Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Nirav Tolia - Nextdoor Co-Founder & CEO | The Man Who Connected 100 Million Neighbors Says AI Is About to Make Us All Lonelier
Transcript
- 0:00You said the age of information gave us the internet, the age of intelligence gave us AI.
- 0:05So what does that actually look like?
- 0:07We need to pair the age of intelligence with human connection.
- 0:11As the machines get more powerful, we cannot lose our humanness.
- 0:15That's connection with each other.
- 0:17How do we successfully use AI in our day-to-day?
- 0:20We don't keep losing our sense of humanness and our human connection.
- 0:23We cannot use AI as a substitute.
- 0:26We can only use AI as a tool.
- 0:28Today's guest is Nirav Tolia, CEO and co-founder of Nextdoor, a longtime technology entrepreneur and investor.
- 0:35He has spent decades building companies around online communities and human connection.
- 0:39In this conversation, he explores how AI can help us connect without replacing the human relationships that matter most.
- 0:45Use technology as a tool, but understand that it's no substitute for ultimately meeting people in the real world.
- 0:52Do you believe that we have a true loneliness epidemic?
- 0:56It will be an epidemic when there is a generation that prefers to spend time with their computer, with their mobile phone, their AI versus spending time with a human being.
- 1:09My fitness pal is a success story partner.
- 1:11Now here's something I've noticed after interviewing hundreds of founders, the ones that are performing at the highest level, the ones that are truly winning.
- 1:17They aren't just optimizing their business or their calendar or their team.
- 1:20They're paying attention to what they eat.
- 1:22And the ones who aren't paying attention, they're usually the first ones to burn out.
- 1:25And that pattern is consistent enough that it got me thinking about my own nutrition.
- 1:28Not whether I was eating well, but whether I actually knew what the big picture looked like.
- 1:33That's why I started using the MyFitnessPal app.
- 1:34I wanted to see what I was actually eating, not what I assumed I was eating, but the real numbers, what my protein intake looked like, what my macronutrient breakdown was, where my calories were actually going throughout the day.
- 1:45And the app gives you all of that.
- 1:47Now, what kept me using it is that there's zero friction.
- 1:50If I eat something, I scan the barcode, it pulls everything up.
- 1:53I can also verbally log what I eat.
- 1:55And it remembers my regular meals.
- 1:56So most days I'm logging my food in under a minute.
- 1:58See, food is a foundation for your energy, your sleep, your recovery, and your performance.
- 2:03It's not one of many inputs.
- 2:04It is the one input.
- 2:06So go to podcast.myfitnesspal.com and use code SCOTT.
- 2:09All uppercades for 15% off MyFitnessPal Premium.
- 2:12That's podcast.myfitnesspal.com, code SCOTT.
- 2:21So Nirav, you said the age of information gave us the internet, the age of intelligence gave us AI, and what comes next is the age of human connection.
- 2:33So what does that actually look like?
- 2:35Well, we live in an amazing time with incredible transformations in this lifetime.
- 2:40And I feel so fortunate to have been around at the beginning of the dot-com boom, which I consider the age of information.
- 2:47We suddenly had access to information in a way that we've never had before.
- 2:52Now we're in the middle of something which I believe is even bigger and even more transformational for society and even better.
- 2:58I'm an unabashed lover of AI.
- 3:01And AI is bringing us the age of intelligence.
- 3:04We're moving from just access to information to intelligence with that information.
- 3:09So the question is, what's going to happen next?
- 3:12And the truth is, I don't know.
- 3:13But what I do know is we need to pair the age of intelligence with...
- 3:18with human connection.
- 3:19Because as we get closer to machines and as the machines get more powerful, we cannot lose our humanness.
- 3:28We cannot lose what makes us unique as a species, and that's connection with each other.
- 3:34So I'm not sure that human connection comes next.
- 3:36I don't really know what comes next.
- 3:38But what I do know is in this age of intelligence, which I think will be unprecedented for the world...
- 3:44We need to pair it with human connection.
- 3:47It can't just be our reliance on AI.
- 3:51It needs to be our reliance on AI paired with our continued reliance on each other.
- 3:57And that's what I mean by the age of human connection.
- 4:00I also think that the more we depend on AI, the more human connection becomes an exceptionally valuable commodity.
- 4:11I think that what you're doing with Nextdoor, where you're building community connection, what a lot of CEOs that I speak to are doing with in-person events, there's this premium on human connection.
- 4:26We all kind of felt the first inflection point in this connection epidemic, if you want to call it that, was COVID, where we were all stuck at home and everybody was lonely.
- 4:37And then I don't think social media helped that much.
- 4:41I think that it isolated us even more.
- 4:43And then now in the age of AI and Zoom meetings, I feel like we're getting information from AI.
- 4:50We feel like...
- 4:52Even half the content we're consuming is AI generated.
- 4:55There's all these different things that are compounding into us wanting to connect with humans more and more and more because we feel like it's getting more scarce and more scarce and even more scarce.
- 5:05So I guess the question is, you see this sort of firsthand, like you work with people who are constantly trying to figure out how to balance AI and humanness.
- 5:18So how do we do that properly?
- 5:19How do we successfully use AI in our day-to-day, but we don't keep losing our sense of humanness and our human connection while still making sure we use a technology that's incredibly powerful and helpful?
- 5:33We cannot use AI as a substitute.
- 5:37We can only use AI as a tool.
- 5:39And so let me go back to build on that argument.
- 5:42So the first thing is, AI and its emergence is not the first time that technology has left us isolated.
- 5:49And you talked about COVID, but this happened much, much, much prior to even the internet.
- 5:55The television, which was a piece of technology,
- 5:59started to keep us inside the home.
- 6:01And when we were inside the home, we weren't outside meeting with people.
- 6:04So that was the first thing that really started this epidemic of isolation and loneliness.
- 6:11After the television, the computer comes along, and after the computer, you have the mobile computer, which now you've got the computer in your pocket wherever you go, and you can interact with it in a way that is much easier and higher leverage than going out and meeting people in person.
- 6:26That leverage is great.
- 6:27And we've seen it continue with Zoom and everything that we can do virtually, right?
- 6:33We can now inhabit these virtual spaces much easier and much faster and much more economically in a viable way than going to someone physically.
- 6:44But it does create a lack of connection because you just don't connect the same way when you're in a virtual space as you do in a physical one.
- 6:52So now AI comes along.
- 6:54And not only do we have access to information, we almost have access to a personality.
- 7:01When you're talking to an agent, it's no longer a computer that's spitting back lists of links.
- 7:08It's almost a dialogue that you're having with another person.
- 7:11And so will that make us stop talking as much with each other?
- 7:15Almost certainly it will.
- 7:16So the thing we have to remember is that we have to pair that use of AI with,
- 7:21with continued human connection.
- 7:23Another way to think about it is, so COVID comes along and we're forced to stay inside.
- 7:28After COVID passes, what industry skyrocket?
- 7:32Well, for the most part, we saw travel and tourism go through the roof because all of a sudden people said, gosh, I remember what it was like to be able to travel and to be with people in physical space that I don't live around, right?
- 7:44And so I'm gonna do more of it.
- 7:46I think you use that word scarcity.
- 7:48I think scarcity does drive value.
- 7:50So the scarcity of these human interactions is going to make them more valuable.
- 7:55But it's a false dichotomy to say either I'm going to use AI or I'm going to talk to people in person.
- 8:01This is where I think most people are mistaken.
- 8:03They're trying to set this up as AI or humanness.
- 8:07And I think that's very much a false dichotomy.
- 8:09I think the idea is use AI as a tool.
- 8:14Allow it to give you leverage in all the ways that it can.
- 8:17But don't lose sight of the fact that real connection happens when you're with another person or with a group of people.
- 8:23And that's what we call community.
- 8:25And so even something like Nextdoor,
- 8:27which is built on the principle of community.
- 8:30Nextdoor is all about using technology to drive people together in the real world, in their neighborhoods, into community, which is something that's been steadily declining in America.
- 8:42You know, we were inspired by the book Bowling Alone, written by Robert Putnam, that was written 20 plus years ago about the decline of community in America.
- 8:50So this has been happening for a long time.
- 8:52But we're not saying...
- 8:53Abandon technology and go out into your neighborhoods.
- 8:57We're saying use technology as an icebreaker.
- 8:59Use technology as a tool, but understand that it's no substitute for ultimately meeting people in the real world and being with them.
- 9:07Because when we're with other people, that's when we feel truly alive.
- 9:12And when you're with an AI, you can feel empowered.
- 9:16You can feel like you're high leverage.
- 9:18You can feel like you're getting a lot of things done.
- 9:20But it never feels like you're part of something bigger than yourself.
- 9:24The only way to feel like you're part of something bigger than yourself is to be part of a community.
- 9:29And that's what's so powerful about being in the real world.
- 9:32Why do you think that so many social platforms, even though there was parts that encouraged some slight real life interaction and some more than others?
- 9:51maybe like LinkedIn would promote a meetup or Facebook would help you or meta would help you promote an event.
- 9:59But majority of social platforms basically said we are recreating your in life.
