Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / "Don't Be Like the Hypocrites!" (and more listener calls)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking, feels so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. I had
- 0:57this bizarre dream within a dream is very inception. I'm dreaming that I'm in
- 1:03a massive sandstorm. I'm on some sort of a remote ocean beach area.
- 1:08I can tell I into it that there's a giant cliff next to me,
- 1:14although I can't even see it, so this feels extremely remote. I don't
- 1:18have a face covering, and yet somehow I am able to breathe as so
- 1:22much sand is pummeling my body, and I'm walking trying to find what I
- 1:26believe is to be a cave, a haven of safety. And so I'm
- 1:32walking inch by inch trying to find the cave, and all of a sudden,
- 1:38as I am walking in the sandstorm, and I can hear the wind,
- 1:44all of a sudden surrounding me. I hear Selene deond the power of
- 1:51love as I'm your lady and you are my man, just surround and it
- 2:00was perfectly normal in the dream. So as I'm listening to Selene, I
- 2:07finally find the cave, and inside the cave there are hundreds and hundreds of
- 2:12people who have been waiting for me. They're like, oh good, Seth
- 2:15was lost and now he is found. We are all in the cave together
- 2:20and we can ride out the storm. Bizarre. I wake up and Natalie
- 2:24is laying there and she's looking at me, and I said, I had
- 2:27the most chacked up dream. What happened? And I told her the story
- 2:31of the sandstorm and Selene in the cave and she's like, that's jacked up,
- 2:37that's crazy. And we had a good laugh about it. And then
- 2:39I woke up again and she was still asleep next to me. And I
- 2:46had not explained the dream. I had only dreamed I had explained the dream.
- 2:50Well, of course, now I'm paranoid. Is this some kind of
- 2:53infinite regress have I just like, am I awake now? Are you here?
- 3:00Or am I dreaming that you are here? And I'm going to wake
- 3:02up and explain that you were here but you weren't. And then I've got
- 3:06to explain the dream again and again. I'm having a moment. Dreams are
- 3:09bizarre. Anyway. I will wake up in the middle of the night and
- 3:14have had a wild one and say I got to remember this to tell people
- 3:17tomorrow. I wake up the next morning, It's gone. It's totally gone.
- 3:23I can't, for the life of me remember the dream anyway. I
- 3:25remembered that one. Maybe it's because we watched the Selin Dion documentary It's called
- 3:30I Am And I didn't realize that her health problems had been so pronounced.
- 3:38And I'm a tremendous admirer of her talent. She's been an icon for forty
- 3:43years. And whether you like the style of her music or not, I
- 3:46mean, there's no doubt she is an extremely talented performer and she has been
- 3:53through it. She has something called stiff Person's disease SPD, and so when
- 4:00the brain is stimulated, she will totally tighten up and spasm and sees it's
- 4:08horrifying. She is in great pain and it has caused her to not be
- 4:15able to perform. It has robbed her of her voice. It's just horrifying.
- 4:20And they took the cameras right into her life. I mean, she
- 4:25just allowed full access, including access to a tremendously traumatic moment when she had
- 4:31a seizure and she's just in horrible shape. And your heart breaks, and
- 4:38you think, how cruel can life be when you have someone who is essentially
- 4:44born to make music and they are unable to do what they love. And
- 4:48anyway, it was very compelling. I recommend the documentary, but it is
- 4:53sobering. I think we were pretty choked up couple of times, you know,
- 4:57but maybe that's why I had Selene on brain. Things continue to go
- 5:01south in my home state of Oklahoma. Ryan Walters, you're killing me.
- 5:09You're killing me. Ryan Walters, the superintendent of public instruction, once the
- 5:15Bible taught as history in this state. He's just terrifying by the way his
- 5:21Republican colleagues are saying nothing in protest. I just think, what is wrong
- 5:28with you people? And I know there have to be some Christians against Christian
- 5:33nationalism. Are they cowards? They just don't want to rock the boat or
- 5:38look disloyal. But you know, there's got to be some people whispering about
- 5:42this guy and how he's totally out of control and he's already bringing lawsuits upon
- 5:46the state after mandating Christian Bibles and public schools. Ryan Walters has assembled this
- 5:55right wing team to overhaul our social studies programs. On this team Dennis Prager,
- 6:03who is the founder of Prager U. Prager You is not a university.
- 6:11It holds no classes, it has no accreditation, it is not a
- 6:15school. Dennis Prager is a right wing talk radio host. He's one of
- 6:21the power players behind this effort. David Barton an uncredentilled pseudo historian and Christian
- 6:31nationalist soundly debunked by credible experts in the field of history. Steve Diis I
- 6:40think it's Deace, Is it Dias or d s. Steve is a college
- 6:45dropout and a former sports talk radio host who went into journalism for the Blaze
- 6:54Network. And of course the Blaze was founded by Glenn Beck, another right
- 6:59wing radio And then there's Kevin Roberts. He is president of the Heritage Foundation,
- 7:04one of the organizations behind Project twenty twenty five. These are the people
- 7:12that he is having to retool and refit and degrade Oklahoma social studies curriculums.
- 7:20And it's terrifying. In some ways. I feel so helpless. I'm like,
- 7:25look, if these people aren't going to be challenged by their own party,
- 7:29and their own party is the one in power. This is an overwhelmingly
- 7:32strawberry red state. How unbelievably frustrating, And people keep asking why don't she
- 7:41get out of there? Why don't you just leave? And I fantasized about
- 7:45it, But honestly, the cost of living prohibits us from going most places,
- 7:50and I really kind of feel like I need to hang here, you
- 7:54know, at least I'm a blue dot in the middle of a red state.
- 7:57But it is not easy. It is not easy. One else feel
- 8:00that I don't know. I've got a web call. Let's see, I
- 8:07don't see a name. Are you with me? And can you hear me?
