Latest / Interfaiths / The Sacred Return: Shared Sanctity in Life and Death
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. I want to start
- 0:02today by just acknowledging where we are in time.
- 0:06It feels like we're standing on the other side
- 0:08of a very long, very dark tunnel, you know, squinting
- 0:11a little bit at the light. That's a really good
- 0:13way to put it. It's Wednesday, January 28th,
- 0:162026. And to really understand the moment we
- 0:19are in right now, I want you to, if you can,
- 0:22just close your eyes for a second and visualize
- 0:24a small physical object. An object that really
- 0:28for the last couple of years has been completely
- 0:30unavoidable. Completely. It's something that
- 0:32if you were walking down the street in Tel Aviv
- 0:34or, I don't know, New York or Miami or London,
- 0:37any time in the last two years, you absolutely
- 0:39saw it. It became part of the visual landscape
- 0:42of the post -2023 world. You saw them on grandmothers
- 0:45in the supermarket. You saw them on teenagers
- 0:48at music festivals. You saw them on professors
- 0:51in lecture halls. They were everywhere. Exactly.
- 0:53I'm talking about the dog tags. But we have to
- 0:56be really specific here. We aren't talking about
- 0:58standard military issue ID tags that soldiers
- 1:02wear under their fatigue. No, these were different.
- 1:04These were different. They were public. Yeah,
- 1:06everywhere. Rectangular pieces of metal, usually
- 1:10hanging on a simple ball chain that carried a
- 1:12very specific, very heavy weight to them. A tangible
- 1:15weight. Yeah. But also a symbolic one. A huge
- 1:19symbolic weight. They had an inscription that
- 1:21became a mantra, bring them home now. Often right
- 1:26below that, a phrase in Hebrew, which translates
- 1:31to my heart is held captive in Gaza. My heart
- 1:34is held captive. Just think about that phrase.
- 1:36It's not I am worried about Gaza or I stand with
- 1:39the hostages. It's an internal state. It's so
- 1:41visceral. My heart is captive. And today we are
- 1:44doing something a little different. We're not
- 1:46just looking at the news headlines or the, you
- 1:47know, the military analysis. We are basing this
- 1:51entire deep dive on a really profound piece of
- 1:53scholarship. by Dr. Iqbal. He's a professor of
- 1:56religious studies and the co -founder of Miami
- 1:58Interfaith. He wrote this incredible essay that
- 2:00analyzes the event that just happened this week,
- 2:02the return of the final hostage, but he strips
- 2:06away the military strategy, the politics, the
- 2:09polling data. All the usual noise. All of it.
- 2:12And he looks at it entirely through the lens
- 2:14of theology. And Dr. Iqbal is such a fascinating
- 2:18guide for this journey because he says right
- 2:21up front, he's an outsider. He's not Jewish.
- 2:23He's a Muslim scholar. Right. And he writes about
- 2:26organizing these interfaith dialogue sessions
- 2:29with his colleague, Rabbi Jamie Aklepi, right
- 2:32after October 7, 2023. He describes walking into
- 2:36these rooms and just seeing these tags on almost
- 2:39everyone's neck. And he admits he was confused.
- 2:42Totally. He just didn't get it at first. Which,
- 2:44if you think about it, is a really fair reaction
- 2:47for someone outside that specific cultural bubble.
- 2:50To an outsider, they look like political merchandise.
- 2:53Or solidarity jewelry. Yeah, maybe even, you
- 2:55know, a statement of militarism. Right. That's
- 2:57the first place your mind goes. You see a metal
- 2:59tag you associate with the army. You think war
- 3:01support. But Dr. Iqbal argues that if you actually
- 3:04stop and study the theology, if you look at the
- 3:06history of symbols in Judaism, these weren't
- 3:09political statements at all. They were a response
- 3:11to a specific historical trauma. A collective
- 3:14trauma. A collective trauma that has been...
- 3:17just bleeding for two years and just came to
- 3:20a resolution two days ago on January 26th, 2026.
- 3:24The day the clock stopped. The day the clock
- 3:26literally stopped. I saw the footage online.
- 3:29It was eerie. For our listeners who haven't been
- 3:31glued to the live feeds for the last 48 hours,
- 3:33let's just set the scene in Tel Aviv. For two
- 3:36years, this place, Hostages Square, has been
- 3:39the epicenter of this national grief. A public
- 3:41wound. Totally. And it has been dominated by
- 3:44this massive digital clock. It wasn't telling
- 3:46the time of day, it was counting up. Seconds,
- 3:49minutes, hours, days. Since the abduction on
- 3:52October 7, it was this relentless ticking reminder
- 3:55of absence. And two days ago, after 843 days,
- 3:59the power was cut. The screen went dark. Because
- 4:01the remains of Staff Sergeant Ranjvili were returned
- 4:04to Israel. Ranjvili, he was 24 years old, a police
- 4:07officer who was killed defending Kibbutz Illumim
- 4:09way back on that very first day of the war. On
- 4:11October 7th itself. Yes. And for 843 days, his
- 4:15body was the last question mark, the last hostage
- 4:18held by Hamas, the final piece of the puzzle.
- 4:21I think we need to just sit with that number
- 4:22for a moment. 843 days. It's staggering. It's
- 4:26more than two years. Dr. Iqbal calls it an eternity
- 4:29of agonizing uncertainty. Think about what that
- 4:33does to a family, to a community. I can't even
- 4:35imagine. Waking up every single morning for 843
- 4:38days, not knowing if your son, your brother is
- 4:41alive or dead, whole or in pieces, buried or
- 4:44abandoned somewhere. It's a psychological torture.
