Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #220 - Jesse Miller / Harrison Mooney
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Mama Meir and this is Van
- 0:20Coller, British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show Tonight, Let's Talk
- 0:25Public Education. Award winning author Harrison Mooney will be here to discuss why a
- 0:31police presence in his daughter's school makes him feel horrified. But first, after
- 0:37Quebec recently implemented a cell phone ban in its public school classrooms, the leader
- 0:42of BC's official opposition, BC United, Kevin Falcon, wants the same kind
- 0:47of ban in BC classrooms. Falcon points to plummeting test scores, particularly in
- 0:53reading and math, as evidence that our smartphones are making our kids dumber.
- 0:58Our first guest tonight dis agrees, saying that such bands can be ineffective.
- 1:03Beaming into the show, he's a recognized authority on media literacy, social media
- 1:07education, and digital trends. The founder of mediated Reality, he is Jesse
- 1:14Miller. Jesse, Hello, hey, mo how's it going. Oh it's
- 1:19going great, man. But here's the thing. I have this toxic habit
- 1:23where I'll be watching TV at the end of the day, you know,
- 1:26unwinding, trying to shut off my brain, and I'll find myself scrolling on
- 1:30my phone. You know the toxic double screening, and basically I'm being distracted
- 1:38from my distraction. And we know that smartphones are a distraction, even for
- 1:42me, a grown ass man. It's why so many people get ticketed for
- 1:45distracted driving in BC. So doesn't banning cell phones in schools actually make kids
- 1:52more productive? Like? Why are you against this proposed ban? Well,
- 1:57I like seeing what other parts of the world do when this conversation becomes a
- 2:00focal point. And we've seen school districts across the world focus on banning cell
- 2:06phones as far back as two thousand and eight, two thousand and six,
- 2:08and so in that fifteen eighteen year period, we should have learned a lot
- 2:14about how bands can be put into place and where the concerns go. And
- 2:19so my concern is, are we tasking teachers with policing devices? Are we
- 2:23telling kids that rely on technology for the purpose of safety that they don't need
- 2:27it on their walk or positioning in class? And when it comes to tech
- 2:30inclusion, how are we raising digital citizens if we don't give them the tools
- 2:35to be effective using the tools that we pay for and buy them so that
- 2:38we as parents can feel like we can connect our connect to our kids whenever
- 2:42we want. So, were there any cell phone bands in schools that effectively
- 2:46failed or backfired? So we've seen statewide or city wide bands and so on.
- 2:53Ontario, the Ford government introduced a cell phone band when they were brought
- 2:57into power, and then they basically said, we created a band, but
- 3:00now we're going to let every school district decide how that ban is either enforced
- 3:04or utilized. And again it then passes the buck. They gain the votes,
- 3:07they get what they want when it comes to the ballot, and then
- 3:10they say to the districts, it's your job to do this. New York
- 3:14City de Blasio introduced a citywide cell phone ban in twenty twelve. In twenty
- 3:20fifteen, it was rescinded because they realized that the kids themselves did not have
- 3:23any ability to regulate using the technology because they also didn't have safe spaces to
- 3:29store the technology. So there are all sorts of issues that come up in
- 3:31these spaces where we see bands don't work and we fail to actually engage with
- 3:36teachers who are responsible for the technology in the classroom. So this might be
- 3:40an issue around implementation. But Piza, the Program for International Student Assessment.
