Latest / Fintech Conversations with Fexingo: Banking, Payments, and Financial Software Companies / How Square and Toast Won Restaurant Payments
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's a stat that's been rattling around my head since I read it last week: Square now processes over a hundred billion dollars in annualized payment volume from food and beverage merchants alone. That's roughly one out of every six dollars spent eating out in the United States. Luna: And yet at the same time, Toast has become the default operating system for full-service independent restaurants. How do those two stories live in the same market? Lucas: That's exactly the question. Both companies are in the same broad category — restaurant point of sale — but they took fundamentally different paths. Square started as a tiny white dongle that plugged into a headphone jack. It was the most generic payment-acceptance device imaginable. Toast, by contrast, launched in 2011 with a full restaurant-specific tablet that included a kitchen display system and a server-facing interface. Luna: Right — Square was horizontal, Toast was vertical from day one. Lucas: Exactly. And that vertical bet created what we in fintech call a switching-cost moat. If you're a restaurant owner and you've trained your staff on Toast's kitchen screen, your expo line is color-coded by Toast's ticket management, and your inventory system talks to Toast's procurement module — ripping that out to switch to a generic terminal would be chaos. Square can offer a lower processing rate, but the cost of migration is psychological and operational, not just financial. Luna: So let's get specific on the numbers. What are we actually looking at in terms of market share? Lucas: Toast has roughly 40 percent of the full-service, independent restaurant POS market in the U.S. Square has maybe 15 percent of that same segment, but it has a much bigger share of quick-service and pop-up merchants — food trucks, coffee kiosks, bakeries. Square's total food and beverage volume is larger because it captures the very small merchants that Toast doesn't go after. Toast's average merchant does about eight hundred thousand dollars in annual card volume. Square's food and beverage average is closer to two hundred and fifty thousand. Luna: So Square wins on volume, Toast wins on wallet depth per merchant. That's a classic horizontal versus vertical trade-off. Lucas: And it's playing out in real time right now. In the last twelve months, Square has added a dedicated loyalty program for restaurants — points-based, not just punch cards — and it launched Square Payroll integrated with shift scheduling. Those are direct shots at Toast's value proposition. Toast, meanwhile, has been pushing into what it calls 'enterprise grade' features for multi-location groups. They just signed a deal with a sixty-unit regional chain in the Southeast. Luna: This is where I think we have to talk about the hardware. Because the actual devices in the restaurant are very different. Lucas: Completely. Square's newer terminal is a sleek all-in-one device — it runs Android, it has a built-in printer, it can take tap and pay. It looks like something designed by Apple. But it's a general-purpose device. You can run a coffee shop on it, or a retail boutique, or a food truck. Toast's hardware is uglier. It's a dedicated restaurant terminal with a separate kitchen display that's often mounted on a stainless steel rack. The kitchen screen is splash-proof, heat-resistant, and it shows orders in a specific format that line cooks are trained to read. That hardware is a moat. Luna: It reminds me of the argument people make about point of sale in hospitality generally. If your line cook can't read the screen, you lose tables per hour. That's real money. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why I think the next battleground isn't just payments — it's the software layer around the kitchen. Toast has a feature called 'Toast Now' that lets managers see real-time sales data and adjust staffing on the fly. Square is building something analogous with Square for Restaurants Dashboard. But both companies are trying to own the relationship between the front of house and the back of house. And there's a third player nobody talks about. Luna: Who? Lucas: Clover — which is owned by Fiserv. Clover has a huge installed base in independent restaurants because Fiserv is one of the largest merchant acquirers in the country. A lot of restaurants ended up with Clover because their bank recommended it. Clover's hardware is also Android-based, it's very similar to Square's terminal, and they've been quietly adding restaurant-specific features. The thing is, Clover doesn't have the developer ecosystem that Square has, and it doesn't have the vertical depth that Toast has. It's stuck in the middle. Luna: So what does that mean for a restaurant owner choosing a system in 2026? Is there a clear winner? Lucas: I think the honest answer is: it depends on the type of restaurant and the owner's ambition. If you're opening a single food truck and you want to start taking cards tomorrow, Square is the fastest, cheapest option. If you're opening a sit-down restaurant with a full bar and you plan to have a staff of twenty, Toast is probably the better bet because the training and the operational workflow is purpose-built. But here's the twist — Square is making a big push into what it calls 'Square for Restaurants Complete,' which bundles hardware, software, and payment processing into one monthly fee. That's very attractive to a first-time