Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 143: Are Parisians still drinking? Wine talk with Alicia Dorey
Transcript
- 0:05You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:08I'm your host, Lindsay Trermuda. How was everyone's January?
- 0:13Did you make it a dry one? Like many people living in
- 0:17France, I took a break from alcohol during the imported
- 0:19milestone of Dry January, which they pronounce Dry January, as I
- 0:24heard earlier today. But now we're in February, and
- 0:27two wine fairs have brought wine lovers and wine pros to the city
- 0:30for talks, tastings and buying. Wine consumption, though, has
- 0:34been dropping steadily in France, and sales have declined
- 0:37since the 1970s. But if I were to judge for my
- 0:40interactions with readers, fellow Parisians and clients who
- 0:43take my tour, wine is still very much front of mine when they
- 0:46visit and go out in Paris. So what's happening here?
- 0:51How are people drinking? Are they drinking?
- 0:54What's the deal with natural wine today?
- 0:56And where should people go to drink well in Paris if they're
- 0:59going to do so? I wanted to get a sense from
- 1:02someone whose career has been built around reporting the
- 1:05insurance and outs of wine and our relationship to it.
- 1:08Alicia Dore is a wine journalist who writes regularly for the
- 1:11Figaro and the author of a book that offers a personal and
- 1:14philosophical look at, of all things, intoxication.
- 1:19Let's get into it, Alicia. Welcome to the show.
- 1:23Thank you. You've been on the road quite a
- 1:25bit. Yeah.
- 1:27So I'm I'm lucky to have you here in Paris for.
- 1:29Like. 30 minutes. Always in between the two two
- 1:33destinations. Kind of a nice life.
- 1:36Yeah, it is. But you're always looking for a
- 1:38new story and, and obviously we are in the country of wine, so
- 1:42there's a lot that you can do here without even leaving.
- 1:45Yeah. Yeah, For a very long time
- 1:48actually, when I was working at Le Figaro, I was mainly going to
- 1:52France, like to every region. And then know that I'm freelance
- 1:57again, I, I travel way more because I think that even if
- 2:01French people are very focused on French wines, there are like
- 2:05so many places to discover and, but we don't find the wines
- 2:09here, so. No, you know, I was just at all,
- 2:13all the month of February, there's an Austrian wine pop up.
- 2:16Yeah, I saw that. Yeah.
- 2:17And and it's, I had no idea that less than 1% of Austrian wines
- 2:23are exported to France. And you know, maybe it's those
- 2:26that relationship between France and Austro.
- 2:30Yeah, I, I think it's kind of the same with the German wines
- 2:34because there is a huge trend. I was in the United States like
- 2:38a few weeks ago and I saw that so many, so many different
- 2:42German wines and wrestling and like, they are so good.
- 2:46And in France you cannot like find them.
- 2:48I don't know if it's like some kind of political like.
- 2:52Wouldn't be surprising, right? No, no, no.
- 2:54The French do everything best. No.
- 2:56Yeah. No, yeah, they consider that
- 2:58like today, they consider that Italians are like making good
- 3:03wines, but it's the only like only the beginning.
- 3:06It's weird. And it's taking a long time to
- 3:08get to that point. So I mean, you mentioned that
- 3:12you used to be on staff at the Figueroa, but you still do a lot
- 3:15of writing for them and other publications.
- 3:18And you are specialized in wine, but you do other stories.
- 3:21I'm assuming you got into this line of work because you are
- 3:24passionate about wine. Was there a moment you can
- 3:28recall that kind of confirmed for you that there was a career
- 3:31to be made as a as a wine journalist?
- 3:35Yeah, like I I discovered one quite late, at the age of 26.
- 3:39And so that was 10 years ago. And before that, I wasn't
- 3:44interested in alcohol. I was the one bringing cider
- 3:47bodies. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 3:48Really. And I used to write about
- 3:51cultural travel and a bit about gastronomy.
- 3:54And then I met, well, my ex-boyfriend and he was
- 3:58passionate about wine. And the first time he cooked for
- 4:02me, he made me taste Saint Joseph from the Mandala Rebo.
- 4:08And it was like revelation. I didn't, I didn't know that
- 4:12wine could be like so intense, so vibrant.
- 4:15And so, and I thought to myself, I want to, I want this to be my
- 4:20job. And I started getting to wine
- 4:23and I learned by drinking mainly and by going to like see
- 4:27visiting wine makers. And I have no formal like
- 4:30training in so many studies or analogy.
- 4:33And but I discovered like a very rich world.
- 4:37And when I was 33, I was working as a freelance for Le Figaro
- 4:43Voyage, and one day a position for editor in chief of the wine
- 4:48department opened and I applied and I got the job.
- 4:52So, but that was like, I don't know how to say Vertigenu.
