Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 109: On Marie Antoinette's Enduring Legacy with Dr. Susan Taylor Leduc
Transcript
- 0:11You're listening to the New Paris, I'm your host Lindsay
- 0:15tributo. If I think about some of the
- 0:17women that have defined Parisian and French history, I instantly
- 0:21think of Marie Antoinette. First and foremost, the long
- 0:24maligned figure of French royalty and one of the many
- 0:26unfortunate symbols of the French Revolution.
- 0:29The former Queen has rarely been painted in a favorable light but
- 0:33what if that's part of an incomplete story, what if new
- 0:36scholarship points to a more nuanced picture of Marie
- 0:39Antoinette and the empress's? That followed in her footsteps.
- 0:43That's part of what today's guest on covered in her new
- 0:45book, Marie Antoinette's Legacy. The politics French garden,
- 0:49patronage and picturesque design, dr.
- 0:52Susan Taylor, Leduc. An art historian previous guest
- 0:54of the show and fellow guy who runs, picturesque voyages, joins
- 0:58me today to talk about all of this, about the world's
- 1:01obsession with Marie Antoinette her role within the Royal Court.
- 1:05What pop culture has gotten wrong about her.
- 1:07And the parallels with depictions of Parisian women
- 1:10today Susan. Welcome back to the show.
- 1:18Thank you so much for having me, Lindsay.
- 1:20It's a pleasure to be here when we first met and I first had you
- 1:24on I believe it was in season 4 because I think we spoke in 2021
- 1:29as the hotel de Maheen was going to open in Paris, you were
- 1:32finishing your manuscript for this extremely dense, heavily
- 1:37researched book that you have now completed and and I'm
- 1:42thrilled that you are here. Now to discuss this book and the
- 1:45topic And that really does, I think.
- 1:49And hopefully we're going to unfurl that for our for our
- 1:51listeners, but really does relate to a contemporary
- 1:55framework in terms of women's, was discussions around women and
- 2:00some of the work that I've done. And so there's a lot to unpack
- 2:04in what you've done, but I'm interested in your argument that
- 2:08my Antoinette and the empress's Josephine Maris and Eugenie are
- 2:12commonly misrepresented. And as you put It's they're
- 2:17commonly perceived as profligate guard and patrons pursuing
- 2:20ostentatious Pleasures at the Petit, Trianon, Versailles, and
- 2:24malmaison and your book, then attempts, to sort of disrupt
- 2:27this narrative arguing instead that their Gardens were liminal
- 2:30zones, at the epicenter of Court societies, venues were each
- 2:34Patron, demonstrated her agency and cultural clout.
- 2:38So I guess maybe even before we get to the specifics of why you
- 2:44looked at the at this aspect. Act of of Court life.
- 2:48Why are we so obsessed with my own twin it?
- 2:51Because, you know, we she seemingly the, the Royal figure
- 2:54that we just can't get enough of and usually in a negative sense.
- 2:59Well, I think that's a very important question and I think
- 3:04I'm not I am an art historian. I'm not a historian.
- 3:07And so I don't expect to, you know, explain to you why the
- 3:14importance of Marie Antoinette historically.
- 3:16We, but what I can say is that, she had this extraordinary
- 3:21Destiny and she came to France as a adolescent bride, who
- 3:27reigned for 20 years, she was extraordinarily influential, and
- 3:33then she died at the age of 37. A tragic death in circumstances
- 3:37that nobody could have predicted at that time for an Austrian
- 3:43princess This story has always had those who say she was
- 3:52corrupt and she deserved this death and you know, that's part
- 3:54of the French Revolution, and we have to take that anti royalists
- 3:58dance and that's part of the foundation of the Republic or a
- 4:02royalist apology that says, we should, you know, consider her
- 4:06to be a martyr and a victim. And this history has been going
- 4:09on in a 19th century, even by out of silicone, do Mom, but it
- 4:13got it in Incredible push in 2006 with Sofia Coppola is
- 4:21moving around when it. So we have to understand that
- 4:27this was a luxurious luxurious production, it was filmed at the
- 4:31outside, it was Kirsten Dunst, it was beautiful and it was
- 4:34based on a biography by Antonia Fraser and there's a certain
- 4:38part of it that I think does capture some of the boredom and
- 4:42the, when we Of their side. But it created this idea that
- 4:49the 21st century could identify with this woman that it was
- 4:53possible to go back in time and get dressed up and eat pastries,
- 4:57and play games and identify with her situation.