- 4:47So here's the mission for this deep dive. The
- 4:49headline on CNN or the BBC is simply body returned.
- 4:53But the story, the real story, is why it matters
- 4:57so much. The why. is everything here. Why did
- 5:00an entire nation hold its breath for two years
- 5:02over a corpse? Why did people halfway around
- 5:05the world wear those metal tags? Right. Dr. Iqbal's
- 5:08thesis is that this obsession with the body,
- 5:10this refusal to leave the dead behind, isn't
- 5:13just a quirk of Israeli society or Jewish culture.
- 5:15He argues that this theology of death, and specifically
- 5:18the shared reverence for the body, might actually
- 5:21be the secret key to peace between Jews and Muslims.
- 5:23Which sounds completely backwards when you say
- 5:25it out loud. It's so counterintuitive. Totally
- 5:27backwards. You'd think peace comes from the living,
- 5:30from negotiations, from planning for the future.
- 5:33But his argument is that the way Jews and Muslims
- 5:36treat the dead is a shared language. It's a frequency
- 5:40they both hear, even when the politics are jamming
- 5:42every other signal. It's this one place of common
- 5:46ground. OK, so let's unpack this. We have to
- 5:48start with the dog tags. Dr. Iqbal calls the
- 5:51phenomenon of wearing them a transformation of
- 5:54consciousness. That feels like a big claim for
- 5:58a piece of metal on a chain. What does he mean
- 6:00by that? It's a huge claim But I think he backs
- 6:04it up. He's pointing out a shift that happened
- 6:05in the Jewish world. To understand why those
- 6:08tags became so ubiquitous, so necessary feeling,
- 6:11you have to understand the Holocaust. Right.
- 6:13But not the way we usually learn it in history,
- 6:15class dates, battles, numbers. He's talking about
- 6:18the specific mechanism of the Holocaust, the
- 6:21psychological machinery of it. He uses a term
- 6:23in the essay that I hadn't encountered before,
- 6:25and it really stopped me in my tracks, necrocide.
- 6:27It's a chilling word, isn't it? Necrocide. It
- 6:29is. Break that down for us. What distinguishes
- 6:32necrocide from genocide? Because they sound related,
- 6:35obviously. They're absolutely related. But necrocide
- 6:38is a specific subset of genocide. So genocide
- 6:41is the killing of a people, the destruction of
- 6:44a group, a genus. The people themselves. Yes.
- 6:47Necrocide is the killing of death itself. It
- 6:49is the systematic desecration and annihilation
- 6:51of the body. Think about the Nazi infrastructure.
- 6:55Yes, they use gas chambers to kill. But the gas
- 6:58chambers were followed immediately by the crematoria,
- 7:00the industrial ovens. The smoke. The smoke. The
- 7:04ash. The goal of the Nazis wasn't just to end
- 7:07a biological life. That was only step one. Step
- 7:09two was to erase the physical evidence that a
- 7:12human being ever existed. To make them vanish.
- 7:15To turn a person into nothing but particulate
- 7:17matter. To scatter them so there was no grave,
- 7:19no marker, no place for a child to come and say
- 7:22Kaddish, the mourner's prayer. It was the ultimate
- 7:24erasure. It's not enough to kill you. I have
- 7:26to annihilate your death. So the trauma isn't
- 7:28just we died. The trauma is we were discarded.
- 7:31We were treated as waste. Precisely. The crematorium
- 7:35became the ultimate symbol of Jewish vulnerability.
- 7:37It meant you were unburied. You were abandoned.
- 7:40Your physical form, the only thing you leave
- 7:43behind, was just gone. And Dr. Iqbal argues that
- 7:46the phrase, never again, which we hear all the
- 7:48time, is usually interpreted as, never again
- 7:52will we be slaughtered. But deep in the theology,
- 7:55deep in the subconscious, it means something
- 7:57else. It means, never again will Jewish bodies
- 7:59be abandoned. That's the vow. That is the core
- 8:03trauma that October 7th reopened, the fear of
- 8:06being left behind, unburied, unaccounted for.
- 8:08That recontextualizes everything for me, honestly.
- 8:11When I saw those tags in 2024 or 2025, I just
- 8:15thought about solidarity with the living hostages.
- 8:17But you're saying it was a theological shield.
- 8:19It was a reaction to the threat of erasure. It's
- 8:21a deep, almost instinctual response. And it links
- 8:25directly to this central concept in Jewish law
- 8:27called kavod hamet. Kavod hamet. That translates
- 8:30to dignity of the dead. Right. And this is where
- 8:33the theology gets really beautiful and really
- 8:34specific. It's not just a nice idea. A bit of
- 8:36a vague feeling. Not at all. In Jewish theology,
- 8:39the body isn't just a shell. It's not like a
- 8:41banana peel you throw away once you eat the fruit.
- 8:44The body is a vessel. It housed the selem elekim,
- 8:48the image of God. The divine spark. The divine
- 8:51spark. So the body itself is sacred property.
- 8:54You don't own it. You're just its guardian. And
- 8:57because it's sacred, you don't burn it. You don't
- 9:00discard it. You don't leave it in a field. You
- 9:02return it to the earth intact with reverence.