- 8:11Yes? I can hear you. How you doing this is Sprinkles with
- 8:13the Reason Writers Atheist Motorcycle Association. How you doing Sprinkles? Welcome to the
- 8:18show? Yeah, yeah, thank you? So my question was regarding your
- 8:22thoughts on the Satanic Temple introducing ministers into the schools out there at Oklahoma after
- 8:26the recent debuncle. I think the Satanic Temple is onto something if we're going
- 8:33to have these Christian nationalists shoving religious dogmas down everybody's throats, and right now
- 8:41where it's in crisis mode, we're trying to block it. But until we
- 8:45block it, if they're going to say we want religion in schools, I
- 8:48welcome the Satanic Temple. Fine, you want to put a cross up,
- 8:52you want to put the Ten Commandments up, you want to put a baby
- 8:54Jesus up. Let's bring in Baphomet and let's put the Bapha met stat you
- 9:00up as well, and have after school Satan and all those things. So
- 9:03I support it. I don't know what's your take on it. My support
- 9:07as well. We recently had a bill out here in Arizona where I'm at,
- 9:11where they are trying to not allow anything Satanic on the grounds of the
- 9:16state capitol where they have a Ten Commandments monument. Of course, and the
- 9:20Satanic Temple out here pushback really really hard, and that bill did not pass
- 9:24because of that pushback. So I think the pushback and the quote unquote scare
- 9:28tactics are unfortunately necessary, especially with Project twenty twenty five at our doorstep.
- 9:35I kind of like TST. They're really good at turning the screw and they're
- 9:39good at turning everybody's words and actions back on themselves. Yep, agreed and
- 9:43agreed with the blue vote in a red state area as well. So I'm
- 9:48right there, all right, brother, So well, hang in there.
- 9:50Thanks for calling. All right, I appreciate you said time a good one.
- 9:54You later the Satanic Temple, you know, I would have been terrifying
- 9:58of anything with Satan and the title. I wrote about this a couple of
- 10:01times in two of my books, where I said, if someone had walked
- 10:05up to my door when I was a devout Christian and they had been holding
- 10:09a copy of the Satanic Bible, which is the Church of Satan, that's
- 10:13different, but any sort of Satanic text, or they were holding a Ouigee
- 10:18board, or had a statue of Beelzebub, something Satanic, I probably would
- 10:22not have allowed them into the house because it was evil. I wasn't going
- 10:28to allow that evil to cross the threshold of my life. Now, when
- 10:33I see Satan and satanic imagery. I just smile. I'm not threatened by
- 10:37it at all. Some of it's kind of awesome. I'm not afraid in
- 10:41any way. I'm totally liberated. And then when those who still believe in
- 10:46that evil, nasty devil see I'm almost flippant about it, they become more
- 10:52terrified that boy's playing with fire. Does he not realize the devil that he
- 11:00is messing with? And they just freak out. And I find that amusing
- 11:05as well. It's a liberation exercise to be able to say I ain't skeered
- 11:09no more. I've got a ja at seven to zero, thanks for calling
- 11:16isis. Growing up high school football, our coach actually had a pregame prayer
- 11:22in the locker room all the time doing the Psalm twenty three four, Which
- 11:26is that ya, though I walk through the valley of shadow? Wait a
- 11:30minute, when public school? Yes, sorry public school growing up in Wyoming
- 11:35so very red and fairly religious in general, but yeah, public school.
- 11:39So this is something that i's teenager. All my other teammates are bowing their
- 11:45head with their eyes closed, and I'm one of the few, if only
- 11:46one, looking around eyeball and everybody's side to side and just not participating,
- 11:50but being in it the whole time. I'm interested in. Yay though,
- 11:54I walk through the Valley of the Shadow of Death before a football game.
- 12:00Was this like a warrior's cry? Yes, I believe so. It's trying
- 12:05to make us face our fears and get out there. So do you think
- 12:09the other team was having a similar prayer? You know, yay though,
- 12:13we walk through the Valley of the Shadow of Death, give us victory,
- 12:16and maybe those prayers sort of cross the field counsel each other out. Probably,
- 12:22but I'm sure they weren't. No one was thinking that. Wow,
- 12:26thanks for calling, Thanks for sharing our concerns about the infection of superstition and
- 12:31public education. Hang in there, okay, okay, sounds good. Thank
- 12:35you. So yeah, I'll see you later. Six' one two. Is
- 12:39it Nicholas, Yes, it is Nicholas. What's on your mind? What
- 12:45do you want to talk about? So? Yeah, I used to be
- 12:48a fundamentalist, now pretty far left. I used to actually be somewhat of
- 12:54a Christian nationalist, although I wouldn't admit it at the time. I actually
- 12:58used to listen to Steve Dace and I now call him the angry potato.
- 13:05He's always frustrated at something. He is very If you turn him on mute
- 13:13and watch him get angry, it is somewhat comical. His rhetoric is very
- 13:18Christian nationalist. It is very much Bible centers. He's got this theology Thursday
- 13:24thing where he misinterprets a Bible. He'll dedicate whole shows to clamping down on
- 13:31gay people or LGBTQ and claiming that we're trying to trans the kids or something
- 13:37like that. One of the things that I very much have learned is that
- 13:43you cannot change your sexuality. I tried for fifteen years, and I prayed,
- 13:48I cried, I did everything that I possibly could, and I just
- 13:52could not. Now it's currently a battle of trying to persuade my family over.
- 13:58Luckily, that is starting to work. My mother and father are kind
- 14:03of starting to open up, showing them that I'm still the same person.
- 14:09But I'm a lot happier now that I've actually come to terms with this.
- 14:13Progress is progress, and you can't expect them to flip overnight. I had
- 14:18to basically dig myself out of the hole that I had kind of created for
- 14:24myself and another thing to acknowledge is that my parents also, because I was
- 14:30very angry with my parents for about half a year, and I then realized
- 14:35they grew up in the same sort of scenario, but it didn't bother them
- 14:41because they weren't cap they weren't an outlier. So they very much are also
- 14:46victims of the very thing that they are putting onto other people. You're doing
- 14:50okay these days, be hanging in there. I am doing better than I
- 14:56ever have emotionally. I like I said after I came out, it's been
- 15:01about a year now, and I am doing very well emotionally. I feel
- 15:05free. Christianity ended up being this anchor that kind I felt like it was
- 15:11anchored to the bottom of the ocean, and the chain wasn't quite long enough,
- 15:15but the anchor is very heavy, and so I would go with the
- 15:18tides, i would get pulled underwater. And now I've cut that anchor loose
- 15:22and I'm free to steer my vessel wherever I please. So I'm doing very
- 15:28well. I appreciate you asking that's fantastic. Well, Nicholas. You are
- 15:33valid and your life is yours to live, and you inspire me, and
- 15:37I appreciate the call today. Thank you, Thank you very much, Seth.
