Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 6 Episode 24: If “Mother Is In Denial About Domestic Violence” Had a Buzzer, We’d Smash It!!!
Transcript
- 0:15Ruth Reymundo: And we're back.
- 0:16David Mandel: And we're back.
- 0:17Ruth Reymundo: How are you there?
- 0:18David Mandel: Hey.
- 0:18David Mandel: How are you?
- 0:19Ruth Reymundo: I'm good.
- 0:21David Mandel: You're more than good, actually.
- 0:23David Mandel: I know you're more than good.
- 0:24David Mandel: So I'm more than good.
- 0:26David Mandel: You're joining us for a year-end Azorian Partner with a Survivor episode.
- 0:34David Mandel: This is our last episode of the year, I think.
- 0:36David Mandel: Today is the 30th of December.
- 0:40Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 0:41David Mandel: So that's pretty close to the end of 2025, right?
- 0:43Ruth Reymundo: Aaron Ross Powell Pretty close.
- 0:44Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 0:45Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 0:45David Mandel: And I'm David Mandel, CEO and founder of the Safe and Taylor Institute.
- 0:50David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 0:50Ruth Reymundo: And I am Ruth Raimundo, and I am the Chief Business Development Officer and the co-owner of the Institute.
- 0:57David Mandel: Trevor Burrus Yeah.
- 0:57David Mandel: And we're going to talk to you about denial.
- 1:01Ruth Reymundo: We are.
- 1:02David Mandel: And the use of the label denial in a moment.
- 1:05David Mandel: But first, you're going to do a land acknowledgement.
- 1:09Ruth Reymundo: I am.
- 1:10Ruth Reymundo: I'm very emotional.
- 1:13David Mandel: Are you?
- 1:13David Mandel: Okay.
- 1:14Ruth Reymundo: Okay.
- 1:15Ruth Reymundo: So we are on the island of Sao Miguel in the Azores, which is part of Macaronesia.
- 1:22Ruth Reymundo: You may know about Micronesia and Polynesia.
- 1:25Ruth Reymundo: Well, dear Polynesian and dear, Micronesian friends.
- 1:31Ruth Reymundo: I am your Macronesian sister.
- 1:33Ruth Reymundo: It sounds like macaroni.
- 1:35David Mandel: I know it does.
- 1:36Ruth Reymundo: Very many people don't know about these islands and their place in the world.
- 1:40Ruth Reymundo: But the Azore Islands is a place where my father's family has lived for as long as the records reach.
- 1:49Ruth Reymundo: And I don't speak with certainty or authority about the first custodians of this land, the first human custodians of this land.
- 1:58Ruth Reymundo: But what I know is partial.
- 2:00Ruth Reymundo: And it's layered and shaped by history, and it actually begins the story of global colonization.
- 2:08Ruth Reymundo: If you think about the first impacted places where that energy arose, this is the first place.
- 2:16Ruth Reymundo: This is the first place that those explorers came to.
- 2:20Ruth Reymundo: And the Azores is really part of a vast oceanic system.
- 2:27Ruth Reymundo: And it gathers moisture, it holds clouds, and releases rain.
- 2:32Ruth Reymundo: And it directs the rain.
- 2:34Ruth Reymundo: It feeds those weather patterns in Europe and in North America.
- 2:38Ruth Reymundo: And the native plants on this island shelter birds and they anchor life in place in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean.
- 2:47Ruth Reymundo: And it is a volcanic island teeming with life.
- 2:51Ruth Reymundo: Many active volcanoes still.
- 2:54Ruth Reymundo: But I really hold with care the story of the people who moved through these waters and through this archipelago.
- 3:02Ruth Reymundo: And the known initial custodians of the lower islands of the archipelago, whose range we don't quite understand, were the Gonch people, the Aborigine people of North Africa.
- 3:16Ruth Reymundo: And they were seafaring, island dwelling people.
- 3:21Ruth Reymundo: And we know that they were eradicated with the Spanish expansion into those islands, and then also the Portuguese expansion into those islands.
- 3:32Ruth Reymundo: And in some lower islands, the Gaunch people have re-established their spiritual practices, which I'm really happy to hear.
- 3:42Ruth Reymundo: But also I acknowledge that this land sustains many, many, many people in Europe as well as North America by its its existence and the way that it functions here in the ocean and how it sustains and nurtures life and migratory pathways as well.