- 5:02When in fact, we were very removed from Court society.
- 5:06And so this obsession with Marie Antoinette has become since 2006
- 5:13incredibly profitable. Oil.
- 5:15It is become a way to consume Versailles and to consume Paris
- 5:22in much the way in your work, that kind of these yen is an
- 5:26image that has been consumed and used to promote Paris and
- 5:31tourism and movies and all that culture.
- 5:33So to unpack this we have to, I think remember that she lived in
- 5:41a court Society, Functioned historically, within that core
- 5:46society. And my point of view, in my
- 5:48book, in particular, was one of the ways to understand how she
- 5:51could have any agency was to look at women in the garden and
- 5:56it was the garden. That was a space that allowed a
- 6:00certain agency, the influence, all kinds of other things but
- 6:03within the context of course society and that is why the next
- 6:08series of empresses Mary Louise Josephine and usually who were
- 6:12also the head of course this IDs looked to her as an example,
- 6:17it's navigating that social, economic ritualised Court
- 6:23Society. So so I guess then in looking at
- 6:28Gardens, which is what you you do, throughout the book, both
- 6:31through my hands when I had and the inferences and purses and
- 6:34also looking at their marriage contracts, which is super
- 6:36fascinating. You is it also a way for you to
- 6:40maybe correct some of the ill-formed ideas about there.
- 6:43Influence. I hope so.
- 6:46I hope so. I think that their influence has
- 6:52to do with their agency. And what I mean by that is not
- 6:57only that they were Garden patronage Garden patrons, but
- 7:03the way that Marie Antoinette was able to navigate, Her garden
- 7:10to create her garden and to walk through.
- 7:12It constructed, a kind of embodied figure, that was
- 7:16extraordinarily important for how people establish themselves
- 7:21in nature and that continues way up until the public park
- 7:26movement and actually is influential for how we see
- 7:29ourselves in Parks even even until today.
- 7:33So, I think that's very important.
- 7:36What period would you say Begins the public park movement?
- 7:39The public Movement is the very end.
- 7:41It usually, you know, her husband is really doing that
- 7:44from 1853 until 1870. And she's at that very moment,
- 7:49restoring Marie Antoinette and Josephine's Gardens.
- 7:53Exactly. That moment, she's saying women
- 7:55to had a place in the landscape and I'm going to give them some
- 7:59historical. In fact, commemorative memory, I
- 8:04would think a cultural and commemorative memory.
- 8:05So this that's important. So one of the things you
- 8:08actually do is call them cure Creators of space, and you're
- 8:12considering them in such a way that I presume as a way to
- 8:16understand power politics at the time.
- 8:18So, can you dig into this a little bit?
- 8:20You know, how was my ultimate constructing her Gardens, you
- 8:23know, what is it about? The design?
- 8:25That was so unique and important in her pursuit of agency in a
- 8:30sense of control. And then is it also a question
- 8:33of this sort of private garden and public space.
- 8:37You know what's at play here. Well, I think that most people
- 8:43understand that the most important Garden style in
- 8:45France, in the 17th century was The Gardens of Versailles, which
- 8:48we call the French formal style, and in the late 18th century.
- 8:52Beginning in England, there was an alternative style that was
- 8:55called, the English garden style, that was more informal.
- 9:00And although Marie Antoinette, may not have initiated that
- 9:05style in France and certainly not in England once she decided
- 9:09to create Create her own garden at the SI she created a space.
- 9:15Curated, a space that was adopting something.
- 9:19That was different from the representational.
- 9:24Public space of the French formal Garden.
