Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / "Sorry About the Car Crash!" - GOD
Transcript
- 0:04The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:23book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews.
- 0:57You are fully aware as an Oklahoma resident, I live in Tornado Alley,
- 1:02and so I've been watching all the meteorologists and they're all increasingly concerned about El
- 1:07Nino. Right We're seeing all the tornadoes across the Midwest and the Southwest,
- 1:12sixty twisters in a single day, and they're calling it potentially one of the
- 1:18most tumultuous storm seasons in a decade, driven by El Nino. And of
- 1:22course I'm like, what's El Nino? And so I logged onto One Dream
- 1:27and low and behold, there's a whole series called the Science of Extreme Weather,
- 1:34and there it is a section on El Neno. This is what I've
- 1:40been doing with my time. I've actually been streaming it via the app,
- 1:42listening as I'm out doing my thing, traveling, whatnot. And I'll tell
- 1:48you I am just so impressed with his service, not just because one Drium
- 1:53is a great supporter of this broadcast, but because there's such a good fit,
- 1:57so many different things to learn, thousands of hours of content, and
- 2:01I want you to know what I'm talking about. I want you to fall
- 2:04in love with Wondrium just like I have. So they are offering a full
- 2:09and free month of one Dream for you to try outs with my special U
- 2:16r L one drum dot com slash seth. Stream it into your life on
- 2:22your schedule, learn new stuff, be entertained, be enlightened, and enjoy
- 2:28one Drum for free for a full month. W O N d r i
- 2:32Um dot com slash Seth one drum dot com slash Seth. I was browsing
- 2:47a Facebook page or my feed or something, and for some reason, a
- 2:52local or a regional, a suburban police department notification came up. I don't
- 2:59subscribe, but I must have seen old Seth's in the Tulsa area, and
- 3:02so he might be interested, you know posts you might be interested in.
- 3:07So it shows up on my feed and it's a police department, an actual
- 3:12town police department, a suburb of Tulsa, Oklahoma, and it was describing
- 3:17there was a collision on the highway. I think it was I forty four.
- 3:21Two cars smashed against each other, and so there were police cars all
- 3:25around, an emergency vehicles, and as I understand it, a semi truck
- 3:30barreled through, couldn't slow down in time through the accident scene, and plowed
- 3:36into a police car. Fortunately, the officer was not inside, and so
- 3:42it struck the car, but nobody else was injured. And the police department
- 3:49gave a sermon and said, we are so thankful to God that the police
- 3:54officer was not in the driver's seat when the semi truck smashed into it.
- 4:00We are very grateful there was no further injury. Blah blah blah. And
- 4:05then it reiterated and we again want to say thank you God for saving the
- 4:11life or potentially saving the life of this police officer. Well, this is
- 4:16a taxpayer funded law enforcement agency that keeps talking about God. And I debated
- 4:26and Finally I went in and said something. And so it's interesting to me
- 4:30that God didn't forewarn the people who were in the first accident that there might
- 4:36be danger ahead, so that they could slow down or pull onto the shoulder,
- 4:41or I don't know, do something else. Avoidance, right, divinely
- 4:46inspired accident avoidance seems kind of reasonable to me. Why didn't God reach down
- 4:54and say to the drivers involved before any accident ever happened, Hey, you
- 4:58want to beware, You want to lower your speed, you want to take
- 5:00this exit, take a turn. Look out for the car in red or
- 5:03the car in blue, or there's a narrowing or a construction site. Just
- 5:08FYI, danger ahead. You do not want to do this, or there
- 5:13will be a wreck. How about the same kind of heads up for the
- 5:16truck driver, Hey, hang on, just a second bunch of emergency vehicles
- 5:20up here. You can't see them all. You're going to plow into a
- 5:23police car. I think you should probably freaking slow down. I think that's
- 5:26reasonable. So I said something on the Facebook page to that effect, and
- 5:30the responses were maddening. What a dumb thing to say. I can't believe
- 5:40you don't understand how God works. Someone else said something totally horrible. Hang
- 5:46on this second, I gotta pull this up. I normally try not to
- 5:50give too much attention to the trolls or the agents of awfulness, but this
- 5:56was so interesting that I went ahead and screencapped it. It said, seth,
- 6:00God doesn't interfere with all the details. He allowed your mother's drug use
- 6:05while pregnant. He didn't make you an idiot. Hashtag God loves stupid people
- 6:13too, hashtag it's not your fault, hashtag poor dope babies. So his
- 6:21idea of a clever, intelligent retort was to say that I'm brain damaged,
- 6:27and the explanation must be that my mother had to have been drug addicted wild
- 6:32pregnant with me. There was no hate like Christian love. And then finally,
- 6:41somebody said the inevitable because this response always happens free will. Well,
- 6:46God didn't prevent this from happening, because we have free will. Someone explained
- 6:53this to me, how does free will affect whether or not God would warn
- 6:59us about him ending calamity? And I say this, I think in several
- 7:02of the books that I've written, the free will argument just totally shatters the
- 7:08minute it is offered up. If I am given better information, then I
- 7:13have a better opportunity to make the free will choice. Hey, Seth,
- 7:17there's a left ramp and a right ramp. On the left, you're going
- 7:21to be more safe. On the right, you might get hit by another
- 7:26car, end up in the ditch and potentially the hospital. You have the
- 7:30choice now, given that information, free choice. Would you like to go
- 7:33left or would you like to go right? That's not an infringement to free
- 7:39will. It's actually capitalizing on my free choice, just giving me better information
- 7:44by which to make the choice. People will give me this argument when it
- 7:47comes to the Bible, Well, why is the Bible so nebulous and vague
- 7:51and contradictory? Why is it so freaking hard to understand? Why is it
- 7:55so problematic? Well? Free, well it Lard gave is very well,
- 8:00I'm so what, I need better information with which to exercise my free will
- 8:05choice. So why would things be vague on purpose because of free will?
- 8:13It's the stupidest, one of the stupidest arguments I've heard in the defense of
- 8:18God's not intervening or doing anything divine the nature of miracles. A long time
- 8:24ago, God he parted the Red Sea, and he stopped the sun in
- 8:26the sky, and he raised Lazarus from the dead. These days, God
- 8:31simply had the police officer get out of the driver's side of the car before
- 8:37a semitruck turned his vehicle into a crushed soda can ah. The Lord works
- 8:45in mysterious ways. He wanted to intervene more than he did, but it's
- 8:48a sinful world. He wants Jesus wants to save the babies that are still
- 8:56born. The Lord wants this child over here not to have brain cancer.
