Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / You weren't encouraged to explore in early development. Now what? Part 2.
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:20love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is September 5th, 2024 at 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time
- 0:29and I thought that I would continue talking about
- 0:34exploration and what happens when you don't learn to do it in
- 0:40childhood or when something interferes with the arising of
- 0:45the creative self, which is the thing the way that it's
- 0:51described often in Western cycle psychoanalytic terms, in
- 0:58attachment terms, we would say that the attachment system turns
- 1:02off and the exploration system turns on.
- 1:06And in I think a Buddhist frame, it would be that you come out of
- 1:11the limited identification with the self and you operate from
- 1:15the place of dot self. So shifting out of that very
- 1:21tight, limited identity of what's possible and what isn't
- 1:24possible and opening up into the capacity of the whole body mind
- 1:31to discover things that are meaningful.
- 1:36In some sense. It's just shifting into that,
- 1:38that place of freedom and allowing the body mind to then
- 1:46engage in activities that it finds rewarding.
- 1:54And then noticing when that a sense of self arises that's
- 1:59constricting, noticing when the exploration system shuts down
- 2:05and the attachment system turns back on.
- 2:11There's that that piece of emotional dysregulation
- 2:17interfering with the capacity to explore and then understanding
- 2:23how to bring yourself back into emotional balance so that it can
- 2:28shut down again and the the exploration system can turn back
- 2:33on. Another way to talk about it
- 2:36really is advanced mentalizing and moving out of the basic
- 2:44frame of mentalizing into the the pursuit of yes, there are
- 2:58higher forms of expression. Any anytime I'm confronted with
- 3:07the hierarchy, I'm always concerned about the point of
- 3:11view that you're looking at something from hierarchies or
- 3:16descriptions of this. And without going into a lot of
- 3:21detail about the nature of the higher levels of mentalizing,
- 3:26just in this talk, that basic frame of being able to let the
- 3:37mind be spontaneous, at the same time monitoring it, being able
- 3:42to discern clearly yourself as distinct from others, the
- 3:48internal expression, the external world, thinking and
- 3:52feeling. When you come out of that sense
- 4:01of identity, in some ways you're also coming out of the confines
- 4:05of the culture. What is that?
- 4:09Those cultural limits that are imposed?
- 4:15What has value in that regard? What happens if the things that
- 4:24really matter to you, the things that move you that you want to
- 4:27pursue, don't have cultural value?
- 4:32It's in some sense easy enough to set that aside.
- 4:35But what also is triggered by things that have high cultural
- 4:38value are the resources that flow into making them possible.
- 4:43So if you pursue things that don't have a high cultural value
- 4:47that are likely to return that value to you, then you're in a
- 4:53position of balancing the primary exploration with the
- 4:57secondary exploration because you have to provide time,
- 5:01energy, and resources to be able to explore that.
- 5:06If you blow your time energy resources into things that
- 5:11aren't culturally valuable, that what you'll find over a period
- 5:14of time is that you don't have the markers of cultural value
- 5:19that might be socially rewarded. And then what do you do?
- 5:31You abandoned the the things that really matter to you in
- 5:35order to to track the, the, the, the, the cultural pieces or can
- 5:42you abandoned those live a life where really it's focused on the
- 5:49meaning part of the collection of the cultural milestones is
- 5:54not so important. But I find in that process, of
- 6:00course, is that there's so much in the way of media and
- 6:06representation of the cultural values that even though you most
- 6:12of the time find that you have this a sense of reward from
- 6:16pursuing the things that matter, a sense of doubt can arise when
- 6:26you don't actually collect all the odoms.
- 6:41And the other thing that happens, of course, depending on
- 6:44what it what Ave. you are, is that you get into rare and rare
- 6:49places of understanding thinking.
- 6:53And then how do you relate to people that aren't actually in
- 6:58your line of exploration? Once you've figured out how to
- 7:07turn that exploratory self, that creative self on that, you can
- 7:14begin looking. We were talking about this last
- 7:18time in relationship to attachment conditioning and how
- 7:22that affects this. Really the, the group that is
- 7:27the most challenged in terms of exploration are people with some
- 7:32kind of preoccupation, mainly because the way that
- 7:37preoccupation forms is through an interference with the
- 7:43capacity to explore. You know, when you're small,
- 7:49just crawling around, you're needing constant reassurance,
- 7:54constant emotional regulation. To pursue regulation, you need
- 7:59to have the the caregivers monitor the risks that you might
- 8:05take and allow you to stretch out to the to the within the
- 8:10limit of your capacity and not over it be protected and safe.
