Latest / The Payments Shed / Ep. 18 - LIVE from the MoneyPot with Mastercard @ Money 20/20 USA 2025
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Payment Shed Podcast, the weekly podcast that
- 0:03dives into the big topics, trends and people shaping the
- 0:06world's of payments, fintech and business leadership.
- 0:09Of your two Co hosts, myself Grant Heavens and Justin Hannah
- 0:13Ranjita, please introduce yourself.
- 0:14Tell us about your role in MasterCard.
- 0:16Absolutely. Thank you so much for having me
- 0:17on the podcast. So I run services for North
- 0:21America. And as we were talking before,
- 0:22that's a broad term, but it includes all of our safety and
- 0:26security assets, all of our engagement, digital engagement
- 0:30assets, so our loyalty programs and things like that, and also
- 0:34all of our data analytics assets.
- 0:36So all of the insights that we get from our data.
- 0:38So it's a broad set of capabilities that enhances the
- 0:41value of payments. Brilliant and we really want to
- 0:44dive into cybersecurity with you today and how that kind of
- 0:47threat has evolved specifically payment side, but also with with
- 0:50the schemes at the moment. So I just wanted to get your
- 0:52initial take on how that has changed in recent years.
- 0:56Yeah. So I've been in cybersecurity
- 0:59and fraud for maybe close to two decades now.
- 1:02So it's a long time and I can tell you that there are three
- 1:06major things that have changed over the last several years.
- 1:09I would say 1 is more data and more an expanding threat
- 1:13surface, right? So think about all the data that
- 1:15we produce in a day. And apparently I was reading a
- 1:18recent stat. It's 2.5 quintillion bytes of
- 1:21data that a user that our that the planet is generating every
- 1:25day. And that is 10 to the power of
- 1:2818. In case you wanted to know.
- 1:30It's a lot of data. So it's increasing the threat
- 1:32surface a lot because of a lot of a lot of interactions, a lot
- 1:36of channels, right, digital channels.
- 1:38The number 2 is that now cybercrime is industrialized,
- 1:42right? So it is no longer the guy in
- 1:45the basement or the girl in the basement.
- 1:48The Nigerian Prince has long gone.
- 1:50This is industrialized crime. They're running it like a
- 1:54business. And the third one I would say is
- 1:56technology. So just as much as we're excited
- 1:58about AI and we're excited about all the the great things we can
- 2:01do with it, it's also enabling the the fraudsters, right?
- 2:05So they're using AI to perpetrate attacks at scale,
- 2:09completely automated. So you can get fake sites,
- 2:13millions of them at scale, which, you know, people find it
- 2:16hard to shut them down before, before they can perpetrate
- 2:20fraud. And it's coming from all
- 2:21channels, social platforms, everything.
- 2:23So automation and they're using technologies like deepfakes.
- 2:28So with the technology and the fact that now we have as a
- 2:31service models even in the crime side, so ransomware as a
- 2:35service, fraud as a service that that technology angle they're
- 2:39using it as well for their for their endeavors.
- 2:44So they're they're operating almost like businesses in their
- 2:46own. Right, it's.
- 2:47Pretty interesting topic. I think the the attackers being
- 2:50more organized and using AI in particular.
- 2:53How do you guys try and monitor and get ahead of that as a
- 2:56scheme? Yeah.
- 2:57So we're constantly looking for patterns.
- 3:01So I would say because it's automated and it's AI driven.
- 3:04We have been employing AI for decades actually to monitor
- 3:08transactions, right. So protecting transactions,
- 3:11identifying anomalies, identifying patterns that just
- 3:15don't look quite right. And so you have to kind of use
- 3:18AI to combat AI, right? So, and then on top of that, you
- 3:22also have to think about things like threat intelligence because
- 3:25there's a lot out there that's available on the dark web and
- 3:28other sources, open web, etcetera.
- 3:31Kind of always monitoring that, monitoring at the portfolio
- 3:34level, looking at what kind of malware and what kind of other
- 3:38vulnerabilities are out there that might be impacting our
- 3:40customers and then getting the signals from that and sharing
- 3:45that with the ecosystem, that is what's going to help us to kind
- 3:49of stay ahead of this. Does the sheer volume of data
- 3:51that you guys have at your fingertips help you in that
- 3:54defense? Absolutely, Yeah.