- 3:46They found that students who spend less than one hour of leisure time per day
- 3:52on their digital devices scored about fifty points higher in math than students who were
- 3:57spending more than five hours a day on their digital devices. I also saw
- 4:00that a study out of Carlton University found that test scores increased by six point
- 4:05four percent for high school students after cell phones were banned, and that the
- 4:10effect was actually double for low achieving students. So, you know, we
- 4:14can debate the implementation, but isn't it true that smartphones are effectively making kids
- 4:18dumber because they're distracted. I think what comes down to is you have to
- 4:25look at how the smartphones are used as a tool in our every day So
- 4:28if our workplaces we would see better employee engagement, or we would see better
- 4:33use of our technologies in the workplace as opposed to the personal devices we bring
- 4:36in, then we could extend it into that space. We have to look
- 4:40at some of these studies and ask the question of what were the target groups
- 4:44who was assessed, what were the literacy rates and numeracy rates with those students
- 4:48prior, and then could we assess whether things have changed using technology to help
- 4:54each individual student as opposed to all students across the board. So when we
- 4:58hear Kevin Falcons say that kids are less literate, I see kids texting all
- 5:02the time, they're navigating the internet, They're exposed to words. How do
- 5:06those children using those platforms then take that information and then convert it to let's
- 5:12say reading a novel. Do they have that ability? And so when we
- 5:15come to the idea of using these tools, I want students leaving high school
- 5:19knowing how to create an email, how to navigate the internet, how to
- 5:23build a website. But if they don't have the tools at their disposal that
- 5:27they can bring from home, where do we then provide technologies that help them
- 5:30use those tools in the classroom and then pivot that information to the working or
- 5:35learning environments in post secondary So out of say like a computer class like setting
- 5:42that aside is there? I mean, give me an example of a function
- 5:46where a kid can have a phone in their classroom and it actually being an
- 5:50effective learning tool again outside of building a website or something related to media literacy.
- 5:57So we have classrooms that will use platforms for student engagement. So you'll
- 6:01have a teacher who will set up a series of questions using an app,
- 6:04and then each student dis ask to use their personal device to go to the
- 6:09website and then participate real time. We have learning tools that are similar to
- 6:13Jeopardy will all all answer questions and then be graded as such. The thing
- 6:16is is that that's an engagement piece. It's not necessarily a testing piece.
- 6:19So if students are able to use their personal device to participate in classroom learning,
- 6:25then the teacher can develop curriculum that works in that space to allow them
- 6:28to learn how to not only bring the tool in the classroom, but then
- 6:31also how to regulate using it. What we also see is students who are
- 6:34using things like gaming, and so gaming is a big part of where we
- 6:38see. Some people say gaming is a waste of time, but I've seen
- 6:41educators who look at what kids do with video games and say, well,
- 6:44how can we get them to conceptualize the game they play and then apply it
- 6:47to curriculum, whether it be mathematics, computer science, or art or design.
- 6:51And so there are a number of places where education technologies that does have
- 6:55success. It just requires an educator to help develop the curriculum, implement the
- 7:00curriculum and they get parent buy in to understand what the kids are doing with
- 7:02technology that they do bring from home. Now, is it fair to say
- 7:06that there are some classes, and I'm thinking of like Pe, where phones
- 7:12really don't have a use and perhaps you know, based on the individual teacher
- 7:15or the actual class, that they should be banned in those classes. Yeah,
- 7:20and we see Pe teachers kind of dictate that. And when it comes
- 7:24to the participation factor, you can't play dodgeball with a phone in your hand,
- 7:28and if you do, you're going to subject yourself to injury. One
- 7:30of the things we have to keep in mind here is that we see this
- 7:32interesting contrast where kids actively put down their technology for the sports or extracurriculars that
- 7:38they're engaged in. You don't hear a lot of hockey coaches or volleyball coaches
- 7:42screaming at their players mid game to put the device down because they are engaged.
- 7:46But they also have the structure of rules and expectations. The same can
- 7:49apply to a classroom. You don't need a full ban, but you do
- 7:53need a teacher to feel empowered in their classroom to say, here are my
- 7:56rules, here's my expectations. And if they're not met, the school has
- 7:59a policy that will allow me to enforce how this piece of technology will be
- 8:03regulated. But here's the enther part too, is that we hear kids all
- 8:05the time say things like, well, my coach yells at me or my
- 8:09coach threatens me when it comes to the next thing that they want me to
- 8:11doing, and it seems like they have this overarching power against them. But
- 8:16the thing is when it comes to a teacher saying, hey, if I
- 8:18see that phone one more time of taking it away, then we see the
- 8:20advocate parent march it and say how dare you tell my child what to do
- 8:24with their device. But the coach gets a really significant pass in that space
- 8:28because for some reason, the priority of sport is deemed to be more important
- 8:33than the priority of maybe mathematics or reading. Fascinating, Jesse, thank you
- 8:37so much for your time tonight. I feel like this is a conversation that
- 8:41does deserve some nuance as opposed to just a simple ban or not to ban.
