Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 310. A Matter of Meaning: What Other People Teach You About Your Communication
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: Sincerity, connection, and empathy define a meaningful life.
- 0:07My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:10Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:12Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:16Today, I'm excited to share a live conversation I had with our
- 0:19returning guest, our first four-time guest, GSB professor Brian Lowery.
- 0:25As part of this year's Stanford LEAD Me2We, Brian and I sat down to discuss
- 0:30what makes for a meaningful life and how we operationalize that through our
- 0:34feedback to and communication with others.
- 0:37Enjoy our conversation.
- 0:39Brian, thanks for being here.
- 0:41It's exciting to chat with you.
- 0:42Brian and I have had a number of conversations on the show and otherwise,
- 0:46and I remember a couple years ago when we had our conversation, people got really,
- 0:50really excited about some of your research about motivation, meaning, purpose.
- 0:57Can you remind us the difference from the way you look at meaning versus purpose?
- 1:02Brian Lowery: Yeah, so purpose is what you do in the morning, right?
- 1:04So purpose is like, "I have to do this, I have to do that," or, "I'm
- 1:07trying to achieve this." And meaning is something that, I think of it
- 1:11as like extends you in time, right?
- 1:14So it's not just what you do at any given moment.
- 1:17One way to think of it is like how you'd be remembered.
- 1:20Why is what you're doing matters?
- 1:21So that's how people talk about meaning.
- 1:23It's about not just what you do, but why does it matter?
- 1:26And also mattering is usually about other people.
- 1:30So purpose is often for you, what gets you up in the morning, but meaning
- 1:33almost always involves other people.
- 1:36So that's kind of the difference.
- 1:37Matt Abrahams: So individual versus connecting to others.
- 1:40Do you have advice and guidance on how we can better find our purpose?
- 1:44Brian Lowery: Find our purpose.
- 1:46I think purpose is whatever.
- 1:47You can just decide what your purpose is.
- 1:48There's no magic in purpose.
- 1:51I think that people when they say purpose, sometimes what they mean is meaning.
- 1:54Purpose is easy.
- 1:54I think the idea of like find your passion, I don't
- 1:57personally subscribe to that.
- 1:58I'm like, make what you do your passion, as opposed to go out and
- 2:01try to figure out what it is, 'cause now you're searching and who knows.
- 2:04I think you decide what it is you want to do and then commit
- 2:08yourself to doing that thing.
- 2:10That, that thing, that is how you find your purpose.
- 2:12Matt Abrahams: So it's almost observing what's going on in your life and
- 2:15what's there and then that becomes it.
- 2:16So how do you find meaning?
- 2:18Brian Lowery: I think meaning is about who do you want to serve other than yourself.
- 2:24And that can be a number of people in different ways.
- 2:26That could be your kids, that could be your students, that could be future
- 2:32generations of users of your product.
- 2:35It could be all sorts of people, but it has to be serving someone other than
- 2:39yourself, connecting to someone other than yourself, providing something outside
- 2:45of yourself that will extend beyond you.
- 2:47So often the way people talk about mattering and meaning is that it has
- 2:51to reverberate beyond your presence.
- 2:54So it can't just be, "I'm here with you, I did this thing." It has to
- 2:57be, "I'm here with you doing this thing, and when I leave, what I
- 3:00did will continue to influence you.
- 3:02How I've touched you will continue to influence you, and then you
- 3:04will influence other people.
- 3:06And so now I've indirectly influenced those people." That
- 3:09is where meaning comes from.
- 3:11Matt Abrahams: So it's almost like a ripple effect.
- 3:13Brian Lowery: It's a ripple effect.
- 3:14And I think meaning is about being mindful of the effect you have on other
- 3:19people, and being purposeful about the effect you have on other people.
- 3:24Matt Abrahams: Okay, so the purpose in many ways drives the meaning.
- 3:26Brian Lowery: Yeah.
- 3:27In the sense of, like, anything you do can affect other people.
- 3:30You just choose to do something, right?
- 3:31You just choose, "I'm gonna try to make this best place to work. I'm
- 3:35gonna choose to make this meeting or this vacation," or whatever.
- 3:39But if you're doing it in service of other people and understand that
- 3:42it's affecting those people, it will change the way you do it, and it
- 3:46will make it more meaningful for you.
- 3:48When you're thinking about how what you're doing touches and influences
- 3:53other people, that will give you an experience of meaningfulness in your life.
