Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Penske To Go Private?, Busting Dealer Myths
Transcript
- 0:00Oh, I got caught sleeping with the trigger button in the middle of that song. [laughs] Just not used to the new one yet. It's Thursday, July 23rd. It's the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly.
- 0:09It's Kyle Mounts here. We're talking about Penske going private, getting on TikTok a little bit. We gotta go. Like, we got a TikTok video to share with everybody. People really wanna know our business. Oh.
- 0:17They stalk us every 15 minutes. Some fire in there. Then we're talking about some big- We got a TikTok video. We do. I think it might be a first, first on the show. It's fun. I mean, all right- You know?...
- 0:25we'll get to the third story when we get to it. We'll get to the third... And we'll get to all that stuff. Yeah, we will, we will, we will. When we get to it.
- 0:29Oh, man, we've made a lot of changes and updates and upgrades and, and kind of like, it's kind of like the off-season for our media company. Yeah, it is the off-season. Yeah. Right? We got, we got people...
- 0:39W- you know, we, we w- the summer is, like, the work in the background mode for the- Yeah... ASOTU More Than Cars team, and we just, like, plan stuff. We're about to launch...
- 0:47I, I, I kind of previewed it on social, but, like, we're about to launch something in the fall that I don't think anybody's expecting from us. We're trying to carry that ASOTUCON energy a little bit more. Oh, yeah.
- 0:59You know? So just- Oh, it's a good hint. Good hint. Good hint... you know. We got some new ways- Just carry the energy... for everybody to stay connected coming up- Yes... as well.
- 1:06Um, we're really upgrading and updating and revamping a lot of the stuff that we do in, you know, overt ways, but also a lot of, like, nuanced ways.
- 1:14And let me tell you, like, the email open rate is really reflecting that people like the changes. I mean- Yep... we're, we're in that 50 to 60% open rate range on a daily email going out to thousands of people.
- 1:26Thank you. If you're a part of that community that opens that email- Yes... every day, thank you, and thanks for, like, being just a bit step closer to what we do, what we believe. Yes. You know?
- 1:36And, and we're, we're, we're working on some ways to bring that email community closer to one another so you can actually have some two-way conversa- so many cool things coming.
- 1:43Uh, if you don't get the email, you should go get it. Daily.asotu.com. D-A-I-L-Y, daily.asotu.com. Go get the email. Be a part of the thing. Realize why so many people open it every day. It's a great- Yeah.
- 1:54It's an awesome way to start your day. It really is. It is an awesome way. Hey, uh, we, we also haven't talked about this on the pod in a few days, but, uh, retailautoevents.com is the bless- Oh...
- 2:04best place to get retail auto events. And- It's, [laughs] you can say it's the blessed place. It's the blessed place. It's the blessed place to get... [laughs] Well, we had four more events added yesterday.
- 2:12So you can actually go subscribe to the calendar, so you can download it to your Google calendar, your iCal account, anything like that, so that when we add new events, you automatically get them on your calendar.
- 2:22Tackle 'em one and all if you want. You don't have to, like, go back and be like- Yeah... "Did I miss anything?" Yes. Yeah. So go subscribe, and then you'll get that landing page.
- 2:28And if you wanna only, you know, look at the in-person events or the virtual events, or you wanna get the whole automotive calendar- Yes... subscribe so you don't miss anything. Do that.
- 2:36That, that site literally started the best way any site can start. We needed a solution for ourselves, so we built it. There's gotta be a better way, right? It's like Shark Tank. That's right. All right.
- 2:46Let's talk about some news. The nation's second-largest automotive retailer may soon leave the public markets.
- 2:52Penske's corp and Japanese partner, uh, Mitsui, have launched a $3.8 billion bid to take Penske Auto private, a move that could give the- Wow... dealership giant more flexibility to invest and plan for the long term.
- 3:05Peske- Pen- Penske and, um, Mitsui are offering $210 per share for the 28%, uh, of Penske Auto Group they don't already own. Shares jumped nearly 10% on the news. Some investors might push for a higher offer. Of course.
- 3:19Management says operating... [laughs] Of course, car people. Uh, management says operating as a private company would provide flexibility to invest, innovate, and make long-term decisions.
- 3:28It's really tough to make decisions in that 30-day, 90-day, you know, earnings report windows.
- 3:32Analysts say the move could also simplify future leadership success- succession and reduce pressure on those cur- quarterly earnings expectations.
