Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Could It Be That This Is the Most Powerful Question You're Not Asking?
Transcript
- Catalyst - Could It Be?: I spend a lot of time reading books, marking pages, filling up notebooks and collecting ideas. They eventually find their way into a wooden box on an index card on my desk. Most of those ideas begin as simple observations. Small things, ordinary things. A phrase spoken, a question asked. Most are insignificant until they aren't. Today's episode is about two small Such utterances. They are separated by only a few words, but may represent two entirely different ways of engaging with the world. The first one we hear nearly every day, if not in our heads, from the voices of others. The second sounds familiar but carries a very different weight. One begins with a conclusion, the other begins with a possibility. One can position us as the owner of an answer, the other invites us into a shared. Exploration. Welcome to Catalyst, a podcast of thought. I'm Dr. G, executive coach, trained ethnographer, and lifelong student of human behavior and the words we use. Over the next few minutes, I'd like to explore these phrases and what they might reveal about how we think, how we lead, how we learn, and perhaps most importantly, how we remain curious in a world that increasingly rewards certainty. So let's begin with a simple question. Could it be that some of our most limiting assumptions arrive disguised as our most confident thoughts? I've heard people repeat things I've said. My students, my friends, my family. Sometimes minutes later while they're laughing. Sometimes ⁓ years later, while they're thinking. Occasionally they'll tell me where they heard it. More often they won't. The thought simply keeps moving. I've come to appreciate that ideas have lives of their own. They leave us and they enter conversations we'll never hear. They become part of how someone understands the world, and perhaps part of how they help someone else understand it. Today's reflection began with a phrase I've heard myself say thousands of times. I'm sure you've said it too. It's the phrase I think. I think we should do this. I think that's the problem. I think they're making a mistake. I think the Vikings will finally win a Super Bowl. Some people might call that wishful I thinking, but that's what I think. Nothing unusual here, nothing controversial in the phrase I think, yet the more I've paid attention to those words, the more I've begin wonder if they reveal something deeper about how we approach the world. Not because those words are wrong, but because they may subtly shape our relationship with certainty. Deep stuff, I know. That's pretty much my default here. So in my descent down the I think rabbit hole, I found myself comparing I think with another phrase that sounds similar but feels different. Could it be that? Let's look at the two phrases in context. I think that's the problem becomes. Could it be that we're solving the wrong problem? I think they're wrong. Becomes. Could it be that they're seeing something we are not? The difference between the two expressions is slight. The difference in mindset feels significant. Let's begin with a simple observation. I like being right. I suspect that you do too. There's something deeply satisfying about understanding a situation. Arriving at a conclusion. and having that conclusion confirmed. We are pattern-making creatures. We constantly gather information, interpret it, and construct explanations. Without this ability, we would struggle to function in our complex world. The problem isn't that we think. The problem is what sometimes happens after we think. We become attached to our thought. A simple conclusion that began as a vague interpretation. quickly becomes an absolute certainty. What started as a possibility hardens into a position. Once that happens, curiosity and conversation often begin to fade. What's fascinating about the phrase I think is that the actual focus of the statement isn't the idea being discussed. The focus is on the thinker. The sentence begins with me. I think. The spotlight focuses directly on my interpretation, my conclusion, my certainty. The ancient Greeks might have recognized this as an appeal to ethos, the credibility of the speaker. Whether consciously or unconsciously, the phrase asks the listener to consider me, my judgment, my conclusion. It says in effect, here's how I see this thing, judge me. It shines light on the speaker less than the idea. There's nothing inherently wrong with that. Experience matters. Expertise matters. Effective judgment matters. Notice what can happen next when we use I think. Conversations can quietly become contests between competing interpretations, competing conclusions, competing certainties. The question shifts from what to who. What are we discovering becomes who is right. The search for understanding can become a search for correctness. It's syntactical thumb wrestling. Now consider the phrase could it be that? Notice where the spotlight moves. It is no longer focused on the speaker. It isn't even focused