Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 228:19-20. Vows: Hataras Nedarim: Permitting Vows, Being Present, Dependent On Someone Else; Yiftach, Moshe, Tzidkiyahu

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 228:19-20. Vows: Hataras Nedarim: Permitting Vows, Being Present, Dependent On Someone Else; Yiftach, Moshe, Tzidkiyahu · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:01
  OK, good morning. We're continuing to help us
• 0:02
  Nadarim. OK, today we're starting see if
• 0:07
  you're Ted, just a comment on Tedzine.
• 0:11
  So we mentioned you have to make a nadir Hataris Nadarim rather
• 0:16
  in front. We're going to see that twice
• 0:18
  today. One time I'm just going to
• 0:22
  mention the story. One of the places that we
• 0:24
  learned that you have to mention, I mean it's from
• 0:27
  Khazal, but one of the places where we see that you have to do
• 0:30
  it in front of the the no there. The one who makes the value
• 0:36
  can't just do it when he's not around.
• 0:39
  All right, so Mahoga Satara says you can't even write it and send
• 0:42
  in that you want to do a Tara to the base din and give your
• 0:45
  reason of Karata. That's not good enough.
• 0:48
  The Pisgre Chuva says it might be good enough.
• 0:51
  F Sharksas la haka when there's no choice, but certainly it's a
• 0:57
  Dinder Abana Mistama said only a dinder Abanan you had the
• 1:02
  reasoning was you need to have proper karata and you have to
• 1:06
  tell over, you know, what the net there was and why and why
• 1:09
  you did it. So therefore it just lends
• 1:12
  itself to the net, to natural din, at least on a level of a
• 1:17
  dinder abanan. I mean concept is close to der
• 1:21
  Isa, but as far as a ruling that halacha that has to be in front
• 1:25
  of them seems to be only a Dinder Abanan and Vidi avid.
• 1:29
  It probably does work, right? We see cases, it probably does
• 1:33
  work Lekha and Vidi avid if they did it otherwise.
• 1:36
  So one of the interesting stories that we have this from
• 1:39
  in Tanakh is where Yiftah Giladi safe for shoftim in the areas of
• 1:48
  Prakhim Udhalakan base. So right, the famous story
• 1:51
  Yiftahan Giladi, he makes a a famous Neder that if he wins the
• 1:55
  war, whoever is going to go through the doors first, he's
• 1:58
  going to bring as a carbon. And it's and it was not a proper
• 2:03
  it wasn't proper for him to do so.
• 2:05
  But Khazal, one of the places in Brazil, Sraba Samer mentions it,
• 2:11
  and one of the places that that somebody did not ask Kahogan and
• 2:17
  it didn't go well for him either, because it turned out to
• 2:20
  be his daughter. Now, of course, we all know that
• 2:25
  the nether of bringing a korban to his daughter was certainly
• 2:29
  not khal for a daughter. A person has no right to make
• 2:34
  another person a korban. You could only make a nether.
• 2:37
  First of all, it has to be done the proper lush, unbelieving.
• 2:40
  If it was, it has to be done on yourself or on something that
• 2:46
  you own. No one can make a nether on
• 2:48
  somebody else binding if it has nothing to do with him or his
• 2:51
  possession. So of course it wasn't hull.
• 2:55
  And so that's a Mahocus if you have to bring animals or not.
• 3:02
  If it's an animal that's not proper as a carbon.
• 3:05
  So it's a Mahocus. If you have to bring money or
• 3:07
  something instead of it, OK, fine.
• 3:09
  But certainly has nothing to do with with its daughter.
• 3:12
  And so anyways, so someone will point out from here you what's
• 3:20
  it called anyway? So here from here we see Penhas.
• 3:24
  All right, what's the famous story?
• 3:25
  It was Penhas and Yiftak. Yiftak was like the president or
• 3:28
  the ruler and Penhas was the was the head of the Sanhedrin.
• 3:36
  So each one said he was a Kachman.
• 3:39
  Each one said I'm not going to go to him.
• 3:41
  He has to come to me. So you see that they had to be
• 3:44
  in front of where the basin is being Mattea, he wouldn't do it
• 3:48
  behind his, you know, for him he needed to to come and he and he
• 3:52
  also had to state that he had kharata if he could have sent
• 3:57
  him a letter or not. So that's the Mahaka Sakhonian.