- 4:03Ruth Reymundo: And I do want to mention some of the other islands, like my Uncle Ernius Island, Flores, where Bartolomeo de las Casas found the deceased bodies of what he called Amerit Indian people.
- 4:22Ruth Reymundo: And those bodies, however they passed, were used as the legal argument for sending ships westward.
- 4:37Ruth Reymundo: So these islands and whomever was found on them, alive or dead, formed the argument for heading toward the Americas.
- 4:49Ruth Reymundo: And when I say that, I feel such emotion inside me.
- 4:53Ruth Reymundo: And it's very emotional for me because I was separated from my family and my heritage and my Azorian family because they were considered to be not acceptable spiritually.
- 5:13Ruth Reymundo: They practiced spirituality, which, though it was wrapped in Catholicism, was deeply about nature and our relationships and our connections and honoring our ancestors, whether they were human or they were trees or they were rivers or they were they were waterways or they were waterfalls.
- 5:37Ruth Reymundo: And that is truly beautiful that I've brought myself and my family home after only two generations of being away from this island.
- 5:50Ruth Reymundo: So thank you, Samigal.
- 5:53David Mandel: That's so beautiful.
- 5:54David Mandel: And it's for me listening to you, knowing what this means, this isn't just a land acknowledgement.
- 6:01David Mandel: It's a remembering in the in that kind of deep use of the word remembering, you know, to to to put things back together, to heal, to reconnect things.
- 6:12David Mandel: And I'm deeply aware that when we're here, it is powerful on so many levels, and I'm really grateful for you to introduce me to your home.
- 6:25Ruth Reymundo: Thank you.
- 6:26David Mandel: And so that's where we're joining you're joining us from, and and hopefully there'll be many more episodes of partner with a survivor from here.
- 6:37Ruth Reymundo: And and just to say it out loud, the Azores San Miguel, sadly, the the manner of of cruelty that was put upon the people here, enforced poverty, enforced illiteracy, because the mainland Portuguese were making a serf class of people in the colonies, it has deeply wounded and harmed Azorian people, it has fractured their families, it has led to a tremendous amount of addiction and alcoholism, there's an 80% domestic violence rate here.
- 7:15Ruth Reymundo: And that is it breaks my heart because if you've ever come to these islands, if you've ever been here, you understand that what is so important is the connection with nature.
- 7:34Ruth Reymundo: Yes.
- 7:34Ruth Reymundo: The quietude, the silence, the wind, the rain, the mist, the water, the waterways.
- 7:42Ruth Reymundo: It's it's all very sacred.
- 7:46David Mandel: Yes.
- 7:47Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 7:49David Mandel: Thank you for giving us that foundation for this episode and many more to calm my hope.
- 7:54David Mandel: And I mean that's an episode in itself right now.
- 7:58David Mandel: That just that little is like a mini experience, at least for me.
- 8:02David Mandel: I want to pivot us gently, because I'm still feeling what you just said to the conversation topic around denial and the use of the word denial, actually.
- 8:14David Mandel: It this is really actually not the concept of denial, it is, but it it was sparked by my return to a lot of the foundations of the model and its inception, both for the safety other institutes, development of fidelity and tracking material and deepening what we're doing.
- 8:34David Mandel: And then also you and I are co-founders of Safety Nexus.
- 8:38Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 8:38David Mandel: We're removing the safe and together intellectual property, material, and concepts into an AI-powered.
- 8:45Ruth Reymundo: And to technology.
- 8:46Ruth Reymundo: AI in this case, but yeah, technology in technology.
- 8:49David Mandel: And really concerned with fidelity.
- 8:51David Mandel: You know, the really the the research says that trained closed LLMs really can be very effective in coaching and supervising and supporting workers' decisions, not doing it for them.
- 9:03David Mandel: And that really means that we want to dive into these terms.
- 9:09David Mandel: We're doing it in writing, we're doing other sets.
- 9:11David Mandel: So I was was looking at this use of the word denial, going back to the beginning of the model.
- 9:18Ruth Reymundo: Because tell people why, because some people don't realize how common that phrase is actually used in child protection on police reports.
- 9:27Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 9:27David Mandel: I mean, I so I really want to name this as a problem.
- 9:31David Mandel: And I if if you take one thing away from this podcast, even just do you just you know you're about to go off and pick up your kids or start cooking dinner or or go to work or you're you're getting out of the car, like this is it, which is that if you hear the word denial applied to a domestic abuse survivor, immediately assume it's actually a diagnosis of the system, not the survivor.