- 10:06community online.
- 10:08And that's really what all these platforms optimized for.
- 10:11I'm curious why, because when I look at Nextdoor, I see it as an outlier, as a platform that really focuses on in-person.
- 10:22Why did, for example, nine out of 10 social platforms focus on online community building when there's so much value in a human to human?
- 10:32Is it frictions?
- 10:33Is it too difficult to build for the, you know, when when Zuck was starting, he was taking people.
- 10:41that had communities at various schools across the U.S. And he moved those people online.
- 10:48He didn't use Facebook to augment the in-person experience.
- 10:52But that would have been the perfect opportunity.
- 10:53So I'm trying to figure out why, again, 9 out of 10 social platforms don't optimize for in-person.
- 10:59What is the toll that's taking on the average social media user?
- 11:04Well, we know that there's a heavy toll because the more time that we spend online, the less time we spend developing ourselves with real people.
- 11:13So that part of it, no argument.
- 11:15But as someone who's lived and worked in Silicon Valley for my entire adult life,
- 11:20I'm a huge believer in technology, and I'm a huge supporter of the people who've created these platforms.
- 11:26So you said, why did nine out of 10 social platforms focus on online interactions, right?
- 11:32The reality is almost 100 out of 100 internet companies.
- 11:36focused on what was happening virtually.
- 11:40I don't think it was intentional that the social platforms came along and said, we're gonna bring people from the real world into the virtual world.
- 11:47In most cases, and I think this is true of Zuckerberg, and I think this is true of all the social platforms,
- 11:53You start somewhere believing that if you remove friction and if you provide these virtual spaces, there's more leverage that's provided to the real world interactions.
- 12:03Remember, the Facebook was about people at Harvard in the physical world.
- 12:08It wasn't about people you don't know.
- 12:10It was actually a less friction way to learn and get more information about the people that you were going to school with.
- 12:16So it started not as a virtual platform necessarily.
- 12:20Right.
- 12:20but as a virtual mechanism to get more leverage from the real world platform.
- 12:25But then all of a sudden the revolution happens.
- 12:29More people use the internet, mobile phones come along.
- 12:31The leverage becomes so powerful that before we know it,
- 12:35The algorithms know us better than other people do.
- 12:38And so we spend more time on them.
- 12:40So I don't think this is a story of intentionality where the creators of these social platforms said, I'm going to find a way to create a loneliness epidemic, or I'm going to find a way to bring people away from the physical world into the virtual world.
- 12:55I think this is largely about unintended consequences.
- 12:59And then all of a sudden you wake up one day and you realize that the building blocks of your platform...
- 13:04have done what you didn't necessarily intend to do, which is they have pulled people away from their real world communities.
- 13:11And they have created loneliness because they make it easier to spend time online.
- 13:16With Nextdoor, what's so interesting is my entire career up to Nextdoor,
- 13:21I was creating virtual communities as well.
- 13:24That was my whole intention.
- 13:26That was my dream, my aspiration.
- 13:28And it came because when I discovered the internet when I was in college at Stanford, the way I first experienced the internet was as a virtual space.
- 13:35I grew up in Texas, so I'm a fan of the Dallas Cowboys.
- 13:39I went to Stanford, which is in San Francisco 49ers territory.
- 13:42So in the 90s, when the Cowboys were last pretty good, when they won their last set of Super Bowls,
- 13:48I wanted to find a place where I could talk to other Dallas Cowboys fans.
- 13:51And I wasn't living in Texas at the time.
- 13:53I was in Palo Alto at Stanford.
- 13:56So I went online and I found other Dallas Cowboys fans in a virtual space, no matter where they lived.
- 14:02Some of them were in Texas.
- 14:03Some of them were in other places.
- 14:04And I realized the power of being able to rely on a virtual space to meet people like me.
- 14:10That was real community.
- 14:12And then I ended up starting a company, Opinions, that was about online community.
- 14:17Now, when it came to Nextdoor, which is the summer of 2010, the first wave of Internet companies had already passed.
- 14:24Remember, the Internet boom started around 1995.
- 14:27Then there was the dot-com bust in the early 2000s.
- 14:30Then the cloud and mobile brought things back.
- 14:32And now we're sitting in 2010.
- 14:34Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter are just emerging.
- 14:37And my co-founders and I of Nextdoor, we said to ourselves, okay, these social platforms are amazing.
- 14:43And you have one that makes it super easy to connect with friends.
- 14:46That's Facebook.
- 14:47And you have one that makes it super easy to connect with business colleagues, and that's LinkedIn.
- 14:52And you have one that makes it super easy to follow your interests, and that's Twitter.
- 14:57But how come there isn't a social platform that makes where you live possible?
- 15:03more powerful, more leveraged, more impactful.
- 15:07And so from the beginning, when we built Nextdoor and we things like using neighborhood boundaries, having verified neighbors, ensuring that you use your real name,
- 15:19We knew that the building blocks of our social platform needed to be grounded in the real world.
- 15:24And so I can't say even for a second that we were so smart as to know that AI would show up one day and we would have a social platform built on verified identity and trust.
- 15:38But we do today because from the beginning at Nextdoor, we really did want to strengthen offline communities.
- 15:45Our goal was not to build a better virtual neighborhood.
- 15:50Our goal was to build a better physical neighborhood and to use virtual tools to do that.
- 15:55And so the tools that you start with are the ones that ultimately create, you know, it's the inputs, outputs thing that a lot of entrepreneurs talk about.
- 16:03Your inputs ultimately drive your outputs and you don't always know how successful you're going to be.
- 16:09The other social platforms, their inputs are.
- 16:12were sound, but they've become so successful that they have created some of these unintentional consequences.
- 16:18For Nextdoor, I would argue that we've been more lucky than good, but by leaning heavily on the real world community of the neighborhood back in 2010, we're better positioned than ever today because that real world set of things, verified identity and trust and knowing that it's your real neighbors, not a bot, those are things that will increasingly be valued in this AI emergent world.
- 16:42Do you believe that we have a true loneliness epidemic?
- 16:47Well, epidemic is a strong word, but I do believe that in the past, it has been much easier to rely on other people versus rely on machines to feel closeness and to feel connection.
- 17:03And so it will be an epidemic when there is a generation that prefers to spend time on
- 17:10with their computer, with their mobile phone, with their AI, versus spending time with a human being.
- 17:17And we're starting to see some of that.
- 17:19There are the stories that in South Korea, women would rather date virtual AIs than have real boyfriends.
- 17:26You think about the people who on a Friday night would rather stay at home and endlessly scroll through Instagram.
- 17:33versus go out into the real world, right?
- 17:36It's starting to happen.
- 17:37When it reaches a point where people start to use machines as a substitute versus as a tool, that will be epidemic.
- 17:46And I think the reason it's important to wake up now, we don't want to have to fix it once we get there.
- 17:52We have an opportunity right now to not shy away from technology, but to pair it with human connection, right?
- 17:58When COVID happened,
- 18:00and we were forced to stay inside, that was an extreme.
- 18:03But when COVID ended, we didn't say, we're only gonna spend time outside.
- 18:08We figured out a way to enjoy where we live and also travel and be in other places.
- 18:13We found some harmony.
- 18:15What I think we're really looking for here is a harmony between the power of technology
- 18:21and the humanness of connection.
- 18:23And that's something that for us at Nextdoor, we feel like we have a unique opportunity to build that and to model it ourselves because Nextdoor is a virtual tool.
- 18:32It is something you experience on your mobile phone.
- 18:35But ultimately, we would like the interactions that you have on Nextdoor with your neighbors to lead to interactions that you have outside of our app, outside of your phone, in your neighborhood.
- 18:46And so that harmonization
- 18:49is the thing that ultimately, I think, gives us the best of both worlds.
- 18:52It gives us access to that technology that we know is super powerful, that we know is going to be here whether we want it to be or not.
- 19:00But it also keeps us grounded in what makes us unique and special, and that is our connections to each other.
- 19:08Plot is a success story partner.
- 19:09Now, I spoke about Plot a few episodes back.
- 19:12This is the AI-powered device that captures your conversations, turns them into transcripts, summaries, action items,
- 19:17And I wanted to come back to it because I keep finding new ways that this thing is incredibly useful.
- 19:21Last week, I sat down with a potential sponsor at a coffee shop and we were going back and forth on deliverables, timelines, pricing, a lot of details and a lot of numbers.
- 19:30And normally after a conversation like that, I'd open my notes app on my phone.
- 19:34I try to write everything down.
- 19:35I remembered and I'd probably get about 70% of it, but the other 30% would be gone.
- 19:41Usually the small details that end up mattering a lot later.
- 19:44But this time, with their permission, I had the note pin S on my shirt and I honestly forgot it was even there.
- 19:50So after the meeting, I opened up my Plod app and everything was already laid out.
- 19:53The full transcript, a clear summary, the key numbers we discussed and the follow ups I'd agreed to.
- 19:58And I could even ask Plod, what pricing did we discuss or what were my next steps?
- 20:02And it pulls up the answer right away.
