Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Intersection of Hi Tech Stalking in Domestic Violence and Family Law Cases
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07the intersection of high tech stocking and domestic
- 0:10violence and family law cases. I'm Alla Poli
- 0:13Castro, Director of Education and Professional
- 0:15Development at Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:18And today I'm delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:21Stephen Bradley. Steven is a law enforcement
- 0:24and legal technology consultant with Our Family
- 0:26Wizard, bringing over 20 years of experience
- 0:29spanning a distinguished FBI career and grassroots
- 0:33victim advocacy work. A specialist in cyber -enabled
- 0:37crimes, digital forensics, and the intersection
- 0:39of technology and abuse, he is internationally
- 0:42recognized for training legal professionals,
- 0:44judges, and law enforcement on stalking, cyberstalking,
- 0:48and intimate partner violence. He is also an
- 0:51Amazon best -selling author, contributing to
- 0:54divorce amicably. We can't wait to hear what
- 0:57he has to share with us today, so I'm now going
- 0:58to turn it over to him. Thank you all, and thank
- 1:01you all for giving up your time today to join
- 1:03us on such an important topic. I guess in the
- 1:06honor of Domestic Violence Awareness Month, we're
- 1:08going to talk a lot about the intersection of
- 1:10domestic violence and law as we go through this.
- 1:14So I'm going to share my screen, and we can have
- 1:16some fun. This may be scary for some of you,
- 1:19and that is not the intended purpose, so my apologies
- 1:22in advance. This is more knowledge is power.
- 1:25We want you to understand that when your client
- 1:28or that litigant comes before you and says something
- 1:30that sounds totally off the wall, like a Hollywood
- 1:33pitcher almost, we kind of slow down and say,
- 1:36okay, well, maybe this is real. Maybe this is
- 1:38actually happening. So we will walk, I will walk
- 1:41you off the cliff. I'll make sure that you don't
- 1:43throw your phones away after this presentation,
- 1:45nothing like that. Also, this presentation should
- 1:48be just as much personal as it is professional
- 1:51because we all carry devices and technology everywhere
- 1:54we go. So we need to know how to protect ourselves
- 1:57along with the people we work with. So the first
- 2:01question I always ask is, why do we care about
- 2:03technology? When we went to school, we went to
- 2:06law school, or maybe you're a mental health professional,
- 2:09or whatever your role may be, you didn't go to
- 2:12tech school. Very few of you may have. You might
- 2:14be an outlier out there. But our focus has not
- 2:17been on technology. However, technology is constantly
- 2:21changing. It changes by the day. And when we
- 2:24talk about technology, one thing I find very
- 2:26interesting worldwide is it's very generational.
- 2:30Let's take my generation, for example, Generation
- 2:32X. We were fortunate or unfortunate, however
- 2:36you want to look at it, because we grew up with
- 2:38technology. We had the horrible dial -up internet.
- 2:42Then we had the DSLs and the cables. We had pagers.
- 2:46Our first cell phone came in a bag. And then
- 2:49we kind of morphed the whole thing where we are
- 2:51today. So these devices, talking about these
- 2:55devices we carry, these cell phones that we call
- 2:58cell phones anyway, these are actually not cell
- 3:01phones any longer. They didn't have cell phones
- 3:03in 2007 when the first smartphones came out,
- 3:07we kind of went forward. So these technologies
- 3:10are constantly evolving, but are we staying with
- 3:13that? So let's put this in perspective and see
- 3:16what we're talking about here. So just a simple
- 3:18one. How many of you are older than Google? Now,
- 3:23we kind of think back, we're like, okay, well,
- 3:25Google's been around for a long time, but has
- 3:27it? September 4th, 1998. So, okay, most of us
- 3:33are probably there. What about the World Wide
- 3:35Web? This whole, you know, this cool World Wide
- 3:38Web, we connect people, connect websites all
- 3:40over the world. Are you older than the World
- 3:43Wide Web? August 6th, 1991. No, maybe not. Then
- 3:49there's the outlier, the big one, the internet
- 3:51itself. How many of you are older than the internet?
- 3:55I remember being a kid and actually playing outside.
- 3:57We didn't have the internet. It was really cool.
- 4:00But January 1st, 1983. So as you see, just here
- 4:04in these questions, there are several generations
- 4:06represented right here. Also, going back to my
- 4:09generation, we went to school, we had textbooks.
- 4:13When I went to typing class, I was actually not
- 4:14a typewriter. The generations today, they have
- 4:17tablets and computers in their hands. So they're
- 4:19more tech savvy than we are. All it's basically
- 4:23to say is meet your client, litigate, whoever
- 4:25you're working with, where they're at, not where
- 4:28you're at. Technology is scary. Like I mentioned,
- 4:33this will be scary for some of you, but technology
- 4:35is not the problem. Technology is a tool. We
- 4:39just have to learn how to work with it, use it,
- 4:42and recognize the things that are happening before
- 4:44it gets out of control, gets out of hand. So
- 4:48let's first kind of start the tone with the difference
- 4:50between the victims and the offenders. So for
- 4:55the victim, a global theme is that it's a mental
- 4:59health crisis. She's crazy. He's crazy. There's
- 5:02no way possible that can do that. Again, that's
- 5:05Hollywood TV show. No, not necessarily. Let's
- 5:09practice down for like domestic abuse or family
- 5:11law. All of us are guilty of playing that 20
- 5:14questions game. What high schools you go to?
- 5:18What's your favorite color? What's your favorite
- 5:20sporting team? When we meet people in relationships,
- 5:23we want to know something about those people.
- 5:25Well, what also are those? Those are security
- 5:30questions to your accounts. We tell people, we'll
- 5:33change your passwords. Well, that's great. But
- 5:36what about the security questions? If I can answer
- 5:39those questions, because I know a lot of information
- 5:40about you, I can get access to your account and
- 5:43make you think you're crazy. I'm adjusting the
- 5:45thermostat, the lights, doing all kinds of stuff
- 5:47just to harass you. When you go to your practitioner,
- 5:50you're like, hey, this is happening. They kind
- 5:52of sit back and like, are you crazy? Give them
- 5:55space and let them know that, hey, this is possible.
- 5:59On the offender side, I can tell you working
- 6:03with thousands of offenders worldwide, less than
- 6:0610 % have any kind of computer background at
- 6:08all. This is what we call keyboard warriors.
- 6:11They simply Google, how do I stalk my partner?
- 6:14What's the best tracker to use? How do I find
- 6:16my lawyer's home address, the judge's home address?
- 6:22There's places out there like YouTube and Reddit
- 6:25where there's all types of conversations that
- 6:27are happening. YouTube does videos and tell you
- 6:29how to get, how to do it and how to get away
- 6:31with it. On Reddit, I get Reddit a lot for conference
- 6:35materials. We go to the search bar and just type
- 6:37in domestic violence. And you'll find two offenders
- 6:40talking to each other. Hey, I got these charges
- 6:43against me. How do I get them dropped? Will this
- 6:45work to my case? Maybe they'll work in yours.
- 6:47What's the best tracker to track my partner?
- 6:50Well, this is what I use and here's the link
- 6:51on Amazon. So they empower each other. So don't
- 6:54think for a second we're dealing with any kind
- 6:56of a higher level being here or some kind of
- 6:59smart individual. They simply Google it. So let's
- 7:04talk about some buzzwords. The buzzwords we hear
- 7:06a lot. Coercive control and power and control.
- 7:10But I often hear times these are used, but they're
- 7:13not used properly or people sometimes misunderstand
- 7:15these. So we're going to take a minute to say,
- 7:18can I talk about that? So think of course of
- 7:21control as the strategy. So this can be employer,
- 7:25employee, this can be relationships, be a number
- 7:28of dynamics here. But this is the strategy. I
- 7:31want you through these course of control tactics,
- 7:33I want you to behave a certain way. Because after
- 7:36all, that's what power control is. Power control
- 7:39is the goal. But because I've done this course
- 7:41of control patterns, I now can look across the
- 7:44room and just give you a look. you automatically
- 7:47fall in line or you'll change your behavior because
- 7:50you know if you don't, abuse can escalate or
- 7:53increase later. So that's the goal. The unique
- 7:56thing behind course control and power control
- 7:58is they're not really synonymous. Course control
- 8:01is a form of power control, but not all power
- 8:04control is course control. I know that's a lot
- 8:07to take in this morning, but it's okay. We're
- 8:09going to kind of skip past this to talk about
- 8:11why we're here. TFA. Technology facilitated abuse.