- 9:55unknown: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 9:55Ruth Reymundo: And and I would add immediately tag that the professional who used it is not proficient in understanding domestic abuse and course or control.
- 10:08David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: And to understand that.
- 10:09Ruth Reymundo: That's more about if a professional uses that, that's right.
- 10:12Ruth Reymundo: You as a supervisor, you as a manager, you as a programmatic person should be like red flag that.
- 10:19David Mandel: It's not it's not you don't have the skill.
- 10:21David Mandel: It's not neutral, it's not it's it's value-laden, it's a judgment or a conclusion, it's not facts.
- 10:28David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 10:29Ruth Reymundo: Isn't it funny?
- 10:29Ruth Reymundo: Nobody ever says that the violent father is not in denial of his violence.
- 10:34David Mandel: It's much said m much less frequently.
- 10:36David Mandel: Yeah, absolutely.
- 10:37David Mandel: My experience is is is and even then you need to unpack that.
- 10:42David Mandel: Because just be really clear, somebody says that somebody else is in denial.
- 10:46David Mandel: They're giving you their conclusion, their judgment, they're not giving you the facts, they're not describing their behaviors.
- 10:53David Mandel: Right.
- 10:53David Mandel: And so we want to talk a little bit about the history behind that word, which we did some research on, and sort of I knew some of it, but I really wanted to be clearer about it, and then talk to you about the dangers and then how to deal with it.
- 11:07Ruth Reymundo: So that's our our kind of template for today.
- 11:10Ruth Reymundo: Let's do it.
- 11:11Ruth Reymundo: And you're gonna hear the wind.
- 11:12Ruth Reymundo: I hope you hear palm trees in the background.
- 11:15David Mandel: Yeah.
- 11:15David Mandel: So so I'm a trained mental health professional, and I knew some of this, but I really wanted to go back and research it.
- 11:23David Mandel: And as many of you know, because many of you also have a similar background, the world, the word denial comes out of its its usage in this context can be traced back to Freud, basically.
- 11:36David Mandel: An early psychoanalytic theory.
- 11:48Ruth Reymundo: And it's I'm really gonna try not to curse on this one.
- 11:50Ruth Reymundo: Okay.
- 11:51Ruth Reymundo: Well, I don't know why it's your podcast.
- 11:53David Mandel: You can curse on if you want.
- 11:55David Mandel: But you know that it it was really about this idea of labeling somebody's resistance.
- 12:00David Mandel: It was about interesting.
- 12:02Ruth Reymundo: Wait a second.
- 12:03Ruth Reymundo: It was actually specifically about women.
- 12:05Ruth Reymundo: It wasn't someone's resistance.
- 12:08Ruth Reymundo: It was women's resistance.
- 12:11David Mandel: Right.
- 12:11David Mandel: So you'll see that that at its core, the term has has a history and a lineage that's about uh what I'm gonna say is kind of like spoiler, mislabeling women, controlling their realities, and determining who controls the truth about experiences, right?
- 12:29David Mandel: Is that fair?
- 12:29Ruth Reymundo: Aaron Ross Powell, Jr.
- 12:30Ruth Reymundo: You know, I I think so what we're talking about is we're talking about the history of Freud labeling denial as a psychoanalytical term.
- 12:39David Mandel: Essentially, if that's where it arose as an internal struggle, as an intra psychic issue.
- 12:46R: Because and and just to put a pin in it, Freud believed that women who reported sexual abuse were hysterical.
- 12:56R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 12:56David Mandel: And reporting on their internal psychic issues.
- 12:58David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 13:01David Mandel: Right.
- 13:01David Mandel: Not about what was really happening to them.
- 13:03R: Not about what men were doing to them.
- 13:04R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 13:05David Mandel: Right.
- 13:05R: Okay.
- 13:06R: But also Freud's theories are deeply grounded in his own sexual fixations.
- 13:12R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 13:12R: Right.
- 13:12R: Okay, he made everything about sex.
- 13:14R: Just to put a pin in that.
- 13:16R: So it is very specific about women.
- 13:19R: It is very specific about women's experiences of male violence and sexual violence.
- 13:26R: So we cannot lose that context.
- 13:29David Mandel: Right.