- 15:41I see you later. When I got out of religion, one of
- 15:43the habits I had to break when I would talk about the gay lifestyle,
- 15:48which is how we spoke about it, the gay lifestyle. And even then
- 15:52I wasn't cognizant of what I was saying. Really, I mean, yes,
- 15:56I saw it as rebellion against nature. Right, it's Adam and Eve,
- 16:02not Adam and Steve. I was that guy. But when I left
- 16:06the faith, I was still using the phrase and someone had to correct me.
- 16:11You know, when you know better, you do better. And they
- 16:14were like, well, it's it's an orientation, it's not a lifestyle.
- 16:18Lifestyle implies a choice. Well, you know, I didn't choose to be
- 16:22attracted to so and so or such and such or a certain gender, etc.
- 16:26That is hardwired into me. It is part of the natural world.
- 16:30So when you say lifestyle that sort of I don't know. It gives a
- 16:36little bit of fuel to those who say that it's a choice instead of an
- 16:40orientation, and I had to make that adjustment in my own life. I
- 16:42also appreciate the fact that Nicholas sees his parents not just perpetrators of bad ideas,
- 16:49but victims of bad ideas. I spoke about this a little bit on
- 16:53my Facebook page, and it's so unpopular with a lot of people who just
- 16:59want to go hard. They just don't see the perpetrators of harm in three
- 17:03dimensions. Let me read this and you can agree disagree. Let me have
- 17:08it in the comments section, I said, this isn't a popular opinion,
- 17:14but I'm convinced we'll never build a better future without speaking to the humanity of
- 17:19those with bad ideas. Yes, we should be outraged at the outrageous,
- 17:25but empathy, grace, and compassion are not the enemies of justice. They're
- 17:30not a cheat, weakness, or enabling And in this toxic fuck you culture
- 17:37of zero to crazy self righteous tantrum, someone has to be the adult in
- 17:42the room. As I emerged from my Fox News evangelical cocoon, I was
- 17:48a human being with a future worth salvaging, and I moved my needle only
- 17:55when I didn't feel like I'd get destroyed. The world is complex, people
- 18:00are complex, and yes it's possible for someone to be both a perpetrator of
- 18:06harm and a victim of harm. In doctrination is real and it runs deep
- 18:12those everyday people need an introduction to the better world. They need tools,
- 18:19they need rescue. And I posted a quote by Carl Sagan and I'll just
- 18:26read it here. He said, in the way that skepticism is sometimes applied
- 18:30to issues of public concern, there is a tendency to belittle, to condescend,
- 18:36to ignore the fact that deluded or not supporters of superstition and pseudoscience are
- 18:42human beings with real feelings, who, like the skeptics, are trying to
- 18:48figure out how the world works and what our role in it might be.
- 18:52Their motives are in many cases consonant with science, if their culture has not
- 19:00given them all the tools they need to pursue the great quest. Let us
- 19:04temper our criticism with kindness. None of us comes fully equipped. I post
- 19:14that, and immediately people are like, well, I'm not gonna be kind
- 19:18to not cease. I swear, it's just so difficult to talk to so
- 19:26many of these people. I find myself frustrated. It's like you're not hearing
- 19:30me. Plenty of calls still to come on whatever is on your mind,
- 19:36short break right back. If you haven't checked out my second show, we'd
- 19:48love to have you subscribe on all major podcast apps. True Stories with Seth
- 19:52Andrews. Most of these run about seven minutes and they can be anything and
- 20:00history, weird news, stupid criminals, celebrity trivia, I mean whatever,
- 20:06Just a poe Perie for you. True Stories with Sath Andrews and thanks so
- 20:11much. I've got Scott making an online call. Are you with me?
- 20:18Scott? I'm here. Can you hear me? I sure can. What's
- 20:21on your mind? I'm wondering if you think this topic I put in here
- 20:26is fair? So the topic I put in was I think secular people,
- 20:30secular or atheist or skeptic people who are disinterested in supporting humanist groups or congregations
- 20:38are in some ways similar to what I'm calling I've got mine conservatives, the
- 20:44people who don't want to pay taxes or services for services that they don't need
- 20:49themselves. So they're the spiritual kind of equivalent of I don't need a community,
- 20:56so I'm not going to support communities. But there are other people out
- 21:00there in the world who do need these communities, And from my perspective,
- 21:06these alternative communities would be stronger if more people were supporting them, even if
- 21:11they weren't the immediate people that would benefit from them. Does that making sense?
- 21:15It does. I think we're talking about so many millions of people,
- 21:19the non religious, the atheist, the agnostic, the seculars, and I
- 21:23think people disengage for a lot of reasons. I think there are some who
- 21:29are like, ah, it doesn't bother me any it does no skin off
- 21:32my teeth. What am I going to engage for? Which is I think
- 21:34what you're addressing that whole screw it. I've got mine. My life's not
- 21:40affected. It doesn't relate to me personally. Do I think those people exist?
- 21:44Sure? But I also see out there so many other things that are
- 21:48those disenfranchised, and they feel like it's not going to make any difference no
- 21:52matter what they do. It's all going to hell. We're circling the drain.
- 21:57I'm just going to batten down the head hatches, maybe find a lawn
- 22:02share to watch the decline of civilization. Yeah, nothing matters, nothing means
- 22:08anything. I think there are some who are overwhelmed so they don't know where
- 22:14to begin. I'm not a psychologist, but I think human beings are complex
- 22:18and their reasons for not engaging are complex. But I find myself frustrated,
- 22:23probably like you are, because with democracy and decency on the bubble, and
- 22:30with these superstitious delates and the power worshipers on the front line steam rolling over
- 22:37the rights and liberties and humanity of other people, I feel like that there's
- 22:42any time people need to get off the bench, it's now, and I
- 22:45get frustrated that they do not. Yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah.