- 8:17So this is where it affects all of us because
- 8:20we, again, we all carry cell phones and technology
- 8:22of where we go. We take our phones to the bathroom.
- 8:25So imagine if I had access to you, your device,
- 8:29what can I do? Not just your clients. So cyber
- 8:33stalking and surveillance. So stalking too is
- 8:37a terminology, a word that gets overused in just
- 8:40social norms. Are you stalking my snap? You're
- 8:44stalking my Facebook, my Instagram, whatever
- 8:45you have. People are very reluctant to report
- 8:48stalking. In fact, even though there's over 850
- 8:51,000 cases reported each year, we know it's one
- 8:54of the most underreported crimes that are out
- 8:56there. Harassment. I can harass you online, send
- 9:00you a bunch of DMs, I can send you emails, text
- 9:03messages, friend requests, a number of things.
- 9:08Image -based sexual abuse. We used to call this
- 9:10revenge porn. Revenge and porn both have negative
- 9:13connotations, so they started changing the terminology.
- 9:17I've also heard NCP, non -consensual pornography.
- 9:20But image -based sexual abuse seems to be kind
- 9:22of the norm today. Account hacking and control.
- 9:27So hacking is very interesting, especially when
- 9:29it comes to family and domestic violence type
- 9:31cases. It's because, again, I know a lot of information
- 9:34about you. We may have lived together at one
- 9:36point. Well, when we were separating, you were
- 9:39worried about shelter, food, all kinds of different
- 9:43necessities, basic needs. You weren't worried
- 9:46about the Amazon Alexa, or the thermostat that
- 9:48we shared, or the puppy cam, or whatever it may
- 9:51be. So when people are going to access these
- 9:54devices, you're like, I'm being hacked. No, you
- 9:57just never took away the control from that person.
- 10:01Digital impersonation. Well, we talk about spoofing
- 10:04a lot, like phone calls and text messages where
- 10:06I could put in somebody's name, somebody's phone
- 10:09number, change my voice from male to female.
- 10:12There's all kinds of tools out there that are
- 10:13free today to be able to impersonate somebody.
- 10:16I can clone your social media, do a number of
- 10:18things. Smart home abuse. Everybody wants to
- 10:22have a smart home, a digital home today. Again,
- 10:25these digital thermostats and door locks and
- 10:27things like that. We'll see more about that in
- 10:29a second. Deep fakes. Yes, it is the generation
- 10:33of AI. And AI, fortunately and unfortunately,
- 10:36is making it harder for a lot of us to do our
- 10:39jobs. I often get asked, is this going to replace
- 10:42my job? No, I don't think we're there yet. This
- 10:45is more like a tool. This is kind of like mediation,
- 10:48like ADR, when it came on scene back in the mid
- 10:51-90s. A lot of people thought that mediation
- 10:53was going to take away billable hours and change
- 10:56the dynamics. But we now know it's a tool that
- 10:59we use going forward. Well, I think AI at this
- 11:02point is going to be a tool as well. But the
- 11:06manipulation of AI with deepfakes, voice cloning,
- 11:09evidence manipulation can be very harmful in
- 11:12the things we do. Let's talk about these personal
- 11:15devices we all carry. Again, we carry them to
- 11:18the bathroom. Did you know, according to Cornell
- 11:20Tech, there's more personal information in your
- 11:22cell phone today than your own home? Let's think
- 11:26about that for a second. Let's kind of let that
- 11:28sink in. We have these wearable devices. Garments,
- 11:31Fitbits, Apple Watches, where a lot of our information
- 11:34coincides with our phone or device. Our steps,
- 11:40our sleep patterns, all kinds of fun stuff. Your
- 11:43pharmacy sends your prescriptions to your phone.
- 11:45Hey, your script's ready, including the name
- 11:48of the prescription. Your financial accounts,
- 11:51Amazon accounts. You may have a VPN to your law
- 11:54firm or to your office where you can get privileged
- 11:57confidential files all to your cell phone. But
- 12:00we hide behind these biometrics, these facial
- 12:02recognitions and passwords to keep our information
- 12:05safe. How many of you have actually gone to the
- 12:08App Store and downloaded an anti -virus, anti
- 12:11-malware program for your cell phone to keep
- 12:14that personal information safe? We do them on
- 12:17our computers and our other devices. We never
- 12:20do it on our cell phones. Remember, this is no
- 12:23longer a cell phone. This is a supercomputer
- 12:25that makes phone calls. There's more power in
- 12:29most cell phones today than most MacBooks or
- 12:31laptops that are out there. But we don't take
- 12:33the time to protect them. Well, this is a problem
- 12:36with our clients as well. Again, we shared a
- 12:38home together. You may have gone to sleep, take
- 12:40a shower. I got access to your device that you
- 12:43hid behind a password that you think I didn't
- 12:45know. And now I've put hidden spyware tools or
- 12:49different types of tools that are on your device
- 12:52that can basically monitor you forever and ever.
- 12:56Another reason why we have so much access to
- 12:58individuals today, including yourselves, is because
- 13:01of these things called IOTs, the internet of
- 13:04things. Today, we have more devices than ever
- 13:07that are connected to the information highway,
- 13:10to the internet. Here's just a handful. So, smart
- 13:14cars. Well, we think like Teslas and e -vehicles.
- 13:17That's not what I'm talking about here. Any vehicle
- 13:20manufactured in 2009 has a vehicle telemetry
- 13:23system built into it. Refrigerators. Today your
- 13:27refrigerator will tell you when to buy milk.
- 13:29I saw an ad the other day where the refrigerator
- 13:32apparently has an app that you can say, hey,
- 13:34what can I make for dinner? It scans the inside
- 13:36of your refrigerator and says, based on these
- 13:38ingredients, this is what you're making for dinner.
- 13:40Creepy or cool? I don't know. Doorbells. These
- 13:44ring, these video doorbell type systems. Watches.
- 13:47Again, apples, Fitbits, garments, thermostats,
- 13:51air tags, sneakers. I heard a radio ad the other
- 13:54day from Skechers, they have a trackable tennis
- 13:56shoe now. It's not one of the pockets you put
- 13:59an AirTag in, the whole shoe itself is trackable.
- 14:04Televisions, mainly smart TVs. If you can hit
- 14:06a button on your remote control and go to a streaming
- 14:08service, it's a smart TV is connected to the
- 14:11internet. Gaming consoles, gaming consoles are
- 14:15widely overlooked, you know, in a lot of these
- 14:17cases. Let's say I have a no contact or I can't
- 14:19talk to my child or my family. but I know every
- 14:22afternoon after school he gets on a video game
- 14:24like Fortnite. What's to prevent me from downloading
- 14:27a video game and talking to my child outside
- 14:30the court's purview? Alexa. I assume probably
- 14:35most of you probably have an Alexa or a dot or
- 14:37something similar in your home today. But how
- 14:40many of you knew it had a monitor mode? So again,
- 14:43we're going through a separation, divorce, domestic
- 14:45case, whatever it may be, and I'm worried about
- 14:49the basic needs of life. I'm not worried about
- 14:52my Alexa that's on my kitchen counter. But with
- 14:55the monitor mode, I can pull up my app, I can
- 14:57hit monitor, and I can listen to everything that's
- 14:59going inside your house. It doesn't announce
- 15:01and say, hey, I'm listening to you. It just turns
- 15:03on automatically. So those privileged conversations
- 15:07you're having with your attorney on speakerphone
- 15:10or you're with another partner inside the house,
- 15:13whatever it may be, I'm monitoring you through
- 15:14an Alexa because you never took away my access.