- 9:26So in retreating to her garden, she created a place where she
- 9:32said herself. I can be myself and invited her
- 9:35friends there and retreated from court.
- 9:37So it's tempting to say This was a private sphere and she wanted
- 9:43to close yourself off and didn't want anybody, see what she's
- 9:45doing? But in fact given her position
- 9:48because she was a celebrity, and it's important to know that
- 9:52she's probably one of the first celebrities kind of like Jacques
- 9:55Rousseau and kind of like, Benjamin Franklin, okay, is the
- 9:58first celebrities that Anton new tea poured pointed out in his
- 10:02book and he first published in 2014 about what is it to be a
- 10:06celebrity. And because it was both public
- 10:09and private Private alumina Zone, how we consider our place
- 10:14as human beings, both men and women in the natural world.
- 10:19One of the things I'm sensing is that, or at least I'm making,
- 10:25I'm getting the impression that maybe we should be more
- 10:27forgiving of someone who was essentially like the equivalent
- 10:31of the Billionaire's of today, right?
- 10:34I mean, well actually the person that I would say and his pains
- 10:39me before That's me to say this but in some ways she's Martha
- 10:42Stewart, okay? If you think of Martha Stewart,
- 10:45okay? She made a fortune out of making
- 10:50simple life. Correct.
- 10:52You could, you could live in your country house, you could
- 10:55have wonderful women's. You could make great meals
- 11:00miraculously. Now if we're Antoinette, really
- 11:02did have all that staff to allow her to do it miraculously.
- 11:05So it was my first Stewart but this idea of simple living of
- 11:08Getting Back To Nature and being simple, really.
- 11:10Ali. And then you know my internet
- 11:12had scandals with her diamonds. Martha went to prison for her
- 11:16wall screen, you know and but you know, Martha survived Marie
- 11:19Antoinette to not. We met gives it a sense of
- 11:22tragedy and Destiny that makes her all the more intriguing.
- 11:26You know. How could it be that a queen
- 11:28was, you know, the headed. So what I would say is that she
- 11:32is a celebrity and she is and we should think of her as a
- 11:37celebrity, but that doesn't mean that Way that we understand
- 11:41celebrity in contemporary culture is exactly the same.
- 11:44At that time, what an alternative way might be is and
- 11:48she came up with the strategy of I'm going to present myself as
- 11:52being natural maternal, I'm going to educate my children in
- 11:57my garden. The garden is an extraordinary
- 11:59space of allegory and fertility, which is important to the state
- 12:02of France, but that strategy didn't work.
- 12:06It was a great strategy. Martha Stewart picked it up but
- 12:10But it didn't work in 18th century because of political and
- 12:16economic changes that she nor her husband, nor the court were
- 12:20equipped to see. So, I mean, I guess if there
- 12:24were to be, if there was to be resentment and and animosity
- 12:27toward the Royal Court, obviously the King was seen as
- 12:32lavish and excessive and, you know, people revolted for a
- 12:35reason, but should we have put money on to a net sort of In
- 12:40that same, should she have been the target of the same ire, you
- 12:45know, because women at the time, you know, what did they have,
- 12:49what kind of influence could they have had over there over
- 12:52the Kings politics? You know, and she was sort of
- 12:55born into this Royal life but this isn't her.
- 12:59I'm just trying to understand. I think we have a tendency now
- 13:02to you know, categorically believe that the wealthy and the
- 13:06people with such power are necessarily Abusing such power
- 13:12and and there isn't the same sort of forgiveness for people
- 13:16who are in these great systems of wealth except my Antoinette,
- 13:18it's not like she had a fully easy life and she sort of was
- 13:22brought into this without much of her own accord.
- 13:25You know, should we be more forgiving of her?
- 13:28I don't know if forgiving is the word.
- 13:32I think that what we can do is try to have a certain Give, and
- 13:40that corrective is what was the context that she was living in?
- 13:44What was she able to do? So, in that sense, and that is
- 13:48in some ways, I can discuss it this way.
