Latest / The Sean O'Connell Show / Kyle Bonagura on potential CFP expansion, House settlement approved, Will Utah win the Big 12 (?) + more
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: That's me and Connor.
- 0:02Speaker 2: You attuned to The Sean O'Connell Show for the Murdoch
- 0:05Chevrolet Studio of ESPN seven hundred at.
- 0:09Speaker 1: One half m.
- 0:20Speaker 3: Kyle vonnegera ESPN College Football Insider ESPN dot Com staff writer,
- 0:27joins us right now on the Sean O'Connell Show. We'll
- 0:29talk about all things in the land of our favorite sport.
- 0:32Speaker 1: Kyle, welcome. How are you.
- 0:34Speaker 2: I'm doing good, Sean, How are you doing all right?
- 0:36Speaker 1: Glad to have you on the show.
- 0:38Speaker 3: I saw a headline yesterday that I didn't know how
- 0:42to feel about it. Man, I can't tell if I'm
- 0:44discouraged by it, if maybe I feel like it's ultimately
- 0:47the right thing to do. But the headline was something
- 0:49to the effect of the college football decision makers are
- 0:53ready to start over when it comes to this, uh,
- 0:56this remaking of an expanded college football playoff, that the
- 1:01four automatic qualifiers for SEC and Big ten has been
- 1:04rejected enough that maybe that's not the right way, the
- 1:07five plus eleven model that was gaining some momentum.
- 1:09Speaker 1: I don't know. We'll see what are you hearing?
- 1:12Speaker 3: Are they really ready to start over and go back
- 1:15to square one on figuring out what's next for the
- 1:18college football playoff.
- 1:21Speaker 2: I mean it's a good question because I think it
- 1:23invites a lot of different possibilities of how to read
- 1:26into it. Right, is it people who are just posturing
- 1:29because they feel like it's going to adequately get their
- 1:32agenda pass quickly? Are they really going to start over?
- 1:37I think it's best here to always look at kind
- 1:39of like the history of how this stuff works, right,
- 1:42And it's always any changes in college football are always incremental,
- 1:47it's always subtle, it's always slow. So I do think
- 1:51inevitably the field will grow to what number. I think
- 1:57that will probably change over the years as well. I mean,
- 1:59I think it's fairly instructive to look at scs and
- 2:02see what their structure looks like, and look, it's it's
- 2:05worked at that level for a long time. But I
- 2:07think what people are kind of realizing is that, you know,
- 2:11the playoff is devalued in balls, right, And so I
- 2:14think the more teams you have, the more the more
- 2:17money you can make, the more the you know, just
- 2:21the more included the country can feel in terms of
- 2:24college football. So yeah, I mean that's kind of like
- 2:26a long winded way to kind of answer that, because
- 2:28I just don't think there's any real understanding like what
- 2:31what is going to be the next step? I think
- 2:33we can only look to know that it's going to
- 2:35it's just going to be bigger down the line, and
- 2:36the structure is going to be you know, what it
- 2:38is for a year, and that it's always going to change.
- 2:41Speaker 1: Right.
- 2:42Speaker 3: This is maybe an unfair follow up on that, but
- 2:44do you feel like the whatever is settled upon for
- 2:48an expanded college football playoff? And I think it's going
- 2:51to be sixteen teams, I think it'll be something that
- 2:55favors the already rich getting richer. But does it then
- 2:58affect conference realignment another round of conference realignments, a further
- 3:04step or movement toward the super conference you know, AFC,
- 3:08NFC kind of system that I'm among those who think
- 3:11that's an eventuality that it's coming. Does the decision made
- 3:15on the college football Playoff in the short term effect
- 3:18that in the long term.
- 3:19Speaker 1: In your mind?
- 3:21Speaker 2: Yeah, I don't think so. I think. I mean, I
- 3:22think like you, I think the super conferences are coming regardless.