- 9:01The Lord wants so and so not to be abused by a domestic partner.
- 9:07The Lord wants the Catholic Church not to rape Gildren. The Lord wants,
- 9:13the Lord wants, the Lord wants, but it just can't because it is
- 9:18a falling world and we have to have free will. I can feel the
- 9:24brain cells just dying in my sky. I just can't take it. The
- 9:31Lord would like to be divine and do divine shit. The free will anyway,
- 9:39That's what I've been feeling. And the more they argue in defense of
- 9:45this God, the more you realize how problematic the arguments are. They are
- 9:48actually pushing people further away and a lot of it is just ad hominems.
- 9:52Right, you go after the messenger, I'm sorry that your brain damaged,
- 9:58or someone else said, who hurt you? As if that's an argument,
- 10:01who hurt you? Why are you so mad at God? I you're that
- 10:05quite admitting I'm sorry you didn't get a chance to totally get introduced to the
- 10:13true version of our faith, because no one who was introduced to the true
- 10:16version of Christianity would ever walk away. There are so many moving goalposts,
- 10:22and for that reason, I don't often engage, but I felt that it
- 10:26was important to, I don't know, draw a circle around one of the
- 10:30problems in a public forum, especially on a taxpayer funded law enforcement page.
- 10:35These are cops and they're paid by all of our too well all of the
- 10:39tax dollars within the town that they serve, and they shouldn't be acting like
- 10:45a church and if they're going to sermonize, I think it's important that they
- 10:48should be challenged, and so I took it upon myself to do so.
- 10:50That's just a window into what I've been up to recently. Have you noticed
- 10:56when you engage people, even good people who mean well will say the stupidest
- 11:01stuff, which is why my most recent book is titled after one of my
- 11:07more recent speeches, called Christianity made me talk like an idiot. Yes,
- 11:13I used to be guilty of it. We can all be dumb about some
- 11:16stuff, but I mean Christianity fundamentalist religions train you to think you are being
- 11:22deep and rich in wisdom and all these things, when in truth, you
- 11:26just sound like an idiot. It's somebody in the chat bring up a salient
- 11:33point about free will. I think we may have made this point on the
- 11:37show before, but it's so good, And I think one of the reasons
- 11:41it's so good is to watch the responses, the expressions on the believer's faces
- 11:45as you bring up this point. You say, okay, well, what
- 11:48you're saying is is that our fall from grace is a product of free will.
- 11:52But that fall has produced kind of a decline of nature. All of
- 11:58nature has fallen. So it's not just that humankind is being punished. But
- 12:03now we see animals that eat each other alive, and volcanoes that explode and
- 12:09cover living things in lava and they burn to death horribly, and people are
- 12:13born with terrible birth defects, and good people are faced with terrible nightmarish calamity
- 12:20in this world on a minute by minute basis. But that happens because humankind
- 12:26has free will, the will to choose. Is that what you're saying,
- 12:31Yes, yeah, we have free will. We chose poorly and then shit
- 12:35happened. Okay, So is there any bad in heaven? Is there murder,
- 12:41birth, defects, natural disasters, calamity, whatever, any malice and
- 12:46pain and horribleness, any of that going on that we're seeing on earth.
- 12:48Will we see that in heaven? No? No, no, of course
- 12:50not. Heaven is perfect bliss. Heaven is absolute joy with nothing negative in
- 12:56it. What means is, then, with your model, by your measuring
- 13:03stick, you are saying that we will have no free will in heaven because
- 13:09on earth free will produces a byproduct of bad decisions. Somebody chooses poorly,
- 13:16calamity takes place. But if that doesn't happen in heaven, it means we
- 13:20must not have the ability to make a choice right or wrong. We don't
- 13:26have free will in heaven. And then they do a little song in dance.
- 13:33It sounds something like this. They're like, no, no, no,
- 13:35you obviously don't know Jesus. You don't know how Jesus works. Jesus
- 13:41is beyond our pithy insect brains. He's perfect, He's omnipotent. He can
- 13:46create any scenario and make it make sense. So in heaven he can guarantee
- 13:52nothing bad ever happens, and you never do or think or say anything terrible.
- 13:58But at the same time, you will never do or say or think
- 14:01anything terrible, and it will be your own choice not to do so.
- 14:07He'll force it, but it'll be your choice, and he'll make it all
- 14:11work because Jesus. I've tried to press people on this point about free you
- 14:18will if you don't have the freedom to decide for yourself, to fail even
- 14:26you don't have freedom. And if you don't have freedom, you are a
- 14:30slave. Heaven is a slave camp. Oh yeah, bring it up.
- 14:37Watch their heads exclude. I don't know. Let's talk. Let's talk about
- 14:46what you want to talk about for a while. Let's take some calls nine
- 14:50to zero first on the switchboard. Who's this name is Matt? Matt,
- 14:54what's on your mind? The topic I wanted to call about what virtue signaling.
- 15:01There's a lot of people on social media and I am buy in large
- 15:05one of them who share things that they support, and it seems like I'm
- 15:11just sharing it with a bunch of people who agree with me, and I
- 15:16just don't know if there's any utility. And I'm starting to ask myself,
- 15:18is there any utility in sharing, you know, to all these people,
- 15:22Hey, I'm against this, and I support that. I think it's important
- 15:26for us to be true and public about our values, and I think social
- 15:33media can be a legitimate way of allowing ourselves as citizens, as human beings,
- 15:39etc. To be seen and heard. I think there are some people
- 15:43that may spend a lot of time on social media because they think they might
- 15:48be helpless to do anything else. Maybe they've told themselves this is how you
- 15:54change the world. Fifteen posts a day talking about how shitty people are.
- 16:00I mean, there's some of that going on. And yeah, I do
- 16:03think there is virtue signaling where people aren't just about the things that matter,
- 16:11but seem to be puffing themselves up a little bit too much. They enjoy
- 16:17being superior just a little bit too much. They tend to vilify other it's
- 16:22just a little bit too much. And look at all the sycophants who come
- 16:27in behind them to say how noble and virtuous you are. I mean,
- 16:33that's a drug. It's addictive, and I have seen people who will even
- 16:38weaponize a worthy cause, but they do it to make themselves feel better about
- 16:45themselves. Yeah, I think that's a legitimate concern. I don't know if
- 16:51you coined that term or not that I'll give you credit. The slacktivist term,
- 16:56I really like that. I read it somewhere and I get it.