- 8:17And then you also need somebody who's interested in what it is
- 8:21that you're discovering. So that cycle is to go out and
- 8:27explore and then to return and express the things that you've
- 8:31discovered. When you're inhibited from that,
- 8:38then those inhibitions need to be removed before you can really
- 8:45get into the exploration. If we would talk about this from
- 8:51a place of emotional regulation, we all basically start out as
- 8:56auto regulators and one of the traps that dismissing adults get
- 9:01into is thinking that their exploration is exploration when
- 9:08actually it's largely auto regulating.
- 9:11They're just distracting themselves or engaging
- 9:14themselves as a way of emotionally regulating and not
- 9:18really pursuing the activation of the creative self and what
- 9:22might be meaningful. When somebody comes well enough
- 9:29that you move from auto regulation to external
- 9:32regulation, but not well enough that you move into a
- 9:35collaborative relationship experience, you remain dependent
- 9:39on the emotional regulation of someone else to bring you enough
- 9:47into balance that the attachment system shuts down and the
- 9:50exploration system turns on. And if you don't have that
- 9:56regulation, then the exploration system stays off and you don't
- 10:02really have the capacity to explore.
- 10:06And disorganized people are are fearful of the world.
- 10:11And that fearfulness keeps the the attachment system engaged
- 10:18and doesn't permit the exploration system to arise.
- 10:28So can you track all of that and see how that's operating within
- 10:37you based on your conditioning, so that you can begin to move
- 10:42out of it, into that place where the the sense of the exploratory
- 10:49self, the creative self, arises freely when you need it?
- 10:55That's really what we mean by advanced mentalizing.
- 11:01If you can tell the difference between an active exploration
- 11:06system and an active attachment system, that you can identify
- 11:12the sense of self when it's arisen and it's constricting.
- 11:16And that you have a way of coming out of that into this
- 11:19spacious, open, unrestricted mind that then allows you to
- 11:26pursue what's what's meaningful to you, which you discover by
- 11:31the body mind exploring who did all.
- 11:39Right, I this is the first time probably I've actually realized
- 11:44or the distinction so clearly that the sense of self is almost
- 11:49a blocker. Yeah, you were supposed to
- 11:53explore from the the no self or emptiness of self point of view.
- 11:59That which I realized, you can say that it's like, oh, now I
- 12:05understand why they we say that. The sense itself coming from the
- 12:08openness, not the openness itself.
- 12:11But yeah, OK, I see. Because I was always confused
- 12:18because I was always looking for my sense of self exploration,
- 12:24But it's actually the openness is exploration, not my own small
- 12:28cells. Does that sound right?
- 12:31That's right. So how do you come and go from
- 12:36that self experience? And in some sense, we could say
- 12:45that's a kind of liberation, that ability to come and go and
- 12:49not be trapped. But how will people do this
- 12:54without like advanced meditations?
- 12:56The openness is not easily accessible for IT person who's
- 13:00simply doing an attachment course.
- 13:07The way that I discovered this was through meditation, but then
- 13:12I also didn't grow up in a in a secure environment where I was
- 13:16what didn't require a kind of vigilance and was quite
- 13:23frightening the the environment I grew up in.
- 13:27So I don't know what that perspective would be where you
- 13:34simply were encouraged from a young age, your caregivers paid
- 13:41attention to you, they saw what mattered to you and they
- 13:43encouraged you to go into it. And they kept good, good
- 13:48boundaries with you so that you developed a sense of confidence
- 13:55in, in your ability to do that. I think that if of course, if
- 14:02you can come and go from the sense of self and you, you, you
- 14:05understand what's meaningful and you can engage it.
- 14:08You're not going to come here. And in the West, you're probably
- 14:11not going to meditate either. Maybe at least my experience of
- 14:17people who come to meditation is they come because the, the
- 14:20standard kit doesn't really help them relieve the distress of
- 14:24their life. So they look for something else.
- 14:29And because meditation provides relief so quickly, it, it's, it
- 14:35engages people and you know, I teach different kinds of groups
- 14:44of people and the, the groups that are traditionally low
- 14:48mentalizing, it is a, it is a, it is very encouraging that they
- 15:00can explore the mentalizing simply and rapidly.