- 20:04I didn't have to reconstruct the conversation from memory.
- 20:06And that's the part that I keep coming back to.
- 20:08I'm not splitting my attention in meetings between being present in the conversation and trying to document and remember everything.
- 20:14I can just focus on the person in front of me, knowing that the important details will be there afterwards.
- 20:19And remember, they do have two products.
- 20:21So the Note Pro magnetically attaches to the back of your phone.
- 20:23It's great for calls.
- 20:24And the Note Pin has clips or magnetically attaches to your shirt, making it ideal for in-person conversations.
- 20:30And you can choose between them depending on the situation.
- 20:32So if you spend a lot of your day in conversations and you're tired of losing important details, go check it out.
- 20:38Go to plod.ai slash success and use code success for 15% off.
- 20:42That's plod.ai slash success and use code success for 15% off.
- 20:47Odoo is a success story partner.
- 20:48And remember, that is pronounced O-do.
- 20:50Now, I want to tell you something that happened to me recently that I think a lot of you will relate to.
- 20:55I was trying to send a quote to a client, and this should be simple, right?
- 20:58Except the pricing was in one tool, and the contact info was in another tool, and the last conversation that we had was in a third tool.
- 21:05And then I spent something like 20 minutes pulling it all together for one quote.
- 21:09And that's the thing.
- 21:10Each tool works fine on its own.
- 21:13The problem is that they don't talk to each other.
- 21:15So you become the person connecting everything.
- 21:18You become the integration.
- 21:19You're the one copying numbers between tabs and making sure everything matches.
- 21:23But that's what Odoo fixes.
- 21:25It puts everything on one platform.
- 21:27So I'm talking accounting, invoicing, CRM, inventory, HR, project management, your website, e-commerce, e-signatures, over 45 apps, all connected.
- 21:36When something happens in one place, every other place already knows about it.
- 21:41So you're not updating three systems every time you close a deal.
- 21:44And the pricing is the part that surprised me.
- 21:46The first app is free for life, unlimited users, hosting included.
- 21:50One subscription after that unlocks everything else.
- 21:53So if you're spending your time connecting tools instead of actually doing the work you have to do, go check it out.
- 21:57Links in the show notes.
- 21:58My fitness pal is a success story partner.
- 22:01On this show, I speak to tons of high performers and the people that sustain that high performance, not just sprint and crash and burn, but they actually sustain, they all treat nutrition like a system, not an afterthought.
- 22:12The same way they treat revenue or hiring or product, it is key to their business.
- 22:18They pay attention, they look at the data.
- 22:21And that really stuck with me and it's how I started thinking about my own health and wellness and what I put into my own body.
- 22:27Not in like a restrictive diet way, but in a data way.
- 22:30See, most people take a look at daily calorie total and they think they have the full picture.
- 22:35That's just one number.
- 22:37The MyFitnessPal app premium, it shows me macros.
- 22:40That means proteins, carbs, fats, broken down by meal.
- 22:45So I can see, am I getting enough protein at breakfast versus dinner?
- 22:49And it also shows me how my food is distributed across the day, because of course I can take a look at my total calorie number, but to see everything broken down by meal, those are two completely different things.
- 23:00Even if your daily total looks fine and you're going to feel the difference.
- 23:03If you eat proper nutrition across your entire day and you track it, your energy is going to allow you to sustain that high performance.
- 23:11Also, the food analysis picks up trends over the week that I'd miss just going by feel.
- 23:15See, this information makes good food choices automatic.
- 23:19See, food is a foundation, right?
- 23:21Energy, focus, performance, recovery, it all starts with food.
- 23:25So do yourself a favor.
- 23:27Go visit podcast.myfitnesspal.com and use code Scott, all uppercase letters, for 15% off MyFitnessPal premium.
- 23:34That's podcast.myfitnesspal.com, code Scott.
- 23:38Why is that?
- 23:39Why are we so bad at making in-person connections when it seemed like it was so easy for our parents?
- 23:44Is it just because we've been born in this digital world where most of the people that we meet and the connections that we make, it's all online?
- 23:50And then I guess the follow-up question is, you know, I grew up in a...
- 23:55not analog, but more analog world than what my kids will grow up in.
- 23:59So if it's worse for us because we were online for the majority of our life, what does that mean for our kids?
- 24:06And then what are the actual steps that we can take as adults and as parents to make sure that we sort of move in the right direction?
- 24:13Because I don't feel like we are now.
- 24:14That's a long-ass question.
- 24:15That's bad form for a podcast, but there's a lot of thoughts and a lot of stress around this.
- 24:19Right.
- 24:19Well, I think that this trend started well before our generation.
- 24:25That's the first thing I'll say.
- 24:26When we started Nextdoor, the simple statistic that we would quote to people is that almost 30% of Americans could not name a single neighbor by name.
- 24:37And that was in the summer of 2010.
- 24:39And like you, when I grew up in West Texas, in Odessa, that had a very strong sense of community,
- 24:50That would make no sense whatsoever.
- 24:52I knew many neighbors.
- 24:53In fact, not only did I know them, I was friends with them, as was my parents.
- 24:58And we would rely on each other, whether it was rides to school or borrowing the proverbial cup of sugar or babysitting for their children.
- 25:06Right.
- 25:06We were integrated with them.
- 25:08And then over many years because of television, because we commuted to work, because things kept us inside our homes.
- 25:15Right.
- 25:17We started to lose touch with people.
- 25:19And as we lost touch with them, it became harder to exercise that muscle that had atrophied, which was the muscle of meeting new people.
- 25:27And all of a sudden, it became weird if you saw someone outside in your neighborhood knocking on doors, introducing themselves, trying to get to know each other.
- 25:37That turned into the nosy neighbor versus the nice neighbor.
- 25:40So you fast forward to today, and I think you actually had the right point, which is
- 25:45It's bad enough for us, even though we grew up in a different period of time.
- 25:50What about our children?
- 25:51I have three sons, ages 14, 12, and 10.
- 25:55They are not at all familiar.
- 25:58with going and introducing themselves to people they don't know.
- 26:02It's just not the way they've grown up.
- 26:03In fact, if anything, people tell them, don't talk to strangers, keep to yourself, only interact with the people you already know.
- 26:12So there have been many societal trends, not just technology, but many societal trends that have gone in the wrong direction.
- 26:19Then you add technology, right?
- 26:20And we see what's happening again to the children.
- 26:22Now social media being outlawed until the age of 16 in Australia.
- 26:27Same thing is going to happen, I think, in the UK and Europe, and eventually it's going to get to the US as well, because we don't want these addictive platforms to take over our kids' brains before our kids had the capability to know that they shouldn't spend as much time on these.
- 26:42We don't believe, my wife and I.
- 26:44that our kids are never going to use technology.
- 26:46It's not like we say, we don't like screens at all.
- 26:49You can never pick up a phone.
- 26:51You can never use Instagram, et cetera, right?
- 26:53But we want to balance these things.
- 26:55So for example, we've taken our kids.
- 26:58I moved to a foreign country because we thought to ourselves, hey, if you're living in a new place, by definition, you don't know anyone and you're going to be lonely.
- 27:07So let's figure out how to put all of us, not just our kids, but my wife and I as well, in a new situation where we need to build community from scratch.
- 27:17It's the end of the summer.
- 27:18We sent our kids just a couple of weeks ago to a camp in Switzerland for almost three weeks.
- 27:24They didn't know a single person.
- 27:27And it wasn't just Americans.
- 27:28It was people from 39 different countries.
- 27:30So we try to do the things that we can within reason.
- 27:35that get them to exercise those muscles that are largely active because of the way society is set up today.
- 27:42I think we need more block parties.
- 27:44I think we need more events where we meet people that maybe we've seen, or maybe we know they live close by, but we don't know their names.
- 27:52And we need to exercise that muscle of getting to know them.
- 27:56We need to go outside and smile at people and shake their hands and introduce ourselves.
- 28:02And that's something that I think for whatever reason –
- 28:05We've stopped doing and we haven't stopped doing it out of some real intentional focus away from community.
- 28:13But things like looking at our phone when we walk across the street, that influences our ability to meet people.
- 28:20We were in Italy this summer and I gave a keynote speech at Stanford has a small campus in Florence, Italy.
- 28:28And I gave a small keynote speech there and I said to get to this palazzo.
- 28:34where you're currently sitting, you sat and walked across a piazza that was probably 500 to 800 years old.
- 28:42And what did you likely do?
- 28:45You looked at your phone the entire way over.
- 28:47Instead of looking around at what is essentially an open-air museum, instead of looking around at all the other people who've traveled to Florence to be in that same environment.
- 28:58And I appeal to them that when they left the speech, put the phone in the pocket.
- 29:03And when you walk back across that piazza...
- 29:07Look at the art.
- 29:09Look at the people.
- 29:10Go and meet someone.
- 29:11So you just need a reminder.
- 29:14Even the way that we planned America, for example, versus Europe.
- 29:18Europe is built around piazzas where people come and congregate, right?
- 29:23America, particularly with the prosperity that we have, it's a suburb and a strip mall, one after another, where you can get in your car and drive to anything you want.