- 17:00I've been guilty of it. I see the revolution going on in Iran,
- 17:04as the women are rising up and demanding freedom, often at their own peril.
- 17:11They're being blinded, they're being beaten to a pulp, they're being murdered
- 17:14in the streets, they're being murdered behind the scenes in prison cells and derogation
- 17:18rooms. People over there doing genuinely brave things to try to revolutionize this backward
- 17:26country dominated by the Islamist regime. And so if I go on the thinking
- 17:30atheist pages, I will post about what is happening. Here is a story,
- 17:37an instance, an anecdote, a statistic. This is a news report
- 17:41that's come out. Here's video that is leaked. People need to know.
- 17:44So I'm able to signal boost in that way, which is legitimate and important,
- 17:49and the hashtags can catch on raising more awareness, which can increase public
- 17:55pressure. So maybe that causes world governments to get involved. We saw this
- 18:00with a refugee out of I'm trying to remember what she was coming out of,
- 18:03but she feared for her life, she was holed up in a hotel
- 18:07room. And yet it was social media and the hashtagging and the sharing that
- 18:11actually caused world governments to intervene and she was able to get asylum in Canada
- 18:18saved her life. So that's legitimate. But once I hashtag and share,
- 18:25what else have I done? Did I call the embassy? That I contact
- 18:30my local officials so that they would call an embassy? Have I done anything
- 18:34else? And it's so freaking messy. I just feel like we can't lie
- 18:40to ourselves and think that ranting on Twitter is how we change the world.
- 18:45I am not convinced that as the case at all, that there's got to
- 18:48be more. There's got to be more. Yeah, I absolutely agree.
- 18:52I mean, I am very grateful that people can in a matter of seconds
- 18:56or minutes raise awareness about but don't stop with the posting and don't stop with
- 19:03the rees sharing. I want to thank one of my commenters in the chat,
- 19:06Raja Muhammad, was the name of the woman who was rescued. Do
- 19:11I think there are some people who go online and they'll throw something out,
- 19:15maybe unfairly vilify an ideological opponent, or they're a binary thinker, or maybe
- 19:22they're just full of themselves, and so this is their way of feeling superior,
- 19:26you know, announcing that they are a superior thinker. I'm a rationalist
- 19:30time I am better in a lot of ways. I run into those people.
- 19:33I've run into them in religious circles, i run into them in atheist
- 19:38circles, and they can be just nasty, and I honestly think some of
- 19:42them they just knock everybody else down so they can feel taller. I am
- 19:48not a fan of those people, and I've mute at a lot of accounts
- 19:52because I don't think that's how we change the world. And I'm certainly not
- 19:56here to feed anybody else's ego. But it's point by point, situation by
- 20:00situation. I think we're all doing the best we can, and I think
- 20:03you draw a circle around a legitimate challenge of trying to be an activist of
- 20:07any kind in the social media world. Thanks for calling my friend, and
- 20:12have a wonderful day. Okay, you too, take care of you,
- 20:15but if I see you later. It really is a cheap way. Sometimes
- 20:18it can be a cheap way a feeling like we're doing something. I've spoken
- 20:23about this. I've done whole speeches about how you know, I used to
- 20:26pat myself in the bag and I get yeah, tweeted about that. Yeah,
- 20:30showed them how it is. I have activisted today. Now I can
- 20:36go off and walk the dogs and take Natalie to the movies, and I
- 20:40can live my relatively well, very privileged life as other people are going through
- 20:45true oppression. Aren't I special? I've been guilty. You get high,
- 20:51especially when somebody else comes in and likes and shares and comments and validates you.
- 20:55That's how you get a chemical rush from that. There's an addictive aspect
- 21:00to social media, so it all feeds on itself, and by the end
- 21:03of the day you feel like a world changer for what sitting at your keyboard
- 21:08going, I have angry typed this world into a more reasonable place. You
- 21:15are welcome, everybody. Five zero two, Hi, tell me your name.
- 21:22Beth. Hi, Beth, thanks for calling. What do you want
- 21:26to talk about? I'm want to talk about therapy, abuse and exploitation.
- 21:33I'm highly grateful that while President Obama was still in office, he had a
- 21:37public comment line that the citizens could call. And if it weren't for President
- 21:45Obama, I may already be deceased. People on his comment line gave me
- 21:52information about an organization, a group. There's a group of people across this
- 21:56country who dedicate themselves to trying to assist people who have been extremely harmed through
- 22:03therapy of use and exploitation. Having me attacked by religious figures, people that
- 22:10imagine themselves to be puritanical and holy and all knowing put me in my entire
- 22:15family under attack. I've been stock mocked, hit by a stranger, falsely
- 22:21accused, sexually harassed, terrorized, issued death threats. I was literally told
- 22:27by a prayer line worker on Trinity Broadcasting Networks prayer line, you can get
- 22:33murdered. Okay, Well, I'm going to interject real quickly, if you
- 22:37will, if you will forgive me, that's okay. You're speaking about a
- 22:40lot without a lot of detail, and I understand why. Let me try
- 22:44to are we distilling this down to in the healthcare industry, there's a heavy
- 22:47religious influence, filled with blaming and shaming, often putting those seeking therapy in
- 22:52danger. Would that be a way to sum that up? I would say
- 22:56that's very accurate. If you absolutely so, we're as sounding the alarm about
- 23:02what religiosity infecting what should be science based mental healthcare. That's right, that's
- 23:08right. Okay, go ahead, go ahead. Now my only resource is
- 23:17through this group, and this in particular individual in this group who has fifty
- 23:23one years of medical experience. If it weren't for her communicating with me now
- 23:29for six years, I might already have died. And if it were up
- 23:33to a lot of individuals who consider themselves to be Christians, consider themselves as
- 23:41being children of God, if it were up to those individuals, I would
- 23:45have already died. They've used spiritual torturing of me to the point that they
- 23:52literally murdered my belief in God. I had been a believer, and I'm
- 23:56no longer a believer them. I now am an atheist. The insanity I
- 24:02feel that exists within organized religions. So you know, there's so much cherney,
- 24:07so much brutality, so much into humanity when you draw a circle around
- 24:12a legitimate issue out there, and I'm glad you're still with us. And
- 24:18I appreciate the fact that you are sounding the alarm, blowing the whistle on
- 24:22this kind of thing, and that you have found someone to be able to
- 24:26confide in and maybe receive counsel from. And your call is greatly appreciated.
