Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 544. Estrogen and Cancer: What Every Woman Should Know About Hormones and Detoxification
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast, where I'm all about helping you lose that stubborn weight that won't come off no matter what you do. Get off your couch at 2pm and get through your day with energy and stop counting the hairs that come out of your head.
- 0:16I'm your host, Dr. Amy, and I'm here to help you get optimized with your thyroid and your hormones. It's all part of living our mantra, better thyroid, better hormones equals a better life. So let's get you back to being the badass human that you're meant to be. Let's approach it from a thyroid and hormone optimization standpoint.
- 0:39Between myself and my guests, you will be floated down with information to take control of your health and get back to being you. So let's get started.
- 0:51Oh my goodness, it's been a long time in the making. I finally have Carrie Jones on the show. You know, we got a chance to hang out at A4M in December of last year. And I mean, your vibe, your personality, I mean, we just totally clicked. So I know this is going to be an incredible conversation. And I've been on your podcast too, which that was an incredible conversation. So I want to kind of extend this, really pick your brain and just
- 1:15give my audience your knowledge. Because like I was saying off air, Carrie, you know so much. You've been in this space for so long, dealing with hormones, dealing with perimenopause, dealing with all kinds of different testing procedures and seeing what works, what doesn't. So to finally have you on the show to unpack your brain for my audience is an absolute blessing. So thank you for being here.
- 1:38Oh my gosh, Amy, thanks for having me. I am so excited. Well, first of all, it was an honor to have you on my podcast. So thrilled to be here to talk about, well, of course, all things hormones, detox, over 40, like bring it on. Rant, rant. Okay.
- 1:53So we have to start with estrogen detoxification. It's a huge question in my audience's mind. And just like we talked about on your show, and my audience already knows, my experience with uterine cancer has really enlightened me to the importance of further testing. And again, we'll start actually with this topic. I have a question for you regarding hormones. This is not to scare women away from using hormones, but to actually...
- 2:21help you be aware that you can use hormones, even if you don't detox properly, or you have some things on your diet or in your genetics that impair that process. You don't have to say no to hormones and suffer a miserable life through perimenopause and menopause. I want to unpack how to do things properly. And in the process, I actually pick Carrie's brain and implement a couple of her knowledge-based things for myself, since I don't,
- 2:48detox estrogen very well either. So on that question, Carrie, I want to kick off by, you know, when you see a woman, and we'll get into what is estrogen detoxification, how do you know, how do you know how you do? But when you see a woman, let's say, not methylating, not detoxing her estrogen properly,
- 3:06Are you going to tell her, you know what, maybe you need to back off on that estrogen or change your hormones or avoid it completely? No, definitely not. And what's even more fascinating than that is like the same pathways that detox estrogen also detox like environmental toxicants.
- 3:21They're not sole pathways for estrogen. So the estrogen piece is incredibly important. And what's even better is we can absolutely optimize it a lot of times through diet and lifestyle, maybe a dash of supplementation. But also know there are highways for other things as well. So if we open up these pathways and just improve them, you're going to improve detox for everything, not just estrogen. Okay, beautiful. Thank you for that. We just want to start off with that. I was going to start clarify, yeah.
- 3:51We don't want women throwing the hormones in the trash like they did when the WHI study came out. Okay, estrogen detoxification. What is it? Why is it important? I once did a poll on my social media, and I was like, how long do you think estrogen lives in the body?
- 4:06And a lot of women wrote, oh, forever. It just recirculates and recirculates. It does not. Estrogen has an exit plan. It needs to get broken down into something that we call water-soluble, because the hormone estrogen, the estrogens are fat-soluble, so they can cruise around your bloodstream in and out of tissues. They can cruise in and out of your cells simultaneously.
- 4:25Very easily. But in order to get rid of them, if you're going to poop them out or pee them out, they have to be water-soluble. So detoxification is a two, if not three-step process to get them from fat-soluble to safe and water-soluble and out of the body. Certain pathways of that are, let's say, better than others, less naughty than others. So we're trying to optimize the good stuff and minimize the naughty stuff to get estrogen and really all your hormones out. But we'll focus on estrogen. Okay.
- 4:53So a woman, let's say, we're going to talk about the perimenopause menopause cohort that is taking exogenous estrogen, from the patch, pellets, cream, however they're taking it. What is that process that it goes through in the body? Just exactly what you just described. Yeah. The estrogen that you make in your body from your ovaries or elsewhere or...
- 5:17The hormones you, the estrogen hormone you take as part of your therapy, as long as it looks just like your own, as long as you're on bioidentical, it's the exact same pathway. And here's the crazy part. It's the exact same pathways for men as well. So sometimes women listen to this and go, what about my partner? What about my brother? What about my best friend? About my husband? I'm like, it's the same pathways. So he's struggling with estrogen also. It's the same pathways, which is great to help estrogen get out. But yes, it's.
- 5:44If it's bioidentical estrogen therapy you're on, this whole thing applies. So I wanted to ask that because, you know, in conventional medicine, it's almost like they treat the bioidentical exogenous estrogen as something totally different than what we actually make in our body. As if we should be looking at it differently, as if it processes differently inside of us, as if that exogenous estrogen comes in and starts wreaking havoc as opposed to the estrogen that we naturally produce.
- 6:12And the term bioidentical, interestingly enough, is not a scientific term. It's more of a marketing term. But I think it's one of the greatest easy to understand descriptions for women. Like you want a hormone that looks verbatim, you know, like the hormone in your body. So that's why we call it bioidentical. Sometimes I see it as body identical. But because...
- 6:32Interestingly, of that women's health initiative that you just mentioned and hormones in general got the stigma of like they cause cancer. They stopped all hormone production prescription except for the birth control pill. Nobody seemed to have a problem with the birth control pill. And recently I read an article that was going, it was a review article looking at the top ways to reduce hot flashes in women.