- 3:56The amount of data that we have absolutely helps.
- 3:58But one thing I will caution is to get the signal out of the
- 4:02data is really important, right? So it's like sometimes it can be
- 4:05like fraud can be or cyber attacks can be like looking for
- 4:08a needle in a haystack. So being able to get that right
- 4:11signal requires a lot of machine learning, a lot of artificial
- 4:15intelligence and a lot of scale, right?
- 4:19I would say a lot of compute power at scale is what you need
- 4:23to be able to get that signal from that mass of data, because
- 4:26there's a lot of it out there, to your point.
- 4:28It's a huge game of cut and mouse, right?
- 4:30This is you think you'll get and now the fraud just do something
- 4:32different and you've got to try and kind of capture that.
- 4:34And actually the point is from before is like them running it
- 4:38as an enterprise. Yes, they're running it as an
- 4:40enterprise, but they're not an enterprise like MasterCard.
- 4:43They don't have a brand to protect.
- 4:44They don't have regulatory scrutiny.
- 4:46They don't have any values that they're running by.
- 4:50They can, they can try anything they want, right?
- 4:52So we're up against that too. Yeah.
- 4:55And look, we know MasterCard sits at the global payments
- 4:58ecosystem right in the center of it.
- 5:00How do you approach securing something from security
- 5:04perspective at such a vast level?
- 5:06Yeah, that's a very, very good question.
- 5:09So really, as I said before, we kind of started at the
- 5:12transaction, right? So we've been protecting
- 5:14transactions for decades, hence the the synonymous word of trust
- 5:20with MasterCard, right? So when you swipe your card,
- 5:21you're never thinking about it. So what we have at the
- 5:24transaction layer is real time fraud scoring of every single
- 5:29transaction on the planet in real time using like thousands
- 5:33of signals per transaction. So that's at scale.
- 5:36Then we also have what we call safety net, which is like AI
- 5:40powered blanket over the network, which is able to pick
- 5:43up fraud that's happening at scale anywhere around the
- 5:46planet. If you go to our command center,
- 5:48you'll actually see, you know, fraud is happening in in some
- 5:52market in the Middle East. You'll see that light up and
- 5:55we're constantly monitoring, right.
- 5:56So that's at the transaction level.
- 5:58We then realized that actually fraud at the transaction level
- 6:01because of our own models at the network level, our partners
- 6:05models at the financial institutions that we work with
- 6:08and merchants etcetera. Everyone's getting more
- 6:10sophisticated, which is great. So fraud at the transaction
- 6:13level has actually been going down over the past several
- 6:16years. However it's migrating, right?
- 6:19So it's migrating to the point where somebody is creating an
- 6:21account or somebody is getting a token provisioned on their
- 6:24device. So it's that time of account
- 6:26opening where we have to understand the individual, we
- 6:30have to understand the identity and that's, you know, that next
- 6:34layer of security that we need to apply.
- 6:36So it's about device identity, it's about the person identity.
- 6:41Is this a synthetic identity? Is this a bad device?
- 6:44What are what do we understand about the device from the device
- 6:46footprint? And then you take it even one
- 6:49step further and you think about the cyber ecosystem in which us
- 6:54and our partners are working and we can understand, we can try to
- 6:59understand what are the vulnerabilities in those
- 7:02ecosystems and making sure that we are compensating for those
- 7:06vulnerabilities. And then also the next layer is
- 7:09threat intelligence, which we just acquired recorded future
- 7:13last year, which is a premier player in the threat
- 7:16intelligence space. So it's about the layers, it's
- 7:18about the transaction, it's about the identities and the
- 7:20devices and then the cyber ecosystem as well, because
- 7:23that's where all the breaches are happening, right.
- 7:26So we're having thousands of breaches every year.
- 7:30All those credentials get out there and then it monetizes on
- 7:33the payment network. Right.
- 7:34So MasterCard card do this all on their own, right.
- 7:36It's, it's great what you guys are doing.