- 24:30So before I move on, just thank you and I'm glad you're still here.
- 24:33Okay, thank you so much, sir. All right, we'll see
- 24:37you, thank you, thank you. Bye. There are a lot of
- 24:41religious people who engage in therapy who do not project their religiosity into mental health
- 24:51and helping their patients. Yet there are also many who believe that therapy is
- 24:56their mission field and so secular a therapy project is a resource. They heavily
- 25:03vet therapists religious or not to make sure that they are using science based best
- 25:08practices to help other people in their journey. And there's a whole web page
- 25:15for them Secular therapy dot org. And I know a lot of people wish
- 25:21they had had that in their journeys before it was established. I think it
- 25:25was established six seven years ago. Secular therapy dot org and hopefully that will
- 25:30help someone else. Five one two, Hi, what's your name? Ethan?
- 25:37Thanks for calling Ethan. What's on your mind? Well, I had
- 25:41a couple of things that I wanted to get your opinion on right now.
- 25:45I think I'm big into TikTok and barely on Twitter at all. But the
- 25:52bigger threat I perceive is things like the Seven Mountains Mandate dominion theology. These
- 25:59people are End Times Christians whose sole purposes to turn America into a Christian theocracy
- 26:07for the purpose of bringing about the rapture the Second Coming of Jesus. Jerry
- 26:11Folwell was one of them. They started a thing called the Council for National
- 26:18Policy, as well as other organizations you've probably heard of, including Project Blitz
- 26:22as a part of it. How do we counter stuff like that? I
- 26:26don't know if a vote is enough? Are we protesting? Are we continuing
- 26:32to raise our voice on social media? Like? How do you protest that
- 26:34kind of insanity? All right? So the question is how do we fix
- 26:38the world? All right? Hang out? That's that maybe a little bit
- 26:41above me, but you and I share the same You're right, Christian dominion
- 26:47theology, and there are a lot of layers to this onion. One it
- 26:52is hell bents. If you wail on making the rest of his second class
- 26:56citizens, it once the head seat of the table and dole out the scraps
- 27:00to the rest of us that can shove it down our throat, and we're
- 27:03supposed to say thank you very much. So much of it, I think
- 27:07is about power. I think much of it is about trying to fulfill the
- 27:11Book of Revelation. I think there is a lot of xenophobia because if we
- 27:19consolidate the United States, with its subjectively drawn borders, into a Christian nation,
- 27:25it is better prepared to defeat the one world government, which is also
- 27:30part of Christian End Times theology. I think there are just some bigots out
- 27:33there that don't want to share this world. I think there's a ton of
- 27:37reasons that people are dominionist and want to have dominion over others, whether it's
- 27:41people of color or those who are non hetero, or whether it's the Muslim
- 27:45or the Jew, or the seek or the Hindu or the non religious,
- 27:48the atheist, the democrat, whatever. And so there's no one magic bullet
- 27:53for any of this except I think resist. I think we have to stand
- 27:57up. We have to be strong. I think we have to let our
- 28:00voices be heard. I think we have to contact our elected officials. I
- 28:03think we need to be seen in the public eye. We are demographically on
- 28:07the rise. What's the number, forty percent roughly of Americans now identify as
- 28:14pretty much non religious, sweetest, don't need it, don't want it,
- 28:18not necessarily atheists, but not engage certainly not interested in a theocracy over democracy
- 28:23model. Well, whenever possible, we need to be out. We got
- 28:26to show the world we're here. We're growing in numbers. We will not
- 28:30be ignored, and these attacks on the rule of law, the constitution,
- 28:34basic human decency simply won't be tolerated. And I think that can manifest in
- 28:40a great many ways beyond the vote. I think, you know, whether
- 28:42we're appearing at a city council meeting, we are contacting our congress person,
- 28:47putting together events or protests, or some sort of a media attraction that local
- 28:53news stations or regional news stations might be interested in. I think we got
- 28:57to do more of that. We have to be seen and hurt. And
- 29:00that's the best I've got. Well, it's something that I've tried to push
- 29:03for on TikTok is getting more people to run at local elections, local things
- 29:10because Democrats don't tend to do that. That's you know, Republicans kind of
- 29:14see it. Christian conservatives kind of see it as an American responsibility to be
- 29:18involved and engaged at the political levels. So now we're seeing school boards and
- 29:22city councils, mayorships go to Republicans where like in a state where maybe they
- 29:27have Democratic Congress and Senate, and so like we're getting in book bands and
- 29:33all this other stuff. And you mentioned something else. I spend a lot
- 29:37of time defending my community, the LGBTQ community, on TikTok and social media.
- 29:42And one of the hardest conversations I tend to have with these types of
- 29:48thinkers is I've actually gone and I've gone to like the American Academy of Pediatrics
- 29:53and American Academy of Psychology, and I've read published papers about gender to for
- 30:00you and what it means to transition and what the best standards and practices are.
- 30:04And no matter how many times I try to drive home that point,
- 30:07cite those sources, give the available details. All I ever get back from
- 30:11these people is, well, that's just liberal propaganda. All the science that
- 30:19impacts their life on a daily basis, from their communications, their entertainment,
- 30:23their transportation, clothing, housing, food, you name it. They're okay
- 30:27with all of that. But when scientists say that a brain can develop in
- 30:32a different way, suddenly they don't believe that science. And you can't get
- 30:37it through to these people. They don't care if it's true. They don't
- 30:41want to believe it, or they believe that they have the truth, and
- 30:44they have been programmed to distrust all disconfirming information. It's like when I go
- 30:49out and talk about Noah's ark, I'm going to take a leap here,
- 30:52but I'm like, you know, you realize the entire geologic column refutes any
- 30:57idea, any notion, any claim about a global flood. This never happened.
- 31:03And their response is not, Wow, show me the geologic column.
