Latest / Sobering Stories / American IDOL To American INMATE
Transcript
- 0:00My name is Caleb Flynn. I'm from Tipp City.
- 0:02OH please. Please please please.
- 0:06I auditioned because I'm sure everybody says it, but music is
- 0:08all I know. It's what I live to do and I
- 0:11love to sing. What are you?
- 0:12Singing my wife is she got two shots to her head.
- 0:17Maybe my wife kind of nudge me a little bit too.
- 0:23My first thought when I got my golden ticket, Honestly all I
- 0:26could do was cover my face because I cried a little bit.
- 0:34I'm. Kind of a crybaby.
- 0:40I get it from my mom and my dad. I mean, he's just been bawling
- 0:43his eyes out, vomiting in the trash can that's in there.
- 0:46But it was honestly just pure joy, excitement.
- 0:55I tried out for American Idol two or three years ago and I
- 0:58didn't make it. Are there?
- 1:01Any other signs or anything? And so to get this was all the
- 1:06more sweeter and all the more meaningful.
- 1:09So it was awesome. There was a fridge in front of
- 1:11it, like on the inside of the garage and it's like someone
- 1:15pushed the fridge to open the door and it's still open.
- 1:20Thing that makes me unique, you know, I absolutely love the
- 1:23Lord. I love my wife more than
- 1:25anything. She is very, very pretty.
- 1:31Just I love her. Ashley's dead.
- 1:34She's dead. I'm just a normal person who
- 1:38absolutely loves to sing more than anything in the world.
- 1:43All right, step forward. What's that for me, Sir?
- 1:50We're not going to discuss that here.
- 1:51I'm the next American Idol because, you know, I can
- 1:55honestly say one thing about me is I love to learn.
- 1:58Mr. Flynn, I do have several charges here.
- 2:01And so if the judge is telling me this is what's going to help,
- 2:03I'm going to do it. Count 1.
- 2:05Is a murder charge is a count to felony of the first degree?
- 2:12And I work harder than anybody I know.
- 2:13And so when I want something, I'm going to go after it you.
- 2:16Understand all that? Yes, Sir.
- 2:19OK. Thank you.
- 2:21We're adjourned. Sup Sobers.
- 2:32It's very pacifically. 2:31 AM Police dispatch receives a phone
- 2:37call from what sounds like a woman, but it's actually a man.
- 2:42Hey ma'am, I need you to take a. Deep breath, OK?
- 2:45Very shaky voice lets the dispatcher know that he found
- 2:49his wife. Double tapped.
- 2:55He says that he has no idea if the person is still in the
- 2:57house. The garage door is wide open.
- 3:00He has two daughters in the house.
- 3:03We've got a situation on our hands.
- 3:05This caller on the phone is Caleb Flynn, former American
- 3:08Idol contestant, gold ticket winner, proud husband and father
- 3:12of two, worship pastor. And by the morning, instead of
- 3:16looking for some mysterious breaker and enterer, they're
- 3:20going to be looking right at Caleb himself.
- 3:22Let's go. All right, welcome back to
- 3:42Sobering Stories with your boy DJ Petrovsky.
- 3:45Please hit the like button. Push this bad boy out as far as
- 3:48we can. Subscribe to the channel Hype
- 3:51this video up. Share it with 50 to 60 of your
- 3:54closest friends and family members.
- 3:56Bro sobering. Stories are straight up tough.
- 3:57These stories are mugging my whole mindset.
- 3:59No cap. This channel is fire.
- 4:00I'm dropping a like and sub right now.
- 4:01For real. This is peak content.
- 4:03I'm sharing this with the whole squad.
- 4:04And let's everybody just tag American Idol in the comments
- 4:07and see what happens. Yo, let's get this to blow up.
- 4:09Subscribe, like and share. Let's go.
- 4:11Caleb Flynn was a 40 year old Ohio resident.
- 4:14He's best known for his 2013 audition for season 12 of
- 4:19American Idol. He ended up getting a golden
- 4:21ticket and made his way to Hollywood.
- 4:24My first thought when I got my golden ticket, honestly, all I
- 4:27could do was cover my face because I cried a little bit.
- 4:30I'm kind of a crybaby. I get it from my mom and my dad,
- 4:33but it was honestly just pure joy, excitement.
- 4:36I tried out for American Idol two or three years ago and I
- 4:39didn't make it. And so to get this was all the
- 4:41more sweeter and all the more meaningful.
