Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Budget bargaining, ADIPEC AI, and Lindsey lament
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. The UK budget looms, Adipec is
- 0:16in full swing, and Lindsay is still in the headlines.
- 0:19That's an awful lot to talk about if you're just me.
- 0:22Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff by joining us this week is
- 0:25Northwest correspondent Floyd March.
- 0:27How you doing today, Floyd? Yeah, all good, ready to go.
- 0:30I feel like Lindsay or refineries in my life for the
- 0:33last month and 1/2. So yeah, looking forward to
- 0:35talking about it again. I'm glad to hear it.
- 0:38You, you were obviously not here a couple of weeks ago when we
- 0:41had the discussion around the, the bed.
- 0:43So we'll get into that properly now that you're here.
- 0:46The the man of the moment, the person in the know.
- 0:49We'll, we'll find out all about that later on.
- 0:52But right now we'll touch on the looming budget.
- 0:57A lot is are riding on the on the budget that's set to be
- 1:00delivered later this month on 26th.
- 1:03You know, so we're, we're waiting for the outcome of a
- 1:06couple of North Sea consultations on the, the future
- 1:10of licensing and the successor regime to the energy Profits
- 1:14Levy. Obviously, you know, we're
- 1:17looking for insight onto AR-7 and various other things.
- 1:21There's a lot, you know, riding on this.
- 1:24And with that in mind, OUK and Scottish Renewables are joined
- 1:30forces to to write to Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Ed Miliband,
- 1:34Energy Secretary, to kind of, you know, call for the things
- 1:38that they see the industry is needing.
- 1:40So they called for a, quote, urgent replacement of the Energy
- 1:44Profits Levy or EPL windfall tax.
- 1:46It goes by many guises. They wanted more funding for the
- 1:50next CFD auction rounds that we allocation round 7 and they
- 1:55wanted an early intervention in place to prevent further job
- 1:59losses in UK oil and gas. Now we've seen numbers from the
- 2:03unions in recent weeks are saying that you know, we're
- 2:07losing a Grangemouth every every few weeks.
- 2:11So you know, job losses are obviously a massive talking
- 2:15point as well. So essentially the they asked to
- 2:20slow down the the rate of decline in oil and gas while
- 2:23ramping up the roll out of offshore wind.
- 2:26That's something that the CEO of Port of Aberdeen has been
- 2:29speaking about lately about how revenues in oil and gases are
- 2:33declining while you know, the offshore wind deployment just
- 2:38doesn't ramping up in the way that we need it to or we
- 2:41expected it to. So some interesting, interesting
- 2:45points to be made there in and of themselves.
- 2:50I've kind of been doing a bit of digging before before we jumped
- 2:53on the podcast about, you know, current Labour policy, what the
- 2:57signals are that are coming from the Kier Starmer premiership.
- 3:02And, you know, recent headlines have suggested that Labour might
- 3:05be considering reversing the changes to the EPL in response
- 3:09to reforms popularity in the polls.
- 3:13This also came around the time that the Tony Blair Institute
- 3:17urged the government to focus on, quote, cheap power 2030 over
- 3:20clean power. So we've got, we've also got a
- 3:25situation where Prime Minister Keir Starmer has vowed to,
- 3:29quote, double down on oil and gas.
- 3:31He said that the North Sea fossil fuels will coexist with
- 3:34their renewables for and again, quote many, many years.
- 3:39So it leaves a lot of speculation around what does
- 3:41that mean? You know, previously laboured
- 3:43campaigned on a no new licenses policy and obviously one in the
- 3:48general election. So its members, its voters will
- 3:51be expecting that no new licenses sort of set up.
- 3:56But thankfully for them, John Underhill of Aberdeen University
- 4:00earlier this year Cater came in and gave them almost a get out
- 4:02of jail free card. See, they've done, Labour have
- 4:06done that thing that all political parties do where they
- 4:08kept that policy super vague so they could really say it meant
- 4:11anything by the time they got into power.
- 4:14So they've, you know, they, they said no new licenses.
- 4:17They didn't say exploration licenses, they didn't say
- 4:19licenses full stop. There was no new licenses.
- 4:22Whenever you asked, it was kind of about wishy washy on the
- 4:25answers. So essentially what Underhill
- 4:29had suggested earlier in the year was handing out what he
- 4:33called bespoke oil permits. And essentially that would mean
- 4:37that assets that are within tie back distance to existing fields
- 4:42with an existing infrastructure would be allowed to to sort of
- 4:46go ahead, but not sort of anything that's, you know,
- 4:51needing loads of loads of new development.
- 4:54This is quite interesting because that unlocks the
- 4:58majority of remaining reserves in the UK North Sea.
- 5:02So it, it creates this, this interesting situation for Labour
- 5:06where they could say we're sticking to our guns.
- 5:07We're not handing out any exploration licenses while
- 5:11still, you know, keeping the oil or getting the oil and gas
- 5:14sector on site. So it's, it's an interesting
- 5:17point. And Floyd, you know, you, you've
- 5:20been looking at reforms policy. You were at the party conference
- 5:25recently. It's a lot to discuss there.
- 5:27They they're going hell for leather and oil and gas and you
- 5:30know, Conservatives are kind of doing the same.