- 3:58Being mindful other people are being influenced by your behaviors
- 4:03changes how you understand yourself.
- 4:06Matt Abrahams: You're adding at least one layer, if not more, on this notion
- 4:09of empathy that we were talking about.
- 4:11It's this idea of my impact on you and what it means.
- 4:14When I read your book, and we talked about it before on the show, one
- 4:18thing that I'm still trying to wrap my mind around is this notion of how
- 4:22we define ourselves through others.
- 4:24Can you walk us through that?
- 4:25And if nothing else, this is a tutorial for me 'cause I'm still trying to grasp
- 4:29this, but can you help me understand?
- 4:30Brian Lowery: So the way I would say it is, without others, you
- 4:33would have no idea who you were.
- 4:34So in this conversation already, you've said, like, you're, or I asked you about
- 4:38it, but you're, you're, you have a wife.
- 4:40Matt Abrahams: And I have two kids.
- 4:40Brian Lowery: You have kids.
- 4:41Matt Abrahams: Yes, I do.
- 4:41Brian Lowery: You have two kids.
- 4:42All those things come together and tell you something about who you are.
- 4:46Like, you're a dad, you're a husband, you're a podcaster, you're an interviewer.
- 4:50And you can add things to that, and those collectively are who you are.
- 4:54All of the parts, those plus any others you can come up with that
- 4:59you think of as who you are, depend on relationships with other people.
- 5:03Those ideas of who you are and your own internal ideas of who you are
- 5:07would not exist absent those people.
- 5:09Like, you can't be a husband without a wife.
- 5:11You cannot be a parent without kids.
- 5:13You cannot be a podcaster without an audience.
- 5:16So without other people, the things that you use to define yourself don't exist.
- 5:20Matt Abrahams: So in connection to others, we help define ourselves.
- 5:23Many folks sitting in this room are leaders, managers, and they
- 5:27have others that work for them.
- 5:28How do we help create the selves of those people who work with us or work for us?
- 5:34I mean, there are things we can do to help them define themselves and
- 5:37their roles in our organizations.
- 5:39Talk to me about that.
- 5:40Brian Lowery: I think that we define people, interact with them all the time in
- 5:43ways that we don't take seriously because in some cultures, at least in the States
- 5:47and other places, not just the States, but certainly in the States, there's a
- 5:51sense of like, 'I exist as an island.
- 5:54I'm the most important thing, and then all I care about is did I affect you
- 5:57and did you affect me?' But there's a barrier that cannot be crossed.
- 6:00I just think that's fundamentally wrong.
- 6:03That is just not how things actually work socially.
- 6:06And so when we're interacting, we are co-constructing each other.
- 6:11Part of that is really philosophical and abstract.
- 6:13Like, if you're a leader, you're telling people what they have
- 6:15to do when they go to work.
- 6:16You're telling people what time they have to show up, that you're
- 6:18making them feel happy to be there or hate being there, right?
- 6:21Those things are part of how they think about themselves.
- 6:23When they go home, they're talking about you and the workplace in particular
- 6:28ways and themselves as a part of that.
- 6:31Like, I hate my job.
- 6:33I'm the kind of person that hates my job.
- 6:35I love my job.
- 6:36I'm the kind of person who loves my job.
- 6:38You know, these people at work, they're annoying to me, or I miss
- 6:40them, or whatever it is, but all those things are changing how you see
- 6:44yourself, and they're changing how you show up and behave at work, too.
- 6:48If you're a manager, you are constructing the environment
- 6:52in which people are working.
- 6:54The environment in which people work, the environment which
- 6:56people live, in all sorts of ways directly affects how they behave.
- 7:00And so when you see someone behaving in a way that you like or don't like, you
- 7:04should first ask yourself, if you're a leader in that environment, what
- 7:07am I doing that produces that, right?
- 7:09And this gets away from this idea of like they are who they are and
- 7:13they're just doing what they do, and you start to think of like how am I
- 7:16participating in producing this behavior?
- 7:20Now, people will be like, "But that's not true.
- 7:21They're just a terrible human being, and they're just
- 7:23lazy." I'm like, "That's fine.
- 7:24I don't know.
- 7:25Yeah, there are some lazy people." But the thing is, one, I'm right. Two, even if I'm
- 7:31wrong, which I'm not, but even if I were wrong, it is more rational to ask yourself
- 7:37as a leader, what can I do to change the situation than to say, "I have no agency.