- 4:43So it was. Awesome.
- 4:44But he didn't make it past the first week he got cut.
- 4:48He really didn't get any live on camera time.
- 4:51But in his audition, he does talk about his faith, loving his
- 4:55family, especially his wife Ashley.
- 4:59And he talks about how his voice, he just feels like he has
- 5:02a different sound in his voice. I'm just a normal person who
- 5:06absolutely loves to sing more than anything in the world and I
- 5:09I think I have a different sound in my voice.
- 5:10I have something to offer. Caleb's faith was not just a
- 5:13talking point for the show. He was actually a worship pastor
- 5:17at a church called Free Chapel in South Carolina.
- 5:20Then he would move on to a church called Christian Life
- 5:23Center in Dayton, OH. He would eventually move on from
- 5:27being a worship pastor, and he would work for Ashley's family
- 5:30business as the VP of sales. This company is called Richard D
- 5:35Smith and Son. It's a commercial flooring and
- 5:39worship seating company, which I guess I never thought about
- 5:42that. Somebody's got to make those
- 5:43benches. Him and Ashley met at a
- 5:45Christian university in Tennessee called Lee University.
- 5:49They were married for like 15 years at this point, two kids,
- 5:53totally normal Christian family. On paper, they're about as clean
- 5:57cut as it gets, seemingly living the American Dream.
- 6:01More importantly, Ashley Flynn was a Tip City, Ohio native
- 6:05through and through. She was born February 24th, 1988
- 6:09and she went to Tippecanoe High School in 2006.
- 6:13Then like I said before, she went to Lee University,
- 6:16graduating in 2010. Same year, same school,
- 6:19everything, same as Caleb. She worked as a substitute
- 6:22teacher for Tip City Schools. She taught Bible classes through
- 6:27Life Wise Academy and she was a 7th grade volleyball coach at
- 6:31Tippecanoe Middle School, so she was very involved with the
- 6:34community and her players remember her for baking them
- 6:37chocolate chip cookies. And she was very active at the
- 6:40Christian Life Center, which is the same church that Caleb
- 6:43worked at. The two of them shared 2
- 6:45beautiful daughters. They were 9 and 12 years old,
- 6:49and thankfully neither one of them was hurt in this breaking
- 6:52and entering incident. Surprisingly, neither one of
- 6:55them woke up either. I'm gonna.
- 6:57Stay on the porch. In case the girls with him OK
- 6:59stay. Right.
- 6:59Yep, Yep. According to Caleb, what he says
- 7:02happened that night, what he tells police, is that his wife
- 7:06told him to sleep on the couch in the living room because he
- 7:09had a really bad cough. So he wasn't in his normal
- 7:13bedroom, in the master bedroom, and at some point sleeping on
- 7:16the couch. His two dogs, they're cute
- 7:19little labradoodles. They woke him up.
- 7:21One of the girls was sick and so he figured maybe one of the
- 7:24girls had gotten up, so he went back to check on him.
- 7:27He goes back, the girls seem fine.
- 7:29He lays down with him for a little while until something
- 7:33wakes him up. He goes out to see what happened
- 7:35and he says that he finds Ashley in the master bedroom.
- 7:39Double tapped. She.
- 7:40She. Sent me out.
- 7:43Here. OK, Yeah.
- 7:46I. Heard dogs shake.
- 7:49Her move her collar. Yeah.
- 7:50And it woke me up and both my girls were sick.
- 7:53Yeah, my mother was one of them that got up, so I went to.
- 7:58Their room and. I lay down with them for I don't
- 8:05need to know. How long?
- 8:07Yeah. That's what I heard it.
- 8:09OK. He notes that the door to the
- 8:11garage was open and he has no idea if there's still somebody
- 8:15in the house. He has no idea what happened.
- 8:17All they know is that there's 2 shell casings at the foot of the
- 8:20bed and unfortunately Ashley is gone.
- 8:23Interestingly enough, both girls and both dogs were asleep when
- 8:29he went and found Ashley slept right through this double tap.
- 8:32The story is heavily reliant on the layout of the house to
- 8:36really make sense in my opinion, and the courts feel the same way
- 8:40because they're actually fighting and delaying the trial
- 8:43so that the jurors can go visit the house.
- 8:46And that's because they want to see like, what's the reality of
- 8:49this? What's the likelihood that 2
- 8:51girls could be asleep with a 9mm going off?