- 7:38How do we take this from a MasterCard perspective to a
- 7:41global issue that we can work together and collaborate?
- 7:44Yeah. Collaboration is obviously very,
- 7:46very critical for us. And we collaborate with our
- 7:49merchant partners, we collaborate with our issuers.
- 7:52And I can give you a specific example of how we collaborated
- 7:57just last year. We had the point of interaction,
- 7:59which is our own conference where we bring in a whole bunch
- 8:03of merchants. And one of the things that they
- 8:05said to us was we're really struggling with returns fraud,
- 8:08right? So and it's a $50 billion
- 8:11problem globally. It's a Subs, it's kind of a
- 8:14subset of first party fraud, if you've heard that.
- 8:18And so returns fraud is is kind of part of that.
- 8:20And so they're like, what can we do together as a network plus
- 8:25the merchants to kind of combat this problem?
- 8:28So there are some signals that merchants have that they can
- 8:31share with us and, and we can kind of share that with the
- 8:33issuer because there's a bit of a information asymmetry, right,
- 8:38obviously between the merchants and the issuers and the network
- 8:41is a nice conduit to be able to pass that intelligence along.
- 8:44So this Q4 of this year, we're actually, we're launching a
- 8:49return fraud risk score. Plus we changed some of our
- 8:53rules on the network so that now people can report return fraud
- 8:57because it wasn't an actual reportable fraud type, right?
- 9:01So we made changes there. We're launching the the return
- 9:05fraud score. So not only can merchants send
- 9:08the data, we can send that insight to the issuer.
- 9:11And then the issuer also knows that somebody calls and hold the
- 9:14chance of return on this transaction is really high.
- 9:16They can question the card holder and be like hey.
- 9:20There's advanced AI and the machine learning that can do
- 9:23overarch that as a product. Absolutely.
- 9:26Yes, it does because we are using past behavior to predict
- 9:30whether this could become a return fraud basically, right.
- 9:33So that's what we're doing and we get those signals from our
- 9:36transaction data and from the data that the merchant will
- 9:40share with us. And I guess a follow up question
- 9:42for me on that, because we're talking about agentic commerce a
- 9:45lot of the conference. How does that agentic future?
- 9:48Obviously you've had merchants come and speak to you and
- 9:50they're talking about fraud. But for me, Agentic seems, you
- 9:53know, I work in the famous industry as as most people in
- 9:55the room do today, but that seems like something that could
- 9:59almost be counterintuitive to the the steps forward we've made
- 10:02as far as prevention is concerned.
- 10:03What's what's your thought on that?
- 10:05So Agentic is obviously brand new and every week I feel like
- 10:09there's another new announcement on Agentic, whether it's open AI
- 10:12with Stripe or Google that put out their protocol on Agent pay
- 10:17protocol. So we're working with all of
- 10:19these industry players on Agentic Pay.
- 10:21We have our own Agentic Pay as well, which is based off of our
- 10:25tokenization framework. So you know who the agent is,
- 10:29it's authenticated. So that's, that's the base.
- 10:32Then we also have APIs that will collect the car, the intent of
- 10:36the human. So if we have intent APIs that
- 10:38go around it as well. And then we also have consent
- 10:42APIs that go along with it as well to ensure that the human
- 10:46behind the agent is actually doing that.
- 10:48But to your point, while agentic opens up a lot of exciting use
- 10:53cases, for example, my daughter no longer needs to stay awake
- 10:56till 1:00 AM to buy Taylor Swift tickets.
- 10:59She can just have her agent to do that, right?
- 11:00So which is amazing, but then you start thinking I've been in
- 11:04fraud long enough. So I see all the dark circles
- 11:06and the dark lurking corners and all of that.
- 11:08But the, what is the, the, the liability framework around that,
- 11:13right? What if your agent goes rogue?
- 11:16Who's liable for that transaction?
- 11:17What if your agent gets taken over, right?
- 11:19Like agent takeover, like account takeover, right?
- 11:22Or how do you do know your agent right, like kya?
- 11:26So those are all the concepts that we're working on to make
- 11:29sure that we trust is embedded in agentic payments as well.
- 11:33Because it is coming, it will, it is going to happen.
