Latest / KAJ Business & Money LIVE / Leading with Purpose: Turning Businesses into Masterpieces with Charles Spinosa
Transcript
- 0:24Speaker 1: Welcome to this very special edition of the KJA Masterclass Live,
- 0:28the show which ensures that you profit from your time
- 0:31spent here with experts, either through their industry insights, information
- 0:36or simply learning from them.
- 0:38Speaker 2: And today we have Charles Penosa.
- 0:41Speaker 1: He's a leadership expert, a management consultant for the last
- 0:45twenty seven years as he develop leaders, change organizational cultures
- 0:50and develop customer propositions. He's also an author written several
- 0:55books Leadership as Master's Creation. We'll talk all about that.
- 1:00Welcome to the show, Charles.
- 1:02Speaker 3: Thank you very much. Aj.
- 1:05Speaker 2: You're well well here.
- 1:07Speaker 1: You are, welcome. Welcome to the show, Charles. Welcome to
- 1:10India in this online form. And I'm sure not just
- 1:13in India, but a lot of people across the globe
- 1:16will benefit from what we are going to talk right now.
- 1:18We'll talk about leading with purpose, that purpose turning businesses
- 1:23into masterpieces.
- 1:25Speaker 2: That will talk all about that.
- 1:26Speaker 1: But before that, let's understand a bit about your journey,
- 1:29your background, Charles, so that people know from you directly
- 1:33who they are listening to.
- 1:35Speaker 3: Sure, thank you very much, Aj, and I'm really delighted
- 1:40that I get a chance to meet your audience. Okay,
- 1:44So I'm Charles Finosa. I've been a management consultant for
- 1:47the last twenty seven years, and exactly as AJ said,
- 1:51I started out helping my clients develop new customer propositions,
- 1:57and from that I moved into helping them change or
- 2:00culture so that they could deliver on those customer propositions,
- 2:03and helping leaders develop their leadership. And that's primarily what
- 2:07I've been doing, but I always did it on the
- 2:10basis of the background I had before that, and before
- 2:13management consulting, I was a professor. I taught Shakespeare for
- 2:18a while at Miami University. I was a Shakespearean That's
- 2:21what I wrote my PhD on. And then I started
- 2:24publishing a lot in philosophy, and I ended up teaching
- 2:27philosophy at UC Berkeley for a short while. At that point,
- 2:31I wrote a book, Philosopher's View of Innovation, and that
- 2:35led me into management consulting. And right from the very
- 2:41beginning in management consulting, my first engagement was with the
- 2:45leadership team at Semex, which at that time was a
- 2:49medium sized cement company that grew to be the third
- 2:52largest in the world. I brought the basic idea of
- 2:56a Shakespearean scholar about Shakespeare, what is that Shakespeare was
- 3:03the one that realized that people live their lives, were
- 3:08starting to live their lives at his time out of
- 3:10life stories. They were telling the story of their life
- 3:13as they lived, and they wanted most of all, to
- 3:16make that valuable. And that's what Shakespeare's tragedies are all about.
- 3:21They're all about the tragic character trying to make his
- 3:25life valuable. And the only way in the tragedy you
- 3:27can prove it is by being willing to die for
- 3:30your life story. Now, in businesses, I was bringing the
- 3:33same message, what are you as a leader or as
- 3:36a leadership team doing to make your lives valuable? And
- 3:41what's the story you're telling? And how do you prove
- 3:44that you make it valuable? And in business, you prove
- 3:46that your story is valuable essentially by making customers lead
- 3:52good lives, enabling customers to lead good lives, enabling your
- 3:56employees to lead good lives, and enabling the owners to
- 4:01lead good lives. That's how you measure whether the story
- 4:04you have of yourself is making you valuable. And that
- 4:07was that's what I began with and it's out of
- 4:10that beginning at CMX that I helped more and more
- 4:16business leaders go beyond just leading good lives for themselves,
- 4:21for their customers, for their employees, but creating organizations that
- 4:26were what I call masterpieces, that changed what we consider
- 4:30to be good lives, and by virtue of that change,
- 4:33enabling more people to lead good lives. And that's what
- 4:36a masterpiece does.
- 4:38Speaker 2: Right. Yeah, you want to add something more?
- 4:43Speaker 3: Can you? Ah? I can. I can go on and
- 4:46on and on. I'll just say very quickly again, creating
- 4:52a masterpiece comes in the humanities. A leader finds a
- 4:55moral anomaly in his industry or her company and resolves
- 5:01that moral anomaly. So it is all moral business right
- 5:05from the get go to what I do today. I'll
- 5:08come back to that as you ask more questions.
- 5:12Speaker 2: Absolutely absolutely, child.
- 5:13Speaker 1: So this whole age of creating masterpieces, is it gone?
- 5:19Is it a bygone era or is it still happening?
- 5:23Or we are we are now considering that utopian not
- 5:28possible today? How should as a normal person, common person,
- 5:31I should understand this?