- 8:55It's a single story, single family home with a three car
- 9:00garage. For some reason, even though
- 9:02there's only three bedrooms and two bathrooms, the plan looks a
- 9:05little bit like this. As you go in, there's two
- 9:08bedrooms off to the right and then the master bedroom is off
- 9:11to the left behind the garage and kitchen and all this.
- 9:14And we can see a little bit of it in the body Cam.
- 9:17But based on where he points when he's referring to the
- 9:20girls, when he goes to check on him, he points to the back of
- 9:23the house. That's the opposite side of
- 9:25where Ashley was found. So that definitely gives some
- 9:28credibility to the fact that the noise may not have carried that
- 9:31far. I still doubt it because it's a
- 9:34pretty loud noise, especially for two kids to sleep through
- 9:38and two dogs especially. Now allegedly this intruder came
- 9:41in through the side door of the garage.
- 9:44What really complicates that theory is that there's a giant
- 9:47refrigerator blocking that door, so they would have had to move
- 9:50the refrigerator by like pushing the door extremely hard.
- 9:54Probably pretty loud. I couldn't find it the first
- 9:57time. Well, that that the back that
- 9:59back the side door is what's open.
- 10:01It's open. Still it is.
- 10:03It there was a fridge in front of it, it's like on the inside
- 10:06of the garage and it's like someone pushed the fridge to
- 10:10open the door and it's still open.
- 10:13They go in through the garage and maybe they look right, maybe
- 10:17they look left, but just to the right of this garage entrance is
- 10:22where Caleb was sleeping on the couch.
- 10:24The intruder then made a left into the master bedroom.
- 10:27Didn't steal anything, didn't take anything, seemingly just a
- 10:32double tap hit and then this intruder was out before anybody
- 10:36noticed anything. Police also noticed inside the
- 10:39garage that the truck is open and the center console of the
- 10:43truck is open. That door is open over there
- 10:46back. That back door is open.
- 10:55Is that laid outside because I can't see.
- 10:58Is that a closet? OK, it is.
- 11:15Should we have him? OK, look at this.
- 11:20Watch out. Oh, no, it's paint.
- 11:26Do you see any blood on the long to cook at all?
- 11:34Hey, someone watching him. Somebody needs to be watching
- 11:39him. They ask if he has any gummy
- 11:46bears in the house. He lists off 3 different ones
- 11:49that he has and he says that one of them, 9 mil, is kept in the
- 11:53center console of his truck. The shell casings found matched
- 11:57the 9mm. Somehow the intruder managed to
- 12:00open up the truck, find this 9 mil with no issues, make their
- 12:04way into the house, not steal anything at all, not worry about
- 12:09any other people in the house. Just went in and for whatever
- 12:13reason targeted Ashley. And then maybe because they were
- 12:17so freaked out about what they just did, they had to get out of
- 12:20there quick before anybody knew what was going on.
- 12:22Allegedly, Caleb heard this noise and that's what woke him
- 12:26up, and that's why he ended up going back to check on Ashley.
- 12:29So we really don't know how this intruder got out so fast without
- 12:34being seen. We also have to take note that
- 12:37by Caleb's own admission, he was up and moving around throughout
- 12:41the night. His story is that he just went
- 12:43to check on the girls, but he's already positioned himself in
- 12:47the living room. He's already admitted to being
- 12:50up and moving around during the evening, and there's no evidence
- 12:54of an intruder whatsoever outside of this garage door
- 12:58being open and the center console of the truck being open.
- 13:02Which is also the only evidence we have of a burglary.
- 13:05And yet the only thing that was taken out was the 9 mil.
- 13:09So doesn't seem like anything was taken from.
- 13:12From you hearing. A gunshot.
- 13:14Did you see? Anybody just like exiting?
- 13:24It's scary. So you froze when I finally got
- 13:29off the door? Leave.
- 13:33The garage was open but I didn't see, but conveniently the nine
- 13:40mil was never found, still hasn't been located.
- 13:43It's also important to note that within this garage there was a
- 13:462016 Chrysler as well which was unopened.
- 13:50They didn't search this at all, they just went straight for the
- 13:52truck. And I will reiterate that this
- 13:55garage side door had a massive refrigerator in front of it.
- 13:59I can barely move a fridge when I'm like I got a good hold on
- 14:03it, let alone just using a door to push it out of the way.
