Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Minis - forget everything you know about deja vu
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, I don't know, let's just see.
- 0:03Oh, I felt this one.
- 0:04Okay, this is from ScienceAlert.com, which I've never heard of before.
- 0:09And it's from January 12, 2024.
- 0:11Doesn't say who's written it, but it is co- Oh no, it's by humans.
- 0:16The opposite of deja vu is a thing.
- 0:19And it's even more uncanny.
- 0:21Our petition has a strange relationship with the mind.
- 0:24Take the experience of deja vu when you wrongly believe you have experienced a novel situation
- 0:29in the past, leaving us with a spooky sense of past...
- 0:33Well, that's presumptuous of them, making them think that we don't know that we've experienced this before.
- 0:39When you wrongly believe that that last sentence was a wild ride.
- 0:44Have you ever experienced a sense of pastness?
- 0:47It just kept going.
- 0:49I really like that.
- 0:50Huh, I'm remembering this.
- 0:52It's wrong, but I'm remembering it.
- 0:54Yes, I'm experiencing pastness.
- 0:57But we have discovered that deja vu is actually a window into the workings of our memory system.
- 1:03What is this website?
- 1:05Our research found that the phenomenon arises when the part of the brain which detects familiarity
- 1:11asynchronous with reality.
- 1:13Deja vu is the signal which alerts you to this weirdness.
- 1:16It is a type of fact checking for the memory system.
- 1:19Repetition can do something even more uncanny and unusual.
- 1:23The opposite of deja vu is jamais vu.
- 1:26When something you know to be familiar feels unreal or novel in some way.
- 1:31In our recent research, which has just won an IG Nobel award for literature, we invest...
- 1:37Big Nobel.
- 1:38They're the offshoot of the Nobel Prize.
- 1:40They always have papers that they award prizes to.
- 1:43Wow, I'm learning so many new things in this article.
- 1:45We investigated the mechanism behind the phenomenon.
- 1:49Ja me vu may involve looking at a familiar face and finding it suddenly unusual or unknown.
- 1:55Musicians have it momentarily, losing their way in a very familiar passage of music.
- 1:59You may have had it going to a familiar place and becoming disoriented or seeing it with
- 2:04new eyes.
- 2:05Is that the same as like when you say a word over and over again and then it loses all meaning?
- 2:09I think so, yeah.
- 2:10It has to be.
- 2:12It's an experience which is even rarer than deja vu and perhaps even more unusual and unsettling.
- 2:19When you ask people to describe it in questionnaires about experiences in daily life, they give
- 2:23accounts like, well, writing in my exam, I write a word correctly like appetite, but I
- 2:28keep looking at the word over and over again because I have second thoughts that it might
- 2:32be wrong.
- 2:33Yeah.
- 2:34In daily life, it can be provoked by repetition or staring, but it needn't be.
- 2:38Yeah, okay, I get this.
- 2:39I've had this happen before.
- 2:41It's just what I said.
- 2:42If you say a word too much, then it loses all meaning.
- 2:45Or you know, going into a room and you're like, why the hell did I come into this room and
- 2:48then leaving?
- 2:49Yeah.
- 2:50Okay.
- 2:51Apparently that happens to be way too much.
- 2:53One of us, Akira, has had it driving on the motorway.
- 2:58Necessity necessities necessitating necessitating necessitating necessitating that he pull over
- 3:05on the hard shoulder to allow his unfamiliarity with the pedals and the steering wheel to
- 3:10reset.
- 3:11The wild is rare.
- 3:13Oh man, that's a Tim Robinson sketch.
- 3:17Is it?
- 3:18Oh yeah.
- 3:19Where he's like, do you even know how to drive?
- 3:20And he's like, no, I don't.
- 3:21I don't even are these things.
- 3:23Yeah, Jumevu.
- 3:25Yeah.
- 3:26We don't know much about Jumevu, but we guessed it would be pretty easy to induce in the laboratory.
- 3:32If you just ask someone to repeat something over and over again, they often find it becomes
- 3:36meaningless and confusing.
- 3:38This was the basic design of our experiments on Jumevu.
- 3:41In a first experiment, 94 undergraduates spent their time repeatedly writing the same word.
- 3:47They did it with 12 different words, which range from the commonplace such as door or
- 3:51less common such as sword.
- 3:54We asked participants to copy up the word as quickly as possible, but told them they
- 3:58were allowed to stop and gave them a few reasons why they might stop, including feeling peculiar,
- 4:03being bored or their hand hurt.
- 4:05Stopping because things are...
- 4:07I like that one.
- 4:09Stopping because things began to feel strange was the most common option chosen, with about
- 4:1470% stopping at least once for feeling something defined as Jumevu.
- 4:20This usually occurred after about one minute, 33 repetitions, and typically for familiar
- 4:25words.
- 4:26In a second experiment, we used only the word the, figuring that it was the most common.
- 4:31This time, 55% of people stopped writing for reasons consistent with our definition of
- 4:36Jumevu, but only after 27 repetitions.
- 4:40But nobody actually knows what the word me means.
- 4:43Like I don't.
- 4:44Do you?
- 4:45It's just there.
- 4:46No, it doesn't have meaning.
- 4:47Why do we even use that?
- 4:49I gotta take it out of my vocabulary.
- 4:51Makes no sense.
- 4:52You go fast now.
- 4:54People describe their experiences as ranging from they lose their meaning or the more you
- 5:00look at them, you seem to lose control of hands.
- 5:03I just lost control of my hand.
- 5:06I had to stop.
- 5:07To our favorite, it doesn't seem right.
- 5:09Almost looks like it's not really a word, but someone's tricked me into thinking it
- 5:13is.
- 5:14What?
- 5:15Someone sounds crazy.
- 5:16It took us around 15 years to write up and publish the scientific work.
- 5:19Well, that's a long time.
- 5:20In 2003, we were acting on a hunch that people would feel weird while repeatedly writing
- 5:25a word.
- 5:26This is just going, they're elaborating on something I feel they shouldn't at this
- 5:30point.
- 5:31Yes, it's almost as if they're repeating themselves so we lose what's going on in this
- 5:34story.
- 5:35Meaning.
- 5:36I just had noticed that the lines he had been asked to repeatedly write as punishment
- 5:40at secondary school made him feel strange as if they weren't real.
- 5:43I don't know.
- 5:44I think we went to be enough on this.
- 5:46That was kind of an interesting article, even though I want to, what was it?
- 5:51Ig Nobel.
- 5:52There's always fun stuff in there.
- 5:53They have different subcategories.
- 5:55They do it every year.
- 5:56Yeah, I would assume like the Nobel Prize, right?
- 5:59Yeah, exactly.
- 6:00And if we say that enough times, it'll lose all meaning.
- 6:04And I think that's good enough for a mini.
- 6:06Yeah, I think so too.
- 6:07I'm glad we have a word for that because I'm going to forget it when I need it, but
- 6:11it comes up more often than we would like.
- 6:14I think as we all get older, we do know there's a word so we can just say, there's a word
- 6:18for this and I can't remember what it is.
- 6:20And if you just keep saying it, it's going to completely lose its meaning.
- 6:24And my hands feeling like it's writing out a control, but this is happening and I know
- 6:29what it is, but that's all we need to know.
- 6:31All right.
- 6:32Well, in any event, hopefully you guys remember that you need to be here in 48 hours.
- 6:36That's non-negotiable.
- 6:37There are repercussions if you're not.
- 6:39So I guess you'll be here in 48 hours.
- 6:41Bye.