- 3:41Stephens analyst Jeff Lick said, "It's easier to do all the things in the context of a private company." That's so true. Yeah. It, it absolutely is.
- 3:48We, I mean, the most recent example of this is X, Twitter, uh, being bought by the man Elon Musk- Uh-huh... and just being able to... well, own the whole thing, right?
- 3:58I don't expect them to cut 60% of the workforce, but... Yeah, they're not gonna do that.
- 4:03But it, the reality is, is that when you have all, all of these, these public auto groups, uh, the bet is on profitability when it comes to shareholder, uh, sides of things and, and even with OEMs, right?
- 4:15So anything in automotive is the bet is on profitability, and it's actually a very steady stock. Um, you know, k- kind of growth mindset, but nothing, nothing crazy. And,
- 4:25n- and the market's not willing to take big dips for risk or big dips for long-term planning.
- 4:30And so I, I think this is a really smart move, especially in a timeline that, like, right now is a point where larger, larger automakers, larger auto, uh, groups, have to be thinking about how I, how do I stay resilient?
- 4:44How do I stay, um, efficient and create net new technology around us that makes me a, a viable factor in three to five years?
- 4:54And so, man, I'm, I'm, I'm kind of excited about it 'cause I feel like Penske will actually get in the news more because they'll try stuff, break things a little bit- It's part, yeah... and it'll be fun.
- 5:03Because it's- You know?... when you're publicly traded, you, you're very careful about how you wanna be in the news and how you want... Like, the PR department- Yep...
- 5:08is burning overtime in evely- every publicly traded company. When you're a privately traded company, you don't have that mass public pressure to do things and not do things. So it's good to...
- 5:18Yeah, 'cause the public is also, like, one of the shareholders. And whoever wants to be dictated by what the public's doing [laughs] in general? Ooh, that's it. Yep.
- 5:27Speaking of being dictated by what the public's saying. Stop. Go. Big wheel. Turn. What a great, great segment. Well, uh, you're welcome to Thursday, team.
- 5:34Uh, our good friend Don Hall of Virginia Auto Dealer Association sent us this viral TikTok this morning early. It's making the rounds. I watched it, and I was like, "I think this is time to talk about this on the show."
- 5:47Uh, we're gonna talk about it on the show. Uh, we're gonna show you the video right now, and, and if you're not listen- watching it, you don't really need to see anything.
- 5:54It's, like, two stick figure cartoon characters having a conversation inside a dealership, so it's not that engaging.
- 5:59But it's the dialogue, and then, uh, we'll talk about the dialogue, we'll talk about the comments, and, uh, get some feedback and get it out there.
- 6:06So, um, Nathan Do, do I need to have my bleep button ready, or do we have it already built in? I've... It's all set. Oh. I've got it taken care of. He took care of it. I had my bleep button ready- Ah...
- 6:16'cause I have one here on my RodeCaster, but [laughs] Yes. All right. Fully censored for our sensitive listening audience. Oh, yeah, very sensitive ears. Ah, perfect. Very sensitive ears. Perfect.
- 6:23Just trying to keep it PG. All right, let's go. It'll be actually funnier probably th- with the bleeps is my guess. It 100% will be funnier with the bleeps. [laughs] I guarantee you. I've watched it several times.
- 6:31All right, hit it. Let's go. Just buy a car directly from the manufacturer. Why would you wanna buy it straight from the manufacturer, rumor right here, okay, your local dealership? Is you gouging me.
- 6:42I mean, it's ridiculous these markups. I can see what the price costs at the manufacturer. Why can't I just pay that price? Well, why don't you go to one of the EV manufacturers? You can buy right from them. Oh, I can?
- 6:53Oh, yeah. No, they bypassed all of our [beep] that we've been- [laughs]... putting together for the last, like, I don't know, 80 years. What level of [beep] did you guys put together?
- 7:02Well, in the early days of the auto industry- Here it comes... the manufacturers had to rely on independent dealers because they just didn't have the cash monies to pony up and start building retail locations.
- 7:13Interesting.
- 7:14And as time went on, we knew our days were numbered, so we created the National Automobile Dealers Association, where we would lobby members of Congress to ensure that it was illegal to buy directly from the manufacturer, and you had to come to one of us.
- 7:29That sounds really [beep] up, like, overall. It is. [laughs] Yeah, yeah, it's still just all about [beep] the consumer. There's really no reason that this is better. Okay, so there's so much to dive in here.
- 7:43If y- if you don't know, if you watch this show and you don't know, the National Auto- NADA and the dealerships happened because Ford's building cars.