- 13:52She was the patron of Eugenia belong.
- 13:53So she was the patron of the female artist and she gave her
- 13:57extraordinary capacities to do, extraordinary work suit, Unix
- 14:03ordinary portraits, and works of art.
- 14:04And so she helped female painters allowed to go Dedicated
- 14:12her Declaration of the rights of women to Marie Antoinette
- 14:15thinking that the queen could intervene to help her.
- 14:19And let's remember that the women who were guillotined in
- 14:22the revolution where Guillotine two weeks after the queen.
- 14:26So there was a moment that some activists women actually thought
- 14:32that she was able to give a voice to another.
- 14:40Give give a female voice, it's important to say that and to
- 14:45understand it again in context, but that's not the same thing as
- 14:48making a kind of proves BBC. Feminist icon TV series that
- 14:54changes her into a contemporary character from today, I wasn't
- 14:58able to watch it. You know, full disclosure, I
- 15:01watched the trailers and I couldn't stand it because it's
- 15:05not fair to go back into history and make her To a contemporary
- 15:11celebrity. Like as if is, if she's
- 15:15completely identifiable, she knew she was in a court system.
- 15:19She was much more learned than we give her credit.
- 15:21We have much more information about her libraries and her
- 15:24books. And when her husband kind of
- 15:27broke down in the end of the revolutionary period in the
- 15:311790s, she was the one who really started to engineer
- 15:34things even as a prisoner. So it's impossible to think that
- 15:37this woman all of a sudden became engineering All kinds of
- 15:42strategies of survival as if she was on, learned, for the first
- 15:46eight years before that, it's just not possible.
- 15:49Do we have to kind of reassess how we knew know her and that's
- 15:54been done through works of wonderful historians, who have
- 15:56looked at her letters and that's important to understand and to
- 16:01try to fight against this Marie, Antoinette, washing that seems
- 16:05to be make her something that can be.
- 16:10Easily identified with when, in fact, it's another time period,
- 16:14right? And just for listeners to
- 16:17clarify, you're referring to the, you mentioned, the BBC and
- 16:21cannot produce series that was called Mount Wynette.
- 16:23And it was, you know, had lots of sumptuous costumes and the
- 16:26backdrops were amazing. And but as you say horse
- 16:30historians, like you yourself, have called it grotesque and
- 16:34full of historical inaccuracies. And that there's this desire to
- 16:37Rebrand her as a feminist icon. But It's really taking it too
- 16:41far to go back to the rights of women at the time, you know,
- 16:48you're talking about her coming up in this court system.
- 16:51What should listeners keep in mind when we think about what?
- 16:54Freedoms existed for women at that time, specifically, in the
- 16:58Royal Court? I mean, I think the assumption
- 17:00is that they were very privileged and affluent and that
- 17:03ultimately inspired the revolution, but is it really
- 17:07that simple? I mean, you started to address
- 17:08this by saying she She was supporting female painters and
- 17:13she, you know, was trying to educate her children and there
- 17:16were, you know, so it wasn't just that she was interested in
- 17:18frivolous aesthetic matters but what else should we understand
- 17:22about that time? Well I think that women in the
- 17:26Ancien régime you know in that period prior to the revolution
- 17:30actually had a certain amount of autonomy they were able to it
- 17:36depending on which class of society were written for
- 17:39aristocratic women. They were able to.
- 17:46Patronize support causes help other women.
- 17:50Contribute to charitable causes when they were educated.
- 17:53They got an enormous amount of freedom, very briefly in the
- 17:56revolution. And then it was all taken away
- 17:59by the period of the terror was gone.
- 18:01And by the time we get to the Napoleonic codes in 1804, it's
- 18:06really a terrible situation for women.
- 18:10After that, the patriarchal order of the Civil codes of
- 18:131804. I think that women in France
- 18:17still suffer from that. Today, I would agree with you,
- 18:21but also, it's so interesting than that.