- 11:36It's going to be happening at scale if it hasn't already
- 11:39started. Right.
- 11:39It always just felt like a bit counterintuitive to me
- 11:41particularly put my European payments on.
- 11:43We've got really familiar in the market with Otps, your one time
- 11:47passcodes, people more used to using those now mandated 3D
- 11:50secure kind of rips up the playbook a little bit on some of
- 11:53these things that we absolutely. Place, absolutely.
- 11:56And if you think about it right now, I was thinking about just
- 11:58sit back and think about all of these things every now and then.
- 12:01But you think about it, you've so far been dealing with a good
- 12:04human and a bad human, but now you're almost in a 2 by 2.
- 12:08So you're like dealing with a good human, bad human, good bot,
- 12:11bad bot, good agent, bad agent, and then you've got this two by
- 12:14two. And each one of those
- 12:16permutations could lead to all sorts of different things.
- 12:18So it has changed the paradigm to your point.
- 12:22And it's something that we're working very closely because we
- 12:25think there's exciting possibilities as long as the
- 12:27right guardrails are in place. I think it's quite interesting.
- 12:30We look at cybersecurity and using AI as a tool, which is
- 12:34fantastic, but it's also a risk because you know that fraudsters
- 12:37are used in cybersecurity AI, right?
- 12:39To do the exact opposite of what we're trying to get them to do
- 12:42in the first place. Exactly.
- 12:43Yeah, should. We talk a little bit then about
- 12:46collective resilience as well, because I know that's something
- 12:48that you're you're quite passionate about and I'd love to
- 12:50get your take on, you know, the collaboration that's going on
- 12:53between banks, fintechs, governments and merchants in
- 12:55that space at the moment. Yeah, absolutely.
- 12:58One example that can bring it to life is scams, right.
- 13:01So scams is something where many times it's authorized push
- 13:07payment, right is what's resulting in, in the scam.
- 13:11And there's a lot involved in that.
- 13:13And this is 1 specifically where when you talk about scams,
- 13:18governments, other entities are very involved.
- 13:22And there are there are associations like the Global
- 13:25Anti Scam Alliance, which is I think a great organization where
- 13:29part of it along with several of our peers as well.
- 13:32And it is an area that really does require a lot of
- 13:35collaboration because many times the person that's actually
- 13:38scammed is embarrassed about it, right?
- 13:41Like they, they're like, oh, how did that happen to me?
- 13:44And many times they don't even report it because they don't
- 13:47know what the recourse is. They don't know how to even go
- 13:50about getting their money back or what they can even do knowing
- 13:53that they might have been scammed on an investment scam or
- 13:56could have been a romance scam or any other type of scam,
- 13:59right? So that is a perfect area for
- 14:03people to collaborate and governments, nations, we're
- 14:08collaborating where the networks are collaborating as well and
- 14:12the financial institutions. Now I know in the UK this has
- 14:16been a big thing and there is kind of like a split liability.
- 14:19So we're kind of monitoring how that works.
- 14:22We don't have that here in the US, but sometimes things like
- 14:26that can actually help to fuel innovation and fuel
- 14:29collaboration, which is really critical.
- 14:32For many years we've been talking about, you know, sharing
- 14:35of consortium data. And while there are several
- 14:39examples of things, I think more needs to be done there to be
- 14:43honest. It's not an all right way with
- 14:45data sharing sometimes as well. I mean, we have GDPR in in the
- 14:47UK and there's this question mark, I guess your government
- 14:50organization and you know, again, we're very precious about
- 14:53the data that sits within there there ecosystem.
- 14:55So you like leaning into how we best collaborate in a fair and
- 14:59trustworthy way, but also not breaching those policies that we
- 15:02have internally. Correct.
- 15:03Exactly. I think everyone gets very kind
- 15:08of, you know, a little bit uncomfortable when you talk
- 15:10about sharing data. But again, let's keep in mind,
- 15:13and I think there are many, I know of many consortiums where,
- 15:16you know, data is being shared at that consortium level and
- 15:19it's, it's useful, but I think part of the problem is there are
- 15:22many, right? So it still creates these silos
- 15:25of data and things like that, which which isn't helpful.