- 6:55And it was ethanol estradiol, which is synthetic, with drosparinone. And I was like, like the birth control pill? Like, yes. Like, what? Did you even look at the patches? Did you even look at the gel? Did you even look at estradiol, what's already in our body? And it's just shocking.
- 7:12shocking to me when men get testosterone no problem generally no questions asked sometimes some labs not always not like we would maybe do and yet a woman's like my candidate for estrogen and it becomes this whole weird blown up thing and god forbid they say the word bioidentical then like you are clearly weird the other thing i do want to clarify with bioidentical it doesn't mean compounded
- 7:35Not always. Right. Like I have actually seen OBGYN sit on stage and go, oh, no, I don't prescribe bioidentical because I don't believe in compounding. My girl, what the patch you have on your lower hip. What do you think that is? It's estradiol. The mist that you spray on your arm, the gel, even the estradiol, you know, one milligram tab is bioidentical. It's not compounded. You can get it compounded, but it is totally FDA approved available at a normal pharmacy right now.
- 8:03And thank you for clarifying that because... And that does apply to thyroid as well, people. Yeah, a lot of people think... Yeah, that's a great clarification. Okay, so estrogen. Now, with my history or my recent history of estrogen-positive uterine cancers,
- 8:25That was taken out. I'm totally clear. I mean, yes, I have circulating tumor cells like we all do. And like anybody does that's had a cancer removed. But in my state right now, they took out the container that contained the estrogen positive cancerous cells in it. Now, naturally, my oncologist who says, you know, this was estrogen positive. So you might want to rethink cancer.
- 8:49your hormone therapy afterwards and maybe go off of that estrogen. And I'm thinking, wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute. You took out the container that was estrogen positive. I realize I still have breasts and that those have estrogen receptors on it as well. But this is the fear that's being put into women, especially after any kind of cancer. And God forbid a woman have breast cancer. My God, good luck getting estrogen then. But this is the fear that we put into women that because that cancer was estrogen positive, we can't have estrogen.
- 9:19And when I sit back and I think, I'm like, wait a minute. And I know this has been said out loud. If estrogen caused cancer, let's say breast cancer, if estrogen caused breast cancer or uterine cancer, we would see a bunch of 16 and 17 year olds with breast cancer and uterine cancer because they have more estrogen in their body than what I was putting into my body that was deficient in estrogen. And I was just trying to replace it. So on that topic, there's so many questions around it, but...
- 9:47Yeah. My God, where do we start? On that topic, I mean, my plan is, and I am right now, on estrogen therapy, I just need to make sure that it's not building up unnecessarily and that it's not going down unwanted pathways.
- 10:04Big overarching question is, what do we need to think about if a woman, let's say, is scared of cancer, has cancer in her family, or is post any kind of breast cancer, uterine cancer, hormone-driven cancer or hormonal cancer, when I say hormone-driven, hormonal type of cancer, reproductive cancer. And then I want to break down the metabolites that estrogen goes into.
- 10:27One of the first things I always tell women is that cancer is not single-handedly one thing. Not in this case. There are some cancers. But in this case, cancer is complicated. I am not an oncologist. Every oncologist I talk to, though, is like, whoa, is it multifaceted?
- 10:42When something goes wrong in the body, when a gene, when an enzyme gets made wrong, when a variant is corrected incorrectly, if you get exposure to something, you know, God forbid, some sort of toxicant chemical, you have a genetic predisposition. You know, like it's what was the straw that broke the camel's back that all of a sudden the cell runs rampant and cancer occurs. It's a lot more complicated than like A plus B equals C.
- 11:08So when women are like, well, estrogen causes cancer, I'm like, not single-handedly, it doesn't, no. And in fact, there's been some really great research around estrogen actually lowering, estrogen by itself actually lowering the risk for, like breast cancer as an example. So in that Women's Health Initiative,
- 11:25The part that made the news was the combination of a synthetic estrogen and a synthetic progestin, which is a fake progesterone. When they were put together, those women had a slight increased risk of breast cancer, slight. Still, the media ran with it. What wasn't discussed was the other part of the study that they continued, which was the estrogen-only part.
- 11:45And the reason it was estrogen only, so no progesterone, no progestin, nothing, was because those women had had their uterus removed. They'd had a hysterectomy. So they didn't need a progesterone or a progestin or anything. So they were the estrogen only part. And they actually didn't have an increased risk of breast cancer. And they let that part continue. Even with all the news freaking out and everybody stopping hormones, they continued that part for a long while. And at the end, still concluded like, yeah, these women without only doing estrogen don't have an increased risk.
- 12:12Very recently this year, earlier this year, 2025, a study came out looking at a large number of women. And the media headlines again were like, HRT, you know, estrogen causes breast cancer. And they completely read it like they read the WHI. It was the estrogen plus the progestin had a slight, slight increased risk of breast cancer over women who had never done hormones.
- 12:35But guess what? Women who've never done hormones, unfortunately, can still develop cancer. Right. We all know somebody who said, I've never done hormones. I've never been on the birth control pill. Yeah, unfortunately, number one risk, especially for breast cancer, is being a woman. And this same study said that the women who were just on an estrogen, so no uterus, so no progestin or progesterone, they actually had a lower, their percentage risk of breast cancer was lower.
- 12:59than the never users, which is not uncommon. We've seen this a few times in studies. Now, I'm not saying this, I will support whatever decisions somebody wants to make. Go on hormones, don't go on hormones, don't feel like you're a candidate. I just want you educated. I don't want any fear-based decisions. I don't want old information, again, from that Women's Health Initiative to be pulled forward when we've had so many studies since then.