- 7:43I can't do anything 'cause they are who they are." Given those two, I
- 7:47think you would choose to say like, "Where am I in this?" And that
- 7:50agency requires responsibility.
- 7:52And what the responsibility I'm talking about here is understanding
- 7:57that how you behave as a leader is shaping how the people that
- 8:01work for you show up and behave.
- 8:03Matt Abrahams: And I think that puts a lot of responsibility on
- 8:06leaders to really reflect on that.
- 8:07A lot of leaders just optimize for output, right?
- 8:10And they don't really think about what they're doing that can lead to that.
- 8:13Brian Lowery: People don't understand that who they are is
- 8:16shaping who their employees are.
- 8:18So it's not just what you tell them to do.
- 8:20It's who you are, how are you showing up?
- 8:22And so people often just focus on what's outside of them, like how are
- 8:25they behaving, how do I alter their behavior, without looking at the self.
- 8:29If you change how you show up, you will change how people around you show up.
- 8:32And so in the context of work, people might not see it that way.
- 8:35But if you think about families, people understand this implicitly.
- 8:38If you're, like, in a terrible mood all the time or you're unhappy with life or
- 8:41something like that, for sure that is gonna affect your wife and your kids.
- 8:45Like, no one has to explain that to you.
- 8:47But somehow you go to work, it's as if, like, people all
- 8:49have their responsibilities.
- 8:50Who I am doesn't matter.
- 8:52I'm just telling them what to do, you do what you're told.
- 8:53And, like, my person, how I show up, has no influence.
- 8:57That just cannot be true.
- 8:58Matt Abrahams: That analogy really does help cement the idea.
- 9:00We think of that with our family and friends very easily,
- 9:03but we don't see it at work.
- 9:04Is there advice or best practices you have for people in leadership roles to help
- 9:09maximize the success and the wellbeing of the people that work with them?
- 9:14What can we do to help them see themselves that way?
- 9:18Brian Lowery: Doing work on self-awareness actually has notable
- 9:21effects on how your employees respond to you and their experience of work.
- 9:26So there's evidence, there's research on this, right?
- 9:28So the closer that the way your employees see you is the way you see yourself,
- 9:32the safer and the more efficient your employees are, as an example.
- 9:38So one is being willing to examine the self and being willing to respond
- 9:45to the environment in such a way that allows for people to know you
- 9:49in a way that allows them to feel a degree of psychological safety.
- 9:53And psychological safety here is, at best, predictability, like understand
- 9:56you, and you think I understand you.
- 9:59That changes the way we work together.
- 10:01And that's not about you're nice.
- 10:04It's not about doing what I want you to do.
- 10:06It's just like I'm working for you, I understand you.
- 10:08You agree with that understanding, now we can work in a different way
- 10:12than if I can't, I don't really know what's going on with you.
- 10:13I can't figure out what's going on with you.
- 10:15I hear what you're telling me to do, but I don't understand you.
- 10:17That creates a distance and some degree of unsafety, which undermines
- 10:21the work relationship and undermines the quality of the work of people.
- 10:24So self-awareness, also being willing to examine and accept the perspective of the
- 10:31other people, even if it doesn't match yours, is legitimate and reasonable.
- 10:36So I might not agree with how you see things, but I should take your experience
- 10:42seriously, whether I agree with it or not.
- 10:44And again, the agreement is not the issue, but, like, truly trying to understand,
- 10:48engaging with how you see the world.
- 10:50Also, that there's clear evidence that that has positive effects because often
- 10:55people care about being respected.
- 10:56So sometimes people worry about or think that people only care about what they get.
- 11:00So of course, people care about that, but they also care about did you hear me?
- 11:04Do you care that I want this thing?
- 11:06Even if you don't give it to me, do you even respect me?
- 11:09And if you demonstrate that to people, like you're asking questions, you
- 11:13really care about the answer they give, even if you don't agree, you're
- 11:15trying to understand, and they see that as a sincere, the way they'll
- 11:19respond to that and the kind of leeway they will give you is surprising.
- 11:23And so that's another thing I would tell people, like, one, understand yourself.
- 11:27Be sensitive to how other people see you so that you can create a
- 11:30match between how you see yourself and how other people see you.
- 11:33There's positive gain there.
- 11:35Two, and as a part of that, taking seriously the perspective of other people.
- 11:39You don't have to agree with them, but taking it seriously changes
- 11:43their experience of the situation.
- 11:45Those things together have huge positive benefits.