- 15:18pacemakers, streaming apps, technologies everywhere
- 15:22today. But what is the one thing most IoTs have
- 15:27in common besides the internet? Well, most of
- 15:31them, you have to use a companion app in order
- 15:33to use that. If you have a Roomba vacuum cleaner,
- 15:36there's a Roomba app. If you have an Apple Watch,
- 15:38there's an Apple Watch app, and so on and so
- 15:40forth. Well, here lies a lot of the problem,
- 15:44especially for us, because Less than 3 % of our
- 15:48population, according to Deloitte, actually reads
- 15:50terms and conditions of these apps. Why? We're
- 15:54practitioners. We work in the legal field. We
- 15:57live and die by the written word. But we don't
- 15:59take time to review the apps that were downloaded
- 16:02to our phone because we just bought this vacuum
- 16:05cleaner. It says in order to use this vacuum
- 16:07cleaner, you have to download an app. So we just
- 16:09go ahead and do it because it told us to. But
- 16:12if you slow down and look at those apps, it tells
- 16:14you that there's a hidden camera, or not even
- 16:16a hidden camera, there's a camera inside that
- 16:18vacuum cleaner that may or may not be taking
- 16:20pictures inside your home and upload them to
- 16:22their servers. All kinds of things that are out
- 16:25there to basically take away your privacy. Go
- 16:30back to IOTs. These smart homes are dumb mistakes.
- 16:35The thing about IOTs is there are some course
- 16:38of control type behaviors or patterns we can
- 16:40do with these type of devices. So again, you
- 16:43have these remote door locks that you can lock
- 16:46or unlock your home from your phone. I can actually
- 16:49do that and harass you, lock you at your home,
- 16:52turn your lights on and off, adjust your thermostat,
- 16:54make it very hot and make it very cold inside
- 16:56your home, monitor through those cameras inside
- 16:59your home. A number of things. I tell people,
- 17:03especially people that are not in a contentious
- 17:05situation, look around your home or your office.
- 17:09What kind of devices do you have? And if somebody
- 17:12wanted to monitor you or manipulate you, could
- 17:16they do it? How many of you actually talk to
- 17:19clients about, hey, what do you have in your
- 17:21home and have we take away the access to this?
- 17:24Because we haven't, they can get access. Remember
- 17:27that mental health piece, he's crazy, she's crazy.
- 17:30No, we just simply didn't basically get rid of
- 17:33the access. I do a lot of expert testimony consulting
- 17:37work and I have a case recently where they had
- 17:40a puppy cam inside their home. It's a thing where
- 17:43you have an app that you hit a button, it shoots
- 17:44a little puppy treat out to the dog, and you
- 17:46can talk and interact with your dog during the
- 17:48day while you're at work. Well, when they split
- 17:53up again, they didn't worry about the puppy cam.
- 17:56They didn't think about the puppy cam. But for
- 17:59the past two years, he's been watching, monitoring,
- 18:02videotaping, listening to everything she's been
- 18:04doing all through this puppy cam. We have to
- 18:08take away the access. Phones, the keys to our
- 18:13kingdom. Again, we take them everywhere we go.
- 18:15Yesterday, you basically track a vehicle with
- 18:18a GPS. Now we just track phones because, again,
- 18:21you don't leave them behind. So there's all kinds
- 18:24of things we can do with these phones. We can
- 18:26read. We can listen. We can locate. We can intimidate
- 18:28you. But there's cool evidence inside the phones
- 18:31that we can get to prove these cases. We have
- 18:34event logs. We have complete downloads, forensic
- 18:37downloads, social media, all kinds of cool things
- 18:40we can get information from. But there are some
- 18:44course of control or abuse patterns behind these
- 18:46phones as well. Biggest one is password coercion.
- 18:50I want to know your password. We're going to
- 18:52be in a relationship. I trust you. You trust
- 18:54me. I want your password. Account session persistence.
- 18:59What are you logged into? What are you not logged
- 19:01into? Notifications spying. So this is your lock
- 19:04screen. So right now, if Julie sent me a text
- 19:07message, it would pop up on my phone. It'd be
- 19:09sort of show her name, a little preview of our
- 19:12conversation. Well, some offenders will say,
- 19:15hey, you're going to keep that turned on because
- 19:17I want to see if you have a new boyfriend, new
- 19:18girlfriend, whatever it may be. These Find My
- 19:21Trackings, these Life 360s, different programs
- 19:24out there to track people today. Snapchat. A
- 19:27lot of kids want to track each other through
- 19:28Snapchat or Snap Maps. Well, if you have your
- 19:32locations turned on, it may not just be your
- 19:35friends tracking you. When it comes down to,
- 19:38again, these conversations, legal conversations
- 19:40I've had with practitioners from around the world,
- 19:43A lot of times comes up, well, is this illegal
- 19:45hacking? They're on the same cell phone plan,
- 19:49same house, same everything. Are they just having
- 19:51access or what's actually happening here? Was
- 19:53there consent? Was there not consent? If I have
- 19:56a hidden camera inside my bathroom, is that wrong?
- 20:00Yes, it's wrong. You can't do that. There's both
- 20:03criminal and civil penalties. You can't put hidden
- 20:05cameras in your bathroom and take pictures of
- 20:07your partner in the shower or changing their
- 20:09clothes. But there's all kinds of weird conversations
- 20:11that are happening behind the scenes. If you
- 20:17do have a situation that's happening, I highly
- 20:20suggest you go into your settings and you turn
- 20:21on what's called an Apple data privacy report.
- 20:25So this is for Android as well. And I will show
- 20:27you that here in just a second. But this is your
- 20:30privacy report. And this basically shows you
- 20:32how your phone interacts with the internet, with
- 20:35the web, and different apps. So if your client's
- 20:38coming to you saying, they're listening to me.
- 20:40They know my conversations. They know my locations.
- 20:43They always show up at the Walmart, the park.
- 20:45They always know where I am. Well, you might
- 20:47want to go to your privacy report and see if
- 20:49your phone is telling somebody or telling an
- 20:52app is telling you wherever you are, like a spyware
- 20:55type app. A couple of years ago, there's a lot
- 20:59of conversation about TikTok being this spying
- 21:02tool or whatever. And they weren't wrong, but
- 21:05where did that come from? It came from privacy
- 21:07reports, because when you pull up TikTok or Tmoo
- 21:10or Alibaba or any of these other companies, go
- 21:13see where your phone actually goes to, how many
- 21:15IP addresses it connects to that are overseas.
- 21:18You simply pull up a website, type in iplookup
- 21:21.com, and it'll tell you where your information
- 21:23is going to. For Android, it looks like this.
- 21:27So these are available on both apps. So I would
- 21:30definitely encourage you, encourage your clients
- 21:33to download these and see. I mean, am I crazy
- 21:36or not? Am I being tracked? Am I being stalked?
- 21:38Let's see. So let's talk about stalking 101.
- 21:43What I mean by 101 is, yesteryear we talked a
- 21:46lot about Bluetooth. Because Bluetooth was the
- 21:49101. This was the basic way to stalk or monitor
- 21:52somebody. Because if you remember back then,
- 21:55the password to Bluetooth was 000 or 1234. It
- 22:00wasn't rocket science. I could pair my phone
- 22:02to your phone just like a set of AirPods. But
- 22:05the industry finally got smart and said, hey,
- 22:07we're going to encrypt this. Now it's just some
- 22:09random characters pop up that you have to put
- 22:12in. But even though it's still, yes, it's still
- 22:15present day and there are different provisions
- 22:18put in place, every time I get a client, they
- 22:21say, hey, I think someone's stalking me or listening
- 22:23to me. This is the first place I always have
- 22:25them go. Open your settings and go to Bluetooth.
- 22:28And as you see here in this list, you're going
- 22:30to see every device your phone's been connected
- 22:32to. And the reason why is because, again, we
- 22:35were in a relationship. You may have taken a
- 22:38shower, have gone to sleep, and I got access
- 22:40to your phone. And I would have paired my device
- 22:42with your device and got that special secret
- 22:44code, and you never know it's there. Because
- 22:47most people don't go to their Bluetooth to see
- 22:49who I'm connected to. You just want to make sure
- 22:51it works. If you're working with Jane and you
- 22:55see Tom's iPhone there, that's a clue. That little
- 22:59blue I button. Click on that and get the MAC
- 23:02address, get all the information from that device
- 23:05with a screenshot, and then you can actually
- 23:07delete that connection. Now, some of you are
- 23:11probably saying, well, Bluetooth is another deal.