- 18:22The French are. So, I mean, I think Americans,
- 18:25when we study French history and we study Napoleon, we do not
- 18:28have a very positive impression of his Reign and everything that
- 18:32he did. And yet the French tend to take
- 18:34a softer stance on him. Everyone, I talked to sort of
- 18:38will point to some of the good things he did.
- 18:40Whether it was, you know, even for setting up the gosh, what is
- 18:44it called? The, the The the central colse
- 18:46of Judaism even or Judo Jewish matters, we will that I mean,
- 18:51yes. I mean, he, there's no question.
- 18:53He was incredible statement, incredible military strategist.
- 18:59There are things that he established for France that we
- 19:02still live with today that are, you know, part of the social
- 19:05State, you know, the sense of a function are meritocracy.
- 19:11It was militarily trusted, but in one particular area, The
- 19:15rights of women. It was completely catastrophic,
- 19:18completely catastrophic. And if you don't mind at that
- 19:21point, it's very interesting to bring in the two other women in
- 19:25my book, which is Mary Louise and Josephine.
- 19:29So, Josephine was someone who grew up under the Ancien régime,
- 19:33people don't know Josephine. As much as they know the
- 19:35mortgage issues, she was born on Martinique, she was married into
- 19:40an aristocratic family who had slaveholding property.
- 19:44She herself Came from a slaveholding.
- 19:47Family in Martinique, she was able to be a incredible Patron
- 19:54in some ways like Marie Antoinette, who relished her
- 19:58connection to planter Society across the Atlantic and helped
- 20:02Napoleon with his Imperial Ambitions.
- 20:06For not only the Atlantic, but when that failed after he tried
- 20:10to invade Haiti as well as Imperial Ambitions to go into
- 20:14the It. And she used her Gardens to
- 20:19support these Imperial Ambitions.
- 20:21Again, the garden became a place for her to support her husband,
- 20:25to Judah to create this incredible support.
- 20:29The colonial Imperial Mission and that Colonial history.
- 20:32You know, it's very difficult to associate that with the history
- 20:34of women in particular and particularly women in power.
- 20:38So that's something I discussed quite a lot and then, of course,
- 20:41because she couldn't have an air, which was so important to
- 20:44Napoleon. And the Empire.
- 20:47She was divorced for no no to did Marie Antoinette's great.
- 20:49Nice and how you do. He's the Revival of Marie
- 20:52Antoinette which it also influenced Josephine to a
- 20:55certain degree, really came back from 1809 to 1815 you know with
- 21:02a complete restoration of Marie Antoinette's Gardens which had
- 21:05been vilified During the Revolution.
- 21:07So it's a very interesting way of thinking about how these
- 21:11women each, then start turning to Marie Antoinette, know what
- 21:14you did is a This way to go to legitimize and distinguish
- 21:18themselves in the relationship to their husbands over time.
- 21:21She becomes kind of an inspiration.
- 21:23It's not the same thing as saying that she's a feminist
- 21:26icon. But what she was able to
- 21:27establish in a particular space became influential, so
- 21:32fascinating, I mean just the the role of Napoleon in upholding
- 21:37slavery and actually reinstating it a second time after had first
- 21:41been abolished. I mean, I really don't think
- 21:43they're teaching that properly in this.
- 21:45Country. You know, I learned about it,
- 21:47actually. From taking a write a report.
- 21:51Yeah, one of his walking tours on, you know, black history.
- 21:54And, and I'll tell you that, you know, there's a little statue in
- 21:57the Luxembourg Gardens related to this and yet, you know, I
- 22:02don't know. I don't get the sense that many
- 22:03people know that France had sort of abolished it and then
- 22:06reinstated it in there the only country to have done that.
- 22:08But anyway, it's a separate topic.
- 22:11Well, you know, I must say in the big Napoleonic Exhibition at
- 22:16At Levi let they did do. They did try but they did
- 22:21address it. I mean there has been an attempt
- 22:23to address it but I think the ramifications and understanding
- 22:29Napoleon's actions is part of a larger.
- 22:31Global trade policy is what underpinning the colonial
- 22:36project which for him was actually not very successful.
