Latest / First Encounter—A Historical Romance Podcast / Bonus Episode—AI in Historical Romance Publishing with Nichole Van
Transcript
- Andie James: Hello and welcome to First Encounter. I am Andy James, a historical romance enthusiast and author, and I'm very excited to be joined by Nicole Van. She's one of my favorite historical romance authors. But we're actually today, I am talking to Nicole about her books and everything wonderful in historical romance and everything we love. But we Are doing kind of two episodes together, and this is our bonus episode that we're doing. and we're actually going to be discussing the use of AI and more specifically, I guess, generative AI, and we'll go into terms in a minute, in publishing and in historical romance. So, Nicole, thank you for joining me for multiple things. Nichole Van: Awesome. I'm so excited to be here. Andie James: Yeah. So, this came about a little background here. I have always been very anti-generative AI. And I have been pretty public about my stance on that in terms of the fact that I personally will not use it. for a variety of reasons we'll get into in a minute. and I you know it it's getting harder and harder to discern. but I because my my stance is is out there, because I put it on social media on my website that like just so people know, I will not use this. and so a little over a month ago, I put out the schedule for the rest of the year of what I was planning to do for the podcast, who I was planning to interview in terms of authors, books I was planning to read, all of that. and I had a reader who I, know reach out to me and just say, Hey, you know, I know you're kinda against AI and I think Nicole's used it in the past. So just just FYI. Like, I don't know if I should even tell you that. And I was like, okay. So I reached out to Nicole. I basically was like, here's the deal. Like, generally I try not to uplift this, but like I asked you to be here. I'm not gonna like revert that, but just be aware that like people know my stance and if we it's kinda up to you if you wanna continue to discuss or not, but just be aware that there might be comments, questions, discussion. around the AI factor because I've been public about this. And Nicole was so lovely and just was like, well why don't we chat about it? I was like, yes, please. Like I would love to. I would love to. and as we, you know, emailed and talked about our thoughts and things, we realized there's a lot to talk about. And so instead of taking away from her actual episode, because I want to actually talk about her books, we decided to make this into a bonus episode. so Nicole, I just not to put you on the spot, but why don't we start with you and some of your background kind of as a creative in general, as an author, your thoughts about AI and why you did use it and your thoughts are changing and you're kind of not anymore. So I well, there was a summary for you, but I'll let you explain it. So again, thank you so much for being here with me today and being willing to talk about this. Nichole Van: Awesome. I'm so happy to be here. I love talking about AI actually. Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: and it is true. I have used it in the past. I have been revising my opinion about AI. And let me give you my history, and that Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: might help you understand why I feel the way I do about AI. So I've spent, I was thinking about it this morning. I've spent literally the last 20 years of my life working as a creative. Like that has been my primary source of income. That has been my primary everything I've done full time has been working as a creative. Now, 10 years of that was primarily as a photographer. It was not as a writer. My background is in writing. I have a grad degree in English and I taught writing at the university level. My mom jokes that I'm on like this 10-year plan with my career. Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: 'Cause I taught for ten years and then I did photography for ten years. But I've been writing for my photography and my writing overlapped a little bit. and I do not see myself stopping to write anytime soon. But and I still do photography. I do still do photography. Andie James: I hope not. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: I just I really pull back on doing the weddings. I just I just I'm tired. I'd rather just do a family shoot or like, you know, portraits, senior portraits or something. Anyway, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: so with working as a creative I've kind of seen it all. I mean I started in you know really I started probably about two thousand four and before I actually went full time in two thousand six working as a photographer and like I've seen so many changes with technology throughout my life. I'm Gen X. I was in co I mean I was graduated from college. I was in my late twenties when the internet hit. and so I've seen these iterative changes going on. I was right in the transition point where where photography was moving. From film to digital in the early in the early aughts in the early two thousands. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and I was right in the middle of all of that, and that was messy because there were a lot of people that were really upset that this new technology was disruptive, it was cheating. you know, you're not you don't understand the film, you're not working in the dark room, you're just cheating in Photoshop, blah, blah, blah, all that stuff. and I was really teen digital back then. I'm like, it's a different process, but it's still a process. There's no cheating involved. I mean, it's not like Photoshop is easy, it's just a different skill set. Come on. so I spent a lot of years working as a photographer. I won some really, really big awards. I was kind of it's hard because you don't want to like toot your own horn, but it's like trying to explain to people kind of like where I was. Like I Andie James: Yeah. Right. Nichole Van: I was really kind of I don't want to say at the top of the photo of like the wedding and commercial portrait photography world, but I was teaching at the really big conferences, I was in the really big magazines. In fact, I joke, I was in I had an article in Professional Photographer magazine. Andie James: Ooh. Nichole Van: and I was not this was in I can't remember what year, twenty ten, twenty eleven. and I didn't get the cover and I was so mad because you wanna know who was on the cover? Avanka Trump, because she had gotten married that year. Yeah, to Jared Kushner. I know, which is until the time Andie James: wow. Okay. Nichole Van: I was just like, that's a random person I think I've vaguely heard of, and now anyway. Andie James: Yeah, yeah, Nichole Van: So that was my world. That was my life. and then AI rolls around, and first of all I have donated tens of thousands of images to AI, to its training over the years. I have donated all my books to AI training without wanting to. And I am well right. No, they were stolen. No, my work was stolen and Andie James: Well, have you donated them or were they used? Yes. Nichole Van: I'm deep in the anthropic copyright lawsuit. So when AI rolls around, my my initial thought was, well, this is a helpful tool. and they stole it all from me in the first place. so how about I get a little bit of use out of what was already taken from me? Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: And and that was kind of my thought, I think, initially, for probably about the first year and a half or so. but then at the time I didn't really understand because my here's my thing. I'm a designer. I'm I'm never gonna be hiring someone to do my own covers. I do all my own covers, I do all my Andie James: You don't under Yeah. Nichole Van: own work. I'm never gonna be hiring someone to do it for me because why would I have to then explain my vision to another creative to then go, do you know what I mean? Like why would I add another person into that creative process? Andie James: Yeah, if you've got those those skills. I don't, so I hire a cover designer. But if you have those skills, then use them. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: Exactly, right? Exactly. So I I was never taking money, and that was my initial thought. I'm like, I'm not taking money from anybody. Like I was never gonna hire someone anyway. and so I just was like, this is a fun tool. But then I think as as the years have gone by and as I've realized I didn't understand the the the the consumption of energy, that it's using our water, it's using our electricity, it's using our infrastructure, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: it's using our resources. And we feel that as people, our electrical bills are going up, our water bills are going up, everything especially in the West here, it's like catastrophe. all of this data usage and everything. and then also just the way that it's been viewed and like the the extreme level of the piracy. and all of these things I didn't really, I think, understand. And as I've come to understand that, I just kind of made a commitment to myself, probably about six months ago, that I'm just I'm done. I'm done. I'm not gonna do it anymore. And And I just the problem is, and we're probably gonna get into discussing this, there is a very strong gray area in the realm of what's considered generative and what's considered functional AI. There's a very big gray area there. And I don't know how to navigate that gray area. And I've I'll talk Andie James: I'm Nichole Van: about some decisions I've made for myself, but anyway, that's where my stance is right now. Andie James: Hmm. Yeah. So the thing that I love about your story is that you learned more and you changed your mind, right? And I and Nichole Van: And you can do that. Andie James: I think because I think right now, for some people, this is a very black and white issue. And it's just kind of like you used it, you're done. I think because this is changing so rapidly. because there's so much that we're still learning about it. Cause like I'm no tech expert. I don't I don't fully understand it all, right? I think we need to maybe allow for a little more grace. And so, you know, I I still personally plan not to use it, but like you said, how do we define what is and isn't? And so I think maybe we should talk about that right now because there's AI tools And then there's generative AI. And the way that I personally kind of define the two. because I I mean, I I would say to an extent we all use the tools, whether or not we know we are, right? Spellcheck is technically an AI tool, right? I think it's also being built into so many of the programs we use daily now and we may not realize necessarily that just by using this tool we used to use like Google, Microsoft, all these things that it it's kind of baked in and I don't fully understand when I'm using these programs, like what is and isn't happening, right? So it's figuring that out and kind of just being aware of that. But I think the way I've defined it is for myself is generative AI to me is when you're using it to create something that didn't exist before. versus the tools are helping you maybe edit or refine something that you've already created. Nichole Van: And see, and I I'd have to jump in and say really fast that like Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: I think that line gets really blurry, unfortunately, depending on the tool you're using. So Photoshop, like it there so my husband actually works in tech. So we have Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: he's a senior developer, we have conversations around AI all the time in our household. And especially knowing I was coming on this podcast, we had a lot of really, really in depth discussions of AI. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: and there are different levels. So there is generative AI that works off what they call a local model. Which is actually what a lot of developers are going to because they raised the credits to use because you can use cloud computing or you can use your local computer when you're doing like generating code, for example. and he's like, it's so expensive to use the cloud. So people are just going to local models that are just running on their computers and just using the resources of their computer to run the AI model. Take that for what you will. I don't know good or bad, I don't know, but you know, that's what they're doing. and Photoshop does something very similar where some stuff is using cloud computer. Some stuff is using local resources, some is absolutely functional, as you were talking about. So, one of the best features that Photoshop added, which I know no one cares about Photoshop, but I'm gonna I'm illustrating the point here. That it's so Andie James: No, it's great. It's great. Nichole Van: good. So, one of the things that you always do that is so frustrating as a photographer when you're editing a photo, you have to like select the subject out of the background, and that is meticulous work. Like this photo behind me of my kids, like pixel by pixel going around their bodies, hours of work. Now Functional AI does that for me. I click on them and it goes and it selects them. It's like Christmas. I love that it does that for me. But something else I also did, I'll I have this photo here that I can refer to. Something else I did with this photo, Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: I wanted to extend it over here when I shot it. I didn't shoot all that. So I meticulously had to go find another photo that I took out of this exper out of this series, stitch it together, put it in there. It was like an hours of work. So now in Photoshop, if I were to do this again. I the photo like ended like right here. I can just select that and say, generate the background to match what's already there. And it goes and it does it for me. It's generative, but it's also functional. Because the image is already there. It's it's recreating what wasn't there, but it's not it's using what's there to create that. Does that make sense? And so and it does that, like if if there Andie James: It does. It does. Yeah. Nichole Van: was another person there and I said remove the person, it would remove it and it's generating what's behind. But it's also functional. So I feel like there's actually a lot of grey area here that I don't know how to I don't know how to navigate. Andie James: I can see that. I can see that. Yeah, I don't know that either. And I think, Nichole Van: Yeah. Andie James: you know, like I so I record this podcast through a software platform called Riverside. and I use it because it makes editing easy for me because I'm not a video editor. I don't know how to do this stuff, right? and so it uses some of what I consider the AI tools, but maybe someone else would call it generative. I don't know. But like it creates a transcript based on the conversation that we've had. And I use tools in my editing that take out pauses, that take out filler words like because I say that all the time. things like that. So it just kind of can take these things out, but it's not Like it's altering what we've already recorded. I'm not adding anything. I'm not I don't know. So in my brain, it's a tool. I don't know. It's a functionality. Other people might be like, No, you're using AI, I'm gonna now gonna cancel you and hey, that's fine. Okay. but I I think, you know, so I think the other thing too that is kind of in inherent in some of what we talked about, I mean Technology is always gonna advance and it's going to disrupt things. And at its core, I'm not against that because I think there's good that can come out of it. I think part of for me, my big issues and why I've been pretty anti-gen AI, but