- 23:12We're talking about 15, 25 feet tops. Well, that's
- 23:15good. Because today, as technology advances,
- 23:19there's what's called BTLE sniffers, or these
- 23:22Bluetooth extenders. It extends at 25 feet to
- 23:2526 miles. Let's just say that you left the home.
- 23:28You're now at a confidential domestic violence
- 23:30shelter. or your sister's house, mom's house,
- 23:33a friend's house. If you're within 26 miles of
- 23:35me, I can still track you. So possibly install
- 23:38malicious software to your phone, listen to you,
- 23:40monitor you, all because of Bluetooth. But you're
- 23:45like, OK, well, 26 miles. I mean, I moved out
- 23:47of state. OK, I'm pretty good there. Well, again,
- 23:50that's good. However, again, as technology advances,
- 23:55there's now free apps out there allow you to
- 23:57track Bluetooth anywhere in the world. So there's
- 23:59no longer a constraint to this. There's no longer
- 24:01a leash that says, hey, you're within 15, 25,
- 24:0426 miles. Now, anywhere you go in the world,
- 24:07you can find Bluetooth devices. And this comes
- 24:10off the back of things like AirPods and Bose
- 24:13and Beats and the things we carry with us that
- 24:15are Bluetooth driven that we may lose on an airplane
- 24:18or fall out of our pockets somewhere. They want
- 24:20you to be able to track them. So if I can track
- 24:23my headphones, I can track your device as well,
- 24:26iPads, whatever it may be. Speaking of other
- 24:30devices, kids' devices, the hidden back door,
- 24:35often overlooked. So let's talk about Google
- 24:38accounts or shared accounts. So when you log
- 24:41into a device today, especially like a wifi,
- 24:44it asks you, do you want to make this shareable?
- 24:47And most people just say yes, because they don't
- 24:49know what that means. Let me tell you what that
- 24:52means. So little Johnny or Susie, they have an
- 24:55old iPad, an old phone. They're going back and
- 24:57forth between mom and dad's house for parenting
- 24:59time. to watch YouTube videos, play video games,
- 25:02or whatnot. Well, when that phone's in mom's
- 25:06house, it needs to be mom's device, let's say,
- 25:08and she signs into Google on her actual device,
- 25:11because that phone is linked to a shared account,
- 25:13it may log in as well. Well, this is where the
- 25:16problem lies, because there's a hidden feature
- 25:19in Google Maps for location sharing. It works
- 25:22like Live 360, but it's a little different. You
- 25:25actually have to go to settings and turn it on
- 25:26or see who's actually following you. Again, nobody
- 25:30goes, none of us go into Google Maps to see if
- 25:33someone's actually following us or tracking us
- 25:34because that's just, why would we? But these
- 25:38devices are going back and forth between the
- 25:39homes. This is where these parenting plans come
- 25:43into play. Do you have a device that goes between
- 25:46homes or does each parent have their own device
- 25:48and nothing actually transfers? Family location
- 25:52sharings, like these Life360s or Findmys. Video
- 25:55games. Nanny cams, all kinds of devices there
- 25:58today that these kids have we might could get
- 26:00access to. Reproductive abuse. So reproductive
- 26:07abuse comes in many forms. This just happens
- 26:09to be a digital form. And it's before lunch.
- 26:12So we can go ahead and talk about this. So this
- 26:14is a app on your phone to track your menstrual
- 26:18cycle. Also known as a period tracker. Why are
- 26:21we talking about menstrual cycles before lunch?
- 26:24Well, believe it or not, it's actually not about
- 26:26your menstrual cycle. These apps also track your
- 26:29ovulation cycle when you're most likely to get
- 26:32pregnant. Well, therein lies the problem because
- 26:35there's been several studies done that shows
- 26:37that this basically creates a double bind. When
- 26:40women or men or whoever are in a relationship
- 26:43and they feel like leaving that situation, that's
- 26:47just a one -on -one type deal. Now you have a
- 26:50pregnancy of a child in the mix of that. So what
- 26:52happens is 8 % of mothers actually delay leaving
- 26:55their pregnancy. because of this child. But these
- 26:59same studies show that 18 to 24 months postpartum,
- 27:03the abuse escalates higher than it ever was before.
- 27:06Because now you have that child, you have that
- 27:08widget, you have that item that they can hold
- 27:10over your head and say, you're not gonna leave
- 27:12me because I'm gonna keep the baby or whatnot.
- 27:15So this can both delay and catalyze the decisions
- 27:18that leave. It's still today in 2026 also, we
- 27:23have several states in the country, including
- 27:25mine right here, I live in Texas. that if you
- 27:28are pregnant, you cannot file for divorce or
- 27:30separation. It's a tool to keep you in a horrible
- 27:33relationship. And these offenders talk and joke
- 27:36about it online, like places like Reddit, where
- 27:38they say, hey, we can do this. Just get them
- 27:40pregnant. Social media. Social media is the number
- 27:47one activity online today. Let's just take Facebook,
- 27:51for example. We know Facebook's for old people.
- 27:53I get it. But if you took just the daily active
- 27:56users of Facebook and you put them on an island,
- 27:59maybe the largest country in the world. Over
- 28:022 .2 billion daily users just on one platform.
- 28:06But there is metadata that can be pulled out
- 28:09of there. There's metadata in these Instagram
- 28:11logs. There's also, and I see a question in there,
- 28:14metadata for the IoTs. Yes, there are metadata
- 28:17in IoTs that we can pull to show what these devices
- 28:21are actually doing. When the ring doorbells interact,
- 28:24when the devices interact, the thermostats. We
- 28:27can pull a great metadata from that. So it's
- 28:29a great question. Snap maps. We talked about
- 28:32snap maps. So where we can actually track each
- 28:35other through that. TikTok lives. You know, everybody
- 28:39wants to be an influencer, everybody wants to
- 28:40be on TikTok today. But if you're posting lives
- 28:43and you're down in Italy on the Amalfi coast
- 28:45and you're claiming hardship where I can't afford
- 28:47my attorney or I need representation, that may
- 28:50be contradictory. Facebook check -ins. Everybody
- 28:53wants to check in. I'm at the coffee shop. I'm
- 28:55at Disney. I'm wherever I am. Well, you're also
- 28:58letting people know your behaviors and what you're
- 29:00doing. LinkedIn employment evidence. You have
- 29:03a job or you don't. They actually say that in
- 29:07the dating world that LinkedIn is actually one
- 29:08of the better dating apps because I know you
- 29:11have a job. Sorry, dad jokes for days. So what
- 29:17is this digital demeanor and how can it be interpreted?
- 29:19How do the courts interpret this? How do custody
- 29:22evaluators, parent coordinators, all the different
- 29:25roles we work with today, how do they interpret
- 29:28these? Well, alcohol, for example. You're doing
- 29:31keg stands at a family reunion somewhere, but
- 29:34now you went through a custody battle. Are those
- 29:37photographs or images going to be in your favor?
- 29:41Again, vacation photos, contradiction and hardship
- 29:43claims. I can't afford this, Your Honor, but
- 29:45here I am on vacation in Mexico. New relationships.
- 29:49Everybody wants to post a new boo online. Hey,
- 29:52look at this, look at that. Whether trying to
- 29:54rub it in somebody's face or not. Everybody wants
- 29:57to live vicariously online through other people.
- 30:01Sub tweeting. Perception often matters. Perception
- 30:04is reality for many, many people. What is sub
- 30:09tweeting? I know everybody wanted to ask, but
- 30:11I was afraid to. What is sub tweeting? So sub
- 30:15tweeting, and you're going to see this a lot.
- 30:16This is kind of a recent, I'll say a recent thing.
- 30:18So I've had cases in the past year that have
- 30:20actually done this. But this is becoming, I guess,
- 30:23a TikTok trend if you want to go there with that.
