Latest / Stacking The Box, a Football Podcast / 2026 NFL Awards: Our BOLD MVP Picks & Best Bets 👀
Transcript
- 0:03[SPEAKER_01]: on me, Jack.
- 0:03[SPEAKER_01]: I have fans sat in here with NFL expert Marcus Mosher and work about to do one of our favorite shows today.
- 0:10[SPEAKER_01]: And that is predicting the NFL awards for the 20, 20, 60s.
- 0:14[SPEAKER_01]: And this is something we did last year.
- 0:16[SPEAKER_01]: We got a few requests for it, Marcus.
- 0:18[SPEAKER_01]: And we're also going to give our best bets as well.
- 0:20[SPEAKER_01]: It should be a fun show.
- 0:22[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and one of the reasons why we get a lot of requests for this show is we typically have been pretty good at at least mentioning some of the players who end up winning these awards.
- 0:31[SPEAKER_00]: And I think last year our best call was Carson Swesinger to win the defensive rookie of the year.
- 0:37[SPEAKER_00]: That obviously came true.
- 0:38[SPEAKER_00]: We talked about Drake May and Matt Stafford as potential candidates.
- 0:42[SPEAKER_00]: I've got some sleeper, this is how to make excited to talk about, so let's get right into it.
- 0:46[SPEAKER_01]: All right, so let's dive right in with the most valuable player, word last year, came down to two guys, Drake, May, Matthew, Stafford, who ultimately got it.
- 0:54[SPEAKER_01]: You and I voted on the athlete, one awards, we're going to reprise those roles again this year.
- 0:59[SPEAKER_01]: Stafford, well-deserving season, we know that it doesn't always necessarily go to the
- 1:04[SPEAKER_01]: faster, most dominant player.
- 1:06[SPEAKER_01]: Last year, you could argue it did.
- 1:08[SPEAKER_01]: Sometimes it's like, all right, this guy got it this year and maybe they're going to give it to somebody else, the following year because of the fact they didn't want to give this like Lamar Jackson in 2024 when he had 41 touchdowns and four interceptions and 915 rushing yards.
- 1:21[SPEAKER_01]: Like, there's debate here for sure.
- 1:24[SPEAKER_01]: And it comes down to how the AP voters are thinking on this.
- 1:28[SPEAKER_01]: But let's go ahead and you go ahead and give your MVP, I'll give mine and we'll give our best bet.
- 1:34[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, this has become a narrative based award.
- 1:36[SPEAKER_00]: And really, it's become a team award as well.
- 1:39[SPEAKER_00]: We just don't have very many MVP winners that are on teams that don't win 11, 12, 13 games last year.
- 1:46[SPEAKER_00]: Think about the Rams, I think, went 13 and 4.
- 1:49[SPEAKER_00]: Matt Stafford ultimately won it.
- 1:51[SPEAKER_00]: We had the Patriots who went 14 and 3.
- 1:54[SPEAKER_00]: Drake may finish second.
- 1:56[SPEAKER_00]: You kind of need your team to be really good to even be in consideration
- 2:00[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why I like Brock Perti at 18 to 1 right now, the narrative around the 49ers is this team is in disarray right now right George kiddo coming back from a torn Achilles Ricky Pierce all out for the year Christian Kirk is banged up Mike Evans has a hamstring injury struggling has already been dealing with a hamstring injury Christian McCaffrey's got some soreness Colisey and a hand was involved in a serious car accident.
- 2:25[SPEAKER_00]: If the 49ers win 11 or 12 games again this year and Brock party puts up the type of numbers that Brock party typically does in a Kyle Shanahan offense, I still see anyway that he's at least not part of the discussion.
- 2:38[SPEAKER_00]: And again, 18 and one, I just think that's a good value.
- 2:41[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I love it for a best bet.
- 2:42[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, you're talking plus 1800 odds here for a guy who routinely puts up good numbers when he is healthy regardless of how The state of his team is around him because he's dealt with a lot of adversity when it's come to injuries to his skill players and he's going to again, unfortunately, I think this year.
- 2:58[SPEAKER_01]: And so I like that bet a lot now my MVP.
- 3:04[SPEAKER_01]: Just going on, let me give you my prediction first of all, and then I'll say where I think the money should go.