- 15:27Ultimately, at the end of the day, I think we really need a
- 15:30step change in the way that data is shared because the criminal
- 15:36rings, they're sharing, right? So we can't, we have to be
- 15:40sharing in order to be able to combat them.
- 15:42And I think we will get to a point where that will be the way
- 15:47that we will need to get better. Because if, if something is
- 15:50happening in one particular financial institution or
- 15:53multiple, chances are it's going to, it's going to spread, right?
- 15:57So the sooner we have that data and we have that information and
- 16:00the sooner we can put defenses in place, the better because
- 16:03we're all fighting against common enemy at that point.
- 16:07And I think the piece there as well is when we talk about the
- 16:09data, it's different businesses within that ecosystem need
- 16:12different pieces of that data, right?
- 16:14So sometimes you're taking all this data and consuming that,
- 16:16but you don't need all of that. So you're trying to kind of
- 16:19decipher 3, what you do need from the data to make a decision
- 16:22within your own engine. And how does then mask and then
- 16:25share them best practices do you think with the wider ecosystem?
- 16:28Yeah. So we are always participating
- 16:31in, in many different forums. We, we participate at the
- 16:35industry level to set protocols like for example, Agent pay, you
- 16:39brought that up before. Like I said, there's a lot to be
- 16:42worked out with agent pay and we are on at least 10-15 different
- 16:47like industry forums and working directly with partners like
- 16:50Google and Microsoft and others that are heavily focused in
- 16:54that. So that's from a standard
- 16:56setting perspective, because obviously we have a large
- 16:58franchise and we have rules around how this works.
- 17:02And we also work with another entity called EMV Code to set
- 17:04the standards. Then when it comes to actually
- 17:07developing solutions, we work very closely with our merchant
- 17:10partners, our small businesses, because small businesses are
- 17:14many times left out or they're very underserved, right?
- 17:17Yet they are the backbone of most economies around the world.
- 17:21So we need more. Inclusive tools, you think?
- 17:23Many more inclusive tools and being able to whatever data
- 17:27insights that we get and we're sharing, making sure that that's
- 17:30actually helping them so that they're not left behind in this
- 17:33game, right? So that's the other piece of it.
- 17:35And then we also participate in several consortia as well to
- 17:40kind of share best practices and data.
- 17:43So looking ahead, what do you think comes next when it comes
- 17:46to cyber resilience? Kind of what's the next phase?
- 17:50Good question. This is the crystal ball
- 17:52question. So I think Agentic we're,
- 17:57despite the fact that we're talking about AI and Agentic all
- 18:00the time, I feel like just being in this industry, we're still
- 18:04very, very early on in this whole journey with Agentic.
- 18:10So I think there's a lot more to come there to the point where
- 18:13it's scaled and being used by consumers at scale.
- 18:16I think there's a lot more to be done for that to happen.
- 18:19Yes, today we're using it just to get some recommendations and
- 18:22stuff. But like at the point where it's
- 18:25autonomously buying for you or doing tasks for you, I think
- 18:29we're still getting there. So that's, I think 1 trend that
- 18:32you will see a lot of advancement in the next couple
- 18:35of years. The other one that I think
- 18:38you'll see a lot of is probably a lot of advancements around
- 18:41quantum resistant because we know quantum is coming.
- 18:45It's the next kind of frontier. They've been saying that for a
- 18:48while, but now I'm starting to see a lot more happening there.
- 18:51And I'm also starting to see a lot of startups and other
- 18:54companies kind of focused on quantum resistant technology,
- 18:57which is good. And then I think we'll also end
- 18:59up seeing a lot more from a cyber perspective, particularly
- 19:04a lot more innovation in the zero trust architectures, right.
- 19:08So those are you, I think we'll see start seeing a lot more
- 19:12innovations there as well. And all of those things are good
- 19:15for cyber. If you were then to pull out one
- 19:20high level, you'll you'll go to tip for all organizations out
- 19:24there as far as protecting themselves, what would that be?
- 19:28I think you need to invest in very sophisticated AI if you
- 19:32haven't done so already. We know a lot of companies and a
- 19:34lot of institutions are doing that.