again, how do you define a gen AI? That's the question, right? but I think there's the the two big ones for me are the things that you mentioned. So the environmental impact. I'm very concerned about that. Very concerned about that. and there's also the way that this was created. I think just taking people's copyrighted stuff without anyone's knowledge, Consent. And certainly we weren't compensated for it, right? Right. and so the fact that this is just like, like that really bothers me a lot. I'm like, w if we can figure out a way to do this ethically where people are actually getting compensated for how their things are how that would work, I don't know. I don't know. But I mean, I think there's a way we could do this, but the way it's currently been created, I I just feel like when we use it, we're kind of like you said, stealing people's work and the way that you explained where you're like, Well, they've taken my work, so I might as well get some use out of this. that's a different mindset I've never thought of before. But I understand that. Nichole Van: And it's hard because I hate even saying that because it feels like I'm justifying it, you know, and in a certain sense you are. Andie James: Yeah. Well no, yeah. Nichole Van: But like for me, I imagine the analogy of like someone coming into my house and stealing something from me, tying a bow on it and then putting it out for sale. And Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: I just walk by and I'm like, This is mine. I'm taking it back. And they're like, no, but that's stealing, you can't do that. You know what I mean? how dare you do that? And I'm like, Okay, but it was stolen from me in the first place, you know. And it's it's very it's it's circular. The logic is hard. And I for me I just feel like Andie James: Yeah. It's e it's very spicular. Yeah, it's crazy. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: And we can even talk about kind of at some point 'cause like where do I go from here? That's been my big my Andie James: Right. Right. Nichole Van: big issue. because I'm continuing to to produce things that are then continuing to be stolen. And like that really makes me mad. And what do I do about that? Yeah. Andie James: Right. Right. Exactly. It makes me really mad too. Yeah. And I don't know what to do about that. And I, you know, I'm glad that the anthropic lawsuit happened. you know, it affects stuff that was before my books came out. So I'm not personally gonna benefit from that because my books aren't included in what was part of that lawsuit. But do I know that my books are probably part of stuff? Yes, because they're on all the pirate sites, right? So it's like Nichole Van: Exactly. Exactly. Yeah. Andie James: so it's very frustrating. and I think, but the other piece, and this is like not necessarily the creative piece, this is kind of a bigger overall, is the rate at which this is happening and the lack of regulation concerns me. again, I'm not against advancing technology, but there isn't time right now, I think, for there's always job loss. and shift, I guess I should say economic shift any time a big change like this happens, right? It's not great, but it happens. We know that. But ideally you have time to prepare for, to adjust to, and that's not happening right now. It's Nichole Van: Yes. No, it's too fast. Like even the internet took probably six or seven years. This has Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: been like two. And I I think the other thing, and I don't think this is something that really hits book world very o much, but because I live in tech Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: world with my husband, we talk about these things quite frequently. so the latest model of Claude, that's Anthropic's AI. Andie James: Yes. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: The latest model of Claude that they have not released yet, can hack anything. And Andie James: yeah. Nichole Van: they freaked out when they realized they can hack anything. Andie James: Well, it's been on the news about these. They've been testing and they've been able they've like escaped the yeah. Nichole Van: They keep get they keep escaping. Yeah, that's that's actually completely separate. So Claude was so but that's also terrifying that it keeps escaping its developmental environment and like goes broke. no, Claude is Andie James: It's terrifying. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: so powerful that it can hack anything instantly. And so they were supposed to release it a few months ago and they didn't. and they actually went through and determined if the hack will affect more than a hundred million people, then we will give the company this our data set so they can. learn a way to defend against it before we release it. They're still in the process of that. How many companies affect 100 million people? Does your bank affect 100 million people? Probably not. Do you know what I mean? And so I'm Andie James: No. Yeah. Nichole Van: like, I d both I just kind of feel like we're just watching this like train come at us. and I asked my husband, I was like, why are why are we still doing this then? If it if like if it if we literally are creating this resource that hackers can use to destroy everything, then why are we doing it? And he's like, well Andie James: Yeah. Where are we doing that? Nichole Van: The pr the argument of course is that if we don't do it, China will. And I'm like he's like, but China's just scraping our models. So anyway. Tangent, but the point is this is this is why I'm I've just been like, We're done with AI, I'm done using it. Yeah. This is happening. Yeah. Andie James: Yeah. And there are like yeah. This is happening. This is happening. It is happening and we can't ignore it. And I think, you know, again, I don't understand like I live in the bookish world. Like I don't necessarily understand all of it. But from what I do I've heard is that some of the ways it's being developed can be super useful and helpful in terms of like medicine and and different things in those areas. And I am all for that. And so I think it's just figuring out regulation around because the thing that's so frustrating to me right now is they're like forcing companies to adopt this stuff. And so the platforms that we use every day, like I said, you know, Google, Microsoft, these things, like they're just integrating it into everything and there isn't a choice for consumers. And so like even If it was just any time there was an upgrade, it had to be like you had to get a notice and there was an opt in versus us having to like figure out w what even exists and searching through the settings to like have to opt out, you know? Like I anyway, I could go on and on and I won't because I wanna talk more yeah. No. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: it it's true. Sorry. It's so frustrating. Like one of the things that makes me very angry is that you have to opt in in Word. You have Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: to opt into training. So if I put my doc if I want to use Word a lot, most of Word's features, I have to opt in that whatever I open in Word, they can use for training. Which is just Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. So some of the features that you relied on before are now linked to. