Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Obesity & Child Abuse
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners, It's that time of year again when I try to
- 0:04clean the slate regarding the emails that y'all have sent in. Whenever you email
- 0:09in, Stacey will put your email into a Google Doc and then I will
- 0:16go through the emails, you know, if I'm doing an episode by myself
- 0:20or an episode with one of the co hosts, and the emails will pile
- 0:26up, and so I at the end of the year. At the beginning
- 0:29of each year, I try to go through all those emails and clean up
- 0:33the Google docs because if I don't do that, the Google docs will become
- 0:40so large that they won't open. If you've ever had a Google Doc that
- 0:45has too many pages, it'll take forever to load. So I thought I
- 0:50would do that now, and I am going to now answer an email from
- 0:56annual patron and YouTube member. She says, I've been listening to your deep
- 1:00dive about the Duggers and watching your videos about Ruby, Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt,
- 1:04and it really struck me deeply because I have my own traumatic experiences as
- 1:10a child, specifically with being sexually abused as a child. I have struggled
- 1:15with weight issues from my teens up until now and since the pandemic, I
- 1:21have gained a lot of weight and currently I would be classified as obese.
- 1:26This is something I want to resolve through my own therapy, but each time
- 1:32I try to talk about it with my therapist, I become annoyed and I
- 1:36shut it down. A few days ago, I came across a link where
- 1:42an intercnologist who champions a healthy lifestyle. This intercarnologist tweeted that on a weekly
- 1:49basis, he deals with a patient referred to him for obesity that has experienced
- 1:55sexual or other abuse as a child or teen and just chiming in here.
- 2:00She sent me a link to said tweet or Instagram post and it is by
- 2:07doctor Carl Nadolski and it says not a fucking week goes by that I don't
- 2:14have a patient referred for obesity and complications who has a history of weight gain
- 2:20after sexual or other abuse trauma as a child or adolescent. So heartbreaking and
- 2:24infuriating going on with the email. So my question is is there a link
- 2:30between this and could this be the reason I am so unmotivated to lose weight?
- 2:36My therapist is asking me to name the emotion behind it, and I
- 2:40just feel like I can't end of email. Yeah. Well, first off,
- 2:46I'm of course terribly sorry that you were sexually abused as a child.
- 2:52It's, you know, that sort of abuse, and really a lot of
- 2:55types of abuse, but you know that in particular can have so many aspects
- 3:00of trauma and long lasting effects. It's not just that it was a difficult
- 3:07experience, because of course it is that, but the lessons that you are
- 3:14taught, the distortions about yourself, the distortions about what you're worth and what
- 3:21you deserve and who you are, it gets under your skin and I'm just
- 3:27so sorry that that happened to you. But to answer your question, is
- 3:32weight gain and obesity linked to childhood sexual abuse? The answer is yes,
- 3:39there is a lot of research on this topic. In fact, coincidentally,
- 3:46I was working on my notes. One of the things that I've benefited from
- 3:53this year trying to slow down with my YouTube video content making is that it
- 4:00gives me a chance to look into topics that I'm just interested in looking into,
- 4:05regardless of the utility of it. And one of those topics was a
- 4:12couple of days ago, I really wanted, you know, I'd heard about
- 4:15this ACES test, and of course i'd used it before, adverse childhood experiences.
- 4:19You know, ACE and I have, of course, you know,
- 4:26talked about adverse childhood experiences. I don't use that phrase. It's mainly a
- 4:30medical profession phrase, and I'll get into that in a second. I don't
- 4:34know, I'm just kind of curious about the history of the ACES test and
- 4:39about what the research is and all that kind of stuff. So let me
- 4:43just kind of go into that right now. So let me talk about Vincent
- 4:47Feliti. He started his career as a physician in the nineteen sixties, and
- 4:56by the nineteen eighties, doctor Vincent Felidi he was head of Kaiser Permanente's Department
- 5:03of Preventative Medicine in San Diego. So he was an influential, important physician
- 5:12in San Diego working at Kaiser Permanente. And while he was working with patients
- 5:17and supervising a lot of physicians, he started noticing that a lot of the
- 5:25patients would drop out of the obesity clinic. In fact, he found out
- 5:30that fifty percent of the patients who came to the obesity clinic had dropped out,
- 5:38even though they were losing weight. And this was very confusing to him
- 5:43because you don't usually see that in the medical field. If you have a
- 5:47clinic that is treating kidney disease and there is a dialysis, for example,
- 5:55and other treatments, and you have someone come in with the need for treatment
- 6:01and they start getting the treatment and their lives start to improve, their blood
- 6:06work starts to improve, their symptoms improve, you don't normally see among those
- 6:13kidney disease patients a fifty percent rate of dropout. You just don't normally see
- 6:17that. You might see I don't know what the average percentage, but you
- 6:20might see like a five percent, ten percent, but not fifty percent.
- 6:26So he was really concerned about this. And he is an interesting person.
- 6:32He's still with us as far as I know, and he's very passionate about
- 6:38helping people. He's a very energetic guy, and so this very much frustrated
- 6:46him. And if you know his personality based on the interviews that I've seen,
- 6:49you could see him just as a young person and his I don't know,
- 6:54would you maybe be in his forties at this point, maybe thirties even
- 6:57He's just like, what's going on here? And so he would look into
- 7:02it more closely, and he would find that there would be patients who were
- 7:09three hundred pounds overweight when they enter the clinic and with treatment would lose one
- 7:15hundred pounds and they're continuing to lose weight and then all of a sudden boom,
- 7:21they drop out. And it wasn't it wasn't clear why all of these
- 7:27people were dropping out, And he wasn't concerned about money in all likelihood.
- 7:32Usually people like this they're concerned about patients, they're concerned about helping people.
- 7:36They're passionate about that. So he's just frustrated with this and doesn't know what
- 7:45to make of it. Remember this is the eighties, So I'm guessing for
- 7:48you all now you will say, well, how about looking into mental health?
- 7:53Well, people don't do that very much now, and they sure didn't
- 7:57do it in the eighties. The reason why we even kind of do it
- 8:01now is to a large extent because of Vincent Felidi. So in the eighties,
- 8:07So later he is working and he's doing an intake interview with a patient
- 8:13who was entering the OBCD clinic, and there were a series of questions in
- 8:18the intake, like how much did you weigh when you started the first grade,
- 8:24and how old were you when you first became sexually active? And how
- 8:28old were you when you got married these kind of questions. It's just like
- 8:31general assessment kinds of stuff, and it's a you know, the purpose of
- 8:37the assessment, I'm guessing is just to kind of get the lay of the
- 8:39land. You know, if the person suddenly gained weight in the last three
- 8:45years, you start looking at the medications or some change in behavior in the
- 8:50last few years. Whereas if the obesity or the weight gain or the overweight
- 8:56aspects of the individual at a very young age was something going on there.
- 9:01So, you know, it's just an assessment, just trying to get a
- 9:05lay of the land. And during one of these interviews, according to him,
- 9:09he says that he flubbed one of the questions. Instead of asking the
- 9:16question how old were you when you were first sexually active, so you know,
- 9:22most people, especially back then, would say something like fifteen sixteen or
- 9:26something. Instead he asked how much did you weigh when you were first sexually
- 9:31active? So doctor Vincent Feleet he mashed up two questions. Instead of how
- 9:39much did you weigh when you started the first grade and how old were you
- 9:41when you become sexually active? He like merged these two things together by accident
- 9:48and before he could correct the question, so he asked, you know,
- 9:52how much did you weigh when you were first sexually active? And the patient
- 9:56answered forty pounds? And he thought, what he's set? Okay, I
- 10:03asked the wrong question. But wait, forty pounds? What are you saying?
- 10:07So he asked the question again. Wait, so let me ask the
- 10:11wrong question. How how much did you weigh when you were first sexually active?
- 10:16And she says, you know, forty pounds, and then she bursts
- 10:22out crying, and he is compassionate, so he listens and she opens up
- 10:28and she says that she was sexually abused by her father. And this is
- 10:35so moving to him, and he starts wondering, is this related to the
- 10:39fifty percent dropout? Because back then and to a large extent now, a
- 10:46lot of medical professionals and I want to indict the medical field. It's it's
- 10:50our culture as well, that the way that people and maybe a lot in
- 10:58the medical profession will look at weight gain, they'll see it as maybe just
- 11:03behavioral, maybe just genetics, or maybe just some sort of hormonal issue,
- 11:11and of course those are things to look at. But the idea that someone
- 11:16would say, I wonder how the person is doing psychologically emotionally in how close
- 11:26are their relationships, how are their relationships, what are the quality of their
- 11:30relationships? Those are something. Those are things that just are generally ignored by
- 11:35everybody, including the medical field, and for those in the medical field that
- 11:39want to pay attention to it, there's not an easy system to facilitate the
- 11:45medical professionals to assess those things because a lot of patients aren't expecting those kind
- 11:52of questions. A lot of hospitals and clinics don't really have that culture.