- 5:34Speaker 3: Okay, I don't think it's gone today. You're right to say,
- 5:36it's being challenged, and particularly in the business world. People
- 5:44right now, people like me, management consultants like me, business
- 5:49school professors, people who write about business. They're teaching two
- 5:53things to managers. The teaching them number one to be agile.
- 5:59And what is that mean. It means you're constantly exploring,
- 6:02testing one idea, testing another idea, testing another idea, testing
- 6:06another idea, and constantly doing that. People they love to
- 6:09say iterating, iterating, and refining. And what do you do?
- 6:13Will you test one customer idea of proposition. If it works,
- 6:17you speedily deliver something as student as it stops working,
- 6:20you test another and test another. You never ask yourself
- 6:24what's really true about my customers? What is really giving
- 6:28them a good life? You can sell something for a
- 6:30short time that doesn't give your customers a good life,
- 6:33that doesn't give your employees a good life. But you
- 6:36don't ask that question. When you're agile, You sell when
- 6:39you can sell. When it starts to die off, you
- 6:43experiment and try something else, and try something else, and
- 6:46try something else. And that's agility, and that's pragmatism. And
- 6:50that doesn't give you masterpieces. What it does is it
- 6:52gives you fast change. You become a fast change artist.
- 6:55And that's one direction that a lot of businesses are
- 6:58going in. There's a famous writer who used to be
- 7:00a co author of mine, Don sal who's written a
- 7:03lot about that. If you're interested in that, Don Sul's
- 7:07the place of the person to read. I believe that
- 7:11well personally, I believe there's some people who just find
- 7:14that exciting. I think for most people, we tend to
- 7:17burn out on that, and the burnout is measured by
- 7:22the other big tendency in business, which is to try
- 7:24to keep everything safe so you don't take risks. You're
- 7:27just constantly experimenting. That's another thing that agile likes it.
- 7:30One small experiment after another, one after another one. When
- 7:33it works, it just takes off. I think that that
- 7:37is not what many of our business leaders are doing
- 7:41today or have done. For instance, Ray Dalyo, who runs
- 7:46the Bridgewater Hedge Fund, he has invented an organization that
- 7:52is very distinctive, and what makes it distinctive. Inside it,
- 7:57people are constantly seeking for what's true and saying what's
- 8:02true to each other all the time. In fact, he
- 8:05developed way before what's happened all the applications we have
- 8:08now a technology where people during meetings would get comments
- 8:13from other people on what they thought, what their assessments
- 8:16were of how the meeting was going, how the person
- 8:18was performing. And that's what Ray Dally was famous for.
- 8:22The anomaly, the moral anomaly. He noticed was that our
- 8:26world was becoming more and more transparent, and how were
- 8:30people responding to everything being online? Well, they were cultivating
- 8:35images of themselves. They were cultivating images of themselves on Facebook,
- 8:38they were cultivating images themselves in all sorts of social media.
- 8:43He said, why not turn transparency into a place where
- 8:46we're seeking truth, stating what we believe to be true,
- 8:50having people object or agree or challenge, and then have
- 8:56that kind of conversation on social media, much like what
- 9:00we're doing right now with aj and he made that
- 9:03the basis of his management. I consider Bridgewater a masterpiece business.
- 9:09It hasn't started changing the rest of the world yet,
- 9:12but I believe it will ultimately replace radical candor and
- 9:17psychological safety. You know, you're always taking a risk at
- 9:23ray Dalio's business. So there's one. Another one that is
- 9:28a bit more controversial is Bezos is Amazon. What happened there?
- 9:34Bezos realized in the early days of the Internet that
- 9:39retail selling things online was very, very crazy. It was
- 9:43like everybody negotiating prices for everything. You would sell unfinished goods,
- 9:48you'd sell finished goods. There was no quality control. There
- 9:50was plenty of room for fraud. And Bezos happened to
- 9:54love the basic trust between a buyer and a seller
- 9:58that we had in the world, and he set out
- 10:01to create something that would save that basic trust and
- 10:09in the world and be online and have all the
- 10:12advantages of the online world. And that was what we
- 10:17know as Amazon and Everything Store now. To achieve that,
- 10:22to go up against Walmart and so forth, he had
- 10:25to develop a relentless culture inside a culture where he
- 10:30was constantly raising the bar on employee requirements and fanaticism
- 10:35about customers, and those were three rough values, and in
- 10:38fact he had to end up firing, what people thought
- 10:43rather cruelly his founding employees to make the point, we
- 10:48really are going to be relentless here. We really are
- 10:51going to raise the bar all the time, we really
- 10:54are going to be fanatical about customers. And in doing
- 10:57that he created an online world where he preserved trust
- 11:01between buyers and sellers, and he invented alongside that out
- 11:07of his relentlessness, the kind of hyper convenience we have today,
- 11:10and that's a real shift in our retail moral order,
- 11:14as I call it. We now expect everything to be
- 11:17really as convenient. We know it's not going to be
- 11:20as convenient as Amazon. We know we don't have everything
- 11:23that we can purchase and purchase it at the click
- 11:26of a key, have it delivered the next day, and
- 11:29if we don't like it, return it right away. It's
- 11:32not going to be that convenient. But we really do expect,
- 11:35even if we go to our favorite restaurants down the street,
- 11:40our favorite museums, that they are going to give us
- 11:43some hyper convenience, that that's going to be part of
- 11:46what they deliver. And that's how people create masterpieces and
- 11:49how masterpieces change communities. It's a kind of moral.