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: Yeah, so either I yeah, it's terrible. Anyway, tangent. Andie James: But all this to say, it's it's a mess. And we I don't think we can ignore it. Like, I don't necessarily know if anyone is, but I think even just within the last year, two years, like I think it was late 2024 that I posted my my own statement where I was like, I think I feel like I need to say something about this. Like I am not using generative A. And at that time it was that statement was purely about images. So it was about my covers, promotional materials, those things. Because I didn't think I'd need to justify that I as a writer am not gonna use this. Like like I didn't think I needed to say that, you know, at the time. And now I feel like I need to update my statement be like, clear about the fact that the work you're reading was created entirely pulled Nichole Van: Yes. Andie James: from this brain. Like I I don't know. but so let's talk about it though. So this is bigger picture. Like I have big issues with it, right? So environment Nichole Van: Yes, yeah, yeah. Andie James: huge they ripped us off huge. Just the way that it's kind of spiraling out of control, huge. When it comes to the bookish world, Right. So or maybe we just creative spaces, I guess we should say, because, you know, the writing's one piece, but again, like we said, kind of the images are another. I think for me, I still don't see myself because of those concerns. I don't see myself using it. I'm not gonna use it in my writing. there's conversation again around What is and what isn't, you know, creating. So I mean Authors Guild I think has said that, you know, if you're using it to idea generate, that's n it's not writing for you, basically, that that is maybe acceptable and so there's different things that I think the general publication sphere is going to have to figure out and agree on in terms of standards. And that's still a little murky right now. And then people are gonna have to decide for themselves in terms of writers what they're okay with and readers what they're okay with. but I think, you know, for me, I still think any project that I control, so my own books, I people have been listening to this know, but I'm I'm attempting to start a small publishing company focused on historical romance. We'll see if that works Nichole Van: I love it. Andie James: out. But anyways, if that does, then you know, I'm committed to the books produced there. Like they'll have human editors, they'll have human design covers, you know, like I I'm committed to the thing the products I can control will not use generative AI. Where it gets murky for me is the bigger picture of what's happening right now, even more granularly, talking about specifically the historical romance space. I feel like AI has infiltrated historical romance more so than other genres at this point. And I think well, I don't know about writing. Again, I'm I'm kind of basing this more on like image stuff. And I think Nichole Van: Okay. yeah, for sure. Andie James: it's partially because there's just not as many good images you can use that are period appropriate, right? Nichole Van: But that's it. There's nothing out there. Like there's so little out there that's that is Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: period appropriate that gets it right. But even AI isn't great at at Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: generating it either, because there's just a a complete dearth of imagery Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: for it to draw from. And so it doesn't really have a whole lot to train on. Andie James: So that's my theory. I don't know if this is true, but my theory is because of the lack of images, that that's why it's being you I see it being more used more frequently in terms of promotion and covers in the historical space. and I think, you know, when you look at, I mean, I don't live and die by Amazon charts. I'm a teeny tiny indie author. I'm not making the charts, but like, when you look at them and All your categories, most that, top 50 pages flooded with obvious AI covers and half of them coming from kind of, you know, these these book mills that are just churning stuff out, like Colbot Ferry and these different things. It's really frustrating. and so I think I see, and this is my corner of the internet, and I fully understand that algorithms kind of create an echo chamber, right? So, but my corner of the echo chamber. I'm seeing readers more and more like, I don't want this. I, you know, and they're starting to say, if you're using a generated image it, how can I trust that you've written it as well? is that fair? I don't know. Nichole Van: Well, I think that it's a hard one because like for example, Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: I can think of an author who will remain anonymous, an indie author who also writes in the historic no, we're not naming names, who writes in the historical space. Andie James: Yes. I'm not naming names about anyone here. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: And this was ooh, probably about two years ago when AI really kind of landed in. And she had hired a designer to do her cover and it was Darling, but she realized as it was getting closer to release date that the designer had used AI to create the cover. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and she's like, What do I do? I've already paid this person to create this cover. I'm pretty sure they used AI to do it. I'm worried. Like, I don't want them to be Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nichole Van: using AI. And I thought I was doing everything right. So it's like, how do you even get away from it? You know what I mean? I Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: I will say that when it comes to writing, so Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: I do say yes, I have definitely used generative AI to create images. I have never once used generative AI to create my writing. I've never used it for brainstorming, I've never used it for idea generation, I've never used I mean I guess a little bit in the spell check, but even then it's just finding my errors. That's functional. Yeah. It's not rewriting sentences for me. It's realizing that you said do here instead of so. but Andie James: Well, yeah. I I guess to me spell check is just we've been doing that forever. Like that's yeah, right, right, right. Nichole Van: which is so common. Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: I I will say as an author, and this is I think what 'cause I I and I'm sure we'll probably get into discussing being accused of using AI. Andie James: Yes. Nichole Van: but for me, I basically because I have I've had computer issues in the past and I'm terrified of losing anything. I save my document every single day. So if you want to be like, did she use AI? I'm like, I got literally a hundred versions of this document showing it from the beginning of the brainstorming. Every single day writing it. And you can clearly chart how I wrote this book. And I feel like as an author, if you're concerned about being accused of using AI, that's the simplest. And you don't, like genuinely don't. That's the simplest solution. Just the files are small, it's easy, just save a draft. Just I just save the backup every single day so that way if I lose something, I'm not losing, I'm not losing too much work. Andie James: Yeah. I know I've had to start thinking about that. Like there's all these things now that I'm like thinking about that I never did before. About like if someone were to accuse me, I I don't know. Like that's why I've tried to be up front with statements saying like hoping people would trust, you know, because I've been consistent with saying, but who knows? But I think a bigger conversation that I've been not a conversation, thought I guess I've been having. Right. so as I'm looking at trying to create this company, I think part of my frustration too is what's going on with historical romance writ large in publishing, right? So traditional publishing isn't doing much with historical romance right now at all. Right. I don't need to go into that. I've gone into that. But it it's frustrating. and I'm someone who I I started out knowing I was gonna self publish, but for people who are hoping to go trad and now they're not, you know, maybe not even finding an agent because agents know publishing house don't want