- 7:51Yes, they cannot afford to put retail locations up, 'cause they're manufacturing, figuring out how to manufacture cars. So all these independent people said, "We'll front the cash. We'll get a dealership.
- 8:01We'll put the cars on the lot."
- 8:03And then what Ford started to do is talk about, "Well, even though you spent, uh, invested all that money to sell our product, maybe we'll sell it and put you out of business," which is why they got together and said, "Hey, if we're gonna invest this money, then we need to have a system where we can be protected for our investment."
- 8:18So it's, it's a lot different.
- 8:20However, I think one of the biggest takeaways here is that there's a perspective and a position, and when we read some of these comments, you realize it's gone uncontested, and there's a lot of reasons.
- 8:32I put a comment in that said- Yes... you know, my, my comment was basically, you know, competition is good for any business. That's the k- that's the kicker. And if- Right...
- 8:42if, if, if all of a sudden you can only buy an F-150 from Ford, do you think it would get cheaper if there was- No... no competition? Okay, so that's- Absolutely not... one of the kickers. Go ahead, Kyle.
- 8:50You have some comments. Well, well, because that- There will be some comments... and, and that's the, that's the reality.
- 8:53When you, when you look at what Tesla has done and you look at their profitability per vehicle, net profitability f- per vehicle, it's significantly higher, and a large portion of the reason for that is because they get to set the price.
- 9:06And, um, and there's no requirement to make the dealer locally competitive to something else, right? That's right. Especially you only see, like, one Tesla store in a city. So it's hard to get to.
- 9:21It's hard to get service. You... The, the dealer increases the level of competition and increases the level of connection with the lo- local customer. Um, with... It...
- 9:31This has been proven out at, uh, in, in other countries, and I think that the, the, like, the lens, the myopic lens at which this video and others like it look at the entire situation is, is, is so short-minded.
- 9:47Um, and I think when, when consumers and, and people that understand business actually start to consider that an entire industry is built on essentially manufactured competition, it is really good- Yes...
- 10:00for the consumer. It is. And then when you think about the local touch of, "Oh, I wanna get on the phone and contest my warranty," right? Oh, there's no advocate. But- Yeah, yeah. There's no advocate.
- 10:11The, the, the dealer literally stands in the gap for the dealer because they wanna make sure... or for the customer, 'cause they wanna make sure that customer's taken care of.
- 10:19I, I know countless cases that the OEM has, has given to the, the desires of a good dealer that fights on behalf of the consumer. Yes. And that's helpful. I understand. You know,
- 10:31it's, it's hard when you don't understand a system, right? And it's very easy- Yep... it's very easy. Like, dealers are an easy target for cer- big business is an easy target. Dealers are an easy target.
- 10:41I think a lot of people under- don't understand that a lot of dealerships aren't big business. It's local business. But I'm gonna read some of the comments just so we can, I think, learn.
- 10:49Uh, there's more to learn in the comments by, by- Yeah... by the way, if you understand how people think. Here's one. Somebody says, "You can absolutely buy a car from the manufacturer. Here's how.
- 10:57Go on the website of the brand, build a car to spec, and the manufacturer will tell you exactly how much you should pay for it. Zero nonsense. None of the haggling. They even have an acronym. It's called MSRP."
- 11:06So, like, uh, there's some... You... We all know there's... That's kinda true, but you still have to buy from a dealer, and there's still some other stuff. Yeah, you tell me who wants to pay MSRP out there. Absolutely.
- 11:16Oh, oh. Yeah. Are we, are we saying that everyone's cool with paying MSRP? Oh, everybody wants to pay MSRP? Sure. We'll make this co- One price... we'll make this whole thing very easy. Done. 100% every time.
- 11:24Every time, MSRP, done. Uh, somebody says, "It also takes four to five hours. Should be able to go in, five-minute test drive, five minutes negotiating on price, five-minute credit check, five minutes signing paperwork."
- 11:34That's fine if you have great credit, actually. Yeah. Um- It's perfect. If you don't have great credit- And I know a lot of people doing that... hey, hey, if you don't have great credit, you don't want that system.
- 11:40Trust me. And if you still take four to five hours to buy a car at your dealership as a general practice, not as like, oh, this customer had, you know, bad credit or needed some help or had...
- 11:50uh, we have some decision-making factor or something. But if that is, like, a general rule- Yeah... for how long it takes, then d- shoot me a DM.