- 29:33You know, when we started Next Door...
- 29:35My co-founder Sarah Leary and I were really struck by the fact that when we went to Italy, say Rome or Florence, and we asked someone, hey, what's the best place to get coffee and espresso?
- 29:46What's the best place to get pizza or pasta around here?
- 29:50Almost always the person in Italy would say, well, it's the place that's right close by to where I live.
- 29:57Whereas in America, if you ask someone, where's the best coffee?
- 30:00Where's the best pizza?
- 30:01Where's the best fill in the blank?
- 30:03They'll largely say, well, get in your car, drive 18 miles or drive across town and you'll be at the best place.
- 30:10And that may be the best place, but it's outside your neighborhood.
- 30:13So that connection you have with it is totally different.
- 30:15So I think a lot of this is larger than technology and larger than AI.
- 30:21But technology and AI is amplifying technology.
- 30:25that epidemic, as you call it.
- 30:27And it will be an epidemic if we don't do something about it.
- 30:30One last thought on this.
- 30:32For parents, what's your advice to them if they can't move overseas, for example?
- 30:37Like, what's the way that they should raise their kids so that they don't succumb to this loneliness?
- 30:42I think you got to find the balance.
- 30:44Our kids go to a great school in Dallas, Texas, and I'm always wondering if in that school they're going to find the right balance of allowing the students to use AI but not overuse it.
- 30:56Because I think the schools that say, oh, no, you can't use AI at all.
- 31:01they're actually putting their students at a disadvantage.
- 31:04But obviously, we don't want the students to only use AI, right?
- 31:08So this is going to be one of the really thorny, difficult, but yet valuable challenges that we have over the next 5, 10, 15 years, which is how do we ensure that the young generation becomes facile with these tools?
- 31:25Because you have to know how to use these things.
- 31:28but doesn't become over-reliant on them.
- 31:32And that requires harmony and that requires nuance and that requires true parenting.
- 31:40And unfortunately we're so busy these days.
- 31:42Sometimes we either say, well, just take your iPad and do whatever you want.
- 31:46Or we lock up the iPad and say, you can't touch it.
- 31:49Right.
- 31:49And even my wife and I are guilty of that.
- 31:52It's much better to sit down with your children and say, okay, I want you to learn how to use AI, but I don't want you to just go there and ask the AI whatever you want.
- 32:02Let's come up with some projects.
- 32:04Would you like to know something about world history?
- 32:07Would you like to know something about the world of arts?
- 32:09Would you like to know something about business?
- 32:11Would you like to learn something?
- 32:13Because, gosh, think about the power of AI for our children in teaching them things.
- 32:19It's like having the world's most advanced tutor.
- 32:23in your pocket.
- 32:24So I don't think we should ignore that at all, but you have to find the balance.
- 32:27I mean, the best we've done, my wife and I, is we've said, okay, there's a quota on the number of minutes of screen time that our children can have.
- 32:36And that's not very big during the weekdays and it's a little bigger during the weekends.
- 32:42So maybe 30 minutes of screen time during the week per day.
- 32:46and then maybe a couple hours on the weekend.
- 32:48The challenge is these pieces of technology have become messaging devices primarily.
- 32:55And so if you're a young teenager, all of your friends are on this device and that's how they all communicate with each other.
- 33:01And so if you stand outside of that,
- 33:04You're out of the flow of information.
- 33:06And you know what it's like to be a teenager.
- 33:08You don't want to be out of the flow of information.
- 33:10So these are serious, serious, serious challenges.
- 33:14I don't think they're unsolvable.
- 33:15But I think it will require nuance.
- 33:17It will require hard work.
- 33:18And it will require, I'll bring up that word again, harmony.
- 33:22between understanding that there is tremendous power and leverage, and we want our children to be facile with technology.
- 33:31But we don't want them to treat it as a substitute.
- 33:34Learn to treat it as a tool, but not as a substitute.
- 33:38One thing that I'm very impressed with is how you built Nextdoor almost against the wisdom of technology,
- 33:47Any sort of entrepreneurship lesson strategy, because when you talk to anybody about how to build a company, they'll always say reduce friction, grow as quick as possible, achieve virality.
- 34:01This is the way to grow a company, right?
- 34:03This is how most people assume this is how they're going to be successful.
- 34:08You added friction.
- 34:10to your growth playbook.
- 34:11So when people sign up, and let me know if this is correct, but from what I researched, so first name, last name, street address, do you also require a postcard in the mail for them to sign up as well?
- 34:25In the early days, the way we verified that you were telling us the truth about where you lived is we would send you a postcard.
- 34:32That wasn't a particularly economical way to verify identity.
- 34:36But you know, it's, it's,
- 34:39It is the case that as an entrepreneur, you need to balance between what we might think of as best practices –
- 34:47And then a contrarian point of view, because you use the best practices to learn from everything that's come before you.
- 34:56But if you don't have the contrarian point of view, you're not going to create something that's different.
- 35:01You're largely just going to create something that's already there.
- 35:04And so you need to have a point of view that says, look, what currently exists is
- 35:10is not good enough, or there can be something that we can build that's better than what currently exists.
- 35:16But you don't build that better thing by doing the same thing that other people have done.
- 35:22And so you got to learn from the best practices, but you have to understand what is the high order bit.
- 35:27So for us, it wasn't, we never said to ourselves, let's increase friction.
- 35:31I mean, as an entrepreneur, that would be a crazy thing to say because you don't have a lot of leverage as an entrepreneur.
- 35:36If you add more friction, there's already enough friction that's actually right there in everything you're doing.
- 35:42Right.
- 35:42And so it's not that we said, let's add friction.
- 35:45We said, let's increase trust.
- 35:48We said, let's more accurately simulate the real world set of connections that people have.
- 35:55And then the solutions that we came up with based on those principles that we were trying to optimize, some of those solutions did create more friction.
- 36:05And gosh.
- 36:06we would have chosen solutions that didn't add more friction.
- 36:11In retrospect, it's easy to say, oh yeah, we added friction and it was a good thing.
- 36:14At the time, we were just ripping our hair out, saying, are we really going to send postcards to a billion people?
- 36:21Because we want to have a billion people using Nextdoor.
- 36:24Now there are over 110 million people who've registered to use the service.
- 36:28You multiply that times the postage of that many postcards.
- 36:31That's a lot of money.
- 36:32We never would have wanted to spend that.
- 36:34starting out.
- 36:35So I think a lot of times when we hear these stories about entrepreneurial journeys, we forget that it all looks very clear in hindsight.
- 36:46But when we were building, the thing that was driving us was not adding friction.
- 36:51The thing that was driving us is, how do we increase trust?
- 36:54And in some cases, the way to increase trust is to add friction.
- 36:58In fact, what's so interesting now as we think about 15 years after that,
- 37:03AI reduces even more friction.
- 37:05If you think about AI search versus Google search, right?
- 37:09Google search, you put in the query, you get the 10 blue links, you have to click on each one of them, you go back, you go forward, you synthesize everything you find in those 10 links in your own head, and then you come up with some kind of amalgamated view.
- 37:23There's some friction there, a lot less friction than there used to be, but there's some friction there.
- 37:27You go to AI and you type in a natural language query that's conversational.
- 37:32And it takes not just 10 links, but every link it's ever found.
- 37:37And it amalgamates all of them into this bite-sized summary.
- 37:41You think about that incredible leverage you just got.
- 37:44The friction just went...
- 37:46I mean, it went bye-bye immediately, right?
- 37:48But sometimes the friction is where you learn to ask better questions.
- 37:53Sometimes the friction is the thing that uncovers the nuance that everyone else is missing.
- 37:58And so I think the friction, in an odd way...
- 38:02is actually what makes us human.
- 38:04We hear a lot about imperfection of humans versus the perfection of a machine, right?
- 38:09Let's use the perfection of a machine to get us to a place really fast, but let's do the very end with the beautiful imperfection of humans.
- 38:18There's a meme that's going around in Silicon Valley
- 38:22Maybe you've heard it, 20, 60, 20.
- 38:24It's a way to use AI.
- 38:26Have you heard this before?
- 38:27No, I haven't yet.
- 38:28What is this?
- 38:29The idea is you as a human do the first 20% of the work.
- 38:34So you have something to do.
- 38:35You have a podcast guest to research.
- 38:38Okay, the first 20% of that research, you do.
- 38:41You're getting to know it, you're understanding, why would I have this guest on the show?
- 38:45What would I want to ask them?
- 38:46What can they add to the community, right?
- 38:49Once you've done 20%, though, you turn it over to AI.
- 38:52And that's when you put the prompts into ChatGPT or you go to Claude and you say, I'm going to interview so-and-so and here's some things that I want you to push on.
- 38:59And what are some great questions and what are some great themes that we should get into?
- 39:03And how is this very topically relevant to what's going on in the world today?
- 39:06And then the AI will give you a lot of information, but you don't stop there.
- 39:10You take that and then you do the last 20% yourself.
- 39:13You look at the list of questions the chatbot has created for you and you decide which ones are the best ones.
