Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 134: France's Snap Elections- What Happens Now?
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Trimuta. In the last episode, you heard
- 0:14me talk to Katie Lee about the snap elections in France, why
- 0:18they happened, what they mean and what party was predicted to
- 0:21perform well in the first round. Now here we are, a day before
- 0:25the second round, and not only has everything we discussed come
- 0:28to pass, the stakes are even higher now.
- 0:32When the results trickled in Sunday evening, I was at a jazz
- 0:34manoush festival in Fontainebleau.
- 0:37I tapped my feet to India Owens and The Cookout, an incredible
- 0:40band from Detroit, and watched as a packed intergenerational
- 0:44international crowd moved their bodies with lightness and joy.
- 0:48A few of us dipped our heads into our phones to check the
- 0:51tally, but being enveloped in a group of people united by music
- 0:55and in the present largely buoyed the spirits.
- 0:59Once at home however, and since Monday, reality set in and the
- 1:03full picture emerged of what happens now.
- 1:09First, let's talk about the results.
- 1:11The Hassan Plamon Nationale or the National Rally or RN as I'll
- 1:15refer to it, combined with their new found allies in Les
- 1:18Republic, namely Eric COT, brought in 33% of the votes.
- 1:23In a rather close second place, we've got the Nouveau from
- 1:25Popular or the Left coalition that formed in record-breaking
- 1:28time, which had about 28% of the votes and six point behind.
- 1:33And 3rd comes ensemble, the president's party.
- 1:36Almost immediately, our Prime Minister Gabriel ET al insisted
- 1:39that to block the far right candidates in 3rd place should
- 1:42pull out of the race. As a result, in a few days, 224
- 1:46candidates in Macron's party on the Left bloc have stepped down.
- 1:50Now, polls are imperfect, as we know.
- 1:51But as a result of this tactical maneuver, Harris Interactive
- 1:55estimates that the RN and its allies will actually end up with
- 1:58only 190 to 220 seats and not the 289 needed for an absolute
- 2:04majority. We can only hope that they're
- 2:07right. As for concretely what happens
- 2:10in every district where a candidate did not yield a
- 2:12majority, voters go back to the urns On Sunday.
- 2:15In my district, we elected Emmanuel Gregoire in the first
- 2:18round with a small majority. So he's in and we don't vote
- 2:21again. Anyway, back to the bigger
- 2:23issue. If the far right doesn't win an
- 2:25absolute majority, there is the issue of a relative majority,
- 2:28which would still make it the biggest caucus in the Assembly.
- 2:31Here's my friend and previous guest, Reem Montaz, a research
- 2:34consultant for the International Institute for Strategic Studies,
- 2:37telling CNN about the implications of this.
- 2:40If that is the case, they would still have the opportunity to
- 2:45form a government. But.
- 2:47In a Parliament that is much more divided, much less stable
- 2:51and where they will be very vulnerable to no confidence
- 2:54votes. There are plenty of lessons to
- 2:57take away from these first round results.
- 3:00First, the turn out rate was unusually high at 66.7 percent.
- 3:0510.63 million people voted for the far right.
- 3:09This was not about abstention and it was not a protest vote.
- 3:13And I think that fact is something we all need to sit
- 3:16with and consider because it is real.
- 3:18And while it is alarming, there are reasons the gilets jaunes or
- 3:23yellow vest movement pre COVID was a clear sign.
- 3:26Just like there were reasons Trump voters were able to give
- 3:29for supporting him despite the lies, despite hateful rhetoric,
- 3:32and despite attempts to dismantle the very services they
- 3:35need to survive. If our leaders in France refuse
- 3:39to understand how and why this happened here, I do fear we will
- 3:42continue down the very same path.
- 3:45Now, As for why Bar de La has been so compelling, I'd say it's
- 3:50because he's a smooth talker now only, however, if he sticks to
- 3:54his scripted talking points, and those talking points are what he
- 3:58trots out at any opportunity. Immigration is out of control
- 4:01and the reason people are suffering.
- 4:03The country needs reinforced security and purchasing power is
- 4:07too weak, economically speaking. Economists have said none of the
- 4:11far right's policies hold up, nor would they benefit the
- 4:14people who need them most. This is a classic scenario we've
- 4:17seen play out in the US and in the fallout from Brexit in the
- 4:20UK. Those are the basics.
