Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Commercial Member Business Loan Risks vs Banks 2025
Transcript
- 0:05This is Mark Rele with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:08This is a short take on commercial credit risks in 2025 in credit unions,
- 0:14uh, and also as pointed out by the OCC.
- 0:17And we have a short summary of just this one topic, which came from a longer
- 0:21one hour episode early last month.
- 0:25In any event, I hope you enjoy and uh, will listen again soon.
- 0:29This is Mark Rele and next up commercial credit risk.
- 0:34Miller: The commercial credit risk, it's been on the kind of a horizon
- 0:40or in the bullseye, so to speak, of all the regulators pretty much since
- 0:44COVID started and you had this work from home and vacancies appearing.
- 0:50So I think the commercial credit risk, it's been at the top of the
- 0:53mind for all the regulators or we're going on five years now.
- 0:58There has been some rising delinquency in that, in both the
- 1:02credit unions and the banking industry over the last couple years.
- 1:06It's not.
- 1:07What you would call a severe level of delinquency.
- 1:11It's still under 1%, but it has been going up.
- 1:15And I think that kind of catches everyone's highlights.
- 1:18You know, we had the low interest rates during COVID.
- 1:20A lot of people refinanced their properties during that
- 1:23time at low rates, two, 3%.
- 1:26A lot of those are variable rate type loans.
- 1:29They're coming due for resets in the coming years.
- 1:32Of course, rates are up in that six, 7% range now.
- 1:35So some of these borrowers are looking at three, 400 basis point stocks and there's
- 1:41concerns are they gonna be able to pay.
- 1:43And, um, you know, what's gonna happen with, um.
- 1:47Future losses and delinquencies.
- 1:49So that's a, it's been the center of the bullseye for all the regulators.
- 1:54We've seen it at NCUA.
- 1:56They some of our clients, they've been asked to stress
- 1:59test their commercial borrowers.
- 2:01They've been asked to stress test their ability to handle payment shocks.
- 2:05And I think we'll continue to see more of that.
- 2:08It's somewhat interesting when you read through that whole risk
- 2:12report from the OCC, they almost seem optimistic and surprised at
- 2:16how well banks are performing.
- 2:19But man, they are uncertain and totally worried about which
- 2:23direction things might go.
- 2:27Treichel: Great points.
- 2:28Uh, Steve or Talk, or Steve or Dennis, anything you wanna add on this topic?
- 2:33Bauer: Yeah, I think, you know, commercial loans, it's a, it's a broad, right?
- 2:36It's a broad category.
- 2:37I mean, within commercial loans there's different types of commercial loans.
- 2:41Obviously.
- 2:41I think what's getting the most press is obviously real estate values,
- 2:44particularly in like city center types of locations, where I think,
- 2:48as Todd mentioned, the whole remote work, the high interest rates, right?
- 2:52There's a lot of vacancies occurring in, in those types of of properties.
- 2:57You know, right.
- 2:58Just in the, in the city of Minneapolis, for example, I think real estate values
- 3:02in the city center area, I think they're down since last year, almost 22, 20 5%.
- 3:08Um, so right.
- 3:08That's where the concern or the concern lies is in those, I think
- 3:12in those types of more in those types of, uh, commercial loans.
- 3:15You know, and I know in our credit we didn't, our, ours was.
- 3:19Our commercial loans were fairly small in nature for the, for the most
- 3:23part spread out either residential types of multifamily dwellings,
- 3:28and those seem to be you know, those seem to be handling economic
- 3:33environment we're in, um, pretty good.
- 3:35So I think where it gets challenging not only for commercial loans but also retail
- 3:41and consumer loans, is how do then, do you forecast this as Todd mentioned, you know,
- 3:46what, what's your forecast for the future?
- 3:48Because Right, that all has to be somewhat incorporated now into, into Cecil.
- 3:52So particularly as it relates to unemployment and, uh, real estate values.
- 3:58So it'll be interesting to see going forward, uh, with the current environment,
- 4:03what type of impact, those Cecil types of factors how that comes into play.
- 4:09You know, based on what I've seen.
- 4:10Trending for both commercial, just overall loans.
- 4:13It appears that Cecil since was enacted in 2023.
- 4:19It's increased, but probably not at the same rate that we've seen
- 4:23delinquency and charge offs increase.
- 4:26So I know there's different flavors of Cecil out there.
- 4:29Not everyone treats Cecil the same, but that could be a big, that could be a
- 4:32big impact I think to, uh, the credit union performance, uh, down the road.
- 4:38Miller: You bring up an interesting point with Cecil Dennis, 'cause
- 4:41you would expect provision expense to grow at about the same rate
- 4:45that loan portfolios are growing.
- 4:47Yeah.
- 4:48And for the last couple years for the credit industry, their provision
- 4:52for loan losses has grown much faster than their loan portfolios,
- 4:55much faster than delinquency.