- 5:33Do you think there's a scope for Labour to try and make
- 5:36themselves look a little bit more appealing to the oil and
- 5:38gas sector? Yeah, I think, you know, if they
- 5:41did a little bit of a wind back of some description, I feel like
- 5:45maybe they'll be kind of, you know, more popular.
- 5:48But but I think the the government need to just kind of
- 5:53accept the fact that every government that's in charge is
- 5:56just like deeply unpopular, like all the time.
- 5:59And like, I feel like if they just accept the fact that like,
- 6:02you know, they've made their choice, they've made their
- 6:03decision and that that's where the, the, the things are going
- 6:06to be, You know, there there's things they can draw from, from
- 6:11that strength. But then additionally, like
- 6:12there's obviously like balance to be hard and, and that can,
- 6:16that can help too, because obviously, like the job losses
- 6:19in the North Sea is just, you know, it's just insane.
- 6:22We talk about an energy transition and how we can
- 6:25replace those jobs. But like I, I was, I've
- 6:27mentioned before an, an Aberdeen, you know, offshore
- 6:31worker isn't necessarily going to move to Liverpool to, to work
- 6:35on high net. You know, those jobs are likely
- 6:38while, so the numbers might be replaced.
- 6:40You know, the geography of these jobs is something that often
- 6:44isn't, isn't spoken about that much.
- 6:48But yeah, I, I think they've got themselves in a lot of
- 6:51difficulty. But as you've mentioned, like,
- 6:54you know, no new licences, it does give them that that wiggle
- 6:57room. But but also like Rachel Reese
- 7:00could just stand to say that, you know, times have changed.
- 7:03We thought it was going to be this way for five years, but but
- 7:07now it's not. And it's not going to be the end
- 7:09of the world if she decides to do that.
- 7:11No, certainly, and it'll be interesting to see how the
- 7:13outcome of the consultations go. And you know, speaking on that,
- 7:16we've also got the energy profits levy.
- 7:19I'm not going to touch on this much because we've spoken this
- 7:21book about it to death over the past three years.
- 7:25But you know, essentially, you know, as people remember labor
- 7:29hype of the rate of tax paid by operators last year under the
- 7:32energy profits levy by 3%. That was not a very popular
- 7:36measure. People were already complaining
- 7:38that their attacks was way too high considering oil prices.
- 7:41It's returned like, you know, down to pre COVID levels.
- 7:46So essentially what UK and Scottish renewables have done
- 7:50together is say the windfall tax is set to end in 20-30.
- 7:55This consultation is meant to be deciding what the tax regime
- 7:58looks like beyond 2030. We need the successor to come
- 8:03next year and 26. That's kind of their big stance
- 8:06on the windfall tax. Probably no, no shock there.
- 8:10But you know, when when the the windfall tax changes came into
- 8:15place last year, we heard oil bosses saying, you know, we need
- 8:19reform now. We don't need reform in 20-30.
- 8:23I by reform, I mean as in changing of the tax bills, not
- 8:27not Nigeria. Before we wrap up.
- 8:30And I really want to touch on wind as well, because this is
- 8:34the, you know, it's the key point of Scottish renewables and
- 8:36over UK coming together over UK. Despite changing his name a few
- 8:41years ago to change from oil and gas to offshore energies, they
- 8:45are still K to see it as the predominantly oil and gas trade
- 8:48body, whereas Scottish renewables and renewable UK very
- 8:52much as the as as the name suggests, focuses on, you know,
- 8:56green technologies. So the two of them were sort of
- 9:00saying that there there needs to be a change in the ER 7 budget.
- 9:05You know, they said that the current framework would
- 9:07significantly restrict the ability of the 6.7 gigawatts of
- 9:13eligible Scottish went Elshaw went projects this year.
- 9:16Contracts for difference. Scottish renewables boss Claire
- 9:20Mack has previously said that since there have been no new
- 9:25CFDS awarded for fixed bottom offshore wind projects since
- 9:302022, the industry need to be reassured.
- 9:33The UK government has a commitment to the sector which
- 9:37is to be to be understood. You know, and we often hear
- 9:41politicians champion Scotland is odd.
- 9:43They're the home of offshore wind and you know they're going
- 9:46to be the green energy capital and if you're not getting those
- 9:50CFD subsidies where other places are, then you can understand by
- 9:54the industry feels a bit snubbed.
- 9:56The the rules for the the allocation round 7 have changed
- 10:01to allow up to about 25.1 gigawatts of offshore wind
- 10:06capacity to enter the bidding process.
- 10:08That covers 20 fixed bottom and five floating project.
- 10:12Under the previous ruling, it would have unlocked around 12.4
- 10:16gigawatts of eligible capacity with about 458 megawatts being
- 10:20flowing now. The interesting talking point
- 10:24here is the fact that OEUK has previously described the past
- 10:29two allocation rounds as failing to deliver.
- 10:33Obviously the allocation round 5, the one that delivered no
- 10:36successful beds for flow for offshore wind projects full
- 10:39stop, floating or otherwise. We can't exactly argue that that
- 10:43was a success. That was obviously a, you know,
- 10:46failure last year Labor and just come into power.
- 10:50As soon as they came in, they upped the the strike price
- 10:52slightly for offshore wind didn't sort of like create a bit
- 10:55of a buzz. You know, a country contributed
- 10:57about 3.3 gigawatts of offshore wind energy, but that's still
- 11:03way behind where they needed to be.