- 4:23But on top of that, there have been highly contested ideas put
- 4:26forth during the last week's debate about dual nationals and
- 4:29Baghdadas intention to prohibit them from accessing what he
- 4:32calls strategic positions, whether that's in ministries
- 4:36working on nuclear energy or national intelligence.
- 4:39Xenophobia, as we know, has always been part of the far
- 4:42right's ideology, and it's still there.
- 4:45And when you look deeply into the R NS platform, their
- 4:48solution to the most pressing issues of their constituents is
- 4:51to halt immigration. Frankly, it's a shortcut for
- 4:55real problems and one that doesn't treat the cause.
- 4:58I spent the last week listening to interviews with everyday
- 5:00French people across the country, listening to people who
- 5:04have publicly stated their intentions to continue to vote
- 5:07for the far right. And what I have found
- 5:09interesting is that many of these individuals previously
- 5:11voted for the left or the far left, and others voted for
- 5:15Macron but felt ignored or neglected by his arrogance and
- 5:19social distance. And so now he is not even an
- 5:22option for them either. I've also noticed that young and
- 5:25working class voters who historically voted left and far
- 5:28left also shifted to the right. And that's true across Europe.
- 5:33You know, these are people, despite being raised by a
- 5:35generation, who brought about the liberal revolutions of the
- 5:371960s and for whom overtly anti-Semitic and racist
- 5:41behaviors and attitudes were shameful.
- 5:44While that all seems to be meaningless, the stigma
- 5:46associated with them, it seems, has faded now.
- 5:50To that, we could say it's because of the cost of living
- 5:52crisis, the extreme isolation during COVID, or the effects of
- 5:57TikTok and other social media platforms where far right
- 5:59content runs rampant. I think ultimately it's probably
- 6:04a combination of all of these things.
- 6:06Eric Fasson, a sociologist and professor at Paris Ritz, told
- 6:10France 24 this week that support for the far right is also a
- 6:13question of identity. Read all their program because
- 6:18in fact they keep changing it. So what are they going to do
- 6:22about Europe? Who knows?
- 6:24What are they going to do about pension reforms?
- 6:27Who knows? In fact, that's why the markets
- 6:30are not worried because in fact, oh, it has been a rhetoric for
- 6:35the campaign sort of saying we're close to the working class
- 6:38and so we're going to have basically we're on the left.
- 6:41That's almost where the National Rally has been playing with
- 6:44Marine Le Pen for years. We're on the side of the working
- 6:47class and we're going to fight financial institutions,
- 6:50etcetera. We're going to fight Europe,
- 6:52etcetera. That's what they say in
- 6:54practice. Everyone knows they're not going
- 6:56to do it and it doesn't change the votes.
- 6:59That is, people know that they will not radically change
- 7:04economic policy. All they know it.
- 7:07But in fact, that's not why they vote for the National Rally
- 7:09because basically the National Rally says it's about identity.
- 7:13It's about being white. It's about not being Muslim.
- 7:20In fact, that's what they're selling and that's what sells.
- 7:22So in fact, that's why they can afford to change their positions
- 7:27on this and that all the time. And so the markets, well, that's
- 7:31not their problem, right? Perhaps what I find most
- 7:34striking of all is actually that voters have bought in to the R
- 7:38NS narrative that the party has changed, that it is somehow no
- 7:42longer the anti-Semitic, hateful, intolerant, fascist
- 7:45fringe founded by Marine Le Pen's father.
- 7:49It's worth remembering in these times that in 1930s Germany,
- 7:52Hitler didn't get elected on his most sinister ideas.
- 7:55He rallied support by taking credit for extending the
- 7:57Autobahn and job creation, which he did through shoring up the
- 8:00arms and defense industry. His unmasked anti-Semitism and
- 8:04terror trickled in over the course of several years before
- 8:07eventually breaking through and unleashing a storm.
- 8:10And if voters can't see or refuse to see the similarities
- 8:13between 1930s Germany and what's unfolding here and in the US,
- 8:17where the Supreme Court has all but guaranteed an absolute
- 8:20monarchy should Trump get re elected, I fear we are really in
- 8:24trouble. I've received a slew of messages
- 8:27this week from foreigners in France who asked, well, what
- 8:30does this really mean? What does this mean for people
- 8:31applying for visas or naturalization?
