Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Paul Tudor Jones Predicts 2027 Market Crash
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine a billionaire investor like looking you right in the
- 0:03eye and telling you the stock market is primed for this
- 0:06massive, unstoppable short term rally.
- 0:10Right, which sounds great, obviously.
- 0:11Yeah, it sounds amazing, but then in the exact same breath,
- 0:15he warns you that the year 2027 is going to be a severe
- 0:20financial disaster. Like a total hurricane.
- 0:23Exactly. Well, welcome to the deep dive.
- 0:25Today, our mission is to decode these incredibly paradoxical
- 0:30warnings from legendary investor Paul Tudor Jones.
- 0:32Yeah, we're pulling this from a recent exclusive interview he
- 0:35gave and we really want to figure out what it all means for
- 0:38you, the listener and you know, your portfolio.
- 0:41OK, let's unpack this because the core tension here is just
- 0:45wild to me. Bright skies today, but a
- 0:48financial hurricane just a few years down the road.
- 0:50It is wild, yeah. And to understand how a mind
- 0:54like Paul Tudor Jones arrives at 2 completely different
- 0:57destinations, we actually have to look at where this
- 0:59conversation took place. Wait, the setting actually
- 1:01matters here? It sets the stage for his entire
- 1:03world view. I mean, they weren't sitting on
- 1:05a trading floor staring at Bloomberg terminals.
- 1:07They were in midtown Manhattan in.
- 1:09A place called Good Shepherd Services, right?
- 1:11Exactly. It's this nonprofit organization
- 1:13that serves about 30,000 kids in New York City, and they're a
- 1:17major beneficiary of the Robin Hood Foundation, which Paul
- 1:20Tudor Jones actually founded. The human element he brought
- 1:23into this interview was genuinely touching, like he
- 1:26started talking about the people running Good Shepherd.
- 1:28Yeah, specifically Sister Paulette, right?
- 1:31Right, Sister Paulette, who used to run the organization.
- 1:34He described her as, you know, the kind of person you meet and
- 1:36just instantly want to hug. Like the most brilliant, loving
- 1:38human being, yeah. And even though she is
- 1:41supposedly retired, she's still showing up to work.
- 1:44She's still bringing in new ideas and literally plays catch
- 1:47with Mitch Mitchell, the new head of the organization.
- 1:50I love that detail and it reveals a core philosophy that
- 1:53drives everything he does honestly.
- 1:55How so? Well, the Robin Hood Foundation
- 1:57and Good Shepherd, they share this fundamental belief that a
- 2:00child circumstance does not determine their future.
- 2:03You know you can intervene. You can completely change the
- 2:06trajectory. Exactly.
- 2:07And that belief in shifting trajectories, it's just a
- 2:10perfect lens for how he views the stock market right now
- 2:13because he's looking at a trajectory most people operating
- 2:15in finance today have entirely forgotten.
- 2:18Yeah, he made an observation about today's market that is
- 2:21honestly a little terrifying. Oh, for sure.
- 2:23He said looking at the market today feels identical to 1999
- 2:27the.com bubble. That is a very heavy comparison.
- 2:30It really is. I mean, 1999 was characterized
- 2:33by extreme euphoria, a complete detachment from any traditional
- 2:36valuation metrics, and just this total obsession with a single
- 2:40new technology. Right.
- 2:41Which back then was the Internet, Yeah.
- 2:44And what makes that comparison so dangerous is how few people
- 2:47managing money today actually remember what that euphoria felt
- 2:50like before the crash. It's true, he sure this reality
- 2:53check from a conference he attended just a week prior to
- 2:56this interview, there were about 200 finance professionals in the
- 2:59room. And you asked him for a show of
- 3:01hands, right? Yeah, he asked.
- 3:02How many of you here were actually trading in 1999?
- 3:06And the interviewer guessed maybe 10% of the room, but it
- 3:08was actually about 20%. Which means 80% of the people
- 3:12moving billions of dollars around today have absolutely
- 3:15zero muscle memory of the 1999 cycle.
- 3:17None at all. They haven't lived through a
- 3:19bubble inflating and bursting. No, even the interviewer
- 3:22admitted that in 99 he was just graduating college and, you
- 3:25know, covering mergers and acquisitions as a journalist.
