Latest / Unforbidden Truth / Interview with Idaho double murderer Eldon Samuel
Transcript
- 0:00Odd odd odd. My name is Elvin Samuel and I'm originally from California.
- 0:34Can you recall any positive memories that stick out to you from your childhood?
- 0:39Yes, my parents tried to make a lot of positive memories by taking me
- 0:48to Disneyland, Universal studios or just like carnivals and stuff. So even though
- 0:55there were a lot of bad memories, there were good memories too with it.
- 1:03So you said there were a lot of bad memories. Can you think
- 1:04of any that stick out to you that are more notable from your talented Yeah.
- 1:12Both my parents were drug addicts, so there were times when they were
- 1:18off on their medications opiates I believe, and they would act out physically,
- 1:26emotionally abused me. Was it was it emotional and physical? Yes? Can
- 1:38you think of any times where you were abused that you can talk about.
- 1:41I don't want to set off any type of traumatic memories by any means,
- 1:45but are you able to elaborate at all? Ye? Oh. My dad
- 1:55he would have a gun at some point and he would threatened to take his
- 2:00own life by pointing the gun to his head, and that kind of scared
- 2:07all of us. There were times when he ran over my mom with the
- 2:12Firebird Pontiac Firebird. There was another time when my mom would act out,
- 2:23but the only difference between my mom and dad is that my dad would really
- 2:30feel bad afterwards, and my mom would just seem to mentally forget it.
- 2:39Now, was the abuse just targeted towards yourself or did your little brother Jonathan?
- 2:45Did he receive it as well? My brother received it as well,
- 2:50but because he was autistic, the trauma didn't affect him the same way I
- 2:55did, and it usually it made me feel alone, like I had to
- 3:01deal with it all by myself, so you felt like you couldn't. Did
- 3:12you feel like you had nobody to talk to or nobody to go to and
- 3:15he just felt isolated? Yes, I know it wasn't his fault that he
- 3:22was autistic, but still made me feel alone. Did you ever try to
- 3:30talk to him about it or do you feel like he just wouldn't understand.
- 3:34He wouldn't have understood. He was lost in his own world, and it
- 3:39just kind of made me mad because he would seem to forget it easier than
- 3:45I could. So besides the abuse, can you can you recall any type
- 3:53of childhood trauma you might have suffered that might have impacted you. Yeah,
- 4:04there was one thing that my mom always did, and she would say if
- 4:10I didn't do this or that, I would die. So like if I
- 4:14took their medications, I would die. If I didn't take my own medicine
- 4:17because I was sick with fevers at a really young age, I would die
- 4:23if I drink or did this or that. Anything. There was always some
- 4:28thread that I would die because of it, and that really affected me.
- 4:34Like like until I came to prison, I was afraid to take psychiatric commundications
- 4:45and just like be alone outside of the house or something. So that affected
- 4:53me more than anything. Kept me away from their drugs, so I didn't
- 4:57become a drug addict, but it kind of made me, you worse in
- 5:00a way. So how would you say that you did get along with both
- 5:06your mom, dad, and brother up until the crimes that took place.
- 5:13There were times when we would be a perfect family, but because both my
- 5:17parents were on drugs, it was only a matter of time till they argued
- 5:24acted out made our life source. But the times when we were a perfect
- 5:31family, then it would be nice, but I knew it can last.
- 5:43And what about your brother? How did you get along with him up until
- 5:46the crimes that took place, I never really could feel like I could connect
- 5:55with him. But there were times when things were okay and things felt normal.
- 6:05Those were really the only times I could like be happy with my brother,
- 6:12my parents. But as soon as like that happy period was gone,
- 6:21then HI was alone again. So you felt like you were alone most of
- 6:30your childhood, if not all of your childhood, Yeah, most of it.
- 6:35I could never really talk to my parents if I felt like if I
- 6:42needed to talk to someone. So did you engage in any criminal activity prior
- 6:51to the two cases you're serving time for now? Did I engage in criminal
- 6:57activity? Yeah? Prior to the cases that you're in prison for now,
- 7:02the only thing I could think of is drinking. When I was about thirteen
- 7:08or fourteen, I never did any hard drugs. My dad actually gave me
- 7:15one of his vicodin or whatever it was at some point. That's the closest
- 7:23I came to actually doing drugs or drinking. So you were a pretty straight
- 7:29and narrow then. Other than the other than drinking, like, you didn't
- 7:32trade any like burglaries or if you weren't fighting at school or anything like that.