- 8:45So again, thank you so much for your insights. Thanks mo,
- 8:48no bans more teacher empowerment for sure, folks. That was Jesse Miller of
- 8:54Mediated Reality, The go to expert NBC on media literacy, social media education
- 9:00and digital trends. Now after some business, do cops in schools feel safer
- 9:05for your kids? One award winning author doesn't think so. So let's talk
- 9:09about it up next. Welcome back to this as Van Color. Our featured
- 9:20guest, Tonight is a writer and journalist from Abbotsford, BC. His powerful
- 9:24debut memoir, Invisible Boy, was recently awarded the Rakuten Cobo Emerging Writer Prize.
- 9:31Make sure you pick it up at your local bookstore. Returning to the
- 9:35show, he is Harrison Mooney and this conversation is supported by shelter Point single
- 9:39malt whiskey distinctly Vancouver Island, uniquely shelter Point. So, Harrison, your
- 9:48daughter is starting kindergarten and you recently found out that there would be a student
- 9:52liaison officer, a VPD officer at the school, and you are upset by
- 9:58this. Can you explain why you are horrified by this revelation? Yeah,
- 10:05you know, So the police were taken out of Vancouver's schools a few years
- 10:09ago. It was in the aftermath of the George Floyd protests, and this
- 10:13kind of brief moment where we were listening to black and indigenous people of color,
- 10:18and you know, and we were saying, you know, the police
- 10:22don't make us feel safe. They harass us more often than they harass white
- 10:26folks. You know, we don't want them in schools. And people listened,
- 10:31and then there was an election, everything was overturned. And now it's
- 10:35a few years later and suddenly the police are back. And you know,
- 10:37the thing that I want to point out to people is, you know,
- 10:41I wasn't consulted. I don't feel comfortable with this. I don't want to
- 10:46have to deal with this at my daughter's school. I mean, she's in
- 10:48kindergarten, for goodness, So let's get into that. Why does it make
- 10:50you feel uncomfortable to have a police presence in the school? Yeah? I
- 10:54mean so the first reason is because I mean I don't trust the police around
- 10:58my hits. That's I think, just across the board, I do not.
- 11:03And you know, there's a lot of reasons not to trust the police,
- 11:05I think based on things that the police have said that have been untrue,
- 11:09based on such as such as, for instance, in the letter saying
- 11:13that they would be coming back to the school. You know, we were
- 11:16told that the police now have undergone specialized training, right, But they haven't.
- 11:22That's just something that they are saying, you know, and that's something
- 11:26that's been proven false already by my colleague Katie Hisslop, who did a freedom
- 11:30of information request and you know, was able to see the specialized training the
- 11:35police have received. Uh and it's nothing. There's no training. So that's
- 11:39just something they're saying. And it's something that was then repeated in the letter
- 11:41to me, like, don't worry the police have received specialized training. But
- 11:46you know I read so I know that that's not that's not actually true,
- 11:52you know. And then I was told, well, you know, they'll
- 11:54they'll be bringing in their weapons, but they'll be concealed weapons. You know,
- 11:56it'll be they'll be careful. But I mean, I don't want anybody
- 12:00bringing weapons into my kids' school. And I think that includes and maybe is
- 12:03especially the police. You know, police shootings are on the rise. BC
- 12:09has the highest rate of police shootings in the in the country. You know,
- 12:13Vancouver has I think the highest rate of police shootings as well, you
- 12:16know, among municipalities like I don't want the police who are not careful with
- 12:20their guns, who I don't think should carry guns now bringing guns into my
- 12:24kids school, because there were no guns in my kids' school until suddenly the
- 12:28police were invited back in, and now I have to worry about that.
- 12:31I don't know this one gun. Yeah, I don't trust them, so
- 12:35and I don't think that you should trust I think that, you know,
- 12:37when we talk about the police as this this kind of like this trustworthy,
- 12:41good force. Well then how come they keep saying things that are not true?
- 12:46How come their return to schools is being trumpeted with this idea that they
- 12:50underwent some training, that they learned something from the reasons that they were asked
- 12:54not to come into schools. You know, they they continue to peddle falsehood
- 13:00and then and now they've returned to schools in my own kids' school. So
- 13:03did your concerns get any pushback from perhaps white parents or just other parents?