- 3:09[SPEAKER_01]: Josh Allen, it's going to be the front runner for MVP for me this season.
- 3:14[SPEAKER_01]: You look at last year, Drake May was up there ahead of him in the voting.
- 3:19[SPEAKER_01]: The Patriots are not going to be 14 and 3 this year again.
- 3:24[SPEAKER_01]: The bills are going to be in it every single year.
- 3:28[SPEAKER_01]: Josh Allen is routinely the most dominant player in football.
- 3:32[SPEAKER_01]: He's the one that you can count on more than you can count on Lamar Jackson, the Joe Burrow, Patrick Mahomes coming off in ACL, very much doubt that it goes back to Stafford, back to back seasons.
- 3:43[SPEAKER_01]: They just tend to not really go that route very often.
- 3:46[SPEAKER_01]: I think the Josh Allen puts up other worldly numbers.
- 3:49[SPEAKER_01]: I think that he is the MVP.
- 3:50[SPEAKER_01]: Now, where I would go with this bet, however, would be your guy, DAC Prescott.
- 3:56[SPEAKER_01]: We're talking about a guy who has had over 400 completions in his last two healthy seasons, which led the NFL, by the way, 2023, 2025, 20, 20, 20, 40, obviously, missed time, 4,500, passing yards last year.
- 4:10[SPEAKER_01]: And that was without CDLAM for three and a half games.
- 4:13[SPEAKER_01]: DAC is going to be there.
- 4:17[SPEAKER_01]: 500 recorder better and I think that that's going to be enough if they get into the playoffs and I think that they'll at least grab one of those spots this year I think that's going to be enough to put back in that conversation and maybe we see a 40 touchdown 5,000 yard season I don't think that's out of the realm of possibility considering how good his receivers are Dak is going to put up numbers.
- 4:36[SPEAKER_00]: I just I have my doubts that the cowboys are going to win enough games for him to be part of that conversation
- 4:46[SPEAKER_00]: a similar situation.
- 4:47[SPEAKER_00]: It's Jordan love who is right now 20 to one to win the award.
- 4:51[SPEAKER_00]: I think the defense is going to struggle early on for Green Bay and that's going to put a lot of pressure on Jordan love to put up some big numbers and we know that he can and they've got a good receiving core.
- 5:01[SPEAKER_00]: We think this is going to be a good offense.
- 5:03[SPEAKER_00]: If Green Bay can win 11, 12 games, if they can win the NFC North,
- 5:08[SPEAKER_00]: and Jordan love has 35 or so touchdowns.
- 5:11[SPEAKER_00]: I think he's at least going to be part of the conversation.
- 5:14[SPEAKER_00]: He's certainly good enough to win this award.
- 5:17[SPEAKER_00]: And I think he's a good value here.
- 5:18[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, to plus 2,000 odds, the value is certainly there for love.
- 5:22[SPEAKER_01]: I would throw another name out here too, and I'm interested to see what you have to say about it.
- 5:26[SPEAKER_01]: But Justin Herbert, plus 1,000.
- 5:29[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, he's 10 to 1 odds here.
- 5:31[SPEAKER_01]: It's not a tremendous payout.
- 5:32[SPEAKER_01]: We're talking about a guy that's got might make Daniel now
- 5:37[SPEAKER_01]: Is this a guy, and then just go back to his second season, and then he's the guy through for 38 touchdown passes, 40, 400 yards, like Herbert, all the talent is there.
- 5:46[SPEAKER_01]: He didn't have an offensive line.
- 5:47[SPEAKER_01]: He still managed to produce good numbers last year.
- 5:50[SPEAKER_01]: Is this any, any bet that you would be interested in?
- 5:54[SPEAKER_00]: Probably not.
- 5:54[SPEAKER_00]: Just because I think that division is going to be too hard.
- 5:56[SPEAKER_00]: And I just don't see the chargers winning it.
- 5:59[SPEAKER_00]: And I,
- 6:00[SPEAKER_00]: I think Herbert's going to have a really nice season.
- 6:03[SPEAKER_00]: I just have some concerns that voters aren't going to give just in Herbert the benefit of the doubt.
- 6:08[SPEAKER_00]: And less they win the division and win 13 or 14 games.
- 6:11[SPEAKER_01]: All right.
- 6:12[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that makes sense.