- 7:38Yeah. I never really got into fights at school, like, not
- 7:42enough to actually cause any damage. There's one thing I did when the neighbor's
- 7:53house was empty, no one was moving in there. I kind of got
- 7:57my rip Rider Bevy gun and shot at the window. So I don't know
- 8:01why I did that. It was ridiculous, but I was a really confused
- 8:07kid. Had you been diagnosed with thinking about the illnesses as a child,
- 8:18No, I'm not. No. My parents tried to veer me away from
- 8:20psychiatrists or any kind of diagnosis. Did you ever get any diagnoses later on
- 8:31in life? Yeah, when I started serving time. I think I'm currently
- 8:43diagnosed for some minor schizophrenia. I don't know what officially my diagnosis, but
- 8:52I think that has to do with it. Were you hearing any voices or
- 8:58see anything at the time that the privates a plate, yea, I think
- 9:05sort of. I really thought I heard my dad shoot his gun outside,
- 9:11and that was kind of the last straw for me to I could do what
- 9:16I did. So let's talk about that. Let's talk about the crimes that
- 9:24you're in prison for now. You're convicted of killing your brother and father and
- 9:28are currently serving a twenty year to life sentence. Do you walk me through
- 9:31everything that led up to the murders of your brother and father. Yes,
- 9:39it started out when we first moved to Idaho. My dad was waiting on
- 9:43a disability check for twenty thousand dollars, and so after we lived in that
- 9:48little shack of a house, he got the money and we started spending it
- 9:54really fast on a truck, a trailer, video games, TVs, just
- 10:03anything that could be of use and like that shock. So there was a
- 10:11time when my dad took us camping and he didn't really act out too much
- 10:18at all. He was legitimately happy, But then he started spiraling down with
- 10:24his drug abuse, getting on too many of his medications, acting out again,
- 10:30yelling. Then, like I noticed he was spiraling down, and I
- 10:35kinda was expecting him to do something crazy. Then one night he was outside
- 10:46and I heard a gunshot or something. I think it was just once now
- 10:50I realized it could have been him slamming the trunk of the truck down.
- 11:00The time, I was playing video games and I was trying a new medication
- 11:07called prozac. Yeah, you know. And then then he came back in
- 11:18the house. He said his guns forty five on the counter. And when
- 11:24I heard that shot outside, or what I thought was a shot, I
- 11:28thought I just thought that was the last straw. And I hid the gun
- 11:31behind my back and stood in the doorway of my room and he said,
- 11:35pack up everything, We're going out of here. And I knew he was
- 11:39delusional, so I said no, and so he prodded me. He poked
- 11:45a finger at me when I was standing in the doorway. He said,
- 11:48what did you say? And I said no again, and I told him
- 11:54not to do that, and when he did do it again, I shot
- 11:56him in the stomach. And from there I just kind of lost my mind.
- 12:11Did you feel like it was almost like an automatic reaction or refleg to
- 12:18shoot him after he had took you? Yes? And what happened after that?
- 12:28When he fell inside my room, I kind of took that chance to
- 12:35run out of the room and he was fleeting everywhere. I was still holding
- 12:41the gun, but I was crying my eyes out and I couldn't even talk.
- 12:46And all he said was you shot me. He said that over and
- 12:52over, and it was like I was watching this from a TV screen and
- 12:56I couldn't control anything. I could barely talk then he crawled to my brother's
- 13:05room. I told him that I'm sorry, and I shot him a few
- 13:13times in the head. I don't know why. I just felt like that
- 13:18was the right thing to do. He was already dead by that point.
- 13:24His face was just drained of blood. So I closed his eyes like I've
- 13:31seen people doing movies before, and I actually held the gun to my own
- 13:43head and I was really going to pull the trigger, just I was in
- 13:48so much pain. Then I heard my brother call out from under the bed
- 13:54where my dad crawled right next to and then I just felt this rage come
- 14:01over me, and I think my brother might have been the only thing that
- 14:09saved my own life, just being angry at him, all those years of
- 14:15him not experiencing the same kind of trauma I did, and I just I
- 14:22just killed him. And from what I understand, you had shot at him
- 14:31a place from two different guns. I shot at him I don't know how
- 14:37many times. With the forty five. I loaded a shotgun and used that
- 14:43on him too. I had a knife, and then when I tore the
- 14:50mattress off the bed so I could get at him, I had a machete
- 14:54and I used that on him. That was the last thing I used.
- 15:01Do you remember about how many times you used the machete? I don't know.
- 15:09I really don't know, Like I was just so angry. Yeah,
- 15:16I just kept using it. I could never guess how many times I used
- 15:22it or so you were just feeling anger and rage at the time with the
- 15:31shooting and the stabbing of your brother, Yes, it was in a way.