- 3:26I mean, we're almost there already with just the way
- 3:28that the money looks. How the money looks in the
- 3:31Big ten in the SEC compared to the a SEC
- 3:34in Big twelve, right, so they're certainly already a very
- 3:37clear tiered system. You know. The attempt to get those
- 3:43at large versets for those two conferences felt a little unnecessary, right,
- 3:48Like the kind of the odds or that there would
- 3:50probably you know, like in a sixteen team playoff, there's
- 3:53probably you know, if you're not going to get eight
- 3:56from those two, it's like maybe seven right most years
- 3:58if you just look like a history. So it felt
- 4:00like you didn't need to build in the automatic bursts
- 4:04for the schools that we're probably going to get it anyways,
- 4:07that that just kind of seems silly for me, but
- 4:09it did show that, look, those schools want or those
- 4:11conferences wanted that, so they're thinking in those terms. And
- 4:15so yeah, like I feel like it's fairly instructive about
- 4:20what they want the future of the sport to look like,
- 4:22to be more exclusive, to be you know, place the
- 4:25emphasis on them and create more separation. So yeah, like,
- 4:30is the playoff structure related. I don't necessarily know if
- 4:34they're tied to each other, but I think like you
- 4:36can kind of get a sense in terms of how
- 4:38things are moving, as kind of insight into what the
- 4:41thought process is from the people who have most.
- 4:43Speaker 1: Of the power.
- 4:44Speaker 3: I guess we're a couple of fridays removed now from
- 4:47the judge signing the house versus ncaa settlement into reality
- 4:53and a lot of the question I think a lot
- 4:55of the answers that came from that just generated more
- 4:58questions for me.
- 4:59Speaker 1: I'll art here.
- 5:01Speaker 3: Does does that settlement change the world of college football
- 5:06and college basketball the big revenue giants? Does it change
- 5:09them in any marked way in your opinion?
- 5:13Speaker 2: Yeah, so, I think there's like there's a couple of
- 5:14ways to look at it, Like does it change it
- 5:16from a like fan standpoint, like when you get like
- 5:19when you turn the TV on on Saturday, is it
- 5:21going to look different? Like? Probably not. Right that these
- 5:24were there was already a lot of money invested in
- 5:26these sports, and certainly I think the bigger change was
- 5:29just the nil changes in the last few years. The
- 5:32fact that these kids were able to uh, you know,
- 5:35get paid separately, right, that that was that was allowed.
- 5:38The fact that the schools are now able to pay
- 5:40you know up till you know whatever. It's twenty million
- 5:42dollars distributed over the over the athletic department. I don't
- 5:45think you'll see a big difference as a fan, right, Like,
- 5:50there's some behind the scenes structures that will be different,
- 5:53Like they're gonna have audits in the nlity something that
- 5:56is like incredibly boring to talk about, right, But but
- 5:58as far as like what we see how we consume
- 6:01college football, I think it's gonna be pretty similar to
- 6:03the last couple of years. Like I think for me,
- 6:05it's like the transfer rules and the NIL rules were
- 6:07significantly more impactful in terms of how the sport looks
- 6:11and feels than this than this. The settlement coming off
- 6:14the heels of those that was.
- 6:16Speaker 3: Another thing that caused me to have more questions out
- 6:19of the answer. It's like, yeah, we're gonna have this
- 6:21new body, this new commission that is going to determine
- 6:25whether or not fair market value is being distributed by
- 6:28NIL deals and whether or not they actually make business sense.
- 6:32And so I was like, Okay, so you're going to
- 6:34try to police pay for play through NIL or you're
- 6:37not going to actually have the teeth to do that.
- 6:40I cannot even imagine a system in which you unring
- 6:44the bell, you put the genie back in the bottle,
- 6:46and players that are hearing their you know, high school
- 6:49buddy from two years ago got a million dollars to
- 6:52show up somewhere, are now just going to accept the
- 6:54idea that a school can't give you that until you're
- 6:57actually on campus. Is this new commission going to have
- 7:01any teeth? Are they going to be able to enforce air?
- 7:03Speaker 2: Absolutely not. I mean, it's just it's it's incredibly silly
- 7:06to think that someone's going to be able to assess
- 7:09market value. Market value is whatever someone is willing to
- 7:11pay exact you know, market value is exactly what I
- 7:16just said. And if you're going to tell some you know,
- 7:19no car dealer in Salt Lake City that you know
- 7:21he he doesn't feel like, uh, you know, you're going
- 7:24to tell him how to spend his marketing dial dollars Like,
- 7:27it's just it's so easy to dismiss out of hand,
- 7:30and then like the litigation that will come from that
- 7:33is again to be just ridiculous and frustrating, and we're
- 7:37going to be looking around like asking what do we doing?