- 22:51I've heard some other sort of prominent voices and the sort of atheist skeptic community
- 22:56when things like this come up, say things like, well, I don't
- 22:57feel a need to meet with other people on a Sunday, or don't I
- 23:03feel my needs through other things. I have hobbies and stuff like that.
- 23:07Well, that may be something a little bit different. There are those who
- 23:11may say I don't require a community to get what I want out of being
- 23:17alive. You know, I think we're mostly a communal species, but some
- 23:22have been burned by church communities and they're kind of gun shy about joining an
- 23:26oasis or a free thought or your minister secular group. And I get that.
- 23:30I empathize with that. And there are other people where they're more independent,
- 23:34they don't really need it in their own lives. But I think that
- 23:37kind of choice not to join a group because I simply am not interested I
- 23:44don't really want to is different than well, I'm not going to engage with
- 23:48activism because it doesn't matter, or because it doesn't affect me personally. I
- 23:55think those may be two different conversations. True. Yeah, I'm a little
- 24:00frustrated with the independent ones. You know, we're all hurting cats is the
- 24:03analogy, all going our own ways, so it's hard to organize and create
- 24:07progress and good in the world when on the other side of things, they
- 24:11all seem to be in lockstep. So it creates the sin of frustration.
- 24:15If we could, maybe, even if you're a little bit uncomfortable with it,
- 24:18try to support some of the organization or try to, you know,
- 24:22if we can organize our resources better. There's all sorts of groups around the
- 24:26place, like you mentioned Oasis, There's Ethical Society, Sunday Assembly, all
- 24:30sorts of things, and they're out there and they're trying to make the world
- 24:34a better place. And I just kind of want to make a case that
- 24:37people should look into it more and support them if they can. I think
- 24:40you're absolutely right. Good stop Scott thanks for calling. Yep, thank you
- 24:44all. I'd see them. I hear some of that. I'm not a
- 24:48joiner. You're not going to make me be a part of a group.
- 24:52Group think. Ah, I left that all behind. It's it's not just
- 24:56a choice to be more of I hate the word loaner because it sounds like
- 25:00a pejorative. You know what I mean. You don't necessarily want to be
- 25:03a part of an organization, which is valid, but it's the whole.
- 25:07Well, anytime you join a group, you are a member of the herd.
- 25:12You are guilty of group think, and I just think that's crazy.
- 25:17We're more effective together. I think life is in most cases more enjoyed when
- 25:22we share it together. And there are a lot of great groups out there,
- 25:27secular and free thought groups. I've been watching the work that Will Judy
- 25:33and the folks at Secular Houston have been doing down in Texas. Man.
- 25:37They're wiring in and getting people involved politically as the conservative evangelical Zealots are going
- 25:45after the school boards and the mayoral races and trying to affect local politics so
- 25:51that it might propel up into regional, state, national politics. They're on
- 25:55the front lines doing great things, and anybody who supports secular values in state
- 26:00church separation is welcome to participate. And that's a great group. And even
- 26:06if you didn't want to join the group, you could donate a few bucks
- 26:08or find another way to support it. And I'm guessing there are probably organizations
- 26:14in your relative zip code that might be doing the same thing. Don't reject
- 26:18it because it is a group, because sometimes groups can get a hell of
- 26:23a lot more done, and we are more effective as a team. I've
- 26:30got Katie at six seven eight, Katie, are you with me? I
- 26:33am fair? How are you today? Fantastic? What's on your mind?
- 26:38I know that basic mainline's Christianity is not said the cult and it is by
- 26:45the bike model. But I have two needss that I say they behave as
- 26:52if they belong to a cult. They don't have any social life outside their
- 26:57church, church ens, church activities. There's nothing else side of your church.
- 27:03I actually think Christianity is a cult, at least fundamentalist Christianity. It
- 27:08is an authoritarian model. There is a savior figure, there is a truth
- 27:14with a capital T. There is behavior monitoring and modification. There is blaming
- 27:18and shaming for anybody who does not toe the line. It is an insular
- 27:22culture where if you go outside you might be in danger or receiving lies from
- 27:30the devil or deceivers snowing. I think Christianity fits, and I think all
- 27:36the major mainstream theistic religions are in fact cults, regardless of how large they
- 27:41may be. Thank you for that, because actually I've been leaning in that
- 27:47way for a long time. But then I keep being told no, no,
- 27:49no, they don't fit the biite model. But well, I mean
- 27:52you're referring to the model put together by cult expert Stephen Hassen for behavioral control,
- 28:02information control, thought control, and emotion control. So behavior, information,
- 28:10thought, emotion b ite. And I'm not saying that's in value.
- 28:14I'm just saying if we look at the definition of cults, often they are
- 28:18seen as fringe. They are seen as small, well outside the mainstream.
- 28:23But if you look at the characteristics of a cult, they actually can apply
- 28:29to Christianity, Islam, etc. All you do is multiply the members.
- 28:33So I think the atmosphere of the culture, the dogmas, the control,
- 28:37those types of things, they are the same, and in my mind it
- 28:41qualifies Christianity at least in a fundamental Bible literalist sense. I do see it
- 28:45as a large cult. Okay, Katie, okay. And one other question,
- 28:51if you have time, sure here, I know that there's not a
- 28:55four year old that was within the realm of Christianity can't restarte the Lord's Prayers
- 29:00and it's plaster walls recited inside, outside, everywhere. But if you ask
- 29:07any of these people what the verses just prior to the Lord's Prayer says,
- 29:12and not one of them can tell you. And I don't remember hearing any
- 29:17minister preach about those verses. That's from the Senate on the Mount Well,
- 29:22Jesus said, could go to your closet and pray, do not pray and
- 29:25plug that. Do not even pray in the synagogue. And none of them
- 29:30know this. And whenever you see a lot of these posturing zealot types doing
- 29:34performative prayers, they're standing outside the gate to the halls of power, and
- 29:38they dropped to their knees and oh Lord, oh, we dedicate this nation
- 29:42to your goodness. And you're like, uh, have you read the Book
- 29:47of Matthew. I understand totally what you're talking about. So I appreciate you
- 29:52so much, Katie. Thank you for calling, Thanks for being a part
- 29:53of the community. Have a good one, Okay, you do, all
- 29:57right, We'll see you later. If I'm going to confess, although I'm
- 30:00familiar with both, I never in my brain connected those two. So I
- 30:06must admit Guilt's not the word. I'll admit to ignorance. It is interesting
- 30:11to read the verse. Let me just read the whole thing, Matthew,
- 30:15Chapter six. Be careful not to practice your righteousness in front of others to
- 30:18be seen by them. If you do, you will have no reward from
- 30:25your father in heaven. So when you give to the needy, do not
- 30:27announce it with trumpets, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and on the
- 30:33streets to be honored by others. And if I skip down to verse five,
- 30:37when you pray, don't be like the hypocrites, for they love to
- 30:41pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners. And then of course
- 30:47it goes down to verse nine and starts the Lord's Prayer, which was taught
- 30:51to us as a song. A great way to brand it into somebody's brain.