- 11:05According to UK's sort of numbers, this allocation round
- 11:09will need to deliver about 8.4 gigawatts the UK governments to
- 11:13get on track with its wind ambitions.
- 11:16And that's not accounting for industry uncertainty and
- 11:20examples like Orsted, who pulled the plug on Horn C4 this year
- 11:25after previously acquiring about 2.6 gigawatts of, you know,
- 11:29strike prices. So there's a lot to do.
- 11:32It's a lot to unpack here as well.
- 11:34And I feel like we're probably running out of time a little
- 11:36bit. Feel like we're already over
- 11:39that 10 minute mark. But Floyd, there's a lot that
- 11:43we've just covered there. It's a lot going on.
- 11:46Are you convinced that the Rachel Reeves and Co are going
- 11:50to deliver for the energy sector?
- 11:52Are we going to write some very angry headlines by the end of
- 11:55the month? Well, I'm quite cynical, so I
- 11:58feel like I'll be able to find an angry article no matter what
- 12:01what's announced. But yeah, I don't know.
- 12:04I think like a it's a big jump from the, the 3.3 GW on offshore
- 12:09in their next allocation round. But but one thing I did, I saw
- 12:13yesterday, George Osborne of all people, he was at the Treasury
- 12:16Select Committee and basically what his kind of advice to
- 12:21Rachel Reeves is like stop talking about the budget.
- 12:25Like just do the budget. Because he mentioned about sugar
- 12:28tax. And he said if he spoke about
- 12:30that pre budget, like the lobby forces, he called them, would
- 12:33have just like made a massive thing out of it.
- 12:35It would have made a decent policy from his perspective,
- 12:39deeply unpopular. So his advice to Rachel Reeves
- 12:43is basically just like, shut up about the budget, wait for it,
- 12:48deliver it, and then people will have to react to your news and
- 12:53and find a way to make it work rather than, you know, she's
- 12:56mentioned the gambling tax and, you know, Betfred said, oh,
- 13:01well, we'll show all of our shops.
- 13:02And then that immediately looks like a deeply unpopular policy
- 13:06for jobs, etcetera. So I feel like maybe she just
- 13:10needs to have confidence that, you know, she's got her plans,
- 13:13like Keir Starmer's clearly sticking by her and yeah, just
- 13:16just like announce the the the policies on on energy and allow
- 13:21the industry to react to it. I guess if you look at it from
- 13:24that perspective and she delivers that, then, you know,
- 13:27the industry will have to suck it up.
- 13:28But yeah, I think no matter what she announces, there's there's
- 13:31going to be a way that that that the industry's unhappy because
- 13:34it's like oil and gas on one side, offshore on the other.
- 13:37Like if you give more money on oil and gas, the offshore are
- 13:41going to be like, well, where's our our money, you know, vice
- 13:43versa. So think she's a little bit
- 13:45doomed whatever she does. Damned if you do, damned if you
- 13:49don't. Sounds like Rachel's in a Catch
- 13:5122. Stick around would.
- 13:53Be Chancellor, hey. Stick around because just after
- 13:56this break, we're going to be flying all the way to Abu Dhabi.
- 14:00Be the first to hear breaking energy news through the Energy
- 14:04Voice app, available to download for free.
- 14:07You get features like saving the articles you want to return to,
- 14:11access to the Energy Voice supplement.
- 14:14You can read exclusive E Forward content and even listen to the
- 14:18Energy Voice Out Loud podcast. If you work in the UK energy
- 14:22sector. Stay in the loop by saving the
- 14:25Energy Voice app to your home screen.
- 14:27Download the app through the Apple App Store or Google Play
- 14:31for breaking energy news on the go by searching Energy Voice
- 14:35app. So up next, our E Forward editor
- 14:39Ed Reid has been down in Adipek in Abu Dhabi and he's been
- 14:42speaking to EQTCEO Toby Rice. There was a lot of acronyms and
- 14:47that, but let's hear what he had to say.
- 14:49Hello, I'm Ed Reid from Energy Voice and I'm here today with
- 14:52Toby Rice from EQT. Toby, tell me about EQT.
- 14:56What are you guys doing? EQT is America's natural gas
- 14:59champion. Every day we produce over
- 15:021,000,000 barrels a day of energy worth of energy, all the
- 15:05natural gas form. We've got a couple big themes
- 15:08that we're we're chasing right now.
- 15:10Providing energy security to the world with LNG while also
- 15:14powering this world and and unleashing this AI revolution
- 15:17that's taking place in America, making sure our tech companies
- 15:20have all the energy they need to run full throttle.
- 15:22Both of these themes are creating a tremendous amount of
- 15:24demanding, tremendous amount of opportunities for our
- 15:27organization. It feels like AI, everyone's
- 15:30talking about it. And we've heard a really strong
- 15:32case this morning around the, the kind of the, the molecules
- 15:35that are going to need to deliver for that, that, that
- 15:38energy for data centers. What role do you think gas has
- 15:41to play in in providing power for for those for those AI
- 15:44plans? That was the question 24 months
- 15:47ago and people were when people started thinking about the
- 15:49tremendous energy demands that AI will take, they asked is
- 15:53renewables going to meet this demand?
- 15:54That's what they thought, realized that's not going to cut
- 15:57it. Then they moved to nuclear and
- 15:58realized it's not going to meet the time, the time horizons that
- 16:01they need. The world is very firmly
- 16:03understands that natural gas is going to power this AI
- 16:06revolution. Now in the United States.