- 4:57Right. It's like one thing led to
- 4:59another. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 5:00And, and I quickly realized that I had to like, get a better
- 5:06knowledge of Bordeaux and champagne because I, I wouldn't,
- 5:11Yeah, I didn't. I had like, like bokudo lacun.
- 5:15I don't know. Some gaps.
- 5:17Yeah, yeah, some gaps and and then I discovered that it was a
- 5:23very like predominantly male and quite traditional field and that
- 5:29the way one was discussed in newspaper was far too
- 5:32intimidating. So I thought to myself that
- 5:36there's a place to carve out as a young self-taught woman.
- 5:39And then since I didn't grow up in a family, like focused on
- 5:43wine, I had no preconceived notions.
- 5:46Like I was not like Burgundy team or, you know, or Bordeaux
- 5:50team. And I approached wine through
- 5:53storytelling. And I don't know, my writing was
- 5:56more literary, So, and I had a certain like, innocence.
- 6:00And I think that was what resonated with people.
- 6:04And so that led to covering the entire section for a number of
- 6:09years. And then you went freelance to
- 6:11be able to do other types of stories as well.
- 6:14And I think there's been a big shift pre COVID, during COVID.
- 6:19And then now sort of whatever this period is, if it's really
- 6:22post COVID or whatever. But we just finished Dry
- 6:24January, which is something that really has sort of taken off in
- 6:27France in the last handful of years.
- 6:30And it didn't begin here, but it has certainly found an audience
- 6:34here. And wine consumption in much of
- 6:37the West seems to be declining, and French wine exports are
- 6:40declining. So in your reporting, what are
- 6:43you discovering about what's at play here?
- 6:46Like, why is this happening? And is it a symptom of sort of
- 6:48this like moral panic that we're all consuming something that's
- 6:51poisoning us, or like as if that's new?
- 6:55Yeah, I like, I understand the need to question the
- 6:58relationship with we have with alcohol, but I can see it's
- 7:02somehow like hypocritical. And either alcohol is dangerous
- 7:08and should be banned just like like other drugs, or we consider
- 7:13that there's I, I think I consider that there's no need to
- 7:17infantilize citizens and instead, like trust them to
- 7:21manage their conception as long as they are not like a danger to
- 7:25others. And I think there is some kind
- 7:28of paternalistic norm that must be clearly distinguished from
- 7:32excessive conceptions. And there's no need to regulate
- 7:36people's habit to the point of telling them you are going to
- 7:39stop playing with this. You know what I mean?
- 7:41And I I think this is the influence of commercial trends
- 7:47originating from the Anglo-Saxon world, just like Halloween and
- 7:51Valentine's Day and Black, Black Friday for.
- 7:54Instance the worst. So you you mean Dry January is
- 7:57like coming from the Anglo world?
- 8:00Yeah, yeah, really and. Must be the Puritanism.
- 8:05Yeah, in some way. And it's quite hypocritical
- 8:07because you know that like United States is a country of
- 8:10excess and in the, in England you have like hooliganism.
- 8:14So like it's on one way. They, you know, so I, I think
- 8:19this is very, it's very weird. I I, I don't think it's related
- 8:24to our Latin culture. I think in Spain, in Italy, in
- 8:28France, we have this like other kind of way of drinking.
- 8:34So do you think that DRY January works because it's just a moment
- 8:37for people to question their behaviors?
- 8:40Yeah, I think we people are driven with like fear and it's
- 8:45this kind of a nudge kind of strategy.
- 8:48And I, I, I'm not telling that it's some kind of plot, you
- 8:53know, but I, I just think that for commercial reasons, the
- 8:58industry is trying to like, make people like being afraid of
- 9:03dying of, or, or losing control. And when they're ready and
- 9:07they're very afraid, they're going to sell them like non
- 9:11alcoholic beverages, just like, you know, sodas.
- 9:14But they are like sugar bombs, so.
- 9:16Yeah, you did a story about that recently, right, right.
- 9:19How your your these alternatives are not necessarily healthier
- 9:22for you in it. I mean, it's maybe not
- 9:25comparable, but they're they're, they're still unhealthy in a
- 9:27different way. In a different way, yeah.
- 9:29And. And people tend to even
- 9:31kombucha, I mean, like we held it like a like a wonderful and
- 9:36it is wonderful, but it's full of sugar, most of them.
- 9:40And we know that sodas are not like very good for your health,
- 9:43so. No.
- 9:45Interesting. So you don't think this is
- 9:46necessarily a lasting phenomenon here?
- 9:50I think the new generation is going to drink less and less.
- 9:54But The thing is that I think it's also related to the way we
- 10:01show the like, the image we have ourselves today.
- 10:04Like, it's very narcissist. And today you want to, you know,
- 10:08you put your face on Instagram, on TikTok.