- 30:56Make it a piece of music, you know, Father, who are
- 31:00in heaven? How low would be thy name? We actually would sing it
- 31:06sometimes in church, which, now I think about it actually does seem a
- 31:11little bit culty. I've got Diane two two five? Are you there?
- 31:18Yes? I am ill set, so glad you called. What do you
- 31:22want to talk about? I was just thinking about how religious trauma is so
- 31:26sneaky. While you're still in the religion. You consume so many harmful ideas
- 31:33and you just buy into them and don't realize the damage it's doing. And
- 31:37I get concerned thinking about my religious family members, and they don't see any
- 31:42harm in the things that they're pushing, but I can't believe that it's not
- 31:48doing harm to them. Can you describe the type of religion that they practice?
- 31:53Yes, fundamentalist Christianity here in the South. I live in Louisiana.
- 31:59So Adam and Eve and Noah built the arc, and Jonah spent three days
- 32:05inside the whale, and Jesus was born in a manger kind of thing.
- 32:08Yeah, by the literist, lerialist and younger creationist. I know for myself.
- 32:15I just a couple of weeks ago I came out to my parents as
- 32:19both an atheist, and a member of the LGBTQ community. And one thing
- 32:25that I noticed is when I told them I didn't believe in God, my
- 32:30dad got up and hugged me. When I told him that I was gay,
- 32:36he threw his hands in the air and said, oh, I really
- 32:37didn't want to hear that. There was a bigger reaction to the homosexuality thing
- 32:43than even the not believing in God. And he's a pastor, so I
- 32:45would think that logically he'd be more upset that I rejected the belief in God
- 32:52than the other stuff. That's pretty gutsy that go in and drop two bombs
- 32:57on him like that, face to face, said you been wrestling with the
- 33:00decision to come out for a while. Yeah. I deconverted from Christianity about
- 33:07two years ago, and I didn't even realize about my sexuality until like January
- 33:15of this year. Just the messages from the church had made me repress it
- 33:20so much I didn't even know it about myself. I was shocked whenever I
- 33:23realized that I wasn't straight, even though I had never really had any interest
- 33:28in guys. When you were a believer, there must have been that tumult
- 33:31going on. I mean there's a dissonance happening. Where did you? Don't
- 33:37let me cry too deeply, but I wonder how does someone deal with I'm
- 33:42not attracted to men when you are in a culture that probably expected you to
- 33:46find a good man, get married, pop out a few kids, and
- 33:49raise some Christians. Right, there was some dissonance, and I look back
- 33:53and I can't believe that it flew under the radar for so long. But
- 33:58at the same time, thing for girls raised in purity culture is you're very
- 34:04virtuous if you don't want to do anything with a guy until you're married.
- 34:07And I never got in a position where I was looking at marriage with a
- 34:09guy, so it was kind of almost a virtue signaling thing for me,
- 34:15like I don't want to do any of that because it's bad and evil.
- 34:19When I came out of the faith, logically I knew that hell wasn't real.
- 34:23Emotionally I was still terrified for a long time. So logically, in
- 34:28your mind you know that this is who you are, But are you still
- 34:31dragging some of those chains from your religious past. Definitely, like it's getting
- 34:37better. I've been in therapy with a great person that I found from the
- 34:42secular therapy project. So she's been awesome and affirming, and she's been able
- 34:46to understand the religious trauma angle. And I've been making a lot of progress,
- 34:52but it's still challenging. Well, don't rush yourself. Give yourself some
- 34:58time, give yourself oxygen, give yourself some grace. You are the product
- 35:05of years and years of indoctrination. But the people who said that who you
- 35:09are is aberrant or perverse or a sin. Those people who wrote the Bible,
- 35:15they didn't know anything about anything, Diane. They didn't know what the
- 35:19stars were, they didn't know what germs were. They didn't understand diseases like
- 35:25epilepsy. They didn't know that the Earth revolves around the sun. They didn't
- 35:32understand so much about so much. And yet here they are supposedly writing perfect
- 35:37truths. They didn't know anything, and they don't have any propriety over who
- 35:43you are. I think you are to be celebrated. I think who you
- 35:46are is remarkable. I am struck by your courage to have that conversation with
- 35:52a pastor, father and your mother and just to come clean. I know
- 35:55it's a difficult journey, but you've decided that's you. Your journey and that's
- 36:00huge. And I just I got your back. This whole community has your
- 36:07back. You are valid just the way you are. Are you hearing the
- 36:12sound of my voice, Diane, Yeah, thank you. All right,
- 36:15we got you. And and if you know anything else happens a new chapter
- 36:21in your story, I'd want to hear about it. So you have your
- 36:23people call our people and we'll talk again. Okay, all right, thanks,
- 36:28all right, thank you. Have you heard that before? Someone said
- 36:32my parents were more traumatized when I came out as gay than when I came
- 36:37out as an atheist. I'm trying to think had I been non hetero,
- 36:42which would have traumatized my parents more. I don't know, you're pretty homophobic.
- 36:49I don't know, it might have been an equal for you. Equal
- 36:52time freakout six one nine. I don't see a name. Yeah, my
- 36:58memo is a Sulf San Diego. I am a long time listener to your
- 37:05podcast. I love your show. I came out from Islam. I was
- 37:10a Muslim. I'm an ex Muslim. I was converted as a Muslim from
- 37:15Sunni to Shia, and later I tried to study Christianity. I dealt in.