- 31:07I would like to see the sedimentary layers and understand better the evidence that you
- 31:11are bringing. They don't do that. What they say is well, of
- 31:15course scientists want the Bible to not be true because they worship science or Einstein,
- 31:21or they're selfish or one to be God's or their agents of the devil
- 31:25right, So they are more interested in defending ideology than embracing education. This
- 31:32is often programmed from their earliest years. And we can all be guilty of
- 31:37ideology, defense of being closed minded, of doubling down, but certainly religions
- 31:44foster that. But it doesn't mean we don't continue to bring the evidence and
- 31:48show the truth because I think there are a few doubters out there who do
- 31:52want to know and who are dissatisfied with the party line, and who one
- 31:56who evolved their thinking. Hell, I became one of them and it transformed
- 32:00my life. You may have been another one of them. It is possible.
- 32:04So I think we continue to pound the drama of science, education,
- 32:07reason, data and humanity. That's all I got, Okay, I understand
- 32:13that entirely. Like even doing what I do on TikTok, I get comments
- 32:16and messages from people who tell me that I gave them a pause to think
- 32:21about things, and in some cases people will tell me that I was what
- 32:27started their deconstruction. Now I'm nowhere near allowed as voice as you are,
- 32:30but I try to do what I can. I did have one more question
- 32:34before I get off the call. Do we meet unkindness with kindness? Is
- 32:37that the goal? At what point do we get to push back in fire
- 32:44with fire kind of attitude? When do we get to stop being nice to
- 32:46people who want to see us cease to exist? And then I will get
- 32:51off the phone and let you answer that answer. I really do appreciate all
- 32:54right, thanks for calling. It's a good call. I appreciate you very
- 32:58much. I don't think you can say for everyone that you use the same
- 33:05approach. There have been people who have a bad idea, destructive idea that
- 33:09they are offering up honestly with good intention. Maybe they're just brainwash, or
- 33:15you know, they've been locked into the fox news culture or some sort of
- 33:17a fundy faith or whatever. But you can see in them they genuinely believe
- 33:22this is good and this is right, and I need to be this is
- 33:25the moral thing to do. So I think I have to gauge intent.
- 33:30Are they just awful people? Are they just poisonous in their mind, heart
- 33:37and gut and they're going out and just doing hideous things because they are hideous
- 33:43people. Well, I'm going to approach them a lot differently, especially publicly,
- 33:47that I would approach somebody who was a fundamentalist believer who may have homophobic
- 33:52beliefs, or who may be a Young Earth or anti science creationist or something
- 33:58like that. I think I approach differently, whether it's the one on one
- 34:02or whether it's the broad stage. I use mockery a lot more on the
- 34:06larger macro level. If I meet somebody who has some problematic ideas, who
- 34:14may be part of the Christian Nation crowd, but I know in their heart
- 34:17they're good people trying to live good lives, and we have a conversation over
- 34:21coffee. That's a lot different than me condemning sixty minutes for platforming Marjorie Taylor
- 34:29Green on what used to be a blue chip, reputable bastion of investigative reporting.
- 34:38Marjorie Taylor Green gets no quarter from me, and I will put her
- 34:44on blast, right, I will nuke her from orbit. But it's situational,
- 34:51and even some of the worst ideas that are propagated by what we see
- 34:55is some of the worst people, Some of those people can be changed.
- 35:01Remember they're propagators are bad ideas, but in many instances they're also victims of
- 35:07bad ideas. And I know a lot of my fellow lefties hate. When
- 35:10I say this, well, they're not victims, they're perpetrators, they're dominators,
- 35:15they're they're evil, they're my enemy. Well maybe maybe they are your
- 35:22enemy. Maybe they're my enemy. It's like when, and this is really
- 35:27controversial, okay, when the terrorists fly planes into the World Trade Center and
- 35:36the Pentagon on nine to eleven, they are the perpetrators of Islamic fundamentalist hate,
- 35:44wiping out thousands of innocent lives. This deserves our condemnation. Fundamentalist Islam
- 35:52deserves. The terrorism terrorists, those involved in the beheadings and the torture and
- 35:58the misogyny, they deserve our condemnation. They must be resisted. We have
- 36:04to stand up and with all force, we have to say no, we
- 36:07won't live in this world, this bigoted, destructive, cruel, primitive,
- 36:13barbaric culture that you want the whole world to look like. We refuse.
- 36:19Right, that's a strong stance. Where did the mindset that you must fly
- 36:24a plane into the World Trade Center and the Pentagon to wipe out the infidel
- 36:30and achieve paradise with Allah? Where did that come from? That's brainwashing.
- 36:38Somebody was so brainwashed, so program with fundamentalists superstition, bigotry, and hate
- 36:46that they were willing to blow themselves and all these other people up in the
- 36:51name of their God. If you look at it in that respect, this
- 36:55person probably brainwashed from childhood who never had a chance. They are a perpetrator,
- 37:02they are also a victim. And there are some people who have been
- 37:07talked out of their hate, out of their bigotry. They have been engaged
- 37:13out of their bad ideas. They have been loved out of their hate.
- 37:19I know some people hate it when I say that out loud. Who's that
- 37:22guy who goes that he's a black gentleman. He goes and he engages member
- 37:27of the k k k cos and talks to white supremacists. He's talked white
- 37:31supremacists out of their hate and they've become dear friends. Right, it's possible.
- 37:40I used to be antique. I used to be all this awful stuff.
- 37:44I was xenophobic, and I thought all Muslims were terrorists, and I
- 37:47was just I was a Christian nationalist, dominionist, and I didn't think women
- 37:51should be able to control their bodies because it's God's decision and the tiny little
- 37:55fertilized embryo whatever it was that's a baby, it's a baby with the soul.
- 38:00So therefore our word in the Christian faith trump saul, and so let's
- 38:04strip all the right. I wasn't thinking of in those terms. I was
- 38:07thinking, we're advocates for the children. But the effect was we are going
- 38:10to rob one hundred and sixty six million American women from their right to choose
- 38:14what happens to their body. I was the enemy of reproductive rights. I
- 38:17was the enemy of the constitutional state church line. I was the enemy of
- 38:22non Christians in that way, and I got rescued. If it's possible for
- 38:29me, maybe it's possible for other people. I was a perpetrator of bad
- 38:32ideas, also a victim of bad ideas. And in the non binary world,
- 38:37where people and issues are complex, these things can exist in the same
- 38:44space. Nuance cannot be dead when we talk about these things. Forgive the
- 38:50rant. I am so sorry. Chelsea at two five two, Thanks for
- 38:54waiting on me. Are you there? I am here. Thanks for Colin.