- 11:48Matt Abrahams: So self-awareness as well as acknowledging seriously
- 11:53the other person's perspective.
- 11:55It strikes me that that requires a level of confidence and vulnerability,
- 11:58though, to do that, to show up as your true self and to look internal.
- 12:02Brian Lowery: Just to be clear, I have no idea what a true self
- 12:04is, but here's what I know.
- 12:05You show up in a particular way.
- 12:07Whether or not that's your true self or not, I don't know I would worry
- 12:11more about sincerity than truth.
- 12:13The goal is not to, like, be who you are all the time with everyone.
- 12:17like, That's just not how human beings operate.
- 12:19And so instead of worrying about the true self, I think you
- 12:22should worry about sincerity.
- 12:23Am I being as honest as I can right now?
- 12:27Matt Abrahams: With myself and with others.
- 12:28Brian Lowery: Yes.
- 12:29And that is a different thing than saying, "Am I being my true self?" Sometimes
- 12:32being your true self might be an asshole.
- 12:34Like, you're in a bad mood, you're being an asshole.
- 12:35That's fine.
- 12:36Don't be that true self.
- 12:37It's okay.
- 12:38But when you engage with people, be sincere, and that's different
- 12:42than, like, 'cause people have this idea of, like, "If it's in my head,
- 12:45I gotta say it." No, you don't.
- 12:46No.
- 12:47Please don't.
- 12:47Be, don't be your true self with me.
- 12:49But be sincere, and I think that that's what people are expecting, sincerity.
- 12:53Matt Abrahams: It does require you to really think about and know
- 12:56what's important to you and to have your own values understood.
- 12:59I wanna talk about the crucible of feedback because it strikes me
- 13:02that, you know, many leaders have to give feedback, but this could be a
- 13:05friction point or some tension with some of the issues you're talking.
- 13:08'Cause when I give you feedback, I'm confronting your perceptions of yourself.
- 13:12How does feedback work well in this paradigm?
- 13:14Brian Lowery: I think it should be, again, sincere.
- 13:16And if you understand the other person's perspective of themselves, I think the
- 13:19fear is that it's hard to give hard feedback, it's hard to get hard feedback,
- 13:23or fear that that's what you're gonna get.
- 13:25I think once you create a relationship where there's sincerity, you can
- 13:29give feedback in such a way where you're asking people to understand
- 13:34how you experience what is happening.
- 13:36And this is, I think, the issue with feedback, is it feels like I'm making a
- 13:40statement of truth that you don't like.
- 13:42But that's not really what's happening.
- 13:44What I'm telling you is, "Here's how I perceive what is happening.
- 13:48Here's how I'm experiencing what you're doing," and maybe even,
- 13:51"Here's what I'm thinking about that."
- 13:53That's a very different claim than like, "You are not good at your job." Right?
- 13:58"You are bad at this thing." I might be like, "Look, what you did here
- 14:03didn't have the effect that we hoped it would." I think that would be
- 14:06enough for most people to understand and like, "Okay, can I get better
- 14:09or not?" And they can ask questions.
- 14:11You know what's funny about this?
- 14:12I'm like working on fiction writings, and I have a developmental editor.
- 14:15And so a development editor, the way it works is like you write,
- 14:17you send them pages, and they give you feedback on the pages.
- 14:19They give you direct feedbacks.
- 14:20They go through your writing, they make comments, and they give you a
- 14:23letter that's like, "Here's what I see, here's what I think, here's what you
- 14:26need to work on," blah, blah, blah.
- 14:27It feels deeply personal, and it's very vulnerable to write something,
- 14:32because it comes from you and it's who you are, and then have
- 14:35someone give you feedback on that.
- 14:38And recently in our meeting, I was like, "Uh, you know, I really love the way you
- 14:40give feedback." And like, I felt like I learned something from her, and this
- 14:44is kind of where this is coming from, 'cause one, the feedback always feels
- 14:47honest, and I don't always like it.
- 14:49I don't even always agree with it.
- 14:50And sometimes it's like the version of like, this isn't good, and
- 14:53I understand what she's saying, but I never feel defensive.
- 14:56I look forward to having these meetings with her.
- 14:59I look forward to getting her letters and feedback.
- 15:01I know it's not gonna all be positive.
- 15:02In fact, I expect it not to all be positive.
- 15:05And I'm not sensitive about it at all.
- 15:07And I talked to her about it, actually.