- 15:05But also to understand that a lot of people operate with very
- 15:12low mentalizing and not know instructions for how to even
- 15:18comprehend that there's such a thing as mentalizing.
- 15:25How can you, which you can all these things, learn to recognize
- 15:33these things and then shift from one state to another with
- 15:37agencies? Really, I think what we're
- 15:39talking about simply drop out of the difficulty of the limited
- 15:45identity into that spaciousness, and then everything is
- 15:52available. And you said the sense of doubt
- 16:00arises when you don't collect what?
- 16:03Well, what I was saying is when you don't collect the typical
- 16:07markers of a successful person in our society because you've
- 16:13used your time, energy and resources in the pursuit of
- 16:16things that matter to you. But we're not of cultural value.
- 16:22Then there's a pressure from the the social spheres around you
- 16:29that are engaged in that, you know, you might get pressure
- 16:36from family or friend groups that what you're pursuing is
- 16:42actually not what's culturally valuable.
- 16:46And so that that it's actually is you're stumbling rather than
- 16:52pursuing something that would be meaningful.
- 16:56Extremely high in Asian countries.
- 16:58Yeah. And so I don't, the reason I
- 17:03bring it up is not so much that it isn't still better to focus
- 17:08on the things that matter, but it it's also, I think, an
- 17:12experience that causes the the rising of doubt, particularly
- 17:18when you're, you're in a period of exploration that isn't so
- 17:21fruitful, which is also pretty ordinary when you see the value
- 17:30of really landing on something that provides a lot of meaning
- 17:33to you. All of the false starts that
- 17:40didn't really go anywhere that that you went through in order
- 17:44to discover the thing that you needed to know.
- 17:47Does it matter so much? You get quite used to the ease
- 17:55of a no in some ways. If somebody says no, there's
- 17:59nothing else to do and it's finished, somebody says yes, of
- 18:02course, then you have to engage all of the stuff that is that is
- 18:06part of that, which is much more complex.
- 18:12But then how many of those you know, you go in a direction, you
- 18:16discover what you can, you take what's meaningful and it directs
- 18:20you often in in another direction.
- 18:22You're you're you're constantly moving toward that.
- 18:28That's a kind of secure model for that.
- 18:31But you don't have that sense of security.
- 18:35For instance, dismissing people are very sensitive to positions
- 18:40of of societal value because they use that position to trade
- 18:45for care. So it can be difficult for them
- 18:52to shift into something that actually would be more
- 18:55meaningful, particularly when they're not remunerated and a
- 19:02preoccupied. People really tend to believe
- 19:06that the meaningfulness of life comes from proximity to somebody
- 19:11who's engaged in an exploration that that has value.
- 19:17It doesn't come from that, but it's often the belief in that.
- 19:22So there's that it, it can be pressure from a preoccupied
- 19:29person on you to share your exploration.
- 19:36That sharing of the exploration is, is what's important.
- 19:40You go out and discover something and you come back and
- 19:42you express the thing that you discovered.
- 19:46And in that expression of the thing that you've discovered
- 19:49with somebody who can really see and understand it, there's a
- 19:52sense of intimacy that arises, a sense of being valued, being
- 19:58seen, being known. And that's that cycle of
- 20:06exploration. When you don't have that piece,
- 20:10which is often a a challenge for dismissing people, they they
- 20:14hold that primary exploration almost completely privately
- 20:19because of the conditions of the childhood where it wasn't valued
- 20:23in the family system. And to get them to risk the
- 20:27rejection and often shame of expressing what is ultimately
- 20:32important, it'd be quite challenging because the
- 20:37expectation is one of rejection. But when you don't share it,
- 20:45it's easy to to have a disordered perspective of it and
- 20:52also easy for it to become an auto regulating strategy, which
- 20:56isn't actually producing much beyond kind of distracted stasis
- 21:04doesn't lead to the growth of understanding this human
- 21:11condition. So we start where we are.
- 21:16That's really the idea when or I might say you start with what's
- 21:25left, you have a really hard, difficult childhood.
- 21:32A lot of the, a lot of those capacities are are lost.
- 21:37We can't hang around hoping that we can revive them or recover
- 21:42them, recreate them. We really have to examine what's
- 21:47left, pursue with what we have. The shift for dismissing people
- 21:55is out of a sort of siloed pursuit of what comes from
- 22:03secondary exploration. The time, energy and resources
- 22:07that they use to contract the kind of care they want into a, a
- 22:12more collaborative way of being with people so that you can set
- 22:19up a, a social network that will be receptive, receptive and
- 22:25interested in the, in the, the primary exploration.