- 13:22And to think that breast cancer in particular single-handedly is due to estrogen. Like, oh, it's so much more complicated than that. Yes, yes, yes, yes. I love all of that because that's what I say as well is I want to give you the information. And even if it's a one-on-one patient.
- 13:39that is asking me, I'll sit down and say, we will talk about it. I will give you all of the information possible. You go out and listen to this podcast, this podcast, and this podcast, and this expert, and then make that decision. But just like you said, Carrie, not out of fear, not out of fear mongering by your doctor either.
- 13:58Yeah, or outdated information or, yeah, or not just the fear mongering just in general. Either if it's old information that your doctor has or the group that you hang out with or the Facebook community you're on maybe has it wrong, hasn't gotten updated yet. And we want to dispel that. Yeah.
- 14:15Absolutely. Absolutely. So where estrogen can be a problem, and I'll use that term very loosely, estrogen dominance, not as it relates to cancer. I mean, women can be estrogen dominant and have the bloat and the water retention and all of that. Or, you know, a lot of women will say, oh, I think I'm estrogen dominant. And I'm like, your estradiol is a 55. Like,
- 14:35I don't think you're estrogen. You just think that you are. And you heard that term way too many. So what is true estrogen dominance? When does a woman experience it? And what is the difference between that and just improper estrogen detoxification? So interestingly, improper estrogen detoxification can lead to estrogen dominance. Estrogen dominance is shortened. It's a big phrase. It's estrogen dominance relative to progesterone.
- 15:01in the luteal phase. What does that mean? So in the second half of the cycle after ovulation, you should make boat loads of progesterone, loads of progesterone relative to estrogen. So think of progesterone like a big tall mountain and estrogen is a little tiny bunny hill. Like that's roughly the difference between the two of them.
- 15:17If progesterone is not a big, tall mountain, if it's dropped down also to a bunny hill, or maybe it hasn't been produced at all. So it's like a flat ski trail. But estrogen is still a bunny hill like estrogen wins. So we call it estrogen dominance like relative to progesterone.
- 15:32And what can happen when you get this imbalance between your mountain and your bunny hill is that you just exactly as you said, it's almost like pro growth. So they're like, oh, my boobs feel big. They feel like they've like I've got like clots. I have heavy bleeding. I'm breaking out. I'm moody. Now, lower progesterone and higher estrogen can cause this basically the same symptoms. But we do know that estrogen is.
- 15:58can cause things to grow. So this is typically why these women will say, I have such heavy, cloudy periods. I feel like my boobs have grown a size, etc. So when we're looking at that, I need to know, are you actually making more estrogen? Are you just not making enough progesterone? Or do we have a backup in the system? So you're making appropriate amounts of estrogen. Think of like,
- 16:20When you go to take a bath, so you fill the water up in your bathtub, but if your drain is clogged, what's going to happen? The water overflows and ruins your bathroom. It's the same thing in the body. If your body is making just healthy, normal levels of estrogen, but your drain is clogged and your sewer line is clogged, your estrogen is just going to back up into the body and cause all sorts of issues.
- 16:40So this is why working on detoxification, which are essentially working on how fast is the water coming in? What is the drain doing? What is your sewer line doing of your own body is going to help with the regulation of estrogen as it goes up and down throughout your menstrual cycle. Okay, so this can affect women of any age. Any age.
- 17:02any age. So even cycling women who are not on estrogen therapy, like let's say somebody's listening to this 30 years old, not even considering hormone therapy, but they're like, um, I have every single symptom you just said. I have all of those. It could be a progesterone issue. It could be an estrogen detoxification issue. It could be both. Now you have somebody listening to this going, well, I'm 55 on estrogen. Right.
- 17:26And I'm having some of those symptoms. My boobs feel like they've grown since going on estrogen. I'm like, things are better, but I'm still moody or I'm having acne. Like, is it possible it's my hormones? It definitely could be. It could be. So do we start with the blood test? Do we start just looking at...
- 17:43Estrogen, total estrogens, estradiol, break it down, estradiol, estrone, estriol, and then progesterone and just kind of go from there. And then, of course, testing that in a woman's luteal phase if she is cycling or any time if she's in menopause.
- 18:01I find most women prefer that route because most women have had not had any workup. Like, let's just say that like most women, unfortunately, don't get the workup that you or I would do. So when they're getting blood work for the first time, they're often told, well, hormones change every day. We're not even going to test your hormones. And you're like, OK, but except we know in theory that we have a good idea after ovulation of where it should be. Like I have my target points.
- 18:28So if I can get you to time your blood test at this certain time, if you're still having periods, and a lot of women over 40 still have regular periods for a while, then let's do our blood test there and start there. If somebody says, I've been doing testing.
- 18:44Or I'm really interested in going deeper. It fits in my budget. I'm ready. That's when we go, I still do blood work because I still need their thyroid. I still need their glucose and insulin and all these other markers. But then I'm like, all right, cool. Let's go to the next level down, which is to look at a deeper view of estrogen detoxification. My preferred test, which you've mentioned already, is the Dutch test. There are other companies out there. However, that just gives me like where are your hormones going? I have an idea based on that test. Yeah.
- 19:12Okay. So we'll get to the Dutch in a second. Staying on blood. Yes. When you look at that estrone and estradiol, are you freaking out if the estrone is higher than the estradiol? Or what do you look for in those patterns? I don't use, not necessarily freak out, but I'm like, dang it.
- 19:32Dang it. It's like, you know, yes. Like, I'm glad you came in. I'm glad we're doing some testing. The same if I see there's another marker, Estrone S, which is Estrone Sulfate. So the S part, the sulfate part, means it's gone through, it's going through sulfation. And sulfation is part of detoxification, but we also call it like a holding pattern. So the body puts a little S on it and then when it needs it later, it can take the little S off and now it's active and go do the thing.
