Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Rethinking Islam: with Adam Elmasri
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking feels so much more happiness. Truth, Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Adam L.
- 0:57Massri is a YouTube post He's got two channels, one in Arabic and one
- 1:03in English. His website describes him as an Australian Egyptian freethinker, speaker,
- 1:10human rights activist, author and content creator. He has been on the debate
- 1:15scene. He founded Faith Crisis Australia and this is an organization to help ex
- 1:22Christians as they navigate their post to religious life. His most recent book is
- 1:27titled How Did Christianity Begin Really? Published in Arabic. He is a registered
- 1:36therapist with the Secular Therapy Project and he also serves recovering from Religion dot Org.
- 1:44Adam, I guess we don't have time to talk now that I've given
- 1:47your resume for about forty five minutes at the beginning of the conversation, Adam,
- 1:51it's great to talk to you. Thanks for coming. Thank you so
- 1:53much for the wonderful introduction. How do I greet you? If we were
- 1:57Muslims? Is it a SALAMU? All like them? Absolutely? ISLAMI like
- 2:02them, Yeah, And then you would respond to what's the reply? Well,
- 2:07it depends because I'm not fanatic enough. I would say we like them
- 2:10Salem. But if you're talking to a specific sixt in Islam, they would
- 2:15just say we like them without repeating Salam. Okay, I'll work on it,
- 2:20you know, because I want to be able to do it properly.
- 2:23I guess, uh, you're all over the place, and I mean this
- 2:25in a good way. On your resume. I'm seeing all right, I
- 2:30got Australian, I got Egyptian, I got Islam. Can we start with
- 2:34Islam? With that being all right with you? Adam, Absolutely, let's
- 2:37start with terms. I hear Muslims, I see Muslims online. They quote
- 2:42from the Qoran and the Hadith. What's the difference. Does Islam have like
- 2:47two Bibles. The Quran is the holy book. Think about it as you
- 2:53think of the Bible. It is the official holy book that was apparently revealed
- 2:59from God. The hadith is the sayings that are attributed to the prophets.
- 3:05So most of d hadith come through a chain of narratives. Think of the
- 3:08Disciples of Christ. It's in the same sense that anything the disciples of Christ
- 3:14said about Christ that would be the hadith. Is it to be understood or
- 3:19assumed that Mohammad wrote all of the Koran wrote is a very tricky word here.
- 3:25Ah. So officially God is the author of the crime. So when
- 3:32you say who wrote the Crian, it's supposed to be God, but yeah,
- 3:36transmitted through Muhammad, that would be the official way of saying it.
- 3:40Well, they say the same thing for the Bible. Moses wrote the Penitug,
- 3:46so Moses could not have been there before spacetime, before the creation of
- 3:51the earth and the first humans. So therefore God was sort of, you
- 3:54know, grabbing Moses after the fact and saying, Okay, here's what happened,
- 3:59and he sort of guide at Moses's hand. It's that kind of thing
- 4:01with Mohammad and the Quran hind that yes and no. In the Bible,
- 4:06what most Christians believe it was inspired by God. God guided Moses revealed to
- 4:13him in an ethereal sense, while in the Quran, Muslims believe that it
- 4:16is actually the literal words of God. It was verbatim. It's like a
- 4:21dictation. So God dictated every word and every letter of the Quran, not
- 4:27in the sense of inspiring some details and left the rest for the human touch.
- 4:31There is no human touch in the Quran. And the Hadith was that
- 4:35written in the same way allegedly, No, the hadith is the actual sayings
- 4:41of the prophet, So there is no dictation here. It's a chain of
- 4:45narration. And then the hadith has massive classification. They call it actually the
- 4:49science of classification in Islam. Where there is authentic hadith, there is weak
- 4:55khadith. There is somewhere in between semi authentic. And it all comes down
- 5:00to the chain of narrators who said what and in what way and to what
- 5:06level they were known to be accurate in repeating the Chinese whispers if if you
- 5:13want to call it that, the Bible too, like we've got the NIV
- 5:17Bible and the New American Standard and the King James and the New King James
- 5:23and all of these thousands of different variations. Any of that going on with
- 5:26the Koran, or is it one thing and you better not not change it
- 5:30or will execute your kind of thing. Absolutely, it's the same thing in
- 5:33the Quran. Wild The funny thing, Seth, I'm glad you asked that,
- 5:38because most Muslims will tell you that no, actually, the Quran,
- 5:41wherever you buy it, anywhere in the world, is going to be exactly
- 5:44the same Quran. But this is absolutely not true. It depends where you
- 5:48buy the Quran from. There are two major copies. It's like the King
- 5:53James. The King James is the most known Bible everywhere in the world,
- 5:56so that there is Huffs and Welsh for the Choran. These are two different
- 6:00versions of the Koran, and you will find the most spread. However,
- 6:04if you go to countries like Algeria or Iran or Yemen, you might get
- 6:11your hands on some interesting versions of the Koran. There's about, as far
- 6:15as I know, there is about somewhere between twenty seven to thirty three different
- 6:20versions of the Koran. You were born in Egypt. Is that correct correct
- 6:26yes to a Muslim family. No, I was born and raised Christian.
