Latest / Bloomberg Law / Ed Sheeran's Victory and What It Means for Songwriters
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: I'm obviously very happy with the outcome of the case,
- 0:11Speaker 2: and it looks like I'm not having to retire from
- 0:13Speaker 2: my day job after all. But at the same time,
- 0:15Speaker 2: I'm unbelievably frustrated that basis claims like this are allowed
- 0:18Speaker 2: to go to court at all.
- 0:20Speaker 3: It's the second copyright infringement trial Ed Sheeron has had
- 0:23Speaker 3: to go through in a year, and he made a
- 0:26Speaker 3: dramatic vow from the witness stand that he would quit
- 0:29Speaker 3: music if he was found guilty of infringing Marvin Gaye's
- 0:32Speaker 3: nineteen seventy three classic Let's Get It On. But after
- 0:36Speaker 3: a two week trial, it took a jury only two
- 0:38Speaker 3: hours to come out with a verdict clearing Sharon and
- 0:41Speaker 3: finding that he and his co writer had created his
- 0:44Speaker 3: Grammy winning hit Thinking Out Loud independently, which is an
- 0:49Speaker 3: absolute defense against copyright infringement. Sharon had defended himself with
- 0:53Speaker 3: his guitar, demonstrating for the jury how similar chord progressions
- 0:58Speaker 3: are commonplace musical elements found in numerous songs that no
- 1:02Speaker 3: songwriter can own. He did a similar demonstration on the
- 1:06Speaker 3: Howard Stern Show on Sirius XM.
- 1:09Speaker 1: So my one is when your legs at work like
- 1:12Speaker 1: they used to before, and then there's ever told, do
- 1:16Speaker 1: you likely that I loved you? And then people get ready,
- 1:22Speaker 1: there's a chain of coming and then what was the
- 1:27Speaker 1: looks like we made it? Look how far we've come?
- 1:31Speaker 1: A baby? And don't she breaks sty?
- 1:36Speaker 2: I mean there was, there was one hundred and one songs.
- 1:38Speaker 3: Despite the win, Shearing expressed frustration at the current litigation
- 1:42Speaker 3: frenzy that threatens songwriters.
- 1:45Speaker 2: It's devastating to be accused of stealing someone else's song
- 1:49Speaker 2: when we've put so much work into our livelihoods. I'm
- 1:52Speaker 2: just a guy with a guitar who loves writing music
- 1:54Speaker 2: for people to enjoy.
- 1:55Speaker 3: Joining me is intellectual property litigator Terence Ross, a partner
- 1:59Speaker 3: at Katin Yuchen Terry. The music industry was watching this
- 2:03Speaker 3: lawsuit with trepidation. Does the verdict alleviate the fears?
- 2:07Speaker 4: You know?
- 2:07Speaker 3: Will it discourage frivolous copyright lawsuits?
- 2:11Speaker 4: You would hope. So. It is certainly significant in that
- 2:14Speaker 4: regard and seems to indicate that the pendulum in these
- 2:18Speaker 4: copyright in song cases has swung back in favor of
- 2:23Speaker 4: the singer songwriters and away from the plaintiffs. You know this.
- 2:26Speaker 4: I'll start it with a twenty fifteen lawsuit against Pharrell
- 2:31Speaker 4: Williams and Robin Thick for their Blurred Lines song which
- 2:34Speaker 4: purportedly infringed Marvin Gays nineteen seventy seven. Got to give
- 2:38Speaker 4: it up an enormous jury verdict that got reduced a
- 2:41Speaker 4: little bit on appeal, but that sort of created this
- 2:44Speaker 4: target for plaintiffs to aim at and encourage them to
- 2:49Speaker 4: bring more lawsuits. And now looking back, we've had multiple
- 2:54Speaker 4: wins for defendants, and it seems like that case involving
- 2:58Speaker 4: Robin Diick and Pharol william was actually an outlier and
- 3:01Speaker 4: that we may have made too much of it. And
- 3:04Speaker 4: keep in mind there was a unique situation going there
- 3:06Speaker 4: and that Robin Thick had given just a dreadful deposition
- 3:09Speaker 4: which he later claimed he'd been high giving it, and
- 3:12Speaker 4: they played that to the jury and it was so bad,
- 3:15Speaker 4: you know, the videotape, that it may have influenced the
- 3:17Speaker 4: jury in ways that we didn't fully comprehend at the time. Now,
- 3:21Speaker 4: with a fantastic performance, and I can't call it anything
- 3:24Speaker 4: less than performance, but a Sharon on the stand in
- 3:27Speaker 4: his case. We see how these cases really do favor
- 3:30Speaker 4: the defendant if the defendant is a credible person who
- 3:33Speaker 4: gives a good test bony and can explain the basis
- 3:36Speaker 4: of his song.