- 39:18You prioritize them in the order that you believe they should be prioritized.
- 39:22I think that's an interesting heuristic.
- 39:2420, 60, 20.
- 39:26We're not relying on the machine.
- 39:29Nor are we saying that we shouldn't use the machine.
- 39:32But we built a framework where we're starting, and then it's doing a lot of the work in the middle, and then we're ending.
- 39:39And I think at the beginning, there's some friction because you've got to get started, and it's hard to get started.
- 39:44In the middle, the machine's just taking all that stuff, that activation energy that you've created, and it's doing the work.
- 39:50But at the end, the refinement is...
- 39:52You want a human to look at that and bring nuance and elegance and beauty and those things that machines typically don't have.
- 40:00So I think there are ways that we can use the AI without losing what makes us special.
- 40:06And sometimes friction is the thing that makes us special.
- 40:09I mean, friction is the thing that helps us understand that we're not talking to a machine, right?
- 40:15And this is gonna be an issue, particularly with online content.
- 40:19If something's written perfectly,
- 40:22increasingly people believe you use an AI to write that.
- 40:27If it's got em dashes and it's perfect from a grammar standpoint, you probably used chat GPT, right?
- 40:33But if you see something and there's a word that's misspelled or there's a construction that's not great from a grammar point of view, you're not gonna think that came from an AI.
- 40:42You're gonna know that that came from a human.
- 40:44And the human can make it better, but that friction, that imperfection, right?
- 40:49That's ultimately the thing that we put into something that gives it soul.
- 40:54I like that 20, 60, 20.
- 40:56Just to sort of echo what you've just said, I found that even something as simple as prepping for a podcast, when I just ask AI to prep and gives me a list of questions, it's...
- 41:07it always falls flat.
- 41:08It never captures the topics the guest actually cares about.
- 41:11Yes, it can pull the things that maybe you're a domain expert at, but it won't know the topics that you're emotionally invested in, that you're going to, you know, you're going to pull ideas that you've never said before and tell stories that have never been heard.
- 41:25Like you really have to, at least for me, when I prep for these,
- 41:29I have to listen to other podcasts you've been on.
- 41:32I have to read the book, at least a bit of it myself, and then I can understand what matters to you.
- 41:36And I found that when I figure out what matters to you, then that's the questions you ask.
- 41:41Those are the things that you triple down on and that creates the best content.
- 41:44But to your point, when you just rely on AI, when it's not 20, 60, 20, but it's a hundred percent AI.
- 41:52It'll try and do a good job, but it always misses the mark.
- 41:55And the interview feels inhuman because you're just pulling up points that the guest has mentioned on previous podcasts, but it may not be what they care about.
- 42:05It may not be things that are relevant to them now.
- 42:10I've actually gone in the other direction where I used to do all my podcast prep manually, and then I used AI, and then I went back to manual podcast prep because I hated the result of the completely AI-generated prep.
- 42:25But I think that's a really good framework for people to use AI in a 20, 60, 20 format.
- 42:32I don't think we want AI to be the first word or the final word.
- 42:35Because then if it's a first word, it's like garbage in, garbage out.
- 42:38If it's the last word, then there's no human audit of the content before it gets posted or before it gets used.
- 42:46It can help us transform the first set of words that are largely imperfect into the final set of words that are much more evolved.
- 42:55But think about it.
- 42:55You wouldn't go to an AI and say, tell me how to make a million dollars.
- 43:00it's not going to tell you anything, right?
- 43:02You wouldn't even go to an AI and say, tell me which stocks to invest in.
- 43:05You might actually ask the AI, you might say, I have this much money that I've just inherited.
- 43:10I'm thinking about creating a balanced stock portfolio.
- 43:13Can you give me some suggestions for names that I should consider?
- 43:16And it'll give you great names, which you can then spend some time thinking about.
- 43:20And then ultimately you decide what the portfolio looks like.
- 43:22So again, I want to be really careful about,
- 43:26Because I believe too many people today want to either say use AI for everything because it's magic or don't use it at all because it's imperfect.
- 43:37Neither of those statements are true.
- 43:39I mean, in fact, if I had to choose one of them, I would actually go more towards AI is magic than it's imperfect.
- 43:45But I would say it's magic at doing a particular set of things.
- 43:50And it's not magical at doing the very end.
- 43:54It's not magical at coming up with the right question to ask at the beginning.
- 43:58So let's use it as a tool the same way that we use all the other tools in our lives.
- 44:02When you were building Nextdoor, and I think it's still, you always have to balance trust versus friction.
- 44:10I'll just call it friction so people understand what we're talking about.
- 44:12Yeah.
- 44:14But you've done things that signal high trust, but it makes it very difficult for a company to grow if they followed the playbook that you followed.
- 44:23I think you also blocked Google from indexing your content on Nextdoor.
- 44:28These decisions...
- 44:31For example, sending out the postcards, blocking Google from indexing content, killing the SEO.
- 44:37How do you think about trust versus friction?
- 44:40Like, how do you know when an idea is something that's going to increase the trust, but just enough that it's going to benefit the company and not hurt the growth?
- 44:48Like, this is this fine equilibrium, this balance that you're trying to figure out.
- 44:54And it's a smart play to increase trust, but it's a difficult idea.
- 44:58It's a difficult thing to decide on what kills a company versus that perfect amount of trust that secures the client or the customer or the subscriber.
- 45:08Well, I'll start by saying that, again, in hindsight, things like not having any of our content inside Google or requiring verification of identity, those look really smart.
- 45:19There were probably 100 things that we did that were actually genuinely bad ideas that we don't talk about today because they're already gone and they didn't work at it.
- 45:28But for those two in particular, because they're related, it's less that we talked about
- 45:34the challenge of choosing those solutions.
- 45:37And it's more that we went back to this truism that we felt was even more important than getting distribution through SEO or through removing friction.
- 45:47And that truism for us was, how do we build a virtual space
- 45:51that is as analogous to the real world space as possible.
- 45:56And so to give you an answer or to give you an example, when you talk to someone in your neighborhood, you don't have to wonder whether or not that person lives in the neighborhood.
- 46:05You've probably seen them or they've just walked out of their front door, right?
- 46:09And so we knew we needed verification of identity.
- 46:12And that's what drove it.
- 46:13It wasn't that we want to just pick the thing that's most high friction, right?
- 46:17It just so happened that that was more friction than what people...
- 46:21had done in the past.
- 46:22With the no SEO, there are a couple things there.
- 46:24The first is when you're having a conversation with a neighbor,
- 46:28You don't think that the contents of that conversation is going to be accessible to anyone in the world.
- 46:34You're just having a private conversation, right?
- 46:36You and I are having a conversation that we both know is going to be accessible.
- 46:39And so we're going into it with the right amount of transparency into what the end result is going to be.
- 46:44But if you and I were having a conversation on your couch tonight about something completely different that wasn't part of the podcast, we wouldn't expect that to show up on YouTube.
- 46:53Right?
- 46:54And so the same way, those conversations that happen between neighbors that have happened for 15 years on Nextdoor, they can't show up in Google because that wasn't the construct behind the conversation to begin with.
- 47:05Additionally, my first company that I started, Epinions, that ultimately became a company called shopping.com, the public, and then was bought by eBay, that company really took advantage of SEO.
- 47:17And after we went public, we dropped out of the Google index for a month because of a clerical error that an engineer made.
- 47:25He put a robots.txt file saying, do not crawl me on the main site accidentally.
- 47:30And so for a month, we fell out of the Google index.
- 47:33As a result, we missed our numbers.
- 47:34The stock tanked.
- 47:35The company had to be sold.
- 47:37And so there was a part of me as a repeat entrepreneur that said,
- 47:42I know whatever company I start, there are going to be big intractable challenges.
- 47:47That's kind of the definition of being an entrepreneur and starting a new company.
- 47:50But at least as a multi-time founder, I want to pick the challenges that I'm comfortable taking.
- 47:56And I don't want to pick the challenge of SEO because I don't know if I can sleep at night
- 48:02knowing that most of my traffic is not in my control.
- 48:06And so today, when you look at actually what's happening, not just with SEO, but specifically what's happening to publishers, because Google is now answering queries with its own AI, without letting users get to the links, right?
- 48:21Can you imagine what it's like to get most of your traffic from Google today?
- 48:24You know that's not gonna continue, but you haven't built the muscle.
- 48:28on how people will come to you directly.
- 48:30So with Nextdoor, it's different because we've never relied on SEO, but I would be way too arrogant to say that we planned that in advance, right?
- 48:38We were very, very, very fortunate that we chose a path because we wanted to protect our users' conversations from a privacy standpoint.
- 48:47We're very lucky that that's led us to a place now where all of our distribution is our own distribution.
- 48:54It's completely earned.
- 48:54And that's why, you know, when I came back to the company,
- 48:57Two and a half years ago.
- 48:59And Bill Gurley and I said to ourselves after the stock had gone down 90 percent from its IPO price, we asked ourselves, is there an opportunity here?
- 49:09Because we're in the age of AI.
