Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / When A Guest Won’t Leave
Transcript
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: Well, it's complicated.
- 0:30Michael Mulligan: Uh and it uh in fact the particular complication that the uh judge was uh sorting out in the case we're gonna talk about uh is a complication that arose out of an effort at simplification, if you can believe it.
- 0:44Michael Mulligan: Uh and what happened is this it's back prior to uh 2011, we had various sections in the criminal code that dealt with self-defense, but they were complicated and often difficult to explain to, for example, juries, right?
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: Which is what this case involves, a judge having to give instructions to a jury.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: Uh and so in 2011, uh Parliament kind of redid the self-defense provisions, trying to make them sort of more coherent and easier to explain.
- 1:13Michael Mulligan: And one of the things that got uh changed were the provisions dealing with the defense of property, that's section thirty-five in the criminal code.
- 1:23Michael Mulligan: And we we have to have that section, or the reason we have that section is an assault as a starting point would include any nonconsensual application of force to another person, right?
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: And so if you didn't have the provisions dealing with defense of property, uh you would wind up committing an assault if, for example, you tried to physically stop somebody from stealing something from you, or uh you came across somebody who was busily damaging your property and you tried to stop them from doing that, right?
- 1:51Michael Mulligan: Um and uh th that provision, section thirty-five, provides uh that it's not an offense if somebody's using reasonable force to stop those kinds of things happening.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: But that section also deals with the issue of defense of property in the context of like keeping somebody out of your house or getting somebody out of your bar or whatever it might be, right?
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: Um without this, you could have a circumstance where somebody just said, Hey, guess what?
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: I'm coming on into your living room, right?
- 2:19Michael Mulligan: Well, hold on, can't have that.
- 2:22Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 2:22Michael Mulligan: And so the this section, this changed section, the issue uh arose because of the wording that uh Parliament used when it was describing when it was a person could use reasonable force for the purpose of, you know, getting somebody out of there, fill in the blank, house, bar, restaurant, whatever it might be.
- 2:43Michael Mulligan: And the language they use is this it says another person who is about to enter, is entering, or has entered the property without being entitled by law to do so.
- 2:55Michael Mulligan: And so when you read that quickly, you sort of think, oh yeah, okay, that that seems to cover what we're talking about here, right?
- 3:01Michael Mulligan: But the problem is, what about a person who originally was permitted in, like a person's allowed to come into the bar and sit down and start drinking?
- 3:10Michael Mulligan: What happens when they get extremely drunk and rowdy and are disturbing other people, they won't stop and they're asked to leave, and they won't leave?
- 3:17Michael Mulligan: Can they just stay there forever?
- 3:19Michael Mulligan: Because when you look at the section, is it as about to enter, well that doesn't count, they're already in there, is entering, well that's not it either.
- 3:26Michael Mulligan: They're they're they've already entered, they've been drinking for the last three hours.
- 3:30Michael Mulligan: Or has entered the property without being entitled by law to do so.
- 3:33Michael Mulligan: Well, no, they were entitled to come in to begin with.
- 3:36Michael Mulligan: So does that mean once you're in, you're just in?
- 3:38Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 3:39Michael Mulligan: And that's what was being dealt with in this particular case.
- 3:42Michael Mulligan: And the fact pattern is is this.
- 3:44Michael Mulligan: It's an interesting one, uh, and probably not that uncommon.
- 3:47Michael Mulligan: Um it was a case where a fellow of the accused, the homeowner, had a number of people over for a social event, including his brother.
- 3:55Michael Mulligan: And the brother came into the was into the house in the house for some period of time, and then uh for whatever reason the uh homeowner had asked the brother to leave.
- 4:04Michael Mulligan: Maybe some disruption, who knows?
- 4:07Michael Mulligan: Uh asked him to leave, he wouldn't leave.
- 4:10Michael Mulligan: Um and then uh after repeated requests to have the brother leave the house, a physical altercation occurs between the brother and the accused.
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: Um and at least according to uh one or one or more of the witnesses, uh the altercation becomes physical and commences with the brother who's not going, uh perhaps hitting or taking a swing at the accused.
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: And then there's uh so now there's a physical altercation going on um with respect to getting the brother out of the house.
- 4:43Michael Mulligan: Now things don't go uh well here in part because the homeowner arms himself with a knife.
- 4:50Michael Mulligan: And so he's holding a a knife, um, and the physical altercation continues.