• 4:00
  But anyways, you see from here though, there has to be in front
• 4:04
  of them. And the fact that Pentecost
• 4:06
  didn't walk too Yiftah and Yiftah wouldn't walk too
• 4:11
  Pentecost. They both got punished right?
• 4:14
  What was the punishment? Pinhas lost his Rukh Kodesh and
• 4:20
  Pinh and Yiftah when he died. It's unclear exactly what
• 4:24
  happened but the Shilas ivarim, I don't know if it was before or
• 4:28
  after he died but some say so. His ivarim were falling off and
• 4:37
  it was buried at each his different ivarim and his bones
• 4:41
  were buried throughout RA Gilad. It says in the puzzle it was in
• 4:47
  RA Gilad. It wasn't in one place because
• 4:50
  they were falling off as 'cause he was diseased at the end of
• 4:55
  his life and it was buried as he was travelling in different
• 4:59
  places. And even though Etzemedin he
• 5:02
  didn't need to make, didn't need to do Ataris Nadarian, he
• 5:05
  thought he needed to. And again, if an Alma arts does
• 5:09
  another inappropriately, then we don't we, we don't just say
• 5:14
  you're off the hook so that it's not call.
• 5:17
  We say you have to do Ataris Nadarian.
• 5:20
  And before she would say he should have at least made him
• 5:24
  hire to pay money instead, like we mentioned potentially, but
• 5:29
  here it's a it's a big Indian. It was a niece.
• 5:33
  It helped cause an ace from Hashem that they won in the war
• 5:36
  and it was done in public. So you should have at least made
• 5:39
  him bring some money. It would have been inappropriate
• 5:42
  just to get him off the hook just like that.
• 5:45
  Anyways, that's some so it's it's a Mahacus.
• 5:51
  What happened? It's his daughter In the end,
• 5:55
  the Sukim never said they killed her.
• 5:58
  So one it's it's unclear what happened.
• 6:01
  Either they killed her after a couple months, right?
• 6:03
  It said that she went to the house for a couple months to cry
• 6:06
  and then she came out and either she either they killed her or
• 6:12
  for the rest of her life she stayed without getting married.
• 6:15
  And every year it's the puzzle says every year, like four days
• 6:19
  a year, I think the the girls would cry.
• 6:21
  And because of the story, it'd be like a public mourning.
• 6:25
  So either with her or without her, it depends if she died or
• 6:28
  stayed alive. But it's unclear what happened
• 6:30
  exactly. But she never remarried.
• 6:33
  She never married ever and lived a proper life.
• 6:36
  That's that's that's clear from the story.
• 6:38
  OK, sorry for the little shop team.
• 6:41
  Your tet nisha Nishba or nadar Las odavar ploni T.O.K Shana
• 6:47
  first. It makes you Shiva.
• 6:49
  He's going to do something within a year.
• 6:54
  So you have an entire year to be Makayam.
• 6:57
  So you're not over the Shiva. But it it's clear according to
• 7:00
  everyone, the Shiva's called right now because you could be
• 7:02
  Makayam, the Shiva right now. So the that's just a case with
• 7:06
  any time the if it's if it's called, if it's applicable right
• 7:10
  away, even though you have a whole year to take care of it,
• 7:13
  you can already do the Hatara immediately.
• 7:15
  You don't have to wait till after you're over, but that's
• 7:18
  fine. Let's go to the next one, cough
• 7:20
  Nadar Aldas Cavaro. OK, so here you're making a
• 7:24
  nadir. You're you're making it in front
• 7:29
  of somebody. It's presumably in general.
• 7:33
  That means again, we're going to see it basically means you're
• 7:37
  doing it when the person, you're giving the person the veto
• 7:42
  power, right? You're not allowed to undo your
• 7:45
  nadir without getting his permission.
• 7:48
  That's the shot of what a case is of Nader Aldas Caviro.
• 7:54
  He did it in front of him and and we're going to see as we
• 7:56
  explained. And so he has to give.