- 22:29The thing about dismissing people is they have all the
- 22:32skills already and their mentalizing capacity is pretty
- 22:36close to a level that you would need for security.
- 22:40And so it's less of a lift to get into a place where you
- 22:46actually are willing to risk primary exploration and also
- 22:50risk the expression of that to other people.
- 22:58The emotional regulation piece is challenging for dismissing
- 23:01people because the main way that they usually regulate themselves
- 23:05is by suppressing awareness of their emotions.
- 23:07So that needs to be drawn into the the conscious experience and
- 23:15then strategies for regulating it so that you have agency to
- 23:21shift in and out of the self. The limiting self identity, this
- 23:28missing people are over monitoring, which means that
- 23:31they're, they're really confined to that limited identity most of
- 23:36the time and very resistant to the spontaneity that is required
- 23:45for exploration. So there's a shift out of that
- 23:51tightness that control that deactivation into it fully
- 23:57engaged position, buddy. The sorry, what's the the the
- 24:06correlation between mentalizing and collaboration in this
- 24:09dismissive piece? Isn't the monitoring a good
- 24:12piece when a dismissive person is monitoring his state?
- 24:16What mentalizing of what? So when you're talking about not
- 24:22mental, not not monitoring for say, but over monitoring.
- 24:28So the the natural state of dismissing people is Uber
- 24:31monitoring, over monitoring and that interferes with the
- 24:36spontaneous movement. As long as you're over
- 24:42monitoring and you're interfering with spontaneity,
- 24:44you don't have the capacity for spontaneous exploration.
- 24:48That would be the quickest path to what's meaningful, and so you
- 24:53need to begin to draw down that super monitoring.
- 24:57That super monitoring also keeps you trapped in a sense of self.
- 25:01The habit of dismissing people is to preview all of the
- 25:07expressions that they might make through the self experience and
- 25:12understand them how they might land from self experience rather
- 25:18than simply risking spontaneity in in a totally spontaneous
- 25:26exchange. Because the conscious self
- 25:30experience runs about 1/2 a second behind the activity of
- 25:34the body mind, you would have to feel safe to make an expression
- 25:39and hear it at the same time as the person that you were
- 25:42expressing it. Dismissing people that makes
- 25:47them extremely uncomfortable because they're so sensitive to
- 25:51rejection and so sensitive to shame.
- 25:54They like to preview it and, and through the self experience and
- 25:58then express it. So that's why there's a kind of
- 26:01rigidness or a kind of stiltedness in the way that they
- 26:05converse, because everything runs 1/2 a second behind in
- 26:11order to preview it. So it, it, there's a notable
- 26:16absence of the spontaneity piece when you really get going, of
- 26:21course, you're both hearing what you're saying at the same time,
- 26:28which is very lively, right? And because you're shifting out
- 26:32of the, the self consciousness of self, it can often be
- 26:36surprising how changeable it is. But of course you're monitoring.
- 26:46So if it the communication doesn't land, you can prepare it
- 26:50right? Well, in this case, it's just
- 26:54like it's viciousness asset, right?
- 26:56Say that again. The over monitoring aspect I
- 26:59think I also struggle with that. It's just that I really, when
- 27:03I'm doing like, see, hear, feel, I have to like almost like
- 27:06imagine that there is nothing behind my head to open up the
- 27:09space. Yeah, just letting it go with no
- 27:15interference that that is in some sense a description of the
- 27:19state of mind where exploration is possible preoccupied people
- 27:28because So one last thing about assisting people, you need to
- 27:32have a group of people that you trust that you are willing to
- 27:37tell everything to, which is where the collaborative piece
- 27:43comes in. You take care of them, they take
- 27:45care of you. This is very different than the
- 27:48typical relationship with a dismissing person where you take
- 27:51care of them and they don't reciprocate.
- 27:55So you have to be willing to open up and express the things
- 27:59that are of fundamental importance to you, and you have
- 28:07to do it with people that will receive that and cherish it and
- 28:10value. We occupied people because
- 28:18they're dependent on other people for exploration.
- 28:21The separation to go explore puts them in a state of
- 28:24dysregulation, which activates the self experience, which shuts
- 28:28down the exploration system. So that's the conundrum for them
- 28:33at the beginning of this. They need to learn to develop a
- 28:45capacity to emotionally regulate themselves separate from the
- 28:50people that they used to regulate themselves.