- 22:39And his Colonial project was not worked, you know, and so France,
- 22:46lost most of its colonies. But the fact that it took
- 22:49another than 30 40 years for the assembly to come back and say no
- 22:54this is not what we want to do, ironically at the hotel de
- 22:58lamartine. In 1848, it's another history.
- 23:03It's another history. So I want to bring it back.
- 23:05Also to sort of contemporary issues, obviously, you know,
- 23:08that I looked at the myth of the Polynesian in my book and trace
- 23:12it back to who. So, who you also talk about and
- 23:15his depictions of women to what extent do you think that the
- 23:18stories of my Antoinette in the other women that you, you know,
- 23:22these empresses, how does that relate to the modern Parisian
- 23:25woman? You know, I mean, you started to
- 23:27address the, you know, parallels.
- 23:28I mean, arrested to know sort of what you see as the biggest
- 23:31connection. Well, I guess that what I would
- 23:35like to say is if we leave Martha Stewart behind, what I'd
- 23:40like to say is, wouldn't it be wonderful to be able to look at
- 23:46Marie Antoinette, and all of the parties in that you presented?
- 23:51I mean, in fact, she was active in all of those areas she was
- 23:55active in, Furniture production, she was active in landscape
- 24:01architecture. She was active in cosmetics.
- 24:05She was active in textiles. She was active in porcelains,
- 24:10though, in many ways, she was an entrepreneur, she was sending
- 24:15herself up as a celebrity who could through her taste at the
- 24:20time, help support the state and help all of these industries and
- 24:27in In ways you'd like to be able to take all of the women in your
- 24:29book and say gee, she was able to relate to all of them.
- 24:32Jewelry and biggest Scandal will be diamonds. 17, there's all
- 24:35kinds of ways to think of that. Unfortunately, that's not what
- 24:38happened. I think what happened is the
- 24:40exact opposite of what you were able to debunk in your book.
- 24:44Is that in some ways? She became the iconic moccasin,
- 24:50she became that, you know, perfectly styled, everything in
- 24:54tuned, wonderful, and maybe that's why she's so, Popular is
- 24:58because the myth of the parties Yen and the myth of Marie
- 25:01Antoinette, almost Collide and crashed and then create this
- 25:06Mythic idea of the perfectly costume perfectly cosmetic and
- 25:10you can and you can buy it. You can just buy it if you buy
- 25:13enough, you know, if you buy enough because many Cosmetics,
- 25:16if you buy enough fashion, you'll be able to and I think
- 25:22there's that sense that that's what also keeps the obsession
- 25:26with Marie Antoinette alive. I've to lesser extent with
- 25:28Josephine because Josephine did very much the same thing
- 25:31certainly with Eugenie. We never really talked about
- 25:33Eugenie but usually understood this completely about Marie
- 25:37Antoinette and Eugenie did exactly the same thing.
- 25:40He was at the top of her top of her game in terms of Arts
- 25:45patronage but to a certain image that, you know, get perpetuated
- 25:50and kind of almost culturally informed what the Parisien would
- 25:55become well and they benefited from that.
- 25:57Right? So, there are certain
- 25:58individuals, and I mentioned this in the book to that, there
- 26:01are certain women contemporary figures, who represent the the,
- 26:04the archetype very well and sort of, you know, capitalize on it
- 26:08because it's good for their careers.
- 26:10It's good to make some money, it's, you know, so they don't do
- 26:13a whole lot to challenge these. You know, these long-standing
- 26:18ideas that we have about women. So now that's super interesting
- 26:22to bring bring together that that overlap and you're
- 26:24absolutely right. I mean, if we think about the
- 26:27Girls throughout history that have really that stand out to
- 26:30people. I mean, yes, certainly in a more
- 26:32modern sense, people, might immediately think Catherine
- 26:35Deneuve, they might think of Juliette binoche even to some
- 26:39degree but, you know, always women in the Arts and always
- 26:41women who are, you know, in the spotlight to some degree and an
- 26:45that circulates globally and Mary Antoinette II guess.