- 3:37Speaker 3: Yeah. I believe that it was the defense attorney in
- 3:39Speaker 3: the Blurred Lines case that said that Shearon made all
- 3:42Speaker 3: the difference here.
- 3:44Speaker 5: He was so committed.
- 3:45Speaker 3: He was in the court every day, he was on
- 3:47Speaker 3: stand from multiple days.
- 3:49Speaker 5: He's this nice guy. But also he took on.
- 3:53Speaker 3: The defense now and again and even called the musicologist
- 3:57Speaker 3: for the other side. So what he was doing was criminal.
- 4:00Speaker 4: You're exactly right, June, and he had made the mistake
- 4:03Speaker 4: early in his career of caving in and settling a
- 4:06Speaker 4: couple copyright lawsuits. The reality is that it's often cheaper
- 4:11Speaker 4: to settle some of these copyright suits than to spend
- 4:14Speaker 4: the money to defend against them. The problem is, if
- 4:17Speaker 4: you get that reputation, people just put you at the
- 4:19Speaker 4: top of their list of targets to go after for
- 4:22Speaker 4: copyright infringement, even though you've not been held libel for
- 4:26Speaker 4: copyright infringement and you don't think you did it. And
- 4:28Speaker 4: a couple of years ago it sharing apparently said to himself,
- 4:31Speaker 4: enough is enough. He defended aggressively a copyright lawsuit in
- 4:35Speaker 4: the UK, which he won. It was last year. This
- 4:38Speaker 4: case has been going on since before the pandemic. It
- 4:41Speaker 4: was brought, and he's been aggressively defending in and I
- 4:44Speaker 4: think with this win, two wins in two years, sending
- 4:47Speaker 4: a very strong message that if you come after him
- 4:50Speaker 4: for copyright infringement, you better be prepared to go the distance,
- 4:53Speaker 4: and you better be prepared to get your rear end kicked,
- 4:55Speaker 4: because he is not giving in anymore, not settling these lawsuits,
- 5:00Speaker 4: and that's going to make all the difference going forward
- 5:02Speaker 4: for him.
- 5:03Speaker 3: The jury found that Scheran had created Thinking out Loud independently.
- 5:08Speaker 3: That's an absolute defense against copyright infringement. Even if it's
- 5:12Speaker 3: a song you've heard and it might have influenced you, it.
- 5:15Speaker 4: Is an absolute defense. So you could say that two
- 5:19Speaker 4: songs have some substantial similarity, which is the test for
- 5:22Speaker 4: copyright infringement, but if the song was independently created, it
- 5:27Speaker 4: just doesn't matter that they're substantially similar. That's an absolute defense.
- 5:30Speaker 4: And the key I think here at this trial was
- 5:33Speaker 4: a you're in getting up on the stand as you
- 5:35Speaker 4: said multiple times and explaining the songwriting process in such detail,
- 5:40Speaker 4: even explaining he wanted to take a break, take a shower,
- 5:43Speaker 4: came back his co writer was working on some chords.
- 5:46Speaker 4: The detail is what brought it home to the jury
- 5:49Speaker 4: that this wasn't in any sense of copying, that there
- 5:52Speaker 4: was a true creative process here, that he was able
- 5:55Speaker 4: to relate to them and explain an enormous, specific factual
- 6:00Speaker 4: detail and then was backed up by his co writer
- 6:03Speaker 4: on this particular song, Amy Wadge, do.
- 6:05Speaker 5: You think the musicologists played a part in this?
- 6:08Speaker 3: I mean whether one was better than the other, whether
- 6:11Speaker 3: the jury like one more than the other.