- 6:12[SPEAKER_01]: I think that odds are these AP voters are going to go with division winners here.
- 6:18[SPEAKER_01]: So keep that in mind.
- 6:19[SPEAKER_01]: Let's move in shift gears to the offensive player of the year here, Marcus.
- 6:24[SPEAKER_01]: And I can go first this time and you can follow up here.
- 6:27[SPEAKER_01]: I really like Jamar Chase.
- 6:30[SPEAKER_01]: I really like Jamar Chase.
- 6:31[SPEAKER_01]: It's not necessarily the best when it comes to the potential payout here.
- 6:36[SPEAKER_01]: It's plus 1,000, but Chase is a guy who has had 1,700 yards in 1,400 yards as last year's season.
- 6:43[SPEAKER_01]: Last year, starting quarterback Joe Burrow missed half the year, and he's still managed to have a 1,400 yard year.
- 6:50[SPEAKER_01]: former offensive rookie of the year.
- 6:51[SPEAKER_01]: He's been a proble or an every single season that he's played in.
- 6:55[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like he is overdue for an offensive player the year award and he's certainly had the production that's justified one at some point in rather in his career.
- 7:05[SPEAKER_01]: So even if he doesn't have a career season, I think that Jamar Chase could get it by having his second or even third best season of his career, he could earn enough votes.
- 7:15[SPEAKER_00]: Honestly, that was the name that I was going to go with as well.
- 7:17[SPEAKER_00]: Just because he's going to be in the offense.
- 7:19[SPEAKER_00]: It's throwing the ball all the time.
- 7:20[SPEAKER_00]: We know that he's got the pedigree.
- 7:22[SPEAKER_00]: He's got the track record and it was quarterback can stay healthy.
- 7:25[SPEAKER_00]: Like he's a legitimate threat to scored 20 touchdowns this year.
- 7:29[SPEAKER_00]: And I know that hasn't been done very often in NFL history.
- 7:32[SPEAKER_00]: But he's that good.
- 7:34[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why he has the best odds of any receiver.
- 7:37[SPEAKER_00]: Now, we should mention, Jimmy or Gibbs V. John Robinson.
- 7:39[SPEAKER_00]: Both of those guys are higher.
- 7:41[SPEAKER_00]: They're just going to accumulate so many yards from skirmish that it might be overwhelming in their favor, but if I had to pick a one long shot here a little bit, I would look at a mon Ross ain't brown, he's just so wildly consistent in that Detroit offense.
- 7:58[SPEAKER_00]: and if he could lead the NFL in receptions and get to 120, 125, catch double the touchdowns, I think he'll at least be in the conversation.
- 8:06[SPEAKER_00]: Just like JSN was last year for the C-Ox after having his spike year, I think Amand Rossate Brown is a pretty good value at 25 to 1.
- 8:14[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and I really dove into these as well, and I don't know if I would go any lower than that, but I do like the gamble on St. Brown at 25 to 1 there.
- 8:23[SPEAKER_01]: But I really feel like this is one of those lists that's going to come from one of the guys atop Gibbs, Bizon Robinson, Jamar Chase.
- 8:30[SPEAKER_01]: Those are like the big three in that running.
- 8:32[SPEAKER_01]: Puka could do it again, Justin Jefferson could have a resurgence.
- 8:36[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, I like St. Brown there as well.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_01]: Gives would probably be my
- 8:41[SPEAKER_01]: If I'm not going with Chase, probably be my second favorite overall just to flat out when the award.
- 8:48[SPEAKER_01]: Let's move over to the defensive player of the year.
- 8:50[SPEAKER_01]: And, man, I feel like this can come down to a two-man race quite honestly, but what do you have to say about DPOI?
- 8:57[SPEAKER_01]: And if there's a long shot that you would actually take here over the top guys.
- 9:01[SPEAKER_00]: There is, but I think you're right.
- 9:02[SPEAKER_00]: It is really to me a two-man race.
- 9:04[SPEAKER_00]: And it's Miles Gare and William or Sidney.
- 9:06[SPEAKER_00]: And,
- 9:07[SPEAKER_00]: I don't love the odds on Willie Anderson.
- 9:09[SPEAKER_00]: He's plus seven hundred, so seven to one.
- 9:14[SPEAKER_00]: I just don't see any way that Miles Garrett doesn't get to like 16 or 17 sex at least.