on the listener. The phrase asks the listener to consider an idea. It says, in effect, here is a possibility, judge it. It shines light on the idea, the idea itself. Suddenly we are no longer defending a position. We are examining a proposed interpretation. A group. Examination of a hypothesis. feels less like ethos and more like logos. An invitation ⁓ to consider, to actively reason. It invites exploration rather than agreement. It asks to investigate together ⁓ rather than evaluate one another. What strikes me most is how differently people may respond. Consider the difference between saying, I think you're focusing on the wrong issue. And asking, could it be that we're focusing on the wrong issue? Feel those two sentences again. I think you're focusing on the wrong issue. Could it be that we're focusing on the wrong issue? The first can feel like an accusation, the second an invitation. One closes in around a conclusion, the other opens a door to possibility. Alright, imagination time. Two people visiting a new planet. New life forms. New space. One enters as a judge. Their task is to determine what the life form is, categorize it, explain it, and render a verdict. The other enters as an explorer. Their task is to discover what they have not yet seen. Both on the same planet, they're both intelligent, both highly trained, both are paying attention, but the relationship to uncertainty is completely different. The judge seeks conclusions, certainties. The explorer seeks understanding, possibilities. I think can sometimes place us and others in the role of judge. Could it be that places us in the role of an explorer? This distinction becomes particularly important in leadership. Many leaders were promoted because they had answers. They solved problems. They made decisions. They provided direction. Over time, however, leaders can become trapped by the expectation that they must always know. As a result, conversations begin to sound like this. I think this is what we should do. The room nods, discussion ends. Now imagine a leader asking, Could it be that we're missing something here? Suddenly the room starts thinking. People contribute observations. Assumptions are surfaced. Possibilities emerge. I know this as an educator. Whoever does the thinking does the learning. So if we want a learned team, we need to facilitate such conversations. I think one statement centralizes intelligence. Could it be that the other distributes it? See what I did there? Sure, you did. This connects to another idea I've been exploring lately. Workers do the work. Leaders create the conditions for the work. In such a model, leadership is less about providing correctness and more about facilitating clarity. Rather than supplying answers, leaders create space for better questions. They help people learn the terrain they are exploring rather than constantly giving directions. Of course, the most difficult place to use could it be that or I think isn't in a meeting, it's in our own minds. Especially when we're hurt, especially when we're frustrated, especially when we are convinced that we are right. Someone doesn't return our call, we say to ourselves, I think they're gaslighting me. We could also say, could it be that something else is happening in their lives right now? A colleague seems distant. We say to ourselves, I think they're upset with me. We could also say, could it be they're carrying a weight I know nothing about? We fail. We say to ourselves, I think I should quit. We could also say, could it be that I'm still learning? The power of the question lies not in its ability to eliminate judgment. Its true power lies in its ability to delay judgment long enough for curiosity to arrive, for possibility to be considered. And could it be that this is the greatest gift we give to others, and most importantly, to ourselves? I've often said that I'm less interested in being remembered than in leaving behind ideas that leave a wake of consideration. Ideas that cause people to pause, reconsider, and perhaps see something differently. The distinction between I think and could it be that feels like one of those ideas. Not because one phrase is right and the other is wrong. We need both. There are moments when judgment is required. There are moments when decisions must be made. There are moments when leadership demands clarity and conviction. There are also moments where certainty arrives too early. Moments when our first interpretation becomes our only interpretation. Moments when a question would serve us better than an answer. So we pay attention to our language. Notice how often we begin with, I think. Then every so often, experiment with a different opening. Could it be that? We see what happens, we see which conversations open up, we see what assumptions are exposed, we see what becomes possible. Perhaps the difference between wisdom and certainty ⁓ is not what know, but how long we remain curious before deciding what to Could it be that the more important thing may not be knowing more, but asking a better question? I'm Doctor G. Those are my thoughts. Thanks for listening.