- 6:30I am a Coptic Orthodox Christian. Well, I was a Coptic Orthodox Christian.
- 6:35What's a Coptic Orthodox Christian? Optic is the word. It's an ancient
- 6:41word for basically Egyptian. Because you know, how you say Russian Orthodox or
- 6:46Greek Orthodox. Usually the first word refers to a country or a geographic region,
- 6:51while the second word is the denomination of Christianity that I belong to.
- 6:55So Coptic basically means Egyptian and Orthodox is Orthodox Egyptian Orthodox Christian. So if
- 7:01Islam is the predominant religion in Egypt and you are in a minority faith,
- 7:08how are you treated? Very interesting? Ah? Sorry, Let's say,
- 7:15let me think about are you are you second class? Are you worried for
- 7:20your safety when you know you are walking the streets and someone sees, I
- 7:27don't know, are you overtly Christian? Do you have Christian apperil or you
- 7:30know in the States, we have Christian markers that people like, whether it's
- 7:34the cross necklace or the crown of thorn's tattoo. Let's say you're broadcasting your
- 7:40Christianity in the streets. What kind of a reception do you expect? So
- 7:45Funnily enough, I do have the Coptic Christian tattoo. I'm not sure if
- 7:48it is visible on my wrist here, but this is something most Coptic Christians
- 7:55in Egypt would have at a very young age. I had this that too,
- 7:58when I was twelve years old. It's kind of our way of putting
- 8:03the faith on our in a visible way. It's kind of revealing your identity
- 8:07in a way. And it's funny because when you say are you a second
- 8:13class citizen or are you treated differently? Well, it depends on the context
- 8:16and who's treating you. Are you in a dealing with a government organization,
- 8:20are you talking about down the street dealing with everyday people. Let's put it
- 8:24this way. In many, many occasions, I was always on edge and
- 8:31not sure of the person treating me, whether that is the guy selling me
- 8:35stuff in the shop or just the next door neighbor, whoever it is.
- 8:39You always have this sense of I'm a second class citizen and it depends on
- 8:43the person in front of me how they will treat me. I don't know
- 8:48that, so so you always have your guards up in a way. If
- 8:50that makes sense, it totally makes sense. There's a couple of other things
- 8:54funny about Egypt. Is that one thing, even if you don't have the
- 8:58cross statued on your hand, your name could very well reveal your religion.
- 9:05If your name is Michael or Gighis or Paul, you're surely is Christian.
- 9:11If your name is Ali or Muhammad or any other Muslim, you're surely Muslim,
- 9:16says Sometimes your name will just reveal your religious affiliations. And the last
- 9:22thing is it's also on your ID card. That's also unique to Egypt.
- 9:26I'm not sure if it is in any other Arab country or not. But
- 9:30if a policeman stops you and asks for the ID on your ID card,
- 9:35it says, if you are Christian or Muslim, are you allowed to put
- 9:39no preference no religion on your ID? In Egypt? There is no such
- 9:43thing. You're either Christian or Muslim or Jew. But I've never seen it
- 9:48on any ID but you're allowed technically. Okay. So with the name Adam
- 9:56l Massri, are you named after the biblical Adam? I mean, would
- 10:01that give you away? Well in a way, yes, Adam is a
- 10:03very common name in Egypt, well in the whole Middle East. So yes,
- 10:09I'm named after the Great Adam. So I'm going to ask you the
- 10:13obvious next question that I ask all heathen activist or he even humanist activist.
- 10:18You had a deconstruction because you're helping others, But how did you get out
- 10:24of the faith? It was my own faith crisis, I think about ten
- 10:28years ago. It's always hard to answer that question, Seth, because you
- 10:33never go to bed one Tuesday night thinking you're Christian, and then you wake
- 10:37up Wednesday morning, I'm like, I'm not anymore. So I guess I
- 10:41went through a phase of doubts and questioning myself and I read a lot and
- 10:48it was very, very troubling. And it wasn't inner turmoil that led me
- 10:52eventually to join a very reputable university in Australia to do a degree in Biblical
- 10:58studies and textual criticism, mainly for my own benefit, because I didn't want
- 11:03to leave my faith coming from a place of ignorance, so I really wanted
- 11:07to throw myself into more knowledge, and by the end of that degree,
- 11:11I openly declared myself agnostic and from there different things led me in different ways.