- 28:56If you look at that early development of emotional
- 28:59regulation, we all started out out as auto regulators.
- 29:04And then if somebody comes reliably enough, we shifted to
- 29:07external regulation. And if they show up reliably
- 29:12enough where we can see the patterns of care and see the
- 29:17patterns of emotional regulation and we begin to interject those
- 29:22skills and we begin to be able to do that for ourselves.
- 29:26And because we're confident in the reliability of the our
- 29:31regulators, we can separate, go explore.
- 29:36But if we get so distressed that we can't manage it ourselves,
- 29:40know that we can come rushing back and that they'll be
- 29:43available to us. That's that collaborative
- 29:47regulation experience. Once you learn to develop agency
- 30:00in regulating your own emotions, preoccupied people that also
- 30:04have to begin to learn to explore.
- 30:08And one of the things that secure people have and and also
- 30:13to some degree dismissing people have is resilience against the
- 30:20predominance of no's or dead ends in exploration.
- 30:27Once you get a real taste of what can happen when you find
- 30:31something that's truly meaningful, that is the
- 30:36beginning of the source of resilience.
- 30:40Because you know that all of the dead ends and all of the things
- 30:43that don't really produce much in the way of meaning are
- 30:47inconsequential toward finding something that's meaning.
- 30:52And the more you pursue exploration of the more you
- 30:57succeed at finding that's meaningful, the the more
- 31:00resilient you become because you know that it's something that
- 31:05you can do and something that you can find.
- 31:08But for adults that are just beginning their exploration
- 31:14process, it often can feel quite defeating after a couple of dead
- 31:19ends. Kind of a sense of hopelessness
- 31:24that you're going to be able to discover anything that you're
- 31:28going to be able to do it. Helplessness is one of the
- 31:35qualities of preoccupied people, which they tend to learn in
- 31:40childhood, where the caregivers take over their exploration.
- 31:45So they haven't really learned the capacity for those low
- 31:50levels of frustration. You're a child and you're
- 31:55attempting to do something and your caregiver gets frustrated
- 31:59with you not being able to do it, and then they take it over
- 32:02and do it for you. So one of the things that
- 32:06activates and preoccupied people as they're beginning to learn to
- 32:10explore is the sense of helplessness that they can't do
- 32:15it, and then the expectation that somebody else will come in
- 32:19and do it for them. Who did?
- 32:24So would it be true to say that a person who's in a relationship
- 32:27right now, a preoccupied person who is in a relationship right
- 32:31now would be good, would be good to explore because he or she has
- 32:38the has the dependent person that he or she can rely on?
- 32:47It depends, I guess, on the relationship.
- 32:49If you're in a relation, if you're preoccupied and you've
- 32:52picked a dismissing person, they're not going to reciprocate
- 32:56to support your exploration. In fact, they're not going to
- 33:00really be open to you leaving them in order to explore,
- 33:05because then you won't be there to provide care for them.
- 33:09So often what happens is that you you pick somebody who
- 33:15continues to interfere with your capacity to explore.
- 33:22One of the dynamics in dismissing in preoccupied
- 33:26relationships is the constant dissatisfaction that the
- 33:29preoccupied person feels because they're not exploring, which
- 33:34they then hector their partner about.
- 33:38But dismissing people can use that energy as a as an
- 33:41encouragement for their own exploration, particularly when
- 33:47both people are centered around the cultural markers of what
- 33:52what what it is to be successful.
- 33:54The dismissing person then benefits from depriving the
- 33:59preoccupied person of their exploration because they use the
- 34:04constant hectoring and energy of the preoccupied person for their
- 34:09own pursuit. That makes sense.
- 34:15It's like like when I have to make choices sometimes I am like
- 34:19wait, I don't know because I never like shopping for example.
- 34:23Is that this good example? If I'm like trying to choose and
- 34:26wait, I'm like wait a second. I've never actually made a
- 34:28choice to choose what shoes I like or what shirt I like.
- 34:32Right. So it's almost like you don't
- 34:34know what you like. Yes, that's it.
- 34:38You don't know what you like. And So what do you do?
- 34:42You try this shirt and that shirt and this shirt and that
- 34:44shirt. You try these shoes in those
- 34:47shoes, and in then having the experience of each of those
- 34:57being right, being present for the experience of each of those,
- 35:01gathering the information about them.