- 11:58It would really be off script for a lot of medical professionals even if they
- 12:03wanted to to ask those sorts of questions. And they're not trained very well
- 12:09on these things, if at all. Some of them are, of course,
- 12:11but it's not a major focus of their training. So and I'm saying
- 12:18them meaning everyone in the medical field. Of course, there's a lot of
- 12:20course, you have psychiatrists who are of course trained in talking to people,
- 12:24but about these things. Anyway, So he starts to wonder, you know,
- 12:28I asked this weird question she says forty pounds. Then she burst into
- 12:33tears and she tells me she was sexually abused, And he starts wondering,
- 12:37you know, I don't ask that question. None of us are asking that
- 12:41question, were you sexually abused? What else are we not assessing for that
- 12:46might be critical in the assessment process and in the treatment process regarding obesity,
- 12:52not just to help people lose weight, but to help them in whatever it
- 13:00is that's getting in the way as they are succeeding in the treatment. What's
- 13:05happening there? Okay, So what do people do in my field and in
- 13:11the medical profession, Well, we do research, which is what he did.
- 13:13You don't just make shut up off the top of your head. You
- 13:16don't go on Facebook and ask your aunt what she would think, unless she's
- 13:22a physician or a scientist. You know. I'm referring to how people go
- 13:26online and get all their medical advice from those sources. Data, data,
- 13:35data. So he conducted a preliminary study and it was formal but more on
- 13:43the casual side. He and his staff interviewed two hundred and eighty six current
- 13:48patients, and he found that most of the patients had indeed experienced childhood sexual
- 13:56abuse. Again, this is the nineteen eighties. This is just as satanic
- 14:03panic is starting to kick in. It's also happening just as the awareness of
- 14:07sexual abuse is starting to become more prominent. It's just emerging. The satanic
- 14:16panic, if you're aware of that problem was partially which is still happening,
- 14:20by the way, Jody Hildebrandt and Teal Swan and all that. You know
- 14:24that one therapist somebody snow anyway, it all kind of comes from this moment,
- 14:30but it was based on something that was good in that all of a
- 14:33sudden you have all these people coming forward saying that they were sexually abused as
- 14:39children, and it went from being something that people would think happened one out
- 14:45of a million times. You know, out of a million families, you'd
- 14:48have one family where there would be sexual abuse. Suddenly, when you start
- 14:52looking at the data, you're looking at maybe a fourth. You know,
- 14:56twenty twenty five percent of people have been sexually abused in some way, maybe
- 15:03not by their parents. That's a much smaller percentage. But when you start
- 15:07broadening the category of well as a child, you know, pre twelve,
- 15:15did you experience any kind of coercive sexual event like by a neighbor or a
- 15:22friend or then or you expand it even further out, you know, as
- 15:26a thirteen year old or fifteen year old where you date raped, this sort
- 15:31of you know, and you start seeing these numbers grow, and it was
- 15:35very, very concerning. And so this is right around that time. And
- 15:41so with this quick study they find, oh, my god, most of
- 15:46our patients have been sexually abused. What that's got to be a high rate
- 15:54of sexual abuse, you know, compared to the general population. Now it's
- 16:00not as much of a difference from the general population, but they didn't know
- 16:06that at the time, so they must have been their minds must have just
- 16:10been blown by this. And in addition to childhood sexual abuse, they also
- 16:15found that some of the patients had been sexually assaulted as adults, meaning that
- 16:22they had never been assaulted sexually as a child or teen. But there was
- 16:27one patient who was raped at the age of twenty three and she immediately gained
- 16:33one hundred and five pounds within a year. So they started looking more at
- 16:41the data, the qualitative data, the interview data, and they found that
- 16:48for these individuals who were who have a history of sexual abuse or sexual assault
- 16:56that they would eat to soothe their trauma conditions, which, of course for
- 17:02us, we all understand that, but not everyone understands that out and certainly
- 17:07they didn't really understand it back then. Also, they found that some people
- 17:12consciously and purposely gained weight to avoid being attractive to perpetrators. This is something
- 17:18that was taught to me when I was first becoming a therapist. Then it
- 17:23blew me away when I learned about this, or at least I think I
- 17:29was taught it, or maybe it was a client that told me. I
- 17:32don't know, but when I heard about this, I was like, oh
- 17:34my god, that makes so much sense. You know that, when you
- 17:38are assaulted and there's no societal help and no help in your system, no
- 17:48one is there for you, you're left to your own devices to figure out
- 17:52a way to avoid this happening again. Of course, right, so for
- 17:56some people they'll say, well, well maybe if I gain weight, I
- 18:02will no longer be attractive and therefore perpetrators won't target me anymore. So that
- 18:10is what they found. They also found that men who were physically abused would
- 18:17also gain weight because they wanted to gain weight to appear more intimidating, similar
- 18:23to some people gaining weight to not be attractive. Men being physically abused were
- 18:30like, well, I'm kind of scrawny, so maybe if I just gain
- 18:34weight both by working out and eating a lot, I'll be physically bigger and
- 18:41therefore no one will mess with me, or they'll mess with me less or
- 18:45something. So this led doctor Vincent Filidi in San Diego Kaiser Permanente to start
- 18:56thinking, Okay, we did this preliminary study with this small group of patients
- 19:00at our particular clinic. We need to broaden this out and we need to
- 19:03start making some waves in our industry. And so in the nineteen nineties he
- 19:11has pulled together a team, a coalition between not only him, but also
- 19:18Kidser Permanente as a whole, and also the CDC, And he was joined
- 19:23by Robert Anda from the CDC, and they worked on developing this project called
- 19:30the Adverse Childhood Experience. This study, this is where that aces come from.
- 19:36ACE. So adverse a childho'd see experience a you know, adverse child
- 19:41experiences for some of you. You know that these phrases very well, and
- 19:45a lot of clinics they'll use these terms frequently, I don't tend to use
- 19:51those terms because well, I'll get it to that. So for this study,
- 19:57what they were wanting to do, I think, was this movement to
- 20:06one recognize that childhood abuse is perhaps way more prevalent than it was before.
- 20:12And two that childhood abuse isn't just something that is kind of sad to you,
- 20:18it can actually dramatically affect your development and your adult behavior. And three
- 20:25this movement to be more what we might call holistic as medical professionals, instead
- 20:32of just targeting the disease, they wanted to treat the whole individual and also
- 20:38think about prevention instead of being a reactive field. Not only in medicine but
- 20:44also in mental health, there was a pretty big movement to say, look,
- 20:48we have to start thinking about prevention. And of course, you know,
- 20:52the medical and mental health field have always thought about those things, but
- 20:56it's considered kind of a luxury at times. So when you start looking at
- 21:00the data in terms of money savings, you can save a lot of money.
- 21:06You know, if you're thinking about the bottom line, like what to
- 21:10allocate taxes to, would you rather allocate taxes to paying for you know,
- 21:15like in medicare, Medicaid paying for people to have cancer treatment when they're sixty
- 21:22five that costs X amount of dollars, or would you rather spend ten percent
- 21:29of X by having a program that lowers smoking, for example, and therefore
- 21:37you save a lot of money and you have a much happier group of citizens.
- 21:45You know. But trying to you know, do preventative tax allocation is
- 21:51very, very difficult because people that are against tax allocation and helping human beings
- 22:00will shoot those bills down. Whereas if you go to those same people and
- 22:04you say, look at this person, they have cancer, it's hard for
- 22:07even those people to not pay for that kind of treatment. So anyway,
- 22:15so there's a movement afoot back then. I kind of remember that when I
- 22:18was first coming up in the field, because that was the nineties. So
- 22:22they gotta so this study, the ACES study in San Diego, but it
- 22:27expanded to a lot of participants and it was over seventeen thousand participants. And
- 22:34with these folks, they asked them about all sorts of abuse and neglect.