- 10:11And so it's not the same as it used to be.
- 10:15Now your image is. You know, the first thing you
- 10:18care about. Right.
- 10:18So you want to show that you're just like example of health and.
- 10:22Yeah. Purity and virtue and right.
- 10:26OK, interesting. Are there other trends that you
- 10:28see happening in France are emerging in terms of drinking
- 10:31culture? Well, I think in France, we are
- 10:34realizing that alcohol and especially wine is integral part
- 10:39of our like daily lives. Like it's deeply tied to key
- 10:43moments of the of like meals, family gathering, friendship,
- 10:49romantic encounters. And I think this year and in the
- 10:54years to come, the trend toward like moderation seems to be most
- 10:58evident. And we we see in restaurant like
- 11:02even the pairings alternating between like alcoholic and non
- 11:06alcoholic beverages. We can see also like dry dating.
- 11:09I don't know if you've seen there is like this survey
- 11:15published by Bumble, you know the.
- 11:17Yes, of course. And they're saying that the new
- 11:19generation, like millennial and Generation Z, they, I think it's
- 11:24one out of three who has decided not to drink at all for a first
- 11:29date, just not to lose control. First date OK.
- 11:32So it is the dry dating and I think it goes up to 40% of women
- 11:38who decide not to drink just not to lose control on not to be.
- 11:43We said like vulnerable. So I think this is one big
- 11:47trend. I think the new generation is
- 11:48going to drink less and less, but maybe drink better.
- 11:52We always tell that. I don't know if it's a real.
- 11:54Right. It's like buy better, buy less,
- 11:56buy better. Are they really doing it?
- 11:58I don't. Know, I'm not sure because when
- 11:59you go to bars, like, like not in our small world of natural
- 12:03wine, like, I don't know, young people, they don't drink like
- 12:06they drink. No, they're drinking garbage.
- 12:07Basically, yeah, yeah, yeah. So.
- 12:09Cheap garbage. Cheap garbage.
- 12:11Yeah. And I think another interesting
- 12:14trend is a kind of convergence between the conventional wine
- 12:18world, which is striving to become cleaner, and the
- 12:21reassessment of natural wine in it's more like extreme and
- 12:25flowed forms, which have significantly damaged its
- 12:29reputation. So today, I think that wine
- 12:33lovers are looking for, like, to drink better, but the wine still
- 12:38has to be good. I mean, like, you know, like all
- 12:40of the flaws we could find in natural wine.
- 12:42I think now even, like, the new generation of wine makers,
- 12:46they're trying to maybe suffer. They put like, they are less
- 12:49radical, wild and radical. Yeah.
- 12:52So maybe I'm being optimistic, but I tend to believe that we're
- 12:55moving toward like overall improvement and the kind of
- 12:58harmonization with like, you know, the very traditional
- 13:02trying to be cleaner with like putting less sulfides and trying
- 13:07to be more like conscious about this.
- 13:09And and on the other way, the more like extreme that are
- 13:13trying to, you know, live up to something more classic.
- 13:17In some way less, less funky. This is the word that people, I
- 13:20guess, are sick of. But I think it really does a
- 13:22good job of explaining that, yeah, sort of unstable, wild
- 13:27flavor that really some people, some drinkers reject.
- 13:32I mean, I leave these tasting tours that are inspired by my
- 13:35book. And I was with clients yesterday
- 13:37and we were finishing with natural wine, and we were
- 13:39talking about what that is and what they like.
- 13:42And actually, one of the two said she actually likes that.
- 13:46Like barnyard, Yeah, smell and taste, which is something I
- 13:52can't stand, you know, and just the palates are so our palates
- 13:55are so different. Exactly.
- 13:56And it's interesting to see. OK.
- 13:58Well from the natural wine makers perspective, how do you
- 14:01reach some sort of balance? Yeah, And even I think young
- 14:06sommelier sometime, like I don't, I go to a restaurant and
- 14:10I don't say I, I don't tell them that I'm a wine journalist and I
- 14:14just listen to them. And they are just like
- 14:17considering that this like default is just like something
- 14:21good. They're like, this is how wine
- 14:23should be. And I'm like, yeah, I think that
- 14:25it's bad for natural wine reputation.
- 14:29And This is why my next book about wine will be about like, I
- 14:33don't know if you could say that in English, but straight natural
- 14:36wines and the the. Yeah.
- 14:40Yeah, and the the the like, the the topic of the book is to talk
- 14:46about wine that will never like disappoint you.