- 7:40I mean, but that's in a way that's encapsulated how
- 7:42the NCAA has operated its entire existence, right, Like, they
- 7:45come up with these you know, short sighted solutions for
- 7:50complex problems and and tell everyone that they're they're they're
- 7:54trying to keep the best interest of the sport and
- 7:56the student athletes, right, But that's not the case. That's
- 7:58never been a case. So yeah, some of that stuff,
- 8:03it's a lot of people I'm spending way too much
- 8:06time coming up with solutions that have no we're going
- 8:08to have no real impact on anything.
- 8:11Speaker 3: ESPN College football insider Kyle bonna Gura is our guest
- 8:14here on the Sean O'Connell Show today. Uh, are you
- 8:17buying or selling on the Utah Youths as a championship
- 8:20contender in the Big Twelve this year?
- 8:24Speaker 2: I Mean, here's I think there's there's a lot to that,
- 8:27but like probably not is the easy answer at the
- 8:30kind of off the cuff answer, like after last season
- 8:32when what you saw, like, yeah, there's like they haven't
- 8:34earned the right to be considered a favorite going into
- 8:37this year. But again, like this is a completely new
- 8:40world of college football. Uh, it's so hard now to
- 8:45have a real I mean it was hard before to
- 8:47really predict college football in the preseason now with you know,
- 8:50with so much fluidity, roster fluidity, no one really has
- 8:54a great sense of any of these teams. I mean
- 8:56Arizona State, no one thought that they would be what
- 8:58they were last year. I mean Colorado over. I mean,
- 9:00there's like so many examples now to show that no
- 9:03one knows what they're talking about this time of year,
- 9:05which I think like actually kind of makes it fun, right,
- 9:07Like if you're a bad program, you don't have to
- 9:10check out for a few years. Like you can say,
- 9:12all right, well, like let's let's write this in one
- 9:14offseason and you can be you can allow for the
- 9:18possibility that you're going to be good. So I think, like, yeah, so,
- 9:20like as you taught a preseason paper now, like I
- 9:23don't think so, but like at the same time, like
- 9:25there's enough precedent now to say, hey, but you know,
- 9:28don't rule them out.
- 9:29Speaker 3: Also, yeah, I mean Arizona State was picked dead last
- 9:32last year, ended up winning the conference. BYU was what
- 9:35thirteenth ended up having a great year, And the outlook
- 9:39for BYU was through a lot of the summer and
- 9:42the spring, people are like, oh, yeah, that's them. In
- 9:44Arizona State they're they're bona fide contenders, not the only
- 9:48ones in the Big twelve. But now there's a big
- 9:50question around the quarterback situation there.
- 9:53Speaker 1: What do you think happens?
- 9:56Speaker 2: Yeah, I don't know if I want to touch that one,
- 9:57just because it's such a touchy subject and you know,
- 10:00you just don't know how it's going to play out, right. Look,
- 10:03I mean, if it's unchanged right and if Retzoff comes
- 10:06back as the starter, and you know, and that's that. Look,
- 10:09I think they've got a proven guy who's shown that
- 10:11he can lead a successful program. And if things off
- 10:14the field progressing away where he's not the guy, Yeah,
- 10:16I mean, now you're starting over with a new quarterback
- 10:18without an unproven name, and I don't have any insight
- 10:21to where that's headed or where things are leading there.
- 10:23So I think it's probably best just kind of set
- 10:26those two scenarios aside and just kind of, you know,
- 10:29wait and see what happened.
- 10:30Speaker 1: Yeah, fair enough.
- 10:31Speaker 3: Texas Tech was like the big spender in the Big
- 10:34twelve certainly, and one of the big spenders in free
- 10:38agency because that's what it is in the transfer portal
- 10:40with nil money, and I'm curious, do you think that
- 10:43they have what it takes to turn that into at
- 10:47least the Conference Championship College Football Playoff appearance, because you know,
- 10:52it's great to have the billionaire booster, but you got
- 10:54to have the coaching in place. You got to have
- 10:56a team culture that can absorb, you know, all those
- 11:00mercenaries and turn them into actual, real good team. Do
- 11:04you do you believe that Texas Tech could make that
- 11:07happen after the offseason they had.