- 30:26Whereas the act of being passive aggressive online
- 30:29to somebody without actually calling out that
- 30:31person. So you're basically, I'm talking about
- 30:35Julie, and Julie knows I'm talking about her,
- 30:37but I never actually called her by name. Typically,
- 30:40what you're going to see is you're going to see
- 30:42a series of emojis next to a username. So on
- 30:45their profile, there's going to be a series of
- 30:46emojis. These emojis constantly change. you know,
- 30:51be changed by the hour, changed by the minute,
- 30:53because I know Julie's looking at my page. So
- 30:56I know that if I say something to her, she's
- 30:58going to interpret that and she's going to get
- 31:00all upset and all in her feelings. Well, what
- 31:02does that actually mean? Someone who acts nice
- 31:06is actually a snake and people are watching the
- 31:08drama. Julie's amazing. I'm not saying that,
- 31:11but I'm just saying this is what people do. They
- 31:13constantly change this to kind of poke the bear
- 31:15at the other individual. But if your client comes
- 31:18into your office and brings you a bunch of emojis,
- 31:20What are you gonna do? You're like, what does
- 31:22this mean? And why are we worried about this?
- 31:25We're gonna talk about emojis later. So let's
- 31:28talk about the fun thing. Cyberstalking. Cyberstalking
- 31:32is something that's widely misunderstood still
- 31:35today. And in fact, California was the leader
- 31:38of this, the pioneer in this in 2008. The rest
- 31:42of the country adopted it by 2012. What you see
- 31:46before you is actually several state statues
- 31:48from around the country. because they all pretty
- 31:50much say the same exact thing. I'll show you
- 31:52yours in a second. Engage in the course of conduct.
- 31:56There can be two or three more events, text messages,
- 31:58emails, DMs, whatever. To communicate or cause
- 32:02to be communicated directly or indirectly, that's
- 32:05key, words, images, or language by through electronic
- 32:08mail, electronic communication, directed at or
- 32:11pertaining to a specific person. To access or
- 32:14attempt to access online accounts, internet,
- 32:16take home electricity, blah, blah, blah. causing
- 32:19substantial emotional distress. Now that is the
- 32:23burden across the land in most places. Emotional
- 32:27distress is something that is different for every
- 32:29single one of us. It's simply feeling overwhelmed,
- 32:32helpless, or hopeless. Well, California is unique,
- 32:36where again, I said that you were pioneers in
- 32:382008, but they seem to kind of, I guess, needs
- 32:41to be updated a little bit. Because in your criminal
- 32:44code for stalking, it basically says there has
- 32:46to be reasonable fear for his or her safety.
- 32:49is not the emotional distress burden, because
- 32:52emotional stress, again, is very easy. It's a
- 32:55misdemeanor, it's not pretty, but I can prove
- 32:56emotional stress more so that I can say that
- 32:59he threatened, he or she threatened to kill me
- 33:01or put me in reasonable fear. But the oddity
- 33:04to this is the civil code in California actually
- 33:08does include substantial emotional distress.
- 33:11So depending on your client and the situation
- 33:13you are, you may be able to use both of these,
- 33:16in fact. Even if you have a civil case or divorce
- 33:19case, you may have criminal penalties to that.
- 33:22You get more legal process like search warrants
- 33:24and cool tools that we can do on the criminal
- 33:26side. Sometimes when it comes to cyber, we don't
- 33:30know where these offenders come from. They come
- 33:32from Arizona, Alaska, Florida. We have no idea,
- 33:36but that's okay because the federal statute,
- 33:40the burden for federal law is emotional distress.
- 33:43So no matter where you go, we can hold these
- 33:46offenders accountable. We actually use these
- 33:49cases a lot, or these statues a lot, excuse me,
- 33:51in doxing cases, where people are purposely putting
- 33:54your information online to cause you harm. Well,
- 33:58there's no doxing laws in many states across
- 34:00the country, but because it's online harassment,
- 34:03we can use these cyber stalking statues to hold
- 34:06them accountable. When we talk about cyber stalking,
- 34:10we talk about these IoTs and different devices
- 34:12we've talked about so far today. One thing I
- 34:16see happen a lot is these protection orders and
- 34:19things that are written are still written like
- 34:21it's 1996, not 2026. How many of you in your
- 34:26parenting plans or POs include IOTs, AI, social
- 34:31media, devices? We have to update these materials
- 34:35and these forms we've been using for years in
- 34:38order to make it real time and real world. Specify
- 34:41what, again, does this device go shared between
- 34:44homes? Do they have their own devices? Whatever
- 34:46it may be. Trackers. So when we talk about trackers,
- 34:53people instantly go to like GPS and things like
- 34:56that. But we're going to talk a little bit broader
- 34:59today because there's all kinds of different
- 35:01ways to track or surveil somebody. Earlier I
- 35:05mentioned vehicles and computers in vehicles.
- 35:08So yes, Teslas have amazing logs, but all vehicles
- 35:11have logs in them in the telemetry system. OnStar.
- 35:16There's metadata, there's location history inside
- 35:18of there. I can call up OnStar and say, hey,
- 35:20where's my Tahoe? Within two feet of accuracy,
- 35:22they'll tell you exactly where it is. App -based
- 35:25driving data. My truck has an app on my phone
- 35:28where I can adjust my radio, my air conditioning,
- 35:31turn it on, turn it off, all of them through
- 35:33my phone. And then there's the EDR. Well, the
- 35:37EDR is more of a... more like an accident type
- 35:41tool. It's just like the last, within maybe two
- 35:43hours of your driving patterns tells you where
- 35:45you hit the brakes, the accelerated left, right,
- 35:47things like that. But the telemetry system is
- 35:50different. So, the reason why we're talking about
- 35:54this the way we are is because today there's
- 35:57this whole sharing concept where mom and dad
- 36:01will share a common home. So that way the kids
- 36:03are not uprooted. Kids have their own toys, their
- 36:06own bedroom. Mom moves out for two weeks, dad
- 36:09moves in, and vice versa. Well, because of financial
- 36:12hardships today, the vehicles are often treated
- 36:15the same way. We only have one vehicle that the
- 36:18car seats will fit in. So not only sharing the
- 36:20home, we're sharing the SUV. Well, with the telemetry
- 36:24system, all I have to do is take the SUV to any
- 36:27car dealership in the country and plug in a little
- 36:30thumb drive to it, and they'll download the whole
- 36:31system for you. Oftentimes, it's free. Then you
- 36:34can go home on your leisure and download all
- 36:36the locations of where that vehicle's been. If
- 36:39you've been by a confidential divestment view
- 36:41shelter, your mom's South sister's house, or
- 36:43wherever, I now can track you. It causes a lot
- 36:46of problems. Then, of course, there's the cell
- 36:50phones we have. A lot of people think that when
- 36:53they turn their locations off on their phone
- 36:55that they're safe. Well, unfortunately, that's
- 36:58not true. Every cell phone manufacturer after
- 37:012015 has two GPS chips built into it. One is
- 37:07for emergency services and one's for like social
- 37:09media, Google Maps, things like that. When you
- 37:11turn off your locations on your phone, you're
- 37:13just turning off social media and Google Maps.
- 37:16Your phone is still in this location. So if I
- 37:18have apps to work off of the E911 chip, I'm still
- 37:21able to track you. Then of course there's the
- 37:25GPS. Well, GPS I found has become a basically
- 37:30synonymous term like Kleenex. No matter what
- 37:33kind of tissue it is, we call it a Kleenex. So
- 37:36when people come in your office and say, well,
- 37:38he's got a GPS tracker. Don't get hung up on
- 37:41a GPS tracker. That's just, again, just a term
- 37:44that people just know and relate to, trackers.
- 37:47GPS, though, is a bunch of satellites in the
- 37:49sky that triangulate your location and pinpoint
- 37:51where you are. There are two types. There's active
- 37:55and there's passive. Active shows you where you
- 37:57are. Passive shows you where you've been. Most
- 38:00people today will not use an active GPS for most
- 38:04offenders. You spend five minutes on Google,
- 38:06you know it's a bad idea. Because if I find that
- 38:09tracker, within minutes I can tell you who it
- 38:11belongs to. It's transmitting information via
- 38:14IP somewhere to somebody. I can get you financial
- 38:17data, all kinds of cool stuff. Most defenders
- 38:20will use a passive GPS if they use a GPS, which
- 38:24means it's a standalone unit or it has an SD
- 38:26card in it, but they have to come back at 4 a
- 38:28.m. to retrieve that to go home and download
- 38:31to see what you've been doing all day. Well,
- 38:33that's a pain in the butt. I might get caught,
- 38:35it might be bad weather, whatever it may be.
