
Opinion: Supreme Court ruling on Roundup points to a confusing difference between the law and science
When a jury decides a chemical causes cancer, does that mean the science is settled?
When a jury hands down a massive verdict against a weedkiller manufacturer or a social media platform, the headlines often treat the ruling as a newly discovered scientific fact. But writing on 27 June 2026, epidemiologist Alex Smolak points out a basic translation error. Science and the legal system use the exact same word—causation—to mean completely different things. Smolak outlines the gap between holding a corporation responsible in a courtroom and proving a biological reality in a lab.
An explanation of…
The skinny
The skinny isn't ready yet — notes appear once the transcript is processed.