- 13:29David Mandel: And and so just to really understand, its very roots position the term as about being the about the internal psychological landscape.
- 13:40R: Trevor Burrus Of women.
- 13:41David Mandel: Of women.
- 13:42David Mandel: And so and and there are people who have analyzed, I'm going to use the word purposely, analyzed Freud's work, analyzed his history, analyzed some of his earlier identification of and talking about sexual abuse and believing that that patients had been sexually abused by their fathers.
- 14:04David Mandel: And that then transitioning from that perspective to making it about reframing things as intra-psychic.
- 14:12David Mandel: Wait a second.
- 14:13R: It's worse than that.
- 14:14R: Okay, go for it.
- 14:15R: I would not convey it that way.
- 14:16David Mandel: Say it.
- 14:17David Mandel: Say it.
- 14:18R: Freud believed that girls were being sexually abused by their fathers, and he made a theory that said that girls wanted to marry their fathers in order to justify men raping their own children.
- 14:32R: Okay, it's really that simple.
- 14:33R: That's right.
- 14:34David Mandel: And this is and and one of the people that you need to know is Florence Rush, who wrote about this in the in the 70s, who is associated with the term gaslighting, which I didn't know.
- 14:46David Mandel: Right.
- 14:46David Mandel: And many of you may know this already.
- 14:48David Mandel: Right.
- 14:48David Mandel: But sort of popularized the use of the word gaslighting for this reframing and re uh talking people out of their real experience and making them not believe themselves.
- 14:58David Mandel: Right.
- 14:59David Mandel: And and while gaslighting is used regularly now in the context of coercive control as a tactic, she was framing it in terms of the cultural and psychological narrative, the narrative that professionals used.
- 15:14David Mandel: She was saying Freud was engaging in gaslighting by saying this sexual abuse didn't happen.
- 15:21R: Right.
- 15:21David Mandel: This is only a reflection of girls' and women's fantasies and intrapsychic struggles.
- 15:29David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 15:29R: And then there's Bertha Pappenheim, okay, because I really do want to bring her into the picture here, or as a counterweight to what Freud was saying.
- 15:37R: And she was Anna O in his initial treatment.
- 15:41R: And he essentially diagnosed her with a form of hysteria because of her psychological complaints about men's violence and sexual violence.
- 15:55R: And she later went on to become a feminist and an antipsychological advocate because her assessment was that Freud was diagnosing with psychol psychoanalytical language things like poverty, domestic violence, rape, and moral double standards for men and women in society at that time, gender double standards.
- 16:24R: And that is still a cogent analysis.
- 16:27R: That's still what is happening today.
- 16:30David Mandel: Right.
- 16:31David Mandel: And so I I think this is, you know, for me, the the critical aspect of this is sort of when professionals label domestic abuse survivors being in denial.
- 16:44David Mandel: And and again, I through my career I've seen it over and over and over again.
- 16:48David Mandel: And one is they're really be clear, they're using a term that was designed for well, came up in the context of what we just described, is about the internal world and problematizes.
- 17:01David Mandel: Is that a word?
- 17:02R: Problematizes resistance.
- 17:04David Mandel: Well problematizes the the the the victim, the survivor, not the external behavior of the perpetrator or the system's failure to respond.
- 17:13R: Trevor Burrus But see, the here you have to look at denial and you have to look at hysteria as two bookends that were basically hedging women in.
- 17:21R: Do you understand what I'm saying?
- 17:23R: Because if a woman was experiencing violence and somebody wanted to take her children because she was poor and her, you know, whatever, they would say you're in denial.
- 17:34David Mandel: Right.
- 17:34R: But at the same time, at this in the same era, and that continued for a long time, if a woman challenged that abuse, she was hysterical and she could be put into an asylum.
- 17:46R: So on one end of the bookend you have denial, where you can take a person's child child away, or you can remove their liberties and rights because they're in denial.
- 17:55R: And on the other end of the bookend, you have hysteria, which is which is pathologizing resistance, so you can abuse a person, shut them down, and remove their liberties as well.
- 18:05R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 18:06David Mandel: So let me let me map some current terms onto what you just said.
- 18:11David Mandel: So on the denial side, we have the failure to protect.
- 18:16R: Right.
- 18:16R: That's the new term.
- 18:18R: That's the new term.
- 18:19David Mandel: That's right.