- 38:38So we're seeing this big shift from all these
- 38:40satellites in the sky to all of you, all of us,
- 38:44into what's called crowdsourcing technologies.
- 38:47This works off of, again, that phone we take
- 38:48everywhere we go. Tiles and AirTags, there's
- 38:52all kinds of brands available online today. Tiles
- 38:56are nothing new. Tiles have been out for over
- 38:5812 plus years, but they did a horrible job advertising
- 39:02themselves. They were advertised as track your
- 39:05luggage. Boring. It wasn't until air tags came
- 39:09out, they're like track your dog, track your
- 39:10lunchbox, track your kid. If I can track my lunchbox
- 39:13and my kid, I can track my partner. So we started
- 39:16seeing all kinds of reports come forward where
- 39:19people are finding air tags in the pocket of
- 39:22their coat or the purse or the car, gas door,
- 39:26things like that. But believe it or not, these
- 39:30are still not the number one trackers being seen
- 39:32today. in domestic abuse or family law cases.
- 39:36In fact, most of you actually probably has the
- 39:38number one tracker, maybe even on your person.
- 39:41You don't even realize it. What are we talking
- 39:44about? We're talking about AirPods. Not just
- 39:48AirPods, any kind of a headphone type system,
- 39:51Bose, Beats. They have a Find My Bluetooth feature.
- 39:54Remember, there's free apps. I can track you
- 39:56anywhere in the world through your headphones.
- 39:59Let's think about this for a minute. Ladies,
- 40:01if you open up your purse or your handbag and
- 40:03you find an air tag in there or a tile, you know
- 40:07somebody's tracking your location because that's
- 40:09the sole purpose of them. But if you find my
- 40:12headphones in there, babe, I've been looking
- 40:15everywhere for my headphones, not my tracker.
- 40:18I've been tracking you all along with my headphones.
- 40:21Or I may purchase them for you for a holiday,
- 40:23birthday or a gift. And I send them up through
- 40:25my Find My or up on for the children. And I said
- 40:29them again through my my my my fine my and not
- 40:31anywhere you go and take the children. I'm able
- 40:33to track you through these headphones widely
- 40:36overlooked. But with these air tags and these
- 40:40different type of devices, you're supposed to
- 40:42get notification pops up within two hours. Hey,
- 40:44this is following you. But what I just say, two
- 40:49hours, a lot can happen in two hours. Let's just
- 40:53say that you're out out the bar for happy hour
- 40:55after work with some coworkers having a great
- 40:57time. You're not really paying attention. Some
- 41:00creep walks behind you and drops an air tag in
- 41:01your purse or your pocket, your handbag, whatever
- 41:03it may be. It's not gonna take you two hours,
- 41:07well, maybe in California traffic, but typically
- 41:09it won't take you two hours to get home. Well,
- 41:12if you're not gonna get a notification, I've
- 41:13been tracking you the whole time, that can be
- 41:15problematic. But even if you do get a notification,
- 41:19it tells you, click here to play a sound in order
- 41:22to find that. Well, you remember that whole mental
- 41:25health conversation where he's crazy, she's crazy?
- 41:28They're not. Because you get notified, you hit
- 41:31play sound 100 times, it's not doing anything.
- 41:34Why is that? Because today on YouTube, there's
- 41:37several thousand videos that tell you how to
- 41:39remove the speaker from an air tag. It works
- 41:42just fine as a tracker, but will no longer emit
- 41:44a sound. So you can hit play sound all day long.
- 41:47It's right within two feet of you. You'll never
- 41:49find it. Again, these offenders keep coming up
- 41:52with ways to cause us harm. Well, as if this
- 41:56is not enough to try to manipulate somebody,
- 42:00This is another conversation I came across on
- 42:02Reddit, where it says, again, if you have, if
- 42:05your same home or you have access to their device,
- 42:08all you have to do is simply go in the settings
- 42:09and turn off the notifications. So no matter
- 42:12what kind of device you have, tile, air tag,
- 42:15knockoff, whatever it may be, GPS, you're no
- 42:18longer going to get notified. It tells you just
- 42:20go ahead and turn it off. This is all of the
- 42:22internet. This is on, I've seen YouTube videos,
- 42:24I've seen it on TikTok. where people tell them,
- 42:27just turn off the notifications and we'll never
- 42:28know you're following them. In 2024, so yesteryear,
- 42:35Apple and Android never talked to each other,
- 42:37but they finally came up with a way to say, hey,
- 42:39we need cross -platform tracking. So now if you
- 42:42have an Android phone, you get a similar pop
- 42:45-up just like on the iPhone that says, hey, this
- 42:47device is following you. But again, it still
- 42:49takes within about two hours for it to happen.
- 42:51So just basically keep yourself safe. Well, that's
- 42:55been a lot of scary stuff, whatever. So let's
- 42:58kind of lighten the mood and just have some fun
- 43:00remaining time we have. So let's talk about hidden
- 43:04communications. Let's talk about, we may get
- 43:06a case with a client, maybe an evaluation case,
- 43:11a parenting case, maybe a litigation case, whatever
- 43:14it may be. And you get something that has a bunch
- 43:16of pictures in it or a bunch of things that don't
- 43:19make any sense to you. Well, today it's very
- 43:22common people talk in emojis or text slang. In
- 43:27fact, I was in New Orleans in recent times where
- 43:31someone from Los Angeles actually stood up and
- 43:33said, hey, we use emojis in our office every
- 43:35single day because we don't want the clients
- 43:38to know we're talking about them. So it's a quick,
- 43:40short, fun way to talk about somebody or talk
- 43:42about a topic. So let's quickly go through this.
- 43:45So what's an emoji? They're cute little picture
- 43:47things that we said. But emojis are not alone.
- 43:51because we also have what's called emoticons.
- 43:55Emoticon is the typed version of the emoji. So
- 43:58instead of sending a picture, you're sending
- 43:59basically a typed version. But again, these are
- 44:03not new. Does anybody have a clue when the very
- 44:05first emoticon was ever used in human history?
- 44:10It was in 1862 to a letter to Clara Cowles. So
- 44:14many of you probably have no idea who Clara Cowles
- 44:17is, and this is all during the whole Civil War
- 44:19era. She was actually the wife of a senator.
- 44:22where the person wrote her a letter and said,
- 44:23Ms. Cowles, will you please accept my thanks
- 44:25for the pair of socks? I could almost wish to
- 44:27have no feet in order to make a favorable return
- 44:29for them. There's a little winky face emoticon.
- 44:33Well, who sent this? Abraham Lincoln. Apparently,
- 44:38he had a lot of witty writings. Yeah, not the
- 44:40Gettysburg Address, but a lot of times when he
- 44:42wrote, he did these little emoticons because
- 44:44he had this witty sense of humor. But these emojis
- 44:48are constantly always in our face, and we don't
- 44:50realize it. How many of you recognize these?
- 44:54Anytime you hit a like button on any platform
- 44:56out there, these are the first ones that pop
- 44:58up. They're always in our face. Have you ever
- 45:01stopped to actually look at them and realize
- 45:03that this is our client's relationships from
- 45:05start to finish? Maybe even your own. I like
- 45:08you, I love you, I hate you, you suck. All the
- 45:10way through, but they're constantly there. We
- 45:12just never pay attention to them. And the reason
- 45:15why we're talking about emojis today is because
- 45:18as of 2023, the recent stats have not come out
- 45:21yet. There's been over 2 ,000 court cases where
- 45:26basically the case has been decided just on emojis
- 45:29alone. Some Supreme Court cases. In your materials
- 45:33will be a list of all these cases if you want
- 45:34to go through them and see which emoji actually
- 45:37decided the case. Here's some examples. The winky
- 45:42face. This was a Texas case down in 2011 where
- 45:45this person met somebody online and it was a
- 45:48sexual assault case, but she had sent him a winky
- 45:51face emoji. and of course he took that as consent.