- 11:53Speaker 1: Effort, absolutely absolutely, child So where is it that people
- 11:59have gone wrong?
- 12:00Speaker 2: Where is that? Is it that leaders have gone wrong?
- 12:03Speaker 1: Is it that only some readers are actually you know,
- 12:06some of these leaders are actually good readers and read
- 12:09the right kind of sex speer and most of them
- 12:12have read the wrong kind of sex speer about Lady
- 12:16macbeth ambition, you know, where let not the knife see
- 12:20the wound it makes, and then everybody is happy because
- 12:23nobody comes to know about the wound. And we have
- 12:25come our planet has come to this this stage. The
- 12:28leadership itself is in crisis. Organizations have become toxic workplaces.
- 12:33We have the great resignation, we have the quiet quitting,
- 12:37we have the revenge quitting.
- 12:39Speaker 2: Why is it? Where? Where have we got? Do they
- 12:41have to read the right kind of books? Which books?
- 12:45Speaker 1: We will come to also your book leadership as mastership,
- 12:49masterplace peace created?
- 12:50Speaker 2: But what first? Let's understand where have we gone from?
- 12:54Speaker 3: Okay, I believe we've gone wrong. I'm going to make
- 12:59a very bold statement, and I might want to take
- 13:02a bit of it back, but I think in essence
- 13:05it's right. We have gone wrong in understanding business through
- 13:09social science instead of understanding business through the humanities. What
- 13:16does that mean? We see, we train business leaders to
- 13:21think of their businesses as machines or as rational bureaucracies,
- 13:28and their goal is to find pragmatic techniques for increasing
- 13:36revenue and growth, increasing profits, and getting good scores on
- 13:45employee satisfaction. And one of those good ways you get
- 13:49a good score on employee satisfaction is by having a
- 13:53so called purpose that you attach your business to and
- 13:56a purpose doesn't necessarily mean something coming from your heart.
- 14:00In fact, it usually doesn't come from your heart. It
- 14:03comes from what journalists are talking about today. It's a purpose.
- 14:06It's a fashionable purpose to attach your business too. And
- 14:10when you start there, you're using the social science. Is
- 14:17what you're doing is you're basically manipulating variables. And that's
- 14:22what a lot of consulting, a lot of business thinking
- 14:25is about. How do we create the right environment for
- 14:28employees to be productive? How do we test products with
- 14:33customers to see if the customers are willing to buy
- 14:38more or buy the next upgrade. And it's all like
- 14:40a social science experiment. There's very very little question about
- 14:46how do I create a good life for my employees,
- 14:48how do I create a good life for my customers. Now,
- 14:52I say there's there's very little in the training. There's
- 14:56very little in what most managers believe there's suppose to do.
- 15:02In my twenty seven years of consulting and working with leaders,
- 15:06I would say I have only run into two who really,
- 15:11deep down, deep in their hearts, believed that. Now, that's
- 15:15what their training was, and that's what they tried to do,
- 15:18and that's what they thought they should do to perform
- 15:21all but two and I haven't counted, but it must
- 15:25be fifty had a sense of what the right way
- 15:31to treat customers was, what the right way to treat
- 15:34employees was, what the right way to treat suppliers and
- 15:39owners was. And they wanted to do it, but all
- 15:45their training said, you're going to end up losing money,
- 15:48or here's the big one, it's too risky. We only
- 15:52take calculated risks in our business. We use game playing
- 15:57analysis to decide what risks to take. One of my
- 16:02basic questions when I go into a business is to
- 16:05ask the leader, what are you always doing wrong in
- 16:11your own organization or in your industry? And I just
- 16:18wrote down the most recent seven I had. What's amazing
- 16:22is almost every leader has an answer to that question.
- 16:26You would think, and you would think that people wouldn't
- 16:30take that seriously, or if it's something, if it's something
- 16:33that's wrong, it's not something that always goes wrong. It's
- 16:35something that periodically goes wrong and they correct. That's how
- 16:38managers think. Managers are constantly firefighting, they're constantly correcting things.
- 16:42But here are the last seven we engage in. This
- 16:46is from a business outside the US and outside Europe.
- 16:52We engage in secretive financial practices, not ones that have
- 16:56first world transparency. We always do this, aways get caught
- 17:00up doing it, and we can't then borrow money at
- 17:03low interest rates and grow that way. We always get
- 17:06this wrong. Another one, we always treat our loyal customers poorly.
- 17:11We're offering all our best deals to new customers to
- 17:14get the new customers in the door. Another one from
- 17:19a utility industry. We always look for big engineering projects
- 17:23to solve our problems. We never partner with our customs,
- 17:27and this one I can say it was the water industry.