- 38:59What you want to talk about? I want to talk about I guess
- 39:02the different tune than what the past few colums were like, and one of
- 39:07them is actually related. I have religious chosen family. I'm part of the
- 39:13LGBT community, and my religious family is just the best family I could ever
- 39:20have. Honestly, they are the most affirming, kind hearted people I've ever
- 39:24had in my life, and they loved me unconditionally. I was raised and
- 39:31let's say, far right but right leaning Methodist, very anti LGBT and all
- 39:37that stuff. And you know, the church has recently split the Methodist Church.
- 39:42That's another topic for another day. But that's how I grew up.
- 39:45But when I started talking with my friends who's now my sister, chosen sister,
- 39:52and I talked to her family. Once I started talking with them about
- 39:57religion and all the trauma I've been through and all that, their narratives did
- 40:00not click with what I used I'm used to. They're preaching love unconditional,
- 40:07and they don't believe in hell per se. They believe you get to choose
- 40:10that when you die, whether you want to cease to exist or you just
- 40:16you go with heaven to God. You know, that's what their theology is
- 40:21like. But that's the end goal of that. But I'm going off on
- 40:24a tangent. I just wanted to say, I just recently got off the
- 40:28phone with my sister, and she is a chaplain over in Michigan. She
- 40:34is a secular chaplain. I would say she is not what you would think
- 40:37a chaplain would be, honestly, because a chaplain is somebody who's religious and
- 40:43is there for like religious therapy, but she doesn't pressure anyone into she is
- 40:50understanding. Like recently we got the phone, we talked about somebody who's non
- 40:53binary, and in class, came to her and asked if she could talk
- 40:59to her professor because a student was proselytizing in class and the professor was not
- 41:07doing a good job at denouncing that or pushing back. So she set the
- 41:14professor down and changed it, changed the professor's mind and professor. Ever since
- 41:20then, the prostizer has not spoken the prostizor still has been proselytizing, but
- 41:29there has been a lot of pushbacks since then. Let me ask this,
- 41:32how old if you want to share, how old is your champlain's sister?
- 41:37Around twenty seven? Thank you? Right? Thirty? And yeah, under
- 41:44not interested in the fundy faiths of their parents and grandparents, moving away from
- 41:51hardline religiosity. And I'm seeing a lot more of this where people who are
- 41:54practicing Christianity, are kind of customed fidding a Christianity which is distanced from the
- 42:02hardline scriptures. Their Christianity has a Jesus who loves and supports everybody unconditionally.
- 42:09In the anti gay verses, those are out of there. And the health
- 42:13theology, ah, that we're going to get rid of that, In the
- 42:15misogyny, in the silencing of women, no, no, let's have a
- 42:19female chaplain. Granted, I think they are manufacturing their own religion and calling
- 42:25it Christianity or a byproduct of Christianity, but it's the humanist. It's the
- 42:30human being in her and others like her, increasingly with the thirty and under
- 42:37crowd that are transforming this world. I think at the demographic level, beyond
- 42:42the halls of power where things have just gone batshit crazy, beyond the entrenched
- 42:45Christian dominionist types. But in the culture as a whole, we're becoming less
- 42:51fundy, more secular, more humanist. And I think your sister is an
- 42:55example of that, a chaplain who is essentially preaching humanity. Yeah, and
- 43:01I thought that kind of pot off. The second to last color or third
- 43:06to last color, the one that was talking about therapy abuse. It made
- 43:09me think about that, so I wanted to also include something about my sister
- 43:15being Chaffline and stuff and how secular and humanist she is. It's a good
- 43:20point, and it's also I think, a reminder that we can't put all
- 43:24religious people in a freaking box. We're back to don't be a binary thinker.
- 43:29People are monumentally complex, and I think there are a lot of good
- 43:31people who have custom fitted a religion that best suits their moral code, and
- 43:37they don't want to be a biggot. They don't want to judge, They
- 43:38want to love and make the world a better place. There it's still sort
- 43:43of affected by a religious model. Your sister inspires me in that way,
- 43:47and I'm thankful for her and I appreciate you telling us about her. Okay,
- 43:51yeah, thank you, thank you for having me. All Right,
- 43:53Chelsea, day be good, We'll see you later. At this moment,
- 43:58I'm thinking about Greta Vosper. She is a minister. She went into Christian
- 44:06ministry for United Church back in nineteen ninety three. This is in Canada,
- 44:12and over the course of several years she began to deconstruct and say this is
- 44:17not making any sense, the dogma, the fundamentalist scripture, the Bible,
- 44:23a lot of the theology. No, I'm not buying this, And so
- 44:28she started to edge away from that stuff and she preached more humanism. Finally
- 44:35came clean to the whole congregation. She just told her church, you know,
- 44:38I no longer believe in a supernatural, involved personal God. I just
- 44:45don't. And she somehow remained a minister. And then the United Church and
- 44:50her had a dispute and they went through a bunch of stuff, which is
- 44:52not really the point. The point is is that she remains a minister.
- 44:59She still a minister. And if you had seen that on paper, if
- 45:05you had seen the title in a brochure, on a poster in a news
- 45:08article and had said Minister Greta Vosper, our instinct is to say, oh,
- 45:15great, another brainwashed Christian who's spreading hate and bigotry based on the Bible.
- 45:21Right, we immediately knee jerk in that direction. We don't take the
- 45:25time to turn the page and read the biography of a minister who became less
- 45:31about theology and more about humanity. And interestingly, I think this was six
- 45:37seven years ago, she did this interview with CBC Television, and she estimated
- 45:45that's around half of all of the clergy in the United Church don't believe in
- 45:52a supernatural god. Now, granted, hers is a subjective opinion, she
- 46:00did have an inside out kind of a look at the culture. So it's
- 46:04obvious she bumped into a lot of pastors and ministers who were kind of doing
- 46:07the same thing. She was right there. I'm a minister, but you
- 46:12know, let's talk about something besides the Bible. Let's talk about charity.