- 22:40They asked them about physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional abuse, physical neglect,
- 22:44emotional neglect, exposure to domestic violence, household substance abuse, household mental
- 22:51illness, parental separation or divorce, and whether or not they had an incarcerated
- 22:56household member. So what they found was that adverse childhood experiences were indeed associated
- 23:07with poor health outcomes. We all know this now, but this was a
- 23:11very novel finding at the time, and we might not know it now if
- 23:15it weren't for doctor Vincent Felidi and others. They also found, according to
- 23:21study, that adverse childhood experiences were correlated with chronic health problems like heart disease,
- 23:26cancer, chronic lung disease. That's also associated with high risk behaviors like
- 23:33smoking, addiction, risky sexual behaviors, and obesity. They also found that
- 23:40adverse childhood experiences were associated with mental illnesses like depression. Of course, for
- 23:45you and me, this is a big duh that adverse childhood experiences would be
- 23:49associated with mentalness. It's also associated with a shorter lifespan, and it's associated
- 23:56with a lot of tickes. This is just the findings of this very first
- 23:59study. There been many, many more studies after this. What they also
- 24:03found was that when you have more adverse childhood experiences, then you have more
- 24:10health problems which of course makes sense, but it was interesting to see that
- 24:15shown in the data. For example, if you had four or more adverse
- 24:22childhood experiences, meaning that you were abused and you were neglected, your parents
- 24:27were violent with each other, and they divorced, then you had a seven
- 24:34times increase risk of alcoholism, So it's a seven hundred percent increase in the
- 24:41risk of alcoholism. You had a two times or a two hundred percent increase
- 24:48in cancer, you had a four times increase in emphysema, And if you
- 24:52had six or more adverse childhood experiences, then that was associated with a thirty
- 24:59time increased risk of suicide. Thirty times. Of course, for you and
- 25:04me, we understand this, but back then it wasn't quite as known,
- 25:08and particularly not as known in the medical field. So another finding that was
- 25:15shocking and concerning according to this study was that adverse childhood experiences were very,
- 25:22very common. They found that two thirds sixty six percent of the participants among
- 25:30the seventeen thousand plus people in San Diego reported at least one adverse childhood experience.
- 25:37Now, when you consider that parental separation and divorce is one of the
- 25:42categories, because that's not an automatic difficult experience. But according to the data,
- 25:49isn't just that one, right. We all know that a lot of
- 25:52people go through neglect abuse, and the study wasn't looking at general difficulties growing
- 26:00up. It was looking at some pretty severe problems, which I'll get into
- 26:03in a second. The study also found that twenty eight percent of the participants
- 26:10reported having been physically abused as children, and twenty one percent reported having been
- 26:17sexually abused. And there were a lot of very shocking findings at the time,
- 26:22So just think about that, like, twenty one percent of this study
- 26:27had reported being sexually abused as children and twenty eight percent reported having been physically
- 26:34abused. And I'll get into the exact questions later, which bring it to
- 26:41some more specificity. They also found that the childhood experience has often occurred together,
- 26:48meaning that if you had one, then you were very likely to have
- 26:52more than one. So what this shows is that for those individuals who experience
- 27:00it's adverse childhood experiences. One way of thinking about it is that you have
- 27:04two groups of or you have three groups of people. You have a group
- 27:07of people who have not experienced adverse childhood experiences, you have another group who've
- 27:14experienced one child averge childhood experience, and you have another group who've experienced a
- 27:18lot of adverse childhood experiences. Well, the two biggest groups are the groups
- 27:25the group that has had none and the group that has had a lot.
- 27:30The group that has only had one adverse childhood experience was a small group,
- 27:36so if you get one, you kind of get them all. And if
- 27:40when it rains, it pours, kind of a thing. And this of
- 27:44course makes sense when you think about why these kinds of things happen, because
- 27:48they generate from parents, and I would say parental trauma and bad modeling that
- 27:55the parents went through. And so when you have a problem there where the
- 28:00problem tends to generate lots of problems. Right. You know, if as
- 28:04a parent, you have just one problem, and that is is that you
- 28:11physically abuse your children, then that's kind of strange because you would think if
- 28:17you're capable of physically abusing your children, then in all likelihood, there's a
- 28:22lot of other problems going on with you, you know, substance abuse,
- 28:26marital problems, all sorts of stuff. All right, Actually, let's take
- 28:30a break and then after we get back, I'll give the items you know
- 28:34the survey questions that they use all right back from the break. So this
- 28:44is the original Adverse Childhood Experiences test. There are newer tests that I tend
- 28:52to like a little better, but this is the original that was developed in
- 28:56nineteen ninety eight by doctor FLEETI and Onda and others, so or and I'm
- 29:03not sure, Pronessa. There are ten questions and they're designed to be easily
- 29:08understood by a lot of people. So it starts off by basically saying,
- 29:15before your eighteenth birthday, did any of the things happen? And the number
- 29:21one question is did a parent or other adult in the household often or very
- 29:26often swear at you, insult you, put you down, or humiliate you,
- 29:32or act in a way that made you feel afraid that you might be
- 29:34physically hurt. So it's saying, before your eighteenth birthday, did a parent
- 29:41or another adult in the household often or very often? So it delineates that
- 29:45you know that it happened occasionally, but did it happen often or very often
- 29:52that they swore at you, insulted you, put you down, humiliated you,
- 29:56or made you feel that you would be afraid to be physically hurt.
- 30:00Okay, that's number one, and I guess you can follow along for yourself
- 30:03because I'll give the data in a second in terms of like the percentage according
- 30:08to the study in nineteen ninety eight. Okay, number two, So what
- 30:12you want to do is you want to tally how many yeses you have out
- 30:15of ten? And trigger warning. Obviously, if you have these kinds of
- 30:22traumas and you have yet to be treated, and you have yet to develop
- 30:29a way of coping with these triggers or even knowing these triggers, you probably
- 30:33don't even listen to this, to this episode, honestly. So number two
- 30:37is did a parent or other adult in the household often or very often push,
- 30:42grab, slap, or throw something at you, or ever hit you
- 30:47so hard that you had marks or were injured. So again trigger warning,
- 30:52because these questions are very explicit. They had to be right if they're going
- 30:57to actually face this issue, they had to be very explicit when they were
- 31:04asked, very overt, very obvious. You know, they couldn't say did
- 31:10a parent physically abuse you? They can't use that term because we don't know
- 31:14how people would interpret that. So they have to get really behavioral. So
- 31:18did a parent or other adult in the household often or very often. Again,
- 31:22not occasionally, but often or very so that tells you the threshold that
- 31:26we're working with in that you know, earlier I was saying that sixty six
- 31:30percent of people have experienced one of these things. It's not like mild trauma,
- 31:37like your mom abused you, you know, two or three different times
- 31:44throughout your life. You know this, at least on these questions when they're
- 31:48talking about physical abuse, they're saying often or very often. Now, what
- 31:52do we mean by often or very often? But you know, I imagine
- 31:56most people can understand that what they're getting at, push, grab, slap,
- 32:01or throw something at you. So push you, grab you, slap
- 32:06you, or throw something at you, or ever hit you so hard that
- 32:08you had marks or were injured. So they're trying to draw that line between
- 32:14just having been spanked or hit occasionally or hit mildly. You know. Again,
- 32:21other tests will get at any sort of physical harm, but this test
- 32:24was trying to capture those individuals who had been fairly severely abused. Number three,
- 32:32did an adult or person at least five years older than you ever touch
- 32:37or trigger warning? Okay, touch or fondle you, or have you touched
- 32:43their body in a sexual way or attempt or actually have oral, anal or
- 32:49vaginal intercourse with you? Again, very explicit, and it doesn't leave a
- 32:55lot up for interpretation, which is is a good thing. You don't want
- 33:00to beat around the bush. You got to ask people. Now, I
- 33:04worry that the people that would be given this test might be triggered, right,
- 33:09but it's not. It doesn't force people to remember in detail. So
- 33:15hopefully people weren't harmed by these things. But and that does complicate assessment and
- 33:22outreach a lot, right, because you could actually harm people who have PTSD
- 33:27around this anyway. So again, touch or fondle you, or have you
- 33:30touch their body or attempt or actually have anal, oral, or vaginal incourse
- 33:36with you? And that that's a good question to put in their attempt did
- 33:39anyone who was five years older? Now, you know you can be sexually
- 33:45abused by someone your age. You could be sexually abused by someone younger than
- 33:49you. So this delineation of five years, you know, they're probably just
- 33:52trying to figure out how to capture things, or maybe they would word it
- 33:55differently today. I would just ask did you ever feel sexually coerced where you
- 34:05didn't have the ability to say no, and you either had to endure someone
- 34:15trying to do something to you that you were pretty clear you didn't want to
- 34:19do, or at the very least you didn't give any indication of consent or
- 34:23wanting to do it. Did anything like that happen to you? You know,
- 34:25it's it's this is why these kind of surveys are not what I use.