- 9:19[SPEAKER_00]: He's going to be on a team that is playing in a bunch of prime time games.
- 9:24[SPEAKER_00]: And we think is going to have a bunch of leads.
- 9:26[SPEAKER_00]: And that's going to give him more past rush opportunities than ever.
- 9:30[SPEAKER_00]: And Tommy, if he goes out there and he leads the NFL and pressures in win rate and sex,
- 9:35[SPEAKER_00]: I think voters are just going to default and give it to him because he is the best defense player in the league.
- 9:40[SPEAKER_00]: And there might, you know, I know he won it last year, but somebody else is going to have to be so much better than him in order to take it.
- 9:47[SPEAKER_00]: And the only guy that I think can get there is Willie Anderson.
- 9:50[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know that Willie Anderson is going to have the super high sack totals.
- 9:54[SPEAKER_00]: He could just be on the best defense in the league, be the best overall player.
- 9:59[SPEAKER_00]: But I think Garrett is, he's the favorite, and I would continue to bet him at plus 450.
- 10:05[SPEAKER_01]: He should be.
- 10:06[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, he should be very easily, because he was already a two-time defensive player that year on a bad Brown's team, and he's coming off of his age 29 season where he had set the sack record in a 23-sax in a year.
- 10:19[SPEAKER_01]: He's going to, if we're,
- 10:21[SPEAKER_01]: AP voters are factoring in Team Success at all, and they definitely do with MVP, and we know that there's kind of trends that they do with other positions as well with other of these words.
- 10:32[SPEAKER_01]: It's only gonna help his cause.
- 10:34[SPEAKER_01]: If they go out there in the Rams win 12 to 14 games this year, and I think that that wouldn't surprise anybody, and then Garrett also has 18, 19, 20, sacks season.
- 10:45[SPEAKER_01]: It smiles Garrett, like this is the only one that I would consider
- 10:50[SPEAKER_01]: And if I would go outside of that, which I really wouldn't want to venture outside of that, but Willie Anderson Jr. is the clear number two.
- 10:57[SPEAKER_01]: He's going to be on a top three top five defense again this year, potentially the number one overall defense again.
- 11:02[SPEAKER_01]: They might have only gotten better with Kate and McDonald and keep in the rest of their team intact.
- 11:07[SPEAKER_01]: I like Will Anderson Jr. a lot.
- 11:09[SPEAKER_01]: I don't like him as much as Garrett.
- 11:10[SPEAKER_01]: Those are the only two.
- 11:12[SPEAKER_01]: And I really have a hard time picking a long shot here for this award.
- 11:16[SPEAKER_01]: Just because I think these guys, both of them might have to be injured for somebody else to win it.
- 11:21[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 11:21[SPEAKER_00]: And if you're going to take a long shot, you should do it at a position not add draw share because for the most part, we know who the add draw share you're going to be.
- 11:29[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why I want to look at like someone like Kyle Hamilton who's got a big time pedigree right this is a multi time all pro selection right so voters know him and if the Ravens defense is transformed under Jesse mentor I could see Kyle Hamilton getting some votes right this is somebody who has had at least a hundred tackles and back to back seasons he's playing near the line of scrimmage the Ravens have a bunch of prime time games
- 11:54[SPEAKER_00]: I'm not saying that he should be, you know, favored over Miles Garrett or anybody like that.
- 11:59[SPEAKER_00]: But I think if you're looking beyond past Russia, I think Hamilton might be the best value, just because he's going to be involved in the action all the time and Baltimore.
- 12:08[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and it's worth mentioning that what Pat Sertian had it in 2023, and then before that Patriots Corner, Stefan Gilman,
- 12:15[SPEAKER_01]: more to bond Gilmore in 2020, I think.
- 12:17[SPEAKER_01]: So it's happened a few times in the last six or seven years.
- 12:21[SPEAKER_01]: It's not out of the realm of possibility, but then we've also seen like the Trayvon digs, 11 interception season, not be one of the top very top MVP candidates because of the edge rusher group, it tends to go to edge rushers.
- 12:33[SPEAKER_01]: They impact the game, play to play week to week, unlike any other position, but I agree with you there.
- 12:39[SPEAKER_01]: I think that if you
- 12:44[SPEAKER_01]: Then I probably would go with a defensive back, and you're just getting far removed from that position, because I don't know if anybody else can compete at that position.