- 19:59So the same thing, if I see a lot of Estrone-S, in the body there is a lot, but like more than I expected, and a lot of Estrone. Estrone and Estrone-S, just give me an indication of like, it could be a lot more inflammatory. It could be a lot more problematic. I want to help support getting out the right way, detoxification essentially.
- 20:17Because estradiol will kind of become estrone and vice versa. They can go back and forth. So estrone and estradiol, so E1 and E2 can go back and forth, but it's a controlled enzyme. We have no control over it. I can't look at your lab work and go, oh, you're in the red on E1, estrone, and you are low on estradiol.
- 20:38and magically push a button and get you to go over to estradiol. Your body is too smart for that. But I can support how your body clears it out of the body, like how we detox. Yeah. Okay. So you look at the blood first. I do. Then if we can, let's move to the Dutch. Now, you are an absolute Dutch. I've listened to so many podcasts of you.
- 21:01So unpacking the Dutch test, it's amazing at your knowledge. Tell people, just in case they haven't listened to another podcast on what is the Dutch, what is it, why do we use it, what is it looking at? Yeah, absolutely. And I do want to go back for a second, back to the blood works. I forgot to say this. You know, most detoxification happens in the liver.
- 21:20Now, it can happen all over. Believe it or not, you can do partial detoxification in cells all over. But if on your blood test I see that you've got glucose issues, insulin issues, your liver enzymes are higher than I would want them to be, if you've been told it's been suggested to you, a fatty liver, right away I know detoxification is an issue. And so some of these other markers I just want to point out because they show up on blood tests, and that's an easy thing to do and generally covered by insurance, mostly covered by insurance.
- 21:49But the DUTCH test, DUTCH is an acronym, funny enough. It stands for Dried Urine Test for Comprehensive Hormones. And it's six pages of all the hormones you think, such as the estrogens we just said, E1, E2, E3, testosterone, DHEAS, progesterone, cortisol, melatonin. There's all sorts of hormones on there. But what makes it six pages long is it goes through the pathways, some of the pathways of how they break down. So here's your testosterone. Where does it go? Okay.
- 22:17Here is your progesterone. Where does it go? Here are your estrogens. Where do they go? Here's your cortisol. Where does it go? And that's really nice to know where it goes because, again, some of those pathways I'm all about and some of those pathways cause side effects or increase the risk for cancer development. So by knowing this information, if you don't have your genetics...
- 22:39this can be so helpful. This is real time to me. Okay. So when you see those pathways on a Dutch, there's a 208, there's a 40H, there's a 1608. Can you break those down for us so we can have a better understanding of what do those even mean and why do we care? So the first phase of detoxification is they, let's say you have estrone since we've been talking about it. You have E1 estrone. So estrone can't leave the body as estrone.
- 23:04So the body's like, all right, cool, cool, cool. I'm gonna put you through phase one. It's called hydroxylation. I didn't name it. I would have named it something way cooler, but there we are. And they put a little OH group on it, a hydroxyl group. So estrone goes through a mommy makeover and becomes through these pathways. And when you go through the pathways, you have three options. We're still in phase one. Estrone can go through the two, the four, the 16 pathways you just said, and that puts an OH group on it.
- 23:31The two pathway is the better pathway to go through. It's the more stable pathway. The four pathway is the naughty pathway. If the four pathway continues, if you keep going through the benchmarks and nobody stops you, then you can be at risk for DNA damage, personogenesis, cancer cause, etc. The 16 pathway is kind of a...
- 23:53gray area pathway. It's a super big, think of it like a 16-lane highway. It's a big detoxification pathway in your body. It's one of your big main ones. And it is estrogenic when your hormone goes through that, when your estrone becomes 16-OH. If it binds to an estrogen receptor, it can cause estrogenic symptoms, heavier periods, sore tender breasts, PMS, et cetera.
- 24:15But it's also really good for bones. Research has shown in women, if you have higher 16, you have less risk for osteoporosis, osteopenia. So it's like a teeter-totter. Like, I like the 16, but I don't want it to dominate. I don't want it too low. And I also know it's the major detox pathway. So that's phase one. I can't turn any of them off. Like, you will always, as a human, go down at least some part of it.
- 24:38But what we want, what we prefer is the majority of our estrogen becomes 2-OH, 2-hydroxy. And like I said way in the beginning, we can help modulate this through diet, lifestyle, and potentially some supplements before we move on to phases two and three.
- 24:55Okay, so we'll stay in phase one. Why do we even have the 4-OH if it's so problematic? What's the purpose in our body for it? Do we know? So here's what's interesting. And I know I say that a lot, but like biochemistry is so fascinating to me, I think because I almost failed it in medical school. And then I realized the whole body is biochem. Once I got past that, I was like, I really need to understand this. And so I've just been studying the heck out of it. And everything just like, we are so fascinated as humans because so many things go through this pathway, not just estrogen.
- 25:25And your body has stopgaps in it. So even if you go through the four pathway, there are still ways your body can say, like, they're just a route of excretion. And so if you go through the four pathway, there's still an offshoot, which uses the antioxidant glutathione, that, like, gets rid of it. So it doesn't even matter that it went through the four pathway. The body's like, girl, I got you. I'm going to attach glutathione to you. You're going to poop it out. You're going to be fine. Or you're going to pee it out. You're going to be fine. And so...
- 25:53Even it's the problem is if we get far enough along this pathway and no stock gap happens. So this pathway starts with a Q. It's the quinone pathway. So if we get quinone development, those are not that great in the body. But like I said, these pathways don't just detoxify estrogen and they do have several offshoots to try to help us not be all naughty all the time. Right. Right. Okay.