- 34:30You know, I have long conversations with any number four. Did you
- 34:36often or very often feel that no one in your family loved you or thought
- 34:38you were important or special, or your family didn't look out for each other,
- 34:45feel close to each other, or support each other. So this question
- 34:49is a lot broader, in my opinion, depending on how people are interpreting
- 34:52it. But you know this this question, did you did you often or
- 34:59very often? Again, not occasionally, but did you often, very often
- 35:01feel that your family didn't look out for each other, that your family wasn't
- 35:07close to each other, that your family didn't support each other. And imagine
- 35:13you're going to get a pretty wide swath there. But that is a very
- 35:15important aspect of childhood and if you don't experience that often and very often as
- 35:21a child. That is a very very impactful adverse child that experienced Number five,
- 35:29did you often or very often feel that you didn't have enough to eat,
- 35:32had to wear dirty clothes, and had no one to protect you,
- 35:38or your parents were too drunk or high to take care of you or take
- 35:42you to the doctor if you needed it. So this question seems like two
- 35:45questions in one or then diagram questions. But very often if you have a
- 35:52child who doesn't have enough to eat, or has to wear dirty clothes to
- 35:55school, or has no one there to protect them, meaning that the parents
- 36:01are either gone or you know, physically there but mentally gone because of the
- 36:07substances. You know, usually it's because of substance abuse. So that's what
- 36:12that question is getting at. So that's getting at neglect, right. Number
- 36:15six, were your parents ever separated or divorced? So I think this question
- 36:22is indicative of the times. In nineteen eighty divorce rates were on the rise,
- 36:28but they I don't think had peaked yet. I think divorce rates peaked
- 36:32in the nineties. Let me look at that divorce rates by year US.
- 36:38It's let's see here, blah blah, blah. Actually, no, it
- 36:43peaked in the seventies and was on the decline in the eighties. I was
- 36:46wrong about that. It's kind of surprising. Huh, that's interesting. Maybe
- 36:51I'll do that for a tougher bluff at some point, because that would that
- 36:54would have stumped me. That's interesting. Yeah, the narrative, because we
- 37:00can't know exactly why these things happened, but the heavy speculation is that you
- 37:07had a lot of women who were in a very difficult, perhaps abusive relationship,
- 37:15in a heterosexual marriage, and we're wanting to leave, but were prevented
- 37:22by culture, religion, the law, and systems in place to help people.
- 37:29And with those systems in place, because feminists fought hard for those rights
- 37:35and for those awarenesses and for those laws, that you had this huge wave
- 37:42of women who were just waiting for the opportunity to get out. And then
- 37:49you had this huge group of people in the late seventies, and then decreasingly
- 37:54from that point forward, you know a lot of people as well. But
- 37:59anyway, so that question I think is indicative of the time, because I
- 38:07don't think today we would think of separation or divorce in one's parents to be
- 38:13like in the same ballpark as these other things, you know what I mean.
- 38:17But anyway, so number seven question, was your mother or stepmother often
- 38:23or very often pushed, grabbed, slapped, or had something thrown at her?
- 38:30Or sometimes often or very often kicked, bitten, hit with a fist
- 38:34or hit with something hard, or ever repeatedly hit over at least a few
- 38:39minutes, or threatened with a gun or knife. I read that kind of
- 38:43funny, but you know, you get the picture. They're basically asking,
- 38:46becifix about was your mother or stepmother abused by somebody, presumably your dad?
- 38:53Again, in today's world, we wouldn't ask it like that. Some people
- 38:58don't have mother's they have two fathers, for example. Also, we understand
- 39:02that fathers can be abused, So why are you asking specifically about mothers?
- 39:07Like why not just ask was anyone in your family targeted repeatedly with violence by
- 39:16someone else in the family or a former partner or something? Anyway? Number
- 39:22eight did you live with anyone who was a problem drinker or alcoholic or her
- 39:28or her used or who used street drugs? Say that like five times?
- 39:31Or who or who used or who used or who used? Number nine was
- 39:38a household member depressed or mentally ill? Or did a household member attempt suicide?
- 39:45It's a pretty big category there, but good question asked. And the
- 39:49final question, did a household member go to prison? All right, so
- 39:53tally up out of ten, how many s's you have? And the the
- 40:00results of the nineteen ninety eight Filidi study Doctor Vincent FLEETI that well, all
- 40:06of you just take a guess in terms of the distribution curve, how many
- 40:10what percentage of people had zero, what percentage of people had one, what
- 40:15percentage of people had two, what percentage of people had three, and what
- 40:17percentage of people had four or more? So it's one category four or more.
- 40:22Okay, So what percentage do you think had none? Where they would
- 40:30say no to all these and that would be me. I would be one
- 40:35of those people. There's my childhood wasn't even close to being a crossing any
- 40:43of those threat thresholds. So yeah, all right, so what percentage of
- 40:49zero? The answer is thirty six percent. Thirty six percent. I'm guessing
- 40:54that's pretty similar to today, depending on region, because there are regions of
- 40:59the United States right now where there's a lot of economic depression and also and
- 41:06correlated with this a lot of heroin addiction and fentanyl being used by these individuals,
- 41:15and also fair amount of myth as well, of course, because that's
- 41:17always around cocaine blah blah blah. And so you have whole communities where you
- 41:24might not find anybody that has any children who have zero avers childhood experiences anyway,
- 41:31and the cycle goes on and on, right because those children grow up
- 41:35to have kids and have the same kind of issues, because these things are
- 41:38trends generational, and you deny the community help and you fill their heads which
- 41:45with a bunch of QAnon shit and da da da anyway. So zero adverse
- 41:52childhood experiences thirty six percent. So on one hand, you're like, wow,
- 41:57that's that's a lot of people. But that means that sixty four percent
- 42:00of people have had at least one. And then how many of the participants
- 42:07do you think only had one? So that percentage was twenty six percent.
- 42:12Remember earlier I was saying that this is the smallest group because the people who
- 42:17have had zero, that's thirty six percent. The people who have two,
- 42:22who have had two or more is just doing a quick math, is thirty
- 42:27nine percent. So the biggest group in terms of that grouping that I made
- 42:32earlier is the thirty nine percent group, and those are the people who have
- 42:38had two or more. And remember these thresholds were high, right. It
- 42:45wasn't did your parent ever swear at you or ever hit you? It was
- 42:52did your parent often or very often? Yish? So number two or how
- 42:59many people report having two adverse childood experiences, that was sixteen percent, and
- 43:04three was ten percent, and four or more was thirteen percent. All right,
- 43:09well let's take a break and get back. I'll continue talking about this
- 43:13all right, back from their break. So again, remember that I went
- 43:20over earlier. What they found in that study was that adverse childhood experiences are
- 43:27highly associated with poor health health outcomes and poor mental health outcomes, things like
- 43:31heart disease, cancer, lung disease. Also highly correlated with smoking and addiction
- 43:39and obesity, and also with things like depression. But we all know that
- 43:46huge increase if you have a lot of adverse childhood experiences for alcoholism, cancer
- 43:54and physema and suicide. And the idea that they had at the time was
- 44:00that these adverse childhood experiences affected you neurologically, that your nervous system was affected
- 44:09because you were raised in this way. And of course that does happen,
- 44:15maybe particularly if you are lacking nutrition, right, or you are beat you
- 44:21know, you know your parents hit you in the head, right. I
- 44:24would say that it's not that simple for a lot of people, right,
- 44:30that it's a developmental issue. I mean, unless you broaden the development,
- 44:34unless you to include just our personalities as they develop, or scheme is this
- 44:40kind of thing. But that's what they were thinking because they were biologists trying
- 44:45to see the world through a biological lens. And you know, there's not
- 44:50really a difference between psychology and biology, but I hope you get what I'm
- 44:52saying. And the model that they came up with is this pyramid model,
- 45:00and I wish I could show you it. You can look it up.
- 45:01But at the bottom of the pyramid is this foundation, right, And at
- 45:08the top of the pyramid is what they say, early death. So how
- 45:15do we get there? And how how does the early death and medical problems?
- 45:21How does it? What? What? What is the foundation of it?
- 45:24What are the building blocks that get us there? And so the very
- 45:29foundation of the pyramid is generational historical trauma. So this is wonderful that they
- 45:37recognized that they didn't just stop with what happened to you. You know,
- 45:42if they had a patient with a bunch of medical problems or they were dropping
- 45:45out of the obesity clinic, they didn't just say, oh, you were
- 45:50abused as a child. They continue to go back further right, which is
- 45:53that there is in all likelihood a transgenerational issue happening here. So it began
- 46:00even before the patient was born. So that's what it's based on. That's
- 46:07the main foundation. Up from there, you have social conditions what they're calling
- 46:10social conditions or local context, so it's probably neighborhood, that kind of thing.
- 46:16Up from there you have adverse childhood experiences. And then up from there
- 46:22you have disrupted neurodevelopment, which I was talking about earlier, which I would
- 46:27worry differently. Again, it depends on what they mean by that, but
- 46:30from my reading on my personal experience, they're typically thinking purely biologically. For
- 46:37a while, I worked at an addiction center. I was in charge of
- 46:44the mental health wing, and I supervised mental health clinicians and did forensic assessments
- 46:51and also provided treatment. And I worked alongside with the addictions folks, and
- 46:55we had a number of therapists who were also chemical dependency professionals and so,
- 47:04but I wasn't. I was maybe the only one that wasn't. I was
- 47:07the only pure outsider anyway. And at this clinic it was founded or owned
- 47:15or I don't know, I can't remember. It was a while ago.