- 15:37It was kind of a way to cope after killing my dad, if
- 15:48that makes sense, Yeah, yeah it does. I know this may sound
- 15:52weird, but do you feel like you almost were releasing a lot of rage
- 15:56and anger at that time? And after you were done, did you feel
- 16:00life better in the sense of you went as angry anymore. Yes, but
- 16:08I realized to kind of make me more empty inside. Did you feel more
- 16:18alone after you had done the crime than before they were done. Yes,
- 16:26it didn't really kick in until the next morning, but I was just hoping
- 16:32it was all a nightmare. So what was the first thing that you did
- 16:41after both crimes took place? Like, what was the aftermath of the shooting
- 16:45and the stabbing of your brother. I founded my cell phone, and uh,
- 16:52I just called nine one one because I didn't know what else to do.
- 17:03Do you remember what that conversation played out like? Or I don't.
- 17:07I didn't even know where I was. I just knew I had to call
- 17:15where you relieved when law enforcement arrived. Yeah, I just wanted to be
- 17:22as far away from there as possible. Yeah, So do you remember what
- 17:29the process of you being arrested was like? It was really just a blur.
- 17:36I remember getting interrogated and going through the county jail through uh booking.
- 17:51It seems to have been a quick process, right, So, I,
- 17:59among millions of other people have seen your interrogation video or a little bit about
- 18:03a little bit of the interrogation video, and uh, do you remember do
- 18:07you remember the interrogation what it was like? Its more specifically, at first
- 18:14you had admitted to shooting your father. But at first I believe you I
- 18:18said that you had killed your brother. Is that correct? If I killed
- 18:23my brother? No, that's I believe you had said that your your your
- 18:30father had shot and killed your brother. Was that correct? Yes? I
- 18:36did at first? So so was that a delusion at the time or was
- 18:41that just a flat out lie? Like? Do you remember what that was?
- 18:48I only remember that it was a lie. Okay, So so you
- 18:52didn't actually believe it at the time, No, okay, I was just
- 18:56I was just curious about that more than anything, because I was just curious
- 19:00because I know you said you have been diagnosed with schizophrenia. If I was
- 19:03curious if that was a delusion or if that was just a lie at the
- 19:07time. But so, what did you think that would happen to you after
- 19:15calling nine one one? Did you think that you would just do a little
- 19:19bit of time and get out or did you did you weigh on the severity
- 19:23of the consequences? I after all that was that happened, I didn't think
- 19:30I know I would be in jail, but I knew I couldn't be let
- 19:38out. At the same time, I didn't really have anyone and I could
- 19:45think could take me in. Yeah. Were you hoping at the time that
- 19:52you would just be released or you would just do a couple of years and
- 19:56get out. At the time, I'm hoping that I just get relieved.
- 20:04So after being arrested, were you charged as an adult or were you tried
- 20:08as a juvenile? I was charged as an adult. So were you in
- 20:15jail with other adult offenders like racists, murderers, robbers, so on and
- 20:19so forth. Yes, So what was that like? Being so young,
- 20:26I didn't know what to think. I could only see them around me while
- 20:33I was getting booked in. So you weren't like physically next to them to
- 20:40where they could like reach out and try to attack you or anything like that.
- 20:44No, but I could see him right outside my window. Would they
- 20:49would they do like the cat calls or would they say anything to you or
- 20:53try to do anything? No, not that I could remember. Mm hmm.
- 21:04So tell me about zombies and video games and how that played into your
- 21:10defense in court. It was an early delusion, is something that kind of
- 21:22connected me with my dad. So he would always die the zombie movies and
- 21:30we would play the video games. Kind of gave us something to to focus
- 21:37on, I guess, besides just having to struggle with life. And so
- 21:49that was used in court. Your your the bonding that you and your dad
- 21:52did over the video games and zombies and how did how was that used as
- 21:59the defense with you sed as like you were what like being brainwashed into thinking
- 22:07certain things or or why was it? Why was it exactly product important?
- 22:11You know? Why I grew up with the delusion that the zombies were real,
- 22:18and my dad didn't help by encouraging that so with me and believing there
- 22:29were zombies. It just kind of made me realize that that life is played
- 22:42differently. I guess, you know, it's not face with reality, which
- 22:49affected why my dad bought all the guns and weapons in the first place,
- 22:56just stockpiling them. Did he ever, like teach you how to shoot guns
- 23:03or prepare you for like in a zombie apocalypse if it ever did happen.