- 12:52[SPEAKER_01]: And so maybe what they can do to transcend their defense might be enough.
- 12:56[SPEAKER_01]: All right, let's talk offensive rookie of the year now.
- 13:00[SPEAKER_01]: And this isn't a ward went to tetmic millen last year.
- 13:04[SPEAKER_01]: And I did a little bit of digging to because I was just curious of the last five seasons Marcus there was only one time.
- 13:12[SPEAKER_01]: where the offensive rookie of the ward didn't go to a team that made to playoffs.
- 13:17[SPEAKER_01]: And that was Garrett Wilson, but it required over 100 catches and nearly 1,200 yards.
- 13:22[SPEAKER_01]: So you either have to have elite production, or you've got to do something to maybe elevate your team and help your team get into the postseason.
- 13:32[SPEAKER_01]: That's how I kind of took this.
- 13:33[SPEAKER_01]: Did you take it the same way?
- 13:34[SPEAKER_01]: Who do you have for offensive?
- 13:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and typically voters like to vote on quarterbacks here.
- 13:40[SPEAKER_00]: I just don't think with Mendoza who is likely going to be starting behind Kirk Cousins, at least for the first four five games of the season.
- 13:48[SPEAKER_00]: is going to have a real shot at this.
- 13:50[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why I'm looking at receivers.
- 13:51[SPEAKER_00]: And I don't think the Titans and Cardinal Tate are going to be competitive enough.
- 13:55[SPEAKER_00]: No, I think are they going to be in the spotlight enough to win this award.
- 13:59[SPEAKER_00]: Same goes for Jordan Tyson.
- 14:00[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think Mackay Levin's going to get enough targets in year one.
- 14:03[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why I like Desan Striply for these San Francisco 49ers.
- 14:07[SPEAKER_00]: If you like Brock Perti to win the MVP award, he's going to have to throw the ball to somebody.
- 14:12[SPEAKER_00]: I think Mike Evans is obviously going to get a lot of those targets.
- 14:15[SPEAKER_00]: But struggling has a bit of guy that a lot of people in training camp right now have been impressed with and all he really needs to do is get to like 800 900 yards to be in this conversation and I don't think it's unrealistic that he could get there.
- 14:30[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, just full disclosure, I don't love this skill group at all of this previous draft class, I think Jeremiah love was by far the top guy for fantasy and should have been the number one overall, but offense of skill player or running back taken in the draft and he was, but the problem is he's on a bad
- 14:48[SPEAKER_01]: add errors on the Cardinals team.
- 14:49[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know how much of that's going to translate.
- 14:51[SPEAKER_01]: You could have the Ashen Gentie curve in the NFL where it's like you're just not very efficient.
- 14:56[SPEAKER_01]: You're not carving out any ground here.
- 14:58[SPEAKER_01]: I like the stripling selection for a best bet.
- 15:02[SPEAKER_01]: I really do.
- 15:02[SPEAKER_01]: You're talking to guy that's plus 2,000 here that's 20 to 1 odds.
- 15:06[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's a really good gamble.
- 15:08[SPEAKER_01]: I still have reserves about dribbling as a player to be deserved to be a second round pick.
- 15:14[SPEAKER_01]: Was he more of a late day to guy?
- 15:16[SPEAKER_01]: But he's entering a very favorable situation with.
- 15:19[SPEAKER_01]: I see him in here.
- 15:20[SPEAKER_00]: And on a team, it's going to be playing in the national spotlight, a ton, and that really does matter to the voters.
- 15:25[SPEAKER_00]: I just don't I really wonder about players like Carnell Tate and Jeremiah love that won't be in any prime time games all year long.
- 15:32[SPEAKER_01]: Having said that, I am not out on McIleman because they jay brown no longer there.
- 15:38[SPEAKER_01]: I think that theoretically there is enough targets to go around and it just depends on what percentage does he carve out, what's his dominating look like this year because if he gets enough and if it's any number that's respectable and the Eagles are in 11 to 12 or maybe 13
- 15:58[SPEAKER_01]: That could be enough to sway voters and say, OK, this is the best offense of player on a playoff caliber team, where you look at a lot of these other guys, Mendoza, what may not play enough might not have a winning record.