- 8:34And to that I say, I think it's too soon to speculate on those
- 8:38particular specifics, but my gut says the far right's priority
- 8:42will not necessarily be to increase its power the second
- 8:45they get in the door. If they get an absolute
- 8:47majority, which by the way, would put Bardela into the role
- 8:50of Prime Minister, I think they will start slowly and do what
- 8:54they can to limit all of the people and entities who can
- 8:57prevent them from trying. Ultimately, it's because they
- 9:01have their sights set on the bigger project on 2027, the next
- 9:04presidential election and the balance for their eventual power
- 9:09grab. The counterweight we need is an
- 9:12independent judiciary and an independent press, and those
- 9:15things are also at risk if they get through.
- 9:17A press owned by industrial or financial groups poses a
- 9:21problem. We've seen that already with the
- 9:23networks owned by the right wing media mogul Vincent Boro Ray,
- 9:26who owns Serit Senus Canal, Prus Hachette, the world's third
- 9:30largest publisher and Havas, a global communication giant.
- 9:34And the same danger exists for regional daily newspapers, which
- 9:37are extremely important to maintain for the local
- 9:39community. The reality is the far right,
- 9:43wherever they are, don't care about their people or their
- 9:46districts in France. They're not invested in them.
- 9:49Long term they will erode public services and privatize public
- 9:53broadcasting including France Television which even pre
- 9:56finances many films and that are made within France and Europe.
- 10:01Marine Le Pen has already communicated her desire to do
- 10:04this. And when it comes to research
- 10:06and science and education, 5 French Nobel Prize winners,
- 10:10along with other researchers, wrote in an op-ed in Le Monde on
- 10:14June 25th that the RN accessing seats of power would constitute
- 10:18a serious and immediate threat to research and higher education
- 10:21in France as a result of xenophobic and nationalistic
- 10:24positions that would isolate France from the international
- 10:28scientific community. I don't know about you, but it's
- 10:32already giving me Ron DeSantis and Trump vibes.
- 10:34Let's rewrite history, let's control criticism, and let's
- 10:37vilify anyone who tries to stop us.
- 10:40Now, As for who's to blame for all of this, I admit my
- 10:44inclination is to blame all of it on our president, and I don't
- 10:48know that it really can fall all on him.
- 10:51But I do think a fair bit of it, Ken.
- 10:54And and I'd like to highlight some thoughts by my friend
- 10:56Lauren Collins, who profiled Emmanuel Macron for The New
- 10:59Yorker in 2019. And she recently looked back on
- 11:02that conversation for her newsletter in light of the way
- 11:05the last month has unfolded, she writes.
- 11:08One of Macron's greatest political mistakes, in my
- 11:11opinion, has been his failure to uphold the pact of equilibrium
- 11:14that brought him to power. Instead, he has tacked further
- 11:18and further to the right, dragging the political center
- 11:21along with him and closer to the Rasom Brimon Nacional and
- 11:24leaving behind his many supporters who fell anywhere to
- 11:27the left of center right. He would argue that the people
- 11:32went and he followed. Even in 2019, it was clear that
- 11:36Macron had not made good on the AU Menton promise on which he
- 11:40rose. In our conversation, he
- 11:42acknowledged a desynchronization problem, saying that he'd front
- 11:46loaded fiscal reforms. He explained that instead of
- 11:50practicing economic liberalism and social liberalism
- 11:53simultaneously, he had chosen to pursue them consecutively.
- 11:57But the social justice sequence that he promised never quite
- 12:01materialized. Personally, I wouldn't want to
- 12:04be in the 80s Eight Palace this week, and definitely not on
- 12:07Sunday evening. But may Mac Holm find it in
- 12:10himself to finally put his hubris aside and reflect on just
- 12:14how much he has contributed to bringing us where we are today.
- 12:20And may that be something he continues to think about should
- 12:22he find himself in a cohabitation or governing with
- 12:26Jordan Bardella on July 8th. Co Haja Tulmond, we need each
- 12:32other more than ever. I'm about to take a short break,
- 12:36but back to you with news from Paris and perhaps the Olympics
- 12:39in just a few weeks. Until then, take care of
- 12:43yourself and Abiento. If you enjoy the show, it would
- 12:48mean the world if you would rate and leave a review on Spotify,
- 12:52Apple or wherever you get your podcasts.
- 12:55Until next time, Abiento.