- 26:18Is it just, you mentioned estrone. Is it just estrone that is going down? Estradiol does as well. Estriol does not. Estriol can become the 16. Estriol can become the 16. But usually what happens is the 16 becomes estriol. And then estriol goes through what's called phase two, which is called sulfation or glucuronidation. And then it's excreted. So we don't often talk about estriol E3.
- 26:46One, because we generally all love E3. It's generally considered like a really cool, very, you know, very safe, kind of, I don't want to say boring, but like kind of, you know, it's big in pregnancy and we don't talk about it much as we get beyond that, even though it's important. So it takes a whole different pathway. It's the E1 and the E2 that goes through these, what we're talking about right now. Okay. Well, since you just mentioned Estri, I'll have to throw in a random question here. Okay.
- 27:10What are your thoughts on estriol? It's like there's this great estradiol-estriol debate out there. Huge. I mean, it is huge, and it's so confusing, Carrie, and especially being post-cancer. Yes, I have replaced with estradiol, but I'm like, should I be tossing in some estriol too just for shits and giggles? I mean, it's kind of like, why not? So I was taught way back in the day, 20 years ago, that estriol-
- 27:34Well, let me back up for a second. So the reason for everyone listening, the debate is, do you just take estradiol? Because that's what we have available FDA approved in the United States, or you can get it compounded. The other debate is that you should do a combination of estradiol and estriol. Well, there is no FDA approved.
- 27:49FDA approved estriol form in the United States. There is in Europe. And through the years, there've been a lot of pushback by pharmaceutical companies, one in particular, to get estriol banned in the United States, which makes no sense to me because they have an estriol product in Europe. But pharmaceutical politics aside, again, these two camps, you should take both or you should just take estradiol. So I was taught years ago,
- 28:13You have two main estrogen receptors. You have more than that, but there's two main ones. You have estrogen receptor alpha. That's your go, go, go, grow, grow, grow. And then you have estrogen receptor beta. That's generally considered like anti-cancer. Estriol E3 prefers to bind to the beta. Estradiol binds to both 50-50.
- 28:33And E1, estrone prefers the alpha, go, go, go, grow, grow, grow, which is why when you mentioned estrone earlier, it's because it binds the go, go, go, grow, grow, grow receptor, the alpha receptor. So I was taught years ago, like, well, we want a mix. You want estradiol because it's 50-50 and that's what's, you know, kind of makes the female body go round. And you want some estriol because you really want to help that estrogen receptor beta be fully supported. If the estrogen, you're taking estradiol.
- 28:59It should be 50-50, but nobody follows the rules. So if it is pushing on the alpha, you've got the beta as the backup with your estriol. Fast forward, then I learned, you know, like that a lot of people are like, well, E2 estradiol is the only thing you want. That's what's important for the brain and the heart and the bones. And I agree with that 100%. I think, yes, absolutely. And I still feel estriol isn't getting the love attention that it deserves and that we still want to support that estrogen receptor beta.
- 29:26I will say vaginally, in my experience, estriol vaginally seems to help the best with lubrication. And I'm sure other practitioners may disagree with me, but I found that estradiol helps prevent like atrophy. It helped prevent yeast infections. It helps prevent urinary tract infections. It helps strengthen fantastic things. But I'd have women go like those things are better, but I'm still not like juicy.
- 29:49And I'm like, oh, we need to add an estriol. And when they added an estriol, they were like, hallelujah. Like, okay, now I'm juicy again. This is great. Obviously not all women experience, but I would just have this, I just saw it over and over and over and over again that estriol brought the juicy back. It didn't stop the atrophy. It didn't stop the yeast infections or the urinary tract infections. But I did find that just from the lubrication factor, like, woof, it brought it up to the next level. And that's what women were looking for.
- 30:12Well, and that's the thing. It's like, there's no harm. It sounds like there is no harm in adding in estriol. And now we have estriol face creams. We have body creams. We have ways to get it. Okay. Even if big pharma bans it or whatever, hopefully it'll stay at least OTC over the counter that we can buy it in care formulations. Right.
- 30:36You can get it compounded. I mean, I, you know, lots, most compounders, that's where I learned is all the compounders were like, we don't have an FDA approved, but we can absolutely include it or make it separate if that's something you want. And I, that's what I did for years and years in practice. Women seem to really like it.
- 30:54Now, not all women, you know, right? Like, so some women are like, no, I only like my estradiol by itself. Like, cool. All right. I'll support you. Personal preference. Yeah. Exactly. Like, we got it. Let's do what works. Yeah. So, okay. I kind of sidetracked, but I had to ask. This is a good one. I had to, because there's like this huge debate out there. So, okay. We go through phase one. Yes. Now what? Now we move into phase two. So phase one, first of all, phase one predominantly happens in the liver, like I said.
- 31:21So and it goes through uses these enzymes called cytochrome P450 enzymes. Again, I didn't name them, but there you go. C-Y-P, cytochrome P450. You can test them. You can see genetically what yours are doing. And they're heme dependent, which means they rely on iron. So if you're iron anemic, iron deficient, you don't need a lot of iron based products. You're going to struggle here in this phase one.
- 31:43When you go through phase one, the two and the four and the 16, they're not that healthy overall. Two is where we want to go. But in the end, you can cause problems. It's a metabolite that's a little unstable. So we want to move them into phase two as fast as possible. So we want to like, we don't even want to stop at phase one. We just want to keep right on trucking on to phase two. And the reason is we're trying to make it fat soluble to water soluble. So this process requires you to, you know, when you're going through hell, keep on going. So we go through like the naughty metabolite into the good metabolite.
- 32:13So phase two has one, if not two steps to it. So the first step can be something called methylation, which some people are familiar with because of the concept of MTHFR. And oh, my gosh, you know, the dreaded MTHFR. But it's actually the methylation cycle. Folate is a tiny part of, but that's not the cycle I'm talking about.