- 46:16Let's talk about kindness. Let's talk about lifting up each other's arms and times
- 46:22of need and meeting needs and loving our fellow human beings, regardless of who
- 46:27they are and where they come from, and what the color of their skin
- 46:30is and what their sexual identity is. We are all the human race.
- 46:35We are all brothers and sisters. This is humanism. These are progressive pastors
- 46:39preaching humanism. Greta Vosper and her Ilk are on our team. Labels matter,
- 46:51Titles matter, yeah, but they are not always the story. Just
- 46:57remember that next time you bump into a minister. We're far from done.
- 47:02So much good stuff to talk about we will do. So next hang up
- 47:15if you would like to support your humble host and this broadcast and help me
- 47:20to do what I do. Become a patron. Patrons gets their own separate
- 47:24RSS feed if they want it, which gives them a totally commercial free broadcast,
- 47:30and it releases a couple of days early. And you can be a
- 47:35patron at whatever level that you want. You know, a dollar or four
- 47:37bucks a month, whatever, I mean, it's up to you, but
- 47:39it does matter. It does make a difference. And I thank you so
- 47:43much for your support. Patreon dot com, slash Seth Andrews four one two.
- 47:52I've got Eric, what's up? Yeah, I thank you for taking
- 47:57my call. I've been listening to your podcast and watching your videos, and
- 48:02as I was watching them, I keep thinking about times with my father,
- 48:07who has been gone left to surf a while ago now, but when I
- 48:13was living with him. When I was living at home with him, he
- 48:16always confused me because he always seemed to flip flop between believing in God and
- 48:22religion and all that to going into logic bones say, wait a minute,
- 48:25I'm ragiving this in the Bible, and that doesn't make sense. It's like
- 48:30throughout his life he keeps flip flopping through that talking to me about it,
- 48:37and I often wondered if you've ever experienced anybody'd like that who seemed to flip
- 48:40flop, And it's almost like he had some sort of flip personality when he
- 48:45had to that. I remember one time when he would at one point tell
- 48:51me a story about something you heard about, how there's a lot of similarities
- 48:54to what the Aborigines believed in, how it related to a known Christian story.
- 49:00But then a week later reads something in a Bible and say, hey,
- 49:05look at this. Does this make sense to you? This doesn't die
- 49:07with me. It is something that he does. It's like he seems to
- 49:14seem think logically about the sort of thing on one level, but then,
- 49:19like I don't know, a month later, he's watching Touched by an Angel
- 49:22on a regular basis. But it was hard to know whether my father truly
- 49:27believed this stuff or as he was curious about it. Would it be safe
- 49:30to say that even my father was, for lack of a better way of
- 49:35putting it, lost, Well, I'm not a psychologist. It sounds like
- 49:38someone who's hate the word seeker because the church likes to use that word,
- 49:44right, But you know you're kind of flying around and you see a queue
- 49:47and you respond to it. Then you see something else and that repels you,
- 49:51and then you turn the other direction and this gives your comfort. And
- 49:53then you go over here and you're influenced by someone else. You may say
- 49:57something that's interesting or might even make ants in the moment, but then you
- 50:00see disconfirming evidence. Yeah, I don't know what his tool set is for
- 50:05trying to determine what is and isn't true. It sounds like a very emotional
- 50:08journey to me, where someone though is legitimately seeking and not intimidated by or
- 50:15too worried about doubt. Sounds like your father's entertained doubt, which is better
- 50:22than many people do. Well, I'll tell you. You just help me
- 50:25my It just occurred to me, and you're right. I mean, he
- 50:30never preached at me, which was good, and both my parents say they
- 50:34don't like to be preached at. My father has been raised or lowered,
- 50:38maybe you could say, by nuns. He had a lot of hilarious stories
- 50:43he told me about nuns. And then the stuff had happened at school.
- 50:47I mean one time when he saw it none for the first time, he
- 50:51thought that they had no feet because they always seemed to be floating in the
- 50:54hallways. There was no got no feet, and that cracked me up.
- 51:00Nuns with no feed. It sounds like an indie band, by the way,
- 51:02you know, tomorrow and concert it's nuns with no fee at the canes,
- 51:07no fee we got. Okay, we got to write that down.
- 51:09Nuns with But you know what, I will say that It's still made me
- 51:15feel better hearing you say that, because I mean, look, you're right.
- 51:20Humans are messy, and it's it's always going to be the case.
- 51:25I just wish we would learn to not really try to over straighten or overcorrect
- 51:32ourselves, if you will. But I guess that's a pipe dream, you
- 51:37know. I think let's try to sharpen each other. You know, it
- 51:39sounds like a Hallmark movie, but I really believe it. You know,
- 51:43if we can go out and challenge each other in ways helves with branding,
- 51:49let's go out and you know, let's try to sharpen each other and can
- 51:52nudge each other toward better ideas. You never know what might happen. Eric,
- 51:55appreciate you very much, thanks for calling. Thank you very much,
- 52:00See you later. I have met those people that seem to sample at the
- 52:05buffet of belief. They'll go over here and they grab a little nugget because
- 52:10that's tasty from this religion or cult or faith tradition or spiritism. And they'll
- 52:15come over here and go, oh yeah, in Christianity, that's a great
- 52:19teaching. Let's grab that. Jesus said some beautiful stuff and this chapter and
- 52:22very and we'll grab that. And over here, looks it's Jainism or Buddhism
- 52:28or whatever. That's a wonderful philosophy. Or so they just to sort of
- 52:31assemble all these things. The ingredients are on the plate, all the different
- 52:36items, and they eat them in the order that they want, and maybe
- 52:37mix up some various foods because the flavor combination is palatable to them. I
- 52:44mean, this is what people do. A lot of people do. And
- 52:46I find that's telling. You know, they're out there's trying to find something
- 52:51that fits them. What's going on in their mind and their heart and their
- 52:53bones and their character, and says a lot about human beings. They have
- 52:58a need to believe, but they also want to be true to their own
- 53:00moral center, their own moral code, and so they customed fit a religion.
- 53:04That's echoes them for better and worse. Nine seven one. I've got
- 53:10Mark, Hello, what's up. I'm one of those Vacation Bible School survivors.