- 11:59I will introduce you to the people that can help you get out of that business. Let's talk... [laughs] Let's talk about some more. "I'd rather get ripped off buying a gas vehicle than ever buy an EV."
- 12:07Okay, we understand where you stand. [laughs] Someone says, "Dealerships are going the way of Sears." Dealerships make about 1 to 2% margin on the sale of any car. The sale of cars is not the way they make money.
- 12:17They make money through service and financing. The video completely misrepresents the truth of the situation. I'd agree with that one, actually. Hey. Okay. Outlaw dealerships because it's a huge tax on the working class.
- 12:28I have no idea how that rationale happened. Where this person just says tax on the working class in every comment, guaranteed. They do, especially all of the working class that the dealer employs.
- 12:35It probably doesn't feel like much of a tax to them. Yep. Welcome to We the Billionaire of the United States Corporation of America. That's a very interesting sentence. Okay, hold on.
- 12:45Um, somebody has a question about, "Why do you have to pay so much to register a car every year?" I like that question. Um- [laughs] They must live in Florida. [laughs] Is it, is it really expensive in Florida?
- 12:56Oh, yeah, 250 for... 250 every year, but, like, minimum. Oh, my gosh. And then a new, a new tag is, like, 750 bucks. It's insane. Yeah. No income tax, though. I mean, yeah. Yeah. Right? Uh- Yeah, I know.
- 13:05And, and Tennessee doesn't even... It's $53 a year for ours, so. Funny how people don't know or recognize the taxes that retail businesses pay for their communities. Do they research on franchise laws and why they exist?
- 13:16Ooh. There's someone with a little reason in there. Uh, lobbying is a num- another name for paying someone off. No. I would say- Oh, you know what? That reminds me.
- 13:23We asked, um, I asked, uh, when we were speaking to the ATA summit, I asked Ted Smith, I said, "Can you give me... Gi- explain lobbying like I'm five." Yep. And he says, "A great lobbyist is just a broker of information.
- 13:37I have to bring you good information," he goes, "I would tell them, and if my, the information I ever bring you isn't truthful, you should never allow me in this office again." Yeah. 'Cause what is it?
- 13:47It's, like, it's, like, plus or minus 3, uh, 412 people across Senate and the House. What is it? What's the number? 435. Something like that. 435. What's that? Thought it was, like, 435. Yeah, between both. Yeah.
- 14:00So it's somewhere in that neighborhood. I don't know. Uh, we're wrong. We're not politicians, okay? I'm, I'm suppli- I'm convinced we are completely wrong.
- 14:05We're probably completely wrong, but let's just say 500 or less people that have to have infinite knowledge across multiple verticals, spaces, business units, political, uh, ecosystems, and, and you're expected for them to understand that without having advocates for each industry?
- 14:24Okay. Maybe, uh, I bet you if all we did was change the word lobby to advocate, people would be like, "Oh, yeah, they just are, like, advocates." That is. Here's a comment about Carvana. "Carvana is better.
- 14:34Dealerships are frauds." Well, there's a little bit of crossover there, now, buddy. Carvana is dealerships. Hey. [laughs] Little bit of crossover, buddy. Uh, so either way, I'm gonna read through these comments.
- 14:43We should just sit down, you and me, for 30 minutes and just go through, go through the comments and, like, respond to them one by one. That would be so much fun. Oh.
- 14:51Frank Ziti just commented on, [laughs] on the video, "You guys should run for Congress." One condition. Fake news. Fake news, Frank. One condition.
- 14:58I will run for Congress, but only if Kyle and I can get elected together, and we get to wear the hats. [laughs] Wear the hats- Right?... in Congress. Wear a two for one.
- 15:06Walk in with our jeans, T-shirts, and hats like bosses. We'll have to share a seat, though. But we, y- you need, you need both sides of this coin. [laughs] You can't just get one of it. Can't get one.
- 15:14[laughs] Plus, we need to make sure we have at least one friend when the day is over. [laughs] When we mess everybody up. We'll make, we'll make everybody on both sides of the carpet mad. Oh, my goodness.
- 15:24I think- I think, I think we're gonna have to cut the c- cut the show short. We're gonna have to cut the third story. But the, the third story- That was too much fun... is a great story, and we'll do it tomorrow.
- 15:31But look, we hope we gave you some [laughs] good stuff to think about. Uh, go on TikTok, we linked it up in the show notes. Uh, and if you haven't done it, daily.asotu.com. Be a part of the community.
- 15:41Move in deeper, we're moving closer to you. We'll see you here tomorrow. [upbeat music]