Latest / Friendship, Actually: Modern Friendship & Real Life / Why Shared Pain Isn’t Enough: Building Friendships on Joy | Friendship, Actually
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of exhaustion that comes from realizing you only have one person to call when you’re falling apart, and no one to call when you’re actually happy. Let’s be real for a second—we’ve all been sold the idea that trauma bonds are the strongest glue, but what happens when the pain fades and there’s nothing left holding you together? I want you to think about the last time you felt truly seen by a friend. Was it during a crisis? Maybe you were going through a messy divorce, or your dad was sick, or you’d just had a panic attack in a Target parking lot at midnight. You called her, she answered, and for those three hours, you were the most important people in each other’s lives. It feels electric, doesn’t it? It feels like intimacy. But here’s the thing I learned the hard way, after burning through half my twenties trying to bond over our worst days: trauma is a terrible foundation for a house. It’s a very sturdy shelter for the storm, sure. But once the rain stops, you still have to live in the structure. And if the only bricks you used were grief, resentment, and shared suffering, you might find yourself standing in a dark room with someone who knows exactly how to hurt you, but has no idea how to make you laugh. I’m not saying trauma bonding isn’t real. It’s visceral. It’s powerful. When two people share a deep wound, they bypass small talk. They skip the polite dance of getting-to-know-you and go straight to the marrow. It creates a sense of urgency that can feel like love. But urgency is not longevity. So, what did we learn from that realization? We learned that while shared pain connects us, shared joy sustains us. And lately, I’ve been noticing a quiet ache in my own circle. The friends I bonded with during my biggest breakdowns are still around, but sometimes, when things are calm, we run out of things to say. The silence isn’t comfortable; it’s heavy. And that’s not a failure of character. That’s a structural issue. Let’s unpack this for a minute, because it’s uncomfortable. When the emergency passes, the adrenaline leaves the body. You don’t need the crisis counselor anymore. You need a brunch buddy. You need someone to point out how ridiculous your coworker’s new haircut is. You need someone who can help you choose a paint color for your bathroom without crying in the corner. If your friendship was built exclusively on the scaffolding of survival, you might find yourselves stranded on that scaffolding long after the building is finished. I saw this play out with my friend Sarah last year. She and Jen met when they were both navigating their parents’ separations. They spent six months talking every night about custody schedules, therapy bills, and the guilt of wanting to escape family obligations. It was intense. It was deep. It felt like the most important work either of them had ever done. But then, life stabilized. Jen got promoted. Sarah adopted a dog. The crises subsided. And suddenly, they didn’t know how to talk to each other except as therapists to patients. The dynamic shifted from equals in struggle to caretaker and cared-for. It wasn’t fair to either of them. Sarah felt patronized, and Jen felt drained. They weren’t friends anymore; they were case managers. And that’s the trap. We mistake intensity for connection. We confuse the relief of being heard with the reality of being known. Being heard is easy when you’re screaming. Being known requires listening to the quiet parts, too. And often, the quiet parts are boring. They’re mundane. They’re about what movie to watch or what to make for dinner. And if we haven’t practiced showing up for those moments, the friendship feels hollow. There’s a cultural narrative that suggests our deepest connections must be forged in fire. We see it in movies all the time. The protagonists survive a war, a plague, or a heist gone wrong, and they emerge forever bound by blood. It’s dramatic. It’s compelling. But real life isn’t a movie. Real life is Tuesday nights. Real life is waiting in line at the DMV. Real life is figuring out why the Wi-Fi keeps dropping. These moments aren’t glamorous. They don’t produce great stories for social media. But they are where trust is actually built. Trust isn’t just knowing someone will stay when you’re broken. It’s knowing they won’t roll their eyes when you’re being difficult. It’s knowing they’ll sit with you in boredom without checking their phone. I remember when I first moved to this city, I thought I needed to find my tribe among people who had also lost jobs or gone through breakups. I wanted that instant shorthand. But those friendships fizzled out faster than I expected. Why? Because once the sympathy faded, there was no common language left. We had nothing in common except our scars. Now, I look for connection in shared interests, shared values, and yes, shared joy. I look for the friend who wants to try that weird new sushi place even though she’s afraid of eels. I look for the friend who sends me memes about garden gnomes at 2 PM. These