- 32:34And if it doesn't go through methylation, it will go through two other forms called sulfation or glucuronidation. Or if you go through methylation, you still have to go through sulfation or glucuronidation. Again, I didn't design this or name them, but there you are. No matter what.
- 32:50And we haven't even gotten into the like what you can do and the treatments and everything. No matter what, like you can still support these phases. You can test your methylation. You can test your methylation cycle. We can get a snapshot of it in blood. We can evaluate your sulfation to a degree because we can do estrone S testing. We can do DHEAS in the blood. Like we can kind of get an idea of how do you sulfate or not.
- 33:13And then we can work with that. But when we go through into phase two, you're now considered water soluble and you're very safe. You're a very safe molecule in the body. So this is what we want to get you to. Okay. So we move through phase two. Yep. And are we seeing that on the Dutch too? Are we seeing phase two or just phase one? So you are seeing part of phase one. So you see phase one and then you will see methylation, which is phase two.
- 33:36Because Dutch is a urine test, that means it's already gone through phase two and phase three. So what Dutch has done is they've pulled all the molecules that have gone through sulfation or glucuronidation. So they'll have little S's and little G's on them. And they just take them off. And then they report essentially like the step right before. So it's on the actual paper you see up to methylation. But because I worked there for so long in concept, I'm like, oh, I know it's sulfation and glucuronidation we're actually looking at. Yeah. Yeah.
- 34:04I know. But for everyone listening, you can see up to methylation. You can see. Okay. You can see up to that. And then the phase three. Well, what is phase three? Phase three is the act of leaving the body. So that's your sewer line. That's when you poop it out or you pee it out. And because Dutch is a urine test, then it's the pee it out part. If you've done any kind of stool testing, you've pooped in a cup for science, there's a marker on there that we look at the microbiome markers, the dysbiosis markers. We look at a crazy enzyme called beta-glucuronidase.
- 34:33which plays with that phase two glucuronidation. So we can evaluate like how well does it go out of your stool or does it get reabsorbed back into your body? If you're listening to this going, well, I have constipation, you got a clogged up sewer line. So you're just going to get it back in your body. So that's phase three. That's the actual literal exit out of the body.
- 34:53So people who, and I mean, this is prevalent in thyroid disease when they're not being treated properly and they're constipated. So people who are not pooping once, preferably two, three times a day, start right there. Start right there. You're not even, yeah.
- 35:08You're not even detoxifying at the end. So you are absolutely going to become estrogen dominant or have a backup in your system through the detoxification pathways because you're not even excreting it at the end. Yeah, so yeah, if you're not going to the bathroom, you're already starting right there with issues. You're going to be estrogen dominant. You're going to have issues detoxifying. Yes, yes. Don't even spend the money on the Dutch test or a stool test or any... Don't spend the money. We have to get you pooping.
- 35:37Same if you're under hydrated. And for example, my nurses, my doctors, anyone in medical, my teachers, like who just don't go to the bathroom. Right. They have to hold it all day because of their schedule. Right. I'm like, oh, my gosh, I know you have to because of your schedule. I need you to like flush your body. I need you to drink water and go to the bathroom. Yeah. I need to get things moving here. Like the kids can wait. Seriously. Yeah. Yes. Yes. Yes.
- 36:01Okay, so that's the end. So now let's go back and what can we do? You mentioned lifestyle changes. You mentioned some supplements that we can add in. So I'm going to ask about myself. Let's start there in that phase one. I push...
- 36:15moderately heavily down the 4.0H and a little bit on the 16. Not horrible, but it's definitely there and it has been there. Just like when I was talking to you on your podcast, my one regret was not paying attention to the Dutch test that I did in 2022 that actually showed that I pushed down the 4.0H. So what can we do?
- 36:35We have a couple options. So we'll start with the 16 pathway. As I said, that's your super highway or, you know, your 16 lane super highway. We don't ever want to slow the 16 down. Just like if you live in the city and have a 16 lane highway, you know what happens when they close a lane. It's all chaos. So what we want to do is take more cars off the road or offer more exit ramps.
- 36:52So for you in particular, anyone listening, I'm like, what potentially are you exposed to? Are you doing that's adding more cars on the road? Is it environmental toxicants? Is it alcohol? Is it medication? You know, people sometimes pop Tylenol, acetaminophen, like it's candy. Like, are you on something heavy for an autoimmune condition that's clogging up the liver? I know you need it. What can we do to support it? Things like this, that's what all goes down a lot of the 16 pathway. So I don't want to slow that down. I just want to open it up and move things through.
- 37:20Now, for the four pathway, I want to minimize that pathway. So these are supplements. Unfortunately, we don't have human studies. We have rat and cell studies. So we're using what we have in the moment for this. But there are supplements such as quercetin. So foods with quercetin, like apples, is an example. Quercetin is common for allergies, histamine.
- 37:42But it also helps to reduce this pathway. Resveratrol. Resveratrol helps to reduce this pathway. And I was just reading this article about auroxalan A, which is in the herb scutellaria. So scutellaria we think of like for stress and calm and sleep. But this one component of it has been shown to reduce the four pathway as well. So if you're already on quercetin for your allergies, if you're doing resveratrol for antioxidant, whatever, it's hopefully reducing that pathway.
- 38:11The other pathway is the two pathway. The two pathway we want to upregulate as best we can, if we can. So these are foods such as your cruciferous vegetables. These are your broccoli, your kale, your cauliflower, Brussels sprouts. Those foods are really helpful for this pathway. Now, I've been asked, can I just eat my way through this pathway? Like if I'm in your situation, can I just, you know, Carrie, I don't normally eat Brussels sprouts. Can I just add in a serving of Brussels sprouts every day?