- 18:19David Mandel: You know, and I wrote about the myth of failure to protect in my book and the problem with that.
- 18:23R: Right.
- 18:24David Mandel: And then on the other side, and I just connected the dots here, which is the modern-day equivalent hysteria, though hysteria is still used, is parental alienation, the allegation of parental alienation.
- 18:37R: Yeah.
- 18:41David Mandel: You're making things up.
- 18:42David Mandel: There's actually you're being vindictive.
- 18:44David Mandel: You're you're you're you're seeing problems where there aren't.
- 18:48David Mandel: Get over it.
- 18:49David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 18:50R: Well, this is all this is all about where the attachment stuff where they claim that the mother's hyper-attached to the child, or the child's hyper-attached to the mother.
- 18:57R: Right.
- 18:58R: Because they're they're they're protecting each other against a perpetrator.
- 19:02R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 19:02David Mandel: And and so what all these things have in common is is decontextualizing and problematizing survivors' experience from the system, from the culture, and from the perpetrator's pattern of behavior.
- 19:16David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 19:17R: It's I think yes, it's de it's a decontextualization, but really ultimately the the operational reality is that it's it's a subversion, it's a pivoting, it's to get everybody to pivot away from the man or the person who's choosing violence and holding them accountable for their actions.
- 19:35R: It's very it's very consistent.
- 19:38David Mandel: Right.
- 19:38David Mandel: And and so what you know, what I started doing, what we do in the model, and we're trying to build into the the safety nexus tool is the same kind of thing, which is is how do you take all this knowledge, what we just talked about, and operationalize it in in coaching and behavior and changing practice.
- 19:59David Mandel: Because you are going to be, so any of you listening, you are going to be confronted with somebody who uses that term.
- 20:06R: You are going to be either supervising or you are going to be confronted with your own frustration in dealing with a survivor who feels like they're in denial to you.
- 20:15R: And your job as a skilled professional is to be curious enough to really understand coercive control.
- 20:23R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 20:23David Mandel: And if you live in that world of of and inside that concept of denial, you're going to see that you're going to think the answer is greater education, more insight, more awareness, healing of trauma, you know.
- 20:37David Mandel: I mean, and and a lot of times, again, this is is often gets wrapped up now in sort of the lens of trauma.
- 20:43David Mandel: She's a trauma survivor.
- 20:44David Mandel: Right.
- 20:45David Mandel: Again, all this stuff is is is focused on the internal world of the survivor or their own.
- 20:51R: And notice who we're not talking about.
- 20:52David Mandel: That's right.
- 20:53R: Notice who's not even in the room right now.
- 20:55David Mandel: Trevor Burrus And so so the first thing.
- 20:58David Mandel: So I'm going to kind of walk you through a couple of steps about this is both like you're saying, Ruth, that you're saying it can be used for self-reflection or it can be done externally, you know, with if you're if you're a supervisor or an or or a coach or or acting some way, which is when somebody says, well, survivor's in denial, is to ask this question.
- 21:19David Mandel: Say, what has she done or said to make you believe or think she's in denial?
- 21:26R: You know, it's so funny because when you when you said what do you do, I I just would like to have an auto sound.
- 21:34R: Universal auto sound that it goes whenever somebody uses that term.
- 21:41R: You're much more constructive about this.
- 21:44R: But I like my version of the world.
- 21:46David Mandel: I like your version of the world too.
- 21:47David Mandel: I think it's you know, if it worked, I would do it.
- 21:50David Mandel: If I'm all over the yeah, that flashing lights.
- 21:52David Mandel: But but the reason what that does is it automatically moves it away from the professional defining the survivor and defining her reality.
- 22:05David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 22:06R: But also in a yeah.
- 22:06R: We need to avoid that, but also it this again is the dance step of partnering.
- 22:12David Mandel: Right.
- 22:12R: We've oft well, I made the analogy of partnering as a dance step.
- 22:16David Mandel: Right.
- 22:16R: Because I like I'm a dancer.
- 22:18R: So so you know, the first thing is you partner with the survivor to understand the context, but then you have to pivot yourself to the perpetrator.
- 22:28R: If we don't get to that second piece, if we're always stuck in assessing the side survivor's inner world and their motivations and their trauma and all of the things that they're doing, we are never looking at the perpetrator.
- 22:43R: And that's so intentional.