- 49:11Nextdoor is not an AI native company.
- 49:13We've already spent a lot of time on this.
- 49:15Right.
- 49:16Is this a company worth spending time on?
- 49:18And we looked at the core assets and we looked at the verified identity.
- 49:22We looked at the fully owned distribution.
- 49:24We looked at the unique content.
- 49:25We looked at the conversational interface.
- 49:28And we said to ourselves, there are some assets here that are just as valuable today in the age of intelligence and AI as they were valuable in 2010, 11, 12, 13 when the company was flying high.
- 49:41So let's come back and try to turn those assets into something that has real material value.
- 49:47And so, again, I wish I could say that we predicted where the world would be today.
- 49:52There's no way that that's the case.
- 49:55We just have been lucky and we'll take the luck, like most great entrepreneurs, we'll take the luck and apply as much hard work as possible against that luck and hope it turns into something special.
- 50:06Thank you.
- 50:06HubSpot is a success story partner.
- 50:08Now, customers are using traditional search less and less to find the businesses they want to buy from.
- 50:13Now, when a buyer or a customer asks AI for a solution like yours, does your business come up?
- 50:19They're looking for a product, they're looking for a service, and they're going into some AI chat tool and they're saying, hey, help me find the best one.
- 50:25If your company isn't showing up, you're missing out.
- 50:27And most companies have no idea if their business is showing up or even how to show up.
- 50:32And by the time they figure it out, they've already lost a deal to somebody to figure it out
- 50:36AI.
- 50:36This is what AEO is.
- 50:38Answer Engine Optimization.
- 50:40HubSpot AEO helps you show up in those moments with the right answers that your buyers and your customers are looking for.
- 50:46It could be before the first click, before the first form fill.
- 50:50That's the moment HubSpot AEO is built for.
- 50:53So check out HubSpot.com to learn more about AEO.
- 50:55HubSpot is the agentic customer platform for growing businesses.
- 50:59NetSuite Next is a success story partner.
- 51:01So they say that every day your business is late to using AI, you fall two days behind and the competition is only moving faster.
- 51:09So how do you keep up?
- 51:11Well, fortunately there is NetSuite Next.
- 51:13Now you probably already know NetSuite.
- 51:15NetSuite is the AI powered business management suite.
- 51:17It's trusted by over 43,000 customers.
- 51:20It securely connects all of your data, financials, inventory, commerce, HR, CRM, into one single source of truth.
- 51:27But NetSuite Next is the next huge leap in how businesses get done because AI is built into everything you do.
- 51:35So NetSuite Next automatically shows you all these custom insights for your business throughout your day.
- 51:41You'll have AI agents work alongside you to solve problems and handle routine work.
- 51:45And anytime you have a question about anything in your business, you just ask like you're having a conversation with a colleague and NetSuite Next will give you an answer.
- 51:53NetSuite is customized for a wide range of industries, so it supports the way that your business truly works.
- 51:59Whether your company earns millions or hundreds of millions, it's time for NetSuite Next, where your business meets AI.
- 52:06If I needed a solution like this, it's what I'd use.
- 52:08For the first time ever, you can try NetSuite Next for free.
- 52:12If your revenues are at least in these seven figures, go to netsuite.ai.scottclary.
- 52:18It's built for every industry.
- 52:20It's ready for every boardroom.
- 52:22NetSuite.ai slash Scott Clary.
- 52:24Monarch is a success story partner.
- 52:26Now, quick question.
- 52:27Do you know where your money went last month?
- 52:29Not roughly, but exactly.
- 52:30And most people don't.
- 52:31And I didn't for years.
- 52:32And that is most of our money stories, right?
- 52:35When we first start our career, we have one income and one account, and you can kind of wing it.
- 52:39But once you're running businesses, once you're investing, once you're carrying 50 different subscriptions that you stop paying attention to, winging it gets super expensive.
- 52:47Monarch fixed that for me.
- 52:48It is the personal finance app that tracks everything.
- 52:50everything.
- 52:51So that means accounts, investments, savings goals, spending all on one screen.
- 52:55The first week I had it, it fired recurring charges I've been paying for months without realizing.
- 52:59And every single week, the AI recap tells me if spending spiked, if my net worth moved, and what bills are coming.
- 53:04And I can just ask it, hey, can I afford this trip without touching my savings?
- 53:08And I can get a real answer based on my actual numbers.
- 53:11It is a financial advisor in your pocket.
- 53:13It costs less than an hour with a real one.
- 53:15So write your own money story with Monarch.
- 53:17Use code success at monarch.com and get your first year of Monarch Core half off at just $50.
- 53:22That's 50% off your first year at monarch.com with code success.
- 53:26A couple thoughts.
- 53:27First of all, when you apply a whole bunch of hard work against luck, there's a point where you are architecting a little bit of your own luck.
- 53:35So I don't think that it's fair to just say it's pure luck.
- 53:38There's a lot of people that could have the same circumstances, same company, same situation, and fumble to a degree.
- 53:44So you still have to understand when you are getting lucky and ride that wave.
- 53:48So you did a great job.
- 53:51One thought about the decline in organic search.
- 53:54this is something that is hitting companies very hard.
- 53:57I mean, I'll speak from personal experience.
- 54:00This podcast is sponsored by HubSpot.
- 54:02It has been for several years now, and every year I speak at Inbound.
- 54:06And I think last year they published a paper, which is basically like the state of organic search, because HubSpot as a company was built on organic search.
- 54:16They were the company where if you Googled almost any business term, you could find a blog article on it.
- 54:21And it just showed they were way ahead of the curve on this, but it just showed year over year, like massive, massive, massive decline in organic search.
- 54:29And this is a company that understands organic search better than almost any company on earth.
- 54:36And then they started figuring out, okay, how do we have earned distribution?
- 54:40How do we go through influencers, different media and content formats?
- 54:45And now they're figuring out, and they have figured out to a degree, like the AI or the agentic search optimization or whatever you want to call it, play.
- 54:55But this is...
- 54:56This is, actually, I'll ask you, what's the lesson for entrepreneurs?
- 55:01So for example, you build a company that's based on organic search, HubSpot navigated it, you've actually built it so you never had to even deal with it.
- 55:11But for the entrepreneur that's starting something, they're thinking, okay, I have to find a way to build a company that can survive if where my traffic comes from
- 55:23radically shifts or should I even start from scratch in a different way where every customer I acquire is earned and I don't have to worry about growing by competing on someone else's platform?
- 55:39Like, what is the lesson in all of this for somebody who's starting out on how to navigate this?
- 55:43Because for somebody starting, this is just scary.
- 55:46Like we're having this conversation about how you lucked out.
- 55:48I'm talking about how HubSpot navigated, you know, their main, their decline of their main traffic source.
- 55:53And somebody's like, oh, my God, I just want to get one customer.
- 55:56And that's my main goal right now.
- 55:57And I don't have any of these things figured out yet.
- 55:59This is overwhelming.
- 56:01So to that entrepreneur, what is your advice to them?
- 56:04Well, we mentioned Bill Gurley and has this great expression, and it is be a learn it all, not a know it all.
- 56:11So typically entrepreneurs, they start off and I would say you want to be intentional about both the advantages and the obstacles that you're choosing, because almost every advantage exists.
- 56:24There's an obstacle side too.
- 56:25Almost everything is a two-sided coin.
- 56:27So if you say to yourself, I figured out a way to get great SEO, you need to understand that the other side of the coin is if SEO changes, you're going to have to completely re-architect your service.
- 56:38If on the other hand, you say, I don't want to have SEO.
- 56:42Well, then the other side, that may be an advantage, but the other side of that coin is, okay, how are you going to build organic distribution, which is one of the most difficult things to do on the consumer internet, right?
- 56:52So the first thing I would say is you can never stop as an entrepreneur, particularly in the tech industry.
- 56:59trying to understand where the industry is going.
- 57:03Because in almost all cases, the great companies are the beneficiaries of megatrends that are bigger than any one company.
- 57:13And if you time one of those trends well, well, you see what happens.
- 57:17And if you're not prepared for one of those trends, you can be flattened instantly.
- 57:22If you're a company today that is timed AI the right way, you almost certainly are valued way higher than you were five years ago.
- 57:31If you're a company today that hasn't prepared for AI, you're almost certainly one fifth of the value that you were five years ago, right?
- 57:38So you have to be a learn it on, you have to be hungry
- 57:42Think about where is this industry going?
- 57:46And at the same time, you can't be too early because pioneers get arrows in their backs, right?
- 57:51So if you were too early with agentic AI and you gave up all of your SEO, maybe you never would have gotten there.
- 57:58If you're too late, you know you obviously will die.
- 58:01So as an entrepreneur, you constantly have to be living in the past, the present, and the future.
- 58:08The past is, okay, what has worked?
- 58:10The present is what's working right now.
- 58:12And the future is what do we think is going to work in the future?
- 58:16I know, for example, that AI...
- 58:19is going to be a boom that we're in the early innings up.
- 58:22So from my standpoint, I could be wrong, but from my standpoint, every hour that we invest in AI today is going to pay off big time.
