Latest / Her Chapter: Women, identity, culture & modern life / The Guilt of Relief When a Difficult Parent Passes | Her Chapter
Transcript
- I watched my six-year-old daughter throw a punch at the air, her face twisted in pure, unfiltered rage, and I realized I had no idea what to do with that moment. It wasn’t about teaching her violence; it was about teaching her how to survive being small in a world that doesn’t always listen. It happened last Tuesday, or maybe Wednesday, time blurs when you’re trying to get out the door on time. We were at the park, the kind of overgrown, slightly neglected community space where the swings are rusted shut but everyone goes anyway because it’s free and it’s green. My daughter, let’s call her Maya for this story, though her name is something else entirely, was playing with a group of other kids. She’s six now. Six is such a strange age. She is all elbows and knees and opinions, bursting with energy that seems to have no off switch. But she’s also learning boundaries. And today, someone took her toy. Not just any toy. A specific red shovel that she had claimed as hers, the one with the chipped handle that she loves more than anything. The other child, a boy who looked maybe two years older, just reached over and grabbed it. He didn’t ask. He didn’t even look at her. He just took it, because he could, because he was bigger, and because he knew that usually, people like him get what they want by force. Maya didn’t cry immediately. That’s the part that sticks in my throat every time I think about it. She froze. Her little hands clenched into fists at her sides. I saw the shift in her eyes, from confusion to a hot, bright anger that I recognized instantly. It was the same anger I felt when I was twenty-five, standing in a boardroom while a man talked over me, using words I couldn’t quite catch but whose meaning was clear: you are not important here. Maya stood there, trembling, waiting for me to fix it. Waiting for her mother to step in, to negotiate, to smooth things over with polite adult language. But something inside me snapped. Or maybe, something inside me woke up. For years, my instinct has been to shield her. To build a bubble around her life where kindness is rewarded and cruelty is kept at bay. I’ve read the books. I’ve done the workshops. I know that gentle parenting means validating feelings and guiding behavior with empathy. And I still believe in that. I really do. But watching her stand there, shrinking into herself, trying to make herself smaller so she wouldn’t be a target, I felt a profound failure. Not because I hadn’t taught her manners, but because I hadn’t taught her power. Here’s what I’m noticing... we spend so much time teaching girls to be nice. To share. To smile. To say please and thank you. We polish their edges until they fit neatly into the boxes society has made for them. But we rarely teach them what to do when someone tries to break those boxes. When someone invades their space. When someone takes what isn’t theirs. I wanted to run over there. I wanted to swoop in and reclaim the shovel with a wave of my hand, asserting my maternal authority. But if I did that, I would be reinforcing the very thing I fear most: that she needs a protector to speak for her. That her voice isn’t enough. That her presence isn’t enough. So I stopped myself. I stayed back. I watched her. And I waited to see what she would do. Because I needed to know if I had raised a warrior, or just a victim. Let’s sit with that for a second. The tension between wanting to protect your child and wanting to empower them is agonizing. It’s a tightrope walk without a net. Most of us aren’t trained for it. We’re trained to solve problems, to fix things, to make the pain go away. But sometimes, the only way through the pain is through it. Maya didn’t move toward me. She didn’t scream for help. Instead, she turned toward the boy. She didn’t have the height advantage. She didn’t have the weight. But she had something else. She had fire. She walked up to him, planted her feet wide, and did something that startled me more than the punch itself. She spoke. Her voice was small, but it was steady. She said, 'Give it back.' The boy paused. He looked at her, surprised that she wasn’t crying. He looked at the shovel, then back at her. He didn’t give it back. He smirked. That smirk... it was everything I hated. It was the arrogance of entitlement. And in that moment, I saw Maya’s face change again. The hesitation vanished. The fear evaporated. What replaced it was a cold, focused determination. She raised her fist. It wasn’t a wild swing. It wasn’t a flail. It was a deliberate motion. She pulled back her arm, coiling her body like a spring, and then she threw it. Right at his shoulder. It wasn’t hard enough to hurt him, I hope. But it was hard enough to shock him. The shovel flew from his hand. It landed in the dirt. He blinked. He looked at his shoulder, then at her. He didn’t hit her back. He didn’t call her names. He just picked up the shovel, gave it a wary glance, and walked away. He went