- 9:05And there are specific rituals for this, right?
- 9:07It's not just a general feeling of respect. It's
- 9:09codified law. Oh, it's incredibly specific. The
- 9:12laws are detailed and ancient. And Dr. Iqbal
- 9:15highlights a few rituals that really, I think,
- 9:18explain the dog tags perfectly. Let's start with
- 9:21the practice of shamira. Shamira. OK, meaning
- 9:23guarding or watching. Yes, both. Guarding. From
- 9:27the moment a Jewish person dies until they are
- 9:29buried, they are never left alone. Not for a
- 9:32minute. You mean practically speaking, like in
- 9:34the morgue, in the funeral home. Someone is physically
- 9:36in the room. Literally in the room. 24 hours
- 9:41a day. There are volunteers. From the community,
- 9:45they're called shamrim guards. They organize
- 9:46shifts. They sit with the body, often reciting
- 9:49psalms. Why? What's the theological idea behind
- 9:52that? The theological idea is that the soul is
- 9:56in transition. It's confused. It's vulnerable.
- 9:58It's hovering between worlds. It doesn't quite
- 10:01know where it is. So you're keeping it company.
- 10:03You do not abandon your brother in the dark.
- 10:05You stay with them until they are safely in the
- 10:08earth. It's an act of profound community care.
- 10:10That is... Honestly, that's incredibly tender.
- 10:13The idea that you wouldn't let someone be lonely,
- 10:15even in death. It is. It's beautiful. And then
- 10:18you have Tahara, the ritual washing. This is
- 10:20another key piece. This isn't done by a mortician
- 10:22or a medical examiner in a clinical setting.
- 10:25Right. It's done by the Shevra Kedisha, which
- 10:28translates to the Holy Society. These are trained
- 10:31volunteers for the community. Men for men, women
- 10:33for women. So it's peers from your own community.
- 10:35Yes. Your neighbors, the person you see in the
- 10:38synagogue, they come and they perform this ritual.
- 10:41They wash the body, they cleanse it, they dress
- 10:43it in simple white shrouds. And get this, the
- 10:47source mentions that before they close the coffin,
- 10:50They ask the corpse for forgiveness. For forgiveness.
- 10:53Forgiveness for what? Yes. They apologize in
- 10:56case they move the body too roughly, in case
- 10:58their thoughts weren't pure enough during the
- 11:00ritual, in case they weren't gentle enough in
- 11:02handling this sacred vessel. Wow. That is the
- 11:06level of reverence we are talking about. The
- 11:08body is treated with absolute sanctity even after
- 11:11life has left it. More than sanctity. It's treated
- 11:13like a guest of honor on its final journey. So
- 11:16let's bring this all the way back to the dog
- 11:18tags. Dr. Iqbal makes a direct connection between
- 11:21Shamira, this concept of guarding, and the act
- 11:24of wearing the tags. How does that work? Well,
- 11:26think about the situation on October 7th and
- 11:28the months, the years that followed. You have
- 11:31hostages in Gaza. Some are alive, suffering in
- 11:33tunnels. Some are dead, their bodies held as
- 11:36bargaining chips. Miley's cannot sit Shamira.
- 11:39Of course not. They're not there. They cannot
- 11:41be there to guard them. They cannot perform Tahara.
- 11:43They cannot wash them. The body is abandoned.
- 11:46It is the nightmare scenario of the crematorium
- 11:48all over again. The ultimate vulnerability. So
- 11:51the community steps in. The community becomes
- 11:53the shamroom. That's the argument. By wearing
- 11:56that metal tag against your skin, by feeling
- 11:59the cold weight of it every single day when you
- 12:01wake up and when you go to sleep, you are performing.
- 12:04A continuous vigil. It's a remote guarding. It's
- 12:07a remote guarding. You are saying, physically,
- 12:09with your own body, I am not leaving you alone.
- 12:13Even if I can't be there, I am carrying you.
- 12:16My heart is captive with you. That gives me chills.
- 12:19It transforms the object from a political slogan,
- 12:22which is how I first saw it. Into a religious
- 12:24ritual. It's almost like a prayer you wear. It's
- 12:27a spiritual refusal to abandon the captive. It's
- 12:30a constant physical reminder of an unfulfilled
- 12:33religious obligation. And look at the inscription
- 12:35again. My heart is held captive. Right. That's
- 12:38not just poetry. It's not a metaphor. It ties
- 12:40directly into another major concept. Pity and
- 12:43Schwim. Pity and Schwim. The redemption of captives.
- 12:47I've heard that phrase used a lot in the news
- 12:49coverage. That's a commandment, right? A mitzvah.
- 12:51It's one of the highest mitzvahs in Judaism.
- 12:54It's considered a massive obligation. Maimonides,
- 12:58the great medieval scholar, laid this out very
- 13:00clearly. What did he say? He said that if you
- 13:02have money collected to build a brand new synagogue.
- 13:06A holy house of God, the center of community
- 13:08life, and you hear that a member of your community
- 13:11has been taken captive. You have to divert the
- 13:13funds. You are obligated to take that money,
- 13:15all of it, and use it to buy that prisoner's
- 13:17freedom instead. The human body takes precedence
- 13:21over the holy building. You paused the prayer
- 13:23to free the captive. That puts the last two years
- 13:26into perspective. The entire society was oriented
- 13:29around this specific commandment. The protests,
- 13:32the international diplomacy, the negotiations,
- 13:35the obsession. It was all pity and shvim in action.