- 13:09You know, I haven't heard much from anybody, which is which is nice.
- 13:13You know, I was invited to do a few other interviews and I
- 13:16and I turned them down because I know how these conversations tend to go.
- 13:20Well, I appreciate you trusting this is me and color that means to see
- 13:24what happens. I guess what I mean is I mean, is this something
- 13:26that you know, if you're black, Indigenous, perhaps a person of color,
- 13:30you kind of understand a little more than you know someone who is white
- 13:33and they have a different experience with the police. Yeah, I think so.
- 13:37And you know, that's kind of been the whole point here. You
- 13:39know, when when the George George Floyd protests were happening, there was this
- 13:43kind of this this big announcement like we're gonna finally listen to black and Indigenous
- 13:46people of color, like we're going to center BIPOD voices, and what we
- 13:50said, you know, the majority of black and Indigenous people of color that
- 13:54were asked was we don't feel comfortable with the police and our schools. And
- 13:58as result of that, that program was scrapped. But then, you know,
- 14:03we we have this election, the police got some folks elected to the
- 14:07school board, and suddenly that decision was overturned. So, you know,
- 14:11my major concern here is that black voices were listened to for a hot second
- 14:16and then we just decided actually no, right now, now, I read
- 14:22that there's been an uptick in calls to the VPD to Vancouver schools. So
- 14:26doesn't having a liaison officer at these schools, Let's say they are trained and
- 14:31specially trained for this, it doesn't have any of Okay, but well let's
- 14:35assume that, assume they are. It doesn't having a police officer at those
- 14:39schools kind of make four faster responses. I mean, I guess so.
- 14:43But when we talk about, you know, the increase in calls, First
- 14:46of all, that increase follows the police being asked not to come to the
- 14:48school. So now you have to call them a little more often if you
- 14:52need them, because they're not already there, right. But then at the
- 14:54same time, that increase of calls is still lower than it was for the
- 15:00George Floyd protests because people don't want to call the police anymore. So,
- 15:03you know, yes, there have been more calls to police since school liaison
- 15:09officers were uninvited, but again those numbers remain below where they were before the
- 15:15George Floyd protests, where we found out what the police actually do or what
- 15:18the police tend to do in schools and the impact that they have on the
- 15:22student populace there and specifically black and indigenous student. Is there any scenario where
- 15:28you would be comfortable of having a police officer there. Let's say they are
- 15:31not armed. Let's say that they do have specialized training. Is there any
- 15:35scenario in your mind where you're like, Okay, yeah, I can accept
- 15:39a police officer having presence at my kids' school. No, no, no,
- 15:45there just isn't. No, absolutely not. You know, if there's
- 15:46like a big crime happening and we have to call the police, fine,
- 15:50but I don't want the police setting up shop in my kids' school. I
- 15:52don't want them walking around looking for something to do. I don't want them
- 15:56in the school. They're not invited to the school less we have an emergency
- 16:00where we need to call them. And again, when that happens, now
- 16:03people are calling the police less because they trust the police response less. Why
- 16:08do you think the VPD or other police jurisdictions, why do you think they
- 16:11want to be in schools. Why do you think the school board wants them
- 16:15there? Why do you think maybe some parents want a police presence there?
