Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Michael Burry Exposed The Tragic Algebra of a $1.7 Trillion Market Illusion
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to this deep dive. Today is April 29, 2026 and we
- 0:05are unpacking what I can only describe as a complete financial
- 0:08bombshell that just dropped on the market.
- 0:10Yeah, bombshell's definitely the right word for it.
- 0:12It's it's massive. Right.
- 0:15So Michael Bury, the investor who, you know, famously
- 0:17predicted the 2008 housing crash.
- 0:20Played by Christian Bale in the Big Short.
- 0:21By exactly that guy. Well, he just released the 66
- 0:25page paper with frankly, a very dry title.
- 0:27It's called APSC, the tragic recurrence.
- 0:31But the premise of this paper is completely mind bending.
- 0:34Bury's claiming that $1.7 trillion of the NASDAQ 100
- 0:38supposed earnings over the last 10 years might be, well a
- 0:42complete illusion it. Is a staggering claim.
- 0:44I mean, it challenges the very foundation of how we value
- 0:47modern tech companies today. He is essentially auditing a
- 0:50decade of corporate financial statements to expose an
- 0:53accounting convention that is, you know, gone mostly unchecked.
- 0:56OK, let's unpack this. Our mission for this deep dive
- 0:59is to audit Bury's math on 97 of the top tech companies in the
- 1:03world. We're going to look at how a
- 1:05seemingly harmless practice called stock based compensation
- 1:10is quietly draining the market. Yeah, the silent drain.
- 1:13Right. And most importantly, we need to
- 1:16figure out what this $1.7 trillion illusion means for you,
- 1:20the listener, especially if you're one of the, I don't know,
- 1:22millions of investors holding passive index funds in your
- 1:25retirement account. Absolutely, but before we jump
- 1:28into the math, we have some ground rules and resources for
- 1:30this financial deep dive to access more advanced researches,
- 1:33applications and our latest published personal intelligent
- 1:36multi agent Deep value intelligence.
- 1:38Welcome to explore and join the deep values dot AI community to
- 1:42track total market temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 1:45the iOS app Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 1:48Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 1:52and may be subject to revisions or different interpretations.
- 1:55All contents from this channel is for educational and research
- 1:58purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 2:02Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 2:05decisions if you like to access wider topics including life and
- 2:09AYA. I am going to stop us right
- 2:11there before we drift into the mysteries of life, but I
- 2:14appreciate the thoroughness. Fair enough.
- 2:17We we have a $1.7 trillion mystery to solve first, right?
- 2:21So to understand Bury's massive warning, we have to look at the
- 2:25specific accounting trick that makes this illusion possible.
- 2:28Mechanics of it. Exactly.
- 2:29And the best way I can describe the mindset of Wall Street's
- 2:33quote UN quote adjusted earnings is that it's, well, it's a lot
- 2:37like a Dieter who decides liquid calories simply don't count.
- 2:40Oh, that's a great way to put it.
- 2:41Right, like the market tracks every operational expense, you
- 2:45know, every paper clip, every desk chair.
- 2:47But then they just down 1000 calorie milkshake of employee
- 2:50stock options and say well I drank it so my body doesn't
- 2:53process it as food. Yeah, that captures the
- 2:55psychology perfectly. I mean when companies pay their
- 2:58employees with shares of stock instead of handing them cash
- 3:01which is known as stock based compensation or ABC, they they
- 3:06treat it as if no actual value left the building.
- 3:09Which is crazy to think about. It is Wall Street universally
- 3:12adds this expense back to their net income they reported to the
- 3:16public as adjusted earnings or non GAAP earnings.
- 3:19But just because a company prints new shares to pay people
- 3:22instead of, you know, handing them dollar bills out of the
- 3:25vault, it doesn't mean the actual costs disappear.
- 3:28No, the calories are still there.
- 3:29Right. If we look at the physical
- 3:31mechanism of dilution, it's more like ordering a large pizza.
- 3:36If I own half that pizza and the company hires a new engineer,
- 3:40instead of paying that engineer from the cash register,
- 3:43management just slices my half of the pizza into thinner and
- 3:45thinner pieces to feed the new hire.