- 13:38It was a whole nation trying to fulfill the highest
- 13:40commandment. And visually, Dr. Iqbal points out
- 13:42something very sharp that I hadn't considered.
- 13:44The dog tags. They recall the numbers tattooed
- 13:47on arms in the concentration camps. Yeah. I can
- 13:50see that. The marking of the body. It's a marking
- 13:52of the body. But this time it's voluntary. It's
- 13:54chosen. It's a symbol of commitment rather than
- 13:57a symbol of dehumanization. It's saying, you
- 14:00marked us to erase us. I will mark myself so
- 14:02I don't forget you. It's an act of defiance against
- 14:04that history. So we have this intense, historically
- 14:07loaded, deeply felt Jewish theology driving the
- 14:10need to get Randville back. But here is where
- 14:13the story shifts and where I think Dr. Iqbal's
- 14:15perspective is most valuable. This is the pivot
- 14:18point of the essay. He isn't writing this from
- 14:20inside the synagogue. He's a Muslim scholar.
- 14:23And he takes us into that dialogue room in Miami.
- 14:25Yes, the Miami interfaith sessions. This is where
- 14:28it gets really interesting. So you have Jewish
- 14:30participants wearing the tags, carrying all this
- 14:32trauma we just discussed. The Holocaust, the
- 14:35fear of abandonment, the sacred duty of burial.
- 14:38All of that is in the room with them. It's palpable.
- 14:41And across the table, you have Muslim participants
- 14:44from the Miami community. And I imagine the vibe
- 14:47in that room was tense. Kent is putting it mildly.
- 14:50The source describes a real wall going up almost
- 14:53immediately. The Muslim participants saw the
- 14:56tags and their guard went up. They saw a military
- 14:59symbol. So they got. They thought, militant,
- 15:02pro -war, you support the bombing of Gaza. You
- 15:06support the IDF. They saw a political threat
- 15:09sitting across from them, wearing a symbol of
- 15:11the army they saw as an oppressor. Which, let's
- 15:14be honest, is a completely logical assumption
- 15:16if you don't know the theology we just spent
- 15:1815 minutes unpacking. If you see a military -style
- 15:21ID tag, you think military. It's a perfectly
- 15:23logical conclusion. But then, because they were
- 15:26in a dialogue setting, the conversation happened.
- 15:28They started talking. And the Jewish participants...
- 15:32guided by the rabbi, didn't talk about military
- 15:34strategy. They didn't talk about borders or Hamas
- 15:36brigades. They talked about death. They talked
- 15:38about burial. They explained the fear of the
- 15:41crematorium. They explained Kavod Hamet, the
- 15:43need to return the body to the earth, the agonizing
- 15:46need to have a grave to visit, a place to mourn.
- 15:49And that's when the light bulb went on. That's
- 15:51when everything changed. Because that is a language
- 15:53Islam speaks fluently. Let's look at that. Does
- 15:56Islam have a similar concept of the body? I know
- 15:59there are very strict burial laws in Islam as
- 16:01well. It's remarkably similar. It's almost a
- 16:04mirror image in many ways. Dr. Iqbal quotes the
- 16:07famous verse from the Quran that said, whenever
- 16:09someone dies, indeed we belong to Allah and indeed
- 16:12to him we return. Acknowledging the source and
- 16:16the destination. Exactly. The theology here is
- 16:18that the body is alone from God. It's a trust.
- 16:22And the mana, you live in it, you care for it,
- 16:25but you don't own it. At the end of your life,
- 16:28you have a duty to return it to the creator in
- 16:30a dignified way. And the rituals, do they mirror
- 16:32the Jewish ones we talked about, like Tahara?
- 16:35It's almost a perfect parallel. In Islam, you
- 16:37have ghusl. This is the ritual washing of the
- 16:39body. It has to be done with extreme tenderness,
- 16:41usually by family members or people of the same
- 16:43gender. You use water. sometimes with camphor
- 16:46or scented oils. It's intimate and respectful.
- 16:49So again, it's the community, the family, not
- 16:51a stranger. Yes. The community takes care of
- 16:55its own. Then you have the kafon, the wrapping
- 16:58of the body in simple white cloth. Just like
- 17:00the Jewish shrouds. No fancy suits, no jewelry.
- 17:03Exactly. Rich or poor, king or pauper, everyone
- 17:06gets wrapped in simple, clean white cloth. It's
- 17:09the ultimate equalizer in death. And then the
- 17:12burial must be swift. Ideally within 24 hours.
- 17:15Okay. I've always wondered about that rush. I
- 17:17assumed it was a practical thing. You know, hygiene
- 17:19in hot climates, desert traditions. That's the
- 17:22secular explanation you often hear. And it might
- 17:24be part of it historically. But the theological
- 17:27reason is all about compassion for the deceased.