- 17:30They partnered with their customers to collect water running off
- 17:34of roofs and things so that they could manage waste
- 17:37water far better. It was far cheaper for everybody, and
- 17:40the customers actually enjoyed doing it. Another one. We negotiate
- 17:46wind lose contracts with our contractors. We know that win
- 17:49wins better, but we always get caught up negotiating wind lose.
- 17:52Another one in healthcare, it's really the insurance company that's
- 17:56the customer of the doctors. This is US Healthcare, by
- 18:00the way. It's really the insurance company that is the
- 18:03customer of the doctor. We need to get the patient
- 18:06as the customer. We have to find a way to
- 18:08do that, but we don't. Another video games, we create
- 18:12macho video games. We know that we can create video
- 18:16games that appeal to women too and appeal to a
- 18:19diverse community, but we only create macho games because that's
- 18:23our practice. And another one, actually, this is one, the
- 18:27one that helped me turn the corner and see masterpieces.
- 18:30We're so safety conscious. We don't innovate here. I love innovation,
- 18:34but there's no way to do it. So those are
- 18:37just seven of the last leaders I dealt with, and
- 18:41what they saw was always going wrong in their industry. Now,
- 18:46changing that is not just a manager's thing to do.
- 18:49Changing that is risky. People are going to think that
- 18:52you're doing something wrong when you try to change that.
- 18:57And that's the hard thing. Really, The hardest question I
- 19:01ask leaders once I get this is what would you
- 19:05love to do? And that is the question that they
- 19:09find so hard. What would you love to do? And
- 19:12that is the real place where I believe the injury
- 19:16of the lack of humanities training causes. They have a
- 19:23hard time saying what they would love to do. They
- 19:26haven't read Shakespeare. They haven't read Milton, they haven't read Homer,
- 19:32they haven't read the Bugga Bigheita. They haven't read the
- 19:37things that inspire huge imandative developed. Say, they haven't developed
- 19:44what I call their moral imagination, which is the capacity
- 19:49that you find in literary writers and also philosophers to
- 19:55look at the world from an entirely different perspective, to
- 19:59look at world, say, from what it looked like in
- 20:02the eighteenth century, or the nineteenth century, or my favorite period,
- 20:06the Renaissance, the sixteenth century. When you begin looking at
- 20:09the world that way, you begin to see new things.
- 20:14Can I give you one little story about what that's like?
- 20:17Speaker 2: Of course?
- 20:17Speaker 3: Okay. When I was a professor, one of the things
- 20:20I would teach students first studying English literature was Chaucer.
- 20:26Chaucer was a poet from the Middle Ages in England,
- 20:30and he wrote a tale called the Franklins Tale. I
- 20:33won't go into it. It's a love story with a
- 20:36knight and a lady. We can all imagine that, and
- 20:40the lady puts the knight through various tasks and they
- 20:46get married. It's a happy story with a happy ending.
- 20:49And I always ask the students, why the lady married
- 20:55the lord the night and the student, and would always
- 21:01give me the answers about what they believed in romantic love. Well,
- 21:04he would make a good partner for her. He showed
- 21:07that he was devoted and would stick with her, and
- 21:12so on. But Chaucer has it just stated right in
- 21:17the tail she fell in love with him because she
- 21:21pitied him. And I showed them the line, and Chauce
- 21:26it must have been asleep at the wheel. He didn't
- 21:29really mean that. We all know that you don't love
- 21:32someone whom you pity. That's impossible, and I say, try
- 21:39and try. Assuming that that is right, what do you
- 21:44see then about the whole nature of the story, and
- 21:48the whole nature of the story is she was putting
- 21:50him through arduous tasks. She was like on a romantic pedestal,
- 21:56like a goddess. And yes, goddess is do pity people.
- 22:01She was a goddess. She was a religious pedical. After all,
- 22:04these were religious times and romantic love was understood. It's
- 22:09like religious love. When you see that, Oh man, oh wow,
- 22:16that's completely different. And then you can take your students
- 22:20through not just understanding chancer, but how that kind of
- 22:24love was alive in our culture right up through the
- 22:29nineteen sixties and is still alive with some people today.
- 22:34And guess what, if you're a business selling vacations to lovers,
- 22:38selling jewelry to lovers, selling other things to lovers, there
- 22:41is that segment which you'll never understand. If you think
- 22:45that all love is partnership love, there is that romantic
- 22:50segment left, and it opens your eyes to that. So
- 22:54it's that eye opening sense that you get from the humanities,
- 22:59from trying to understand literature from the past, understanding literature
- 23:03from other cultures. But then you see the world as
- 23:07a richer place, and then you can answer the simple
- 23:10question that a consultant like me says. Okay, so you
- 23:14produce macho video games, you, in fact, were one of
- 23:18the people who developed World of Warcraft. Now you realize
- 23:22you want to do something. What would you love to do?
- 23:26I would love to create a video game that men
- 23:31and women love to play. Okay, well, let's start there.
- 23:37What risks are you going to have to take to
- 23:39get there? And that, by the way, is the next
- 23:41step on the journey. Once you can get people actually
- 23:45to see what they'd love and that's the way I say,
- 23:47I have to basically do some humanities training to get
- 23:50them there, to enrich their moral imagination. The next step
- 23:55is taking the risks to do it, and those risks
- 23:58that's what the heart of leadership, as masterpiece creation about,
- 24:04those moral risks, as I call them. That's then what
- 24:09leaders have to do, and that is the mark of leadership.