restaurateur who doesn't want to deal with three different vendors. Luna: It's interesting that both companies are now essentially selling a managed service rather than just a terminal and a processing rate. That's a huge shift from five years ago. Lucas: Huge shift. And it matters because the actual processing margin is getting thinner. The interchange fees on credit cards are regulated, and the spread that Square and Toast can charge has come down as competition has increased. Five years ago, Square's blended take rate on card-present transactions was around 2.75 percent. Today it's closer to 2.6 percent. Those fifteen basis points matter when you're processing a hundred billion dollars a year. That's a hundred and fifty million dollars in lost revenue, which they have to make up through software subscriptions, hardware sales, and value-added services like lending. Luna: And Toast's model is different — they actually charge a higher processing rate upfront, but they bundle in the software. Their average effective rate is around 2.9 percent, but they don't charge a separate subscription for the core POS. So the merchant sees one number. Lucas: Which is a classic bundling strategy. You hide the software cost in the processing fee, which makes the sticker price look simpler. Square unbundles — they show a 2.6 percent processing fee plus a monthly software fee of sixty dollars for the restaurant plan. On a hundred thousand dollars in monthly card volume, Square's total cost to the merchant is about two thousand nine hundred sixty dollars. Toast would be about two thousand nine hundred dollars. It's basically a wash at that volume, but the psychology is different. Luna: So the battle is shifting to features that drive revenue for the restaurant, not just cost savings. Things like online ordering, loyalty, and marketing automation. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where things get really interesting. Square launched a feature called 'Square Marketing' for restaurants that lets you send automated email campaigns to loyalty members based on visit frequency. Toast has a similar product called 'Toast Marketing Pro.' Both are trying to prove that their system can increase the restaurant's top line, not just process its bottom line. If you can show an independent pizzeria that your system drives a 5 percent lift in repeat visits, that's worth more than a 0.15 percent lower processing fee. Luna: That kind of data-driven argument is hard to beat. But it also requires the restaurant to actually use the tools, which is a classic adoption problem. Lucas: Right. And that's why both companies are investing heavily in onboarding and support. Toast actually has a team of 'restaurant success managers' who visit the physical location and train the staff. Square has a similar program but it's less hands-on. That physical presence is expensive, but it builds loyalty. Luna: It also creates a human relationship that's harder to sever than a software contract. Lucas: Speaking of loyalty — and I realize this is a bit of a tangent, but it connects — a lot of these conversations we have on the show are possible because our listeners believe in the value of independent, ad-free content. These episodes take time to research, and a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going. If you've gotten something out of the show, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It makes a real difference. Luna: Absolutely. It keeps us independent and focused on the details that matter. Lucas: So back to the restaurant wars. The next frontier I'm watching is online ordering. Square acquired a company called Onosys a few years ago, which powers online ordering for multi-location restaurants. Toast has its own native online ordering platform. But now you have DoorDash and Uber Eats building their own white-label ordering systems for restaurants, trying to disintermediate the POS entirely. That's a big threat. Luna: Because if the order comes through DoorDash's system, DoorDash can dictate the terms — the commission, the customer data, the upsell offers. The POS becomes just a pass-through. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why Square and Toast are both trying to make their own online ordering platforms sticky. Square offers commission-free online ordering if the customer uses Square Online. Toast does the same. The idea is to own the relationship with the customer even when they're not in the restaurant. That's a long game, and it's not clear who wins yet. Luna: One more thing — I've been hearing about a new entrant from the grocery space. Instacart has been testing a restaurant ordering feature that integrates with point of sale systems. Could they be a factor? Lucas: Potentially. Instacart has the delivery logistics and the customer base, but they don't have the POS integration. They'd likely need to partner with someone like Square or Toast, which gives those companies leverage. I think the more interesting threat is actually from the big processors — like Fiserv and FIS — who have deep merchant relationships and are starting to build their own restaurant-specific software. But that's a topic for another episode. Luna: Agreed. For now, it feels like Square and Toast are in a two-horse race, and the horse that wins will be the one that makes restaurants more money, not just saves them money on processing. Lucas: That's the soundest bet I've heard all day. And on that note, we'll leave it for our listeners to decide which system their local spot uses — and whether it matters to their dining experience.