- 17:29How so? The belief is that the soul has separated
- 17:32from the body and is waiting to begin its journey
- 17:35back to its creator. Delaying the burial is seen
- 17:39as keeping the soul in a state of distress. of
- 17:41limbo it's like leaving someone waiting at a
- 17:44train station for days on end so it's an act
- 17:46of mercy it is an act of mercy to the deceased
- 17:48you hurry to bury them not to get rid of them
- 17:51but to help them on their journey to give them
- 17:53peace so when the muslim participants in miami
- 17:56heard the jewish participants talk about the
- 17:58agony of waiting of not being able to bury their
- 18:01dead for days weeks months years they understood
- 18:05viscerally In their bones, the political symbol
- 18:10of the dog tag just melted away. Yeah. Underneath
- 18:13it, they didn't see an enemy soldier or a political
- 18:16opponent. They saw a fellow human being with
- 18:18an unfulfilled sacred duty. They saw a shared
- 18:21religious obligation. They realized, wait a minute,
- 18:24you aren't wearing that because you want to destroy
- 18:26my people. You're wearing that because you were
- 18:28in agony over your need to bury your brother.
- 18:31That is such a powerful shift. It moves the entire
- 18:33conversation from my side versus your side to
- 18:36we're all humans who need to bury our dead. It
- 18:39humanizes the other through the shared experience
- 18:41of grief. It creates a bridge. Dr. Iqbal calls
- 18:45it a moment of understanding. Now, let's be crystal
- 18:47clear. It didn't solve the geopolitical crisis
- 18:50in the Middle East. Of course not. It didn't
- 18:52stop the bombs. But in that room amongst those
- 18:54specific people, it changed the temperature.
- 18:57It allowed them to see each other as human beings
- 19:00bound by similar sacred laws. It allowed them
- 19:03to speak. Which brings us to the actual logistics
- 19:05of this return. Because while the theology is
- 19:07beautiful and shared in a conference room in
- 19:09Miami, the reality on the ground in Gaza was
- 19:12messy. It was violent. It was complicated. Messy
- 19:16is a massive understatement. When we talk about
- 19:18the return of Rancho Vili this week, we aren't
- 19:20talking about a simple handover at a border crossing
- 19:22with a handshake and a somber moment. We are
- 19:24talking about a massive military and intelligence
- 19:27operation that took place inside a hostile war
- 19:30zone. The source material. mentioned something
- 19:32that I found staggering, and I had to read it
- 19:34a few times. It says that Israeli authorities
- 19:36spent days exhuming approximately 250 bodies
- 19:39from a cemetery in Gaza just to find him. Let's
- 19:42just pause on that. 250 graves opened. 250 bodies
- 19:46disturbed. My initial reaction to reading that
- 19:48was shock. I mean, it feels extreme. It feels
- 19:50like a violation, especially knowing what we
- 19:52now know about the Islamic reverence for the
- 19:54dead and the need for a swift, undisturbed burial.
- 19:58It is extreme. And from a purely secular perspective
- 20:01or a purely military strategy perspective, it
- 20:03makes zero sense. Think about the cost. Think
- 20:07about the resources. Why expend those resources?
- 20:10Why risk soldiers' lives in a hostile zone for
- 20:14a body? Why generate that much anger and hatred
- 20:17on the other side by digging up their cemetery?
- 20:19It seems completely irrational. It's totally
- 20:22irrational from a cost -benefit analysis. But
- 20:24if you view it through the lens of necrocide
- 20:26and Kavod Hammett... Then it becomes a religious
- 20:28imperative. It's not a choice. It's an obligation
- 20:31that supersedes almost everything else. You cannot
- 20:33leave the body behind. The idea of the mass grave
- 20:35or the unknown grave is the ultimate nightmare
- 20:38scenario from Jewish history. So the state acts
- 20:41on it. The state, acting on this deep subconscious
- 20:44theological impulse, goes to lengths that seem
- 20:47irrational to the outside world to recover one
- 20:49single body. And it's not just about October
- 20:517th either, is it? As you mentioned, there's
- 20:53a pattern here in Israeli history. A long, consistent
- 20:56pattern. Dr. Iqbal points to Zachary Baumel.
- 21:00He was an Israeli tank commander missing in action
- 21:03in the first Lebanon war in 1982. Right, 1982.
- 21:06His body was missing for 37 years. 37 years.
- 21:10Most nations would have declared him dead and
- 21:12moved on decades ago. Israel kept looking. They
- 21:15ran intelligence operations for decades. They
- 21:17eventually got his remains back from Syria in
- 21:192019 via Russia. 37 years. Or Eli Cohen, the
- 21:23famous spy executed in Damascus in the 1960s.
- 21:26To this day, Israel is still trying to get his
- 21:28remains back. Decades of secret negotiations
- 21:31just to get his bones back. Time doesn't diminish
- 21:34the obligation. It's a debt that never expires.
- 21:37But here's the twist in the Ranjvili story that
- 21:39Dr. Iqbal really highlights. The source says
- 21:42Hamas actually provided the information to find
- 21:44him. This is the fascinating and deeply messy
- 21:46cooperation of enemies. This, in turn, didn't
- 21:49happen in a vacuum. It wasn't just an Israeli
- 21:51raid. No, it was part of the deal. It was part
- 21:53of the ceasefire negotiations. It was entangled
- 21:56with the opening of the Rafah crossing, with
- 21:59the release of Palestinian prisoners with aid
- 22:01shipments. So it was a bargaining chip. His body
- 22:03was a bargaining chip. Explicitly. And Dr. Iqbal
- 22:06doesn't shy away from that at all. He says both
- 22:08sides instrumentalized a sacred duty. What does
- 22:11he mean by that? He means Hamas used the body
- 22:14as leverage to prove they were serious about
- 22:17the ceasefire terms or to get more prisoners
- 22:19released or more aid in. Israel used the ceasefire
- 22:23as leverage. to get the body. It was raw political
- 22:26currency. That feels so cynical. Using a corks
- 22:29as currency. It is cynical. It's ugly. It's the
- 22:31reality of war. But Dr. Iqbal finds a sliver
- 22:34of hope, a silver lining, even in the cynicism.