- 24:11The capacity to do something that people are going to
- 24:15see as wrong. Now, to fire those employees, to take
- 24:20that money from something that looks like the money should
- 24:23go to everybody agreed it should go to and put
- 24:28it in this risky venture, or even to hire people
- 24:34that people will tell you can't be hired because they
- 24:38don't know anything about creating video games. But you need
- 24:40to hire people who can create video games that men
- 24:45and women will play. Those those are the kinds of
- 24:47risky things that you then have to do. Sometimes the
- 24:50risks seem simple, but in various industries they are hard.
- 24:53One of them we worked with women in recruiting industry,
- 24:57Julia Robertson in the UK. She by the way she
- 25:01created a masterpiece, she deserves to be far more famous
- 25:05than she is. The first and in the recruiting industry
- 25:08temporary workers. The idea was to just get the workers
- 25:11in and out as fast as possible. You don't treat
- 25:12the workers well. You work with companies that just want
- 25:15to move workers in and out fast as probably possible,
- 25:17without caring for workers. That's the nature the industry. She
- 25:22thought that was unfair to everybody that industry. But the
- 25:27first thing she imposed in her own company was people
- 25:31making promises. People simply promising to say what they were
- 25:34going to produce the next quarter, the next week, and
- 25:37then trying to keep those promises and renegotiating if they couldn't.
- 25:42In most companies a lot of companies, and her industry
- 25:44in particular, promises were for fools. Promises were ways that
- 25:48you created win lose circumstances. You only got a promise
- 25:52from somebody if you wanted to win over them, beat
- 25:55them somehow. And so she had to fire rather harshly
- 26:01the people who wouldn't keep their promises in her company,
- 26:04and some of them were leaders, and those are the
- 26:06kinds of moral risks. Firing them harshly that could have
- 26:09taken the whole company down. That could she could have
- 26:14been seen not as somebody who was trying to make
- 26:17lives good for people. But as someone who's trying to
- 26:20make lives bad for people, that was the risk she
- 26:22took and she succeeded. So even simple things like that
- 26:25can be huge moral risks in a particular.
- 26:28Speaker 2: Company, absolutely charged explained. Now, shoot one focus on.
- 26:35Speaker 1: Making leaders or leadership as masterpieces or should they focus
- 26:40on making organizations businesses as muster pieces?
- 26:45Speaker 2: Where should the focus be?
- 26:46Speaker 1: Because leaders will come and go and organizations will be there.
- 26:50Like for Amazon, if you go into Amazon to adopt
- 26:53and adapt that culture.
- 26:56Speaker 3: I believe you can. I mean, it's an interesting case.
- 27:00Can you make a business into a masterpiece without making
- 27:04your leadership style into a masterpiece? I haven't found the
- 27:11case where you can, and the reason I'll give you
- 27:15the reason. However, you know I am a kind of
- 27:18philosopher in the background, so I'm always testing this. Someone
- 27:22can some could you create a masterpiece without having to
- 27:26make your leadership into a masterpiece leader? And I can't
- 27:29give you a knockout, knockdown argument that you can. But
- 27:33this is what I find In making your business into
- 27:37a masterpiece, you're going to have to take moral risks,
- 27:41and you're going to have to bring your team or
- 27:43the majority of your team along with you. When when
- 27:49Bezos fired founding employees, he had to bring the majority
- 27:53of his team with it. When when when Anita Roddick
- 27:56from the the Body Shop sold half the company behind
- 28:00the back of her CFO, she had to bring most
- 28:04of the people with her. You need to do that. Now,
- 28:08how do you do that? When you're taking risks that
- 28:12people don't think makes sense. They have to admire you.
- 28:18And the reason they have to admire you is because
- 28:23you exhibit virtues that they find very attractive. It can
- 28:28be a virtue of wisdom, It can be a virtue
- 28:31of loving your company, your employees. It can be a
- 28:35virtue of justice. It can be any one of the
- 28:37classic virtues. Or it can be a virtue like Steve
- 28:40Jobs of inventiveness. But you have to build yourself and
- 28:47your leadership style around your virtues. And if you do that,
- 28:52you'll have a masterful leadership style that people admire, and
- 28:57then you can bring them along through the moral risk
- 29:01taking to create the company. Now, the virtues can be
- 29:08rather simple. Julia Robertson, whom I mentioned to you, who
- 29:13changed the recruitment industry. She was a nurturing leader. She
- 29:20nurtured her employees as much as she could. Now we
- 29:23can say nurturing that sort of a mom like virtue.
- 29:25That's not a leader like virtue. It doesn't make any difference.
- 29:28If you push your virtue to the max. To the maximum,
- 29:32people will admire it. They can follow you, and they
- 29:34will fire you, follow you through those very difficult moments
- 29:39that you have to go through to create a masterpiece.