- 3:47Exactly. The physical pizza didn't get
- 3:49any bigger, but suddenly my share of the pie is
- 3:52significantly smaller. And that shrinking slice of the
- 3:55pie is exactly what Bury set out to measure on a macroeconomic
- 3:58scale. He didn't just, you know, write
- 4:01an opinion piece here. No, he brought the receipts.
- 4:03He really did. He and his team downloaded the
- 4:06audited 10K filings for 97 companies in the NASA Q 100.
- 4:11Yeah, he excluded 4 of them strictly for technical reasons
- 4:16like foreign currency conversions, meaning he
- 4:18practically audited the entire index over a full 10 year
- 4:21period. He wanted to compare the fantasy
- 4:24numbers against the strict legal reality.
- 4:26OK, we should define that reality for a second because we
- 4:28hear the term gap all the time. Generally Accepted Accounting
- 4:31Principles that is the standardized rulebook created
- 4:35after the Great Depression to stop companies from lying to
- 4:38investors. It's the strictly audited legal
- 4:41foundation of corporate reporting.
- 4:43The. Bedrock of the system.
- 4:44Exactly. Non GAAP on the other hand is
- 4:46basically a choose your own adventure novel where management
- 4:49just gets to decide which expenses they feel like
- 4:52ignoring. Yeah, and the gap between those
- 4:542 is where Bury focuses. When you look at the strict gap
- 4:57numbers over that 10 year period, the actual reported net
- 5:00income for those 97 companies was $4.9 trillion.
- 5:04OK, $4.9 trillion. Got it.
- 5:07But Wall Street's adjusted earnings, you know, the inflated
- 5:10diet logic numbers they sell to the public, claimed $5.8
- 5:14trillion. That is a huge difference.
- 5:17It is, but Bury takes it a step further, though.
- 5:19He calculates what he calls the true owner's earnings.
- 5:22Earnings, right? This means looking at what is
- 5:25actually left for the shareholders after you account
- 5:28for the real physical cost of printing those shares and the
- 5:31cash required to manage them. When you do that, the profit
- 5:34drops to just $4.1 trillion. OK.
- 5:36Wow, that is the big reveal right there.
- 5:38Wall Street is boasting about $5.8 trillion in profit on CNBC
- 5:42and all the financial news networks, but the actual
- 5:45tangible money left for the people who own the stock is only
- 5:48$4.1 trillion. So there is your $1.7 trillion
- 5:52gap. I mean, for every dollar of
- 5:54audited gap earnings reported, you, the listener, the
- 5:57shareholder, you only actually keep 83.49 cents.
- 6:01The rest just evaporates into the corporate machinery to
- 6:03sustain employee compensation. Which fundamentally warps how we
- 6:08value the entire market. I mean, think about the forward
- 6:10PE ratio, the price to earnings multiple of the nasty Q 100.
- 6:15It's constantly quoted by analysts as being around 30
- 6:17times earnings. Right, which is already pretty
- 6:19high. Right.
- 6:20But when you apply Bury's owner's earnings math, the
- 6:23multiple jumps to 42.5 times earnings.
- 6:26We are looking at one of the most expensive stock markets in
- 6:29the history of global finance masquerading as a, you know, a
- 6:33totally reasonable one. This raises an important
- 6:36question though. If 16.5% of the intrinsic value
- 6:40of these companies is just silently walking out the door
- 6:42every single year, how long until the math just breaks?
- 6:46That's the billion dollar. Question, right?
- 6:47And to see the stress fractures, we have to move from the broad
- 6:50index and zoom in on the most important case study in Bury's
- 6:53entire paper, which is NVIDIA. Yeah, this is where it gets
- 6:56real. Because this shows how the
- 6:58accounting trick operates at the absolute highest level.
- 7:00Exactly. NVIDIA serves as the perfect
- 7:03laboratory for this dynamic because of a very public
- 7:07financial to maneuver they executed in early 2026.