- 38:36Well, I have a research paper that shows it's like six to seven cups a day that you're going to need. Most people don't eat six to seven cups of cruciferous vegetables a day. Right. I mean, maybe at your best, you're three to four on a great day, but six to seven is kind of a lot. So what's in the brassicatese family, this whole family, cruciferous family, is a compound called indole-3-carbinol, I3C.
- 38:59When you chew these foods up and they hit your stomach acid, you have to have stomach acid, they break apart into a few other compounds, one of which is known as DIM, diindole methane. DIM helps shift towards the two pathway. And we do have a retrospective study, but it is on people. It is on predominantly women that shows that people on DIM, their two pathway goes up and like their 16 pathway. It just shifts.
- 39:25It doesn't block the 16 pathway, it just shifts it away. There's a receptor that DIM activates, and that's what helps shift it over to the two pathway. So when someone says, like, you're a great example, if you were to call me and said, you know, should I do DIM? Should I eat Brassica family? Should I take quercetin? For you, I would have said yes. All of the above. Let's just support the heck out of your phase one. Absolutely. While all the other, like, of course, addressing all the other, you know, just general liver support,
- 39:52in your life. But yeah, those are the sort of main, the main things I can find the most like research on to take to wrap my my hands around. It's not ideal. There's no big pharmaceutical money in any of these. So are we going to find a thousand person woman's study on resveratrol in this? No, but we're doing the best we can with what we have.
- 40:13Well, and then just retest. So that's my plan. Actually, I'm doing all of those things that you just said. And then retest and look at my pathways and see if they have changed. And yeah, I'm so happy you brought up DIMM because this is another big controversy. There's a lot of practitioners out there saying, well, DIMM will reduce your estradiol. And it's like, but I'm on it anyways.
- 40:35Right. So you would just have to adjust the dose. So I do get asked, I don't use a lot of DIM, I'll be honest, in like menopausal women with low estrogen levels. If you're on estrogen, like you're a very separate case than let's say me. So you came to me, Carrie, you know, uterine cancer, but I'm back on estrogen. Here's my Dutch results. I don't favor the two pathway. Would you put me on DIM if I was your doctor? This is not legal or medical advice, but yes, I would.
- 41:01Yes, I would because you're already on estrogen and you have a very recent history and you're a great candidate for it. We're also going to talk about phases two and three. But yes, the average person listening going, well, I've never had breast cancer or uterine cancer.
- 41:16and I'm not on estrogen, but I have low levels, should I go undim? It can make it lower. This retrospective human study that looked at it did show it dropped estrogen levels. So if you don't want your estrogen lower, then we skip phase one. We move on to phase two and phase three instead. And that's totally okay because some people go,
- 41:36But what about the four? You said the four was naughty. But remember I said the four had like these sort of like pathways out from it that like glutathione. Like we have other ways to support. Even if you go down the four pathway, we have so many ways to support it away from it that it's okay. We can skip the DIM if you don't want high levels of estrogen.
- 41:55Amy, if you were to stop your estrogen, let's say you decided ultimately in the future, like, wow, I really shouldn't be on estrogen, whatever reason. Then I would say, okay, stop the DIMM. Yeah. Because you're not even on it anymore and you already, you know, you're menopausal. So let's not do that. Okay. So I do like that caveat because sometimes people hand out DIMM like it's candy, like Oprah hands out CARS. And I'm like, ooh, it will lower estrogen. And in a low estrogen state, not ideal. Yeah. Yeah.
- 42:21Yeah. Well, I like it for guys because it'll lower their estrogen dominance. Yeah. Totally. And with men, they still need some estrogen, believe it or not. Like it's important for their mood. It's important for their bones. Like they still need a little bit of estrogen. But we've all maybe noted somebody who has gone on testosterone or just happens to have, you know, they drink a lot of alcohol or have insulin issues. So they happen to have a lot of estrogen and they get breast development and they get the beer belly look and they're moody and they're not motivated. And you're like, that's a lot of estrogen they've got floating around. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 42:51No doubt. Okay. Now moving into phase two and three. Now what? Yes. Okay. The generic general support for phase two are twofold. One I've already said is glutathione, which is a very potent antioxidant. So supporting glutathione, however that looks, can be very helpful. The other comes from broccoli sprouts.
- 43:12So if you're a sprout person, if you like to grow your own sprouts, if you like to put sprouts on sandwiches and salads, aim for the organic broccoli sprouts. When you chew or chop the sprout, not a full grown broccoli, but like the sprout. When you chew or chop the sprout, these two compounds come together. And like Superwoman, they turn into something called, again, I didn't name it, sulforaphane.
- 43:33So sulforaphane, with S-U-L, sulforaphane helps open up or activate something like 200 phase two enzymes. So remember earlier I was talking about water and drains and sewer lines. Sulforaphane helps open up some 200 drains, bathtub drains, shower drains in your body. So which is great. And included in that 200 are the drains for estrogen.
- 43:57So add in broccoli sprouts, grow organic broccoli sprouts on your counter, or it does come as a supplement. And you can add that in. It will help with the drain part of detoxification. Whereas glutathione helps neutralize over here. Sulforaphane opens up drains. So that's the first, like the most basic. When we're talking about methylation, methylation uses a lot of nutrients. So methyl B vitamins, B2, B3, B6, B12, methylfolate.
- 44:24Choline, like in egg yolks. So are you able to eat egg yolks? Can you eat egg yolks? Trimethylglycine, which is TMG. Trimethylglycine is a supplement, but it has that word methyl in there. Very important. Zinc. Zinc is helpful. Are you eating foods with zinc in them? How is your zinc doing? These all help move that system around. But the main, main, main cofactor is magnesium. Magnesium, which is like...