- 4:56Michael Mulligan: There's no suggestion that he's trying to do something with the knife, but the the altercation try to get the brother out of the house eventually winds up in a wrestling match on the couch, and it would appear the brother got stabbed with the knife accidentally and dies.
- 5:12Michael Mulligan: And so the charge is manslaughter, and the concept of the manslaughter charge is that um if there's a uh death caused by somebody um and it occurs by means of an unlawful act, that's enough to constitute manslaughter, right?
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: There is no intention to kill the brother, that's clear.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the accused was immediately trying to save him and you know, very upset, and no indication that was the intention, he was just trying to get him out of the house.
- 5:39Michael Mulligan: But the crown's argument in the case uh is that this constituted manslaughter on the basis that the possession of the knife was for a purpose dangerous to the public peace, and that's a criminal code offense, even if you didn't do anything with it.
- 5:54Michael Mulligan: And so the crown's argument was, well, look, uh he possessed it, that's the crime, even if he didn't intend to use it, even if that was an accident, uh, well, that's an unlawful act, that caused the death, and so he's uh should be convicted.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: And the uh Crown or the Crown then also opposed the jury being instructed about that section, uh the self-defense provision that we just talked about, on the basis that, well, hold on, he was originally invited, that doesn't count.
- 6:21Michael Mulligan: Look at the wording, just read the wording, right?
- 6:23Michael Mulligan: And so the crown is saying you can't do that.
- 6:25Michael Mulligan: It shouldn't tell the jury about it at all.
- 6:28Michael Mulligan: And so that required the judge in this case to interpret that section to determine, well, w what does what does that include?
- 6:36Michael Mulligan: Uh and the starting point when you're doing something like that is you would look at the plain reading of it, wording of it.
- 6:42Michael Mulligan: Well, does that is it clear?
- 6:44Michael Mulligan: But really what's required, and the judge does this, is that there's an effort to try to assort try to determine, well, what was the intention of parliament when they did this?
- 6:55Michael Mulligan: You know, you you've got to read the words, and it can't be something that doesn't fit with the wording at all, but you know, you're trying to divine what what's meant by this.
- 7:03Michael Mulligan: And and furthermore, in the criminal context, where there are two equally possible interpretations, the sort of the one concept would be, this is to simplify it a bit, the tie goes to the runner, in the sense that, you know, if there's two possible interpretations of something, uh, you should pick the one that's less likely to wind up with somebody in prison, right?
- 7:22Adam Stirling: Okay.
- 7:23Michael Mulligan: Um, and the so the judge is left with trying to interpret it.
- 7:26Michael Mulligan: So the judge when it looked at things like the parliamentary debate, so what did the minister say about it, what information the government released about the section at the time, uh, and then also just some of the practical considerations, which would include things like if you interpret it in a literal way, it would mean that, for example, the rowdy drunken bar patron could just stay.
- 7:46Michael Mulligan: You say, Well, if you touch me, you're committing an assault.
- 7:49Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 7:49Michael Mulligan: So I'm just staying here, right?
- 7:51Michael Mulligan: Or once the person gets into your house, there's just no getting rid of them.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: You know, the vacuum cleaner salesman shows up, you say, Okay, come on in, I'll chat with you.
- 7:58Michael Mulligan: No, I'm not interested.
- 7:59Michael Mulligan: Thanks so much.
- 7:59Michael Mulligan: Uh, you know, please be on your way.
- 8:01Michael Mulligan: And the person could just say, Nope.
- 8:03Michael Mulligan: I got in, that's it, I'm here forever.
- 8:06Michael Mulligan: Or you committed an assault.
- 8:08Michael Mulligan: And so the idea is, well, that literal interpretation does not appear to be consistent with what Parliament intended, not what they said about it, and it would have a bizarre outcome, which would be that once you're in, you can never get out.
- 8:19Michael Mulligan: Uh and found the judge found that there was not the intention to make a major shift in the substantive law, which would mean that, you know, you could remain in bars and houses and everything forever once you got through the threshold, right?
- 8:31Michael Mulligan: Um, and so found that that's not how it should be interpreted.
- 8:35Michael Mulligan: That was not the intention of parliament to make a major change in the law with that bizarre outcome.
- 8:40Michael Mulligan: And the judge did point out that, and this is in keeping with the uh how that the previous actions were interpreted, and indeed the common law, which was they tried to codify, that when you're asking somebody to leave, they have to be a person has to be given a reasonable amount of time to go.
- 8:54Michael Mulligan: It can't be like, get out.
- 8:55Michael Mulligan: No, okay, I've leapt on you, right?