- 47:19The leader, the main off site leader, was a physician, someone like
- 47:24this, doctor Vincent Felidi, who I think him and his wife had a
- 47:30kid who suffered from addiction, might maybe died from it, I don't know.
- 47:32Don't quote me on that, but I had a lot of conversations with
- 47:37him. I just didn't write any of it down. And as a physician,
- 47:42as a successful physician, he wanted to help. I think what his
- 47:50problem was was that when he looked at the landscape of addiction treatment, he
- 47:55found that there was a lot of problems with success with treatment success you know,
- 48:02efficacy, right, and he wanted to figure out why that was and
- 48:09implement treatment that had greater efficacy. Of course, now from my perspective,
- 48:17I came to this project midstream or maybe even late stream, and I never
- 48:24said this, but I thought, well, you understand that in my field,
- 48:30and in the addictions field, we've been studying addiction for over one hundred
- 48:36years, and we have a lot of data, and there's a lot of
- 48:38different paradigms, and it's complicated. It's not as if we're ignoring it,
- 48:45and it's not as if we haven't looked into it. And it's not it's
- 48:49not as if we're dummies. You know. I've had these kind of conversations
- 48:52before. I had one a while back with a venture capitalist, you know,
- 48:59a tech guy who is always looking to quote unquote disrupt some industry,
- 49:06and he wanted my advice about a way that he was going to disrupt the
- 49:12mental health industry. And I will go into specifics, but as he's talking
- 49:15with me, his perspective was that he was looking at the field of mental
- 49:21health, maybe having interacted with it a bit, or maybe he had a
- 49:24partner or someone that did and it didn't go well, and so he thought,
- 49:29Okay, there's something wrong here, and I'm going to not only figure
- 49:34out the problem, I'm also going to figure out the solution, and I'm
- 49:37going to become a billionaire because my solution is going to save the world.
- 49:42A lot of these tech If you don't live on the West Coast, you
- 49:45might not ever meet these people. They're everywhere in Seattle and in Silicon Valley
- 49:51and at San Francisco and LA They're everywhere, maybe particularly Seattle, I don't
- 49:54know. And God bless him, you know, I wouldn't be talking to
- 49:58you if there weren't some of these guys. And there's a smattering of women
- 50:02too. Mainly guys though, so you know, a lot of our enjoyment
- 50:07in life comes from these folks. Patreon was basically created by someone in that
- 50:12category, right, what's his name, Kanti. I don't think people would
- 50:16stereotype him as one of these guys, but you know, it's kind of
- 50:19in that category anyway. But for Patreon, that did actually meet a need.
- 50:22It filled a service, a hole in our business options. That has
- 50:30been very helpful for a lot of creators, really helpful. Just you know,
- 50:34makes it a much more democratic content provision world right where you don't have
- 50:40to rely on these big corporations like the network TVs and the netflixes and the
- 50:47big newspaper conglomerates to give us information. You can just little all mean sitting
- 50:54at home in front of my computer or in a microphone, I can actually
- 50:58make a living and Patreon is a major factor. I mean, I could
- 51:04argue it's the factor. There are problems with Patreon, of course, but
- 51:07without it. So, you know, the disrupting game I appreciate at times,
- 51:15but there are times when I And so anyway, I'm at this addiction
- 51:19clinic and there's this guy and you know, God bless him, and he
- 51:22wanted to help. And his big thing was that he wanted to find a
- 51:29treatment regimen that might involve a biological angle, right like with heroin addiction,
- 51:35for example, you'll use certain treatments, biological treatments that will help people to
- 51:43refrain from using, or it'll blunt the effect if they happen to use,
- 51:46you know, all the kind of things. So he wanted to create a
- 51:51treatment regimen for addiction that was much more guaranteed to work. And the fact
- 52:00is is that it's not that easy unless you live in a society where you
- 52:06can lock people up and prevent them from using, which none of us want
- 52:13to live in a society like that. Then it's going to be hard.
- 52:16And you could develop a very effective or very well researched and intense, an
- 52:24intense treatment program for addiction and yet only find a minority of clients who actually
- 52:30not only kick the habit, but they sustain abstinence for three to five years
- 52:37after. Because that's kind of the kicker, right, It's like, well,
- 52:39sure and impatient. You can get people to quit, but they don't
- 52:43have access typically, can you get him to quit and stay quit? That
- 52:47that's the key. So he would talk about these biology factors, these biological
- 52:55factors a lot, and I remember just trying to help this guy understand that
- 53:01if you zoom out from biology and you take in all of the data that
- 53:07contributes to behavior and personality and who a person is, then it's impossible for
- 53:15any human or groups of humans to comprehend why someone does something. Now,
- 53:22maybe AI in the future will start to zero in on this because it has
- 53:27the ability to consider lots of factors all at once and evaluate them potentially,
- 53:35but it's hard, you know, and I understand the effort because you know,
- 53:39in medicine, when you reduce the problem to say a gene or a
- 53:46protein or a virus, then you have what you can target, right,
- 53:52you know what to do. You have this disease that is killing a bunch
- 53:58of people and causing a lot of people to get sick in Wuhan, China.
- 54:00Well medicine says, well, what's the problem. It's not some grand
- 54:06scheme of a bunch of a bunch of factors. No, it's in all
- 54:10likelihood it's some sort of some sort of virus, some sort of bacteria.
- 54:15There's some infection, and if we can find that thing, then we can
- 54:20target that thing and we can help people. That's how you know, you
- 54:23want medical people thinking that way. You don't want them always thinking that way,
- 54:27by the way, because there are conditions that cannot be reduced to that.
- 54:31But I think that's where it's coming from anyway. So that's a long
- 54:35time. But so on the triangle, you have this historical trauma at the
- 54:39bottom. Then you have social conditions local context, you know, maybe racism,
- 54:45sexism. Then you have adverse childhood experiences. Then you have disrupted neurodevelopment
- 54:51development above that, then you have social, emotional, and cognitive impairment,
- 54:55meaning that you have a child that is impaired somehow emotionally, socially, or
- 55:00cognitively. And then you have above that adoption of health risk behaviors, meaning
- 55:07that because you have a child with these impairments, they will adopt risky behaviors,
- 55:14addiction, eating too much, committing crimes, I don't know that kind
- 55:22of stuff. And then above that you have disease, disability, and social
- 55:28problems. By the way, I don't know if you can hear my neighbor's
- 55:30dog yelping, I don't know if the microphone's picking up, But if you
- 55:35hear it in the distance, that's what it is. It's not someone dying
- 55:38in the background. I swear I don't have I swear my wife isn't torturing
- 55:44anyone in the room near me. So then you have disease and disability and
- 55:50social problems above that, and then at the very top you have early death.
- 55:52You know, pretty pretty interesting model, and it really emphasizes not only
- 55:57adverse childhood experiences, also sizes local context, and it also emphasizes historical trauma.
- 56:02You know, I think it's good. So let's go over what I
- 56:07think is a better test that a lot of people might use today. And
- 56:14this is a test that's put out by aces Aware. It's an organization in
- 56:20California that promotes the awareness of average childhood experiences. So it's ten items again
- 56:28and again. It asked to people to think about before your eighteenth birthday?
- 56:32Number one, did you feel that you didn't have enough to eat, had
- 56:37to wear dirty clothes, or had no one to protect or take care of
- 56:40you. So right away you can tell that the questions are a little easier
- 56:45to read, but they're very similar, right It was a very similar question
- 56:51on the original test. Number two, did you lose a parent through divorce,
- 56:55abandonment, death, or other reason. This question captures more of the
- 57:02people who have been through difficulty rights, not just divorce, its abandonment,
- 57:07death or another reason. Did you live with anyone who was depressed, mentally
- 57:12ill, or attempted suicide? So that's a similar question to the original Number
- 57:16four, did you live So you can play along here because I'll give you
- 57:22not the percentages, but what should be done. And for you clinicians out
- 57:27there and medical people too, you can think about this as well, and
- 57:30maybe you already do. Hopefully you do, imagine you do. Number four
- 57:36did you live with anyone who had a problem with drinking or using drugs,
- 57:38including prescription drugs? So they include prescription drugs in there. Number five,
- 57:44did your parents or adults in your home ever hit, punch, beat,
- 57:47or threaten to harm each other. So this isn't focused on moms and stepmoms.