- 7:10Now I'm actually going to push back on Bury here for a second
- 7:13and defend NVIDIA. Oh really?
- 7:15Yeah, because I think stock based compensation is entirely
- 7:18necessary. Look, if I am running NVIDIA, I
- 7:21am competing with Google, Meta and Open AI for the absolute top
- 7:261% of AI engineers in the world. Right, the talent war.
- 7:29Exactly. I cannot just hand them a base
- 7:31salary. I have to offer them equity to
- 7:33align their incentives with the company's growth.
- 7:36It is the core engine of Silicon Valley innovation.
- 7:39That's true. Furthermore, NVIDIA announced a
- 7:41massive $40.1 billion stock buyback in fiscal 2026.
- 7:45The CFO, Colette Kress, was cheered by the financial press
- 7:49for this. They called it a capital return
- 7:50bonanza. As an investor, if a company is
- 7:53buying back $40 billion of its own stock, taking shares off the
- 7:57open market, that makes my slice of the pizza bigger, How is that
- 8:00a negative? Well, your premise about
- 8:02attracting top tier talent is totally correct.
- 8:05Silicon Valley absolutely relies on equity to build the
- 8:08technology, but the flaw isn't how investors are told to
- 8:12account for the cost of that. Talent.
- 8:13OK, explain that. Let's break down the actual cash
- 8:16flow of that $40.1 billion buyback you just mentioned.
- 8:19Let's do it. When Bury audited the cash flow
- 8:21statement, he found that $15.5 billion that buyback wasn't
- 8:26returning capital to shareholders to make your slice
- 8:29of the pizza bigger. Wait, then what was it doing?
- 8:31It was spent entirely on the open market just to offset the
- 8:34dilution of the employee stock they had already printed.
- 8:36Oh. Wow.
- 8:37So the company printed millions of new shares to attract those
- 8:40top tier engineers, and then had to take $15.5 billion of actual
- 8:44cash out of the corporate treasury to buy shares back
- 8:47simply to ensure the total share count didn't explode.
- 8:50Precisely they are. Running on an extraordinarily
- 8:53expensive treadmill just to stay in the exact same place.
- 8:56And that treadmill has another massive hidden cost that people
- 9:00don't talk about. Bury found that another $7.3
- 9:04billion went straight to the IRA.
- 9:06OK, walk us through the mechanism of that IRS payment
- 9:09because I think a lot of people, myself included, sometimes
- 9:11assume stock options are just paper transactions until the
- 9:15employee eventually sells them on an app like E*Trade.
- 9:19Why is the company paying the IRS in cash?
- 9:22Right, so when an employee's restricted stock units vest, the
- 9:25US government views that as taxable income subject to
- 9:28standard withholding taxes. Sure.
- 9:30The employee doesn't usually write a check to the government,
- 9:32though. Instead, the company withholds a
- 9:35portion of those vested share to cover the employee's tax
- 9:37liability. But the IRS obviously doesn't
- 9:41accept payment in NVIDIA stock. You want dollars?
- 9:43They require U.S. dollars, so the company has to take hard
- 9:46cold cash out of its own bank account and remit it to the
- 9:50federal government on the employee's behalf.
- 9:52Man, that's wild. It drains the company's actual
- 9:54class reserves, and it hits a line item in the financing
- 9:57section of the cash flow statement that casual investors
- 10:00rarely check. The math on that is STAG you
- 10:03have $15.5 billion going out the door to stop the dilution, plus
- 10:08$7.3 billion going to the IRS for taxes.
- 10:11That is $22.8 billion walking out of the treasury.
- 10:15But NVIDIA reported their GAP stock based compensation expense
- 10:19on the income statement as only $6.4 billion.
- 10:22Yeah, that discrepancy is the core of Barry's thesis.
- 10:26The reported expense is $6.4 billion, the true drain on the
- 10:30Treasury. The actual cash required to
- 10:32manage the compensation program was $22.8 billion.
- 10:36That is insane. It's nearly 3 1/2 times larger
- 10:39than what shows up on the headline earnings report.
