenagers that are not necessarily on board with doing any of this, that
- 52:36it could be you know, annoying to do for everybody, the teacher and
- 52:40the kids included. I like that annoying, whereas a regular health curriculum might
- 52:45be a lot more tolerable. It's a lot more down to earth, or
- 52:49a lot more simple or something expected. Yeah, expected, And so I
- 52:57you know, maybe they accounted for all this in the study, and like
- 53:00I said, I'm too lazy to find out otherwise. But also in addition
- 53:05to what Bob said of just like it could create these effects because you're beginning
- 53:10the journey of healing, and that pulls everybody, including the client, but
- 53:17also the system out of their homeostasis, which is going to cause disruption and
- 53:23upsettedness. You suddenly have a teenager that is asserting themselves and that is not
- 53:29going to feel good to anybody, including the teenager at first. Right.
- 53:32So not only that, but when you ask people who have been suppressing their
- 53:38emotions and have never been asked about their emotions and have thus developed defenses to
- 53:45ignore their emotions. And you ask them about their emotions, then they might
- 53:51suddenly start acknowledging how they're feeling. And initially they're going to feel worse,
- 53:55more anxious, more depressed, more bothersome. So that's also a possibility.
- 54:02How long was the program? Did it? Say? Right? That's the
- 54:05other thing is I have a hard time believing that it was the entirety of
- 54:08DBT, which is a year of pretty intensive work. I imagine it was
- 54:15just a module or two. Who knows, maybe it was over a year.
- 54:19But anyway, the fact that the Atlantic ran this, it just shows
- 54:25that it's just clickbait. We have studies like this all the time. There
- 54:30are countless studies all over the board regarding effectiveness and harm. We do these
- 54:37studies to ourselves. We choose to investigate the efficacy of our own models.
- 54:44We don't need outsiders to do it for us. We do that all ourselves,
- 54:47and we're very careful to provide an unbiased evaluation of these things. And
- 54:55yeah, if you cherry pick a study or two, you can find that
- 55:00all of therapy harms people. So when you take DBT into you take all
- 55:07the studies and you look at it, as with all the studies with CBT,
- 55:13you find that overall it's beneficial to people, there's a percentage that will
- 55:19be worse off afterwards, either just randomly or because they just don't fit with
- 55:22the model, or they have a terrible teacher, or they had a terrible
- 55:25classmate or whatever it happens. So that's what I'll say about that. Yeah,
- 55:32sounds good. But Bob, given your knowledge of DBT, oh sure
- 55:37if there was a real effect here that was happening, and you know,
- 55:45let's say that with these five hundred Australian teenagers they were using DBT well enough.
- 55:52It wasn't fantastic, but it was. That's not the issue, and
- 55:58it's not assertiveness emerging or emotional awareness emerging. It's actually the model. Like
- 56:07let's say you were the one, you were the one that taught these five
- 56:12hundred teens, and you had say two months, and the data was there
- 56:22that the kids, on average, compared to the kids going through the regular
- 56:25health group health curriculum were you know, a little bit not significantly, but
- 56:32a little bit more on average, anxious, a little bit more on average,
- 56:35depress, a little bit more on average feeling worse, like they wished
- 56:42they hadn't gone through it, they wished they had done the regular health program.
- 56:46What on what would be like a possibility that you would look at.
- 56:52We did not involve families. Like most of the time when they when teens
- 56:59in Rome DBT, their families are part of the process, like their families
- 57:04and like my friends did family groups. So they'd have a skills group be
- 57:07six families, three people, you know, an identified client which as a
- 57:10kid and then a parent or both and or both parents or whatever whoever the
- 57:16caregivers at home are and they'd all engage, so they're all learning the same
- 57:22thing. So my guess is if it were me, I'd be thinking,
- 57:25Yeah, the reason this failed is because we did not involve the family.
- 57:30And what negative effect would that have on efficacy? I think it would just
- 57:36sort of set kids up to feel like shit. It would just set them
- 57:39up for that because they're being handed something. It's like being given a car
- 57:45without ever being taught how to drive. Okay, great, now you go
- 57:49get behind the wheel and you drive, You're going to have a bad day.
- 57:52I think that's probably what happened, is they were, you know,
- 57:55sort of the rudiments of this is a car. Here's where the steering is.
- 58:00Now, go drive. You're not gonna That's not enough, meaning they
- 58:06needed more guidance, more mentorship, more help, more support, more support,
- 58:10more guidance, more mentorship, and more involvement, more proactive and involvement
- 58:16of you know, the real people in their world, which is you know,
- 58:21probably a parent. The students in your DBT group had an individual DBT
- 58:27therapist. Oh true, Yeah, they had an individual therapist. And they
- 58:30were also volunteers who were there for a reason. They weren't forced into it.
- 58:34They wanted it, They sought it out right. They were also suited
- 58:40for the model, which is people who have a particularly hard time with distortions
- 58:47and over emotional reactivity and downward spiraling and that kind of thing, either are
- 58:53self identified or a caregiver, a doctor or another therapist suggested that they do
- 59:00the thing. Yeah, I suppose that could be one effect to look at
- 59:05anyway, that the model assumes a fairly high level of distortion regarding one's emotions.
- 59:13Right, because typically borderline individuals right, typically, and with them pre
- 59:20recovery, they will interpret the smallest thing real or imagined behavior in their attachment
- 59:29figure as an indication of abandonment or betrayal, and then they'll get upset and
- 59:34downward spiral. And so a big part of DBT is to ask a question
- 59:38and to radically accept the possibility that that isn't actually what's happening, that you're
- 59:45not being betrayed or abandoned. And that's a critical component and very helpful to
- 59:51these folks. But if you have a bunch of kids that don't have borderline
- 59:55and they don't have that distortion, you can imagine a well meaning facilitator hammering
- 1:00:02on that module and having kids start to second guess themselves or wonder, why
- 1:00:10am I being forced to believe that my perceptions are distorted or something. You
- 1:00:16know, that's just another possibility. All right, Well, that does it
- 1:00:21for that episode in which I talked about crowning and going number two and everyone
- 1:00:30out there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it.