- 45:55Well, not knowing the consent could be taken
- 45:57back at any time, luckily the court did, they
- 46:00put him in prison for 10 years. Gun face emoji.
- 46:05Probably a bad idea anyway. This is a France
- 46:07case where Mayo sentenced to 22 months, was actually,
- 46:1120 -year -old Mayo sentenced to three months,
- 46:13it was actually an 11 -year sentence but was
- 46:14suspended, for basically sending his ex -girlfriend
- 46:17a picture of this pistol emoji, where the court
- 46:19determined it as a real threat. The dizzy face.
- 46:24First off, I did not know this was a dizzy face.
- 46:26I thought this meant death anyway, but so did
- 46:29the prosecutors in Massachusetts. Well, they
- 46:31deemed this as premeditated homicide. They charged
- 46:35it as such. When we talk about emojis, context
- 46:40matters. So to be fair, when I built this, I
- 46:43didn't realize I did this, but I did that. Put
- 46:46the finger in the hand thing. But context matters.
- 46:50So when you look at emojis in a series of pictures,
- 46:53what does this actually say? Basically, it says
- 46:55an ambulance is coming. If I take that hand and
- 46:58turn it around, it simply says you're gonna need
- 47:00an ambulance. So again, it's just context. Well,
- 47:04not only is context a problem, so is the platform
- 47:07or device you use. So if you use the Android,
- 47:10Apple, Facebook, whatever it may be, emojis may
- 47:14look different. So when you're trying to interpret
- 47:16these as a practitioner, you have to know all
- 47:20kinds of information about this before you even
- 47:22start knowing what it actually says. What platform,
- 47:26you know, you know, what context? What color?
- 47:30Colors have meanings too. I've been sending the
- 47:33message, wrong message to a lot of people for
- 47:35a long time because I had no idea that colors
- 47:37actually meant something. A lot of this conversation
- 47:41stood from a TV show that many of you may have
- 47:45seen on Netflix called Adolescents. To me, it
- 47:48was horribly done. If you haven't seen it, it
- 47:50could have been done on one show instead of five.
- 47:52But the premise behind this was There's an online
- 47:56group of what's called incels, which means they're
- 47:59involuntarily celibate. Nobody wants to hug them,
- 48:01love them, kiss them, be with them, whatever
- 48:03it may be. And the thing about social media is
- 48:08people find a sense of community. People are
- 48:10always looking for a sense of community. Well,
- 48:12social media being online does that. Well, this
- 48:16group right here of incels found each other and
- 48:18they basically created their own terminology
- 48:20or code based on emojis. Where these emojis actually
- 48:24mean something to them in their own terminology,
- 48:26their culture. Whereas you'll see here in a minute
- 48:29where the red pill means something totally different.
- 48:32All these have different meanings, but to them,
- 48:33this is what it meant. Let's take drugs, for
- 48:37example. So again, the pill there meant that
- 48:40you were involuntarily celibate. Now it means
- 48:42you're at a rave getting some MDMA. Frosty, who
- 48:47knew frosty was cocaine? The ape, all I get.
- 48:50Ketamine, okay, I get that one. But again, they
- 48:52have different meanings, so context. Here's all
- 48:55the violence ones. Snitches get stitches, all
- 48:58that fun stuff. Locked up, trap music, weapons.
- 49:02There's all the fun ones most of us probably
- 49:03know. We've probably seen these a bunch of times.
- 49:07If you look here in the lower right -hand corner,
- 49:09the little splashy water means you're having
- 49:11a great time. Here, not so much. It means you're
- 49:14actually harming yourself, you're cutting yourself.
- 49:17So again, what's the context? So we look at emojis,
- 49:22we have to know the device, the context, and
- 49:26now we have to look at the age. Because yes,
- 49:29adults use these as well. Adults and kids use
- 49:32these, but they're interpreted very, very different.
- 49:35Let's talk about the face with tears, Joy. The
- 49:37tears coming down. For us adults, it's hilarious.
- 49:40It's laughter. For kids, it's outdated, ironic
- 49:44or sarcastic. A little slight smiling face. Let's
- 49:48be in polite, you know, positive tone. Kids is
- 49:51awkward. That's being passive aggressive. Don't
- 49:52do that. Heart eyes, enthusiastic. Kids still
- 49:56use it, but it's millennial coded. Basically,
- 49:58they'll send multiples. They won't just send
- 49:59one. The pile of poo. Adults think it's funny.
- 50:04Kids think it's immature. Go figure. The loud
- 50:07crying face. Extreme sadness or crying. To kids,
- 50:11it's hysterical laughter. I'm rolling on the
- 50:13floor laughing. I'm just overwhelmed. Thumbs
- 50:16up. Approval. In agreement, professional. Kids,
- 50:20okay, boomer. And going back to generations,
- 50:23it doesn't matter what generation you're in,
- 50:24we're all boomers. If you're older than them,
- 50:26you're a boomer. So don't get offended by that
- 50:28because everybody's a boomer. So now we have
- 50:32the device, we have the context, we have age,
- 50:35and now we have the culture. Because again, we
- 50:38have to interpret what this is saying. We're
- 50:39reading this on our reports, but we don't know
- 50:41what it means. So cultures have meanings too.
- 50:44So the Western, the fold of the hands means prayer,
- 50:47thank you, or ask completely. I've also seen
- 50:49it as a high five. In Japan, it's about showing
- 50:52apology of gratitude. Again, the pile of poo,
- 50:56we think it's funny. In Japan, it's good luck.
- 50:58Who knew? The okay, the okay symbol. In the Middle
- 51:03East, it's highly offensive. The raising hands,
- 51:06you know, they put them up, you know, praise,
- 51:07celebration. In Caribbean African cultures, this
- 51:10is, you know, Pentecostals is a religious expression.
- 51:14You know, the call me maybe, the shock of hands.
- 51:16Hawaiian culture means hang loose, chill, chill
- 51:18out, just be calm. So again, we have to have
- 51:22all this context behind the emoji. Here's an
- 51:26example of what you may see. And this one's very
- 51:28nice because there's actually words that go along
- 51:31with the emojis. Most times you will not see
- 51:33this. So let's take that first one, for example.
- 51:37I used little two emoji, this little cringy face,
- 51:40my tongue, and this little fist, my, and this
- 51:43guy blowing a puff of air. So what's that actually
- 51:46say? I used to bite my tongue and hold my breath.
- 51:51Second one, you got a little ghost down here.
- 51:54Two, rock the sailboat, make a, there's a guy
- 51:58throwing something in the trash can. Okay, we
- 52:00can probably figure that one out. Because again,
- 52:01these are very friendly to us. There's words
- 52:03there. Scared to rock a boat and make a mess.
- 52:06So I, there's two people and a monkey in a covered
- 52:09space. So I said quietly. So even though this
- 52:15is actually a case, this is actually, what I
- 52:17understand is this is the opening to Katy Perry's
- 52:19roar as well. Who knew? So here's another actual
- 52:24court case, probably a list that you'll see or
- 52:26things that you saw earlier and you'll see in
- 52:27the materials. This is a divorce case where two
- 52:30parents are talking about the divorce through
- 52:33emojis. And this is what you see. There's no
- 52:35words here. It's just pictures. So you have this
- 52:38little stockbroker line. You have this money
- 52:40with wings, question mark and hourglass and lady
- 52:43going, eh. So what does that mean? Why are they
- 52:47talking like this? What are they hiding from
- 52:49us that we can't see as practitioners? Money's
- 52:53low. Where's your share? You're late again. Just
- 52:56say that we're adults and I have to reinterpret
- 52:58this. Don't talk in pictures. Say that. Because
- 53:01parent two responds with this clipboard, this
- 53:04muscle arm, graduation cap, a check mark, rolling
- 53:07eyes, a scroll and rolling eyes again. I covered
- 53:13meds, doctor and school. Stop acting like I do
- 53:15nothing. Again, nothing we can't read. Nothing
- 53:18that's going to be harmful to anybody in court.