- 11:10Speaker 2: Yeah, and I do. I think. I mean, at the
- 11:12end of the day, talent is what Talent is the
- 11:15biggest factor in winning games. All those other things matter
- 11:18continuity coaching for sure, but there's been enough, like there's
- 11:22enough a precedent to show that It's not like it's
- 11:24these are like middle school coaches blessed with a bunch
- 11:27of talent. These are guys who you know, they know
- 11:28what they're doing. So I think, like when things are
- 11:30close with coaching, right, talent's gonna win out. And they
- 11:34just have so much of it now. And it's not
- 11:35like they're spending a couple of million dollars more on
- 11:40building that roster. I mean, this is tens of millions
- 11:42of dollars more right. I mean, look at you know,
- 11:45if you look at a professional salary cap sport, right,
- 11:48it's it's pretty it's pretty clear that the teams that
- 11:52have outside salary pools to work with are generally the
- 11:56most successful. And I don't think there's any reason to
- 11:59believe that that and apply at the college level either.
- 12:02Speaker 3: Yeah, they're deep in Texas texts, deep in the luxury
- 12:04text I think who generates more college football headlines this year?
- 12:11Bill Belichick or Deone Sanders.
- 12:13Speaker 2: Oh, that's a good one. Well, I mean I would
- 12:18have said if there was no off the field stuff
- 12:20in North Carolina, it probably it probably still would have
- 12:23been Deon. But since the introduction of the soap opera
- 12:26in Chapel Hill, like, I feel like he's certainly made
- 12:29a strong offseason to challenge Dion for the throne of
- 12:35most stories unrelated to what's happening on the field. So, yeah,
- 12:39that will be fascinating to see how that plays off.
- 12:43I think the fact that you have the look Bill
- 12:45Belichick's the most successful, you know, NFL coach of all
- 12:48time going to the college level was an incredibly interesting experiment.
- 12:51I'm actually working on the story right now that'll publish
- 12:54next week about Bill Walsh's return to college football in
- 12:58the nineties after overseeing the forty nine ers to see
- 13:00which has been really fascinating to dive into. Actually talk
- 13:04with Tom Holmo about that because he was on the
- 13:06staff with with with Bill Walsh at Stanford. But anyways, yeah,
- 13:10it's it's it's a fascinating experiment. And I think the
- 13:12fact that Dion's been there a few years a little
- 13:14bit of that probably probably has worn off. So in
- 13:16year one with Belichick, uh, he'll He'll get my vote
- 13:19for that.
- 13:19Speaker 3: Do you think Dion has success without, you know, two
- 13:23of the best players in the country on his roster.
- 13:26Speaker 1: I do not.
- 13:27Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean just the so much of what they
- 13:32were was was with Travis Hunter just making play after
- 13:35play and Shador getting up after getting knocked down and
- 13:38making big making big throws down the field. And without
- 13:41those two guys, I mean, look, they're they're better off
- 13:43than they were a couple of years ago before Dion arrived.
- 13:45But yeah, like, I think it's certainly reasonable to expect
- 13:49a pretty significant drop off after losing to two players
- 13:52of that quality. So yeah, I don't think I mean,
- 13:55Colorado is going to be interesting because just Dion has
- 13:57this is this incredible force to to make you know,
- 13:59just that the gravitas that he has is remarkable and
- 14:02love him hate him. Like people are going to be
- 14:04paying attention. But I don't necessarily think that they're going
- 14:07to be as good next this come year.
- 14:10Speaker 1: Kyle.
- 14:10Speaker 3: After working in the in the Pac twelve sphere for
- 14:12as long as I did, I still am not really
- 14:15over the death of that conference and the way that
- 14:17it has changed the landscape of college football, and you know,
- 14:21all those great teams and programs have been scattered to
- 14:23the wind. But I've always been very fascinated with Stanford
- 14:27in particular because you know, I had that year working
- 14:30in the Bay area and got close to some Stanford
- 14:33people and thought it was so strange that the team
- 14:36was so good and didn't have community interest and couldn't
- 14:39sell out a home game, and just was like, it's
- 14:41the weirdest place in college sports. But it was awesome
- 14:45when they were great, And I wonder, do you think
- 14:50will they ever be great at football again at Stanford?