- 3:27He wasn't actively trading the boom in the subsequent bust.
- 3:31That lack of lived experience matters immensely, especially
- 3:34because of what Paul Tudor Jones calls the 2 speed economy.
- 3:37Right, because in 1999 the market fractured.
- 3:39You had Internet and telecom stocks rocketing to the moon,
- 3:42while old economy stocks, you know, the company's making
- 3:45physical goods, they just sat there or actively declined.
- 3:48And he sees the exact same perfect bifurcation happening
- 3:51right now. Exactly.
- 3:53But instead of the Internet, the dividing line is artificial
- 3:55intelligence. It's almost like a train
- 3:57splitting onto 2 tracks. You've got the AI companies on
- 4:00this sleek magnetic levitation bullet train, and everyone else
- 4:04is stuck in a rusty hand car. That's a great way to put it.
- 4:08And as an investor, your returns depend entirely on which track
- 4:11you happen to be standing on. Yeah.
- 4:13And the broader indices like the S&P 500, they mask this reality
- 4:16because they're weighted by the massive size of those few AI
- 4:20driven tech companies. So the market isn't moving as a
- 4:23cohesive unit anymore? Not at all.
- 4:25It's pulling itself apart based entirely on AI adoption and
- 4:28hype. Which, you know, actually
- 4:30reminds me of those tools a lot of modern investors are using to
- 4:33navigate this kind of extreme hype.
- 4:35Oh, right, because figuring out what's real versus what's just a
- 4:37bubble is the hardest part. Exactly like if you're trying to
- 4:41figure out if the whole market is overpriced right now, there
- 4:44are these apps like the Buffett Indicator on iOS or Bubble Watch
- 4:48if you're on Android. Yeah, those are super useful
- 4:50gauges for this exact kind of environment.
- 4:52They really are, and for specific stocks there is the
- 4:55Deep Values app on iOS for checking Buffett style intrinsic
- 4:59value. Plus their full research
- 5:01platform at Deep values dot AI actually uses a multi agent AI
- 5:05analyst to run deep value intelligence.
- 5:08Which is ironic, right? Using AI to analyze the AI
- 5:11bubble. Right, But you need that level
- 5:13of insight when you're looking at A2 speed economy, because
- 5:17here is where the historical context of 1999 makes things so
- 5:21incredibly tricky. Yeah, the interviewer pointed
- 5:23out that even after the initial mainstream boom of 1999, the
- 5:26market still ran up another 40% before it finally capitulated
- 5:31and crashed. Another 40%.
- 5:33So the billion dollar question is whether we are at the Crest
- 5:36of this AI wave right now or if we still have years of massive
- 5:40runway left. And Paul Tudor Jones actually
- 5:43admits it is incredibly hard for him professionally to see much
- 5:47beyond December 31st of the current year.
- 5:49I mean, hedge funds live and die by their annual performance.
- 5:52Exactly. So his immediate tactical focus
- 5:54is just navigating through the end of this year and tactically
- 5:57he is very optimistic about the fourth quarter.
- 6:00Interesting. Why the fourth quarter
- 6:02specifically? He looks heavily at midterm
- 6:05election cycles. Historically, markets tend to
- 6:08bottom out sometime in late October or early November during
- 6:11a midterm year. Oh, because markets just hate
- 6:14uncertainty. Right.
- 6:16Once those elections are resolved, regardless of who
- 6:18actually wins, the political uncertainty clears up.
- 6:20So the capital that was sitting on the sidelines just waiting to
- 6:24see what happens usually deploys back into the market.
- 6:26Yeah, driving prices up in that Q4 window.
- 6:29He looks at current market positioning and believes that
- 6:31strong finish is highly probable.
- 6:33OK, here's where it gets really interesting for me.
- 6:35Let's hear it. If historical trends in midterm
- 6:38cycles are pointing toward a strong finish and we might still
- 6:41have a 40% runway left just like in the late 90s, why skip ahead
- 6:45to 2027 to panic? That's a fair question.
- 6:48Right, like why not just ride the wave and enjoy the returns
- 6:51for the next few years? The answer lies in the
- 6:53underlying mechanics of the market itself.