- 11:18Were there consequences for you, family, friends, your social circle?
- 11:22Massive consequences. The first thing is I was excommunicated. I lost my entire
- 11:28social circle because my whole life was entrenched in the church. So overnight I
- 11:35didn't have any friends at all, zero friends. It also led into my
- 11:39divorce, so I was married at the time when I had my faith crisis,
- 11:45and then eventually that led to a divorce. I had some hiccups with
- 11:50my family, mom and dad and brother. They are all living in Australia
- 11:54and it took some time to restore the relationship with them, and luckily for
- 11:58me, it eventually got to the point that they just accepted who I am
- 12:01and it's my own personal journey. There was no shunning, but there was
- 12:07You know that they always have this idea that you probably read a couple of
- 12:09books that missed with your head. So we will convince you once we just
- 12:13if you come and sit with Bishop such and such or priests such and such,
- 12:18they will restore your faith. But more and more they realized that I
- 12:22know more than that than they can restore. I guess it's interesting how these
- 12:28cultures like to pinball toward authority at the Capitol because I had the same thing.
- 12:33I'm coming out. I'm realizing that two plus two did not actually equal
- 12:39five, and that all this stuff doesn't make sense, and people started throwing
- 12:43names apologists' books. Someone asked me to attend an apologist seminar because they have
- 12:52a theology degree. Somehow, even before they heard him speak, they knew
- 12:58he would speak the truth. They lean into these authorities, and personal thinking
- 13:03seems to shut down. I don't know if you noticed that, Adam,
- 13:07I do, and I had this dual understanding. I could see for the
- 13:11first time how I saw these people I just mere humans after all, while
- 13:18my family still thought of them as holy figures, that they are the bearers
- 13:22of light, they are the bearers of truth. So it was very interesting
- 13:26at that time because I just came out of the faith. I held these
- 13:33people at some point in my life as holy people and the bearer of truth,
- 13:35and if I needed to ask about anything, I would go to the
- 13:37priest or, to the bishop, or whoever it is. Now I'm going
- 13:41to an academic and I'm going to university to secular academics to get my answers
- 13:46from. And it was at that time that I started saying, Wow,
- 13:50my worldview has changed, and I'm saying things for the first time, completely
- 13:54different from my family. It's funny how we are so conditioned bond to give
- 14:01extra equity to somebody who begins with the introduction reverend, pastor minister, at
- 14:07least in the United States. And I tell this story. Forgive me if
- 14:11you've heard it. Everybody who was watching and listening, but free flow.
- 14:16The Florida Freethought Convention in Orlando was having its convention and there was a Friday
- 14:22night costume party and I went as a priest, and so I got a
- 14:28very authentic priest outfit and I wore it out of my hotel room and got
- 14:35into the elevator when all the way down walked through the lobby, down the
- 14:39corridors and to the party. Well on my way. You should have seen
- 14:43how people deferred to me. No idea who I was. They had no
- 14:48idea what my degree might have been in I could have been a serial killer,
- 14:52a gild Miletia. They have no idea. But I walk into the
- 14:56elevator and everybody's raucus, and they're all swapping stories and laughing, and they
- 15:01went stone quiet and start almost looked at the floor reverence toward me. Someone
- 15:09asked me if a patron had died in the hotel, and I was there
- 15:13to perform like last rites, and I thought to myself, the power that
- 15:20the clerics hold just perceptions of credibility. Jim Palmer is a guy who he's
- 15:28not religious, but spiritual, and he and I have our disagreements, but
- 15:31he says a lot of interesting and sometimes really good stuff. But he says,
- 15:35you know, somebody who has a pastoral title has no real Credibit is
- 15:41not more credible than anybody else. I don't know, I'm babbling. Adam,
- 15:45do you have any thoughts on the moms and the clerics and the pastors
- 15:48and the reverence. I probably will say exactly what you just said. It's
- 15:52so funny how in especially in the Middle East, like you're describing how it
- 15:56is in America, in the Middle East, it's multiplied by ten. How
- 16:00these people are very much regarded at a higher level. But since you're talking
- 16:06about your friend as well, who is spiritual but not religious, I went
- 16:08through that phase when I came out. It's like morphing. It's not like
- 16:15I know, I said, by the end of my degree, I openly
- 16:18declared myself agnostic. But there was a phase in between where I couldn't be
- 16:22completely spiritually naked. In a way. I needed something to hang on too,
- 16:27So I went out Christianity hanging onto some spiritual elements out there before I
- 16:33really could have the guts to declare myself agnostic or agnostic, etheist, whatever
- 16:37you call it. I always say that you're in the center of the bull's
- 16:41eye, which is high control religion, fundamental literalist, you know, Bible,
- 16:47Koran literalist. But you start to doubt, and you take the next
- 16:51step, well, the Bible is partially true or some of it's metaphor.