- 29:42If there is another way to create a masterpiece aj
- 29:44where you don't have to do that, somebody write me
- 29:48and tell me. I haven't seen it, And I'll tell
- 29:51you this. Lots of leaders would love to find because
- 29:54they've been trained in social sciences. Give me a recipe
- 29:57for being able to turn my business into a master
- 30:00where I don't also have to turn myself into a masterpiece.
- 30:03People would love it if they could find that. I
- 30:05don't think there is. One of the things I harp
- 30:09on in the book is we don't have roses without thorns,
- 30:13and one of the thorns is if you're going to
- 30:15create a masterpiece, you have to make yourself into a
- 30:17virtuous masterpiece to do it.
- 30:20Speaker 1: Absolutely, we'll come to your book, but first help us
- 30:23understand you talk about moral risk taking.
- 30:27Speaker 2: Yes, and at.
- 30:30Speaker 1: Outset it sounds like you know something towards the negative,
- 30:34but I guess it means something positive. Help us understand
- 30:37what is this moral risk taking in leadership that you
- 30:40talk about chance?
- 30:41Speaker 3: Well, ay Jaye, thank you for asking that. I can't.
- 30:47I'm going to try to give you the shortest answer
- 30:49I can. But that is the best question anybody could
- 30:53ask me about the book. And as I say, listen,
- 30:59let me say to you and your audience, I'm going
- 31:02to give the shortest, quickest answer I can't. If you
- 31:04don't like it, if it doesn't make sense, send me
- 31:07an email, contact me through LinkedIn. I'll go on about this.
- 31:10I'll tell you where in the book you can find
- 31:13the answer. It's in chapter six More was Thinking is
- 31:16a new idea and the whole and it's repellent to
- 31:22most ways of thinking about morality because when you take
- 31:25a risk, luck is involved. You're successful by luck or
- 31:28by not. And we don't believe that anybody. We don't
- 31:32in the first instance, believe that anybody can be good
- 31:35by luck or evil by luck. We believe it. That's
- 31:38who they are. It's deep down, deep in their character,
- 31:42in their habits, in their hearts. A philosopher I named
- 31:47Bernard Williams, who recently died, said that's not right. We've
- 31:52really missed how we live morally. And he invented the
- 31:56story of Gugana to show that. And for those of
- 32:02you who don't know European art, is a famous twentieth
- 32:04century European artist post impressions and absolutely brilliant artists. And
- 32:08it'll come out as I tell the story. But here's
- 32:12William's story. Grgan was a struggling artist in Paris with
- 32:18a wife and five children and a very bourgeois family,
- 32:21very very middle class, very middle class values. He had
- 32:25the intuition and it was just a whim that if
- 32:29he got out of his bourgeois surroundings, his middle class surroundings,
- 32:34he could paint some great art, some art that would
- 32:37be really valued around the world. Now, in the middle class,
- 32:41everybody's got whims like that. You don't follow them, that's immoral. Well,
- 32:46in fact he did. He abandoned his family, he ran
- 32:51off to Tahiti and painted the great art that we
- 32:55know Gaugaan for. And if you don't know Gagan's art,
- 32:58it's largely art of Tahitian women into Tahitian life. It's
- 33:04very earthy, it's erotic, it seems to people it's laid
- 33:10back and easy going. It doesn't have any of the
- 33:14middle class stresses in it. And in fact, for those
- 33:18of us who grew up with the art, it did
- 33:21change our view of what a middle class life was like.
- 33:24It opened it up a little. I recommend those of
- 33:27you who haven't seen Gogan that you just look at
- 33:30someone gone Gainsts art. It is amazing. And then Brennan
- 33:34Williams asked the question, did go again do the right thing?
- 33:41And he asked it of people who appreciate Godgaan's art,
- 33:43people like me, who in fact change my golgams are
- 33:48And he said, and the answer is, if you really
- 33:51appreciate his art, you have to say he did the
- 33:54right thing. You can regret the fact that he hurt
- 33:58his family in doing it, but it's hard to say
- 34:03he did the wrong thing. And here's where the luck
- 34:06comes in. Suppose he ran off the Tahiti, lived an
- 34:11unrestrained life there and produced no great art, how would
- 34:16you answer the question, did you do the right thing?
- 34:18You would say, no, he was a cat here's a
- 34:22bad guy. He was a bad husband. He deserves to
- 34:25be punished. It turns out that if you create i
- 34:31want to say, life changing art, a masterpiece, in short,
- 34:39the moral actions that you took, or the immoral the
- 34:43seemingly immoral actions that you took, were really the right actions.
- 34:48It's not just an ends means thing, because in these cases,
- 34:54when you're facing a moral difficulty of the sort go again,
- 34:58you don't really know if you can succeed. You don't
- 35:01know what the success will look like. It's really much
- 35:06more risky than just saying the ends could justify the means,
- 35:09or calculating the ends and saying they could justify the means.
- 35:12But that kind of moral risk actually binds us together
- 35:16more closely. And I won't take the time to explain
- 35:20how it does, but it makes us complicit with Gaugan.