- 8:58Michael Mulligan: There has to be a reasonable time to leave.
- 9:00Michael Mulligan: A person's entitled to, for example, take their belongings with them.
- 9:03Michael Mulligan: And furthermore, any force use has to be reasonable.
- 9:06Michael Mulligan: It can't be completely excessive, right?
- 9:08Michael Mulligan: Uh but as the judge pointed out, the Supreme Court of Canada has also been clear that there's no universal rule that says a a weapon couldn't be used when somebody's trying to protect their property.
- 9:19Michael Mulligan: Uh and so for the judge, and this is a jury case, it's not for the judge ultimately to make the decision.
- 9:26Michael Mulligan: Some of the factual findings will be up to the jury, right?
- 9:29Michael Mulligan: What facts do they find?
- 9:30Michael Mulligan: Do they believe this witness's description of what happened on the couch or another ones, right?
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: But the threshold is whether there's kind of an air of reality to a potential defense.
- 9:40Michael Mulligan: Could the jury, if it accepted uh certain things, uh, could that make out the defense here?
- 9:45Michael Mulligan: And the crown is arguing, no, it couldn't possibly, because look, just read this thing literally, and it can't apply to anyone who got through the threshold with permission.
- 9:53Michael Mulligan: And so the judge has rejected that.
- 9:55Michael Mulligan: It's the first time, and at least a reported decision that anyone could find, where a superior court judge has uh defined this section in this way.
- 10:04Michael Mulligan: Some other provincial court judges had come to the same conclusion this judge had, but no Supreme Court judge.
- 10:09Michael Mulligan: And so we now have a clear decision in this case that indeed the self-defense provisions that allow you to use reasonable force to get somebody out of your home bar or whatever it might be, if they won't go and you've asked, you've given them a reasonable period of time, um, and and so on, at that point, yes, you can use force to get the person out of your bar.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: Not every bouncer is committing a crime uh when they're getting the person out, and you're not forced to have the you know uh encyclopedia salesman or whatever in your living room forever uh once you've invited them in.
- 10:42Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the uh BC Supreme Court, uh, and I think a uh a practical and realistic uh definition uh of what Section 35 meant and uh not the the uh interpretation that you could come to on a plain wording without considering intention and what was said at the time.
- 11:00Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest on self-defense and defense of uh property uh from the BC Supreme Court.
- 11:05Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan Defense Lawyer will continue right after this.
- 11:09Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers Michael is too long.
- 11:16Adam Stirling: For division of property, there is a time limit from the date of separation.
- 11:24Adam Stirling: What's the story?
- 11:27Michael Mulligan: So the the background of this is that uh in British Columbia, under our family law legislation here, um we have uh created a uh scheme that uh provides for the division of property where people are in a marriage-like relationship.
- 11:43Michael Mulligan: Now, as you probably can imagine, just given that description, uh, it can be sometimes complicated about, well, when do these things start and end, right?
- 11:52Michael Mulligan: As the judge pointed out in this case, you know, often relationships will kind of progress over time, right?
- 11:58Michael Mulligan: And so it can be uh sometimes ambiguous about, okay, well, when did this marriage-like relationship begin?
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: How much time do you need to be spending together, and what how do you have to be holding each other?
- 12:09Michael Mulligan: Uh, how do you present yourself?
- 12:11Michael Mulligan: When does it turn into a marriage-like relationship, right?
- 12:14Michael Mulligan: It's obvious when somebody gets married, well, there's the date, right?
- 12:17Michael Mulligan: Um, and equally it can be complicated when relationships kind of uh end, because they don't always end with, well, there's the date of the divorce.
- 12:25Michael Mulligan: We can all see what that is, right?
- 12:27Michael Mulligan: Um, you can have circumstances like in this case where you had a uh couple, they eventually they originally met, looks like back in 2012, one of the uh the uh uh woman had come over from the UK, Scotland, uh, and she had met a fellow here.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: He was married at the time, he agreed to leave his wife, they eventually started a long-distance relationship, and then they wound up eventually buying property together and cohabiting for a period of time, and there was little doubt that they were in a marriage-like relationship.
- 12:58Michael Mulligan: Uh, but uh the things were, I guess, rocky at some points.
- 13:02Michael Mulligan: It sounds like there may be some disputes over financial matters, and they uh eventually wound up sort of separating, but not in the clearest, crispest sort of way anyone can imagine, because they separated, they were dating other people, but then they got together uh the following year, they were going on trips together, you know, it was kind of on again, off again, uh, you know, meeting each other, up, going on vacations, living together for shorter periods of time.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: And so the thing kind of petered along until eventually it ended, right?