- 26:48I hadn't realized how instrumental Sofia Coppola's
- 26:51film would have been in anchoring our association of Of
- 26:57Paris and, and wealth and style to that figure in that film.
- 27:03But anyway, yeah. And then, of course, it's not
- 27:07only her is not only Sophia couple, it was Madonna as well,
- 27:10I mean, you know, Madonna and ENT MTV Award with the cones.
- 27:14So the yeah, not only that, but I think she did it in.
- 27:18I think it was in 1990 when she does the, you know, she
- 27:21literally comes out as Marie Antoinette.
- 27:23And he said, there's a pop culture that keeps this going.
- 27:28In a way that says, her taste was so extraordinary and we are
- 27:32always trying to get back to you, which was extraordinarily
- 27:35important. For example, the goncourt
- 27:36brothers, who thought that she was, you know, absolutely
- 27:41perfect because she had this perfect taste and that notion of
- 27:44taste. And what is that French taste?
- 27:46What is that? What is that French
- 27:47savoir-faire? What is that French?
- 27:49Is in this a call? All of that was comes,
- 27:53completely comes back to Jamaica and even though she wasn't
- 27:56French Originally, yes, yeah, she was in French and she was
- 28:01considered to be the there is that part.
- 28:03There is the education and the Foreigner who could never
- 28:06integrate in that switch. But that has a particular
- 28:08overtone that has to do with revolutionary rhetoric, I think
- 28:11in its modern capacity. That's, that's kind of been
- 28:14Marie Antoinette washed though. That, you know, she's become
- 28:19represent a french-style even though she was even though she
- 28:22was a horror of Corey, so when Mary Antoinette was guillotined,
- 28:27If you write that the special prosecutor seized her Gardens as
- 28:30a tangible, materialization of her corruption.
- 28:33So he purported that the gardens were a dangerous place that
- 28:37served as a backdrop for the Queen's clandestine, and
- 28:39counters and impersonations, what was going on here?
- 28:43I mean, what, how did that, how did that Association come to be?
- 28:47And if a woman were to be prosecuted today for such things
- 28:51in Paris, you know, what would be the stand-in for the garden.
- 28:54Oh, gosh. Well, Nina standing Well, I
- 28:59think that they were, they were, there were a number of events
- 29:04that led to thinking that the first of all that she would
- 29:07retired from court and gone to the petite female and made her
- 29:10Gardens there. And only her friends could come
- 29:12meant that this became a place where she was having a private
- 29:15life and was therefore, excluded, and not doing what a
- 29:18good Queen should do. And so, as a result, there was
- 29:20this idea that this was a secretive place.
- 29:23It's also the same moment is beaumarchais in The Marriage of
- 29:26Figaro away. There's all these switched
- 29:28identities. And, you know, this idea that
- 29:32the garden is the place where you could be duplicitous but
- 29:35everything will turn out. All right.
- 29:36In the end. So that there was a cultural way
- 29:39of thinking of the garden is a place a playful place.
- 29:42And therefore, for the Republic, it had to be not secretive
- 29:47because Gardens had been secretive.
- 29:50They always had Amorous places for meeting and unsaturation,
- 29:55father, and a republic. The Republic wanted to make it a
- 29:59transparent space. So getting rid of this secrecy
- 30:02duplicity dissimulation, was part of that agenda.
- 30:06Then of course, there was the diamond necklace Affair where
- 30:09she was accused of stealing these diamonds.
- 30:11She didn't actually do it, but it supposedly happened in the
- 30:13garden. So therefore again, this was
- 30:15someone who was corrupting the court.
- 30:17Many of the ideas that were promoted during her trial are
- 30:20the ones that kept coming back over time, you know?
- 30:22This is why she was a duplicitous frivolous.
- 30:27Asia's disconnected figure were were part of the Revolution
- 30:32where we would see this today, where women being duplicitous
- 30:38are threatening today. In some ways, what we could say
- 30:42is the fact that women are in the public sphere today and are
- 30:45out there marching and being able to manifest it and use
- 30:51their space in the public sphere is what makes them still
- 30:54threatening to. It is the threat today.
