Latest / Her Journey: Women, ambition, love & reinvention / The Awkwardness of Reconnecting With Your High School Crush | Her Journey
Transcript
- I almost deleted the text before I even hit send, my thumb hovering over the back button like it was a live grenade. There is a specific kind of terror reserved for reopening a door you thought had been nailed shut twenty years ago. Let’s be real for a second. You know the feeling. It’s that moment when your phone buzzes with a name you haven’t seen in a decade, and suddenly your heart does this weird little flip-flop thing, part nostalgia, part panic. I got a message last Tuesday from a guy named David. Not just any David, but David Miller, who sat two desks over me in AP English senior year. We didn’t date. We barely spoke. But we shared a silence that felt heavy enough to fill a room. For weeks, I’d been thinking about him, not because I wanted to relive high school, but because I was trying to figure out who I was now, and sometimes the easiest way to do that is to look at the people who knew you before you became complicated. When I saw his name pop up on Instagram, my first instinct wasn’t joy. It was dread. Because reconnecting isn’t just about saying hello. It’s about confronting the gap between the person you were and the person you are today. David sent a simple message: 'Hey, saw your profile picture. You look happy. How have you been?' Simple. Innocent. And completely devastating. Because what do you say? Do you tell him you’re tired? Do you tell him you’ve spent the last five years rebuilding yourself from the ground up after leaving a career that looked perfect on paper but felt like a cage? Or do you give him the polished version, the one you use at parties where you smile and nod and pretend everything is fine? Here’s the messy part. When we think about old crushes, we’re rarely thinking about the actual person. We’re thinking about the version of ourselves that existed in their presence. In high school, I was shy. I was unsure of my voice. David was confident, easygoing, someone who seemed to glide through life while I was tripping over my own feet. Reaching out to him wasn’t really about him. It was about asking, 'Can I still be that girl? Can I still be light and unburdened?' The truth is, I can’t be her anymore. And neither can he. We’ve both changed. We’ve both broken, healed, failed, and tried again. The awkwardness comes from the collision of these two timelines. You remember the spark, the potential, the maybe-what-if. But reality is made of mortgage payments, career pivots, grief, and quiet mornings where you just want to drink coffee in peace. Trying to bridge that gap feels clumsy. It feels like wearing clothes from three sizes ago. They might fit, but they don’t feel right. You’re hyper-aware of every word you type, every pause in conversation, wondering if you’re too much or not enough. Wondering if you’re reaching out for connection or just for validation. I used to think that reconnecting with an old flame meant picking up where we left off. Like nothing happened. Like the years were just a long comma instead of a period. But that’s a myth we sell ourselves. We want the fantasy of the uninterrupted story. The one where time stands still and love remains pure because it never had to deal with taxes or illness or the mundane grind of daily life. But here’s the thing about reinvention. It’s not a single event. It’s a continuous practice. Every day, I choose who I am. I choose authenticity over polish. I choose connection over competition. And when I look back at David, I don’t see a missed opportunity. I see a mirror. He represents a time when I didn’t know my own worth. I thought I needed someone else to validate my existence. Now, I know better. That’s why the reconnection is awkward. Because I’m no longer looking for a savior. I’m looking for a witness. Someone who can see the whole arc, not just the beginning. And that’s a lot to ask of someone who only knows the prologue. So, what now? How do you navigate this without making it weird? Well, I did something unexpected. I didn’t try to recreate the past. I didn’t flirt or hint or play games. I just told the truth. I wrote back and said, 'Hi David. Yes, life has been busy. I left my corporate job last year. It was scary, but it was necessary. How are things with you?' No filters. No highlights reel. Just the raw, unedited version of my life. And you know what happened? He breathed a sigh of relief. He told me he’d been struggling with burnout too. He admitted he’d been stuck in a job he hated for a decade. We started talking not as high school sweethearts, but as two adults who had survived the same wars. The awkwardness melted away because we stopped performing. We stopped trying to impress each other with who we were or who we thought we should be. We just met in the middle, in the present tense, with all our scars visible. This is the secret. The magic doesn’t happen in the nostalgia. It happens in the vulnerability. When you let go of the fantasy, you open the door to something real. Something human. Something that doesn’t require you to shrink yourself to fit into a memory. Why do we do this? Why do we reach out to old crushes? I think it’s because we’re lonely. Not necessarily lonely for a partner, but lonely for a version of ourselves that felt simpler. In a world that demands constant productivity and perfection, looking back feels like a safe harbor. It’s a place where the rules were clear. Where rejection felt manageable. Where we hadn’t yet learned how much pain we could endure. But staying there is dangerous. It keeps us from fully inhabiting our current lives. If you’re always looking for the ghost of who you were, you miss the person you’re becoming. Reconnecting should be about integration, not regression. It should help you understand where you’ve come from so you can appreciate where you’re going. It’s okay to miss the feeling of being young and hopeful. But don’t mistake that feeling for a destination. It’s just a checkpoint. I found peace in realizing that David wasn’t the answer to my questions. He was just a fellow traveler. And that was enough. More than enough. It was liberating. Because once you stop needing someone to complete your story, you realize you’re already writing it. And you hold the pen. So, take a breath. Put down the phone if you need to. Look around you. Who is here with you right now? What is real in this moment? That’s where the power is. Not in the past, not in the maybe. Here. Now. Thank you for letting me sit with you today. Until next time, keep building your new world, one honest brick at a time. I’ll see you soon.