- 16:55And then before you know it, you take the next step and you say,
- 16:57well, that's not a religion. I don't really need the Bible.
- 17:00I love Jesus. And then maybe you take the next step and say,
- 17:03well Jesus may have been God, but he had some good things to say
- 17:07and blah blah blah. And then you end up near the ends and the
- 17:11next steps are there may be no God. That's terrifying, and it's totally
- 17:18understandable why people would pause there in this nebulous area of well, I think
- 17:23there's something out there, and I'm not religious, but I'm spiritual. I
- 17:29think that's a position of safety because for many the next steps are pretty scary,
- 17:33and in your work as a secular therapist you probably see a lot of
- 17:37that. I'm terrified to go the distance. I think maybe I'll just sort
- 17:42of sit here in the neutral zone, right totally, yeap. And this
- 17:47is the huge difference you find between Adam the activist and Adam the secular therapist,
- 17:51because Adam the activist Adam on YouTube. On my YouTube channels, I
- 17:56promote critical thinking, I challenge scripture, and I basically debunk a lot of
- 18:03beliefs on my channel. But when it comes to therapy, my role is
- 18:07not to debunk anything or challenge anything. It's my role is actually to meet
- 18:11the person where they're at. And it's a completely different position and it requires
- 18:15a lot of discipline because at that point, you're basically trying to validate where
- 18:21this person is at. You're trying to assure them that they're not going insane
- 18:26for doubting. They have every reasonable reason to doubt, how they are doubting
- 18:30and where they're at. And I get all sorts of different people, some
- 18:34people who want to leave Islam and embrace Christianity, some people who want to
- 18:40leave the religion altogether. So yeah, it's an interesting world where you do
- 18:45the work as a religious trauma therapist. Still to come. It's pretty gutsy
- 18:51to say out loud there's a bunch of bullshit in the Quran, but Adam
- 18:57has been doing that. We're going to find out more about this next.
- 19:07Thanks for your support on Patreon makes a difference Patreon dot com, slash Seth
- 19:14Andrews. You get the show early, and you get the show absolutely commercial
- 19:18free. Speaking here with Adam L Masri. He is a former religious person
- 19:27and he is helping people in their own journeys. Two YouTube channels are they
- 19:33echoes of each other? I mean, do you do a version of one
- 19:36video in English and then it's the same content in Arabic? No. I
- 19:41started the Arabic channel about seven or eight years ago. And when I started
- 19:47it, I started it just because I was I wanted to share my experience
- 19:51with others. I wanted to find like minded people who had a similar journey
- 19:55to mine, and it was my way to connect and share my two cents
- 19:59wor Little Dot. I knew at the time that it will grow into over
- 20:03one hundred thousand subscribers one hundred and twenty now I guess fifteen million views.
- 20:08It grew beyond my expectations, and it wasn't until about two years ago that
- 20:15I realized that hang on a second here, Yes, while I'm doing this
- 20:18work in Arabic, there is a huge gap in the English speaking world,
- 20:23specifically to understand Islam from an Arabic speaking person. So the material that I
- 20:30present on both channels are in a way completely different. I focus on certain
- 20:34topics on the Arabic channel that is suited for the Arabic speaker, while in
- 20:40the English world I try to present my arguments in a slightly different way,
- 20:44more focused on Islam and more suited to the Western to the Western world from
- 20:51your perspective, to people, doubters, even apostates, atheists in high control.
- 20:57Let's say one of the third teen Islamic nations, right with Islamic governments,
- 21:03Do they have access to your channel? Are they down in the basement
- 21:06looking you up online and watching you and then secretly reaching out. It depends
- 21:11who the person and what which country they come from. So I can tell
- 21:15you that there are some people, let's say in Egypt, a lot of
- 21:19people are just watching me in the privacy of their own bedroom or office.