- 6:13Speaker 4: So musicologists testify as expert witnesses. The only difference between
- 6:17Speaker 4: expert witness and the other witnesses that an expert witness
- 6:21Speaker 4: is allowed to offer his or her opinion based on
- 6:24Speaker 4: their expertise, whereas a lay witness can only testify to
- 6:28Speaker 4: facts that they actually saw witness experienced. And as a result,
- 6:32Speaker 4: sometimes jurors, because there's this process of qualifying an expert
- 6:36Speaker 4: making them seem to be great juris, say well, they
- 6:38Speaker 4: must know something more than we do, because the judge
- 6:41Speaker 4: has specific said they're an expert in the field, and
- 6:43Speaker 4: we may want to defer to them. My experience has
- 6:45Speaker 4: been that in these sorts of cases where you have
- 6:47Speaker 4: a very articulate defendant who can explain the songwriting process,
- 6:52Speaker 4: that the musicologists sort of flip into the background a
- 6:56Speaker 4: little bit and are less important. Now that's set here
- 6:58Speaker 4: in this so called battle the experts between the two musicologists,
- 7:01Speaker 4: it is clear that Edsurance god got the better of
- 7:04Speaker 4: the argument and got helped in that respect enormously by
- 7:08Speaker 4: Edsuran's own testimony. In his testimony during his defense part
- 7:11Speaker 4: of the case, ed Sheeran specifically when after the plain
- 7:15Speaker 4: tests musicologists and explained how this particular chord progression, or
- 7:19Speaker 4: at least the second chord in the chord progression, was
- 7:21Speaker 4: not substitutable, and how it really made a significant difference
- 7:25Speaker 4: in how a pop song came out, And he played
- 7:27Speaker 4: and explained to the jury almost as if he was
- 7:29Speaker 4: his own musicologist expert. And I think that's really was
- 7:32Speaker 4: a turning point. His musicologist then picked up on that
- 7:35Speaker 4: theme and supported it and sort of gave legal credence
- 7:38Speaker 4: to it. But again, I think this was Edsurance testimony
- 7:41Speaker 4: that won the day.
- 7:42Speaker 3: Jerry Verdick doesn't set any legal precedent. But the way
- 7:45Speaker 3: that Sharon testified about chord progressions he used that are
- 7:49Speaker 3: common among songwriters and building blocks of music, do you
- 7:54Speaker 3: think this provides a blueprint for other songwriters accused of
- 7:58Speaker 3: copyright infringement?
- 8:00Speaker 4: So the defense here certainly wrote a script on how
- 8:04Speaker 4: to handle this sort of copyright infringement lawsuit and if followed,
- 8:10Speaker 4: should yield simple results. The interesting thing about this whole
- 8:12Speaker 4: case is that the judge studiously avoided writing any decisions
- 8:16Speaker 4: that might have served in any way as presidential. It
- 8:20Speaker 4: was very curious. It makes it very difficult to challenge
- 8:23Speaker 4: on a pile as well. But you have here as
- 8:25Speaker 4: a straight up jury verdict with a jury finding, and
- 8:27Speaker 4: appellate courts say that apps them some sort of corruption,
- 8:30Speaker 4: some sort of fraud committed, They got proper instructions which
- 8:33Speaker 4: they did that you don't overturn jury verdict. So what's
- 8:36Speaker 4: interesting in that respect because I think it's less the
- 8:38Speaker 4: presidential value this case that matters going forward than sort
- 8:42Speaker 4: of the notions that defendants are no longer going to
- 8:46Speaker 4: roll over and settled just because of an accusation of
- 8:48Speaker 4: copyright vengement that Gore vigorously defended and that this is
- 8:51Speaker 4: not going to be easy pickings, which is how it's
- 8:54Speaker 4: been viewed for the last five six seven years in
- 8:57Speaker 4: the Robin Thick Blurred Lines case.
- 9:00Speaker 3: We've said about the defense here. There are two more
- 9:03Speaker 3: lawsuits against shear And over the same song, brought by
- 9:08Speaker 3: investment banker and musician David Pullman and Structured Asset Sales,
- 9:13Speaker 3: which bought a portion of ed Towns in the state.
- 9:16Speaker 3: And after the verdict, Pullman said that he and his
- 9:19Speaker 3: lawyers had learned from the trial, we know what to expect.
- 9:22Speaker 5: Why another trial about the same song.