- 14:49I know this is quite like antisthetic with like with what
- 14:54you should expect from natural one because it has to be like
- 14:58different on every bottle. But then at the same time, you
- 15:01you could expect to have at least some kind of, you know,
- 15:04balance between the. Some features have to be the
- 15:07same. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 15:08Interesting. OK, lot to discuss there because
- 15:14I remember distinctly a time when you would go to restaurants
- 15:17and, you know, you could tell that they were just jumping on a
- 15:19movement and they didn't actually know if a bottle was
- 15:22bad or just a little funky. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 15:26That's complicated for consumers, especially wine
- 15:29drinkers, who are are very rigid in their choices and you want to
- 15:32try to get them to experience something else.
- 15:34And if that first impression is lousy, they're never going to.
- 15:38Touch it again, you lose them. Like my father-in-law, but he's
- 15:42in his early 80s. So I think he gets a pass.
- 15:45But but you know, there are, there are other diners, much
- 15:47younger drinkers, sorry, much younger, who are not going to
- 15:51give it a second chance. Yeah, yeah.
- 15:53And and the idea of the of the my next book was that it's like
- 15:58my publisher asked me what is the question you have the most?
- 16:02And, and one of the question I have the most is I get the most
- 16:08is where should I start with natural wine?
- 16:11Like what should I drink? I don't know like which ones,
- 16:14because this is something paradoxical is natural wine.
- 16:17It's some of them have like, you know, funky labels and like so
- 16:21you you see that there. But today it's very difficult
- 16:26because some very conventional are going to play with this
- 16:30codes and they're going to have like, you know, funky labels,
- 16:33but they're not natural at all. And some very natural wine are
- 16:38not like certified organically. They have like really like, you
- 16:43know, like old school labels. So you have to be an insider to
- 16:46know. And this is where I have a
- 16:48responsibility and where like I like to do my job because of
- 16:53that, because I want to taste like many, many things and be
- 16:56able to tell to people. Well, this one looks very
- 16:58classic, but it's one of the most vibrant and natural you can
- 17:02find. And this is like, this should go
- 17:05to garbage. So, you know, like, that's the
- 17:07thing, and I think it's what makes our jobs interesting.
- 17:10Sure. I mean, the public really, I
- 17:12mean, for to give you an example, and this is where I'm,
- 17:15I'm hoping you will jump in as well.
- 17:18There is still a misunderstanding about what
- 17:20natural wine is. Yeah.
- 17:22And so, you know, my my listeners may have discovered my
- 17:26my sort of definition in in the new Paris.
- 17:29But what are you telling your readers if they don't
- 17:33understand, you know, like what makes it natural?
- 17:36Is that just sort of a an umbrella term?
- 17:39You know what does it mean? Well, there is no like
- 17:44certification, but the definition would be like, to me,
- 17:48it's a wine made with like minimal intervention, sorry,
- 17:52both in the vineyard and in the cellar.
- 17:54Because sometimes people like, tend to like, they're not sure
- 17:59between like organic and between and natural wines, but organic
- 18:03is just in the vineyards. And then I think what makes wine
- 18:07natural, He's really interstellar.
- 18:10Also, like it typically comes from organically or
- 18:13biodynamically farmed grapes harvested by hand, usually and
- 18:18fermented with native yeasts rather than commercial ones.
- 18:22And in the cellar, when makers avoid like additives such as
- 18:26sulfides and enzymes and artificial artificial
- 18:31stabilizers and and they refrain from like processes like
- 18:38filtration or not all of them, but most of them and heavy
- 18:41manipulation. To me, the goal of natural one
- 18:44is to express the purest like essence of the grape.
- 18:48Yeah, that's. That's a perfect definition.
- 18:51I try. No, no, it's because you know,
- 18:53it's, it's not a regulated term. No, you have like a
- 18:59certification named, I don't know, the label is Vomitadnatur.
- 19:07But The thing is like it gathers like not of like not all of them
- 19:12because like we see the natural wine world as a whole scene, but
- 19:16it's like a whole scene with like many, many different, you
- 19:19know, clans, right, right. So it's.
- 19:22And they don't agree amongst each other.
- 19:24No, no, no. What is and isn't natural?
- 19:26Yeah, you have the ayatollahs who like they don't want to have
- 19:29like any sulfides. But then it makes like, and
- 19:33usually the wines are exported like everywhere in the world.
- 19:36So I, I don't know, I travel a lot and when I drink some of the
- 19:40wines I used to love in France and I would drink them in Japan
- 19:44or elsewhere, like it's complete mess because.
- 19:48By the time it arrives there, there's nothing to stabilize.
- 19:50Right. Interesting.
- 19:52So. And we know that, you know, some
- 19:55businesses, especially in the restaurant world here in Paris,
- 19:58are now closing, right? Like we managed to get through
- 20:02COVID. And I'm starting to see more
- 20:05businesses decide to close shop now, and not just in Paris, you
- 20:08know, other places. And that's not just restaurants,
- 20:10it's coffee shops. It's people who are just like,
- 20:13it's our time. Yeah.