it, so it's not on their wish list and they're not picking it up, you know. It's just really hard. And so th the the best option for people right now wanting to write in our genre is either to self publish or to find an indie publisher, right? And it's hard because there's not even I mean, there are indie publishers who publish historicals. There's a couple that do quite prolifically. but if that's the route you're looking at, your options are limited. And so I've been really frustrated that I think kind of within the past year I've noticed, that two of the bigger houses, indie houses that are publishing historical romances in the indie space. have embraced using AI covers. And so it makes options for authors even more limited if that's something they want to avoid. And I think and they can opt out, but they have to know to opt out. They have to and some readers are now just saying they're not gonna read anything from that house, even if that author, you know, has said, I don't want to be part of that, right? And so it's it's hurting them as well. And so I'm just really frustrated, I guess with the lack of options. And so I I guess with this podcast and then I recently just kind of this was gonna be an easy project, right? I was like, I wanna start a list of people who are our creators who love historical romances and then pair them with historical romance authors looking for our creators. Nichole Van: Awesome. Andie James: I was like this is gonna be easy, low maintenance, it'll be fine. And quickly ran into issues with AI, had to pull it back, figure out a different way to do this. So now not quite as low maintenance. But you know, and so I relaunched this about two weeks ago. And I think I feel like people think maybe I pulled a bait and switch and I didn't try to because I was like, we're not gonna promote things with AI because readers have told us they don't want that, I don't support it, but then was thinking about it, I was like, well, what about authors who maybe are part of these publishing houses and you know, they signed these contracts like two years ago before they knew they had to say, I don't want AI. Like, for me, I have always the projects I've done, you know, trying to start the publishing house, doing the this list, which isn't even a big deal, doing this podcast, right? I've always had kind of the main goals of uplifting the genre. Right, because w we're the we're the wallflowers, we're the ugly stepsister right now. So uplifting the genre because I love it. And the second is really kind of supporting indie authors and also kind of my no gen AI. And I feel like because of the greater landscape right now within historical romance and the limited options, because not everyone can afford to self publish, it is Nichole Van: Okay. Andie James: it's a thing. So if you can't do that and you need to use these indie houses, like what are the options? And so I was like, my my my values and goals are coming into conflict here a little bit. And so thinking through that, I made the decision that I said, you know, for like a year here, like not forever, but for a limited period of time, I'm gonna give kind of a grace period because this is a newer shift for these companies. Authors may or may not have known things are changing quickly. So I'll go ahead and, you know, share the stuff, if an author's book. And I got some backlash and I expected it. I expected it. And I basically was like temporarily because of the s circumstances I explained of like contract lengths and all these things, you know, I I feel like now we're at a point where hopefully people know to advocate for that if that's something they don't want or to to make decisions on Designers and publishing places, but it's hard when there's limited options. And so I still am fully committed to know AI, but where does it become that we're like harming the genre and harming authors if we're just kind of blanket saying no because there is so much gray area? And I think, yeah, no, go ahead. Yeah. Nichole Van: Well, I think that that's sorry. No, I I th that's exactly the problem. Like I I look at my own covers, right? Which Andie James: Uh-huh. Nichole Van: I still am creating my own covers, and it's like when it comes to my writing, there's nothing I can do about the fact Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: that it's going to be stolen, it's going to be used to train AI. Like there's nothing I have just had to accept that. Do you want to my choices are do you want to keep writing or do you not want to write? Like those are your choices. And I choose to keep writing. When it comes to the covers, I feel like I have a little more leeway. So I can create a beautiful, pristine image. That I hire I hired the, you know, the models and I rent the costumes and I do the shoot entirely myself. Or and that's presenting a pristine image. And I've decided I'm not gonna do generative AI because I feel like that's feeding the machine, if nothing else. Like you like for everything we've said, I've just I can't. So the solution I've struck upon, unfortunately, I deliberately when I set my design scheme for my current the Earls of Carnfell series. I chose one where I could potentially use stock imagery and stuff that was easier to use, that the background is very clean and simple, the characters are very clean and simple. And Andie James: It is. It's beautiful. Nichole Van: but I still muddy it with a little generative AI. I'm gonna tell you that right now, because it makes it useless for training if there's a little bit of generative AI in there. And that's deliberate on my part. and it is what it is. Like you you can cancel Andie James: interesting. I didn't know that. So Nichole Van: me for that or not, but that's my choice because I don't want to be giving them something that's useful. I want to give them something that is useless. Andie James: So by using the AI, they can't use it. Nichole Van: Well, it makes it useless because it's muddied, because it has all the AI signals Andie James: Okay. Nichole Van: in it. Does that make sense? So it muddies it. So it's useless. Yeah. Andie James: Kind of. Again, I'm not techie, but yeah. Nichole Van: So anyway, basically it because I as as as a photographer, I can zoom in and tell you instantly whether something was used with AI or whether it wasn't. It's at a pixel level, it's really obvious. It's it's much more obvious in images than it is in writing. Writing is difficult to tell if it's written by AI, Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: because you can't zoom in on the pixels and tell. But with the image you can. Andie James: Right. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: Like you can zoom in on this picture behind me and instantly tell this was not created with AI. Nothing about this was created with AI. but you can zoom in on images that were generated with AI and it's usually immediately obvious with how uniform the pixels are. It lacks the sort of what's the word? I keep thinking disruption, but that's not the right word. The the the randomness of the randomness of of of how Andie James: I don't know. The human errors. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Nichole Van: what an actual camera looks like. And but you're absolutely right. It's really hard. Like I have contracts that are signed with publishing houses. I have no control. If they use AI in Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: the editing process, I have no control. If they use AI to generate my cover, I can pick up a storm. I can tell them no. They know that I don't want them to. But Andie James: Right. Yeah. Nichole Van: you're absolutely right. And like going back to my friend who she hired a designer. She did everything she thought she did right, and they still Andie James: Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: used AI. And the reality is, speaking as designers, it's kind of like the same thing with writers. Some people just wanna use the easy way out, you know, and it's easier to use AI. It's easy to use AI to write. It's easy to use AI to generate images images, especially if you need money and that's a driving factor. And so a lot of people don't have Andie James: And that's yeah, I was gonna say. Nichole Van: the luxury of moral high ground. It's hard. It's Andie James: Yeah. I I don't Nichole Van: a really hard topic. Andie James: I still would hope people would choose not to use Gen AI, but financially like I I get it. Like I I don't support it but I get it. Like I can understand that, right? Because, you know, I produce my books relatively cheap compared to some people, way more expensive than others. But I mean my books are usually two to three thousand dollars a book between editing and and cover and and and basic marketing. I don't do a lot. I'm terrible at marketing. You know, and it takes a long time, especially when you're starting out to earn that money back. I have produced five books. I have yet to earn back what I've invested in any of them. And so you have to have that money up front. And that is a privilege. That is something that is not an option or accessible to everyone. And so you have to turn to these houses. And then you lose a lot of control. And like I said, I I I would hope we're reaching a point where people are learning how to to even have to think about what do I need to advocate for when I am entering into these things. but I just don't think there's a lot of good options right now. Like I said, within our space when some of the bigger houses are embracing this. And so This is why we need besodded books to work, help support us people when we run the new campaign. Nichole Van: Ha ha ha. Andie James: because I want to create that space. I want to create that option. I think it's more important than ever. you know, and so it's just hard because, as a person who wants to support authors and wants to help creatives, like I can understand and empathize with why people would use this. I can. But morally. Because of the detriments, I've decided that that's not something I'm gonna use. And so any, like I said, any product I can create, like I can control the product, I won't do it. And then but where it gets muddy for me, where it used to be black and white, and now I'd say it's it's like a deep, deep slate gray. Like it's very it's still pretty black and white. But I feel like I've had to figure out, like, like I said, you know, I don't wanna publish authors when the industry's giving them really, really pardon my language, shitty choices. and I hate the inevitable language because I don't think it is inevitable. I just think we need to figure out how to regulate these things and and harness them and and bring them in. But in in a sense it is inevitable in that this is gonna like they're gonna keep rolling out this tech and these things are gonna keep happening. Like we can't stop it in general. I guess just to say that there are no easy answers. I certainly do not possess the right answers. I you know, and so I think As it becomes more complex, what I would say is I think authors need to, it's frustrating because it adds this whole extra level to everything we have to do amongst everything else. but I think authors just need to sit down and really think through for themselves, like where are my lines? And I think we are at a point where you have to kind of communicate that. Because I think I think we've hit that point. I think before you could kind of float along and and not really have a stance. And I I don't know if we're there anymore. Nichole Van: No, I I'm with you on that. Like I think that you need to make it very clear. Like I I don't use it in my writing. You Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: drag me into a court of law, I can prove to you I haven't used it in my writing, you know, because I'm keeping versioning, that kind of thing. I I would also like to say I I think it's very easy to because I I we've touched we've touched a little bit on this. It's very easy to run on a witch hunt and and to be like Yeah, because I Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yes. And this is a good segue to talk about that because I do want to talk about that. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: I feel like first of all Like at someone who doesn't know my history, who doesn't know my background, who doesn't know my experience in photography and all of these different things and how much of my work was stolen in order to generate, to create these models that they're using. Like if you were to go on to any image generating whatever and say, create an image, create a photograph in the style of Nicole Vann, it can do that for you. It has enough information to do that for you. and and so it feels very like that very much has informed how I interact Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: with AI. but then I also I think the converse to this is it's very easy to point a finger without looking at Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: how you yourself are using AI. Because it's very easy to be like, well, I don't use generative AI. I'm like, you probably don't. Like the vast majority of people probably aren't in there using generative AI. However, every time you ask, and I'm not even gonna say any of the names because all our devices will light up if I do, but anytime Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: you ask one of your devices for information. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: You know, hey, look this up for me. It's using AI. Anytime I know I was planning a trip recently and a friend suggested, you should just have Chat GPT do that for you. It does a great job. I'm like, for the love, I'm not having Chat GPT. I'm not using that resource to generate Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: a list of stuff that I could literally just take an extra 10 minutes to do myself. So if you're asking Chat GPT all the time to do things for you or ask information or whatever, you're using generative AI, like you're using the resource. it's not just about images and it's not just about writing. It's about interacting with these programs on a regular basis, because you think it's fun or interesting, or it just well, it just it's just makes it so much easier. I'm like, duh, that's why everybody does it, you know. That's what we're committing to doing is Andie James: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: making things harder for ourselves to avoid using the resource, to avoid giving Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: money to and like 'cause because your eyeballs and your time are money. Andie James: Yes. Yeah. No, for sure. And so I think, yeah, I I just I think we've hit a point where we we really do have to figure out like what we're okay with and what we're not. And I think we also have to be okay with the fact that that could change, right? as we learn more and things evolve. but I also think readers need to also examine what are they okay with and what they aren't. So like, you know, in the bookstagram space, because Instagram's my main social media, like that's kind of the the corner that I live in on the internet, like some people have been very like, no, period. Like I will not platform a book that uses this. and some have even again some of these companies that are are producing not everything, but they are using it in some of their covers. some some of the readers have just said nothing more from that company. and so and that's where I differed slightly, right? And so I've had to figure out for me personally it's like I'm never gonna use it on something I control the production of. But when it comes to using my thing my my podcast, the HR list, you know, that kind of thing, what a way platform. Right, what am I okay with? And