- 9:26Speaker 4: It's a great question, and it's a real problem in
- 9:29Speaker 4: this field. My understanding of the situation is that a
- 9:34Speaker 4: third party funder obtained rights to portion of the copyright
- 9:39Speaker 4: owned by ed Townsend's estate, which gave them independent standing
- 9:44Speaker 4: to sue for infringement. I think there's going to be
- 9:46Speaker 4: a real question when that lawsuit is right, whether or
- 9:50Speaker 4: not the verdict here, which was specific verdict of independent
- 9:53Speaker 4: creation is what's known has raised judokata. In other words,
- 9:56Speaker 4: it decides the issue once and for all. That motion
- 9:59Speaker 4: will have to be brought by the defense and it's
- 10:01Speaker 4: a pretty strong motion, so they may not get to
- 10:05Speaker 4: a trial in that second lawsuit.
- 10:07Speaker 3: Well, the Pullman said one of his lawsuits would be
- 10:10Speaker 3: different because it involved a copyright on the recording of
- 10:14Speaker 3: Let's Get It On, rather than just the sheet music.
- 10:17Speaker 3: I know we've discussed it before, the sheet music versus
- 10:19Speaker 3: the recording, whether that does make a difference.
- 10:23Speaker 4: So it's one of the anomalies of twentieth century US
- 10:27Speaker 4: music that we did not have copyright protection for recorded
- 10:32Speaker 4: sound until very late in the twenty century nineteen seventy eight. Well, correctly,
- 10:38Speaker 4: the law that was the copyright law for most of
- 10:41Speaker 4: the twentieth century, the Copyright Act of nineteen oh nine,
- 10:44Speaker 4: did not allow for copyright and recorded sound because it
- 10:48Speaker 4: was in its infancy. It did allow in copyright lonios.
- 10:51Speaker 4: That's going well back into the nineteenth century, allowed for
- 10:55Speaker 4: copyright in sheet music. And so at the time that
- 10:58Speaker 4: What's Getting on was published, record it there was alay
- 11:01Speaker 4: copyright available in sheet music. Now there is one sort
- 11:06Speaker 4: of variant on that. There are states, individual states that
- 11:09Speaker 4: have allowed copyright and record is found earlier than the
- 11:13Speaker 4: United States Congress did, and apparently they were going to
- 11:16Speaker 4: make some sort of claim under state law. You remember
- 11:19Speaker 4: a couple of years ago the old pop group The Turtles,
- 11:22Speaker 4: who recorded all of their music prior to the Copyright
- 11:26Speaker 4: Act of nineteen seventy six coming into effect and allowing
- 11:29Speaker 4: for copyright recorders. They brought a series of lawsuits across
- 11:32Speaker 4: the country under very state laws accusing the streaming services
- 11:36Speaker 4: of infringing their copyright purported copyright, and ultimately settled when
- 11:39Speaker 4: they got a favorable decision out of one of those states,
- 11:42Speaker 4: I think Florida maybe. So there's this issue that has
- 11:45Speaker 4: always been hanging out there and has never been decided
- 11:47Speaker 4: by the Supreme Court. The Copyright Act, both the nineteen
- 11:50Speaker 4: oh nine Act the nineteen seventy six Act preempted all
- 11:53Speaker 4: other laws. But because record it sound wasn't covered by
- 11:57Speaker 4: the nineteen oh nine Act, it wasn't in theory a
- 12:00Speaker 4: preemptive of recorded sound copy because there was none. So
- 12:04Speaker 4: the states were free to do what they wanted to do.
- 12:06Speaker 4: And so that's what the reference here is with respect
- 12:08Speaker 4: to this other lawsuit in the.
- 12:10Speaker 3: Sharing case with a computerized version of Let's Get It
- 12:13Speaker 3: On based on the sheet music, if the plaintiffs in
- 12:17Speaker 3: the next case can actually play the song. Do you
- 12:20Speaker 3: think that would make a difference even if Sharon testifies
- 12:24Speaker 3: as as he did here.
- 12:25Speaker 4: So clearly made a difference in the Blurred Lines case.
- 12:28Speaker 4: I was not in the court room when that happened.
- 12:30Speaker 4: A lot of people said that the playing of those
- 12:32Speaker 4: two when listened to by the jury, seemed to have
- 12:34Speaker 4: an impact upon the jury, So it is possible that
- 12:37Speaker 4: it would have that pack here. I've listened to both songs.
- 12:39Speaker 4: You know a little bit about music, but I'm not
- 12:41Speaker 4: some sort of musicologist expert, and I'm not sure that
- 12:44Speaker 4: it would make a difference to me. But you know,
- 12:46Speaker 4: every jury's different, and I have to wait and see
- 12:49Speaker 4: what happens. But again, I think it's important to note
- 12:52Speaker 4: that the jury made a really important factual finding here
- 12:55Speaker 4: that this was an independent creation. That should really, my view,
- 12:59Speaker 4: can role.