- 14:54Speaker 2: Yeah? I think so. I Mean I think there's because
- 14:58I mean there's a couple of factors here, right, You're
- 15:00always going to like there always is going to have
- 15:03the education component at Stanford, even in the nil eor,
- 15:06I still think has like true a lure to air
- 15:10like it's a world class institution and you're going to
- 15:13have people who value that more than getting you know,
- 15:17a couple you know, you know, ten twenty thousand dollars
- 15:19more than than someone else and they had you know,
- 15:22they have a lot of rich donors, right, and so
- 15:25I don't think like I think at some point you'll
- 15:28have people who are going to be willing to get
- 15:29them competitive in that innile to the point where, look,
- 15:32you can be competitive in the ACC for sure. There's
- 15:36Stanford has always been. There's always been waves of success
- 15:40and then dips and success in dips, and I think
- 15:45that will continue to be the case there. They always
- 15:49seem to attract good quarterbacks. That's you know, going back
- 15:51fifty years. I mean, Jim Plunkett won of the heusband
- 15:54seventy and you've had I feel like a number one
- 15:56overall pick you know every decade since then is what
- 15:59it feels like. But look, I think Andrew Luck's a
- 16:02sharp guy. I mean I had a chance to talk
- 16:04with him a number of times over the years and
- 16:06he's committed to, you know, to the football side of things,
- 16:09and if you if you get the right coach in there,
- 16:11it's still it's still a place that you can win at. Now,
- 16:15if you're asking me if they're going to ever start
- 16:17filling that stadium again, probably not. I mean even when
- 16:20Christian McCaffrey was there, they weren't selling out Stanford Stadium.
- 16:23They're still going to the roads. But winning the Rose Bowl,
- 16:26it's I mean, I grew up here, I live here
- 16:28in the Bay Area, and it's just it's just and
- 16:30you know, from from being here for a year, like
- 16:32it just is not part of the local media landscape
- 16:35when it comes to sports, which makes it really interesting
- 16:38because there is you know, there has been a lot
- 16:40of success over.
- 16:41Speaker 1: The years before I let you go. Will Texas win
- 16:45the SEC Uh?
- 16:48Speaker 2: No, I mean they'll win it someday, but not this year. Yeah,
- 16:52it's another one. I think. I'm I'm I'm very like,
- 16:55this is kind of a top out, But it's just
- 16:57a numbers game, right If I if I'm like, if
- 16:59I'm taking Texas where I'm taking the field, I'm taking
- 17:01the field and that's just the way the way my
- 17:04brain works. Logically, the certainly would be surprised, but there's
- 17:07just so many other teams that have are are right
- 17:10there on part with them talent talent.
- 17:12Speaker 1: Okay, how about this one man.
- 17:13Speaker 3: Does the Big Ten or the SEC emerge from this
- 17:16year with the bragging rights of where the best conference
- 17:19in college football? We crownd the national champion, et cetera.
- 17:22Speaker 2: Yeah, so I think the SEC will still have the
- 17:25we are the best conference thing going for it, because
- 17:27like they're just going to point to depth over the
- 17:30Big Ten. Whoever went like, you know what, who wins
- 17:34the national championship? I think is part of that. Part
- 17:36of that kind of conversation, But is for me is
- 17:38not the Gavendel b All, and it's it's certainly a
- 17:41nice bragging right. So the Big Ten has had and
- 17:43try to kind of take over that mantle. I mean,
- 17:45I'm more interested in Big Ten football, So I would
- 17:47I would hope that the Big Ten kind of steps
- 17:50forward because I think it's better for the sport to have,
- 17:53you know, kind of that that label of best conference
- 17:56move move around a bit, but you know, I think
- 17:58it's probably still the SEC.
- 18:00Speaker 3: Kyle, Thanks for giving us some time today, love your stuff,
- 18:03and we'll get you on again pretty soon before the season.
- 18:06Speaker 1: At least sounds good.
- 18:08Speaker 2: Appreciate.
- 18:09Speaker 3: Kyle Bonnagura ESPN dot com, ESPN College Football Insider writes
- 18:14a bunch of soccer stuff as well