- 21:25Usually my videos are watching private because no one is open about their current state
- 21:30of belief. But then you have a country like Afghanistan, for instance.
- 21:34This is a country that officially I received a number of emails from YouTube saying
- 21:38that a government body in Afghanistan has requested for this video to be banned in
- 21:45their country. And I have about fifty percent of my channel banned in Afghanistan.
- 21:51Yet I received messages from people from Afghanistan saying, well, don't worry,
- 21:55brother, we will use VPN, or we found ways to browse your
- 21:59videos and still watch you through the VPN. So it depends how tech heavy
- 22:03the person is. It depends what country and what length they go to ban
- 22:07your material. So you do videos pointing out things like mistakes in the Quran,
- 22:15and then what do you go down to your bunker and lock the door
- 22:17because you know people have declared war on you. Do you worry about your
- 22:21safety? I always have to ask this to people taking on Islam. Do
- 22:25you worry about somebody who's going to exact Allah's justice against your physical body.
- 22:30There is I have to be honest, there is a level of concern.
- 22:34Yes, not to the level that I am worried looking over my shoulder all
- 22:40the time. But I received the threats. I received emails and messages from
- 22:45lawyers in Egypt saying that under the blasphemy law they filed cases against me in
- 22:51the court. So one thing I am actually, I'm unable to go and
- 22:53visit my home country. I cannot go to Egypt because if I go to
- 22:56Egypt, I'll probably be arrested in the airport. The opportunity to be one
- 23:00hundred percent sure if there are cases against me or not. But according to
- 23:03the messages that I received, there are cases against me in the court under
- 23:07the blasphemy law. And I have reached out to the Australian Federal Police a
- 23:12couple of times to report death threats that I received. But that's more out
- 23:18of being wise and being cautious in a way. I try to stay private,
- 23:25not living in a bunker or anything. You're not crawling to the car
- 23:29and the prone position. Now, okay, So I open that can of
- 23:33worms, mistakes and misstatements, myths, and lies in the Quran. Uh
- 23:37Oh, I'm going to have to ask for some examples, because I always
- 23:41heard the Koran was perfect, the perfect word of Allah. What are we
- 23:45talking about. I can't remember what I presented in that particular video, but
- 23:49I can tell you a lot of mistakes in the Koran. Specifically, there
- 23:53are historical mistakes that are scientific mistakes in the Quran. It really depends.
- 23:59I can give you example of each if you wish ture. So one good
- 24:03example, since I'm from Egypt, there's a verse in the Quran where Pharaoh
- 24:11is calling someone named Herman and he's asking him to bake bricks to build a
- 24:18massive tower to go up in the skies and find out about the God of
- 24:22Moses. So Pharaoh was apparently jealous from the God of Moses and wanted to
- 24:26build a tower using baked clay to reach the heavens. And in that video,
- 24:33I am arguing that if only the author of the Quran knew that the
- 24:37ancient Egyptians never built high rises and high towers using baked clays, ABC engineering
- 24:45would say that the baked clay or the baked bricks will crumble under the heavyweight
- 24:48of the structure, so the Egyptians knew that, but the author of the
- 24:52Quran didn't know that. And of course I get all sorts of apologetic responses
- 24:57trying to say, well, you're you're trying to say that Egyptians didn't use
- 25:02baked clay or baked bricks. I'm like, that's not the argument. The
- 25:04argument. I never said that Egyptians didn't use baked clay, but they never
- 25:10used it in high rises. Specifically, if the author of the Quran knew
- 25:14that the pyramid, one stone in the pyramid weighed about five tons, wouldn't
- 25:18have set such averse. So that is one historical error in the Quran,
- 25:23a scientific error in the Quran. And again there's a lot of refutations and
- 25:26apologetic response, well, refutation attempts and apologetic response about how a character in
- 25:33the Quran named as Dulparnaine apparently went to the far edges of the earth and
- 25:41found the place where the sun sets and it was setting in murky waters.
- 25:45And while it's very clear scientific error, again people try to refute it and
- 25:52say, well, it appeared to Dulparnaine in his eyes, in the way
- 25:56he saw it, that it was setting in murky waters. But that's not
- 26:00what the Quran is saying. And again, I don't know to what length
- 26:03do you want me to present the arguments and their refutations and the responses.