- 10:40And what's crazy is that when NVIDIA announced that $40
- 10:43billion buyback management explicitly stated they were
- 10:46going to start including stock based compensation and their
- 10:49adjusted earnings moving into fiscal 2027, they framed it as
- 10:52total transparency. Right, they made a big deal out
- 10:54of it. But they're only planning to
- 10:56include that $6.4 billion accounting figure, totally
- 10:59ignoring the $22.8 billion cash reality.
- 11:02Yes, and to be incredibly clear on this point, Bury is not
- 11:05claiming the AI revolution is fake.
- 11:08He is not disputing the explosive demand for their
- 11:10chips. Of course not.
- 11:11He is arguing that the earnings quality is fundamentally
- 11:14distorted. NVIDIA can afford a $22.8
- 11:18billion drain right now because their profit margins on AI
- 11:22hardware are just astronomical. It barely registers against
- 11:26their massive revenue. What happens when that changes?
- 11:28Exactly the second that growth normalizes when the hardware
- 11:31cycle peaks and margins compress, the fragility of those
- 11:35earnings becomes a severe structural risk to the stock
- 11:37price. Which naturally, leads to the
- 11:39next phase of Bury's argument. If an absolute juggernaut like
- 11:43NVIDIA is having to Sprint on a $22 billion treadmill just to
- 11:46maintain its footing, what happens to the companies in the
- 11:49index that do not have astronomical profit margins to
- 11:52hide the cost of their compensation programs?
- 11:55Well, they collapse under the weight of their own share
- 11:57structure. Bury isolated a specific group
- 11:59of nine companies within the NASDAQ Q 100, that he refers to
- 12:02as the tragic tier. Here's where it gets really
- 12:05interesting. Who is in this tragic tier?
- 12:07The list includes Tesla, Palantir, Crowdstrike, Datadog,
- 12:11Axon, Work Day Z Scaler, Shopify, and Marvel.
- 12:15I mean these are some of the most popular high flying tech
- 12:18darlings of the last few years. Why single out these 9?
- 12:22Because for these specific companies, the real cash cost of
- 12:26their stock based compensation doesn't just cut into their
- 12:29profit margins, it completely exceeds their cumulative gap net
- 12:32income. Wait, really?
- 12:34Yes, yeah. And we aren't looking at a
- 12:36single bad quarter or a tough macro year here.
- 12:39We are looking at the entire 10 year measurement period of the
- 12:43audit. OK, let's slow down and look at
- 12:45the aggregate scale of this wealth destruction over 10
- 12:48years. If you look at the official
- 12:50legal filings for these nine companies, they reported about
- 12:53$42 billion in cumulative gap net income.
- 12:57That is the profit they legally declared to the world.
- 12:59On paper, yes, right. But when you synthesize Barry's
- 13:02data and subtract the true economic cost of that stock
- 13:05based compensation, factoring in the constant dilution, the
- 13:08mandatory tax payments to the IRS, and the buybacks required
- 13:11just to tread water, their true owners earnings plunged to -267
- 13:16billion dollars. -267 billion dollars.
- 13:19We are talking about an accounting convention that
- 13:21allows management to pretend 1/4 trillion dollars of wealth
- 13:25destruction simply didn't happen.
- 13:26It's remarkable. It highlights how a booming
- 13:29stock price can mask deeply flawed business fundamentals.
- 13:32Yeah. I mean, if we look at the
- 13:34biggest name on that list, Tesla, the distortion it creates
- 13:38is profound. Let's talk about Tesla.
- 13:40Removing just Tesla from the NASDAQ Q 100 drops the aggregate
- 13:45overstatement of the entire index from 19.78% down to
- 13:4912.52%. That is wild.
- 13:52That means one single company is responsible for more than 7% of
- 13:55the earnings illusion for the top 100 non financial companies
- 13:59in the country. And that data is calculated
- 14:01before factoring in Elon Musk's staggering $1 trillion pay
- 14:05package that was approved in November 2025.