- 16:09[SPEAKER_01]: Jeremiah, love.
- 16:10[SPEAKER_01]: Same way, I still like love, just as the overall favorite for the sheer volume in the guy might touch the ball, 300 to 350 times this year.
- 16:18[SPEAKER_01]: And maybe that's enough to overlook the fact that the Cardinals will get like two or three wins.
- 16:22[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
- 16:23[SPEAKER_01]: If it does, it'll kind of defy the odds a little bit based on the recent data.
- 16:28[SPEAKER_01]: But I like dribbling a lot in terms of the best bet and I like lemon overall just because of the eagle situation.
- 16:35[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I think lemon is a guy that could catch a lot of passes, and that's why we're at least mentioning him now.
- 16:41[SPEAKER_00]: There has been some buzz about don't have you in wicks looking really good.
- 16:44[SPEAKER_00]: Mackay lemon is missed time with a hamstring injury.
- 16:46[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe it's going to be a little bit of a slow burn for lemon, but again, if he has a couple big games in prime time, that could be enough to sway voters.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and it does really seem like all of these rookies from this class, regardless of position quarterback,
- 17:03[SPEAKER_01]: Furnitizes that aren't very good right now and are not projected to be playoff teams.
- 17:07[SPEAKER_01]: I think stripling in lemon are the two in those top 10 or 12 that are and they very well could get the word coming their way.
- 17:15[SPEAKER_01]: All right, let's talk defensive rookie of the year now and who do you have going here?
- 17:21[SPEAKER_01]: Because I can see several different directions with this one.
- 17:25[SPEAKER_00]: This one's tricky, and it's usually a front-seven player that gets us a word.
- 17:29[SPEAKER_00]: This is why we put Carson's question in your last year.
- 17:31[SPEAKER_00]: Like we just thought he was going to be on a good defense, and he was going to be accumulating a ton of stats.
- 17:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 17:36[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why I like our Val-Riese for the New York Giants.
- 17:39[SPEAKER_00]: I think he could potentially get
- 17:41[SPEAKER_00]: four or five sex this year.
- 17:43[SPEAKER_00]: He's going to be playing off ball linebacker.
- 17:44[SPEAKER_00]: So I think he can get a hundred plus tackles.
- 17:47[SPEAKER_00]: The giants have a bunch of prime time games.
- 17:49[SPEAKER_00]: And if the giants defense is significantly approved, I do think you're going to see Reese get a lot of that credit to me.
- 17:56[SPEAKER_00]: He's just my favorite bet on the board regardless.
- 17:59[SPEAKER_00]: I think he should be the favorite.
- 18:01[SPEAKER_00]: I love our Valreys at 8 to 1.
- 18:04[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I like our role Reese as well.
- 18:05[SPEAKER_01]: And we saw evidence last year, the voters were willing to go with Carson Swisinger, who deserved the award, but they disregarded the status of his football team that was not very good last year.
- 18:17[SPEAKER_01]: And if that's the same ends up happening here, with the,
- 18:20[SPEAKER_01]: the the giants then it's going to be him right in the running.
- 18:25[SPEAKER_01]: Uh, some other names I consider like Ruben Bay and Junior, I think that this guy is ready to come out and compete.
- 18:30[SPEAKER_01]: He's going to be hungry.
- 18:31[SPEAKER_01]: I think that he might be more pro ready than some of the names on this list.
- 18:35[SPEAKER_01]: He might be my overall favorite bed if we're not factoring in the potential payout here.
- 18:40[SPEAKER_01]: And then I look at your Dallas Cowboys Marcus and I hate to do this, but
- 18:44[SPEAKER_01]: Caleb Downs is a player who could potentially slide in there.
- 18:48[SPEAKER_01]: We did see a defensive back when it in 2022 with Saus' gardener.
- 18:52[SPEAKER_01]: It's only happened twice though, at the last 10 years, it's been a defensive back, but they also have Malachi Lawrence, who could get huge opportunity in Dallas.
- 19:00[SPEAKER_01]: And if the wins are factored in and if Dallas ends up getting 10-11 wins this year in Malachi Lawrence, has a 9 or 10 sack season as a rookie, maybe that's more than what the rest of these defenders are going to offer.
- 19:12[SPEAKER_00]: I like the call on Caleb Downs.