- 22:45David Mandel: And in a time poor environment, every minute you spend looking at a survivor that isn't ultimately about partnering is is taking time away from holding the perpetrator accountable.
- 22:54David Mandel: Right.
- 22:54David Mandel: So and this is I'm gonna even layer in that this is also about partnering with that worker because I found that you that being didactic and lecturing to that worker doesn't help them uncover what they need to understand about themselves, their practice, and change.
- 23:12David Mandel: Right.
- 23:12David Mandel: So this is both about partnering, encouraging partners.
- 23:15David Mandel: But it's partnering with that person.
- 23:17R: But it's also partnering with professionals.
- 23:19David Mandel: That's right.
- 23:19David Mandel: Yeah.
- 23:20David Mandel: And and and so what that means is that by asking that question, what has she done or said that makes you come to the conclusion or assume or believe that she's in denial?
- 23:32David Mandel: One you're you're putting the word belief, conclusion, in the sentence into the paragraph.
- 23:38David Mandel: Right.
- 23:38David Mandel: Because that's now saying that's your conclusion.
- 23:42David Mandel: That's not hers.
- 23:44David Mandel: That's yours.
- 23:45David Mandel: That's your label analysis.
- 23:46David Mandel: That's your label analysis.
- 23:47David Mandel: Ask me, let's create a common understanding of the things she's doing or saying.
- 23:53R: Behavior.
- 23:54David Mandel: Put it on the table so we both can look at it together, and gives me a chance as your coach or your supervisor to reflect and maybe reframe something or recontextualize it or re understand it.
- 24:04David Mandel: And so what I found is that people will say, well, often and this was the most common thing, would be, well, she's not leaving him.
- 24:10David Mandel: I mean, I I I could tell if if if it that's not the answer 50% of the time.
- 24:15R: Yeah.
- 24:15R: Probably more like 60 or 70%.
- 24:17David Mandel: She's not leaving him.
- 24:18David Mandel: Yeah.
- 24:18David Mandel: She hasn't ended the relationship.
- 24:19David Mandel: She keeps going back to him.
- 24:20David Mandel: She keeps going back to him.
- 24:21David Mandel: And then what that does is gives you a chance to say, okay, what's your worry about that, right?
- 24:27David Mandel: So then then you say, what's your worry about that?
- 24:29David Mandel: Because going back to a relationship isn't a problem unless there's a danger.
- 24:35R: Right.
- 24:35David Mandel: People have the absolute right to move in and out of relationship, to choose who they love.
- 24:40David Mandel: It's none of the state's business.
- 24:42David Mandel: I feel very passionate about this.
- 24:44David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 24:44R: Even if it's a even if it's a relationship that you judge as being dysfunctional or not nourishing to that person.
- 24:50R: That's right.
- 24:50R: That's right.
- 24:52R: That's right.
- 24:52David Mandel: You know, even if you're well-intentioned saying you deserve better, really the boundary of of child protection involvement, other people's involvement is often this, particularly the state, particularly interesting in the state, which is are people in danger, are kids in danger, is there is there a risk here that is that is big enough to warrant intervention in people's personal lives.
- 25:14David Mandel: And when you say what the worry is, the worry then if it's a response is legitimate, is gonna be framed or should be framed around my concern is that he's gonna hurt her again.
- 25:28David Mandel: And I would hear that a lot, by the way.
- 25:30David Mandel: Right.
- 25:30David Mandel: It would move quickly from she's in denial to I'm worried he's gonna kill her.
- 25:35R: I'm afraid he's gonna kill her.
- 25:36David Mandel: He's gonna kill her.
- 25:37David Mandel: Right.
- 25:37R: And that's gonna be traumatic for me as a worker.
- 25:39R: It's gonna be traumatic for the children.
- 25:41David Mandel: And I don't want that to happen to her.
- 25:42David Mandel: Legit.
- 25:42David Mandel: That I could be comfortable about saying, tell me what he's done that's made you worried.
- 25:53David Mandel: He's gonna kill her or he's gonna do this.
- 25:54R: And now we get down to behaviors.
- 25:56David Mandel: That's his behaviors.
- 25:57R: Now we get down to the perpetrators' behaviors.
- 25:59R: So it's so important to note because I think what happens is is that we go through these cycles of where people are like, oh, this term is terrible and it's victim blaming.
- 26:09R: Yes.