- 14:08Exactly. If that package fully vests, it
- 14:10overwhelms the entire data set. The dilution from that single
- 14:13event would dwarf any previous compensation package in
- 14:15corporate history. It changes the math for the
- 14:18entire market. It really forces investors to
- 14:20ask who the company's actually being run for, you know, is it
- 14:24for the external shareholders who provide the capital or the
- 14:27internal employees and executives who extract it?
- 14:31And here is why you, listening to this right now, need to care
- 14:35about the tragic tier. You might assume you're
- 14:38insulated from this because hey, maybe you don't day trade
- 14:40individual stocks. Right.
- 14:42You think you're safe? You consider yourself a prudent
- 14:44investor who just buys the QQQ ETF, the most popular passive
- 14:49index fund for the NASA Q 100. But that passive strategy is
- 14:53exactly the trap Bury is highlighting.
- 14:56It's a huge blind spot. If you own the QQQ, you own all
- 14:59nine of these companies at their full market cap weight.
- 15:02You cannot carve them out every time a portion of your paycheck
- 15:05automatically goes into your retirement account.
- 15:07You are blindly buying shares regardless of the underlying
- 15:10valuation. You are passively funding a
- 15:12direct wealth transfer from your savings account into the pockets
- 15:16of tech employees. And passive investing relies on
- 15:18the assumption that active market participants are setting
- 15:21rational prices. But when trillions of dollars
- 15:24flow blindly into ETFs, those flows become completely price
- 15:28insensitive. They just keep buying.
- 15:30Exactly, they push the market higher, which pushes the value
- 15:33of the stock based compensation higher, which allows management
- 15:36to extract even more value without anywhere looking closely
- 15:40at the plumbing. Furry has clearly laid out this
- 15:43tragic algebra, and the math is horrifying, but he doesn't just
- 15:47write academic papers. No, he puts his money where his
- 15:49mouth is. Right, we have to look at his
- 15:51actual real money execution because three days after the
- 15:55paper dropped on April 10th, 2026, he posted what he calls
- 15:59his Trading Post update. Right, he transitioned from
- 16:02macro theory to active market positioning.
- 16:04He disclosed that he is heavily shorting NVIDIA.
- 16:07He purchased the January 2027 Expiration 115 dollar strike put
- 16:12options. He paid a premium of $3.30 per
- 16:15contract for them, and he's stacking those on top of $100
- 16:18strike puts he already owned for that exact same expiration.
- 16:21That's a massive, concentrated position.
- 16:23He is making a direct leveraged bet that Nvidia's stock price is
- 16:29going to crash well below $115.00 a share by early 2027.
- 16:33He also confirmed his short position against Palantir, which
- 16:36is one of the tragic tier companies we just talked about.
- 16:38He is holding 2 tranches of put options against them.
- 16:41And actually, there was a significant media frenzy earlier
- 16:44this year regarding this specific trade that we really
- 16:47need to clarify. Oh yeah, the headline numbers.
- 16:49Right financial outlets were reporting that Burry had taken
- 16:52out a $912 million short position against Palantir.
- 16:55I remember seeing those headlines.
- 16:57A billion dollar bet against a single tech company sounds
- 17:00incredibly reckless for an investor known for deep value
- 17:03analysis. Right, it sounds totally out of
- 17:05character. But looking at the actual
- 17:07filing, the media completely confused the notional value of
- 17:10the contracts with the premium paid.
- 17:12Classic mistake. The notional value is just what
- 17:15the underlying shares would be worth if he controlled them
- 17:17outright. But the beauty of options
- 17:19contracts is they let you control those shares for a tiny
- 17:22fraction of the cost. The actual cash he put on the
- 17:26table, the premium he paid, which is his maximum theoretical
- 17:29loss, was only $9.2 million. Precisely.
- 17:33The media saw the total share volume and printed $912 million
- 17:38to generate clicks, but his actual capital at risk is less
- 17:41than $10 million. Big difference.
- 17:43Huge. It is a textbook asymmetric bet.