- 16:08What does that mean? That means that we're going to
- 16:10see a between a 10 to 20% increase in natural gas demand
- 16:14just to increase the power generation in this country.
- 16:17That's not all data center related.
- 16:19About 40% of that demand is attributable to data center
- 16:23development. So this Electrify the World
- 16:26theme that's taking place, not just in America, around the
- 16:28world is going to create a tremendous amount of
- 16:29opportunities for natural gas. Let's look at prices because it
- 16:32feels like US natural gas prices are a challenge, I suppose in
- 16:37terms of sort of producers, right?
- 16:38How do you, how do you tackle that as a as as clearly as a as
- 16:41a big gas producer? Yeah.
- 16:43So I think the biggest challenge we see with natural gas markets
- 16:46is going to be incredibly volatile.
- 16:48And this is because there's some structural things that have
- 16:50taken place in the natural gas markets in the US over the past
- 16:54couple, over the past decade. And, and specifically it's been
- 16:57the lack of, of infrastructure build out.
- 16:59We've seen demand in the US grow over 50%.
- 17:03Pipeline capacity to service that demand has only grown 25%
- 17:06and storage infrastructure to bounce the markets has only
- 17:08grown 10%. So what that means is we've got
- 17:11parts of this country, due to lack of infrastructure, they see
- 17:14incredible market discrepancies in pricing.
- 17:17You know, in Pennsylvania this winter I'll be selling my gas
- 17:20for $4.00. In Boston, my mom will be paying
- 17:24over $14.00 for her natural gas. It's only 300 miles away.
- 17:28These are the highest natural gas prices not in the country,
- 17:31in the world. OK.
- 17:32That's the lack of infrastructure.
- 17:33So, and the storage lease is just a, a tremendous amount of
- 17:36volatility. So the way that you need to
- 17:39prepare your business to thrive in this is you got to have a
- 17:41really low cost structure. And that's exactly what we've
- 17:43done at EQT over the last five years.
- 17:45We've taken our cost structure down by over 30%.
- 17:48We have break even cost of $2.00 Henry out pricing and we've and
- 17:53we've been able to do that grow our production 50% in the
- 17:56meantime. And and the result of those two
- 17:58efforts we've doubled the profitability of our business.
- 18:01So we're positioned to thrive in this volatile environment, but
- 18:03it's going to be, it's going to be wild.
- 18:06And LNG, right, I mean, you talk about infrastructure, LNG
- 18:08clearly playing a part in that kind of infrastructure build
- 18:11out. And yet we know we're also
- 18:13seeing these these these pressures, you know, like
- 18:15everyone's sort of saying like, oh, you know, the, the
- 18:17challenges that like the oversupply, all these things.
- 18:19Is that a concern for you? Well, LNG is, is one of three
- 18:23main, main themes that are driving gas demand in the US.
- 18:25We talked about AI. We, we still have the evolution
- 18:29of our energy systems using better sources of energy like
- 18:32replacing coal with natural gas that's still going.
- 18:34But LNG certainly has been one of the biggest themes on on
- 18:37demand for the US. We're currently, we've gone from
- 18:41think about this, the US was not a material exporter of LNG, but
- 18:45in 2016, we had roughly 0. Now 8 years, almost almost nine
- 18:49years later, we are the world's largest LNG exporter.
- 18:52Today, we are exporting 19 BCFA day of natural gas.
- 18:55That's about almost 20% of US natural gas markets goes to
- 18:59exports that's going to grow to over 30 Bcfa day by 2030.
- 19:04So this is a tremendous demand signal.
- 19:06It's going to create tremendous long term pricing support and
- 19:11and demand for our product, but it is going to expose this
- 19:14international prices. We got to look at what else is
- 19:16happening with LNG pricing around the world.
- 19:18We've got Cutter who's another big LNG exporter.
- 19:21They're going to be putting some projects online in the 2728 time
- 19:24frame just as we're continuing to ramp up to that 30 BCFA day
- 19:28total in the US And that's going to create a little bit of a
- 19:31oversupply situation in the world.
- 19:33That's great for gas consumers around the world.
- 19:35They're going to have lower prices that could translate to
- 19:38lower LNG capacity in the US, which means lower demand in the
- 19:42US, which means could create some softness on pricing.
- 19:45Here's that volatility that we're talking about and the way
- 19:48you need to weather stormers to be a low cost energy provider
- 19:50like what EGT has done. It feels like a lot of the the
- 19:54sort of innovation in in the US or shale patches, you know,
- 19:58apart from the sort of the, the underground things, it's been
- 20:00the above ground things, right? I feel like financing plays a
- 20:02really key part in that. How do you see the sort of
- 20:06financial perspective, private equity, other sources of capital
- 20:09for your business? Well, right now, I mean, quite
- 20:11frankly we're, we're self financing.
- 20:13We're in a position right now where a lot of, a lot of energy
- 20:15producers are in maintenance mode.
- 20:17So we're not on a, we're not on a blind growth pattern.