- 57:52This is just did your parents or adults in your home, because you
- 57:57could have grandparents or aunts and uncles or whatever, ever hit, punch,
- 58:00beat, or threaten to harm each other? Number six? Did you live
- 58:04with anyone who went to jail or prison? Number seven did a parent or
- 58:08adult in your home ever swear at you, insult you, or put you
- 58:12down? Pretty similar question to the first original test. Number eight did a
- 58:15parent or adult in your home ever hit, beat, kick, or physically
- 58:20hurt you in any way? Nine? Did you feel that no one in
- 58:23your family loved you or thought you were special? Similar to the original number
- 58:29Ten did you experience unwanted sexual contact such as fondling or anal or oral or
- 58:36vaginal intercourse penetration? You know, interhourse or penetration. Okay, So for
- 58:45y'all who might be scoring for yourselves, I don't have the percentage in front
- 58:50of me. I'm guessing there is research around that, but in terms of
- 58:53because this is all being used for treatment, right, and it's specifically being
- 59:00used to help medical professionals know what they should be focusing on, and it
- 59:07alerts medical professionals to patients that might benefit from additional treatment options besides just the
- 59:15typical medical treatments. Going back to doctor Vincent Felidi, who is very successful
- 59:22in helping people to lose weight, and yet fifty percent of those people who
- 59:30are losing weight successfully drop out. This test is trying to capture those folks
- 59:37and shore up those issues such and address those issues such that not only do
- 59:45you not have people dropping out of various different treatment programs, but also you
- 59:51don't have people who you might have helped them with their disease, but you
- 59:55haven't actually helped them helped them, you know. So the scale is that
- 1:00:04if you have a score of zero, you're considered low risk, low risk
- 1:00:07of your adverse childhood experiences affecting health outcomes. So it's all about health outcomes.
- 1:00:16So there's low and intermediate and high risk. For intermediate risk, they
- 1:00:22say if you have a score of one to three, but you don't have
- 1:00:28any of the associated health concerns currently. So if you have one to three
- 1:00:34adverse childhood experiences according to this test by aces AWARE, and you don't yet
- 1:00:39have any of the associated health concerns, then you're considered immediate intermediate risk intermediate
- 1:00:45risk, and for people in this category, you want to provide preventative education
- 1:00:52regarding how adverse childhood experiences might be affecting them and how to avoid the behaviors.
- 1:00:59Because going back to that pyramid, according to this model, anyway,
- 1:01:04you have the adverse childhood experiences lower on the pyramid, and then up from
- 1:01:07there you have health risk behavior, and then up from there you have disease,
- 1:01:13and then up from there you have early death. So you could have
- 1:01:16average childhood experiences and you could have disrupted neurodevelopment, you could have impairment,
- 1:01:23but if you haven't actually developed risky health behaviors, then it'll interrupt the early
- 1:01:32death process. Right. But for these people, they are at high risk
- 1:01:37of developing those risky health behaviors, and thus you need to provide preventive education.
- 1:01:44But you don't have to hit it hard because there seems to be something
- 1:01:47going on with this person that's preventing that from happening. And then you have
- 1:01:52high risk folks, and these are people who have a score of one or
- 1:01:57more and they have health concerns, or they have a score of four or
- 1:02:01more without health concerns. So what you're seeing here is that. Look,
- 1:02:08even if you only have one average childhood experience and you have already developed some
- 1:02:15of the health concerns. Now, maybe the other health concerns are unrelated to
- 1:02:19the advers childhood experiences, but maybe they are, and the treatment and your
- 1:02:24compliance with the treatment or you're paying attention to your health might be affected by
- 1:02:29your advers childhood experiences. So you are considered high risk. You already have
- 1:02:34this problem, that the health problem, You already have the negative outcome and
- 1:02:40adverage childhood experiences, even if it's just one. We have to be very
- 1:02:45careful about how we treat this person. We have to go on high alert
- 1:02:49regarding advers childhood experiences. We can't just treat them for the issue that they
- 1:02:53have. We have to be very And what they say is you have to
- 1:02:57provide education about how chronic stress affects their health. So not just preventative education,
- 1:03:02which you want to do as well, but you also have to say,
- 1:03:06right now, your health in all likelihood has already been affected by the
- 1:03:14neurodevelopment and the behaviors that emerge out of your child at verage childhood experiences.
- 1:03:21Also, if you don't have any health concerns currently but you have four or
- 1:03:25more at verge childhood experiences, then what these folks are saying is your risk
- 1:03:31is so high for developing because remember going back to the original study that if
- 1:03:37you had four or more adverge childhood experiences, you are at a seven times
- 1:03:44increased risk of developing alcoholism, seven hundred percent increased risks. You have double
- 1:03:51the risk of cancer, and you have four times the risk of emphysema.
- 1:03:55And that's just those three issues, right, There's all sorts of other issues,
- 1:04:00medical issues that can occur. And you know, think about all that
- 1:04:04we have done as a society regarding cigarettes and how successful we have been at
- 1:04:13reducing the rate of cigarette use, and how many people's lives have been saved,
- 1:04:19how many parents have lived longer, how many grandparents have lived longer because
- 1:04:25they didn't develop cancer or emphysema, because we have poured billions I don't know
- 1:04:30how many dollars, but a lot of money and a lot of effort into
- 1:04:34raising awareness about cigarettes. As a former you know, two pack a day
- 1:04:41smoker myself, I can tell you those advertisements worked on me. Like I
- 1:04:47mean, it wasn't like I didn't want to quit. I did but in
- 1:04:51the nineties, I remember there was this billboard ad in Seattle that just reminded
- 1:04:58me all the time that cigarettes cause your lungs to erode from the I can't
- 1:05:05remember what the ad was. It was very explicit, you know, it's
- 1:05:10like cigarettes kill you or something, and it had some picture, and of
- 1:05:15course I knew all this stuff. But every reminder kind of helps, you
- 1:05:19know, And that's why we spend our tax dollars on this. That's why
- 1:05:25we have public health, because it helps. It works. We see the
- 1:05:30outcomes. Billboard ads don't have a huge effect, but a little bit of
- 1:05:34an effect. And if it prompts someone to look up something on the internet
- 1:05:40and then boom, that starts a road blah blah blah, you have not
- 1:05:44only them quitting smoking, but over time, you've drastically reduced their risk of
- 1:05:49cancer. You've drastically reduced If we're thinking in terms of politics and trying to
- 1:05:55pass these bills and these budgets, you're drastically reducing that individuals, you know,
- 1:06:01future need for tax dollars to pay for treatment or to pay for their
- 1:06:06food, because if they develop medical promts, they might not be able to
- 1:06:11work anymore. And it's stupid to think this way. I think we should
- 1:06:15just be thinking in terms of morality. But if you need to think that
- 1:06:19way anyway. So, if you have for or more adverse childhood experiences,
- 1:06:26even if you have yet to develop any health concerns, you are considered high
- 1:06:30risk for obvious reasons. And for these folks, you want to provide education
- 1:06:34about how their current stress will affect their health in all likelihood, right,
- 1:06:41So you have to have education, and I'm guessing that also involves a lot
- 1:06:45of skills training and a lot of awareness and options regarding other kinds of treatments
- 1:06:49like therapy or groups, or other kinds of websites or forums or classes.
- 1:06:57You know, it involves a lot of kind of things. So that's the
- 1:07:00aces aware test, the average childhood Experiences test that aces aware puts out.
- 1:07:06And getting back to annual patron and YouTube members question, you asked, is
- 1:07:13there a link between childhood sexual abuse and gaining weight? And also is there
- 1:07:19a link between childhood sexual abuse and not wanting to lose weight? The answer
- 1:07:26is a resounding yes, there's a clear connection and there have been thousands of
- 1:07:32studies, hundreds at least hundreds of studies, maybe thousands of studies replicating and
- 1:07:38refining these data, done in different countries, different regions, with different sorts
- 1:07:45of people, and for each person it's different, right, And what doctor
- 1:07:49Feleety found in the eighties is still what I would say, right to explore
- 1:07:58with your therapist is is there something related to soothing traumas? Right? And
- 1:08:05therefore, if you treat your traumas effectively, you won't need to soothe it.
- 1:08:11Right because for people who are suffering from ongoing trauma conditions like PTSD or
- 1:08:18personal disorder or complex PTSD or dissociation or eating disorders, for example, but
- 1:08:26aside from eating disorders, meaning that it'll be clear why I'm excluding that for
- 1:08:30now is there's a lot of suffering. There's a lot of pain, there's
- 1:08:36a lot of anxiety. And even if you're in a path, even if
- 1:08:43you're on a path of recovery, like you have a good therapist, you
- 1:08:45have a good team, there's still a lot of pain and there's still a
- 1:08:49lot of suffering, and of course we are going to look for ways to
- 1:08:55soothe those feelings. And there's only a a small set of things available to
- 1:09:01us. Even if you had someone who knew about all of them, which
- 1:09:04most people don't. There's not a lot that works, and certainly nothing works
- 1:09:10permanently, right, You have to do the work. It takes a long
- 1:09:14time, and even then it might not ever go away fully. Of course.