- 53:17I was as a kid, like where I'm the I think it was
- 53:20in the fourth grade. Was a summer we saw flyers in the neighborhood come
- 53:23to the vacation Bible School. So my sister and I she's a year and
- 53:28a half younger me, and we both went and we that's how I ended
- 53:32up becoming an Evangelical And it was, you know, at the time,
- 53:38you know, it seemed like it was a nice experience, but some of
- 53:42your guests have pointed out it's a very attractive thing two parents because it's two
- 53:46weeks. You can get the kids out of the house for half a day
- 53:50or whatever, and they seem to like it. But we did that and
- 53:53then just the kids ended up attending the local Evangelical church four towards down from
- 54:00us, And it was a weird situation where you had two kids who were
- 54:05active in the Evangelical church and yet their parents were not believers, and that
- 54:10kind of caused a lot of tension. It was hard. You're getting one
- 54:15message from the pulpit and from the Sunday School. It's a very conservative Christian
- 54:20viewpoint, and then my home was more liberal, where Democrats the whole congregation,
- 54:25where Republicans as the right about the time Reagan was in his ascendency.
- 54:30So I think that I had to kind of live with some contradictions and was
- 54:34a member of the church all through high school until I got to college,
- 54:37and then I just kind of slowly drifted away. And people asked me,
- 54:42you know, was there one thing that did it? And I'd say,
- 54:44well, I think this. Over a period of time, I started to
- 54:49see that life was not black and white, and there was a lot of
- 54:52shades of gray out there. Why do you call yourself a vacation Bible School
- 54:57survivor? Flesh that out for me? No, I mean I get it,
- 55:02I totally get it. I just want to hear it in your words.
- 55:05Go ahead, Okay, yeah, because I went through that experience.
- 55:08But you know, I look back and I know what they said, what
- 55:14scripts are following their ideas to bring kids into the church. And yes,
- 55:20in a lot of ways they were successful. They were successful in the short
- 55:23term, but eventually I moved towards I moved out of that. It's not
- 55:29that I renounced my face all at once, but I slowly stopped bleeding it.
- 55:32Well, I'm gonna camp out here. If you'll forgive the phrasing camp
- 55:37out, please do Were the flyers pitching, hey, come out, the
- 55:43kids will get canoeing and hiking and crafts and fun and games and make new
- 55:47friends. Did they focus on, you know, the camp aspect more than
- 55:52the church aspect, because that's what a lot of them do. Oh?
- 55:54Absolutely, I mean we didn't have canoe maybe we had everything else, the
- 55:59craft i'm and snacks and meet new friends and all of that. Oh yeah,
- 56:02there was a local one here Falls Creek, and they would have all
- 56:07of that. And yet you had to attend a church service three times a
- 56:09day. There was a morning service just as soon as you had breakfast,
- 56:13and then there was a mid day, and then there was an evening for
- 56:16I think two weeks every day, three church services a day. Did you
- 56:21have a regimen to go and worship or praise or be taught or discipled or
- 56:24whatever? Yeah, we had that we had. That was of course.
- 56:28It was you know, an insolent's backyard, and you know we're on picnic
- 56:30tables and so on, and but it was Yeah, it was essentially that
- 56:35kind of message. Were you memorizing verses? Were they training you to evangelize?
- 56:39I mean, flesh it out for me. I'm just curious. Oh
- 56:43yeah, we're learning verses and learning little Bible stories and dull thing. Yes,
- 56:47you're absolutely right. So programming, I mean, is that an overreach?
- 56:52If I say you were being programmed? I think that's a pretty good
- 56:55way to put it. Yeah, I'll buy that for a dollar RoboCop reference.
- 57:00All right, now we're you and I've bonded you and I as eighties
- 57:05and nineties children have bonded. That's awesome. You draw a circle around one
- 57:09of the more insidious aspects of child ministries. It's almost like when there's a
- 57:15local church downtown and they tell parents, Hey, we would like to send
- 57:20a bus into your neighborhood. Put your kids out front, we'll pick them
- 57:23up. We're going to take them to church, and they're going to get
- 57:25games and fun and friends and a free lunch out of the deal. Well,
- 57:30weary parents who've been working their asses off, who would love a break
- 57:35go all that sounds nice, and it's church that'll be benign. So they
- 57:38put their kids out front. They send them off to go frolic and make
- 57:42friends and have fun, not necessarily cognizant of the fact that in order to
- 57:46have all of the good stuff games and food and candy and whatever, they
- 57:52have to sit through an evangelical sermon that warns them about hell and ask them
- 57:57to come forward, drop to their knees and accept Jesus into their heart.
- 58:00It's really insidious and a lot of child based ministries do that kind of thing,
- 58:06and your story is yet another example. And I'm glad you were able
- 58:08to escape because I know that's not always easy. Oh no, it's not.
- 58:13And you're absolutely right. You hit that, and you got some guests
- 58:15on your show that have talked about the same thing. So yeah, absolutely,
- 58:19I am living proof of that. One one way or the other.
- 58:22You're free. You're liberated, not by the blood of the Lamb, and
- 58:25you just sort of did it on your own. But I think that has
- 58:29a lot more meaning. Mark, You're awesome, Thanks for calling the show
- 58:31man. Thank you, sir. All right, we'll see you brother.
- 58:35We've got a show on vacation. It was at vacation Bible School or child
- 58:40based ministries. We've covered it, but I think we did a whole show
- 58:43on Christian summer camps. So if you want to filter through the archives,
- 58:49I know I have six hundred plus shows, but but I think if you
- 58:52just Google search or go to spreaker or iTunes podcasts or whatever, Apple podcast
- 58:58and search the thing King Atheist Christian Summer Camp, I think it should pop
- 59:02up. But we did a whole show exposing some of the more insidious methods
- 59:07that these organizations use. They win could parents and say fun and games.
- 59:10When they get the kids in and have and control the environment, then it's
- 59:15all about theology and doctrine and brain washing. You are amazing, Thanks for
- 59:22listening. Join me on the next show, as I have no illusions,
- 59:27Host of the Scathing Atheist, we are going to talk about Christian video games
- 59:34on the show. Oh you thought the Christian movies were bad, the video
- 59:38games maybe even worse. And I'm going to talk to somebody who has researched
- 59:45decades of this stuff that is coming up on the next show. In the
- 59:49meantime, take care and I will see you. Then. Follow The Thinking
- 59:52Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts. And videos,
- 59:58products like mugs and t shirts. During the Thinking Atheist logo, links to
- 1:00:01atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions.
- 1:00:07Log onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com