- 37:22I didn't like it. Either, and I discovered later that America is
- 37:28unfortunate because we still have this conservative thing going on here. Like I was
- 37:35for a long time a believer that Christianity was different from Islam, but going
- 37:40through politics here, I discovered that Christianity is just another fundamentalist religion, just
- 37:47like Islam. And what the Supreme Court did recently, for example, when
- 37:52they gave the resident all the powers like a king, that reminded me of
- 37:59Islamic country. So that even made me feel more sorry for this great country
- 38:06going on down like and I hope it will not end like that in the
- 38:10statesleship, a Christian fundamental group rolling over everything. But I don't know,
- 38:17Like, what do you think, I mean, do you think that Christianity
- 38:22could be the curves that could kill this democracy? Oh my gosh, let
- 38:29me make sure I'm understanding your point. Having come out of Islam and you
- 38:35have seen these authoritarian Islamic theocracies, religious dictatorships, you are seeing us trending
- 38:43toward a religious dictatorship in the United States, except here it would be sort
- 38:47of framed as a Christian nation that I get that right, Yes, exactly.
- 38:54I don't think it fits in a box. But I do, in
- 38:58my own mind, see two major gears in the machine. One, there
- 39:04are Christian fundamentalists who know nothing about our history. They've never read the Constitution,
- 39:09at least properly. They do think that we are a Christian nation that
- 39:15belongs to their specific deity. So I do think there are many true believers
- 39:22at play. But I also agree with journalist and author Catherine Stewart, who
- 39:27has written the book The Power Worshippers. I think a lot of people have
- 39:30weaponized Christianity for power. Many of them are atheists, but they understand that
- 39:37if you invoke God and you sort of stoke people's fears and speak the language
- 39:43of zealotry, that you can obtain and then consolidate power. May understand the
- 39:50power of saying that God wants this, I'm just his messenger. And so
- 39:54I think those two gears are really the main ones drive true zealotry and a
- 40:01quest for power, and they kind of bleed into each other as well.
- 40:06Does that sound right to you? Do you have something else that you think
- 40:09is playing a major part? Yes, thank you for your point. I
- 40:15think that the problem is that Republicans are like, for example, they're against
- 40:20having education available to everyone in this country. And that's exactly what religion needs.
- 40:29An ignorant populous. Of course, it will be easy to control.
- 40:34And also the rates. He doesn't mind, like giving the ignorant people some
- 40:40religious drugs so they can live with it, so they don't care about having
- 40:47a veteran nation. And I just want to make the last point is that
- 40:53Americans don't have the experience I went through. I have seen religion youth even
- 41:00by some secular people, like some people calling themselves secular, yet they pay
- 41:07millions of dollars to mosques and the religious clerics in order to keep people under
- 41:14control. So I appreciate your show, Seth, and I love you.
- 41:19I love your show, and I wish you all the success. Thanks very
- 41:23so much. I'm glad you escaped Islam and you keep kicking out there.
- 41:29Okay, okay, thank you. Have a goodbee lovey. Christianity at its
- 41:34core is an authoritarian model, and I think that's one of the reasons why
- 41:38so many of these devout Christians who know really nothing. I say they're devout
- 41:44emotionally right. They are those people who they may go to church on Sunday
- 41:50and they live pretty much religion free lives the rest of the week except for
- 41:53maybe praying over the mashed potatoes kind of thing. Maybe they wear the cross
- 41:58necklace. But they claim Christianity. We do Christian things, and we have
- 42:05Christian friends and Christian values, and this is a Christian nation, and whatever
- 42:09the Christian nation candidate tells us, we will do because he is God's man.
- 42:16Well, I think these are people primed for authoritarianism. This is a
- 42:22command handed down that you will obey. It's a way of surrendering thinking,
- 42:29surrendering having to navigate the complex on your own. You sit back and your
- 42:34spoon fed what to do next. I also think there is a suspiciously Old
- 42:39Testament vibe to the Savior King narrative when it comes to Donald Trump. These
- 42:45Christians, many of them, do not just want a Christian country that puts
- 42:51them at the head of the table. I think they want Old Testament justice
- 42:57doled out to everybody they find. And ikey. I think they many of
- 43:02them are gleeful at the idea of taking those brown people at the border and
- 43:10splitting them away from their families. And those ikey gay people, Let's make
- 43:15their marriage illegal and maybe even make it a crime to be gay. Those
- 43:21people who have aborted babies, they are the enemies of God, those murderers.
- 43:24Put them in prison, execute them. They see an Old Testament kind
- 43:30of what they call justice going on, and they they're gleeful about it.
- 43:37Forgiveness, Nah, it's punishment. It's blood in the streets. And you
- 43:42know what, the infidels, they had it coming. And if that sounds
- 43:46strangely like Islamic regimes, yeah, it absolutely does. These types of shows
- 43:55are great ways for us as a community to interact with each other, and
- 44:00we will take more of your calls. In just a second. I'm going
- 44:09to be in Fort Worth and Houston this weekend. I was looking ahead at
- 44:15how many Bible Belt or Jesus areas are on my speaking stop list, because
- 44:23with Kentucky coming up, it's going to be in the Lexington area, Bentonville,
- 44:29Arkansas, Arkansas. Hell. I thought Tulsa or Oklahoma was Jesus se
- 44:37But man, you know what. I spoke in Little Rock recently, and
- 44:40I'm driving back. I got Natalie on the car phone or whatever we're talking,
- 44:45and I looked to my left. There was this big pasture and there
- 44:51were no kidding like fifty alternating signs, Trump Make America great Again, Trump
- 44:57Make America great Again, over and over, over and over and over.
- 45:01And I was telling Natalie, Wow, another few miles, another pasture,
- 45:07and again another fifty alternating flags. So this must have been property owned by
- 45:14the same guys, or the neighbors called each other, and like, let's
- 45:16try to extra maga the highway. Let's just brand it even further. And
- 45:23I saw them billboards, and there's cross statues everywhere. Have you seen those
- 45:30turn or burned billboards where you're supposed to call the one eight hundred number,
- 45:34you know, will you go to Heaven Oil and they've got hell and Fiery
- 45:39font you're supposed to dial a numbers. Anyone ever call that number. I
- 45:44find myself looking at the tour schedule going some of these people must crawl to
- 45:49these events in the prone position, so we're afraid they're going to get shot.