- 1:09:19So you have people who are just sitting there suffering, and the things
- 1:09:25available to them are substance abuse, drug abuse, drinking, drugging. You
- 1:09:30have you know, porn addiction, you have compulsive gambling, you have compulsive
- 1:09:36spending, you have compulsive eating, you have compulsive exercising. You know,
- 1:09:43there's there's those folks. You have binging and pursing, you have cutting,
- 1:09:48you have working too much, there's a there's a there's a few other things,
- 1:09:56right in terms of large categories. And for or someone to turn to
- 1:10:00food, let me give you an example. It's not the same, but
- 1:10:05it's analogous. When I was trying to quit smoking, I really hit it
- 1:10:12hard for three years. And I'm a therapist by this point and I treat
- 1:10:15addiction. And it took me three years. And if you would have asked
- 1:10:21me at year two and a half if I was going to succeed, I
- 1:10:27would have I would have put money down on me, not succeeding even though
- 1:10:31I was trying very very hard, and I did a lot of things.
- 1:10:38And what I learned about halfway through was to quit smoking, maybe to quit
- 1:10:44anything. It's a matter of balancing how many sacrifices do I have to make?
- 1:10:54But I don't want to make too many sacrifices because then I'll suffer needlessly.
- 1:11:00And like when I first tried to quit smoking, just as an example,
- 1:11:05the sacrifice quote unquote that I made was that I was just going to
- 1:11:09grin and I was just gonna grin and Barrett, I was just gonna white
- 1:11:11knuckle it. Of course, that almost never works, but that is kind
- 1:11:14of a sacrifice, right I'm going to take the cigarettes I currently have,
- 1:11:17I'm gonna throw them away and I'm going to not buy cigarettes. That is
- 1:11:23in my model that I'm using right now as a sacrifice. Right. Well,
- 1:11:28eventually, what I found was I have to make dozens of sacrifices,
- 1:11:32like I have to not only do that, but I have to tell everyone
- 1:11:36around me that I'm no longer a smoker, and don't let me smoke,
- 1:11:41or don't give me a smoke, or if I'm smoking, like tell me
- 1:11:45stop it or something I had. I'm not everyone shouldn't do that, by
- 1:11:49the way, because you don't want shaming. It actually hurts your recovery usually,
- 1:11:54and I did. I had actually a group of people around me who
- 1:11:58were super cool about the whole thing. None of them smoked, so it
- 1:12:00wasn't like that, but they meaning that if there were smokers around me,
- 1:12:05they'd be well anyway. My point is is that my support system neither shamed
- 1:12:12me nor really where it was on my back about staying sober. You know,
- 1:12:17they just sort of let me do my thing anyway, and that really
- 1:12:21helped because it was a very ego shredding experience to fail and fail and fail
- 1:12:28and to announce and then fail announce and fail, and for people around me
- 1:12:32to just be like, yeah, you know whatever, well, you know,
- 1:12:34we still love you, and you're on your path, do your thing.
- 1:12:39That that was perhaps the single most important factor in me quitting, because
- 1:12:44if I had even a little bit of shaming or disapproval or judgment, I
- 1:12:53think I would have gone into a tailspin and just said, fuck it,
- 1:12:57I'm just going to continue using. So there's that. But eventually what I
- 1:13:00found was that one of the sacrifices that I had to make apparently, was
- 1:13:05that I was going to eat whatever I wanted to because it distracted me.
- 1:13:12And one of the things that I did, I would come home. I'm
- 1:13:16a therapist, right, and I did a lot of different work than I
- 1:13:20was a professor. I was an agency therapist, and I was in private
- 1:13:28practice and I had an office, but I also did in home therapy.
- 1:13:30So I was working seventy hours a week. I was trying to pay off
- 1:13:33my student loans, and I was working, you know, from morning until
- 1:13:39sometimes midnight. I would have clients. I would schedule clients at ten thirty
- 1:13:43at night because I'd say, well, I have one spot, maybe a
- 1:13:50Wednesday at ten thirty. And some people will be like, well, if
- 1:13:55that's your only spot, then yeah, okay, And I'm like, oh,
- 1:13:58well it's money so and I'm a night owl, so let's go for
- 1:14:00it. So I'd come home late and I would sit in front of my
- 1:14:08shitty thirteen inch television, you know, cathode ray tube television and with Bunny
- 1:14:16ears with an antenna no cable, couldn't afford it. And I would sit
- 1:14:23in front of the shitty TV on the floor by the way, and I
- 1:14:28would eat a giant bag of Gurrido's every day. I love my chips.
- 1:14:38I can't if I were on my deathbed and someone said, what, well
- 1:14:44it come down it well nachos. You know, I'll go to Mexican restaurants
- 1:14:48and that's what I'll order for my meal is a plate of nachos. So
- 1:14:57I would eat an entire bag of Dorito's. Is that healthy? No?
- 1:15:02Is that what I wanted to do? No? But that was one of
- 1:15:09forty different things that I did that I would hope I wouldn't do forever.
- 1:15:15Like another thing I did is I couldn't go out anymore because it would just
- 1:15:17trigger this urge to smoke. So I no longer went out right, I
- 1:15:23didn't hang out with people like Bob and all them, and so I didn't
- 1:15:28want to do that forever. But it was a temporary thing and it helped
- 1:15:32me. I actually attribute, along with the thirty nine other things, me
- 1:15:39being able to eventually quit after three years. In this summer, I remember
- 1:15:43it was August two thousand and I remember having my last cigarette and thinking,
- 1:15:51well, I went on this friend trip. We would always go to Lane,
- 1:15:57and I think there were still smokers in the group back then, and
- 1:16:01I was like, it's going to be so hard for me not to smoke.
- 1:16:05Okay, fine, I'll smoke. But I said, okay, after
- 1:16:09this Shellan trip, I'm gonna I'm gonna quit smoking. It'll be over.
- 1:16:13That'll be my last hurrah. And of course in the in addictions, they
- 1:16:17say you shouldn't be doing that because you'll always have another last hurrah. But
- 1:16:23I had this last hurrah, and because there's it's a very important trip to
- 1:16:27me and my friends, blah blah anyway, and because at that point we'd
- 1:16:31been doing it since like eighty six or something, so it was it's like
- 1:16:38this really important bonding thing that we do every Anyway, we stopped doing it
- 1:16:43years and years ago, but I quit and and I thought, well,
- 1:16:48there's a pretty good chance that I'm going to start up again. And I
- 1:16:54added a few more of these sacrifices, you know, the chips and a
- 1:16:57couple other things, and the sobriety lasted a little longer than it did before.
- 1:17:02And then it lasted a little bit longer. It was hard, like
- 1:17:04there was a lot of you know, agitation and urge, but I had
- 1:17:11I had put a system in place, so effective with these forty things that
- 1:17:15it made it a lot easier for me to refrain, you know, And
- 1:17:18after six months it was easier, and after twelve months it was really easy.
- 1:17:25I continue to have dreams about smoking. I've talked about that before.
- 1:17:30I still do sometimes, but I don't know. Maybe those dreams have ended
- 1:17:34in the past year anyway. So my point is is that for you annual
- 1:17:40patron and YouTube member, for people who are who have yet to recover from
- 1:17:47trauma, and I'm not saying this is true for everyone, of course,
- 1:17:51but if I had a client, and I've had clients that have been in
- 1:17:55situations like this, if I had a client who came to me and we
- 1:17:58looked at them holistically and we said, so many things stem from the trauma
- 1:18:04that we need to prioritize that over a lot of other things. And while
- 1:18:12we're on this path of recovering from trauma, and you, childhood sexual abuse
- 1:18:15for a lot of people is no joke regarding the recovery. It's a thing,
- 1:18:21and there's a lot of distress that is necessary as you go through a
- 1:18:27maaginal exposure. And for these folks, there are sacrifices that have to be
- 1:18:34made to help people to cross the finish line, so to speak. There's
- 1:18:40no finish line, but I mean there kind of is. Like I guess
- 1:18:43you could argue whatever condition you're trying to treat, like if it's PTSD,
- 1:18:48for example, then once they're sub threshold of being diagnosable, then you've crossed
- 1:18:57some sort of threshold, right, And so for these folks there are sacrifices
- 1:19:03like for example, one that I always will recommend that clients engage in is
- 1:19:10that they tell people they take an inventory. And sometimes we'll do this in
- 1:19:15session of who who you know, of the people in my life that depend
- 1:19:20on me, like my spouse, maybe my kids, maybe there's a few
- 1:19:26friends that kind of depend on me, maybe there's someone at work. I
- 1:19:30and as I go through this trauma recovery, I have to, you know,
- 1:19:35the client, I have to make sacrifices by telling them I'm not sure
- 1:19:44if I'm going to be dependable as I go through this period. And so
- 1:19:47I'll have the clients think about this and go to these people. I even
- 1:19:51say this to first quarter students at the university because a lot of therapy students
- 1:19:57are helpful to people around them and are depended on right. But graduate school
- 1:20:01is no joke, and so I will I mean, it's perhaps easier to
- 1:20:05go through than trauma recovery, depending on how you look at it. But
- 1:20:10I'll tell people that that you know, you know, you are normally a
- 1:20:14person that people come to for help, to vent with, and there's a
- 1:20:20good chance that as you go through graduate school or as you go through trauma
- 1:20:24recovery, it's funny that those things are similar that you are not. It's
- 1:20:30not possible. It'll interfere with your treatment if you continue to try to help
- 1:20:36others, because it will make you not have the capacity to take care of
- 1:20:42yourself. You're going to be so raw all the time as you go through
- 1:20:46recovery. That's it's not feasible that you're going to have the capacity to take
- 1:20:54care of other people. Plus you're going to be going through a lot of
- 1:20:58struggle and they need to be taking care of you, and so you have
- 1:21:01to start telling everybody. So that's one of those sacrifices. But another sacrifice
- 1:21:05that I would imagine if a client identified it, they said, one of
- 1:21:11the only ways that I cope is by eating. And we might talk specifically
- 1:21:15about it, like Okay, well, how would you like to incorporate that?