seem small, trivial even. But they are signals. They are data points that say, 'I am present with you in the ordinary.' They say, 'I enjoy your company when there is no agenda.' And that is infinitely more sustainable than relying on disaster to keep the lines open. So, how do we build these newer, lighter, more resilient friendships? Or how do we deepen the ones we have that are stuck in the trauma loop? We have to court boredom together. This sounds counterintuitive, right? Who wants to court boredom? But hear me out. Intentionality is key here. We have to create spaces where the focus isn’t on fixing, healing, or analyzing. It’s just on existing. Think about the concept of 'third places'—not home, not work, but somewhere in between. A park bench. A coffee shop. A pottery class. These are environments where interaction is low-stakes. You don’t have to perform vulnerability. You just have to show up. When I started taking a weekly watercolor class, I didn’t go looking for a soulmate. I went because I wanted to learn to mix blue. But over three months, I sat next to a woman named Mara who hated watercolors too. We spent twenty minutes complaining about the bristles shedding, then ten minutes laughing about how we looked like toddlers painting. We never talked about our exes. We never talked about our fears. We talked about pigment viscosity and whether the studio radiator was broken. And somehow, that became the bedrock of our friendship. Because when I told her I was stressed about a project later, she didn’t treat me like a victim. She treated me like a partner. She asked, 'What’s the plan?' instead of 'Oh honey, that’s terrible.' There’s a difference. One isolates you in your pain. The other empowers you to move through it. We need friends who can handle our joy as much as our sorrow. Because joy is fragile, too. It needs protection. It needs celebration. And if your friend only knows how to catch you when you fall, they might miss the chance to cheer when you fly. This doesn’t mean you have to cut off your trauma-bonded friends. Life is messy, and some of the people who held you up during the storm deserve your gratitude. But it does mean we need to diversify our portfolio of relationships. We cannot rely on one person to be everything. That’s an unfair burden to place on any human being. We need a village, not a single crutch. Some friends are for the deep dives. Some are for the adventures. Some are for the quiet companionship. And that’s okay. It’s healthy. In fact, it’s necessary. I’ve started asking myself a simple question whenever I feel a dip in a friendship: 'Do we have anything else besides this problem?' If the answer is no, I start planting seeds elsewhere. I invite them to do something active. Something that requires engagement but not emotional processing. Hiking. Bowling. Volunteering at an animal shelter. Sometimes, the act of doing something side-by-side unlocks a new layer of connection. You stop being the patient and the doctor. You become co-pilots. And that shift changes everything. It allows for humor. It allows for lightness. It allows the friendship to breathe. We have to give ourselves permission to seek out joy as a primary currency in our relationships. Not as a distraction from pain, but as a reason to connect. Because ultimately, we spend most of our lives in the middle. Not in crisis. Not in euphoria. Just... living. And we deserve friends who are excited to live it with us, not just survive it. So, here is your invitation for this week. I want you to look at your closest friend. The one you talk to most. Is the conversation mostly heavy? Are you venting? Are you analyzing? If so, try something different. Next time you meet, set a boundary. Say, 'No complaining allowed for the first hour.' Force yourselves to talk about something light. Talk about a dream. Talk about a silly thing you saw online. Talk about food. Watch what happens. You might feel awkward at first. You might feel like you’re avoiding the real stuff. But in that avoidance, you might find a rediscovery of who you are outside of your struggles. You might remember that you are capable of pleasure. That you are interesting. That you are fun. And if you’re feeling lonely right now, don’t just reach out to the people who know your pain. Reach out to the people who know your potential. Find the friend who believes in your happiness. Because happiness is a practice. It’s a muscle. And it grows stronger when we exercise it together. We are not just survivors. We are creators. We are builders. And we deserve friendships that reflect that fullness. Not just the cracks, but the whole picture. So let’s stop romanticizing the struggle. Let’s start celebrating the stability. Let’s build friendships that are not just safe harbors, but launchpads. Because you deserve more than just someone to hold you through the dark. You deserve someone to walk with you into the light. And that starts with choosing joy, intentionally, repeatedly, and bravely. Thank you for letting me into your day. I’m Elise Blackwell, and I’ll be right here next week, ready to listen. Take care of yourself, and remember: joy is a valid reason to connect. Bye for now.