- 35:24If we love the art, we have to excuse the wrong,
- 35:28and we in fact are complicit in that wrong, in
- 35:33him leaving his wife. And that is the way in
- 35:36which Bernard Williams says we're bound together. That is the
- 35:39moral lesson at the right in the middle of leadership
- 35:45is masterpiece creation, and that is the key moral lesson that.
- 35:48I believe you learn from the humanities today that you
- 35:52can carry on into business. I apologize for anybody if
- 35:57I went through that too fast. That's the fastest way
- 35:59I know to go through it.
- 36:02Speaker 1: We will certainly get a chance to talk much more
- 36:05on this chanice. But while you were talking about we
- 36:08were talking about the great, great artists, whereas some of
- 36:11these leaders, I can tell you we are.
- 36:13Speaker 2: They are not artists. They are corn artists. And I
- 36:16don't know how they can be they can.
- 36:19Speaker 1: Get to be leaders, masterpiece, leadership, muster piece in themselves.
- 36:24Speaker 2: That's a very tough task, you know.
- 36:26Speaker 1: And many a time they invoke the name of great
- 36:29great they do they do.
- 36:31Speaker 3: Look I write about Andrew Fastile in the book Andrew
- 36:34Fastew we see CFO of Enron, and I consider the
- 36:42these real evil doers, like the evil doers in literature.
- 36:46And if you look at the and I haven't looked
- 36:49at all of them as a researcher, but I certainly
- 36:52looked at Andrew fast Now. And these are people who
- 36:56fall in love with their own genius in overcoming a
- 37:01moral anomaly. They're brilliant. They see a moral anomaly, they
- 37:06see the dark side of the moral anomaly, and they
- 37:11actually moved to that, and that is how they create
- 37:16the evil that they create. You can Bernie made off
- 37:22hugely evil. He saw the nature of trust, He saw
- 37:28how it was that people actually came to trust other
- 37:31people very deeply, and he manipulated it. He fell in
- 37:38love with his own genius and understanding trust so that
- 37:41he could manipulate that. And that happens, and that also
- 37:45shows you it's not just greed. That's the mistake. People
- 37:52think these people are just greedy. No, these people love
- 37:55the evil. They fall in love with the evil, and
- 37:59that's why they do it. The people that do these
- 38:04terrible things in business, I believe could succeed without doing
- 38:12the things that are evil. I think it's again it's
- 38:15it's a mistake. We're thinking it's just motivations, and somebody
- 38:21finds it easy to get a little extra money here,
- 38:23a little extra money there. They're greedy and they create
- 38:26a bad organization. The bad organizations, in my view, the
- 38:30ones that you described a moment earlier. That's because people
- 38:35have fallen in love with their genius. They can see
- 38:37a way to do it well. They can see a
- 38:39way to do it poorly, and they do it poorly.
- 38:42It is It's what Saint Augustine told us about evil.
- 38:48He tells the story and his confessions. He stole the
- 38:51pairs from the neighbor, not because he was hungry and
- 38:53wanted pairs. He didn't even like pairs. He stole the
- 38:58pairs from his neighbor because he saw his neighbor was
- 39:01innocent and did not protect the pairs, and that made
- 39:05them open to theft. And he did it for the
- 39:08pure joy of the evil of harming his neighbor. That's
- 39:12where evil comes from. That's what it's like, and that's
- 39:15where how we have to counter it.
- 39:19Speaker 2: Absolutely, and that's how human nature is. That's the way
- 39:22we are made.
- 39:23Speaker 1: We have to find good in ourselves and try to
- 39:26also see that evil does not take over our genius
- 39:29wherever we.
- 39:30Speaker 3: Are there, you are a very important lesson from the humanities,
- 39:35not something that in social science you'll learn because of
- 39:38social science. It is all motives and incentives.
- 39:42Speaker 1: Absolutely, there's so much to learn from you chance, so
- 39:45much to learn from your book. Let's come to your book, Leadership,
- 39:48best masterpiece Creation. Tell us who is this book for?
- 39:52Is it for the genius? Leaders is it for the
- 39:54evil leaders? Is it for the good leaders? Who is
- 39:58this book for?
- 40:02Speaker 3: Okay? For me I put it. I think of it
- 40:05a little bit more simply than that, Although I love
- 40:08your question. It is for the genius leaders, but not
- 40:15primarily for the genius leaders, either good or evil. It
- 40:19is for all the leaders that I tried to describe
- 40:22in the beginning, and that is the people that have
- 40:25a sense of what the right way to treat their
- 40:28customers is, what the right way to treat their employees is,
- 40:33what the right way to treat their owners is. And
- 40:36they're being told by everybody around them to follow a
- 40:39recipe to scale up, to increase productivity and profits and
- 40:43so forth, and they're following recipes, but they think they're
- 40:46not doing the right thing. This book. The people that
- 40:48love the book that I love saying your book gives
- 40:52me permission to do what I've always wanted to do.