- 6:56To grasp why 2027 is his danger zone, we have to talk about a
- 6:59concept called flows. Flows.
- 7:02I hear that thrown around a lot on financial networks.
- 7:05Yeah, it's the single metric Paul Tudor Jones watches more
- 7:07closely than anything else in the financial world.
- 7:10But what does that actually mean for the money sitting in a
- 7:13regular person's retirement account?
- 7:15Like for you listening right now?
- 7:18Think of the overall stock market as a giant swimming pool
- 7:21of capital. The water level, which
- 7:23represents the overall price of the market, is determined by
- 7:26what is flowing into the pool versus what is draining out of
- 7:29it. OK, I can picture that hoses and
- 7:31drains. Exactly so.
- 7:33Since the depths of the 2009 financial crisis, this pool has
- 7:36been artificially filled by incredibly strong, positive
- 7:41corporate support. So the hose is running full
- 7:43blast. Right.
- 7:44And the two main hoses pumping water into the pool have been
- 7:47corporate stock buybacks and mergers and acquisitions.
- 7:51OK, let's break that down. When a company buys back its own
- 7:54stock, it is literally going into the open market and
- 7:57purchasing its own shares, right?
- 7:59So taking them out of circulation, correct?
- 8:01That reduces the overall supply of shares available.
- 8:04So if demand stays exactly the same but supply shrinks, the
- 8:07price of the remaining shares is naturally forced up.
- 8:10Yep, it's just basic economics. And M&A does something similar.
- 8:13When one company buys another at a premium, it injects cash into
- 8:17the hands of shareholders. 2 then usually turn around and
- 8:19reinvest it right back into the market.
- 8:21Exactly. So that's your positive flow,
- 8:23but you have to subtract the negative flows.
- 8:25The drains at the bottom of the pool.
- 8:27Yeah, the drains. These are initial public
- 8:29offerings, secondary stock offerings, and stock unlocks.
- 8:33Oh, OK. Because an IPO or a secondary
- 8:36offering creates millions of brand new shares out of thin air
- 8:38and dumps them onto the market. Right.
- 8:40And stock unlocks happen when early insiders and venture
- 8:43capitalists are finally legally allowed to sell their massive
- 8:46hoards of stock. So all of these events dump
- 8:49massive amounts of new supply onto the market.
- 8:52Exactly, which requires capital to be sucked out of the pool
- 8:54just to absorb it all. OK.
- 8:56So the math is essentially taking all the buybacks in M&A
- 9:00and subtracting all the IP, OS, secondaries and insider selling.
- 9:03You got it. And the result of that math
- 9:05right now is alarming. Paul Tudor Jones warns that we
- 9:09are currently looking at the most negative flow picture for
- 9:12the US stock market since 2002. Wait since 2002.
- 9:16So the drain is suddenly opening up much wider than the hose
- 9:19filling the pool. It is the underlying corporate
- 9:22support that has propped up the market year in and year out for
- 9:26over a decade is fundamentally shifting.
- 9:28That's a massive shift. Did he say what's causing it?
- 9:31Yeah, he pointed to some very specific massive entities that
- 9:35are causing this. He mentioned a $2 trillion
- 9:38valuation for SpaceX, plus the coming public offerings or
- 9:41massive capital raises from AI giants like Open AI and
- 9:45Anthropic. Oh wow.
- 9:47Yeah, he specifically noted Anthropic has a major liquidity
- 9:49event likely coming in November. Think about that.
- 9:52When a $2 trillion behemoth like SpaceX eventually goes public,
- 9:57or when open AI needs hundreds of billions of dollars just to
- 10:00build out their massive server farms, That capital has to come
- 10:03from somewhere. It doesn't just materialize out
- 10:05of thin air, right? It's like dropping a giant
- 10:08sponge into the swimming pool. These massive tech and space
- 10:11entities are going to soak up all the liquidity, all the
- 10:14everyday capital that used to slosh around and prop up the
- 10:17broader stock market. Exactly.
- 10:19By the time we hit 2027, the rest of the market could be
- 10:22dangerously dry because all the money has been sucked into a few
- 10:25massive AI and aerospace vacuums.
- 10:27That is a terrifying picture. That structural risk is exactly
- 10:31what he is identifying. The math of supply and demand is
- 10:34shifting out of the market's favor.