- 22:37What's the silver lining there? He argues that
- 22:39by using the body as currency, both sides were
- 22:42admitting that returning the dead matters. How
- 22:44so? It feels like the opposite. Think about it.
- 22:46For something to be valuable currency, both parties
- 22:49have to agree on its value. If Hamas didn't care
- 22:53about burial, they wouldn't have kept the body.
- 22:55They wouldn't have tracked where it was buried.
- 22:57They would have just left it in the field. Okay,
- 22:59I see that. And if Israel didn't care, they wouldn't
- 23:01have negotiated for it. So even in a war where
- 23:04there is almost zero good faith, where both sides
- 23:07view the other as inhuman monsters, they both
- 23:10implicitly agreed on one thing. This body is
- 23:13valuable. This body deserves to go home. It's
- 23:16a weirdly profound agreement in the middle of
- 23:19a bloodbath, a shared recognition of a moral
- 23:22violation. We know keeping this body here isn't
- 23:25right. Exactly. Both sides know that keeping
- 23:28a body from its grave is a transgression and
- 23:31that shared knowledge, even when it's used cynically,
- 23:33is a tiny, tiny point of light. It's a shared
- 23:36moral language. But we have to acknowledge the
- 23:38tragedy here, too. The deep, painful asymmetry
- 23:41of this whole situation. Because this story isn't
- 23:44just about one family getting closure. No. And
- 23:47Dr. Iqbal is very clear and very insistent on
- 23:50this point. Rangevili goes home. He gets a state
- 23:53funeral. His family sits Shiva. They have a grave
- 23:56to visit. They get certainty. Which is invaluable.
- 23:59Invaluable. Meanwhile, the operation to find
- 24:02him involved deking up a cemetery and disturbing
- 24:04250 Palestinian graves. And at the same time,
- 24:08thousands of Palestinians are still missing under
- 24:11the rubble in Gaza. Their families have no closure.
- 24:14They don't have a body to wash. They don't have
- 24:16a grave to visit. Their cemeteries may have been
- 24:18bulldozed or disturbed. The inequality of who
- 24:21gets to mourn is just. It's stark. It's a gut
- 24:24-wrenching contrast. One family gets certainty
- 24:27while thousands get more chaos and desecration.
- 24:30And that tension, that painful asymmetry, leads
- 24:32us to the central paradox of this entire deep
- 24:34dive. The question that really haunts this whole
- 24:36episode. The question of the living versus the
- 24:38dead. Exactly. Dr. Iqbal poses this provocative,
- 24:42deeply uncomfortable question. If we invest this
- 24:45much moral weight, this much energy, this much
- 24:47resource in the dead, if we're willing to negotiate...
- 24:50Pause fighting, exhume graves, risk soldiers
- 24:54and spend millions to bring back one corpse.
- 24:57Why don't we invest as much in the living? Oof,
- 25:00that hits hard. Because we don't. We don't. It
- 25:03exposes a massive failure, a collective moral
- 25:06failure. Because here is the great irony. Both
- 25:09traditions, Judaism and Islam, actually prioritize
- 25:12life over death, unequivocally. Let's look at
- 25:15the Jewish side first, the concept of pikish
- 25:17nefesh. Pekesh nefesh, the saving of a life.
- 25:20In Jewish law, this is the trump card. It's the
- 25:22highest value. It overrides almost every other
- 25:24commandment in the Torah. Almost everything.
- 25:26Almost everything except for murder, idolatry,
- 25:28and certain sexual sins. You can break the Sabbath
- 25:31to save a life. You can eat non -kosher food
- 25:33if you're starving to save a life. You can drive
- 25:35a car on Yom Kippur, the holiest day of the year,
- 25:38to get someone to the hospital. And the Talmud
- 25:39has that famous saying. Whoever saves one life,
- 25:42it is as if he saved an entire world. the value
- 25:46of single human life is infinite. And in Islam,
- 25:49is it the same? It is almost identical. The Quran
- 25:52in Surah 5, verse 32 says, Whoever kills a soul,
- 25:56it is as if he had slain mankind entirely. And
- 26:00whoever saves one, it is as if he had saved mankind
- 26:02entirely. The exact same idea. Saving one life
- 26:05is like saving all of humanity. Precisely. And
- 26:08a teaching of the Prophet Muhammad says that
- 26:09the first question a person will be asked on
- 26:11the Day of Judgment is about bloodshed. Did you
- 26:13spill innocent blood? The sanctity of life is
- 26:16paramount. So the theology in both faiths is
- 26:18crystal clear. Life comes first. The living take
- 26:22precedence over the dead. The theology is clear.
- 26:24But the politics failed. The human beings failed.
- 26:27That's the tragedy Dr. Iqbal highlights. The
- 26:29return of Ranjili was a triumph of Kabod Hama
- 26:31dignity for the dead. We nailed that part. We
- 26:33fulfilled that obligation. But the war itself,
- 26:36the 843 days of fighting. It was a catastrophic
- 26:39failure of Pekwash Nefesh. Failure of Koran 5
- 26:41.32. We fail to save the thousands of worlds
- 26:44that were lost on both sides. He mentions another
- 26:46concept from Judaism, tzitzal emet. He translates
- 26:50it as true kindness. Yes. In Jewish thought,
- 26:54caring for the dead, washing the body, burying
- 26:57it, mourning, is considered the truest kindness.