- 1:21:18What's the healthiest version of that? Right? There's versions where you just
- 1:21:23like binge an entire weekend because you know, I would treat people with eating
- 1:21:28disorders? Who would do that? Or is there a version where you're more
- 1:21:31intentional about it, where maybe you create a whole ritual where you select a
- 1:21:39recipe and then you go to the store and you try to think along the
- 1:21:43way to make it healthy for you. But you know, if it's kind
- 1:21:45of something that is a cheat day or something maybe a splurge a little bit
- 1:21:49and you drive, you sort of make it a part of the system that
- 1:21:55you have to drive to the store and then you have to get the ingredients
- 1:21:59and then you check in with yourself and that, you know, make sure
- 1:22:02that this is really what you want to do and you're not you know,
- 1:22:04because now if a person has an eating disorder, then it's a whole other
- 1:22:09topic. Because for people with eating disorders, this whole area has a lot
- 1:22:15of complication to it, including you know, pre awareness, pre insight.
- 1:22:20For the client, they might not be a good ally for me because they
- 1:22:27might try to protect their habit of the eating disorder. And so I have
- 1:22:32to assess for all that. But you know, so if we're not talking
- 1:22:36about someone that has that susceptibility or history, then you know we might make
- 1:22:40it intentional. And so for me, for example, when I was quitting
- 1:22:45smoking, if I had a therapist that I'm sure I did at the time,
- 1:22:48I'm sure I must have talked about this at the time. And so
- 1:22:53if I said, well, I think part of the pathway to quitting smoking
- 1:22:59is me eating an entire bag of Dorito's late at night before I go to
- 1:23:04bed while I watch Deep Space nine on my television. That gets terrible reception.
- 1:23:14That sort of zoning out at a time when I would be normally smoking,
- 1:23:20I think is helping me. And I'm gaining weight, and it's not
- 1:23:24good for me to do that health wise, but I think for the time
- 1:23:27being, I think it might help. If I had a therapist that said,
- 1:23:31no, you can't do that, that's not healthy, I might still
- 1:23:36be smoking. So sometimes you have to get kind of real with this stuff.
- 1:23:41It's similar to when people want to quit drinking, they start drinking a
- 1:23:44lot of coffee or maybe smoking right, and for some folks they'll say,
- 1:23:48well, you're just transferring your addiction around. But for other people it's a
- 1:23:54transition, and quitting drinking is so hard that having another substance, maybe addictive
- 1:24:02substance, but far less destructive, is helpful. And we can debate that
- 1:24:10whole thing. It's individual, and that's you know, getting back to that
- 1:24:13notion of that physician who was in charge of this agency that I worked at.
- 1:24:19I don't know if you heard me just sort of slap my arm.
- 1:24:21Sometimes I wonder if I make a noise, people like, what was that
- 1:24:24noise? Getting back to him? The pathway to sobriety and recovery from addiction
- 1:24:32is so particular, right, No one in their right mind would say,
- 1:24:39in order to help Kirk to quit smoking in nineteen ninety nine, we have
- 1:24:45a module on how he should eat doritos as a distraction. No one has
- 1:24:49that. Now there's probably some greater module on distractions, but I don't think
- 1:24:54they would ever recommend that people overeat something that is terrible for them. You
- 1:25:00know, it's particular. Now, I'm not saying that all things are on
- 1:25:05the table, like in order to quit drinking, you can use heroin or
- 1:25:09something, and I'm not saying that, but it's complicated, you know,
- 1:25:13it gets complicated. So for people who are going through trauma recovery, it's
- 1:25:17a conversation, is the point. And it's important to have those conversations because
- 1:25:26once you can actually get people to recover from trauma and have far less symptoms
- 1:25:31of depression and anxiety and terror and distress and triggering, then it's so much
- 1:25:36easier to address everything else, including some bad habits that you might have acquired
- 1:25:43along the way. Like for me, I didn't eat a bag of Doritos
- 1:25:46every night for the rest of my life. I only did it for a
- 1:25:50certain amount of time, and then once I felt that I could not do
- 1:25:58that and still not smoked that night, I stopped doing that. And then
- 1:26:03later on I started going out again and hanging out with friends and maybe having
- 1:26:10a beer and maybe being around people who are smoking. You know, I
- 1:26:14would slowly introduce and get rid of those sacrifices, right, And when it
- 1:26:20comes to this sort of thing, I think that it's just part of the
- 1:26:24holistic treatment process, because often trauma recovery is by far the most important thing
- 1:26:32that we can do to help someone, and everything else might fall into place
- 1:26:36after that. All the other problems might just fade away after that. If
- 1:26:44it's their chronic I don't know their workaholism, or their marital problems or their
- 1:26:51sexual problems or whatever. You know, there's as with this study that was
- 1:26:58finding that in the beginning you had adverse childhood experiences like abuse and neglect.
- 1:27:04Addressing all the random symptoms of that isn't going to solve the problem anyway.
- 1:27:12So does that answer your question? Annual patron and YouTube member, I didn't
- 1:27:17intend on talking this long about it, but it's funny. As I was
- 1:27:20reading our email at the beginning of this, I was planning on answering a
- 1:27:24lot of emails, because you know, this whole thing is based on me
- 1:27:27trying to clean the slate, and I have maybe thousands of emails to get
- 1:27:31to, so getting to one email in one episode is not a good pace.
- 1:27:36But as I'm reading your question, I'm thinking, oh my god,
- 1:27:41two days ago, I just did this huge, random deep dive for no
- 1:27:45reason on doctor Vincent Felidi and the asis test, and it's and it's cause
- 1:27:53a link to gaining weight and its causal link to difficulty with treatment. So
- 1:28:00let's get to that. You're saying that you each time, So you're trying
- 1:28:08to talk about it in therapy, but each time you try to talk about
- 1:28:10your therapist, you become annoyed and you will shut it down. Well,
- 1:28:14you know, of course, explore that with your therapist, but there could
- 1:28:17be a lot of options there. It could be that your solution to being
- 1:28:26abused was to gain weight, right, not only as a soothing mechanism,
- 1:28:30but because you're suffering from trauma constantly, but also because you don't want to
- 1:28:35be targeted again and you believe and also I should say that gaining weight does
- 1:28:43not mean that you won't be targeted. That is a myth completely people.
- 1:28:49There's a lot of well that's all say is that gaining weight does not mean
- 1:28:55you will not be targeted. That notion is very silly. Not that it's
- 1:28:59silly to have that notion, but society kind of has that notion. Like
- 1:29:04Donald Trump even said something like this, like who would want to rape her?
- 1:29:09Did he say this something? Anyway, people will say something like that,
- 1:29:13and that is silly. So with your therapist, you're saying that you
- 1:29:17will become annoyed and you will shut it down. So it could be that
- 1:29:21as yourself you're like, h I want to talk about this with therapy,
- 1:29:25and you start going down that road also as yourself, another part of yourself,
- 1:29:30you're like, well, wha, wha, wha, wha, whoa,
- 1:29:30hold on, hold on, we need this, don't get rid of
- 1:29:33this, don't stop that, because we need this, We need this to
- 1:29:38be in place, otherwise bad things will happen. Right, So it could
- 1:29:43be something like that, it could be something else, who knows, But
- 1:29:45I really encouraged by your email because it shows that you're in therapy, you're
- 1:29:50working on it, you're mulling it over, you're thinking about it, you're
- 1:29:54asking questions, and this is the path, this is the way. And
- 1:29:59everyone out there please take care of yourself because you deserve it, you really really do