- 53:21Parent one responds with the scroll, exclamation
- 53:24point. Alarm clock. Turtle. A girl with a broken
- 53:28heart. It's okay. I think a girl's broken heart.
- 53:30I can figure that one out. Or can I? We had an
- 53:34agreement. You're always behind. She's the one
- 53:36hurt. Again, nothing we can't read. Parental
- 53:41response with this non -emotion face. Brain.
- 53:45This magnet. Legal scales. Two people. Money.
- 53:48And a coin. So we know the laws involved maybe,
- 53:51right? I don't know. I think it's rude. Try to
- 53:55be fair. Stop making it all about money. So,
- 53:59when I do this class in person, it's fun to be
- 54:00able to see the room kind of split up by generations,
- 54:04because a lot of the younger people will actually
- 54:05get these, or they'll understand them, and some
- 54:07won't. But that's okay. We have resources out
- 54:11there, one's called Emojipedia .com, that you
- 54:15can actually go back and look at these emojis
- 54:17and see what they actually mean. For a lot of
- 54:20practitioners, I tell you, because most of you
- 54:21are probably using AI already, like a chat GPT
- 54:24or Claude or whatever, You can put these in there
- 54:28and try to see what it actually says. However,
- 54:32you have to put the context, the age, the device,
- 54:37the culture, all the background in there, and
- 54:40then the emojis, and they'll give you a probability
- 54:42of what it actually says. Otherwise, you're gonna
- 54:44have to hire an expert to come in and say, this
- 54:46is what it actually says, or just tell them to
- 54:48quit talking in emojis, one of the two. But then
- 54:52there's this whole tech slang issue. What are
- 54:54people trying to say? There was a study done
- 54:57last year, some of you may have seen this, down
- 54:59in South Florida, where it took a bunch of graduating
- 55:02seniors from high school, like 1700 children,
- 55:05to say, hey, I want you to write a letter to
- 55:06your future self. So when they got these letters
- 55:10back, less than 1 % actually had some type of
- 55:14text language inside the letter. The BFFs, the
- 55:17LOLs, nobody could write a letter, a complete
- 55:19letter without putting text lying into it. So
- 55:22what's this stuff mean? What are kids saying
- 55:24behind our back? Or what are people saying that
- 55:25we don't know? AF. Well, once you figure that
- 55:30one out, this presentation is good AF or maybe
- 55:32not. A mood basically means it's a feeling of
- 55:37situation. ASL. Pay attention to ASL quite a
- 55:42bit. If you have children or you've worked with
- 55:44children or you're seeing writings between children.
- 55:48In the human trafficking world, there's a lot
- 55:50of buzzwords out there. And one of the common
- 55:52ones we see is carne fresca. Carni fresca means
- 55:56fresh meat, which means that the person is gonna
- 55:58be under the age of 18. They're gonna be a child.
- 56:01Well, people kind of got on to that, that we
- 56:03were looking for buzzwords like that. So they
- 56:05started basically making it simple. So now if
- 56:07you're on like a chat, a DM, you know, AMI TV,
- 56:11chat roulette, whatever it may be, a lot of times
- 56:14the very first question or first three questions
- 56:16is gonna be ASL, age, sex, location. They want
- 56:20to know where you are, which door and how old
- 56:22you are. Ate that. We ain't talking about the
- 56:25buffet. We're talking about you pulled it off.
- 56:28You actually did something amazing. Your aura.
- 56:32Aura basically is how cool you are. Or not. Your
- 56:36bae. Your boo. That's your crush. That's your
- 56:38person. Basic. You don't want to be basic. It
- 56:42means you're boring. You're just a conforming
- 56:43person. You're boring. Bet. Again, we're not
- 56:46talking about the horse track. We're talking
- 56:48about an affirmation. You want to get a store?
- 56:50Bet. You want to do something? Bet. Beta. Don't
- 56:55want to be a beta either. Beta basically means
- 56:57you're soft. You're just the opposite of an alpha.
- 56:59You're just a weak person. Bestie. Okay, we probably
- 57:03get that one. It's our best friend. Glazing.
- 57:06I see this a lot and a lot of parents are guilty
- 57:09of glazing. And you'll hear this, you know, quit
- 57:11glazing that kid. You're like, what are you talking
- 57:13about? It basically means you're over praising.
- 57:18A couple more. Body count. We're not talking
- 57:21about a drive -by here. We're talking about what
- 57:23you've been doing. Bruh. Bruh, believe it or
- 57:27not, is not gender specific. Girls use it, boys
- 57:29use it, everybody uses it, bro. That's just basically
- 57:31the dressing body. What's up, bro? Bustin'. Bustin'
- 57:36actually is good. It means these tacos are bustin'.
- 57:38These are great, these are awesome. Cake. Couple
- 57:42years ago, there was a song called Cake by the
- 57:44Ocean. That's right, it's your butt, it's your
- 57:46booty. You donka donk. Cappin'. Cappin' missing
- 57:50means you lying. You just lying. Crashing out.
- 57:55You're out of control. You're throwing temper
- 57:57tantrum, you're just out of control, losing your
- 57:58mind. Cringe. I've also heard crunchy, depending
- 58:02on how old the person is. You're cringy or crunchy.
- 58:05Basically means you're awkward, you're embarrassment.
- 58:08Daddy. Oh, how'd that get there? Sorry. Attractive
- 58:13man, usually older, base power. Somebody say,
- 58:16that's cringy. I get that. IRL. In real life.
- 58:22Dope. We're not talking about smoking, nothing.
- 58:24We're talking about how cool or awesome. And
- 58:26then of course your drip. Drip is your fashion
- 58:29sense. So what are some implications for professionals
- 58:33like yourselves? Well, the biggest one as you
- 58:35saw there was misinterpretation. You know, if
- 58:38we don't understand the cultural, the device,
- 58:40the context, whatever, we can very easily misinterpret
- 58:44these and or overlook them. Also is the hidden
- 58:48harassment and manipulation. Are they talking
- 58:50bad about each other, talking bad about us? We
- 58:52don't know. Evidence evaluation. Again, you may
- 58:56have to hire an expert in some of these cases.
- 58:59I know we're at time. All in all, we did a lot
- 59:01of information in an hour, but you have to get
- 59:03comfortable with technology. Technology is ever
- 59:05-changing. There's amazing resources out there,
- 59:07and we are one of them. RFM Wizard is an amazing
- 59:10company that cares about educating practitioners
- 59:12like yourselves, just as much as the product.
- 59:14Feel free to reach out. If you want to connect
- 59:16to LinkedIn, we can do that. There's my email
- 59:17there. My coworker, Julie Saunders is down there
- 59:21as well. Reach out and see what we can do to
- 59:23help. Now, if I can reduce some of these questions
- 59:26we have down here. So once the person is asking
- 59:38about a checklist, and yes, I will make sure
- 59:39to include a checklist that I put together based
- 59:42on the information that you saw and plus some
- 59:44more, that you can sit down with your clients
- 59:46upon intake or at any point, or your family and
- 59:49loved ones as well, and go through the checklist
- 59:51and say, hey, this is actually, how can we stay
- 59:54safe? Another one is, how can you document these
- 59:57various criminal acts for the courts? Judges
- 59:59have no clue about these high tech stalking and
- 1:00:01harassment. I would love to get in front of any
- 1:00:03judges you have, if you have a connection there,
- 1:00:05because I agree. A lot of judges, one, need to
- 1:00:08either age off the bench or they just don't understand
- 1:00:10technology. But it's about having the conversations,
- 1:00:13about documenting the information. And I'd be
- 1:00:15happy to talk to you about metadata. There's
- 1:00:18so much stuff we haven't talked about, we couldn't
- 1:00:20talk about. But feel free to reach out to me.
- 1:00:22It's my email address there for specifics and
- 1:00:24I can help you navigate that. Mesh cycles are
- 1:00:29not gross. I agree they're not gross, but it's
- 1:00:31something we have to talk about. So thank you
- 1:00:34all for having me. I know we're at time. Thank
- 1:00:35you for giving up your morning for this. Again,
- 1:00:39thank you for having us. And if you have any
- 1:00:40questions, please reach out. Perfect. Thank you
- 1:00:44so much, guys. You guys take care.