- 16:18Like, what's motivating the other side? I suppose right well, the school
- 16:22board wants them there because again, the VPD has stacked the board with people
- 16:26who support the VPD. So and you know, it's like a five four
- 16:29vote, So it's not like overwhelming everybody wants the police in schools, but
- 16:33you know, the school board voted to have them come back in. And
- 16:36the reason I think the police want to be in schools is because it gives
- 16:38them the ability to then target kids who they think are going to be I
- 16:42don't know, future criminals, you know, start to put kids on lists,
- 16:47start to keep an eye on certain kids in certain communities, and know
- 16:49things that they wouldn't otherwise know. But I don't think that they should know
- 16:55that stuff. I think that they should leave my kids alone when they're at
- 16:57school. You know, if my kids start to make a fore into criminality,
- 17:02criminality later, like maybe they'll you know, get known then. But
- 17:07what are other parents that might actually like this program? Do you think that
- 17:10they are working with false premises? I do? You know? First of
- 17:14all, the there has been no evidence that school liaison officers have any kind
- 17:18of beneficial impact, you know, And there have been studies, and those
- 17:22studies have shown that no, this program does nothing. It doesn't actually help
- 17:26anybody. And you know, I've asked and I've looked, and other people
- 17:30have asked for evidence that this program has some kind of positive impact, it
- 17:37doesn't, you know. I understand that the police want that presence, and
- 17:41I think another reason is because it gets everybody accustomed to having a police presence
- 17:45in their lives, right. Ye know. It's about this surveillance state and
- 17:49this idea that well, the police are welcome. They can just stand over
- 17:52there and they can watch us, and they can keep an eye on us,
- 17:55and then they can decide when to intervene. But I don't want that,
- 17:57and I don't think that, you know, people who think that they
- 18:00do. I don't think that those people actually want that either. We don't
- 18:03want the police just watching us all the time. It's not fun and it
- 18:08doesn't actually help us at all. Well, Harrison, I appreciate your perspective
- 18:11and your viewpoint. Thank you so much for your time tonight. Thanks for
- 18:14having me. Folks, make sure you pick up his award winning memoir Invisible
- 18:18Boy. It's a timely memoir exploring his coming of age journey from white cult
- 18:23to black consciousness. He is Harrison Mooney. Thank you to Shelter Point Single
- 18:27Malt Whiskey for supporting local conversations from a diversity of voices. Now after a
- 18:33little business. How can we talk about education in BC without talking about school
- 18:38portables. I'm going to take a moment. Up next, welcome back to
- 18:49this as Van color in an episode themed around public education in British Columbia.
- 18:53We have to address the twenty one hundred elephants in the room. So let's
- 18:59take a moment. It's shameful that in British Columbia there are over twenty one
- 19:11hundred portables across the province's sixty public school districts, as a record amount of
- 19:18BC students receive their education in portables this year. Portables that lack bathrooms,
- 19:22heating, air conditioning, accessible entrances like ramps, and can be summarized figuratively
- 19:29and literally by this student when it really stinks, Yeah, they stink.
- 19:36Now. Some folks will blame immigration, as if New Canadians don't expand the
- 19:40tax base from which you can fund schools, and some will blame the BCNDP.
- 19:45I mean, they're in charge and the problem is only getting worse.
- 19:48And according to the CBC, the province doesn't even track the number of portable
- 19:52classrooms. How do you decrease the things when you don't even know the number
- 19:56of the things you're trying to decrease. In fairness, the BCNDP doubled annual
- 20:03school capital funding since twenty seventeen, but they're playing catch up after annual school
- 20:07capital funding was frozen for eight years before that, frozen by BC United,
- 20:12then known as the BC Liberals. Who has the provincial government closed down two
- 20:17hundred and sixty seven schools in sixteen years. Maybe we wouldn't need portables if
- 20:22those two hundred and sixty seven schools were open today. In twenty twelve alone,
- 20:27under then Finance Minister Kevin Falcon, the current leader of BC United who
- 20:32wants to be Premier, Falcon sold off forty eight pieces of public land that
- 20:36were education properties, including twenty one in Surrey, land that could have been
- 20:41used to build more schools. That's how we got here. Years of underfunding,
- 20:45closing down schools, selling off public land, without the foresight that the
- 20:49population will grow, especially in Surrey, and without the foresight that the rising
- 20:55cost of land means that it now costs way more to buy that land back
- 21:00to build more public schools. Now, none of this excuses the BCNDP,
- 21:04which needs to spend more money on public education to make up for years of
- 21:08bad decisions by Kevin Falkon and the other guys, because if they don't,
- 21:12this whole mess, like the portables themselves, will only get stinkier. Folks.
- 21:26That's our show. Thank you to Jesse Miller and Harrison Mooney for their
- 21:30time tonight. We'll be back next week. In the meantime, find me
- 21:33on X. It will always be Twitter to me or TikTok at Van color.
- 21:38Of course, this is Van color, and I'm moamir telling you that
- 21:42in a province where you can be anything, be colorful. Peace,