- 27:01Why true? Because the dead person can't pee you
- 27:04back. They can't write you a thank you note.
- 27:06They can't do you a favor later. It is pure altruism.
- 27:09You do it simply because it is the right thing
- 27:12to do for a fellow human being. It's an act of
- 27:14grace. It's a beautiful concept, doing good with
- 27:17absolutely no expectation of reward. It is. But
- 27:20the challenge Dr. Ipbal throws down at the end
- 27:22of his essay is this. Can we extend that true
- 27:25kindness to the living? Can we act with that
- 27:27same selfless grace towards people who are still
- 27:29breathing? Can we treat the living populations,
- 27:32the people in found, this destroyed Kibbutzim,
- 27:34the people in Khan Yunus, the refugees in Tenzin
- 27:37Rafa, with that same level of sanctity we afford
- 27:40a corpse? Because right now it seems like we
- 27:42treat the dead with more reverence than the refugees.
- 27:45That's the paradox, isn't it? We honor the body
- 27:48once the life has left it. We treat the empty
- 27:50vessel like a holy object. We move heaven and
- 27:53earth to bring it home. But while the life is
- 27:55in it, while the telemelechim, the image of God,
- 27:58is still breathing inside it. We allow it to
- 28:01be destroyed. We allow it to starve. We allow
- 28:03it to be bombed. We fail it. So where do we go
- 28:06from here? I mean, it feels hopeless. The clock
- 28:10has stopped. The body is home. The war. Well,
- 28:13the war shifts. It changes, but it doesn't end.
- 28:16Is there a lesson here? Dr. Iqbal suggests that
- 28:20we can actually use this shared theology of death
- 28:22to build peace. He does. He refuses to end on
- 28:24a hopeless note, which I appreciate. He suggests
- 28:27that honoring the dead can be a bridge. How does
- 28:30that work practically? Because it feels like
- 28:32a nice poetic idea, but how does it work in the
- 28:35real world between enemies? Well, think about
- 28:37the universality of grief. It's the one thing
- 28:39everyone in this conflict shares. Every single
- 28:41person. Everyone has lost someone. Everyone has
- 28:44a story of a funeral. Or the lack of a funeral.
- 28:47Because it's a shared experience. It's the most
- 28:49fundamental shared experience. Dr. Iqbal suggests
- 28:52that organizations on both sides could work together
- 28:55on the dignified treatment of the deceased. Like
- 28:57a joint burial commission, something like that.
- 29:00Exactly. Or a joint project on identifying remains
- 29:02from past conflicts. Or mapping cemeteries to
- 29:06ensure they're protected. It's a space where
- 29:08enemies can recognize each other's humanity without
- 29:11having to agree on borders or security arrangements
- 29:13yet. You don't have to agree on who owns Jerusalem
- 29:16to agree that a mother should be able to bury
- 29:19her son. That's it right there. It's a starting
- 29:21point. It's a nonpolitical human level task that
- 29:25builds a tiny reservoir of trust where none exists.
- 29:28And he brings up some deep vocabulary from both
- 29:31traditions that could help. He says we use political
- 29:33language too much and it fails us. This is so
- 29:36important. We're stuck in the language of politics.
- 29:39Two state solution. Demilitarized zones, security
- 29:42envelopes, that's the language of policy papers.
- 29:45It's sterile. It has no heart. It has no heart.
- 29:48Dr. Iqbal says we need to use theological language
- 29:50because that's what speaks to the people's souls
- 29:52in this region. These are religious societies,
- 29:55whether we in the secular West like it or not.
- 29:57So from the Islamic side, he lists a few key
- 29:59terms. The first is Rama. Rama, mercy. It's one
- 30:03of the primary names of God in Islam, Araman,
- 30:05the all -merciful. To act with Rama is to emulate
- 30:09God. but also sul, which means reconciliation.
- 30:13It's an active process of mending broken relationships.
- 30:16And a very pragmatic concept he mentioned called
- 30:19maslach. Maslach. I find this one fascinating.
- 30:22It means public interest or the common good.
- 30:24In Islamic jurisprudence, it allows for leaders
- 30:27to make treaties and compromises, even with enemies,
- 30:29if those treaties serve the greater good of the
- 30:32community and prevent further harm. So making
- 30:34peace with an enemy isn't surrender. It's maslach.
- 30:37It's a wise and religiously sanctioned act to
- 30:39protect the community from further death and
- 30:41destruction. It gives a religious permission
- 30:43structure to stop fighting. And the Quran verse,
- 30:46he quotes, if they incline to peace, then incline
- 30:50to it. Exactly. It's a command, not a suggestion.
- 30:53If the other side offers a hand, you are religiously
- 30:57obligated to take it. And from the Jewish side,
- 30:59the key term is, of course, shalom. Shalom. But
- 31:03not just as a passive greeting like hello or
- 31:06goodbye. The Psalms say, seek peace and pursue
- 31:09it. The Hebrew is, The rabbis point out something
- 31:15fascinating about this verse. For most commandments,
- 31:18you wait for the opportunity to come to you.
- 31:21You wait for the Sabbath to arrive. You wait
- 31:23for a poor person to ask for charity. But peace.
- 31:26You have to chase it. You have to run after it.