to play elsewhere. Maya stood there, breathing hard, her chest rising and falling. She looked at me. Her eyes were wide, searching for my reaction. Was I proud? Was I horrified? Was I disappointed that she used violence? This is where it gets complicated, isn’t it? As a woman, as a feminist, as a mother who values peace, I have a deep aversion to violence. I don’t want her to be aggressive. I don’t want her to be cruel. But I also don’t want her to be powerless. There is a difference between aggression and assertion. Aggression is about dominating others. Assertion is about protecting yourself. I needed to help her understand that distinction. I needed to help her understand that her body belongs to her, and that she has the right to defend its boundaries. I walked over to her. I knelt down in the dirt, ignoring the stain on my jeans, and I looked at her. I asked her, 'How did that feel?' She shrugged, trying to play it cool, but her hands were still shaking slightly. 'Good,' she said. 'Bad,' she added. 'I was scared.' I nodded. 'It’s okay to be scared. It’s okay to be angry. But tell me, why did you do it?' She looked at the shovel, then at me. 'Because he took it. And I wanted it back.' Simple. Direct. Honest. I hugged her then. I held her tight, feeling the tremors in her small frame. I whispered into her hair, 'You did good. You protected yourself. You didn’t hurt him, but you made your point.' Later, after we got home, after dinner and bath and stories, we sat on the couch together. The house was quiet. The plants in the corner seemed to lean in, listening. I told her about the time I was in college, and a guy tried to grab my arm when I was walking home late. I told her how I froze, too. How I wished I had known then what I know now. That knowing your worth gives you strength. That taking up space is not rude; it is necessary. She listened, her eyes heavy with sleep, but present. She absorbed it. She stored it away for a rainy day. We live in a culture that tells women to shrink. To make ourselves smaller so we don’t threaten the men around us. To swallow our anger, to smooth over our conflicts, to keep the peace at all costs. But peace purchased with silence is not peace. It’s submission. And I refuse to raise my daughter in submission. I want her to know that her anger is valid. That her boundaries are sacred. That she has the right to say no, loudly and clearly, if necessary. Teaching her to throw a punch wasn’t about encouraging violence. It was about building confidence. It was about showing her that she has agency. That she can affect the world around her. That she is not passive. When she threw that punch, she reclaimed her power. She sent a message to the boy, and to herself, that she cannot be pushed around. That she will fight for what is hers. This is not easy for me. I worry that I’m raising a fighter in a world that punishes fighters, especially female ones. I worry that she will be seen as difficult, as hostile, as too much. But I worry more about her being invisible. About her being erased. About her apologizing for taking up space. So I keep practicing. I keep talking to her. I model boundary-setting in my own life. I show her when I say no to people who demand too much of my time. I show her when I walk away from conversations that drain me. I show her that self-respect is not selfish. It is essential. And when she throws a punch in the air, in her room, in her imagination, I don’t scold her. I watch. I wait. I support. Because she is learning how to navigate a world that is often unfair. And she deserves to know that she is strong enough to handle it. There is no finish line here. No day when I can say, 'Okay, you’re safe now.' The world will keep testing her. People will keep pushing. There will be moments when she freezes, and moments when she fights. Moments when she shares, and moments when she hoards. All of it is part of her becoming. Part of her figuring out who she is. And I am here to witness it. To guide it. To love her through it. Yesterday, she asked me if she could learn karate. I smiled. I said yes. Not because I think she needs to kick people in the head. But because I think she needs to feel the strength in her legs. I need her to feel grounded. I need her to know that she can stand her ground. And if she ever needs to throw a punch, I want her to know exactly how to do it. With precision. With purpose. With grace. It’s complicated, isn’t it? The balance between gentleness and grit. Between softness and steel. But maybe that’s the point. Maybe we are meant to hold both. To be tender and tough. To be kind and fierce. To be human. Fully, messily, beautifully human. And as long as I’m here, holding her hand, listening to her heart, teaching her that her voice matters, that her body matters, that her anger matters... then I think we’ll be okay. We’ll figure it out. One punch, one conversation, one breath at a time. Thank you for letting me into your day. Thank you for trusting me with your attention. Until next time, take care of yourselves, and each other. Love you.