- 45:53So fort Worth on Saturday, Houston Sunday, coming up at Sarnia,
- 45:59to on to, I'll be in Lexington, Knoxville's coming up, Bentonville and
- 46:05others. Seth Andrews dot com slash events for all those details. I've got
- 46:12Hans from Germany calling online, Hans, thanks for being here. What's on
- 46:16your mind? Hey? How's it goes? I'm well, just out curiosity.
- 46:21What's the nomination did you come out of? What do you think?
- 46:23As shrafted? I got thirty one flavors man. I went to a Baptist
- 46:29school. My father was ex Lutheran and my mother was a Pennecostal. So
- 46:34I sort of dabbled in both the conservative and the more kind of wild and
- 46:37crazy kind of Christianity. And did you read your Bible? Awesome? I
- 46:43did? Interesting? Did he follow Jesus rise often? What do you say?
- 46:47Did I follow? What? Did he followed? Jesus's worse? Did
- 46:52I try to follow Jesus's words? Well, look as if he would have,
- 46:58then you would have never left the church strubling, because specifically good for
- 47:01you. Let me say it this way. I attempted to be a good
- 47:05person, to tell the truth, to have compassion for others. And I
- 47:09also Jesus hold on. I saw Christ as a messenger of charity, of
- 47:19humility, of peace and goodness, and I tried to emulate that in my
- 47:22own life. I also held to the great commission go ye into all the
- 47:27world, and preach the Gospel to all the nations. So I was rather
- 47:30evangelical in that way. I was always sort of puffing Christianity. So in
- 47:35that way, yeah, I wanted to emulate the teachings or what I felt
- 47:37with the teachings of Christ. Okay, well did you fall everything? He
- 47:42said? I can't recall everything? He said? Why do you ask?
- 47:47Well, because he says specifically that we need to build our faith on a
- 47:52foundation. Otherwise, when the first thing comes that will make you falty in
- 47:55your faith, it'll get lost away easily. So, but sounds like you
- 48:00didn't bill your faith on a strong foundation. You just had you had a
- 48:02very shallow faith. It sounds like I see on your call screening that you
- 48:07were disowned by a Christian family when you left the church. Is that why
- 48:12you're calling? Yeah, this a Celtic I guess it. Yeah, Catholic
- 48:17church. Okay, when you left the Catholic church? Yeah, tell me
- 48:22about the church that you left and why you left. No, that's let's
- 48:27talk about you, because it sounds like you didn't actually follow Jesus said.
- 48:30Let's do you address that. You don't know anything about me? I was
- 48:34a true Well, I do know anything as the first thing came around you
- 48:38you abandoned it when the first thing came around Do you mean literally almost a
- 48:44decade of examining Katie Dawson your jack, I'm going to put you on mute.
- 48:51Hans. You don't know anything about me. My journey wasn't a blink
- 48:55of an eye journey. It wasn't overnight. I wasn't blase or flippant about
- 49:00my religion. I was traumatized at the idea that what I had long believed
- 49:06was not true. There were major consequences when I left. I learned more
- 49:12about the history of my religion and what the Bible said as I d constructed
- 49:16than I ever did when I was a blind faith believer. And I reject
- 49:22this idea that you can call and you can just say, well, I
- 49:25know more about you, I know why you left, and it is illegitimate.
- 49:30You're obviously a really shitty Christian because as you're saying all that, so
- 49:35that's fully sad. Man. Is your first name Hans from Germany? Because
- 49:40this doesn't sound like a Hans from Germany where you're from, really this is
- 49:45kind of Germany. What do you know about me? Why not any that
- 49:52I couldn't understand. You say it again, weiser Lach, you may be
- 49:59a trop up men, Yeah, I think you may be a troll.
- 50:02Forgive me everybody. I didn't pick up on that at first. I thought,
- 50:06well, maybe I'm not making a connection. But I don't believe that
- 50:09was a Hans from Germany. I think it may have just been someone seeking
- 50:14attention, which unfortunately is sometimes the nature of online pot well actually broadcasts in
- 50:21general. Hans or whoever you are, whatever attention you seek, I hope
- 50:25you find it somewhere. Seven five to seven, I've got Hannah. Thanks
- 50:30for calling. What's on your mind? Hello? Wow, this is my
- 50:35first time calling on the show, so I'm very excited. You're doing great,
- 50:38doing fun. Okay, So just to give you a little background about
- 50:43me, I'm thirty and for the past three years I've deconstructed from Christianity,
- 50:50so at least twenty years of my life maybe a little bit more than that.
- 50:53I was like in it, but now I kind of say like,
- 50:58I'm an agnostic atheist because while I don't believe that there is a God,
- 51:04I can't really prove one way or the other that it does or does not
- 51:07exist. My question was, there's two questions, actually because I can't I
- 51:14don't know, but I really value your opinion. My first question would be
- 51:19do you believe that the figure of Jesus did exist at some point on this
- 51:23earth? And then the other question is, you know, as you know,
- 51:28when you first come out of Christianity and you learn like a bunch of
- 51:31stuff, one of the things you face is anger. And I face a
- 51:35lot of that. And it's only been like three years for me. Like
- 51:38I said, so, I'm sure I still have a lot to learn,
- 51:42but I still feel the anger at times. I find myself rolling my eyes
- 51:47at a lot of stuff that I see going on in the world, even
- 51:52like when I pass a church or like a sign that it's just it's just
- 51:55I just feel like the anger is not very strong. But I just it's
- 52:00like the sense of ugh, come on, like seriously, their adults out
- 52:06here still being brain roshed or we like seriously. I just and you're much
- 52:10further along at this than I am. So I just was curious if those
- 52:15feelings ever go away or does it come with more healing or Sorry, that
- 52:21was like a lot I got you. I'm totally tracking and I can relate.
- 52:27First of all, I don't really care what you call yourself. I
- 52:29wouldn't get hung up on atheist agnostic. I mean, if you don't believe
- 52:34there's a god, or you've been shown no reason to believe, you're an
- 52:37atheist. But some people are more comfortable with agnostic because I don't know that
- 52:43there couldn't be something out there. Okay, fine, I'm a seeker.