- 31:28You have to hunt it down. It requires active,
- 31:30relentless effort. You can't just sit back and
- 31:32hope for peace to happen. I love that image.
- 31:34Running after peace, not just waiting for a treaty
- 31:37to be signed by politicians. And Dr. Iqbal makes
- 31:40a crucial distinction here, which is maybe the
- 31:42most important takeaway. He warns against conflating
- 31:45the religion with the nationalism. The trap we
- 31:47all fall into. All the time. He says we have
- 31:50to be so careful to distinguish Jewish theology
- 31:52from Israeli government policy. They are not
- 31:55the same thing. And we have to distinguish Islamic
- 31:58theology from Hamas or Palestinian resistance.
- 32:01They're not the same thing. Right. When we collapse
- 32:03those identities, we lose all the wisdom we've
- 32:05just been talking about. We lose the wisdom.
- 32:07We just get tribalism. We just get my team versus
- 32:10your team. He points out that the diasporic communities
- 32:13in Miami, in London, in Toronto have a special
- 32:17role here. Because they aren't on the front lines.
- 32:19They aren't in the bomb shelters or the refugee
- 32:21camps. They have a bit of distance. They have
- 32:23the luxury of safety. And with that luxury comes
- 32:26a responsibility. They can model what it looks
- 32:29like to hold multiple truths at the same time.
- 32:31To say, I believe in Israeli security and Palestinian
- 32:35dignity. To say, I mourn the Jewish dead and
- 32:39the Muslim dead. If it can happen in a dialogue
- 32:42room in Miami, if those dog tags can, for a moment,
- 32:46become a point of connection instead of division,
- 32:48maybe eventually it can happen in Jerusalem.
- 32:50It's about small acts of recognition. Yes. Grand
- 32:54peace treaties often fail. because there is no
- 32:57trust on the ground. They're imposed from the
- 32:59top down. But small acts like returning a body,
- 33:02like helping to identify a grave, like sharing
- 33:05a meal build trust from the bottom up. Dr. Iqbal
- 33:08points to history. He says we have to remember
- 33:10this isn't impossible. Look at Northern Ireland.
- 33:13Catholics and Protestants who slaughtered each
- 33:15other for generations. That's right. Now they
- 33:17share a government. Look at South Africa. Black
- 33:20and white. Apartheid seemed insurmountable. Or
- 33:22France and Germany. They killed each other by
- 33:25the millions twice in a single century. It was
- 33:28unimaginable that they would ever be allies.
- 33:30Now they share a currency and an open border.
- 33:33Reconciliation happens. It's a long, painful
- 33:36process, but it happens. And it always starts
- 33:39when you begin to see the other as human. And
- 33:42ironically, as we've seen today, seeing how the
- 33:44other mourns their dead is often... The first
- 33:47most powerful step in seeing them is human. When
- 33:49you see a mother crying over a grave, you don't
- 33:52see a terrorist or an oppressor. You see a mother.
- 33:54And that changes everything. So as we wrap up,
- 33:57let's go back to that image in the intro. The
- 34:00dog tags. They are being retired now. The source
- 34:02mentions they are being collected, being placed
- 34:04in repositories and synagogues. They are becoming
- 34:06sacred objects of history. Artifacts of a time
- 34:09of waiting. They are being taken off necks and
- 34:11put into archives. And the clock in Tel Aviv
- 34:15has stopped. The digital numbers are dark. That
- 34:18constant ticking reminder is gone. It has. The
- 34:21count is over. The vigil for Ranjivilli is over.
- 34:24So the question Dr. Iqbal leaves us with, the
- 34:27question for all of us is, what did we learn
- 34:30from these last 843 days? What did we learn from
- 34:33these dog tags? Did we only learn how to recover
- 34:36the dead? Did we get really good at fulfilling
- 34:39Kavod Hamet? Did we perfect the art of being
- 34:41efficient undertakers after the fact? Or did
- 34:43we learn how to protect the living? Did we learn
- 34:45anything about Pekwash Nefesh? It's a haunting
- 34:47choice because we can't do both, it seems. It
- 34:50feels like we have to choose. It does. The theology
- 34:53is there. The resources are there. The true kindness,
- 34:56the cheese of Shalomet exists. We saw it in the
- 34:58exhumation. We saw it in the negotiation. The
- 35:01machinery of care exists. We just have to decide
- 35:03to apply it to the people who are still breathing.
- 35:05The image of Randville returning home. It's tragic,
- 35:09but it's also a reminder of what humans owe each
- 35:12other. That even in the midst of total war, we
- 35:14can pause for this one sacred act. He was a defender.
- 35:18He was a son. And in the end, his return was
- 35:22a moment where the war stopped, just for a second,
- 35:25to honor a human life that was lost. Dr. Iqbal's
- 35:29final words in the essay are beautiful. He says,
- 35:31may the memory be a blessing and may the wisdom
- 35:34of the dead teach the living how to stop the
- 35:36war. That's the hope, isn't it? That the dead
- 35:39can teach us what we couldn't seem to learn on
- 35:41our own. Thank you for listening to this deep
- 35:43dive. It's a heavy one, I know, but I think an
- 35:45important one. As you go about your week, maybe
- 35:47think about that clock. Think about all the energy,
- 35:50all the focus, all the national will it took
- 35:52to stop it. And just think about where else that
- 35:54energy could go. Take care, everyone. See you
- 35:56next time.