- 10:37So it becomes incredibly difficult for the broader market
- 10:40to sustain its current price levels when these massive
- 10:43capital vacuums turn on and start pulling money away from
- 10:45everything else. Precisely.
- 10:47Which brings up a huge issue for anyone managing their own
- 10:50investments. If we were in a bifurcated 1999
- 10:54style bubble and these massive companies are about to suck the
- 10:57liquidity out of the room, you have to look really closely at
- 11:00the valuations of the AI companies themselves.
- 11:03You really do. I mean even if they are soaking
- 11:06up all the capital, are those massive trillion dollar
- 11:08valuations actually safe? Well, Paul Tudor Jones is
- 11:12extremely cautious about this. He specifically warns about the
- 11:15severe risk of multiple compression in the tech and AI
- 11:18space. OK, multiple compression.
- 11:20Let's ground that concept for a second.
- 11:22Think of multiple compression like buying a neighborhood
- 11:24lemonade stand. OK, I'm with you.
- 11:26Let's say last month people were so hyped about the future of
- 11:29lemonade that they were willing to pay $100 to buy a stand that
- 11:33only makes $10 a year in profit. So they were paying a multiple
- 11:36of 10. Right, But today the hype cools
- 11:39off. The stand still makes $10 a
- 11:41year. The earnings haven't changed at
- 11:43all, but now people are only willing to pay $50.00 for the
- 11:46whole business. The underlying business is
- 11:49exactly the same, but the stock price drops simply because of
- 11:51the enthusiasm. The multiple shrink.
- 11:54Exactly. So what would cause that
- 11:56enthusiasm to shrink for these AI companies?
- 11:59Two primary factors could trigger that exact compression
- 12:02for these AI darlings. First, general concerns about AI
- 12:05safety, and 2nd, very specific rhetoric coming out of the
- 12:08current administration. OK.
- 12:10And just to be clear, we are looking at this strictly as
- 12:13impartial market analysts reporting on the factors moving
- 12:15the market. Right, Absolutely.
- 12:17We're just reporting what was said.
- 12:19The administration has signalled clearly that AI companies will
- 12:22be held legally and financially responsible if their platforms
- 12:25make a mistake or cause harm. So if your product causes
- 12:28damage, you are on the hook. Exactly.
- 12:31And Paul Tudor Jones paints A terrifyingly stark scenario
- 12:34regarding that liability. He calls it the doughnut
- 12:37scenario. The doughnut scenario going to a
- 12:39doughnut, meaning the valuation goes to 0.
- 12:42Right, zero. He points out that an AI company
- 12:44can have spectacular earnings, incredible subscription revenue
- 12:47streams, and the most amazing growth projections in the
- 12:50history of capitalism. Yeah, everything looks perfect
- 12:53on paper. But if we wake up one single day
- 12:56and an AI model has gone rogue, or a bad actor is used it
- 13:00maliciously to execute a massive cyber attack or cause real world
- 13:05physical damage, that company's valuation goes to a doughnut.
- 13:09Instantly, the liability would wipe out the entire market cap
- 13:12overnight. The downside risk is just
- 13:14absolute. It makes investing in these
- 13:16foundational AI models incredibly fragile.
- 13:19You know, because you're exposed to an extinction level event
- 13:21that you cannot possibly predict or build a financial model for,
- 13:25right? The models don't account for
- 13:27going to 0 overnight, but. Wait a minute, looking at the
- 13:30source material, isn't he being completely hypocritical here?
- 13:33How do you mean? Well, he is ringing the alarm
- 13:36bells about AI going rogue and valuations going to 0, but he
- 13:40explicitly states that his own firm runs three internal
- 13:43quantitative trading teams plus a separate sports analytics
- 13:46business. That's true.
- 13:48And they have been using neural networks and forms of AI, quote
- 13:51UN quote, forever. So how can he warn the public
- 13:55about a technology that he actively uses every single day
- 13:58to make billions of dollars? What's fascinating here is that
- 14:01his fear doesn't come from a place of ignorance.
- 14:04It comes directly from his intimate experience with the
- 14:06technology. Oh interesting, So it isn't
- 14:09hypocrisy. No, not at all.