- 26:10R: But what everybody should be taking away from the migration of psychological words and languages that have been applied to victims over time throughout the history of the legal framework and psychoanalytical terms is that jargon terms that erase behaviors are dangerous in the context of liberty removal and rights.
- 26:38R: And then no professional and no judgment should ever be made on a foundation of jargon, psychoanalytical terms, and labels that we don't actually have the responsibility to map those behaviors and prove that that person is a danger to others and they should lose their rights.
- 27:01R: Now that I want people to really understand and hear what I'm saying because this is also about protecting people against the removal of liberties and rights who have been accused of things that they haven't done and that there's no behavioral evidence for.
- 27:17R: But somebody has overlaid a term on top of them.
- 27:21R: They've said you're in denial, you're resistant, you're hysterical, you're whatever, failure to protect.
- 27:28R: All labels that have nothing to do, that do not give us any context, which are extremely dangerous in the context of the law.
- 27:36R: So I really want people to hear that what I'm advocating for and why I love the Safe and Together model and what you made is that it is behaviorally specific and makes it harder for individuals and systems to remove the rights of people who have done nothing wrong.
- 27:55David Mandel: That's right.
- 27:56David Mandel: There's there's you're talking and I'm I think that's right.
- 28:03R: I feel the volcano in reality.
- 28:04R: I love it.
- 28:05David Mandel: Well, it's it's making me think about you know that we have allowed ourselves professionals, so I'm gonna kind of name name us as a group, to be lazy.
- 28:16David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 28:17R: It is lazy.
- 28:18R: It's not just lazy.
- 28:19R: It's not just lazy.
- 28:21R: It's dangerous.
- 28:22R: It's it's malfeasance, but it's malpractice, but what's it?
- 28:27R: All the mouths.
- 28:28R: It's all the mouths, okay?
- 28:36David Mandel: So it it's all the mouths, and I I think it's i i you know, this idea that i denial becomes this proxy word, it's value laden for all the things that we've said.
- 28:48David Mandel: Yeah.
- 28:49David Mandel: And it becomes a shorthand and it becomes a justification for removing kids from survivors, for instance, or doing other things.
- 28:59David Mandel: Right.
- 28:59R: Or removing women's liberties.
- 29:01David Mandel: Right.
- 29:02R: Or m removing men's liberties.
- 29:03R: That's right.
- 29:04R: It's very denial not as much, but but labels themselves.
- 29:07R: Very important.
- 29:09David Mandel: And and and that to really to really understand that we we must ethically and for for the safety of children and for well-being of families, do the work to show the work and say what's our worry, what's the danger here?
- 29:28David Mandel: Yeah.
- 29:28David Mandel: And the danger isn't the denial, the danger is the perpetrator's behavior.
- 29:34David Mandel: And to turn it up.
- 29:36R: We have a pharma implement going by.
- 29:38R: That's right.
- 29:39R: We all are just gonna have to be patient here for a second.
- 29:42R: Okay.
- 29:43David Mandel: To to really this pivot to the perpetrator is so important.
- 29:47David Mandel: And so again, I'm gonna kind of break this down.
- 29:49David Mandel: This is probably enough for this episode, you know, in terms of what to do, but it's it's say what is she doing or saying that's making you believe or think or conclude that she's in denial?
- 29:59David Mandel: Again, framing this now as a conclusion, not as a fact.
- 30:03R: Right.
- 30:04David Mandel: And then and then asking, okay, what's your worry about those that that behavior, you know.
- 30:10David Mandel: She's saying she keeps going back to him, what's your worry about that?
- 30:13David Mandel: Right.
- 30:14David Mandel: And that should, in most cases, bring you to to the doorstep of the perpetrator's behavior, which you then could say, okay, let's explore that.
- 30:21David Mandel: And then for me, as as the person doing consultation to doing the work, I I could often say, okay, so I totally understand based on what you're describing about his behaviors that you'd be worried he's gonna do X, kill her, keep the kids from her.
- 30:33David Mandel: That's what it let's talk about one now, how the system's tried to intervene with him.
- 30:38David Mandel: Let's talk about what we can do now to intervene with him.
- 30:40David Mandel: Let's make sure your documentation reflects what we just talked about.
- 30:44David Mandel: Not that she's in denial, but his behavior continues to be your concern.
- 30:48David Mandel: Now, with that new framework, let's talk about how you can partner with her.