- 30:57You know, and I think when we are concerned about who's
- 31:03marching and what they're claiming that that is in some
- 31:07ways, maybe a contemporary space for that.
- 31:11So how much of this do go into on the tours that you lead you?
- 31:14You also run tours. Picturesque voyages or Voyage.
- 31:19How curious are people that you work with about the history of
- 31:23my own toilet? Well, I guess I could say that
- 31:26I'm truly Uli an educator because one of the places where
- 31:32the Marie Antoinette story is the most promoted is obviously
- 31:37the tourist industry. I mean, if you can put a Marie
- 31:41Antoinette label on it, it becomes something that people
- 31:46want to know more about. Now might be that what they
- 31:51expect to learn is closer to the Sofia Coppola movie than what
- 31:56I'm willing to. Tell them but I am happy to have
- 32:01the and feel very lucky to have the possibility to talk about
- 32:06Marie Antoinette and even Josephine.
- 32:09Gatita may know a BSI at Ma Maison to explain the complexity
- 32:14of these figures and explain these Notions of celebrity and
- 32:17what they mean, overtime in the spaces that they actually
- 32:22created in use to create their own identity politics.
- 32:25So I find it a great privilege to be able to do that.
- 32:31Although it might not necessarily be the image that
- 32:35people have expected when they booked the tour.
- 32:39Well, I always say that. It's good that if, you know, if
- 32:41people walk away learning something new and you know,
- 32:43challenges, yes. There are their organs in that
- 32:46complex story. Yeah, it's not nice for more
- 32:48complex. Yeah, I think that's the thing.
- 32:49We have a tendency to reduce a lot of these figures to a very
- 32:53simplified version of what actually happened.
- 32:56So you're sort of Going deeper, so people can find your book, it
- 33:00is an academic quality heavily researched book and we are going
- 33:04to be talking about it at the American Library, sometime in
- 33:07April. So I'll make announcements if
- 33:09that is also open to the public. And in the meantime, if people
- 33:13are coming to Paris, they should absolutely book you for garden
- 33:16and artistic artistic, I say artistic.
- 33:19But, you know, Museum deep Dives because you have such a breadth
- 33:23of knowledge. So Susan, thank you so much for
- 33:25coming on to talk about this, my It is clearly endlessly,
- 33:29fascinating, but hopefully we've given people something else to
- 33:32think about when it when they're thinking about this.
- 33:34This romanticized and maligned character.
- 33:40Thank you very much. It's a pleasure always to push
- 33:43these push, these ideas that sometimes even Academia into the
- 33:47into the public sphere and your work at your own work.
- 33:49Lindsay has allowed me to do me and others to do that and
- 33:53continues to be inspiring. So I think we have to continue
- 33:56this mission of The city and rethinking and challenging.
- 34:00That is so important in many levels for those of us who live
- 34:04here, as well as for those of us who want to visit.
- 34:07So let's keep fighting the stereotypes, Susan, talk to you
- 34:10very soon. Thank you, Lindsay.
- 34:16That's the show for today. As always.
- 34:18Thank you for listening subscribing and sharing with
- 34:21Friends, you can find all previous episodes of The New
- 34:24Parish podcast forever, you stream your podcast and on world
- 34:27radio Paris. If you're enjoying these
- 34:29conversations please consider picking up a copy of the New
- 34:32Paris book for my recent release the new Keynesian from your
- 34:35local book Cycles. Until next time again.
- 34:16That's the show for today. As always.
- 34:18Thank you for listening subscribing and sharing with
- 34:21Friends, you can find all previous episodes of The New
- 34:24Parish podcast forever, you stream your podcast and on world
- 34:27radio Paris. If you're enjoying these
- 34:29conversations please consider picking up a copy of the New
- 34:32Paris book for my recent release the new Keynesian from your
- 34:35local book Cycles. Until next time again.