- 20:19So we're not overspending cash flows at EQT, we are doing a
- 20:23maintenance program. So we need about $2.00 Henry Hub
- 20:26to break even. Everything above that at our
- 20:28scale, if gas prices are 4 bucks, every penny above the
- 20:32$2.00 break even is about $23 million of free cash flow for
- 20:36our business. So we can use that to finance
- 20:37this growth. But I'll tell you the the the
- 20:41bigger sentiment of financing hydrocarbon projects, I think
- 20:44that sentiment is shifting. I think you're seeing people
- 20:47really take a step back and look at some of the decisions that
- 20:50were made to move away from oil and gas and realizing what did
- 20:54we learn when the bombs dropped in Ukraine?
- 20:55We learned one thing. Without security, you cannot
- 20:58transition. And the key to energy security,
- 21:01where did they find it? They found it in natural gas,
- 21:03specifically US LNG. So I think that's a really
- 21:07important lesson the world has learned.
- 21:08I think now we look at the massive demand that's in front
- 21:11of us with AI. We think about all the great
- 21:13benefits that artificial intelligence is going to bring
- 21:15this world. It's going to be powered with
- 21:17natural gas. So there are so many
- 21:19opportunities for us to invest more in the common sense,
- 21:22practical, affordable, reliable clean energy solutions that's
- 21:26got natural gas written all over it.
- 21:27So we see a big future for natural gas investing and that's
- 21:30what it's going to take. It's going to take a tremendous
- 21:32amount of infrastructure build out to meet this AI revolution.
- 21:36Also on the LNG side to allow America to continue to provide
- 21:39energy security for the world. So we haven't seen any issues in
- 21:42getting that that type of infrastructure finance.
- 21:44But the other big demand where I think this has played a bigger
- 21:47role, we're talking about AI and those are that's really
- 21:49sophisticated demand. Step back and realize there's
- 21:52billions in this world that live on less electricity and it takes
- 21:54to run a fridge. What about those people?
- 21:56And, and Bill Gates just put a comment about this, about his
- 21:59views on climate. And you know, he said three
- 22:02things. One, climate change is not going
- 22:04to end civilization. That's a good thing #2
- 22:06temperature is not how we're going to measure progress.
- 22:08We should make a measure progress based on human health
- 22:12and well-being. And the third thing he said is
- 22:14that the key to protecting the world from the impacts of
- 22:17climate is to make them prosperous.
- 22:19And you know how you make people prosperous?
- 22:21Give them access to energy. There's no better correlation
- 22:24than energy consumption and quality of life and energy,
- 22:28energy consumption and wealth creation.
- 22:31They're linked. And so we look in the
- 22:33undeveloped parts of the world. That's where the financing has
- 22:36been really challenging. And I think the sentiment change
- 22:39in the developed world is going to allow these people the
- 22:41opportunity to have what we've been, what we've had here, what
- 22:43you're seeing here in Abu Dhabi, a place that has been
- 22:46transformed from a desert to an Oasis because of fossil fuels.
- 22:50Now the rest of the developed world will be able to developing
- 22:52world will be able to start experience that type of
- 22:54progress. That's the energy transition
- 22:56we're excited about. I mean, you're you're here in
- 22:57the Middle East. Obviously there's, you know,
- 22:59energy is very much the kind of the the nature of the game.
- 23:01You're you're off to, to, to Asia shortly, I gather.
- 23:05What is what is what is the interest in, in the rest of the
- 23:07world for you? Like, I mean, I feel like that,
- 23:09you know, given, given your sort of strong US roots, what are you
- 23:11looking for for the rest of the world?
- 23:13So I think it's just continued approach towards taking a
- 23:17practical approach. We want the world to continue to
- 23:19drive to use the most affordable, reliable energy
- 23:22solutions. And that means there's going to
- 23:24be a ton of natural gas demand around the world.
- 23:27When we look at the the, the global market for for LNG today,
- 23:31it's around 55 BCF a day. That's going to double to over
- 23:34100 BCF a day by 2040. OK, So what do we need to do in
- 23:38the meantime? We need to continue to champion
- 23:40the fact that natural gas is going to be a low cost energy
- 23:44solution. When it's coming from countries
- 23:46like the United States, it's going to be incredibly reliable
- 23:48and you're going to have security of supply.
- 23:50And then when it's replacing coal, it's going to be a clean
- 23:54decarbonizing option for you. So we need to check all the
- 23:57boxes. We're here internationally
- 23:58making the relationships because energy demand, what we're seeing
- 24:01in the US is happening all over the world when it comes to AI
- 24:05and, and energy security is, is compromise a lot of parts of
- 24:09this world, which means there's going to be more opportunities
- 24:11from a security perspective. We just need to connect the dots
- 24:14and make and, and make some deals and make sure that these
- 24:16markets can work and that the the the best energy gets its way
- 24:20to the best markets and that's going to be around the world.
- 24:23And final question, I mean, it feels like, you know, you're,
- 24:25you're talking about global trade, talking about, you know,
- 24:28all of these opportunities. And yet at the same time, you
- 24:30know, we're seeing some real sort of geopolitical challenges.
- 24:33US, China talks, you know, up down what what is what is what
- 24:37is life for a sort of an LNG shale gas producer look like in
- 24:41a world where, you know, globalization is in.
- 24:43Question. Well, I think it's going to
- 24:45expose us to to, to a bigger market.