- 20:15Bars, however, here seem full. They seem, there seem to be new
- 20:20bars kind of regularly, maybe on wine chops and wine, so many
- 20:24wine shops. So I'm, I'm kind of wondering
- 20:28what do you make of our options in Paris today?
- 20:32Are there and and the ones that you love personally?
- 20:35How are they doing? Well, I think that like wine
- 20:39shops and bars, like after COVID, it was like this kind of
- 20:43golden age of like everyone wanted to go everywhere and, you
- 20:46know, forget about this nightmare.
- 20:49And but I think today, like the one that I'm going to managed to
- 20:55stay open, it's when they have vintages and a real like
- 21:02charismatic, like owner. And I don't know, like I used to
- 21:08work for the footing. And I think that the footing has
- 21:11contributed to a kind of standardization, like even in
- 21:14terms of atmosphere and like interior design.
- 21:17And so it seems that all like a lot of wine bars today are
- 21:22looking alike and they have the same wine selection.
- 21:26So I think the one that are really interesting today are the
- 21:30one that I've like, you know, worked on a very specific kind
- 21:34of selection and with like, yeah, vintages because people
- 21:38want to drink. The one I like today are this
- 21:41one, the one who look like bistros more.
- 21:45Yeah, OK. And we see that the Bistro
- 21:47cuisine is like it's back. So I think this is kind of the
- 21:52same in the wine bar. I think for the one geeks, the
- 21:56best natural wine bar, it's a bar.
- 21:58Well, like from the outside, you cannot even know that it's a
- 22:02yeah, that it's a natural wine bar.
- 22:04Natural wine. Bar, Yeah.
- 22:05So what? What is that for you?
- 22:06What are a couple that you really love?
- 22:10Well, I love, I don't know if you could say that it's a
- 22:13natural wine bar, but I love like Cavallo Grand because to me
- 22:16it's really like, you know, under under.
- 22:20Well, first, it's beautiful. In the Vivian.
- 22:23Yeah. And they have a very wide
- 22:25selection. If we talk about like natural,
- 22:28natural, I would say Vivon, Vivon Devion, it's the.
- 22:33Restaurant and then the bar next door called.
- 22:35Yeah, I think they have a very good selections and I love
- 22:40Augustine Marshall. Yes, yeah, because it's very
- 22:43cozy and it looks like a like some kind of, you know, shady
- 22:47Speakeasy. I don't know it's and he has a
- 22:50really good selection of. That's on the Left Bank.
- 22:52Yeah, of Jihad and Italy and like every time.
- 22:57I don't even, he doesn't even have like a wine list.
- 23:01He he just like and I, this is what I love.
- 23:04When you really love wine, you don't want to have like, you
- 23:07know, like a huge book, a huge wine list, like it looks like a
- 23:11encyclopedia. You just want to trust.
- 23:14It's funny because we have a mutual friend who hates when we
- 23:20go, you go to a bar and they're just like, no, just tell me what
- 23:23you're interested in and I'll recommend something as the
- 23:26expert, you know? And he, he, given his knowledge,
- 23:29is sort of like very suspicious of that.
- 23:31He's like, I just want to at least see some of what you have,
- 23:34even if I'm going to end up putting my trust in you.
- 23:37I want to know what you got. And again, this could be just a
- 23:41different level of existence. As we say, I don't know.
- 23:46I I I just find it amusing to to drink with him and.
- 23:49Yeah, Yeah, yeah. No, that's.
- 23:51True, he reacts to that that dynamic with a a server or a
- 23:56SIMULIA who looks like they're 12.
- 23:58Yeah, yeah, yeah. I think this is one of the bias.
- 24:00When I see someone like younger than I am and telling me like
- 24:04I'm the list, I'm like. Exactly.
- 24:06Really. You are the list.
- 24:08Yeah, Interesting. That's the problem.
- 24:10I think that's, I think mostly what he's reacting to.
- 24:13Yeah. But Speaking of Lafouring, your
- 24:16point is a very interesting one because I wrote an essay for the
- 24:18Footings new guide, unfortunately it's only in
- 24:21French, but about the enduring appeal of the of the Parisian
- 24:24Bistro in America. And I actually spoke to our
- 24:28mutual friend Jon Bonet, who's been a guest of the show several
- 24:31times about the various evolutions, and he's been there
- 24:34for most of them. And we talked about the
- 24:38influence of La Bouvette and Septime Cavs specifically on New
- 24:42York City icons like the Four Horsemen when, you know, there
- 24:47was a period after the economic crash where American restaurant
- 24:50owners and bar owners started coming back to Paris and just
- 24:53being like, yes, this is what we want and we want to transport
- 24:57that to to New York. Do you think Paris is still a
- 25:00source of inspiration for a lot of these?
- 25:03You know, you were just in New York.