- 35:04And then since it's usually not the whole thing, but pieces of
- 35:08the things, you begin to gather the pieces of what works for you
- 35:16and what doesn't work for you. And then when you look for the
- 35:19next shirt, of course you're looking for the shirt that has
- 35:21the pieces that were are leaving out, the pieces that don't work.
- 35:28And then that begins to to narrow in on what your style is,
- 35:33that selection of what works and what doesn't work.
- 35:37And in the next iteration, choosing the things that work
- 35:44and leaving out. And so there's this organic
- 35:48process where it refines itself just in that that process that
- 35:55makes sense, Christian. I always think of like
- 36:05archetypal examples of like famous artists, painters,
- 36:10novelists that have spouses that kind of like manage their
- 36:15careers and like feed them and clothe them and like, they would
- 36:18be wandering off into traffic if not for someone that's kind of
- 36:22doing all that work. But they get to be kind of the,
- 36:25the famous one. That's kind of the trade.
- 36:28Right, they get to be proximate to the famous person.
- 36:34Wait, all these singers are like not writing their own songs,
- 36:36right? In that case, like song well.
- 36:41The one of the things about the consolidation of media and the
- 36:47consolidation of culture is that the the individual voice, the
- 36:59analog, let's say is being lost. Market research with
- 37:08supercomputers, right? You're crushing a billion pieces
- 37:12of data to come up with what works and then everything gets
- 37:21homogenized. And so rather than have this
- 37:28heterogenic culture where all of these different things are
- 37:32happening. For instance, when I was coming
- 37:35up, the sound in Manchester was completely different than the
- 37:40sound in London for instance, because there was enough
- 37:45distance that the the scene where where the different sounds
- 37:49were developed were far enough apart that there wasn't so much
- 37:54exchange the the the scene in Seattle for instance, so
- 37:58different than Chicago or New York.
- 38:05On King in Kings Rd. in the 70s, you'd go down and one shop after
- 38:11another would have these unique items that were made in small
- 38:18operations all over England. And I went in the 2000s 'cause I
- 38:31wanted to buy some English shoes and there weren't any.
- 38:35They were all the big factory shoes, generic.
- 38:43And so one of the things about this, our culture as it becomes
- 38:47this monolith, there's very little Ave. for anything that
- 38:52isn't that part of the idea of can you?
- 39:04So I'd like to say, can you tell one set of actor ABS from
- 39:07another? If you just see the ABS that
- 39:20making sense, what happened to all of that?
- 39:23And then of course you see the reaction to it is, is the the
- 39:27digital over processing of everything?
- 39:30People are now shooting film again because it's at least you
- 39:35could tell that it's not AI generated.
- 39:42Soon we're going to be sitting around campfires and people are
- 39:44going to be playing guitars again in reaction to that sort
- 39:52of that unitive cultural experience.
- 39:56That is not meaningful enough, right?
- 40:10That's the thing. So I'm sorry, one last thing is
- 40:18the preoccupied exploration. You've worked with a lot of
- 40:21students over the years. Is this simply them trying out
- 40:25different things about the skills that are already gained
- 40:27in their life? Because I feel the preoccupied
- 40:31will not have any skills. Well, there's a few shifts that
- 40:36are important. The 1st shift to make headway, I
- 40:41think for preoccupied people is to come out and pretend that is
- 40:47and that that is really hard to do.
- 40:51And depending on how far down the rabbit hole pretend mode.
- 40:55Pretend mode is where you read somebody else and decide who you
- 41:02have to be in order to entice that person to engage you to
- 41:10come out of that pretend mode into an authentic expression.
- 41:16It's not so simple to do because the authentic expression has a
- 41:21lot of painful associations with it because it's so unwanted in
- 41:26childhood. It's a terribly painful process
- 41:30to abandon the authentic experience of self and move into
- 41:35pretend mode. But because the experience of
- 41:41life has presented you only being able to succeed in getting
- 41:45the care you want in pretend mode and never be able to get it
- 41:51from an authentic expression, it's very frightening to attempt
- 41:58to do that. And so depending on how poor the
- 42:02foundation is for some kind of capacity for emotional
- 42:08regulation, it's very challenging to come out of
- 42:11pretend. Once you come out of pretend
- 42:15mode, what you discover, of course, is that you have this
- 42:18false self, which is very accomplished, and you have an
- 42:22authentic self that that that is, you know, a bumbling mess.