- 23:10He did teach me how to shoot guns, how to use different weapons,
- 23:15and you and I made plans like where to go if the zombie apocalypse happened?
- 23:23Where was that place you two would go, just surplus stores, anywhere
- 23:34that would be like a safe stronghold to survive. So were you offered any
- 23:48type of pleadial while you were on Kyle? The only thing I could remember
- 23:56was the prosecutor offering like forty years or something like that. My attorney told
- 24:07me about that you wanted to get me a better deal, So it was
- 24:14hard for me to understand of what went on in the court. And did
- 24:21you have any stay at the time of whether you wanted to accept it or
- 24:23reject it since you were a juvenile. No, I really didn't get a
- 24:32say in a lot of things except the like before the trial even started.
- 24:40The I don't know what to call it. It's like a quick trial or
- 24:47or a longer drawn out one. So how did you feel after you were
- 24:57convicted and send us to twenty years to life in prison under the age of
- 25:03eighteen? I was just numbed to it. I mean, being fourteen or
- 25:15even sixteen, it's it's a lot to take in because all be in prison
- 25:22for longer than I've been alive. How does that make you feel? Thinking
- 25:32about that kind of makes me feel that things are pointless, you know,
- 25:40not being able to live a real life out there. So I try not
- 25:45to think about it too much or else I get in a bad headspace.
- 25:53So after being convicted and sentenced, do you remember what the bus ride was
- 25:57like on your way to prison? It wasn't a bus ride, it was
- 26:04just a transport car. But uh, actually being driven to that prison in
- 26:11the desert, it felt ominous, you know, And the cops would tell
- 26:18me like, like, just mind your own business and don't will bother you
- 26:26trying to make it sound really bad. Was it as bad as that they
- 26:34made it seem to be when you got there. Not really. They did
- 26:41a better job at keeping me away from other inmates because I was underage.
- 26:51It was still kind of ominous, like the place was bigger, but it
- 26:56just felt really empty. I think, did you have fears of being like
- 27:07molested or rape or anything like that, being that you were younger than other
- 27:11inmates. I did. I tried not to think about it at the time,
- 27:22but those fears were open, and the guards did a pretty good job
- 27:29of protecting you from people like that. The guards did. Yeah, they
- 27:36were the only people I could talk to at the time. So today,
- 27:45how do you spend your time in prison? I spent my time just reading,
- 27:53studying, socializing with people here and there. Now that I'm older,
- 28:00I can, you know, feel comfortable about talking with people. Yeah,
- 28:11So do you feel like you're ready to be released from society today? I
- 28:17know that if I was given a chance, I would definitely take it.
- 28:22I don't like being institutionalized in here, you know, I would take any
- 28:26chance I could and try to be independent in that life because I've never had
- 28:30that chance before. I always depended on my my dad taking care of me,
- 28:38so I just want to take care of myself. Do you have a
- 28:44plan set in place to when you are released to make sure that you won't
- 28:48reif then? Yeah. I think the prison will have me do program classes
- 28:56like pre release, key fact anything else they feel is appropriate upon release.
- 29:11Is there anything that you'd like the public to know about you or your case
- 29:15for that matter? Yeah? I uh. I know some people think like
- 29:26I'm a bad person for what I did, especially to my brother, but
- 29:37it hurt me more than I even thought it would. I still have dreams
- 29:45about my dad and brother, and in those dreams, like I like I
- 29:55realized that like they survived the crime, But when I wake up, I
- 30:03realize, you know, like that's just another delusion. It's like I can't
- 30:07accept that they're dead. Do you have remorse? Yes? Like sometimes I
- 30:19wish that at the very least, I could have used the gun on myself
- 30:25instead of killing my dad and brother. Looking back, now, do you
- 30:37think there's anything that you could have done back then that could have prevented both
- 30:41homicides from taking place? I I think I could, like I try to
- 30:56go back and see if I could change it, Like I could have been
- 31:02less trouble for my dad and mom. Would they should have been working,
- 31:07like going to school, consistently trying to help out around the house. Even
- 31:14doing that much, I could have prevented a lot in my own mind,
- 31:26and maybe my dad could have gotten help my mom too. I could have
- 31:30been a better brother. So before we conclude that the interview, is there
- 31:42anything that you'd like to talk about that we haven't covered yet, or anything
- 31:47that you would like to end with. I don't know what else to bring
- 31:55up. To be honest, I'm I'm, I'm I'm I'm I'm odd forbeted
- 32:05truth. I'm I'm fine, I'm fine, I'm mind odd forbeted truth. I'm h