- 15:08I said like, "You know, I was gonna tell you that like, first of
- 15:10all, I teach a lot of classes and like, you're really good at this.
- 15:13I really appreciate the way you give feedback." And what she said was,
- 15:17"When I give feedback, I always think about the intent of the author." So
- 15:22I'm like, "What were you trying to do?
- 15:24What was your goal here?
- 15:25You might have completely failed, and I do all the time.
- 15:27And I need you to understand how you failed because my job is to help you grow,
- 15:32so I, I have to give you this feedback." And that engagement with her, I think
- 15:36why that feedback works, and what I love about it, is I feel seen in the feedback.
- 15:41And when she says something, I'm like, "That's correct," right?
- 15:44But I feel seen.
- 15:45'Cause by the way, I worked with someone else who I hated, couldn't stand her.
- 15:47I was like, "This person is terrible." And she was also probably right, but
- 15:51the feeling was like, this person is telling me what I should be.
- 15:56She's telling me what she sees and how I'm falling short of her ideal.
- 16:00It was like even if it was right, it was just bad.
- 16:02And this other woman is like, "I see what you are trying to be.
- 16:06I see what you are trying to do.
- 16:08And I'm gonna tell you where you're falling short." It was
- 16:11just a world of difference.
- 16:13And I thought about that and I'm like, look, if you assume that people are
- 16:16trying to be successful, right, and you're looking at their intent and like
- 16:19even when they fall short, it's not that people don't know they're falling short.
- 16:22If they don't, then it is your job to tell them.
- 16:24And so saying like, "I see what you're trying to do. I see you're making effort.
- 16:28Here's where it might not be working." And doing it in a way that takes seriously
- 16:33that person's desire to be successful, I think changes things dramatically.
- 16:38Matt Abrahams: So much richness in that answer.
- 16:40The part that I'm really reflecting on in my own life, seeing the person
- 16:44for who they want to be versus who you think they should be is a fundamental
- 16:49difference in how you approach feedback.
- 16:51And what you said earlier, which I think is also really important, is what am
- 16:55I doing that's contributing to this?
- 16:58So it's not just about here's what's wrong or here's what could
- 17:01be improved, it's what am I doing?
- 17:02And then really help the person to see it through that understanding
- 17:08and being present for them.
- 17:09I have to really think about how I've been giving feedback.
- 17:11I appreciate that.
- 17:13Last question I'll ask, the class you teach is very popular.
- 17:15A lot of people are really excited to take it.
- 17:17What's one thing you hope your students take away from the class?
- 17:20Brian Lowery: The thing that I always want people to take away is, and if
- 17:23you hear me talk outside of class, I think it's probably more apparent,
- 17:26but I think for me, my class is about being a better human being.
- 17:32And I don't mean good.
- 17:33I don't mean like, I hope you all are good people.
- 17:35You should strive to be good people, but I'm not talking
- 17:37about morally a good person.
- 17:40What I'm talking about is being better at being human.
- 17:44And I think the fundamental thing about being human is our
- 17:48connections with other human beings.
- 17:50And I mean this literally, you are not human without other human beings.
- 17:53You cannot be fully human absent other human beings.
- 17:57And so what is defining about being human is our connections with the quality of
- 18:03interactions with other human beings.
- 18:05When you show up at work and there are people there, those are not
- 18:07different human beings than the human beings that are at home or at any
- 18:11place else that you see human beings.
- 18:13And so being a better human being, being more effective at engaging with human
- 18:18beings in relationships will definitely make you a more effective leader.
- 18:23Matt Abrahams: It boils down to connection and other-focus.
- 18:26Well, thank you, Brian.
- 18:28An incredibly rich conversation.
- 18:30It's about introspection, it's about invitation and empathy and connection.
- 18:35And it is through that that we build ourselves and the stories
- 18:39that we work with others.
- 18:40So it's about communication internally and externally.
- 18:44Thank you.
- 18:46Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 18:48Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 18:50To learn more from Brian, please listen to episodes 23, 84, and 142.
- 18:56This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Alex McCarthy,
- 18:59Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 19:02Our music is from Floyd Wonder with special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 19:06Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 19:10Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 19:12Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 19:16And check out fastersmarter.io for deep-dive videos, English language
- 19:20learning content, and our newsletter.
- 19:22Please consider joining Think Fast, Talk Smart's learning community
- 19:26at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 19:29You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards, an AI
- 19:33coach, and book club opportunities.
- 19:35Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of our Think Fast,
- 19:41Talk Smart learning community.