- 13:00Speaker 5: Another thing about these suits is this was seven years
- 13:05Speaker 5: and you think about how long the Stairway to Heaven
- 13:08Speaker 5: and the Katy Perry was.
- 13:09Speaker 3: This involves the artists with lawyers for so many years.
- 13:14Speaker 4: Yes, this case is an example of what happened to
- 13:18Speaker 4: the court system in certain jurisdictions around the country during
- 13:23Speaker 4: the pandemic. This case was filed before the pandemic was
- 13:26Speaker 4: moving at a nice clip, and then the pandemic hit.
- 13:29Speaker 4: In that particular court, the Southern District New York, which
- 13:32Speaker 4: is the court for the City of New York, just FROs,
- 13:35Speaker 4: they had trouble dealing with the whole pandemic issue. Not
- 13:39Speaker 4: every court in America did that. I tried a virtual
- 13:42Speaker 4: case in May of twenty twenty when the pandemic first started,
- 13:46Speaker 4: the very first virtual trial in the United States, and
- 13:49Speaker 4: we did just find that way not every court was
- 13:52Speaker 4: capable of managing the process. And then once the court reopened,
- 13:57Speaker 4: then they started getting a handle on how the cases.
- 14:01Speaker 4: During the pandemic, they were stuck with the unusual situation
- 14:04Speaker 4: that Edsurant was not allowed to come into the country
- 14:07Speaker 4: because of various international bands on travel during the pandemic,
- 14:11Speaker 4: and the court rightfully said, defendant is entitled to be
- 14:15Speaker 4: there for trial and iled to testify and should be
- 14:18Speaker 4: heard live. And so that delayed even further. And then
- 14:22Speaker 4: all that delay in that particular court some Industrict New
- 14:24Speaker 4: York created this backlog so that when we finally got
- 14:27Speaker 4: out from under the pandemic and the court system, you
- 14:30Speaker 4: had all these cases that had to be tried first
- 14:32Speaker 4: because there were criminal cases. In the United States, we
- 14:34Speaker 4: have a Speedy Trial Act. You've got to try criminal
- 14:37Speaker 4: cases when it's a certain point of time or the
- 14:39Speaker 4: defendant walks, and so all those criminal cases got priority
- 14:42Speaker 4: over civil cases. And so it to a better part
- 14:45Speaker 4: of a year and a half before we got around
- 14:47Speaker 4: to this copyright lawsuit. And it is unfortunate that it
- 14:50Speaker 4: took so long, but it's not the norm, and hopefully
- 14:53Speaker 4: things will start getting back to normal.
- 14:55Speaker 3: The deliberation time here is also not the norm.
- 15:00Speaker 4: Jury took on He's like two hours to do this.
- 15:02Speaker 4: I mean, you think about this too. Yeah, the jury
- 15:04Speaker 4: gets back there and it takes a half an hour
- 15:07Speaker 4: to get organized, get a cup of coffee, whatever. And
- 15:10Speaker 4: that's assuming that it's not the lunch breaker ready, in
- 15:12Speaker 4: which case they kill an hour. Then they spend fifteen
- 15:15Speaker 4: to twenty minutes arguing about four person because you got
- 15:17Speaker 4: big four person first, and the bailiff brings in the
- 15:20Speaker 4: forums and they go, okay, what is it that we're
- 15:22Speaker 4: supposed to say that sort of thing? You know, So
- 15:24Speaker 4: that two plus hours is probably only an hour of
- 15:27Speaker 4: deliberation time.
- 15:28Speaker 3: It'll be interesting to see if those other cases get
- 15:32Speaker 3: to trial because Ed Sheeran. Now it's his second time testifying,
- 15:36Speaker 3: second time winning. I think he knows what to do now,
- 15:40Speaker 3: Thanks so much, Terry. That's intellectual property litigator Terrence Ross,
- 15:44Speaker 3: a partner at Katin Yuchen Rosenman. And that's it for
- 15:47Speaker 3: this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can
- 15:50Speaker 3: always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 15:53Speaker 3: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 15:56Speaker 3: www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcas Cast slash Law,
- 16:01Speaker 3: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 16:04Speaker 3: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
- 16:08Speaker 3: and you're listening to Bloomberg