- 14:06Caleb is then allowed to call his mom.
- 14:08He goes outside, mom shows up to grab the girls and take them to
- 14:12a safe place. Caleb is seen throwing up out
- 14:15front and he is just completely distraught.
- 14:18Now this is either extremely genuine and he's just losing it,
- 14:22or this is a pretty epic theatrical show.
- 14:27Obviously police think that he's just putting on a show because
- 14:3082 hours later they call him in saying they're going to do some
- 14:33more questioning. And even though his story seems
- 14:36to line up between his interrogation and his original
- 14:39statements, they decide that his story doesn't make much sense
- 14:43and there's too many red flags and they arrest him.
- 14:46I want you to take special note of how Caleb himself doesn't put
- 14:50up any fight, doesn't ask any questions, doesn't even seem
- 14:54surprised. His brother, however, is the
- 14:58only one asking on what evidence?
- 15:00Like, why are you guys arresting him?
- 15:07All right, Caleb. And then you just stand up and
- 15:12we'll replace something with us. All right, step forward.
- 15:16Which one? What's that?
- 15:18Turn on it. For me, Sir.
- 15:19We're we're not going to discuss that here.
- 15:21OK Put your hands together for me like Patrick call you.
- 15:24What's that Patrick call you now?
- 15:27I didn't know that he was calling me.
- 15:29So his lawyer supposed to be calling right now.
- 15:31OK, yeah, we'll get in touch with him.
- 15:33I'm, I'm, I'm being cordial. I'm being cooperative.
- 15:40You want to. Get my hug real quick.
- 15:42He's held on a $2,000,000 bail and he's being charged with
- 15:47aggravated murder. He's been indicted on 11 counts
- 15:51by a grand jury, one count of aggravated murder, 3 counts of
- 15:55murder, 2 counts of felonious assault, 3 counts of tampering
- 15:59with evidence, and two misdemeanor counts of
- 16:02intimidating a witness. I'm assuming that's for the
- 16:04kids. Not really sure.
- 16:06Obviously tampering with evidence traces back to staging
- 16:10a scene, the 9 mil never being found and lying to police,
- 16:15obstructing the investigation. Obviously aggravated murder
- 16:19because obvious reasons. But the three murder charges
- 16:24trip me up a little bit. But I guess in Ohio, probably in
- 16:27a lot of states, the prosecution will actually just charge
- 16:30multiple different counts, multiple different indictments,
- 16:33or, I don't know, multiple different felony versions of the
- 16:38same crime. That way, if the jury doesn't
- 16:40find him guilty on the aggravated murder, they could
- 16:43still find him guilty of one of the other murder charges.
- 16:46Now, at the arraignment, Caleb pled not guilty.
- 16:49Like I said, he was held on a $2,000,000 bond and his only
- 16:53argument to the judge for why he should be released on bond was
- 16:57he's not a flight risk and he just wants to be out to take
- 17:01care of his daughters. So the.
- 17:02Court will establish a bond and you have the right to tell me,
- 17:05hey, I'm not a flight risk, I am a flight risk or anything of
- 17:08that. Is there anything you would want
- 17:10to tell me about that? Sir, I I just want to take care
- 17:15of my. Daughters, I'm not a risk.
- 17:17I'm. I understand.
- 17:21OK, Well, the court is going to order a $2,000,000 blanket bond
- 17:26in this case covering all of your charges.
- 17:29Should you post bond in this case, the court will order that
- 17:33you be on pretrial services, electronically monitored house
- 17:36arrest. Now we have to assume that he's
- 17:39innocent until proven guilty. This one definitely makes that a
- 17:42little hard to do, that's for sure.
- 17:44But if he really cared about his daughters?
- 17:46If he really wanted to take care of his daughters, he wouldn't
- 17:49have left them without a mother, and he wouldn't have left them
- 17:51with permanent traumatic scars and left them without a father
- 17:55who's now in prison. He's waived his right to a
- 17:57speedy trial. And that's because his defense
- 18:00attorney is really concerned that they're rushing this
- 18:02investigation and they've got tunnel vision on Caleb.
- 18:06He just doesn't want there to be a wrongful conviction, and
- 18:09neither do we. But some of the things just
- 18:11don't make sense to me, to investigators, probably to
- 18:15potential jurors. But that detail from the top,
- 18:18right off the bat, he says that his wife was double tapped.