- 42:29And it feels actually so much safer to be in the false self
- 42:33than in this unskilled, untrained young authentic self.
- 42:44And sometimes you can unload the skill set from the full self to
- 42:47the authentic self, but a lot of the times you have to really
- 42:53begin to develop that experience.
- 42:59Once of course you've done it, it's totally worth doing and a
- 43:02complete no brainer. But at the beginning of it, it
- 43:05looks so difficult and the full self activity is so reliable.
- 43:13The pretend mode is so or appearing so reliable you hardly
- 43:22notice the constant sense of deprivation from never actually
- 43:26getting what you want. And half the time you don't even
- 43:29know what that is. So that that's all the early
- 43:35process of coming out of it. But then you do.
- 43:44What's a good example? Did you learn to ride a bike
- 43:48when you were a kid? And did you try to learn to ride
- 43:50a bike when you were an adult, not knowing how to ride a bike
- 43:53because you didn't learn how to ride it as a kid?
- 43:56When you fell over as a kid, basically you bounce When you
- 43:59fall over as an adult, you don't bounce so much.
- 44:06Things like that. Doable.
- 44:10It's doable and it's worth doing.
- 44:13And then how do you get people to support you to do that?
- 44:18So I think one of the reasons why the attachment community is
- 44:23nice to be involved in this because lots of people are
- 44:26trying to do that. And so you, you have a natural
- 44:30support that's available to you. Disorganized people, the main
- 44:40difficulty for them is the epistemic trust.
- 44:44So epistemic trust means that you believe somebody is telling
- 44:47you the truth, they have evidence for it, and you believe
- 44:51that the reason that they're telling you what they're telling
- 44:53you is meant to be helpful to you.
- 44:57And because disorganized people are so often exploited through
- 45:00that system, they it's very hard for them to drop the vigilance
- 45:05that would keep the attachment system active.
- 45:12And the exploration system are when attempting to move into
- 45:20support of intimate relationships, they're waiting
- 45:23for the betrayal because that's what they were used to in their
- 45:27early experience. So the process now is to develop
- 45:36a sense of the willingness to trust people and developing the
- 45:42mentalizing capacity to see that they do the things that they say
- 45:48they're going to do and they don't do the things that they
- 45:51say they're not going to do, which is one of the capacities
- 45:56of empathy, but also of mentalizing.
- 45:58Is that making sense? You did.
- 46:06So the why can't a discriminate person sort of isolate a little
- 46:10bit? I know they'd love to, but
- 46:13isolate so that they can do the exploration at least other
- 46:16things. Sure, they have to work on in
- 46:18terms of trust, but can they do the exploration in isolation?
- 46:24The danger always is, does the, is it a pseudo exploration
- 46:30that's really auto regulating and not actually an exploration
- 46:36that is engaging of the world? And the main way that I like to
- 46:42track that is are you going out and finding stuff out?
- 46:45And then are you attempting to express it to people that are
- 46:49close to you in an authentic way so that they can really see and
- 46:53understand what it is that's meaningful to you?
- 46:56And often what you find in disorganized people is that
- 47:00there there's an absence of the expression and and then that
- 47:05just becomes a kind of auto regulating activity that doesn't
- 47:10really reduce much in the way of exploration.
- 47:21So you said exploration for the world.
- 47:26The the, the the process of exploration is to go out into
- 47:31the world and discover the things that you need to know and
- 47:33then come back and express them in your social group.
- 47:41What often happens to disorganize people because they
- 47:44socially isolate to regulate, They don't actually trust
- 47:48anybody to share the the most intimate stuff.
- 47:53They engage in activities that would appear to be exploratory,
- 47:58but they're really meant to consume time and they don't lead
- 48:03to any meaningful discoveries. So exploration always needs to
- 48:11have a rebounding effect with a group.
- 48:14It cannot just be a exploration that you like to do by yourself.
- 48:18I don't think so. We don't really know who we are
- 48:31when we simply withdraw into our internal structures.
- 48:37We really know who we are through the reflection of other
- 48:40people's experience of us. And it's very hard to navigate
- 48:44meaningful exploration if you don't have the reflection of
- 48:48someone else that helps guide you toward the thing that you
- 48:52need to know. You simply get caught up in
- 48:54these internal loops. It's very easy to convince
- 48:58yourself that auto regulating is is, you know, stunning
- 49:03exploration. But if it's not commutative, it
- 49:07isn't relatable. And it really simply is this
- 49:11activity of auto regulating. So I have a friend, she loves to
- 49:16paint if she doesn't publish anything to anybody or share
- 49:20with. Nobody ever sees any of them.