- 26:07Oh, it sounds just like the Christianity apologists. If it happens to line
- 26:11up with history, it verifies the Bible. If it doesn't, it's a
- 26:15mistranslation, misinterpretation, metaphor, or the science and historians are all colluding to,
- 26:22you know, try to kill God. I don't know, it's silly
- 26:26putty. They can just sort of mash it into whatever they want. Doesn't
- 26:30the Koran say, and I'm doing this for memory, and it's early and
- 26:33I need more coffee. But doesn't it say the origin story of humankind is
- 26:37the first human was harvested from a clot of blood instead of Adam and dirt.
- 26:44Was it a clot of blood? In the Koran, it's yes and
- 26:48no. It doesn't necessarily talk about Adam as the first human, but it
- 26:52talks about how humans are created in the womb, and yes, it says
- 26:57that all human beings they start from being a clot of blood in the worm,
- 27:03which is absolutely wrong. Well, when you bring these contradictions and problems
- 27:07and morality issues to Muslims. Given the fact that I think, as I'm
- 27:14to understand it, most Muslims are like most Christians. Their scripture illiterate,
- 27:19and they'll parrot of you, cherry picked things, maybe even chanting them.
- 27:23I've heard a lot of Muslims do this. It's almost like listening to a
- 27:27parrot, an apologist parrot, where they've just got this thing and you know,
- 27:32and God is good, all'll be great kind of thing. Does it
- 27:34make a dance with anybody? When you point this stuff out? I have
- 27:40to say, Seth that I found Muslims to be much more literate about their
- 27:44books more than Christians. It's often the case that you would reveal a verse
- 27:48in the Bible and a Christian believer wouldn't have a clue or the first time
- 27:52they heard this verse. But it's hardly the case with Muslims. Perhaps that's
- 27:57because part of the is faith is to memorize the Quran, so most of
- 28:03them, whether they understand it fully or not, that's a different question.
- 28:06But they do remember the verses, and sometimes he gets this stoned face where
- 28:12they heard the verse before, they recited it a million times before, but
- 28:17they never really pondered upon the meanings, and the moment you reveal something,
- 28:22they're like, no, no, no, no, you got it wrong.
- 28:25The first point of attack is that you're not an Arabic speaker. And
- 28:29once I revealed that actually I was born and raised and grew up in Egypt,
- 28:32I am an Arabic speaker, they're like, ah, still, you're
- 28:34not understanding it correctly, and you get into a different type of argument.
- 28:40So if they read the story of Muhammad marrying a six year old and then
- 28:45molesting the child at nine, for to be honest, many people are quoting
- 28:49that, but they're not really going past they're not scratching past the surface.
- 28:55And perhaps you have the conversation that causes them to consider what they just have
- 29:00been parroting in the past, and then they have that moral dilemma. Would
- 29:04that be an example of what you're talking about, Not with this particular example,
- 29:08because this particular story about Mohammed marrying a child has been exhausted over and
- 29:15over and it's kind of that there's this level of stubbornness to say the argument.
- 29:19Funny that you raised that because literally today I was watching a video by
- 29:25a Muslim apologist known as Ali Daua, and he was talking about this.
- 29:30He lives in the UK and most of his work is in the UK,
- 29:33and he was arguing that what did the prophet do wrong? If in the
- 29:37UK, in Britain, Great Britain, one hundred years ago, if you
- 29:41read the law and he presented I cannot repeat what he said verbatim, but
- 29:45he was arguing that in the UK, child's marriage was allowed up to one
- 29:51hundred or one hundred and fifty years ago, and the minimum age was twelve
- 29:53years old or something like that. So he says, if you go back
- 29:57and see it in the context of time that it happened, the prophet didn't
- 30:02make anything wrong. This is a very, very famous and well known argument.
- 30:06So this is not the example that I would get people having an aha
- 30:11moment or being shocked. Most of my arguments are around areas related to other
- 30:17things like women's rights in Islam, things related to female genital mutilation, marital
- 30:22rape, inequality under the justice system. These are the things that the average
- 30:27Muslim probably never heard about or have minimal knowledge around. It is child marriage
- 30:33epidemic in islam dominant nations and even beyond in Islamic culture, child marriage something
- 30:41beyond the fringes. It is, but then you get the contradiction. It's
- 30:45a it's such a cognitive dissonance because if you look at a country like Egypt,
- 30:48for instance, child marriage is illegal by the law. However it's happening
- 30:53right left and center, and you will find marriage celebrants, and you will
- 30:57find people to do the work, and you can register the marriage, and
- 31:02you can forge the age of the child, and you can go about it
- 31:07completely legal despite the fact that it is illegal in the books of law.