- 18:24How does he know that, especially if he didn't hear any
- 18:27of the things going off? Also, we're supposed to believe
- 18:31that this intruder saw a man laying on the couch sleeping and
- 18:36decided that he was going to bypass that and leave the risk
- 18:39of this guy waking up and possibly freaking out on him
- 18:43just totally fine? And he went back to the bedroom
- 18:46and took out the less threatening of the individuals
- 18:48there? I don't know.
- 18:49How does he know that she wasn't?
- 18:51How does he know that there wasn't some other type of
- 18:54utensil involved to take her out?
- 18:56How does he know she was double tapped?
- 18:58Now it is worth noting that Ashley's family believes that
- 19:01Caleb did this and the main reason they cite is a life
- 19:05insurance policy, which Caleb is the beneficiary of.
- 19:09Could be a motive. At this point, we don't really
- 19:11have a motive, but there is speculation that there was a
- 19:15mistress involved, someone who worked at the church that he was
- 19:18at. This young lady's name is
- 19:20Aaliyah Botner. She's a fellow worship leader at
- 19:23the Christian Life Center, where Caleb was a worship pastor.
- 19:27She resigned from her position very shortly after Caleb's
- 19:31arrest. I want to thank you, our church
- 19:33family, for the prayers, support, and love that you've
- 19:36shared with me and our staff. We are deeply grateful to rely
- 19:41on God's comfort, abundant grace, and wisdom during these
- 19:45past few emotionally challenging days.
- 19:51I also want to inform you that Aaliyah Botner, one of our
- 19:54worship leaders, submitted her resignation without explanation.
- 19:59We do not know why Pastor Josh Bonslar will continue to oversee
- 20:05and lead weekend services, tech and worship.
- 20:08As he has for these past few years, we continue to support,
- 20:12care, and pray for Ashley Flynn's family.
- 20:15She and her extended family mean a lot to me personally and to
- 20:19our church. Her life and faith have impacted
- 20:23thousands, maybe 10s of thousands, maybe hundreds of
- 20:27thousands. We will continue to fully
- 20:30cooperate with law enforcement as they carry out their
- 20:33difficult work during this ongoing investigation.
- 20:37And the one thing I respectfully ask from each of you is to guard
- 20:40hearts to resist the temptation to speculate or gossip.
- 20:45Much of this is fueled by social media posts from individuals
- 20:48with no direct knowledge or facts.
- 20:51Unfounded rumors only make the situation worse, and each of us
- 20:55are called to love, mourn, care, and keep our eyes fixed on
- 21:04Jesus. Now, there's been speculation
- 21:07online that there was a divorce that was imminent.
- 21:09There's been speculation that this mistress was pregnant.
- 21:13We don't really know for sure. What we do know is that the
- 21:16prosecution as of their April release of the witness list,
- 21:20they got her listed on there, which is interesting.
- 21:22But if a mistress was involved, if a baby was involved, well,
- 21:28think about how much of Caleb's life would completely unravel.
- 21:32He works for Ashley's family's company.
- 21:34He would then have to pay alimony.
- 21:37He wouldn't be able to see his daughters and likely his whole
- 21:41life would be ruined. But as of today, where things
- 21:44actually stand, Caleb is set to go on trial September 17th of
- 21:48this year. He is pleading not guilty and I
- 21:51guess we'll just have to wait and see what ends up happening
- 21:54with all of that. And I realized that this case
- 21:57didn't really have any addiction thread to it.
- 21:59But I would say I am just forever consumed with the fact
- 22:04that people refuse to just get a divorce.
- 22:08They refuse to just separate from whatever situation they
- 22:11don't want to be a part of and they go to these extreme
- 22:14lengths. And I found it to be a really
- 22:16interesting story and situation. And with it being so relevant
- 22:20with the trial coming up, I thought it was a good case to
- 22:22cover. But if there's any other cases
- 22:24you guys want me to cover, of course, drop them down in the
- 22:26comments. I've been trying to do more of
- 22:28like true crime style cases on my Tuesday mini dives.
- 22:32I can usually cover those quicker and then I usually save
- 22:35the deeper, more conspiratorial vibes for Friday.
- 22:40But that's all I got for you guys today.
- 22:42I look forward to doing this again with you guys on Friday
- 22:45for another one. But until then, sleep safe, stay
- 22:49sober, stay awake, stay alive, and you're going to Hollywood
- 22:55later. Sobers, let's go.