• 7:59
  He has the right not to allow you even no, sometimes there's
• 8:06
  issues of Khashad or Busha. You could embarrass somebody or
• 8:10
  someone was is going to think if they don't know about you
• 8:13
  undoing it, they won't know and therefore they're going to think
• 8:16
  you're over another. Even if that's not the case,
• 8:20
  that could be the case. But even if that's not the case,
• 8:23
  you still need their permission. That's that's what the normal
• 8:27
  case of Aldas Cavaro is. So let's read Ayn matirin lo
• 8:33
  Ella ingenho deal. You're not allowed to undo the
• 8:36
  Neder and right, the basin can't undo the Neder unless they tell
• 8:41
  this person Osso Shanadar Aldaso, because they made the
• 8:45
  Ned there it was on his dos. He it was like it was in front
• 8:51
  of him and it seemed to be understood again, it depends on
• 8:53
  the case, but it's understood that you need his permission and
• 8:57
  therefore you can't just go and undo it behind his back because
• 9:00
  that's not how it was done. So there now, now once right.
• 9:07
  So it always means he gets his permission.
• 9:10
  And once you get his permission, you don't have to be maternet
• 9:16
  there in front of him. You just need the basin and they
• 9:19
  know there you don't need this other Chavera.
• 9:24
  That's the shock. So what I just pointed out was
• 9:27
  the shock, but it's I think Lakuli Alma.
• 9:30
  And the way I explained it is the way the Roma explains it.
• 9:35
  And the shock says that's there's no machocus.
• 9:37
  That's the opinion of the Shochana.
• 9:42
  I know. I have that too.
• 9:43
  I got the Yeesh Omrin. So the Yeesh Omrin is not always
• 9:47
  a Mahokhit and sometimes it's only coming to explain.
• 9:53
  OK, so that it it, it could be the Shokhanarak is referring to
• 9:58
  Mepaniya Busha. That is a discussion.
• 10:01
  It's a discussion if it's a Mahlokit or not a Mahlokit.
• 10:04
  That's OK. Well, so we'll leave it at that.
• 10:07
  But those who say it's a Mahlokit have trouble with the
• 10:10
  Shokhanar. Simple reading to make everyone
• 10:12
  happy is that there's no Mahlogas.
• 10:14
  OK, the aish Omri that Filo Hodillo in my Tyrion El
• 10:18
  Amidaltor at Sonovochain icar. It doesn't mean that you have
• 10:22
  to. It's not enough just to tell him
• 10:25
  because the nether was Aldas and it depends how the nether was
• 10:30
  made. But if it was Aldas Cavaro,
• 10:33
  usually that means or we're assuming a reading that it means
• 10:37
  you had it was with his permission or veto power and
• 10:41
  therefore you you have then he then then if that's the case,
• 10:45
  you would need his permission as well.
• 10:47
  It's not just enough to inform him.
• 10:50
  And that is the correct way of of Vadav Questionadar Aldato
• 10:59
  bishvil Shumtova Asalo bishvil Hashvua.
• 11:08
  Now when is this halacha that you need his permission?
• 11:13
  It's when you made it in response for someone doing you
• 11:17
  at Tova. So someone did you at Tova and
• 11:21
  at that moment you took upon the the net there because of that
• 11:30
  you or it's it's on a condition. In other words, you you, you
• 11:38
  make him. So here let's come.
• 11:40
  Moshe Schenader aadas nidro bishvil shahisi lo Vito.
• 11:45
  And like what Moshe Rabeno married Sepora, the daughter of
• 11:50
  Yisra. It was Kilo on the condition he
• 11:54
  made a shivua. Yisra only gave up his daughter
• 11:58
  again because Moshe made a shua. I'm not going to take your
• 12:02
  daughter away with me and move back to Mitzrayim without his
• 12:06
  permission. Yeah, Shivua, I tell it to Ellis
• 12:09
  ISRO and the Shivua was for the benefit of I don't know how
• 12:15
  mashma it is. It might be mephouresh, but I
• 12:17
  think Rashi actually stresses the point that before Moshe
• 12:22
  went, it says something that Moshe went to ISRO before he
• 12:26
  moved to meet shrine. So again, how mephouresh it is.
• 12:29
  But with Rashi, it's mephouresh that he got permission before he
• 12:32
  went back 'cause he made a Shiva.
• 12:35
  OK, ABBA miatsmo Nadar adas cabero if on his own he just did
• 12:44
  something, you know, you hold him.
• 12:47
  He made another and he he told his friend about it.
• 12:51
  It was it was helpful for the friend, but it wasn't and and it
• 12:55
  could be his friend did another favor for him another time.