- 49:23No. So it's auto regulation in that
- 49:28case. That's what I really.
- 49:30Yeah. Truly good paintings as well, so
- 49:32that's why I'm surprised. How do How do you know that your
- 49:38capacity to communicate, your discovery is possible if you
- 49:41never attempt to communicate and in the process of communicating
- 49:45it, illuminate for yourself, actually it's relevance to you,
- 49:57the whole different, a whole level of insight and
- 50:05understanding. How do you know that you've even
- 50:09understood it if it's not expressible?
- 50:16If it's not expressible. If you if you understand
- 50:21something to be one way and then you express it to someone else,
- 50:25and in the process of expressing and their reaction, you have
- 50:28insight into whether that understanding is actually
- 50:32accurate or not, how do you know otherwise?
- 50:38Oh, if the other person doesn't. Oh, what they reflect back to is
- 50:44another angle to look at what is happening, how easy it is to get
- 50:50lost in your own instructions, how easy it is to misinterpret
- 50:58or misunderstand. Pretty damn easy, Christian.
- 51:09George, what you're saying follows with exploration, but
- 51:11I'm curious. I mean, I know there's like
- 51:15there's a songa and, and it's not as totally solitary
- 51:18activity, but meditation itself is pretty internal.
- 51:22Like so much of it that's happening can be very
- 51:25interesting, but it's happening very internally.
- 51:28So unless you're like, unless you're having like battles where
- 51:33you're like throwing attainments at at people or something, like
- 51:36how much of that can you really communicate to others?
- 51:40So I'm kind of curious about your thoughts on how meditation
- 51:42fits in that in that framework. Well, I think that at a certain
- 51:46point, if you're going to make a lot of progress and you're going
- 51:49to know what to do in terms of your practice, it's good to have
- 51:52a teacher that you can express what the experience of your
- 51:55practice is so that they can reflect it back to you.
- 51:58I think that's a very good example.
- 52:01How do you know which insights are worth pursuing and which
- 52:08ones are not? And if you don't have a teacher,
- 52:13what ends up happening for most people is you end up pursuing
- 52:16insights that aren't valuable in terms of the pursuit of
- 52:19liberation. And so you go in these side
- 52:23directions that just consume the energy of practice.
- 52:27Whereas if you have a teacher, they can help guide you through
- 52:31that maze of stuff that comes up.
- 52:34You have a a more direct path to liberation than you might at a
- 52:41certain point beyond the beginning.
- 52:44If you want to go into the intermediate or advanced
- 52:47practices, you need to find a teacher who you can relate to or
- 52:51you can't find your way. So that's it.
- 52:56And then also, if we use the ideal parent figure protocol as
- 52:59an example, you are encouraged to go into the protocol and
- 53:05simply express what's coming up for you.
- 53:07And you have the facilitator who's interpreting the way that
- 53:12you create the experiences of reality from an attachment lens,
- 53:16that if you create a version of reality that isn't in the in
- 53:22what would be considered a secure path, you're redirected
- 53:26toward the secure path. So that process is, is the same
- 53:30process that I'm talking about in the other aspect of it.
- 53:37That makes sense. We've talked for a long time and
- 53:43didn't leave much time for meditation.
- 53:45So we just do 30 minutes or so of love and kindness practice.
- 53:54All right, let go of the meditation.
- 54:00How's that? So tomorrow actually we have a
- 54:07class, level 2 class starting on Friday mornings, 10:30 to 12:30.
- 54:16We haven't done a level tour. That's interesting if you
- 54:18consider it. We have a 1/2 day long on
- 54:23exploration at the end of the month and then we have one in
- 54:29October. So there's two of them.
- 54:32One is the basic concept of exploration and then I thought
- 54:35that I would talk about exploration through the lens of
- 54:41making the photographs that I make so that it's more hands on
- 54:45and that way. What else?
- 54:54That's about it. That's coming up right away.
- 54:57Most of that's on the website, so take a look at it.
- 55:00Ioffer the teaching freely. But I do hope that if you're
- 55:02able to support myself and Medigroup through a donation and
- 55:06which you can do on the website, that's really appreciated.
- 55:10Any amount help support me and also the work we do and
- 55:13Medigroup. Thank you for your practice and
- 55:16I will see you soon.