- 17:46He is risking a highly controlled, relatively small
- 17:49downside for an absolutely enormous payout if his thesis
- 17:52plays out and the stock price collapses to reflect its true
- 17:55cash flow. And the timeline of that
- 17:57Palantir trade is fascinating. The stock is already down about
- 18:0036% from its November 2025 peak. Recently, Donald Trump posted on
- 18:05Truth Social praising Palantir's military and war fighting
- 18:08capabilities, which, you know, caused the stock to briefly
- 18:11bounce on the retail hype. Right, a temporary surge.
- 18:13But Bury refused to sell into that bounce.
- 18:15He held his put options. He is completely convicted that
- 18:18the floor is going to fall out. If we connect this to the bigger
- 18:21picture, his conviction comes from the structural reality of
- 18:24exponential decay. OK, unpack that.
- 18:27Well, the broader market focuses on the $1.7 trillion aggregate
- 18:30number, but the real danger is how that wealth extraction
- 18:33compounds over time. We discussed earlier that the
- 18:36shareholder retention rate is roughly 83.49 cents on the
- 18:40dollar, with the rest walking out the door to pay employees.
- 18:43Right, that 16.5% annual extraction.
- 18:46Exactly. That extraction does not
- 18:48compound linearly. If a company continues that
- 18:51aggressive stock based compensation regime at its
- 18:54current pace, the math dictates that after five years, the
- 18:58shareholder retains about 58% of the company's intrinsic value.
- 19:01OK, Ouch. After 10 years it drops to 16.5%
- 19:05and over a 20 year horizon a shareholder retains a
- 19:08microscopic 2.7% of the intrinsic value of the business.
- 19:12Wait 2.7%? That is genuinely shocking.
- 19:14Over 2 decades, 97% of your investment's true value is
- 19:18silently transferred to someone else through dilution and tax
- 19:21obligations, all while the headline earnings look
- 19:23fantastic. Yeah, it's brutal.
- 19:25Which perfectly explains why Burry is completely
- 19:28restructuring his long portfolio.
- 19:30He is pulling his capital out of American mega cap tech companies
- 19:34and funneling it into the assets the broader market is currently
- 19:37terrified of, Chinese e-commerce platforms, global payment
- 19:41technology, and distressed retail turnarounds.
- 19:45His guiding philosophy is that the most lucrative opportunities
- 19:48are hidden in the things people irrationally fear, while the
- 19:51most dangerous value destroying traps are the very things
- 19:54everyone blindly and passively loves.
- 19:56So what does this all mean for us?
- 19:58We have covered a massive amount of ground today.
- 20:01We started with a 66 page paper from a legendary investor and we
- 20:05ended up auditing the actual cash flows of the most powerful
- 20:08tech companies on earth. It's a lot to take in.
- 20:11It is, but the key take away is that this is not a vague
- 20:13doomsday prophecy based on market sentiment.
- 20:16It is an objective audit of 10 years of publicly available
- 20:19legal filings. The gap between Wall Street's
- 20:22earnings illusion and the actual cash reality is $1.7 trillion.
- 20:27The math doesn't lie. The treadmill of share dilution
- 20:29and IRS tax payments is accelerating, and based on the
- 20:33specific expiration dates of Bury's options contracts, he is
- 20:36betting his own money that the bill is finally coming due in
- 20:39late 2026 and early 2027. It is the ultimate staring
- 20:44contest between audited arithmetic and a shared market
- 20:47hallucination. But you know, it leaves you with
- 20:49one final critical question to ponder.
- 20:53What's that? Michael Bury was absolutely
- 20:55right about the mathematical inevitability of the 2008
- 20:57housing crash. Yet he was painfully early.
- 21:00He sat on mounting losses and endured immense pressure for
- 21:03almost three years before the subprime mortgage trade finally
- 21:06paid off. Right, he almost lost his fund
- 21:08waiting for. It exactly so, if his math
- 21:10regarding this $1.7 trillion illusion is indisputable today.
- 21:14But the $30 trillion market is currently operating entirely on
- 21:17passive autopilot, with money blindly flowing into index funds
- 21:20every single week. What exactly is the catalyst
- 21:23that forces the system to stop ignoring the liquid calories and
- 21:26finally look at the true scale?