• 12:58
  But that's not cashour to the Nader.
• 13:01
  If it's not clear that the Nader is in response for a favor, then
• 13:07
  it's not considered a das Cavaro.
• 13:10
  In other words, it doesn't have this halacha that you need to
• 13:12
  get his permission because the Ned there is you're holding
• 13:16
  Mahatralo below that you don't need his das because you never
• 13:20
  the Ned there was never made on the condition that he that he
• 13:24
  allows you to do Hatara. That's the only time where it's
• 13:29
  binding. This tonight again, exactly
• 13:36
  anyway, Llamai said. Obviously gets a little bit
• 13:39
  great when it's if it's if it's not so clear, but anyways, huga
• 13:44
  viesh omrim shitsarek shio diolo shahitiolo and but some say even
• 13:50
  if it's not Nikardin, you have to worry about getting his
• 13:53
  permission still. You did it in front of him.
• 13:57
  Could they show you did it in front of him and he knows about
• 14:00
  the nether? It was really for him or as a
• 14:03
  favor for him, whatever you did it in front of him.
• 14:05
  Shalo yashad otosha avar al nidro.
• 14:08
  Since he was there at the time of the Neder, you did it in
• 14:11
  front of him. You should tell him so that he
• 14:13
  doesn't think you're being over you're Neder because he didn't
• 14:17
  know that you got Ataris Nadarian.
• 14:18
  You should go to at least inform him that you did Ataris
• 14:21
  Nadarian. Maheem khvar meis shiaf
• 14:24
  Charlotte hodil material no ka ka.
• 14:30
  And once he dies, at least in this case, then it's not a
• 14:35
  problem at all to undo it. Bafilo another aldato vichfield
• 14:41
  tova SH asalo medievit hetirolo bilodaito Javier hatara.
• 14:46
  No it not really. You need to do it in front of
• 14:50
  them. You have to get his permission,
• 14:52
  but the Basdon can override getting permission and it's not
• 14:57
  correct to do so. But if you did so, but you have
• 15:01
  it, it works, then who? Shiparat Anadar via de Haviero
• 15:07
  NASA. But you have to know that it was
• 15:09
  done to Alice. It was, you know, you have to
• 15:13
  tell them what the Nether was and has to say OK, this is
• 15:17
  worthwhile to undo Hatara even without his permission, they
• 15:22
  have a right to go ahead and undo it.
• 15:26
  Omiyu based in Chenis caca Oeliaso Lafico, but the based in
• 15:34
  I have Omiyu. Omiyu, Omiyad.
• 15:37
  OK, we'll use both Miyad and Omiyu.
• 15:46
  OK, the shock says Omiyu fine anyway, so regardless, both make
• 15:50
  sense. The Bayesian should tell him
• 15:53
  that you know, that's very inappropriate that you made such
• 15:56
  a Ned there especially and Aldah somebody else, and now you're
• 16:00
  going to do without without getting permission the Yesh Omim
• 16:03
  Dilohave Hatara and some say it actually, even with the of it.
• 16:07
  We don't allow it anyways, just to share a quick story from the
• 16:12
  Gomar and Nadarian Samhay has the story where we see over here
• 16:16
  also the concept of the fun of but it's actually really here.
• 16:21
  It's really not in the fun of before we learned that the no,
• 16:27
  there has to be in front of Basden here in this story.
• 16:31
  Really the fun of is going on the Das Cavaro that the Cavaro
• 16:35
  has to be there to give rushes. What happened.
• 16:37
  Sidkiyahu saw Nabucha Netzar eating a raw rabbit, the meat,
• 16:46
  the flesh eating right. And Sid Kiya Assad and Nabuka
• 16:50
  Netzer saw that Sid Kiya Assad was embarrassed and he forced
• 16:55
  him to make, he made him make a neder that he will not tell a
• 16:58
  soul. I won't tell anybody what
• 17:00
  happened. So that because if people find a
• 17:03
  Shiva, he made him make a Shiva, that he will not tell anybody.
• 17:06
  Because if he does, apparently everybody Bob and everyone will
• 17:12
  hear about such a crazy story that he's eating a raw rabbit
• 17:15
  and they're going to be Mavazza him.
• 17:19
  Maybe it was just the Jews he was worried about.