- 19:14[SPEAKER_00]: The only issue is that voters do not give us a war to safety.
- 19:18[SPEAKER_00]: The last safety to win defensive rugby the year was in 1990.
- 19:21[SPEAKER_00]: It was Mark Carrier.
- 19:22[SPEAKER_00]: It just doesn't happen.
- 19:24[SPEAKER_00]: They tend to pick players who are rocking up a bunch of stats and it just doesn't happen for safety is very often.
- 19:31[SPEAKER_00]: Now again, if the Cowboys defense is much improved and Downs is making a bunch of tackles from the slot, I could see it but I do think there's better bets on the board.
- 19:39[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I think that that's fair as well.
- 19:41[SPEAKER_01]: Is there any bet for defensive rookie?
- 19:44[SPEAKER_01]: What's the farthest you would be willing to dig down on this list and say, OK, this is a potential monster payout, and I really like this player.
- 19:52[SPEAKER_01]: And it has a chance to actually win the award.
- 19:54[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you should be looking again at these players that can rack up a bunch of stats.
- 19:59[SPEAKER_00]: It's really the only way that you can win this award.
- 20:02[SPEAKER_00]: And you're looking for players who are going to be on teams that we think are either going to have a good defense
- 20:10[SPEAKER_00]: I'm looking at someone like Armace and Thomas with the Kansas City Chiefs.
- 20:13[SPEAKER_00]: The Chiefs really need a lot of help in the edge rush.
- 20:17[SPEAKER_00]: I think Armace and Thomas can certainly give them that juice.
- 20:19[SPEAKER_00]: We know the Chiefs are going to play.
- 20:20[SPEAKER_00]: I believe in six prime time games this year.
- 20:23[SPEAKER_00]: He's 65 to 1.
- 20:24[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's a pretty good value.
- 20:27[SPEAKER_01]: And if it wasn't for that, Marcus, it wasn't for the, the stat that you just threw out there about the safety, it's just not winning this word.
- 20:32[SPEAKER_01]: Dylan Thineman is another one I would be really interested in.
- 20:35[SPEAKER_01]: I love the talent.
- 20:36[SPEAKER_01]: I think he's a splash playmaker in the secondary, the bears.
- 20:40[SPEAKER_01]: Ironically, he had what the most splash plays in the league last year on defense.
- 20:44[SPEAKER_01]: They get they have a knack for taking the ball away.
- 20:46[SPEAKER_01]: They should be a playoff team again.
- 20:48[SPEAKER_01]: He'd be another one that I'd be intrigued by, but the stats say otherwise.
- 20:51[SPEAKER_01]: One other one real quick, Jacob Rodriguez.
- 20:53[SPEAKER_00]: This is very much like the Carson Swesinger thing last year.
- 20:57[SPEAKER_00]: defense is going to be worse than what Cleveland was, but he's 15 to 1.
- 21:01[SPEAKER_00]: And I could just see him just like on a production.
- 21:04[SPEAKER_00]: On a production, third league and tackles.
- 21:07[SPEAKER_00]: He's got four intersections because this is all he did at Texas Tech.
- 21:11[SPEAKER_00]: And by the time we get to the end of the year, it's just overwhelming how good the stats are.
- 21:15[SPEAKER_00]: Don't forget about Jacob Rodriguez.
- 21:16[SPEAKER_01]: I want to say Rodriguez too because I really like the guy.
- 21:20[SPEAKER_01]: I think he's going to be monstrously productive this year if you can play all 17 games.
- 21:25[SPEAKER_01]: The biggest factor is not only is he going to, is this team going to have a bad record this year.
- 21:30[SPEAKER_01]: Like the Browns did, but he's also not going to be on a good defense.
- 21:33[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that is the other thing they consider here.
- 21:36[SPEAKER_01]: But I think if they just disregard that and say you can only control what you can control Rodriguez.
- 21:41[SPEAKER_01]: You had 150 tackles or whatever you took them all way three or four times like maybe that's enough to get it anyway with the group that we just outlined here sunny styles any interest in that
- 21:53[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's kind of how I feel.
- 21:57[SPEAKER_01]: All right, and that brings us to the comeback player of the year.
- 22:01[SPEAKER_01]: And I was just, I was trying to look this up as well and say, all right, what's the history look like here?
- 22:06[SPEAKER_01]: And what are the requirements and how much time you have to miss?