- 31:11So is it epidemic? Yes, it is, But at the same time
- 31:15someone can argue that how it is an epidemic when the country is actually considering
- 31:18it unlawful. Imagine in Christianity saying Jesus not the Messiah. Is it true
- 31:26that the Koran says Jesus is not the Messiah. We're going to talk about
- 31:32that in just a second. Speaking here with ex Christian and human rights activist
- 31:47Adam L. Masri, you have a video that's titled the Quran's biggest mistake
- 31:52in saying Jesus is the Messiah. Again, I need you to educate me.
- 31:57I always thought that the Koran presented Jesus as just another prophet and not
- 32:04the Messiah. No, that the Koran keeps referring to Jesus as the Messiah,
- 32:08and that's exactly what you just said, is the problem in the Koran.
- 32:13How can the Quran refer to Jesus constantly as the Messiah son of Mary
- 32:19when it doesn't really understand or endorse and endorses the concept of what Christ really
- 32:27means. Okay, well, let me make sure I'm understanding. So the
- 32:30black and white verses of the Koran, you is Messiah, but Islam as
- 32:36a culture doesn't treat Jesus as the Messiah. So the concept of Messiah in
- 32:40both Judaism and in Christianity is around salvation, bringing salvation, whether in the
- 32:47Jewish context that salvation is earthly salvation or in the Christian theology where the salvation
- 32:53became more of a spiritual salvation and restoring the relationship between man and God.
- 33:00Christ or the Christ was that anointed figure that is supposed to come and have
- 33:06salvation for humanity, restore world peace and all that jazz. The funny thing
- 33:10is that the Quran then comes and endorses Jesus being the Messiah, but at
- 33:16the same time denies his crucifixion. There is no salvation that came with Christ
- 33:22and definitely no world peace that came with Christ. So under what basis exactly
- 33:27are trying to tell me? I'm asking the Qoran here on what basis you're
- 33:32claiming that Jesus is the Messiah if you're refusing every context that he can be
- 33:38the Messiah the Savior? Am I then to understand that islamis revere Mohammed more
- 33:45than Jesus Ah, that's a slippery slope. I mean, I know it's
- 33:50a subjective, it's your perception and you don't have to answer Adam, but
- 33:54I just I never hear Muslims talk about Jesus because it's always about Mohammed.
- 34:00The Quran speaks of Jesus very very highly as the most regarded figure. However,
- 34:07in the minds of everyday Muslim, they think that Muhammad is the finest
- 34:12human being that came to earth, and definitely they revere him way more than
- 34:15anyone or anything else. You will find a very famous chanting in times of
- 34:22crisis in the Middle East. You will find a lot of people chanting Faedeka
- 34:25abu umi asula law, which means even my mom and Dad, I consider
- 34:30a sacrificial to you or prophet. This is how they consider the prophet Jesus.
- 34:37That's sobering. The mom and dad are raising an eyebrow, going,
- 34:40oh, you know, sleep with one eye open because we might be sacrificed
- 34:45for the prophet. Let's pinball to your book. How did Christianity begin?
- 34:51Really think about the book as one of bart Hrman's books. It's all about
- 34:58how Christianity urged from Judaism, how they came to form their books, how
- 35:02they came to form their theology, and the earliest sects or different denominations.
- 35:08That there was no denominations officially at the time, but there were many,
- 35:13many different groups that believe different things and they all call themselves Christians. And
- 35:17in the Western world it's very common knowledge. But one of the reasons why
- 35:21I wanted to write that book is that one, bart Erman's books are not
- 35:24available in the Middle East. Two there's hardly any of that material available in
- 35:30Arabic for the Christian communities in the Middle East. I'm talking about the communities
- 35:35that they cannot read English, and their English illiteracy in our world is very
- 35:40common. So I wanted to produce something in Arabic on that topic. And
- 35:45it was in my own words and in my own knowledge as I learned things
- 35:51during my university years, and I did, as I mentioned earlier, my
- 35:54degree in Biblical Studies. I wanted to put that in an easy narrative to
- 36:00educate the average Arabic speaker. Is there an English version or just in Arabic
- 36:06right now from my book? No, I haven't. I haven't translated in
- 36:09English, And I thought one reason is that there are many, many famous
- 36:14and big authors who wrote on the topics. I didn't feel the need for
- 36:17my book to be in English as well. So now you're counseling, You're
- 36:22working with people who are deconstructing. What do they need? What are the
- 36:28trends you are hearing as people are doing what they do. Finally asking questions
- 36:31or asking for permission to ask questions. What are you seeing out there?