• 17:21
  He's telling everyone I don't know.
• 17:22
  But anyways, he didn't want it to get out.
• 17:24
  So he made a Shiva. OK, he let him free and then he
• 17:28
  out. It was it was extremely troubled
• 17:31
  and he couldn't get over it. He really wanted to tell the
• 17:33
  story to be Mevaza Nevilka Netzer.
• 17:36
  It was just eating got him really bad.
• 17:37
  So he went to the Sanhedrin. The Sanhedrin hold over heard
• 17:41
  over the story and they were Matir Nader, Matzo Shivua.
• 17:47
  Thank you. There's Matzo, there's Shivua,
• 17:49
  even though Nabuka Netzar didn't give permission for him to be
• 17:53
  Matzo Nader. So it works again, the no there
• 17:58
  one in front of the basin. It works.
• 18:00
  But the problem was and then Nabuka Netzar found out because
• 18:06
  everyone on the street was making fun of Nabuka Netzar and
• 18:08
  the story made it to all the papers and he was terribly
• 18:12
  embarrassed and angry. So he went to the base to this
• 18:15
  on Hedren and he said how can you do such a thing?
• 18:17
  Isn't there a halafa that you have to do what the fun of in
• 18:20
  front of me Adas Cavaro and yeah, but they felt it was
• 18:26
  little Ellis. But anyways, the story was
• 18:28
  basically they they got caught on this prat that is supposed to
• 18:32
  be Befanov and he was marked and he was upset.
• 18:36
  Yeah, but it was the Shiva work. He wasn't Swans to the toba, but
• 18:39
  it was Al Das and some level Adas Cavaro.
• 18:43
  Yeah, it's a question exactly how do you interpret If he would
• 18:49
  have given permission, it would have been permitted.
• 18:53
  But here it's unquestionable. We see it's a question.
• 18:57
  But the mice anyways, they did it and he told them that you
• 19:02
  have to sit on the floor. Now it's I don't know exactly
• 19:06
  how he punished them or if he punished them or he got
• 19:08
  punished, but I don't know. Here in In the Shock says Shenet
• 19:13
  and ash hooves and Hedren. She had tirulo because it was
• 19:17
  also makes ehol Hashem made a made a big hill Hashem to
• 19:23
  Nebuchadnezzar in front of Nebuchadnezzar because they see
• 19:26
  how the Hakamim can just go against you know, you did
• 19:29
  something Geneva, whether you call it Geneva's das or das
• 19:33
  Haviero. However you want to, even if it
• 19:35
  was technically mutter it's you know, sometimes you could do
• 19:39
  something that you can. You know, technically you think
• 19:42
  you can get away with it according to the letter of the
• 19:44
  law, but you're missing the biggest letter of the law that
• 19:47
  you're violating the hill Hashem and Geneva's does.
• 19:52
  That's the Shah. Those are the words of the Shah.
• 20:05
  And I think he gets it from the base Yosef.
• 20:07
  I I'm not sure exactly what's from the base Yosef and what's
• 20:10
  from the Shah. I didn't compare the two.
• 20:14
  Memezine. OK, let's go on.
• 20:19
  Yeah, me akhar chasala tova venish bolo mishumze because you
• 20:25
  did it for this tova, for this reason, or you let him live or
• 20:28
  whatever it is he about. Nish Bola havira lasala EZ davar
• 20:33
  bolo ASA cane mishum tova shasala alpha piche materiala
• 20:39
  bolo daito Niko Malcolm. But you made a shua, let's say,
• 20:45
  to your friend to do something, but you did something.
• 20:49
  You didn't do it because of a certain tova.
• 20:55
  If you wanted to do something good, but it wasn't like an
• 20:58
  exchange or on condition of a particular tova, so then really
• 21:02
  you should. You did it for him and you told
• 21:04
  them about it. You shouldn't do a tar star in
• 21:07
  La Catrilla without letting him know.
• 21:11
  I don't know. I don't know if you need
• 21:12
  permission, but anyways, but La Catrilla you should.
• 21:15
  But if not, then certainly on this case it works.
• 21:19
  But we have it. What is it?
• 21:21
  In the case of Ticchio, it was for little Ellis.
• 21:26
  And the question is, well, that's my focus.
• 21:30
  If it worked. But let's say it did work,
• 21:31
  right, we'll assume it worked. So there, that's not.