- 13:32Michael Mulligan: Uh and then the uh fellow in this case brought uh an application uh under those provisions that we mentioned for uh division of half of the property that the uh woman had acquired during the course of their relationship.
- 13:48Michael Mulligan: Uh and he filed that claim in 2022.
- 13:51Michael Mulligan: Uh and the case uh eventually wound up uh proceeding to uh trial and now eventually now to an appeal.
- 13:59Michael Mulligan: Uh and one of the principal issues here was whether he has done this in time.
- 14:03Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh at the trial, they they seemed to be focusing on everyone, it sounds like both lawyers and the judge were focusing on when the marriage-like relationship ended.
- 14:14Michael Mulligan: And so it got into those things about well, is it a marriage-like relationship when you were going to Hawaii together for two months, but weren't after that?
- 14:23Michael Mulligan: Uh, what exactly did that end?
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: But as the Court of Appeal pointed out, the act actually is queerer than all that because it says that, you know, when you define what a marriage-like relationship is, uh, for the purposes of this act, the languages has lived with another person in a marriage-like relationship and has done so for a continuous period of at least two years, right?
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: So if you're in that, if you're doing that continuously, but then you break up and you're dating other people for a while, and then you get back together, well, that's not continuous, right?
- 14:54Michael Mulligan: Um, and it's clear there was a period of time that was more than two years where they were living together and you know, uh as acting as spouses would, and so there's no doubt there was that kind of relationship at one point.
- 15:06Michael Mulligan: But the act actually says, under in section 198, uh that you can bring a claim uh no more than two years after uh the date the spouses separated.
- 15:18Michael Mulligan: And so you don't need to actually parse out too cleanly when did the marriage-like relationship end, because that can be a little bit ambiguous.
- 15:26Michael Mulligan: Once there's a separation, and here there appears to have been one, right?
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: Okay, you separated, you're in dating sites, you're dating other people.
- 15:32Michael Mulligan: Well, you got back together later.
- 15:33Michael Mulligan: Well, they clearly separated.
- 15:35Michael Mulligan: That's when the uh flair would go up for two years.
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: Uh and he just waited too long.
- 15:43Michael Mulligan: And so by the time on either formulation, whether you got into the uh you know the Court of Appeal, unnecessary, uh complicated figuring out of when does the marriage-like relationship end, if you just run from the when they separated, and that was clearer, uh, in either case, it was just outside of two years.
- 16:01Michael Mulligan: And so he's just out of luck.
- 16:04Michael Mulligan: Um and so that's an important thing for people to bear in mind.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: First of all, to know this exists.
- 16:09Michael Mulligan: I think many people would know it exists, but as I said, people can drift into these things, and if you drift into the marriage-like relationship, you're then, and that goes on for a continuous period of at least two years, you're then going to be subject to this division of property regime.
- 16:24Michael Mulligan: So people should know about that because it's not like getting married where it's clear what you're doing, right?
- 16:28Michael Mulligan: It can just kind of drift drift, you know, happen by drift.
- 16:32Michael Mulligan: Um, and then uh there uh it can be a division of property, but you've only got two years to do it.
- 16:38Michael Mulligan: So uh first of all, pay attention to what you're doing so you don't inadvertently wind up in this circumstance that's not what you intended.
- 16:44Michael Mulligan: Uh and then if you do, bear in mind that if you are going to be making a claim or the other person's making a claim, it's two years, and the two years runs from the date of the separation.
- 16:54Michael Mulligan: And so as a result of that, uh, this fellow was just out of luck, no division of property.
- 16:58Michael Mulligan: So lots of public policy questions there about whether we should have that in those sort of relationships, but we do, uh, and that's the time limit.
- 17:06Michael Mulligan: So everyone mark that on your calendar if you've drifted into potentially the uh the unintended uh marriage-like uh relationship.
- 17:13Adam Stirling: All right, we've got four minutes left.
- 17:15Adam Stirling: Security for cost ordered for a trial, a 10-day trial.
- 17:18Adam Stirling: And does it take a $250 million claim over a vehicle?
- 17:24Michael Mulligan: It indeed it does.
- 17:25Michael Mulligan: So this claim started out, uh, I guess, sort of in the realm of reality.
- 17:30Michael Mulligan: Uh it started out with a fellow who purchased a 2013 GMC terrain, uh SUV, I guess, of some kind, from a used car dealership.