- 36:37Brother? All sorts of things, not only as a therapist, but since
- 36:42I joined RfR or Recovering from Religion, and since also Recovering from Religion,
- 36:47religion has become an Australian organization as well. So now we have recovered from
- 36:54religion Australia, and I started working with them a number of months ago,
- 37:00plus being on the Secular Therapy Project. Working with these two organizations, you
- 37:07find a lot of people with different needs, and the needs vary all the
- 37:10way from someone struggling with the mental capacity or the mental burden I should say,
- 37:17from questioning their faith and losing their faith and all that, all the
- 37:22way to people who already made peace with the doubts and they already abandoned their
- 37:27religion, but they are struggling with the social aspect of it, the family
- 37:30shunning, the coming out. So you have an entire spectrum of how different
- 37:35people experience trauma. And one of the wonderful things that are both globally and
- 37:42Australia provide is the support groups for these people. Whatever you're at, whatever
- 37:47you're experiencing, there are other people who experienced similar feelings and similar questioning and
- 37:54doubt and trauma. You will find a lot of the LGBTQ communities who because
- 38:00of their faith, they couldn't come out, or even when they come out,
- 38:06they struggle with their own sexual identity or sexual orientation. It's a huge
- 38:10spectrum seth to talk about in I know it's a question, I mean,
- 38:15you know, you and I are both deconstructed. In my own journey.
- 38:21I was struck by how freeing it was that I was no longer being told
- 38:25who to judge. Absolutely, You're spot on and one yes. I felt
- 38:31liberated and now accepting of everyone and their own experience. And one funny thing
- 38:37I say to my dad, who is still a practicing Christian church goer till
- 38:43today, whenever he talks to me about my experience, this is something I
- 38:46tell him all the time. It's so funny. What I tell him is
- 38:51it is so funny, Dad, I actually feel that once I abandoned Christianity,
- 38:54once I denounced Christianity, I became more Christian. And he looks at
- 39:00me puzzle like, what do you mean you became more Christian after you left
- 39:04Christianity? Excuse me? I'm like, yeah, Well, if you consider
- 39:08Christianity as live like Christ except all love people wherever they are, That's exactly
- 39:15how I'm living my life. If that is your definition of christian then I'm
- 39:20just living that. I just don't believe in all the fluff around it and
- 39:23the things that require me to believe. I just don't believe. I just
- 39:27love the people. Adam, you have a very soothing way about you.
- 39:30I can see if I was, if I would look, I may just
- 39:32call you anyway, despite the seventeen hour time difference. Maybe if I'm having
- 39:37a challenge, I'm just going to call you and let you soothingly walk me
- 39:42through whatever crisis I'm in, because you have a very gentle, calming demeanor
- 39:46about you, And I mean, you'd be the call I think i'd want
- 39:51if I was on that journey. If I ever get down there, I'm
- 39:53going to shake your hand and also give a big hug to my dear friend
- 39:58who works with RfR share this us. She's just a precious, precious person
- 40:02and really fast. Give me your website, tell people how to find you
- 40:07and your work. Yeah, my website is as my name is spelled on
- 40:12the screen, Adam Ilmasri dot online. And the way to find me online
- 40:16is basically if whether you go on Google or YouTube and you just type Adam
- 40:21and Master, you will find both my Arabic and English speaking channels. Whichever
- 40:25language you speak, You'll find a lot of material on there. I'm also
- 40:30on Instagram on Facebook, so yeah, just google Adam and Master and you'll
- 40:34find it all and I'll put the links in the description box. Now,
- 40:37if you and I were still, if we were in the Islamic faith,
- 40:40how would we end our exchange? Would we say a salamo or whatever it
- 40:45is? What would I say? Well, ask works both as a greeting
- 40:52to come in and to leave, So you don't say l anymore. So
- 40:55you say Salam alekum, starting with the s salamok See, it sounds much
- 41:00more musical coming out of your mouth, So I'm just going to leave it
- 41:04at that. Adam el Masri. It's an honor to be able to have
- 41:07this conversation. We've got our problems in the States. Obviously, the front
- 41:12burner, the wildfire is the looming death of democracy and decency under the shadow
- 41:19of Christian nationalists, etc. But Islam does remain a critical issue that we
- 41:23in the West need to be speaking about more. And so I'm honored to
- 41:29be given the opportunity to be able to use this conversation to stignal boost that.
- 41:34I'm going to send everybody to your site and your channels and your work
- 41:37and let's talk again soon. Okay, thank you so much, Thank you
- 41:40for having me, and I am honored to be with you. Follow the
- 41:44Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos,
- 41:50products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist
- 41:54pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. I'll
- 42:00go on to our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.