- 14:11It is a first hand operational respect for the danger.
- 14:15But how does using the technology every day make him
- 14:17fear it more? It comes down to what the
- 14:19computer science world calls the Y problem or the black box
- 14:23problem of neural networks. The black box.
- 14:26Yeah, when his quant teams feed market data into these advanced
- 14:30AI models to figure out what to trade, there are billions,
- 14:33sometimes trillions, of permutations and calculations
- 14:36happening across the hidden layers of the network.
- 14:39So the machine takes in the historical data, does a trillion
- 14:42invisible things to it, and spits out a final answer.
- 14:46Right, it says buy the stock or for his sports business, draft
- 14:50this player. And you just have to trust it.
- 14:54Well, you get the output. You know what the AI decided.
- 14:59But, and this is the terrifying part that Paul Tudor Jones
- 15:02highlighted, you have absolutely no idea why or how the AI
- 15:06arrived at that answer. That is wild.
- 15:09The mechanics of the decision making process are entirely
- 15:12opaque, even to the very engineers who built and trained
- 15:15the model. So it's not like traditional
- 15:17software where a programmer can trace the code and say oh on
- 15:20line 42 we told the computer that if X happens then do Y and
- 15:24there was a bug on line 42. Exactly.
- 15:27This is completely non linear. A neural network adjust its own
- 15:30internal weights autonomously. It's teaching itself.
- 15:34Yes, it creates its own logic pathways across billions of
- 15:37nodes to find a pattern. Human comprehension is literally
- 15:40left behind by the math. Which means if you don't know
- 15:43how a machine is making its decisions, you cannot
- 15:46confidently debug it. And more importantly, you cannot
- 15:49predict when it will make a catastrophic error.
- 15:52Wow. That is why AI safety is his
- 15:54ultimate concern. Yeah, it's a daily operational
- 15:57reality for him when his machines are trading massive
- 15:59amounts of capital based on logic no human can read.
- 16:02So what does this all mean? We started this deep dive trying
- 16:06to reconcile a sunny short term forecast with a hurricane
- 16:10warning for 2020. Seven, right.
- 16:12And I think what we're looking at is a market landscape defined
- 16:15by extreme duality. The two speed economy.
- 16:18Exactly. We have a bifurcated market that
- 16:20perfectly mirrors the setup of 1999.
- 16:23In the short term, looking toward the end of the year,
- 16:25historical midterm cycles and the clearing of political
- 16:27uncertainty suggest a strong optimistic push is very much on
- 16:31the table. But beneath that optimistic
- 16:33surface, the actual mechanics of market liquidity are breaking
- 16:37down. Yes, by the time we look toward
- 16:392027, the market faces a severe structural liquidity drain.
- 16:44The giant sponge. Right, The math of market flows
- 16:46is turning incredibly negative. Giants like SpaceX, Open AI and
- 16:50Anthropic are preparing to soak up the capital that has
- 16:53historically propped up the broader market, basically
- 16:56draining the pool for everyone else.
- 16:58And all of this, the multiple trillion dollar valuations, the
- 17:03future of the economy, the massive shift to market flows is
- 17:07resting squarely on the shoulders of an AI technology
- 17:09that is fundamentally unexplainable.
- 17:12It's a technological foundation where we are happy to accept the
- 17:15output but remain completely blind to the mechanics of how it
- 17:19actually works. Which leaves us with a final
- 17:21thought for you to Mull over is you navigate this 2 speed
- 17:24economy. We are building the future of
- 17:27global finance on a black box. We really are.
- 17:31If the brightest financial minds, the most sophisticated
- 17:34hedge funds, and the most advanced neural networks in the
- 17:37world are making trillion dollar decisions without actually
- 17:40understanding how the models arrived to their conclusions,
- 17:43are we truly investing in a new technological era?
- 17:46Or are we simply surrendering the steering wheel to a machine
- 17:49we don't fully comprehend, just hoping it knows the way?
- 17:53That is the defining question every investor's going to have
- 17:55to answer for themselves over the next few years.
- 17:58And on that note, we want to thank you so much for joining us
- 18:00on this deep dive. Keep questioning the consensus,
- 18:03keep looking at the underlying mechanics, and we will catch you
- 18:07next time.