- 24:47I mean we're in a period of time where natural gas over the past
- 24:5120 years natural gas has been a regionally constrained market
- 24:54because it needs land based pipelines to go from where it's
- 24:57produced to where it's supplied. LNG has completely changed the
- 25:00game. LNG has basically given us a
- 25:02pipeline to the world and so we have tremendous amount of
- 25:06flexibility. And so EQT we have over
- 25:086,000,000 tons of LNG off take where we'll be taking our gas,
- 25:11liquefying it and shipping it around the world.
- 25:14Tremendous opportunity as it relates from a geopolitical
- 25:17perspective, what does, what is, what is, you know, the trade
- 25:20and, and the tariff impacts have caused a lot of, a lot of
- 25:24challenges for people to understand where is this going
- 25:25to land? We'll understand this.
- 25:27This administration understands that American energy is the key
- 25:30to peace and prosperity around the world.
- 25:32And we believe that energy is going to be a great tool for
- 25:37this administration used to help balance trade.
- 25:40It's we are the largest producer of energy in the world.
- 25:42If you added up the oil and gas we produce, it's over 30 million
- 25:44barrels a day equivalent. The administration knows that.
- 25:46And they're going to use that as an opportunity to connect this
- 25:49energy with countries that need more energy to power their
- 25:52energy security, their, their, their, their economies.
- 25:54So it's going to be a great opportunity to create even even
- 25:57more opportunities for us as, as natural gas producers.
- 26:00Perfect. Toby, thank you very much.
- 26:01Bye. Thanks, Ed.
- 26:02So that does it for the add a Pet coverage this week.
- 26:05Obviously there was a lot happening on the show floor.
- 26:07So if you feel like you've missed anything, well,
- 26:09energyvoice.com is the place to go.
- 26:12After this break, we're going to do as we promised at the top of
- 26:15the show. We're going to speak about
- 26:16Lindsay. Energy Voice leads the global
- 26:20energy conversation, which is why we're excited to introduce
- 26:22our newest offering, E Forward. E Forward is the essential and
- 26:27exclusive community of senior North Sea leaders driving the
- 26:29movement to secure clean energy. The energy transition is not
- 26:33just a climate issue, but an economic imperative.
- 26:36We have a leading position in this race.
- 26:38An E Forward can help you take advantage in a discrete
- 26:41environment where thought leaders and recognized experts
- 26:44can collaborate on moving energy forward.
- 26:47This is the specialist membership designed exclusively
- 26:49for North Sea innovators, offering a focus program of
- 26:52events, valuable data-driven insight and an exclusive digital
- 26:56hub. This is where you can set the
- 26:58agenda and shape the energy transition.
- 27:00If you're 1 of energy's forward thinkers, it's time you joined
- 27:03us. Visit E forward dot energy.
- 27:06That's EFWD dot energy to learn more and to join this exclusive
- 27:10community. So Floyd Lindsay refinery, it's,
- 27:16it's not, it's, it's been doing, you know, it's not been doing
- 27:18much lately. It's been very quiet, no
- 27:20headlines, nothing going on. You know, in all seriousness, we
- 27:24had that our public private partnership bed recently.
- 27:29We spoke about that on the podcast, myself, renewables
- 27:33reporter Michael Bear and Ed Reed, who you just heard before
- 27:36the break. And, you know, we discussed that
- 27:39and we we explicitly said Floyd's the man in the know for
- 27:42this. He's been sort of speaking to
- 27:44the relevant, relevant people. He's the person that should be
- 27:48here. You weren't able to make it last
- 27:50time, so we've got you here now. What's happening at the
- 27:54refinery? Yeah.
- 27:56So obviously the the big news was that 125 jobs were going to
- 27:59be lost by the end of October. Obviously we're in November now.
- 28:02There was a big push, you know, last minute push from loads of
- 28:05people in the industry, you know, saying we should use
- 28:09devolution money from the new combined authority in
- 28:12Lincolnshire just to to fund the refinery for a short period of
- 28:16time, put staff on furlough instead, just to kind of like
- 28:21manage, manage wages and try and keep people long as possible.
- 28:25That that all failed. Unfortunately, 125 people did
- 28:28lose their jobs on Halloween of all days.
- 28:32So, yeah, obviously really sad news for the sector, Bit of an
- 28:35industry trend. If you look at oil and gas, you
- 28:37know, on a whole, you know, it's probably just 125 added to that
- 28:41thousand plus that that OEOEUK was mentioning.
- 28:47But yeah, but but outside of that, there's been, there's been
- 28:49a lot of conversation about who's going to take over the
- 28:52refinery. Obviously the official receivers
- 28:54like taking charge and you know, insolvency services all very
- 28:59hush hush, really hard to get any information out.
- 29:03But you know, kind of out of nowhere this enigma, Mark Hamrim
- 29:09kind of put forward a proposal to take over the refinery in a
- 29:12in a 5050 joint venture with the government.
- 29:16Obviously sounds like a perfect plan, you know, from their
- 29:19perspective or the union's back to, you know, reformer, back to
- 29:25it sounded like the perfect plan.
- 29:27So obviously I was doing a little bit more digging and I
- 29:29managed to actually get in contact with James Ascott, who
- 29:33is in charge of the due diligence on behalf of this
- 29:37unnamed consortium. And yeah, he, he sent me the
- 29:43proposal. And obviously it looked good on
- 29:45paper, but like, there was like not that much detail, to be
- 29:49honest. I read it and you know, not to
- 29:53debrate, berate the hard work that I'm sure went into it, but
- 29:56I think I could have written it. There was like there was no
- 30:00clear definition of what the role would be.