- 17:38Michael Mulligan: It had $113,000 kilometers on it.
- 17:40Michael Mulligan: He bought it for $8,995.
- 17:43Michael Mulligan: A couple of days after he bought it, took it in for servicing at the dealership, uh, and uh then he uh oil changed, various other things done, got the wheel rotors done.
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then apparently the vehicle didn't work that well.
- 17:57Michael Mulligan: He described as burning oil at a problematic rate, and he described driving it as continuously shuddering, shaking, and lunging around while slowly idling in traffic.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: That's probably not in the sales brochure for the 2013 GMC terrain.
- 18:12Michael Mulligan: But anyways, he didn't the car wasn't working well.
- 18:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and he had this particular complaint about the oil getting used up and having to top up the oils, burning oil.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: And then he got a letter from the dealership that said that uh there were problems with uh some vehicles, including that one, uh, and that if the oil consumption was excess, found to be excessive, GMC would replace the piston rings.
- 18:34Michael Mulligan: So uh good news.
- 18:36Michael Mulligan: The dealership required him to uh bring it in to have it topped up again and to then bring it in a number of times to monitor the oil usage, basically, to see whether the piston rings need to be replaced.
- 18:48Michael Mulligan: And eventually they sent him uh an email offering to replace the piston rings.
- 18:52Michael Mulligan: Good for GM.
- 18:53Michael Mulligan: Uh but the fellow didn't think that that was sufficient, and he wanted the didn't think that would solve the problem, and his view was the entire engine needed to be replaced.
- 19:01Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then he brought a claim alleging that they had done various things fraudulently like uh overfilling the oil and uh failing to replace the engine for thirty thousand dollars and requiring unnecessary service visits and potentially losing possible business profits, and then he wanted money for emotional worries and distress.
- 19:20Michael Mulligan: So the claims went on and on.
- 19:22Michael Mulligan: And then he eventually started seeking uh $250 million in damages against the dealership and the place that sold the $9,000 used car.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: Uh and this claim had been then peep going on for some four years, but not advancing very far.
- 19:39Michael Mulligan: And it eventually led to an application by the dealership in the used car lot to seek uh an order for security for costs.
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: And the idea there is that if you don't have any money and you sue somebody unsuccessfully, even if they're ordered, there's an order that they pay a part of your legal expenses, you're never going to get it because they have nothing.
- 19:58Michael Mulligan: And so the judge had to weigh up is that appropriate here.
- 20:02Michael Mulligan: And there are a number of considerations, and it's sort of uh it's discretionary because the the flip side of it is that if you require somebody who doesn't have much money uh to provide security for costs, it may mean that the claim just can't go forward, right?
- 20:17Michael Mulligan: They just don't have the money to provide the security for costs.
- 20:20Michael Mulligan: On the flip side, we don't want to have a circumstance where somebody with no money, or let's say a shell company, is just going to sue you randomly at great expense, lose, and then have no way to collect.
- 20:31Michael Mulligan: And so a judge has to weigh up things like balancing possible injustice and can consider to some extent things like the merits of the application or the merits of the action.
- 20:41Michael Mulligan: And I think that's one of the things which really hurt this fellow because the outrageous amount claimed uh didn't s suggest that this had uh much merit.
- 20:49Michael Mulligan: It was described as grossly disproportionate to what was actually at stake.
- 20:53Michael Mulligan: And then the other consideration here was this fellow had previously sued over an unrelated patent dispute in the UK, unsuccessfully, got a $50,000 cost award against them, and then went bankrupt.
- 21:05Michael Mulligan: And so that was a consideration for the judge as well.
- 21:07Michael Mulligan: And so eventually the outcome here, after four years of uh this litigation over the enormous claim uh arising out of the oil-consuming GMC terrain, the judge concluded that uh, you know, even though this fellow might not have the m money to uh provide this, justice required, given all of those sort of factors, that he provide the security for costs.
- 21:29Michael Mulligan: And so that's what they've got ordered.
- 21:31Michael Mulligan: Uh and if the fellow doesn't come up with the money, uh the uh they asked for some uh I think it was twenty thousand dollars or so in some payments, the the uh to twenty-five thousand dollars, the effect will be that he won't be able to carry on with his multimillion dollar claim for mental distress over his uh oil burning car.
- 21:48Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest on security for costs again from the BC Supreme Court.
- 21:52Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour of your Thursday.
- 21:57Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 21:57Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:59Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:59Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 22:00Adam Stirling: News is next.