- 58:31Next year, the year after, and I think for a decade,
- 58:35for now.
- 58:36And so I would tell any entrepreneur, make sure you're deep in AI.
- 58:39I don't know exactly where it's going to go.
- 58:41I don't know if it's going to be mostly software or if they're going to be robots and other pieces of hardware.
- 58:45But I know that understanding AI and being able to harness it and use it and understand how it affects businesses, that is probably the most important skill for any entrepreneur in any industry right now.
- 58:56And so I can say that as an entrepreneur who's lived through dot-com boom,
- 59:01and then transition from desktop to mobile, mobile to cloud, now cloud to AI, right?
- 59:06I've seen the way these transitions work, but you cannot get stuck where you are.
- 59:11I mean, the great companies in our industry, they either don't last very long,
- 59:16or they reinvent themselves.
- 59:18Look at Apple and Microsoft.
- 59:20They were both left for dead.
- 59:22It's amazing to think this, but left for dead.
- 59:26And then they transformed themselves for a new generation.
- 59:28And today, you may ask yourself, where's Apple on AI?
- 59:33What has Microsoft done at?
- 59:34They're going to have to do it again, because today they're not the leaders when it comes to AI, right?
- 59:40So as an entrepreneur in this industry,
- 59:43If you make it a priority to be a learn-it-all, you're putting yourself at a competitive advantage, right?
- 59:50Because you are more likely to be able to adjust to the changes that are made, right?
- 59:56I mean, it's that old Clayton Christensen book, you know, The Innovator's Dilemma, right?
- 1:00:01I mean, the other thing I'd say is almost always success is...
- 1:00:05is the wrong kind of lesson to continue succeeding.
- 1:00:09Whereas failure, if you learn from it, can equip you to succeed in the future.
- 1:00:15I mean, if you're successful, you kind of sit back and you're pinching yourself, saying, wow, this is amazing.
- 1:00:21Can you believe what's going on right now?
- 1:00:23And you won't see the tidal wave that comes behind you.
- 1:00:26and takes your company away with it.
- 1:00:28If you fail and you're at the bottom of the ocean because you've already been hit by the tidal wave, you do one of two things.
- 1:00:33You say, gosh, this isn't for me.
- 1:00:35I'm hanging it up.
- 1:00:36Or you say, I never want to be at the bottom of this ocean again.
- 1:00:40What am I going to learn from this experience to make sure that the next time this tidal wave comes...
- 1:00:46I'm writing it versus being buried by it.
- 1:00:49And that's all about learning.
- 1:00:51I think the ultimate competitive advantage for an entrepreneur is to learn.
- 1:00:56If you can learn, and this is why AI to me is so powerful.
- 1:00:59Because before, where could you learn?
- 1:01:02You learn from other people, you learn from books, you learn from what you read and what you saw, right?
- 1:01:07Now, all of that is coming to you in the form of one agent.
- 1:01:11And you can talk to it for hours and hours and hours.
- 1:01:14So I think there's an incredible opportunity for entrepreneurs today to have a level playing field in terms of that access to information and intelligence.
- 1:01:22But that doesn't mean that the AI is going to do the work for us.
- 1:01:24We still have to do the work.
- 1:01:26But if we do the work, we'll be able to anticipate what's ahead.
- 1:01:30You've said that leaving next door was the hardest thing you've ever done professionally.
- 1:01:35I want to know what was going on in 2018.
- 1:01:37But also, I want to piggyback off of your idea after you tell the audience that story, because there's some lessons there as well.
- 1:01:45When you came back, you were just speaking about these companies that almost died and came back.
- 1:01:50And I don't want to say that's what happened with Nextdoor, but when you came back, you called it a refounding, which is a really interesting word.
- 1:01:57Refounding, not a turnaround.
- 1:01:59So please tell everybody the story about why you stepped away, why it was so hard, what was going on.
- 1:02:05But then let's talk about...
- 1:02:07You coming back, we could talk about Bill Gurley's.
- 1:02:09He's been on the podcast.
- 1:02:10He's a great guy.
- 1:02:12Incredible, incredible investor.
- 1:02:13If you don't know who we're talking about.
- 1:02:14So please go look up that episode, but talk about this, you know, this hiatus, this refounding, and then also why, why refounding?
- 1:02:22What's the lesson from, you know, coming back and disrupting something or refounding it that an entrepreneur can learn from, but tell your story first.
- 1:02:34Yeah, no, you said a lot of powerful things in there.
- 1:02:36So I'll start with leaving next door and why it was hard.
- 1:02:39And it kind of...
- 1:02:42It echoes what I said before about success not being a great teacher.
- 1:02:47I started Nextdoor in the summer of 2010.
- 1:02:48And even though we were never a hyper-growth company, I don't remember a month or a quarter or a year where something we did in the past was better than what we were doing in the present and what we were going to do in the future.
- 1:03:02So we were very steady in terms of our growth.
- 1:03:05And our growth was getting bigger and bigger and bigger as we compounded.
- 1:03:10But my performance as a CEO was kind of doing the opposite.
- 1:03:14I had plateaued and then I was actually, I think, starting to become less effective all the time.
- 1:03:19And maybe a part of that was the company was larger and it required a different set of skills.
- 1:03:25A lot of times founders are really good in the early days and then they get worse and worse as the company gets larger.
- 1:03:31Maybe it was because I was really tired.
- 1:03:33I'd been a CEO for, gosh, I don't know, almost 20 years at that point.
- 1:03:37Nextdoor was the third company that I started.
- 1:03:40And then I think the third thing is I wasn't that self-aware.
- 1:03:44And early in my career, I was really lucky because I had the CEO coach, Bill Campbell, probably the best CEO coach in the history of Silicon Valley.
- 1:03:52And he was like a mirror for me as I developed as a young CEO.
- 1:03:58I was a CEO for the first time at 27 or 28 years of age.
- 1:04:00I knew nothing.
- 1:04:01I didn't deserve to be a CEO.
- 1:04:03I was lucky to be there.
- 1:04:05And Bill helped me take that luck and make the most of it.
- 1:04:09Bill sadly passed away and I didn't really have a CEO coach, nor was I open to seeing what my weaknesses were.
- 1:04:19And so in 2018, the board of Nextdoor felt that we were building a company that could be a company for the ages, tens of billions of dollars of market cap or even larger.
- 1:04:31And I don't think they felt that
- 1:04:34If I ran it as CEO or continue to run it as CEO, we would get there.
- 1:04:38So it was hard to lead because it wasn't my choice, for one.
- 1:04:42But the other reason is when you're a founder and the CEO of your own company, your identity is just indistinct from that company, particularly if you're in Silicon Valley.
- 1:04:54So I went to Stanford and I worked in Silicon Valley.
- 1:04:56And when I thought of myself and my identity, it was as the founder and CEO of Nextdoor.
- 1:05:04And so if I'm no longer the CEO of Nextdoor, who am I?
- 1:05:08And it sounds silly, but it's kind of profound because you wake up every morning thinking that you have this purpose professionally, and the purpose is to fulfill the identity that you have.
- 1:05:19And that identity for me was as CEO of Nextdoor.
- 1:05:22And so when you can't continue that, and it's not really your choice, I mean, it's a double whammy because the first thing is...
- 1:05:30You're not able to do it even if you want to continue.
- 1:05:32And the second thing is you're going to have to pick up the pieces and figure out what you do next.
- 1:05:37And so I left at the end of 2018.
- 1:05:40It turned out to be one of the greatest blessings ever because it allowed me to take a step back.
- 1:05:47to relax for a moment, to take a deep breath, to spend more time with my wife and three kids, and to finally have a moment to look in the mirror and say, okay, what do I want to be?
- 1:06:00What do I want to learn from this experience?
- 1:06:02How do I want to change?
- 1:06:03How do I want to grow?
- 1:06:05I talk a lot about being a learn-it-all, right?
- 1:06:07I needed to be a learn-it-all, right?
- 1:06:10And so it provided the breath of fresh air, right?
- 1:06:14For me to say, I'm not worried when I wake up every morning about the company because I'm not running it anymore.
- 1:06:21Let me be worried about myself and being the best person I can be, not just the best CEO, but the best human being, the best father, the best husband, right?
- 1:06:31And then maybe a CEO.
- 1:06:33The truth is I was so burned out at that point.
- 1:06:35I never thought I'd be a CEO again.
- 1:06:37I didn't want to be.
- 1:06:38It's a lot of pressure.
- 1:06:40It takes a lot of life force to run a company.
- 1:06:44I was really lucky.
- 1:06:45One of the early Nextdoor investors, Hedda Sophia, a London-based VC firm, the founder and CEO Ian Osborne had been an investor in Nextdoor.
- 1:06:55He said, why don't you join Hedda Sophia as executive chairman?
- 1:06:57He
- 1:06:58You can learn to be an investor and you can sit on boards and you can be part of the other side of the table.
- 1:07:04You know, one side of the table is the entrepreneurs.
- 1:07:06The other side is investors.
- 1:07:08And I loved the time that I spent at Hedo Sophia.