- 30:02There was no finances involved. It was just like, let us run the
- 30:06refinery. You own it.
- 30:09We we get the profit. Effectively, they've been
- 30:12ignored by the government. So they're kicking off a lot of
- 30:14force. And they've actually, they sent
- 30:16me the document of their intention to launch a judicial
- 30:19review against the government over the handling of the
- 30:22refinery, which is quite interesting.
- 30:24And they gave a 14 day deadline, which will be coming up kind of
- 30:28next week. So, so yeah, I guess this time
- 30:31next week on the podcast, we'll be talking about whether they
- 30:33they actually file for that. Yeah, it's an interesting
- 30:37situation, isn't it? Because, yeah, the, the deal,
- 30:39even before you were able to see the the details of it, did feel
- 30:45a little bit like, you know, you guys for all the bail, we'll
- 30:48take all the money from it and not, you know, they didn't seem
- 30:53to be any like risk for the consortium coming in.
- 30:56It felt like it was very much like you could get some good
- 30:59press because you can save these jobs if you say yes to us.
- 31:03And we, yeah, we stand to benefit essentially.
- 31:08After reading it, is that still, was that a fair reading?
- 31:10That was kind of our take away the other week, which might have
- 31:14been unfair looking back on it. Tell us.
- 31:17Yeah, I mean, The thing is Philip 66 look like red hot
- 31:21favourites to to get this refinery.
- 31:23You know, everyone like, you know, has been talking about it
- 31:25off the record saying, yeah, it's going to be Philip 66.
- 31:28You know, there's been lots of like discussions about their
- 31:31connections with FTI consultant who are the administrators.
- 31:36So and Philip 66 will want to turn it into an import terminal.
- 31:41Whereas this consortium, despite it being unnamed and questions
- 31:45around Mark Cameron and whether and who he actually is, they,
- 31:48their proposal clearly stipulated that it'll be run as
- 31:53an oil refinery, you know, as it is, if that makes sense.
- 31:57So, so that's where the clear differential between the, the
- 32:01two proposals are. And, and that would obviously,
- 32:04if they, it was all legit, would protect jobs, you know, if, if
- 32:08they decided to run it as is, you know, the proposal mentioned
- 32:12about rehiring the needing to rehire the 125 people that have
- 32:16been made redundant. So on paper it looks like a
- 32:19great proposal, but obviously there's like key questions
- 32:21around like who the consortium are, how much money they they
- 32:24will look to put into the refinery and what the joint
- 32:27venture would actually look like.
- 32:30You know the government aren't going to buy this refinery, give
- 32:32it to an unnamed consortium, and then the consortium does a praxe
- 32:36and the government are back to square one with all this debt
- 32:40and you know this problem refinery.
- 32:43Well, this is kind of the problem presented by this or
- 32:46Mark Hammer in bed, isn't that? Because, as you say, the man is
- 32:49a bit of an enigma. There's not too much of them
- 32:52online. I mean, products weren't quite
- 32:55the same. They did have a track record and
- 32:57at least the downstream oil and gas, like they were buying the
- 33:00product from refineries in the sense that they own petrol
- 33:03stations and they ramped up to refineries and offshore
- 33:06installations and all this. And it seemed very quick.
- 33:09And there were questions, you know, being asked at the time of
- 33:13where are these guys getting their money from?
- 33:15We don't know. And clearly they weren't getting
- 33:18their money from anywhere because they ended up folding.
- 33:22You know, there's questions to be asked there.
- 33:24But then I think as well about, you know, the sort of Phillips
- 33:2766 model of what would happen with their with Pratt with them
- 33:32Lindsay, if if that was if they were to take over versus this
- 33:37consortium lead some questions to be asked.
- 33:40But the profitability of the refinery as as as well, right.
- 33:44You know, total sold the the asset, presumably because it
- 33:49wasn't making as much money as they'd want it to, right.
- 33:52You don't sell something that's Rican in the cash for you.
- 33:56And so, you know, they've they've handed off and then
- 33:59practice have went on there while running it.
- 34:02You know, and don't get me wrong, I'm not saying Lindsay
- 34:04sunk Prax. I'm sure there was plenty,
- 34:07plenty going on there that we'll probably never find out about.
- 34:11But and then we've got, you know, these guys coming in and
- 34:15saying we'll run exactly how it was.
- 34:18Do we have a, do we have a state of play on, on the the refinery?
- 34:22Have the sort of administrators said, you know, Oh no, this was
- 34:25making fistfuls of cash or what's the situation there?
- 34:29So the receiver obviously been tight lipped about it, but I did
- 34:32speak to Ward at the time when it was announced and and they
- 34:36said that by all means a refinery seemed profitable like
- 34:41they was doing their review of profitability of of the refinery
- 34:45and they they seemed to think that it, it was profitable.
- 34:51So, yeah, so, so they said in 2023 the the refinery was
- 34:54profitable. There was in like the throes of
- 34:56the 2024 calculations, but they said that it looked to be
- 34:59profitable too. And they just said like the
- 35:03indicator margins for that general industry profitability,
- 35:08sorry, across refineries in Europe, is that that that all
- 35:13profitable? They all remain profitable and
- 35:15will remain profitable, you know, despite the energy
- 35:18transition. So, yeah, so, so Wood would
- 35:22confuse at the the the state of play for the refinery.