- 19:36But you need to continue to invest because think about
- 19:38Agentic, right? It could change the paradigm and
- 19:41shift everything. Cuz all this time we kept saying
- 19:44bots are bad, right? Because they were the bad bots.
- 19:47But now I could have a perfectly good bot trying to buy Taylor
- 19:51Swift ticket for my daughter. You don't want to, you don't
- 19:54want to shy that bot away, right?
- 19:55Because you want, it's going to drive business.
- 19:57So I think those types of paradigm shifts are going to
- 20:00happen. So you're going to have to get
- 20:02ready for that. So just because you've invested
- 20:04in AI doesn't mean you can just kind of sit on the laurels.
- 20:07You need to continue to evolve as the kind of ecosystem.
- 20:10Market though, isn't it? I mean, it's great advice, but
- 20:12at the same time it's, it's just so much, so many brands, so many
- 20:16startup companies, you know, even SMB are getting hammered
- 20:19every single day with come use our AI for this, come use our AI
- 20:22for that. How do you kind of cut through
- 20:23the noise? Yeah, it's a good question.
- 20:26I think one of the things that you have to focus on as a
- 20:29company is focus on your key strategic value that you're
- 20:33providing your customers. If that can be enhanced by AI
- 20:37and you determine how that can be enhanced by AI, go for it.
- 20:40Invest in it. Build the infrastructure to
- 20:42measure the success of that investment from the ground up.
- 20:45Build the infrastructure to be able to scale that from the
- 20:48ground up and build the security infrastructure and the
- 20:52governance around it to be able to monitor that as well from the
- 20:56ground up. I think if you did that, you
- 20:58know you'd be in a good. Spot and other than your
- 21:00daughter going to watch Taylor Swift, what excites you the most
- 21:04of the next couple of years of the future?
- 21:08I think the the potential with AI and agents is amazing.
- 21:12It's going to change the way things I think we operate, how
- 21:16we work, potentially even in the workplace.
- 21:19I think that's quite exciting. We can, I can see a future where
- 21:22as managers, we're managing a workforce of agents and humans
- 21:27with the, with the thought of, you know, the agents augmenting
- 21:31the human workforce, right? Yeah.
- 21:33Because there's a there's a very big human element here that we
- 21:36cannot forget. But I think that it opens up a
- 21:38lot of exciting possibilities as.
- 21:39Well, Sky, that's here, it's creeping in, isn't it?
- 21:41But thank you so much for joining us today.
- 21:43We have got one final section. I'm not sure if you've watched
- 21:45our show in the past, but we have an end item called the
- 21:48Shelf of Shame where I guess nominates something that call it
- 21:51a payments ick or a business ick if you like.
- 21:54It really grinds your gears that you can nominate to put on the
- 21:56Shelf of Shame, never to return again.
- 22:00As much as I hate to say it, passwords are still used and I
- 22:04know my parents use them and I know many people use them and
- 22:08we've been talking about for decades we have to kill
- 22:10passwords. But we haven't done it yet and I
- 22:13would love to see a world where there's literally no password.
- 22:16I just looked on informationisbeautiful.com.
- 22:19I don't know if you've seen that website, but password 12345 is
- 22:23still the most prevalent password.
- 22:25Which blows my mind after two decades in security.
- 22:28But. Has everyone in this room got a
- 22:30question mark or an exclamation mark in a lot of their passwords
- 22:33as well for being honest? I don't think we have a choice
- 22:35anymore, right? You've got to be in the most
- 22:37obscure kind of password, so you forget it most of the time
- 22:40anyway. So you're hoping your safety can
- 22:42save you every time, right? So let's just get rid of it all
- 22:44together. It makes life a little bit
- 22:46easier. We don't need 100%.
- 22:48I agree going into the shuttle show.
- 22:49Never to return well. Thank you so much for joining us
- 22:51today. Where can people get in touch
- 22:53with you if they want to find out more about what you do at
- 22:54MasterCard? They can e-mail me at
- 22:57ranjitaranjita.iriyer@mastercard.com. Amazing.
- 23:02Thank you so much, Ranjita. Thank you.