- 1:07:11I loved helping entrepreneurs.
- 1:07:13I joke and say I love giving them advice.
- 1:07:16And then going home and going to sleep with a clear conscience where they would go to sleep worrying about the advice I had just given them and whether it was the right advice or the wrong advice, you know, the way I had for 20 years.
- 1:07:27And so I never thought I would come back to next door.
- 1:07:30Why did I come back?
- 1:07:31I mean, the company was failing.
- 1:07:33Yeah.
- 1:07:33It honestly was.
- 1:07:35And I was on the board and Bill was on the board.
- 1:07:36And so you can't blame that on anyone, right?
- 1:07:40I mean, it's collective responsibility, but it wasn't working.
- 1:07:44And even though it would require a tremendous sacrifice to leave a great job at Hedda Sofia and go back to next door,
- 1:07:53My wife said to me, I think if you're on your deathbed and this thing called next door had gone poof and had failed and someone asked you, why did you let that happen?
- 1:08:05You would have a regret if you thought to yourself you had a chance to go in there and try to make the outcome different and you didn't do it.
- 1:08:12And so I went back and...
- 1:08:15You talk about a refounding.
- 1:08:16I mean, there were so many reasons that we needed a refounding.
- 1:08:19You mentioned one of them, which is we needed to massively disrupt
- 1:08:24the trajectory that the company was on.
- 1:08:26The company had lost 90% of its value.
- 1:08:28The company was shrinking.
- 1:08:30The company's product was not performing the way that it was intended to perform.
- 1:08:35And so turning that around, I mean, can you think of that many consumer internet properties who've gone from shrinking to growing?
- 1:08:42It's very, very, very hard, and it rarely happens, if ever.
- 1:08:46So we needed something radical.
- 1:08:48The other thing is, I needed to be a much more effective CEO.
- 1:08:53to be part of that turnaround.
- 1:08:55I knew that.
- 1:08:55I knew that if I came back and operated the company the way I had in the past,
- 1:09:00Nothing would change.
- 1:09:02In fact, maybe the company would fail even more quickly.
- 1:09:04And so I had to ask myself, I mean, this is a refounding for me as a CEO as well, but ultimately when you talk about a refounding, you're going back to your DNA, you're going back to your first principles, you're going back to why did I start this company in the first place?
- 1:09:20And we start thinking about things like the power of community.
- 1:09:23And we start thinking about things like the age of human connection.
- 1:09:26We start thinking about things like making people love where they live even more than they do.
- 1:09:32And those are really powerful building blocks.
- 1:09:35But you have to get back to them because when you've been around for 13 years and you're a public company and you're on that quarterly rhythm, the metrics start to take over.
- 1:09:45They exceed the mission.
- 1:09:47But when you're a founder, you don't have any metrics.
- 1:09:49It's all about mission.
- 1:09:50And so we needed to get back to the mission.
- 1:09:52And I needed to get back to my own personal mission as a CEO too.
- 1:09:56Because when I left, I think like many CEOs, I was beating people down to get things done.
- 1:10:02You know, I was persecuting people to get results.
- 1:10:06It's an easy way to do it.
- 1:10:07You intimidate, you threaten, right?
- 1:10:11When I came back, I said to myself, gosh, I know this is going to be very difficult, but I'd like to reinvent the way that I lead.
- 1:10:18I want to lift people up.
- 1:10:20I want to inspire them.
- 1:10:21I want them to feel empowered to do the best that they can do.
- 1:10:25And I knew that that was going to take a refounding myself.
- 1:10:28It was going to require more patience.
- 1:10:30It was going to require more clarity.
- 1:10:32It was going to require more poise, more calmness.
- 1:10:35Those aren't things that you typically associate with a founder, right?
- 1:10:39I mean, founders are impatient and we're stressed out and we're anxious and we're pulling our hair out, right?
- 1:10:44And so it was a tremendous challenge for me and a tremendous challenge for the company.
- 1:10:48And we're still in the middle of that, but I think we're making progress.
- 1:10:51When you think about your decision to come back and to participate in this refounding and this disrupting of Nextdoor, what?
- 1:11:00Have you thought about who the most influential person was in that decision?
- 1:11:05And when I say that, I mean, were you the most influential person convincing yourself?
- 1:11:10Was it somebody like a Bill Gurley?
- 1:11:12Was it somebody on the board?
- 1:11:13Was it your wife?
- 1:11:14Was it your kids?
- 1:11:15Like, who is the person, and it can still be you, who decided or influenced you to say, yes, I'm going to take this on again?
- 1:11:25You know, I'm really lucky.
- 1:11:26I have this old friend, Reid Hoffman, the founder of LinkedIn.
- 1:11:31And I met him in 1996.
- 1:11:32And so I knew him before he started LinkedIn.
- 1:11:36I knew him when he was Reid Hoffman alone, not Reid Hoffman, the billionaire founder of LinkedIn.
- 1:11:40And he has this really interesting experience.
- 1:11:44theory, which is founders tend to work on the same problem their entire careers.
- 1:11:49It may be through various different companies, various different efforts, investments, et cetera.
- 1:11:54The through line for me is not just professional that way.
- 1:11:58It's personal, which is I crave community, both in my professional life and my personal life.
- 1:12:03And what that means is a decision like coming back to next door, it could never just be me.
- 1:12:10Who's the reason behind that decision?
- 1:12:12It was a community.
- 1:12:14It was all of the people that you mentioned.
- 1:12:16It was my wife.
- 1:12:18It was my parents.
- 1:12:19It was my kids.
- 1:12:20You know, my kids are now 14, 12, and 10.
- 1:12:24When I left next door in 2018, I mean, you can do the math.
- 1:12:28That was eight years ago, right?
- 1:12:29They were much younger.
- 1:12:30I don't think they really knew what it was like.
- 1:12:33for their father to be the CEO of a company.
- 1:12:35Now they know, they understand the sacrifices.
- 1:12:37They don't always like them, but hopefully they're learning that when one is passionate about something, it does require sacrifice and it does require commitment and work ethic and all those things that we have to put in.
- 1:12:49Bill Gurley was a big part of it because if he felt given his ability to really understand sacrifice,
- 1:12:56value and how to unlock that value in a very radical way.
- 1:13:00If he felt that there was no opportunity in next door, it wouldn't make a lot of sense for me to leave investing in great companies that are on the bleeding edge and come back to a company that had no future.
- 1:13:11My co-founder, Sarah Leary, I was lucky that she came back to the company.
- 1:13:15She was pivotal in the decision.
- 1:13:18But look, at the end of the day,
- 1:13:21I love community.
- 1:13:22And the idea that I would have an opportunity with my own hands to be part of building a product, a tool, that has the potential to make community stronger, safer, and happier...
- 1:13:36That really is my purpose, certainly professionally.
- 1:13:39That is my happy place.
- 1:13:42That is what I want to do when I wake up in the morning, regardless of the sacrifice.
- 1:13:47And so it required all of those things.
- 1:13:49And even with all of that, there were a lot of scary moments and there still are.
- 1:13:55And that is the entrepreneurial journey.
- 1:13:58For people who are listening, who are, a lot of them are entrepreneurs.
- 1:14:01A lot of them are building their first company.
- 1:14:04Some may be serial, but I want you to just take the most important lesson that you've learned over your career, founding multiple companies, multiple successes, multiple failures along the way too.
- 1:14:14What's that one lesson that you want to leave everybody with?
- 1:14:16The most important thing that I have learned over and over again is the most important question is not what, it's who.
- 1:14:25And who could be, who am I starting this venture with?
- 1:14:29Who am I going to seek for investment funds?
- 1:14:31Who am I building this for?
- 1:14:32Who is my customer?
- 1:14:33But so many entrepreneurs start by asking what?
- 1:14:37What should I build?
- 1:14:38What's the competitive advantage?
- 1:14:40What's my distribution strategy?
- 1:14:41All of those things are important, but to me, way more important by an order of magnitude
- 1:14:47is the question of who.
- 1:14:49First of all, thank you for everything.
- 1:14:51I just want to give people the opportunity to connect with you.
- 1:14:53So where do you want to send people?
- 1:14:54So we'll put everything in the show notes, all the links, everything, but social, where do you want them to go?
- 1:14:59Easy to find me on X and LinkedIn.
- 1:15:02And increasingly, I'm going to start on Instagram as well.
- 1:15:05So any of those three.
- 1:15:07If you could go back and you could tell your 20-year-old self one piece of advice, it doesn't have to be business advice, it could be life advice, whatever you want, the most important lesson.
- 1:15:14You can only pass on one lesson.
- 1:15:16What would it be and why?
- 1:15:17The lesson would be to enjoy the journey because the only asset that we cannot make more of is time.
- 1:15:25And so whether it's those times when I was up all night, just bellyaching because I couldn't solve a problem, or whether it was those brief moments when it felt like we'd finally scaled the mountain and we were at the top –
- 1:15:39I wish I could just hold on to those moments forever.
- 1:15:42And so enjoying the journey and taking advantage of the roses along the way, it's so important because it all goes too fast.