- 44:50Hundreds of reactions use magnesium, including estrogen detoxification. So are you getting enough magnesium? Are you eating enough magnesium? Do you maybe need to add in some more magnesium? That's like the main, main, main co-factor. And so you can see right away where food is nutrition is super important, and then are you absorbing it? And if not, we can add in a little here and there to help. Well, that's easy to do. I mean, that's not like a big confusing protocol just to help with detoxification.
- 45:18It's not. And I've listed off a lot of things. I don't want people to think you have to do all 20 things I said at all. No, no, no, no. Definitely start with the colon. Are you pooping? Are you hydrated and peeing? Right. Like we start there. Then we go. Food is nutrition. Do you eat cruciferous vegetables? And I understand what the thyroid fear. People are like, well, I don't eat them because of my thyroid. Slightly cooked, steamed foods, broccoli sprouts. Yeah.
- 45:40Really helpful. Can you are you able, you know, are you able to do that? So then we check what's the alcohol look like? Right. Are you what's the medication look like? What is your glucose doing? Is it possible you have fatty liver? Like we got to work on some of these things. What are you being exposed to? What are you putting on your body, in your body, around your body? Start reading labels. Right. And like so far, we haven't spent any money. I'm just evaluating what you're doing.
- 46:02Yeah. And what you're eating. And then from there, you might go, you know what? I probably do need magnesium. All right. I can add in a little magnesium. You know what? I love to grow things. I'm going to grow broccoli sprouts. I'm going to buy organic broccoli sprout seeds and grow them myself on my counter. That's what I do. Okay. Well, okay. If I don't want to eat broccoli sprouts, does that come in a supplement form? It does. A hundred percent comes as a supplement. Yes.
- 46:24And I have those too for when I travel. Yes. Or when I'm not home and can't like tend to my sprouts. But yes, you can take it. That would seem. Some people are already on glutathione, right? They're already there. Their doctor practitioner already has them taking glutathione or N-acetylcysteine, NAC. And so some of these things, people listening may be like, oh, check, check, check. I'm already doing some of these or I'm already taking a B-complex. Let me read the label. Oh, look at that. B2, B3, B6, B12, methylfolate. Like, okay, check, check, check. Got it.
- 46:54And that's what makes it really nice. A lot of times we're already doing, we just maybe have to amp it up. And if you're not doing like, all right, let's double down. Yeah, I love that. Okay, that's beautiful. Now, last question I want to just leave with this. I know we talked about estrogen detoxification a ton today, but even with the Dutch test, do you even recommend women who, let's say they haven't been on hormones for five, maybe two,
- 47:2310 years post-menopause, is it even beneficial to do a Dutch test or should they actually implement some kind of hormonal therapy first? That's always been my take. Like if I'm working with a patient that came in and she's, again, 10 years, no hormones, post-menopause, I'm like, let's get these started based on your blood. We know they're all in the toilet. And then let's test your Dutch. Because I always heard that doing a Dutch test on a woman with no hormones is like
- 47:53You're just not going to see that much. It's zero. So again, two camps for that. Some people feel they want the Dutch test because not only the ovarian hormones are a part of it, but they want to look at the cortisol levels, melatonin. The last page is called the organic acid page. It gives some extra information. So sometimes some people, it fits in their budget. They really want it. They're educated about it and they want a before and after. Yeah.
- 48:17Other people, it's 100% true. She hasn't had hormones in a long while. My analogy is you're staring at a riverbank that's like dried up. And you're asking me, well, how high does the estrogen get? Like, right? Like, where does it go? Like, where, you know, does the estrogen have waves? I'm like, I don't know. There's no estrogen in her body. Right.
- 48:34It's a dried up bank. But once we get water in, once we get estrogen right into your estrogen river, then I can see. So I feel I can go either way on this decision because it's either way you're going to use, you're going to test for these metabolites. So if you don't start right from the get go, it's not like you're going to let her go years and not know a couple of months and you're going to do a test and see what's going on. And then you'll know right away. Beautiful.
- 48:59I want to ask the expert on that one. Yes. Yeah. I'm kind of, I'm 50-50. Yeah. The person depends on the person in front of you and their goals, their budget, what you find in the blood work, things like that. And sometimes history. Sometimes, you know, I may be thinking like, oh, I'll wait on a Dutch test. And then they're like, well, I have this strong history of craziness or personal history or family history. And I'm like, oh, you know what? I should probably know this ahead of time. Let's go ahead and test. Yeah.
- 49:23Let's do it. Yeah. Let's do it. Okay. Beautiful. Oh, my God. Well, okay, Carrie, we have to bring you on for a part two because there's so much that I want to ask you that we're just not going to get to this time. So we'll break this up as well and do a part two. We'll coordinate that. But for now, can you tell people where they can find you? You just released your podcast. It's amazing. I'm so happy that you started because you're, like I said in the beginning, your knowledge base is just huge.
- 49:47huge. So you need to give all of that knowledge that's inside your brain to the world. So I'm very grateful for that. But where can people find you and listen to your podcast? Yes, thank you. I am at drcarriejones.com. Everything's there. Free ebooks, everything I'm doing, articles. The podcast is called Hello Hormones. It is literally brand new. Amy was one of the
- 50:11first guests I interviewed. So the Hello Home Runs podcast with Dr. Keri Jones, because I like to talk about all things hormones and I have an opinion, so I'm going to say it. I love the title too. Women everywhere are going to find it just because it has hormones. Yes. Beautiful. Well, we'll put all the links in the show notes, but Dr. Keri, thank you so much for jumping on. It's been such a pleasure. I love talking to you and we're definitely going to have you back on. Dr. Amy, thank you. Okay. Till next time.