- 25:04You saw a lot of things. Do you think that's still a
- 25:06model? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 25:08I so, yeah, I was in New York like 3 weeks ago and I noticed
- 25:12that France is still like a major reference when it comes to
- 25:16wine bars. And in some places you'd think
- 25:19that you were in the tents around, around this small Paris.
- 25:23Yeah. It's almost a caricature.
- 25:25I yeah, I've been to like, like new open places and I, yeah, I
- 25:30really felt like I was in Paris. And the only difference is that
- 25:34the wines are like five times more expensive.
- 25:38But yeah, but. And then again, which is good,
- 25:41it's the selection is we said like it's wider because you can
- 25:46find like wines from Catalonia, like South Africa and like
- 25:50they're more like open minded. I was laughing going to Claude
- 25:55in the Lower East Side because yeah, I think it's a really like
- 26:00emblematic of the, of the, the New York like passion about like
- 26:05French wine bars, like the, the wine list.
- 26:08It was like first it was 2 categories, France and
- 26:13everything else grouped at the bottom.
- 26:15And they're like the band, not France.
- 26:19And I think like it tells a lot about the influence of the
- 26:23French model. It's actually quite rare that to
- 26:26see it happen in this direction because usually, you know, we
- 26:29are Americanized. But in this particular section,
- 26:32I think it's the well it. Is called Claude, right?
- 26:35I guess they're trying to, they're trying to be French.
- 26:37Yeah, yeah, right. But that's a funny way of of
- 26:40categorizing. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 26:41But I think it's very funny. I think it's kind of, you know,
- 26:44like some kind of provocation. Yeah, a bit, but that's
- 26:48interesting. So you think Paris still?
- 26:52Yeah, yeah. In terms of in terms of image,
- 26:55yeah, really. And I could like I was with
- 26:58John, our mutual friend. So I was, you know, like people
- 27:03were very nice to me. But even in other countries when
- 27:05I go to places and people like have like looked up.
- 27:09Before. Yeah, I'm like the whoa, you
- 27:11know, I'm the French wine person and it's so funny you're.
- 27:15On a throne, yeah. Yeah.
- 27:16Yeah, and it's so funny. Like it doesn't happen here.
- 27:20I mean, people don't care. Well.
- 27:22Choose you humble. Yeah.
- 27:23Yeah, right. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 27:25Speaking of humble, you don't need to be humble about this.
- 27:28You wrote a a wonderfully respected book called Ano
- 27:33Zivres, which I guess sort of roughly translated, translates
- 27:37to an ode to our intoxications or our inebriations.
- 27:41Or how would you say it? Right, Like one of those.
- 27:44Yeah, yeah, yeah. And it's only available in
- 27:47French for the moment, but it will be coming out in other
- 27:48languages. What did what do you cover in
- 27:51this book? Is it strictly about alcoholic
- 27:54intoxication? No, Yeah, yeah.
- 27:57So like, for now, it has been translated into Spanish, and it
- 28:01will soon be available in Italian and Korean, but
- 28:04unfortunately not in English yet.
- 28:06But it's. We're working on it.
- 28:07Good, good. And the idea behind this book
- 28:10was to offer like a fresh perspective on IRS, which is
- 28:14often mistakenly seen as a dangerous state or like a
- 28:18prelude to alcoholism. And but I still believe that
- 28:22it's a fascinating state and when you know how to navigate
- 28:26it, and one that opens doors to like many encounters and
- 28:33including with yourself. Like I discovered like a new me
- 28:36by discovering this. Like before that I didn't drink
- 28:39alcohol so I was always lucid in some way.
- 28:42So before the age of what, like 26?
- 28:44Yeah, I would drink some time out of like, politeness just to
- 28:48be, to be polite. And so in the book, I explore
- 28:52the theme of intoxication through like different lenses.
- 28:56So like travel, the body, the gender, love, family, like many,
- 29:03many different themes, plays a very specific role in each of
- 29:08these aspects of our lives, I think.
- 29:09And I wanted to portray it in a way that is less like, demonized
- 29:14and gentler and above all, like more luminous and without
- 29:19encouraging, you know, like excessive conceptions.
- 29:22And I also emphasize that there is a fine line and delicate
- 29:26balance that must be reassessed with every new glass, which is
- 29:30the why the book subtitle is Every Glass is a First Time.
- 29:35And I would. Just say, oh, I love that, you
- 29:37know, like and I would even add that every glass is also a last
- 29:40time because that's what I love about wine.
- 29:44It's this moment and ever again, like if we have a drink today
- 29:48and even if we drink tomorrow, the exact same wine, you will
- 29:51have change. I will have change.
- 29:52We won't have had the same day. And that kind of feeling, it's
- 29:57what's like makes you feel like alive.
- 29:59And, and at first I was afraid of how it would be received the
- 30:04book because it was my first essay.