- 22:09[SPEAKER_01]: There really isn't any.
- 22:10[SPEAKER_01]: Like there's not a set amount of games that a player has to miss to be eligible for comeback player, but they typically go.
- 22:16[SPEAKER_01]: The voters typically go for the players who miss a large chunk of time,
- 22:22[SPEAKER_01]: And so, to me, Marcus, like this, I really, Jane Dale just sticks out, like a sore thump to me.
- 22:29[SPEAKER_01]: We're talking about an offensive rookie of the year, two years ago, had a tremendous season, led us team to 12 wins and a playoff win.
- 22:37[SPEAKER_01]: And then this past year, only place seven games has the elbow injury and just,
- 22:44[SPEAKER_01]: Now we look at him again, this guy has got the talent to get back up there, the problem is will they give it come back player to a team that I no longer think can get a winning record and that's my hang up here with the Washington Commanders I don't know as good as Daniels isn't if he returns to form if he can lead his team to a winning record and how much that's going to matter to AP voters.
- 23:05[SPEAKER_00]: I have four that I want to mention and then my favorite is honestly milk neighbors at 12 to 1 just because I think neighbors is one of the best receivers in the NFL it seems like he's going to be ready for week one I think a healthy neighbors is going to put up 121300 yards he'll be on the conversation
- 23:20[SPEAKER_00]: Aaron Donald at nine to one.
- 23:22[SPEAKER_00]: I think we all believe Aaron Donald's coming back.
- 23:24[SPEAKER_00]: And if Aaron Donald is 85% of Aaron Donald, he's going to win this award.
- 23:30[SPEAKER_00]: And then two other ones.
- 23:31[SPEAKER_00]: Tankdale is 40 to one who missed all of last season with a really big knee injury.
- 23:37[SPEAKER_00]: If he plays at all this year and is somewhat productive, I could see it.
- 23:40[SPEAKER_00]: But my absolute favorite bet is Jonathan Brooks at 40 to one.
- 23:45[SPEAKER_00]: He's healthy.
- 23:47[SPEAKER_00]: He's going to get a lion share of the work in Carolina's backfield.
- 23:51[SPEAKER_00]: He's basically missed the last two full seasons with an ACL injury.
- 23:55[SPEAKER_00]: I just think if he has 800 rushing yards and plays 15, 16 games, he's going to be the one getting this award.
- 24:02[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, he very well could.
- 24:03[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that's certainly a sleeper in one that I think is is worth a gamble right there.
- 24:07[SPEAKER_01]: Ironically, Patrick Mahomes is number one, according to drama sports, but I don't see either.
- 24:12[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not saying that because plus 185, I wouldn't put your money there.
- 24:17[SPEAKER_01]: I only missed three games last season, still played essentially a full year and he's going to be ready to go.
- 24:21[SPEAKER_01]: So I don't think he faced as much adversity as maybe some of these other
- 24:26[SPEAKER_01]: players did.
- 24:26[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's where the awards going to go ultimately to one of the guys that we just outlined there.
- 24:32[SPEAKER_01]: All right.
- 24:32[SPEAKER_01]: What do you guys think?
- 24:33[SPEAKER_01]: Let us know on YouTube we go live on stacking the box or excuse me.
- 24:39[SPEAKER_01]: We premiere every Tuesday evening on stacking the box.
- 24:42[SPEAKER_01]: Be sure to check us out.
- 24:43[SPEAKER_01]: You can follow Marcus's written work.
- 24:48[SPEAKER_01]: on the fan-sided NFL network.
- 24:50[SPEAKER_01]: Check out Marcus's content on X at Marcus under score.
- 24:54[SPEAKER_01]: Mosher, you can follow me on X at Tommy Jagai.
- 24:57[SPEAKER_01]: You can check out the stack in the box podcast wherever you get your podcast.
- 25:01[SPEAKER_01]: Also check us out on YouTube.
- 25:02[SPEAKER_01]: You can follow my written content on stillCurtain.com.
- 25:06[SPEAKER_01]: Marcus is on the fan-sided NFL network.
- 25:07[SPEAKER_01]: Be sure to check out fan-sided.com for all your daily sports news and opinions.
- 25:11[SPEAKER_01]: And thanks again for listening to the stack in the box podcast.