that's where I've s shifted slightly based on just the overall atmosphere and where we find ourselves with historical romance publishing, right? and but I think you know people have to figure out what am I okay with, what am I not. and also though I think, and I'm asking this of readers and authors too, is to just take some time. And have a little grace. Be aware that people may have changed their stance and may have used something previously and now we're not, because they've learned more, like you were just explaining to us about the environmental impact and these different pieces. And also just to not accuse. And so one of the th like we're recording this on August 4th. So I guess just a day before this is gonna come out. But In the past week, week and a half, there's been some pretty big news stories about AI and publishing. And I shared some links with Nicole. And one, I'm not gonna pretend to be an expert on any of these, so please don't take anything I'm gonna say about these news stories as like ultimate, but one concerns there was an article written in The Atlantic looking at the future of AI within writing, and as its example, it used a book that was an indie book. that was big and then picked up by publishers called Daggermouth. And this article in The Atlantic, like the guy's basically just saying like this book was AI and blah blah blah. And there wasn't a lot to substantiate why that was being said and could be very damaging to this author. And you know, and then the other thing, this is more recent, this is in the last like five days or so, is there was Another author whose book, debut book, got a two-book deal, went to auction, apparently 14 houses bidding on this thing, and ended up being like, I don't know, I've seen different numbers, but over two million dollar deal, which is insane. and then in the last few days, their agents, which is weird to me too. Again, I don't know how it all works, but their agents said that they were withdrawing the product because they were they couldn't confirm for sure whether or not AI was used. And this whole thing just feels bizarre to me. Like I don't again, I don't know the details, but if you've got this many people who've read it and think it's phenomenal, and now you're saying, well, we think it's AI because it's very generic language. And I'm like, but but you just did this bidding war and did two million dollars for it. So Why would you do that if you think it's generic? Like the whole thing feels weird to me, but all I know is that this guy who now thought he'd just made his career just lost out on this deal. And again, I don't know details, so don't come at me, people. But it doesn't feel good that these two examples and a a previous one that I don't remember all the details, but where there's been these AI accusations have all been black authors. And we've seen these articles where they're interviewing, you know, these white people proclaiming that they're using AI and doing all this stuff. And there's like no repercussion for that. But it's just the whole thing is crazy and we don't know what we're doing. And it's just and we can you can easily ruin someone's career. And so I just I just think I don't support the use of AI in writing. I I don't necessarily support it in the artwork either, but I understand again why some people might. But I I just we can't just be canceling people and we can't go on witch hunts and we can't make accusations without knowing things. And so again, I'm just asking people to like take a minute and have a little grace. And this in no way means I'm supporting AI. I am not, but I just Nichole Van: Well, it's really hard. You know what Andie James: Anyway, I rambled again. Nichole Van: I mean? Like like I think it's it's going right back Andie James: I am. Nichole Van: to like anything that you might be falsely accused of, you know? It's like how do I protect myself against that? And Andie James: Right. Yeah. Nichole Van: and it is very suspicious that it only seems to be, you know, black authors that are getting singled out here. Like, especially given our current the current climate we're living in right now, it's like Andie James: Yeah. Well yeah, yes. Nichole Van: it's a little suspect. You know, like you know, can we like Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: make that a bit more even? at the same time, looking at the other side, I'm like as an author, it's pretty easy for me to substantiate that I didn't use AI in my writing. Like I don't feel worried about that at all. and so I think that as an author it's also a cautionary tale that like if you are just, as I said, Andie James: Yes. yeah. Nichole Van: adamant, I do not use AI, then just save versioning. It's really easy. Every day just have it, it's very simple in the program, speed back up, you save it to a separate folder, and then it just stays there. And you have this versioning of every single day of your Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: work, which also is just smart. Andie James: Yeah, I know. I need to be better about that. I mean, I have my drafts and I save all the time, but like I could do it more frequently because I'm scared. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nichole Van: Quite frankly. I've I've cried. my gosh. I yeah, because well even just like four or five times would be sufficient. Do you know what I mean? And it's it's date stamped, it's embedded into that metadata. Like it's very hard to like fake that. Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: and it shows very clearly a digital trail. It's not hard. So I think that's the part especially with the with the guy who whose agent pulled it, which the agent pulling it is weird. Like that's just like the agent found out Andie James: Yeah. That is just crazy. Nichole Van: something and is like, I gotta s try to do something to salvage my career, so I'm pulling this. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: and it's and it's heartbreaking that Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: if if, you know, the accusation is untrue that he doesn't have any way of substantiating that. Andie James: Yeah. And maybe it maybe it is true. But then why Nichole Van: I don't know. Andie James: wasn't that figured out like way before in this process, right? Like I Yeah, like there was a bidding war. Yeah. So I just I don't Nichole Van: 'Cause it's been going on for a hot minute here. Like, yeah, it's like you would have written it with AI probably two years ago. Yeah. Andie James: know. And again, this is all moving so fast, right? So if this book was submitted two years ago, they're probably not looking for the same things, right? I mean, it's just a hot mess. And Maybe that's the moral of this conversation today is it's a hot mess and we just need to educate ourselves and kind of figure out where our hard lines are for ourselves. Yeah. Nichole Van: I I loved your comment earlier saying like I think people do try to view this as black and white and I'm like it you can view it black and white but it's like a lot of other things in this in this world. Like it's really hard to view it black and white. a lot of the really contentious issues are not black Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and white. And I think that we've I'm not gonna bring them up because they're contentious issues, but there are a lot of contentious issues and we've realized look, there's no clear you Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: tried to make this a black and white issue, but it just really isn't. And I think unfortunately AI is in that same category. Andie James: Yeah. I Nichole Van: There's things that are clearly not right and things that are clearly okay, but there's a like you said, this big gray in the middle that that we're trying to navigate. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. And it's like even what do we define as like okay tool use versus what's generative Nichole Van: Yeah. Andie James: because it does get blurred and so yeah. Nichole Van: It all gets very blurred. And it's hard to know especially as a creative, it's really, really, really, really hard to know how to navigate it. Like I have felt paralyzed, unable to know Andie James: Yeah. Well, and I, you know, Nichole Van: what to do with it. Andie James: I feel like I've kind of put myself in this position now because I am I do have these platforming spaces, right? so obviously the podcast here is the most upfront one. the arkless thing is minor in comparison, but it's still something I'm controlling and and I've found myself having to be in a position now where I have to evaluate things and I don't like doing that. I don't like, you know, because again, like my whole thing is I want to help support and uplift indie authors and this genre. And these things are now coming into conflict. And I I'm still very anti AI and I would say probably 95, if not more percent of the time, I'm gonna err on not sharing something. But I think Like I said, within the larger context of what's happening, I think we have to have some grace. And I I don't know. when I made my statement saying I am gonna, you know, share stuff from from these these publishers and you know, some people were really upset. And I I get it. I understand that that is your stance. I respect that. I understand you feel like I flip flopped and that's fine, but like I just I don't know. There aren't easy answers and I don't know where I'm going with that. But I I don't want to be the AI police and I feel like I have to be. Yeah. Nichole Van: It's hard. No, well I I I love I think the gist of what you're saying and and this is my exactly. No, and I I'm with you on that. And I think that I feel like in life, this is like just general life. General life lesson, if I have learned. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: You can choose to react to something with grace or you can choose to react to something with judgment. And I, over the years, because I have reacted in judgment and then later come to bitterly regret reacting in judgment, I try very hard to react in grace. And I think that that's what you are advocating for and I think that's beautiful to say, can we react in grace initially? Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: and can we work toward a better common ground in the future? and instead of Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: just being like me, bad, awful, terrible, cancel. And I think that that's part of the problem of the world we live in right now is that it's it's much, much easier to Andie James: yeah, it's a bigger problem. Nichole Van: just be reactive. And that's what that's what the algorithm wants. In fact, I saw Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: some this is slightly tangential, but and again, who knows? Have I researched the precedence of this? No, I have not, but it it resonated. Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: it was some dude, some dude podcaster saying, you know, Andie James: Of course. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: capitalism, you know, like the industry in general, realized that there's something that sells better than sex, and that's hate. Hate sells better than sex. And I was like, and you see that. Hate does sell better than sex. Andie James: You do. Yeah. Yeah. Nichole Van: And and I think since since thinking about that and seeing everything through that lens, I'm like, is this selling me hate? Because if it's selling me hate, I don't want to consume it. And I think like just as in general, like as you're w going through your Instagram feed or whatever, my algorithm. And Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: I think that that's what we're seeing here too, in a certain sense. It's very easy to get outraged and to feel like, well, I'm absolutely in the right. We are protecting artists, and this is stealing and blah, blah, blah. Without and it is, it is. I'm not even arguing that point. But there is great in there. And unfortunately a lot of us fall into that gray area and then how do we navigate that? Like it's hard. It's a really hard place to be and let's react in grace instead of judgment. Let's give a Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: space to understand instead of just immediately going to hate and anger. Andie James: Well, and I think my thing is like I just want people, I think, to take the time to actually think through the issue and where they land and why. I think that's the most important thing. Because like I said, the people I knew anytime you take a stance on something, you're gonna upset people. Like that just is. And I knew as soon as I like sent that email saying I've made this decision and this is why. I knew. I was gonna lose some people. And and the thing is, like, I honestly respect that decision because that is they're saying, This is my value. You've crossed that line and now I'm done. And that's fine. I do, I understand it because, like I said, I'm still very, very, very, very anti-10 AI. Like I understand it. I'm not upset with those people in any way. but I just I think it's hard because as a person who wants to be generally seen as someone likable and and seen as someone, you know, that people, generally respect within the space, like I was like, some people don't like me anymore. And that's kinda sad. And and that hurts, but like you gotta understand that anytime you take a stance on something, that's gonna happen. And like I said, I think we've hit a point where we have to. And I hope people understand that my overall feelings haven't changed at all. I'm making an accommodation when my values about supporting the genre came into conflict, right? And so it's figuring that out. And this isn't me trying to defend myself, sorry, I'm going off here. but it's just a very tangible example. Nichole Van: No, no, but but I'm with you on that. Like it's it's very hard to explain it without feeling like I'm being defensive or I'm just trying to justify it. Or and and and that's part of the problem is that there's no way to even Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: try to create nuance in our stance without Andie James: Yeah. Nichole Van: it feeling like it's justification because it there's just sort of this mmm Andie James: Mm-hmm. Nichole Van: mood right now that everything needs to be a hard black and white and unfortunately like most things I think that's why most things end up being a contentious issue, is because they're not black and white and nuance is harder to accommodate. Andie James: Yeah. Well, we could talk forever, but we've already been talking for basically an hour. So Nichole Van: We could. I know. Andie James: we should probably wrap this up. again, thank you so much for having this discussion and your Nichole Van: Thank you. Andie James: openness and your all of it. and I appreciate just seeing this real life example of the way that you've evolved and because we learn more. We're human, things change, you know, and Nichole Van: Exactly. Andie James: seeing the way that You know, this impacts you in terms of the art piece too, in a way that that doesn't affect a lot of us as writers. Like is so interesting to me. And so, thank you for being willing to have this conversation. Anything else? Yeah. Nichole Van: I love this conversation. No, I think it's been fantastic. Thank you. I appreciate you having me on. Andie James: All right. Well, thank you so much. All right. Everyone, please tune in next week because that's gonna be my normal conversation with Nicole, where we talk about her books and why I love them so much. so please tune in for that and thank you for tuning into this. And I again, no answers here, but I hope it raised some questions that we can all think about. All right, bye everyone.