- 40:55It gives me I mean, that's a little bit heartbreaking,
- 40:58because I think it gives more than permission. Of course,
- 41:00it gives you permission to create a masterpiece, but it
- 41:03gives you lots of particular things to do to create
- 41:06a masterpiece and get yourself ready for it. People do
- 41:09give me credit for that, but the big thing they
- 41:11say is it gives me permission. So it's all those
- 41:14leaders between the small business owner who knows exactly what
- 41:18to do, who is creating a moral business, and the shapers.
- 41:22It's all of those people in the middle. That's the
- 41:25first thing. But you do not have to be the
- 41:27leader of a business if you are even an employee.
- 41:32But if you're somebody who has any leadership aspirations, this
- 41:37book is for you. And the early chapters I tell
- 41:42you things that you need to learn to be a
- 41:45morally imaginative leader that you can do in any role
- 41:50in your organization. You in any role can learn how
- 41:54to manage your mood. Bad moods are contagious, they harm
- 41:58an organization. Good moods aren't so contagious. But if you
- 42:02have a good mood and you can maintain a good
- 42:04mood and expression, you're doing something moral for your organization.
- 42:08Next step up at this I took from a consultant
- 42:12name Fernando Flor's make promises. Don't just get an order
- 42:17from your boss and fulfill it. There's sometimes when you
- 42:20have to do it. But make a promise. I'll get
- 42:23this to you by such and such a time. It'll
- 42:25be at such and such a quality. Make it moral.
- 42:29Just make it moral. The next one up, learn how
- 42:33to tell truth to power. You can do this at
- 42:37any level in the organization. Now, learning how to tell
- 42:39truth to power isn't just seeing what's true and blurting
- 42:42it out. People don't like that because you're essentially telling
- 42:46them they're wrong. To tell truth to power, you have
- 42:49to let the people in power know that you care
- 42:51for them. They need to know that you've really studied
- 42:54what you're talking about and thought about it, and they
- 42:57need to know that you care about the organization. You
- 42:59have to be able to all those things when you
- 43:02say what's true, and if you do, odds are you'll
- 43:05get listened to. So those are things that you can
- 43:07do even if you're not in management. If you are
- 43:10in management, this book teaches you the moral questions that
- 43:15you face all the time. If you're a manager of
- 43:17any sort. Do you stretch this employee? Do you push
- 43:20this employee hard? Really let off? And by the way, consultants,
- 43:26everybody who is advising people every advice, that's one of
- 43:30the basic questions in your life. Do I stretch this
- 43:32person further harder or not, And you need to be
- 43:36waking up in the middle of the night thinking did
- 43:38I do it right? Did I do it wrong? And
- 43:41the same thing. Are we treating customers as do it
- 43:44yourselfers or are we treating customers as people who need
- 43:48lots of help? Where on the spectrum are they? How
- 43:50have I set things on that spectrum? Am I doing
- 43:54win lose contracts with contractors even when I want to
- 43:58do win win contracts the contractors? How do I get
- 44:01out of that? And by the way, I run into
- 44:03many people who want to do win win, But the
- 44:07habits to do win lose are so strong that it's
- 44:12almost impossible. You see an opportunity, you just take it.
- 44:15You can't help yourself. By the way, that's falling in
- 44:18love with your own evil. That's a version of it.
- 44:20So anybody who has any leadership aspirations, they can begin
- 44:25with the book and learn from it. The early chapters
- 44:28are basically stuff for anybody. By the time I get
- 44:31to the big deal moral risks taking and the strategies
- 44:34around moral risk, you do have to be the leader
- 44:37at least of a division to get that, And those
- 44:40are the last chapters of the book. And I think
- 44:42most people would want to know what it's like to
- 44:44be a leader, even if they can't use those skills
- 44:47right away. Thank you for asking that question, by the way,
- 44:51aj I really appreciate it.
- 44:54Speaker 2: Thank you.
- 44:54Speaker 1: There is so much to learn from you about all
- 44:57these things, Charles. And I'm sure a lot of people
- 44:59who want to learn more from you, about you, about
- 45:03what you have been doing, what you do now, from
- 45:06about your book and so many other books that you
- 45:08have written. So what is the best way for them
- 45:11to connect with you?
- 45:13Speaker 3: The best way to connect with me is right now
- 45:15through LinkedIn. It's Charles Spinosa LinkedIn. It's it's pretty simple
- 45:21to get to me there, you know. I I answer
- 45:27email when people write me on email too, I'll say
- 45:30it what the email is. The LinkedIn is the thing
- 45:33that's easy to remember. But Charles dot Spinosa dot PhD
- 45:37at gmail dot com.
- 45:40Speaker 2: Wonderful with this.
- 45:41Speaker 1: It's set up on this very special edition of The
- 45:44Cage Masterclass Live.
- 45:46Speaker 2: Thank you so much.
- 45:47Speaker 3: Indeed, can I tell them please look at Amazon and
- 45:50purchase my book? I think it's inspiring.
- 45:53Speaker 2: Of course.
- 45:54Speaker 1: Of course, I'll also add the link to the to
- 45:56the description and show notes. So with this it's set
- 45:59up on this very special edition of the Skage in
- 46:02Masterclass Live.
- 46:03Speaker 2: Thank you so much indeed for joining us.
- 46:07Speaker 3: Thank you all