- 30:06So I didn't know at all. And but like it got very
- 30:11positive press coverage. And what was surprising, it was
- 30:14like on the left press and right press.
- 30:18It was like two different interpretation, like for the
- 30:22writer was that, yeah, someone like, you know, is not going
- 30:26into this like a genist thing. And from the left wing, it was
- 30:32more like, oh, finally a woman, you know, like takes the thing.
- 30:36So it was very funny to like, see that.
- 30:39But there's something very philosophical about that take
- 30:43and and really quite special to consider that, you know, the
- 30:47glass that I had last night and and if I had the same thing
- 30:50today. Yeah, I guess you don't
- 30:52necessarily consider that you are technically a different
- 30:55version of yourself the next day because of all the other factors
- 30:58that have occurred in 1224 hours.
- 31:03I don't think we think about it in in such detail.
- 31:05Not really. Like I had the time to think
- 31:07about it. And and The thing is like, even
- 31:09like you, it distorts in some way your relationship to time
- 31:14and your top reality. I don't know how you could say
- 31:16that because when you start drinking, like time flies and
- 31:20you know, you, you, you look at your watch and it's already like
- 31:24midnight or one or so. Yeah.
- 31:26Like what moved me the most, though, is that where the like,
- 31:30all the messages and the letters are received afterwards.
- 31:33Like especially from, from women telling me they found the book
- 31:37courageous, but I think it was just mostly reckless.
- 31:41You know I I didn't you. Thought it was.
- 31:43Reckless. No, like I, people were telling
- 31:45me, Oh, it's very courageous to write like because I give a lot
- 31:49of like my story in this. But afterwards I thought like,
- 31:54no, like I didn't even, you know, by writing I was thinking,
- 31:58oh, maybe my parents were idiots.
- 32:00But I, I didn't even, you know, and realised that a lot of
- 32:04people were going to read it. So like, even now I meet people
- 32:08sometime and they're like, oh, so in 2006, you, I don't know,
- 32:12you had sex for the first time or something.
- 32:13And I was like, yeah, oh, they read my book.
- 32:16Oh yeah, I did say that, didn't I?
- 32:18Yeah. So, but I don't know.
- 32:21He and most women told me that he'd helped them to feel less
- 32:26guilty and like, it was very like, emotional in some way.
- 32:31And This is why I'm going to launch this new series from
- 32:34Madame Madame Figaro about women and alcohol because we don't
- 32:37really talk about that. It's a huge taboo.
- 32:41Still like the you. Think in France in particular,
- 32:43it's still taboo. Yeah, yeah.
- 32:45Because from like when we are very young, we all like we
- 32:50already hear that see Babu in from Kiboil.
- 32:55It's not beautiful. A woman who drinks and and even
- 32:59I I mean like I'm making my auto like criticism.
- 33:03It's even when I see a guy having some kind of behaviour, I
- 33:08will find it funny if a woman has the same behaviour, I will
- 33:13be, you know, uncomfortable. Even even if I have, I'm a woman
- 33:18and even if I have like thought a lot to this subject, Yeah,
- 33:21yeah, I still have this kind of automatism.
- 33:24So I think it's interesting to kind of see why and how like
- 33:30woman has to restrain from alcohol and men.
- 33:33And a guy who in France, a guy who doesn't drink, he's seen as,
- 33:39you know, some kind of feminine, you know, or like, not male,
- 33:43kind of. It's a very Latin country still.
- 33:47You're right, you're right. I sometimes forget that.
- 33:49But you've also, what we were talking about before we started
- 33:52recording was in the wine world, too, and in wine reporting.
- 33:57The effect on that, the the jobs effect on women, you know, who
- 34:03have come before you and how few women are actually writing about
- 34:07wine. Yeah.
- 34:09What are you noticing? Yeah, like lately I was kind of
- 34:13worried to see that my one of my, how do you say concern.
- 34:20Peers. Yeah, peers from Jean Al Lamont.
- 34:23She's just stopped writing about wine because she said, like, I
- 34:27can't take it anymore. I, you know, it makes me sick.
- 34:31And she has become some kind of allergic to mine.
- 34:35And then there is another one in at Liberation.
- 34:37She stops or so. So and they are a bit older than
- 34:43I am. I'm 36.
- 34:44So I'm like, well, I really have to be careful about that.
- 34:49So even you can play on the, you know, social media and make
- 34:54people think that you're drinking and going out all the
- 34:57time, but it's not true. Actually it it requires a lot of
- 35:00discipline like. Well, and tastings, if you're
- 35:03really just doing tastings, do you have to drink the whole
- 35:05glass? Yeah, No.
- 35:07Are you? No, I spit all the time.
- 35:10And at the beginning of my career, I couldn't really spit
- 35:13because people wanted to, you know, test me in some way.