• 21:37
  But look at Hila there. They should have asked they they
• 21:39
  needed to, right? We're saying, but look at the
• 21:40
  Hila. You still need to get
• 21:42
  permission, right? Yeah, the IM Nispala a person
• 21:52
  makes his Shuatas Kabira that he's not going to leave.
• 21:55
  But he was over and he left Matirinam alpha P Shalom
• 21:59
  medaito. So then you're Matihim.
• 22:01
  Even if it's not medaito Kevan shenanah shuvelom Ashvi Abedavar
• 22:06
  is you can't get benefit anymore.
• 22:07
  You left already. If it's before you left, before
• 22:10
  you went back to Egypt. So then you need to get
• 22:14
  permission. But once he was over and it's
• 22:18
  not going back, then you go ahead and just be a matter they
• 22:22
  show me then you kill it and some say no it doesn't matter
• 22:30
  you need to get permission. I got an E mate also said
• 22:35
  another so And if he dies then you're allowed to be matir meal
• 22:45
  IMA Shiva. I tell it to Alette Caviro.
• 22:47
  But if the Shiva was to benefit to help his friend, he's a dovar
• 22:53
  to help him with something. Oh shalala sok Biskora built the
• 22:56
  rishuso or not to do any business without getting his
• 23:00
  permission, but yell it to Alette Caviro and he was going
• 23:03
  to help his friend be E Kochhovir shohem Dinkomo.
• 23:06
  So then by 8 Kochhovir Shahem Dinkomo.
• 23:10
  So then if if it still stands, if it's still going to help the
• 23:15
  orshim. So then you need to get their
• 23:18
  permission. Komako Shah Nishba Kibel Tova
• 23:21
  Mina Mashbiya whenever the Nishba the one who's making the
• 23:25
  Shiva gets help from the one who's making him make the Shiva
• 23:29
  Alpha Gavsha Mashbiya Kibel you tear tova me menu.
• 23:33
  Even though Mashbiya got a much bigger benefit.
• 23:37
  Filaki mikri atava so-called the benefit Chahara yitro kibo tova
• 23:42
  yuterra tova MI Moshe shenasabito.
• 23:46
  It's true that Yustro benefited more that his son-in-law was
• 23:50
  Moshe, that Moshe benefited that Yustro was his father-in-law,
• 23:54
  but still is there. It's still called a benefit.
• 24:05
  And you made the shua for the benefit of marrying his
• 24:07
  daughter. And that's true, he could have
• 24:10
  married someone else, but doesn't matter.
• 24:12
  You, you, you made the shuwa for that benefit.
• 24:14
  So now you're bound by it. Let's just kind of see if we
• 24:17
  could just finish here. Yesh omrim de letzara mitzvah
• 24:20
  matiri neder shanishpa dot caveiro afilo bilodas caveiro.
• 24:25
  And we kind of said this, but if it's a tsara, A mitzvah, so then
• 24:28
  we can be a matteir Ned there afilo without him knowing,
• 24:33
  presumably only by the evet. What if it's not?
• 24:36
  If it's not ish the Isha Shaquille O'Hara manisha zelizer
• 24:41
  man and woman they made a harem 1 to another Lisa Zed Zed to
• 24:48
  marry each other. Aim matirin velodas caveiro Zen
• 24:52
  migre hatava Lisa caveiro. So that is called a Each one is
• 24:58
  benefiting the Nisbu Mishun ka. And so they made a Shiva for
• 25:02
  this zelizer to each other, right?
• 25:07
  So I guess to marry each other About IMA isha omarich shiso
• 25:11
  naoto then not now Maslatova is very Almatyrin shalomedaito.
• 25:16
  But if the woman gave some kind of a namatla, a good explanation
• 25:20
  why she made such a Shiva. But really she hates him and has
• 25:24
  never had any kavana to go ahead with it and she needs to get
• 25:28
  separated and to not go through with it.
• 25:30
  So then it can be done. Shalom medaito about the filo in
• 25:34
  kavar NASA merit not is ally haya lahot scene because even if
• 25:39
  she's already married and she says he's disgusting to me then
• 25:43
  he has to divorcer. I'm Misha, say Misha Nishba,
• 25:47
  Shalo, Lisa, Isha, Al Isha. Look over there and.