- 35:25So I guess that would give the Ameren's consortium, you know,
- 35:29the confidence maybe from their perspective, if they say like
- 35:33James, the due diligence guy told me that they'd only be able
- 35:37to give the finances when they're able to like, you know,
- 35:40see the books and that they've been blocked from being able to
- 35:43do that, which is obviously a fairpoint.
- 35:45But yeah, they they must take confidence from, you know, what
- 35:48Wood is saying about the profitability of the the
- 35:50refinery. And they think, well, you know,
- 35:53we've got all this money, we can we can put some into this
- 35:56profitable refinery and save these jobs.
- 35:58So that's what their perspective is.
- 36:00And obviously the the workers are going to are going to back
- 36:03that. Local politicians are going to
- 36:04back that idea. But I think it is really
- 36:07important to to mention that like the consulting's unnamed
- 36:10mark doesn't have a public track record in this sector, you know,
- 36:14and, and they've not spoken about finances.
- 36:16So it's equally just as harsh for the public if they think
- 36:20that the refinery could be saved and the government are deciding
- 36:23to block it, which isn't the case because official receivers
- 36:26position the government couldn't intervene even if they wanted
- 36:29to. Right.
- 36:30So just just to be clear, when you're speaking about wood,
- 36:33that's Wood Mackenzie, isn't it there?
- 36:35Yeah, just in case our die hard North Sea listeners are going
- 36:39what what does Wood Group have to do with us?
- 36:42But yeah, Wood. Mackenzie Wood.
- 36:45Mackenzie had that sort of figures a wee while ago, right?
- 36:47It's, it's an interesting situation and you know,
- 36:50obviously, you know, we've heard, we've heard of refinery
- 36:54closures and recent, you know, earlier this year we had range
- 36:57about as well. Like it's, it's, it's a big
- 36:59talking point. And you know, we saw the SNP in
- 37:03Westminster around the time of, of the Grangemouth closures are
- 37:07criticizing Kier Starmer's premiership for, you know, I get
- 37:13Stephen Flynn said moving heaven and earth for, for British Steel
- 37:17and sort of nationalizing that. And then, you know, maybe not
- 37:21putting that same sort of effort into Grangemouth and you can
- 37:24totally understand why local politicians and local people
- 37:28around Lindsay are saying the same thing, right?
- 37:32For sure. Feels like you're being, it
- 37:33feels like they're being snubbed.
- 37:35But then as you present there is there's that issue of, well, if
- 37:38we just say yes to this guy that we don't really know, we don't
- 37:41understand where his money's coming from or what's happening
- 37:45here. You've then got a whole other
- 37:47situation around, well, do we just have another practice and
- 37:51are we just kicking the can down the road?
- 37:53And is that any better for the workers impacted?
- 37:57You know, it's still going to be 125 jobs lost if if these guys
- 38:00take over and then immediately fold.
- 38:03I was just going to say, So you've been speaking to them off
- 38:06the record. What's your general sense?
- 38:09You feel like there is kind of like a firm hand on the rudder
- 38:12with them? Or do you think there's still
- 38:14questions to be asked? I don't know, there's, there's
- 38:16got to be questions to be asked. But like, you know, just because
- 38:18the consortium's like, you know, not like a public entity where
- 38:22everyone knows, like who's involved, it doesn't mean
- 38:24they're not legit. If, if that makes sense.
- 38:27But it's just like, you know, journalistically, it just leaves
- 38:31those questions. So I've been digging and digging
- 38:33and digging and trying just to get some names of consultants
- 38:35even off the record just to kind of like, verify all of this
- 38:39information because, you know, everybody's free to try and
- 38:43like, get this refinery right. You know, you and I could sit
- 38:46down together and come up with a proposal.
- 38:49So, yeah, where, wherever there's secrecy, there's
- 38:51obviously that doubt in play. But Reform UK have been quite,
- 38:55they've jumped quite quickly to, to back this.
- 38:58But whether that's just, you know, political opportunities or
- 39:01more like, you know, James Ascott, the, the, the guy in
- 39:04charge of due diligence told me that he's been speaking with
- 39:08Reform, you know, in person quite a lot.
- 39:10So maybe they do have more detail and they do think that
- 39:14this is a good plan. There's still so many unanswered
- 39:17questions about the the Lindsay or refinery, the handling of it.
- 39:22You know who wants to buy it, whether Phillips 66 of the right
- 39:25move, which obviously makes makes for great podcasting and
- 39:29will be taking much more of my time up on calls and and trying
- 39:34to dig this information out. Oh well, you're just going to
- 39:37have to stay tuned to hear more. There's more headlines to come.
- 39:40As Floyd said, the Lindsay Oil Refinery situation isn't going
- 39:44anywhere. Well, that does it for this
- 39:47week's episode of Energy Voice Out Loud.
- 39:49Thank you very much, Floyd, for joining me and thank you very
- 39:52much for listening. If you'd like to stay up to date
- 39:55with everything that's happening between this week and next,
- 39:57theenergyvoice.com is your place to go.
- 40:00And myself and Michael will be at the Floating Offshore Wind
- 40:03Conference in Aberdeen next week.
- 40:05So please do come along and say hello if you're in the area.