- 35:16So I well, I would spit for like, you know, tastings, but I
- 35:20didn't dare to spit for like lunches and dinners.
- 35:24But now I, it's not that I, it would be very like, you know,
- 35:29like to say that I don't have anything to prove anymore.
- 35:32It's not true, but people know that I know how to taste.
- 35:36And so now I even spit for for like in dinner, like
- 35:40professional dinners. And which is funny is like now I
- 35:45at the end of like before I leave, I just take my casual
- 35:51spitter and I'm always amazed by the weight of the thing.
- 35:56And I'm like, wow, this is everything I didn't like put in
- 35:59your body, put in my body. So yeah, it happened like a year
- 36:02ago. I did that.
- 36:03And now I do it automatically. And I'm like, oh, yeah, lucky
- 36:08me. Because it's so like, it's so
- 36:10bad for your body yet like in this intensity, Right, right,
- 36:14right. Like.
- 36:15Right, a glass here and there is very different from what it
- 36:18would look like if you were to drink at every occasion that
- 36:20you're. Yeah, and this is like, this is
- 36:24I'm very lucky because I could have like, like very like
- 36:29exceptional wine every day. And, you know, if I go to La
- 36:32Roman de Conti, he doesn't care that I went to shave or, you
- 36:36know, overnoir the the, the day before, he just wants me to
- 36:40drink his wine. So it's kind of, it's always
- 36:43hard diplomatically to manage and to say, oh, no, I had too
- 36:47much yesterday. So you have to, you know,
- 36:50balance. And this is the hardest thing, I
- 36:52think. So you're about to leave on
- 36:56another reporting trip. So I want to just get one last
- 37:00question in which is you named a couple of places you like
- 37:03Deviant, Vivant, Cavieux, Grand Augustine, Marchand Van, which
- 37:09is great. Maybe maybe the last question
- 37:13then is sort of what listeners who are going to come to Paris
- 37:16and order wine, is there something you think they should
- 37:19be asking? Is there a question or a way of
- 37:22trying to understand more of this natural thing?
- 37:26I tend to tell people that the word funky is at least
- 37:28understood and even in French, funky, you know.
- 37:31But is there? Is there another way that
- 37:35consumers or clients at a restaurant or bar can better
- 37:39control what they might be served or like have it better
- 37:43suited to them? But I think if you want to like
- 37:47not be disappointed, you have to ask for I see the natural wine
- 37:52wars like you have like 2, maybe 3 generations.
- 37:57And I think the first generation of, you know, Baquelais, Chav
- 38:02and Lapierre under like they made mistakes.
- 38:05And then now they're considered as like some somehow like trader
- 38:10because they have become like more, you know, classic in their
- 38:15way of making wines like or the generation after them.
- 38:19And I think that when you go, for instance, to look on to a de
- 38:24resistant, they yeah, they have a white selection, They have new
- 38:30funky wines, but they also have like, you know, going on, they
- 38:33have like very I think at first you should go for like the
- 38:38classic natural wines. I think it's the if you, if you
- 38:43can find them because they're becoming like rare, but I think
- 38:47that would be my, my advice would be to go, not go for the
- 38:51young funky ones at first. You can go in funky afterwards,
- 38:56but you have to try like my, I was lucky.
- 38:59I started with Daribo because like it can be funky sometimes,
- 39:03but it's still like, you know, very well made.
- 39:07And I think when you have this one, you, you realize that it's
- 39:11very different from conventional ones that are like, you know,
- 39:13kind of plain and no like emotion.
- 39:16And you discover like a whole new world to me so.
- 39:20So someone could go into one of these bars or go to Le Cuantro
- 39:23de Resistant and say what's the sort of more classic natural?
- 39:27They can ask it in that way. Yeah, like they can say even
- 39:30like straight, straight, straight.
- 39:33Yeah, sometime, like somebody are, you know, annoyed by this,
- 39:36but they know what you mean. So I think it would be the best
- 39:39way. And then you're sure that you're
- 39:40going to have something, you know, like exquisite.
- 39:44Well, I think that's excellent advice and I think you're going
- 39:46to have to come back and talk more about your your series on
- 39:49women in wine when you start or women in alcohol when you start
- 39:53reporting. So, but for now, Alicia, thank
- 39:56you for. Thank you so much.
- 39:57That was great. Thank you.
- 40:01That's the show for today. Thanks for listening.
- 40:04As always, if you're streaming this on Spotify, be sure to
- 40:07check out a little poll that awaits you pertaining to this
- 40:09discussion. Just Scroll down on the episode
- 40:12page within the app and vote. And if you enjoy the show, I'd
- 40:16love it if you'd subscribe, share with a friend, and pick up
- 40:19the books that inspired it, The new Paris and the New
- 40:22Parisienne. Until next time, Abianto.