- 4:57But for the first quarter here of 2025, Cecil charges, a provisioning
- 5:03actually shrank when you still have loan growth and rising delinquency.
- 5:07And it's like you ask yourself, did they get ahead by Overfunding in
- 5:12the past or are they just getting behind because of earnings pressure?
- 5:16Like I said, just the way Cecil works, you would expect provisioning to grow at
- 5:21about the same pace that loan growth is.
- 5:24And for the first quarter anyway of 2025, it's behind.
- 5:28Yep.
- 5:29Treichel: And as you tell, it could be behind because they're trying
- 5:31to manage earnings a little bit.
- 5:33It could be a little bit of, uh, architecture of earnings there.
- 5:37Miller: Yep.
- 5:38Treichel: So a couple one other thing on commercial loans not related necessarily
- 5:43to the risk report, but the things we've seen in our discussions with credit
- 5:46unions is NCA being hyperfocused on the annual review process that's required
- 5:53in the commercial loan portfolios.
- 5:54And oftentimes recently, uh, some credit unions have not kept up with that.
- 6:00And that's something that definitely gets written up.
- 6:02And then the, you know, the discussion about office buildings being empty and
- 6:06the return to, to the workplace and, and how that might reinvigorate some of
- 6:11these office spaces near where NCA is at.
- 6:14Uh, patent and trade is right, right across the street from NCA
- 6:18and they used to rent three or four buildings in addition to the one.
- 6:21That they own.
- 6:23And they've let leases go on two or three.
- 6:25And then across the street from that, there's a, another agency that was
- 6:30renting the building right next to that.
- 6:33And their lease is up in a year and it's been vacant for four years.
- 6:37And they have guards that walk around it just like the patent and trade offices.
- 6:41And they actually did a public notice that they're trying to convert that
- 6:44to either a condo or apartments.
- 6:46And then when you, when you think about, um.
- 6:48When you think about, um, the rate situation that, that, I
- 6:52think you both mentioned that, and that's mentioned in the report.
- 6:55And there's the, a lot of those loans are structured with five-year
- 6:59balloons where those can get repriced.
- 7:01So what happens when that happens if you can't reprice it?
- 7:04Reminds me of some or all of you may have gone to the School of Banking of
- 7:07the South for commercial lending class.
- 7:10Yep.
- 7:10I've seen, I'm seen some nods.
- 7:12There was a guy there, professor Willie Stotts, he looked like, uh, Groucho Marx.
- 7:16And, uh, he coined the phrase, or first time I heard the phrase, uh,
- 7:20a rolling loan gathers no loss.
- 7:23You know, so you get to that, you get to that rewrite date.
- 7:26You, you, you wanna rewrite to a new, to the new rates, which
- 7:30is why you put that in place.
- 7:31But can they do it?
- 7:32Can they not?
- 7:33You might see some pressure on delinquency in that regard.
- 7:37Steve, did you wanted to add on, on this topic before we move?
- 7:41Farrar: Yeah.
- 7:42You know, the commercial lenders you're always dealing with you kind of new issues
- 7:46that your borrowers are dealing with.
- 7:48Whenever I am out talking with people who own businesses and stuff, the conversation
- 7:54anymore always goes to insurance.
- 7:56They are really being surprised.
- 7:59This is just in, in, uh, you know, property and casualty insurance,
- 8:02that they're, they're being very surprised and some of 'em are even
- 8:07being counseled by institutions they've been with for 20 some years.
- 8:12So I think that's kind of gonna be a new problem.
- 8:14And then you look at, you know, just the state of some of the, you know,
- 8:17the flooding and that kinda stuff.
- 8:19Insurance is gonna continue to be a, a new and more dramatic issue for
- 8:24a lot of your commercial borrowers.
- 8:26Within the
- 8:27Miller: fine print of the report, they actually mentioned that
- 8:30rising insurance costs, that are increasing expenses for these folks.
- 8:35Just kind of turn this into credit unions too, and something we're seeing
- 8:37with some of our clients, as Dennis mentioned earlier, there's different
- 8:41types of commercial loans, but we're seeing NCUA is asking credit unions that
- 8:47are involved in the commercial lending business to really set concentrations
- 8:52on those different types of loans, the different types of properties.
- 8:54You know, before it was a concentration limit on commercial loans.
- 8:58Now they want concentration limits on hotels, on office buildings,
- 9:03on, you know, just a variety.
- 9:05Go through the whole N-A-S-I-C codes and want concentration limits, very
- 9:11detailed for the different types of commercial lending they're doing.
- 9:14So, raising the bar on expectations for credit risk management, for card unions
- 9:20that are involved in commercial lending.
- 9:23Treichel: Great.
- 9:23Great point.
- 9:24I that's a, a nice pivot.