- 52:47I don't know. I don't have any idea. I'm still kind of digging
- 52:51around to find out. I don't care. I mean, we often trip
- 52:53on labels, so I wouldn't beat yourself up over what you call yourself.
- 52:58Just take the journey. Was Jesus a real guy? I don't know.
- 53:02I don't have any idea. I mean, very possible that the god myth
- 53:07was based on a charismatic guy who lived in that time. But we know
- 53:13that no contemporary historian recorded anything about it. Jesus the Gospels weren't written.
- 53:19I think the first one it was in the late avandees CE. And you
- 53:24know what, was he a myth? Was he borrowed from other previous deities?
- 53:30Or was he once a guy? And then the legend sprung up from
- 53:34him, I don't know. And finally, on the subject of being angry,
- 53:38anger is totally understandable. Sometimes we find ourselves apologizing. I can't get
- 53:45past the angry face. I'm pissed off, I wasted time, people are
- 53:50so dumb, or I'm being judged. And they're the one who believes in
- 53:53talking donkeys, you know, they're the ones who were being bigoted against my
- 53:58friends and the people like care about, and they're doing battle with my values.
- 54:02And of course I'm angry, and I think, Hannah, you have
- 54:07every right to be angry. Don't apologize for it, don't feel guilty about
- 54:13it, don't feel like you're doing deconstruction wrong. I think anger is part
- 54:17of the process. But I will say, after four years on my end,
- 54:23I finally started to get over that hump just a little bit. Not
- 54:28that my anger is gone, but that it kind of hits differently. I'm
- 54:34processing it differently, I'm approaching people differently. I'm guessing we're taking a road
- 54:39trip together, Hannah, Is that what's going on? Yeah, I'm sorry,
- 54:45I guess I have a signal where I'm at. I'm so sorry.
- 54:47You're doing fun as long as I can totally understand what you're saying, and
- 54:52the listeners can as well. I think it's absolutely fine. Here's the one
- 54:55challenge that I have. I think anger is a powerful motivator, and that's
- 55:02a good thing. Anger can also eat us from the inside. It can
- 55:09turn to this kind of non stop, teeth gritting rage that is destructive.
- 55:17It's destructive to us. It doesn't necessarily help us to change the world.
- 55:23It makes everything harder. And that's a tough line to draw. So as
- 55:30I am someone who cares about other people and i want to see a better
- 55:32world, and I'm upset about injustice, I'm angry about that. But I've
- 55:37also finally come to a point when I've been able to channel it differently and
- 55:40also find a little bit of balance, to embrace the good and not allow
- 55:45my rage to eat me alive. Does that make sense? All right?
- 55:49Thank you so much. I totally agree with that. Time is an amazing
- 55:53healer, but it's a long journey for some I'm telling you that if you
- 55:58look at the temperature of my work when I first came out and started this
- 56:01channel, I was a hell of a lot nastier. I was more sarcastic.
- 56:06I know if nasty is the word. But I was just pissed off
- 56:08and I was going hard all the time, boom boom boom, and it
- 56:12took me a while to get over that speed bump. And that's okay,
- 56:15and so do it on your timing. But I think better days are going
- 56:20to come for you. All right, Thank you. I really appreciate you.
- 56:23And you know, I think it's I think you're really strong and brave
- 56:28for putting up with trolls. And I really thought you had handled that with
- 56:32I don't know if grace is a weird work to ease, but I mean
- 56:36you did. You handled it with grace, and it was perfect. So
- 56:39I just really admire that and how you look at the people. See,
- 56:43I may not have done that five years out of the faith. I may
- 56:46have popped in a ring on the guy. I may have you may have
- 56:49seen the vein come out of my forehead. But time is a great healer.
- 56:53So there is hope, Hannah, and you drive safe out there,
- 56:57okay, thank you, all right, we'll see. I tend to resist
- 57:01this idea that not freaking out and losing your mind and cussing people out and
- 57:07calling them names somehow a sell out I just I think so many times,
- 57:13actually that's the easy way. It's easy to knee jerk. It's easy to
- 57:19surrender to your first emotional instinct and to pound on the table and to call
- 57:23people names and to lose your mind. I mean, any child can do
- 57:29that. And I'm not saying already there's someone who's going well that says we
- 57:32shouldn't be angry about again the Nazis. This is always what they lead with.
- 57:42No, I'm just saying I've been going through this on social media with
- 57:46the whole punch a Nazi crowd. Well, I'm going to punch as many
- 57:51now. I think Nazis need to be punched, just sucker, Just punch
- 57:54them and make them afraid to show their faces. They'll never understand reason.
- 57:59They all only understand violence. We have to speak their language. We have
- 58:02to get down in the gutter. And I said, it's not how we
- 58:07fix the world. We tried taking the high road. Now we need to
- 58:12go and just do battle. Grab them by the throat. Any child can
- 58:19surrender to their base instincts. And I just don't think AsSalt is how we
- 58:24fix the world. That's not a position of weakness or acquiescence or enabling.
- 58:31I think we need adults in the room, and there are a ton of
- 58:37ways to be strong without becoming these fist flailing, lawless tantruine throwing children and
- 58:45excusing it because while I just have to, they made me do it.
- 58:49Anyway, that's probably a whole other show. The punch a Nazi crot,
- 58:53I swear to you well, Seth wants to go soft on the Nazis.
- 59:00Seth Seth thinks we should all gather around and sing Kumbai Yah with Nazis.
- 59:07Did I say that that's what binary thinking does extremist thinking? And don't believe
- 59:13that we don't have extremist thinking in every tribe, every group, every community,
- 59:19every circle, every culture. You will find the mainstream, you'll find
- 59:22the spectrum, and you'll find the extremes. And the extremes are so desperate
- 59:29to justify extremism. No, I don't think we fix the world by sucker
- 59:35punching people in the street, no matter how awful they are. Anyway,
- 59:40I'll let you chew on that. So i'mone to call it a day.
- 59:44I will see you back here. Actually, I'll see you on the road
- 59:46and I'll see you back here next time, and take care. Follow the
- 59:51Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos,
- 59:55products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist. Love links to atheist
- 1:00:00pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log
- 1:00:06onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.