- 30:53David Mandel: Because if you go in and say to her, you're in denial, and the answer is more education, she's often going to be resistant.
- 31:00David Mandel: You're gonna entrap her more versus you going to say to her, hey, I'm worried too that he's dangerous.
- 31:06David Mandel: I see how hard you're working to keep the kids safe.
- 31:08David Mandel: Let's collaborate together to figure out what will make things better for you.
- 31:13R: So there's another piece of the there's another plea piece of real important information that will come out of questioning the term denial, because it always leads back to she keeps going back, or I'm afraid, you know, she won't leave, either of those two.
- 31:29R: And that is that you know, being curious and saying you know, talk to me about that will lead us to the perpetrator.
- 31:37R: But also if you're a really adept professional, if you really know your stuff, if you're good at asking questions and you're really good at listening, you will hear the ecosystem around that survivor.
- 31:49R: You may hear things like she keeps going back to him because her mother keeps kicking her out of the house because she doesn't think that they should be divorced.
- 31:58R: Okay, now you have a case of lateral violence.
- 32:01R: You should know as a professional that that that there is that there is an ecosystem of entrapment and coercive control around that woman, and then you should move to being able to understand how to support her with that lack of support and that danger that's being caused by that lateral violence.
- 32:20R: A lot of times, denial is not just about the perpetrator.
- 32:24R: Denial is about lateral violence, it's about a structure of social control, it's about isolation.
- 32:33R: Think about our episode where we talked about rural communities.
- 32:37R: Right.
- 32:37R: Okay?
- 32:38R: Right.
- 32:38R: Where a woman who's fleeing domestic violence gets on a ferry, and I think about the Azores, because these are teeny islands and everybody knows each other and we're all related.
- 32:47R: Okay?
- 32:48R: This island's the biggest island.
- 32:50R: There's islands like Corvo where there's very few people or few thousand people.
- 32:54R: A few thousand people.
- 32:55R: So if a woman is being abused by her partner on those islands and she needs to escape, she needs to get on an airplane or a boat and leave.
- 33:07R: And so understanding denial may be understanding the impediments that are real to that person, to them finding safety in the context they're in.
- 33:17David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: Right.
- 33:18David Mandel: And so the danger here, just to just to keep reinforcing what we're talking about, is is going to this place of psychological explanations based on theories that have problematic origins at best.
- 33:34R: Can you imagine, though, being a victim survivor who is trying to flee domestic abuse and maybe you live on one of the many islands in the Philippines.
- 33:45R: And your social worker comes from one of the larger islands and tells you you're in denial because you won't leave your perpetrator.
- 33:53R: Right.
- 33:53R: What a bunch of crazy making, crazy incompetent, I want to use a curse word.
- 33:59R: There we go.
- 34:01David Mandel: Okay.
- 34:01David Mandel: You can imagine what she said.
- 34:04David Mandel: But it it it's really, you know, this is for for me again to to to direct this to professionals to really understand that we have power to either increase entrapment by the language we use or decrease it.
- 34:20David Mandel: And and and the language we use is can hurt or can help.
- 34:27R: The language that we can use can lead to further entrapment and that woman's death and those children's further abuse.
- 34:34R: And that is very real.
- 34:36David Mandel: Yes.
- 34:36David Mandel: And and it's so for us, the possibility of suggesting you can do this with different language.
- 34:43David Mandel: You can keep kids safe, you can partner with survivors.
- 34:46David Mandel: And and so what my my direct suggestion for professionals is go a week, go a month without using the word denial.
- 34:56David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 34:56R: Every time.
- 34:57R: As it relates to domestic abuse.
- 35:04David Mandel: Okay.
- 35:05R: Maybe that'll help.
- 35:08David Mandel: And and and one last one last um, you know, we're going to be doing this bridging, I think, a little more on this podcast is if you're using AI and you're using untrained AI, it's very dangerous.
- 35:21David Mandel: Be really careful about the answers it gives you in areas like this, because untrained AI is going to the common cultural narrative.
- 35:31David Mandel: So all of the Trevor Burrus, it's even worse.
- 35:33R: It's very victim-blaming.
- 35:34R: It's very dangerous.
- 35:36David Mandel: And it's also it's it's it's programming to please will follow if you're already talking about denial.
- 35:41R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: If you're like an abusive guy and you go on AI and you you bent to AI about your story of abusing your partner.
- 35:47R: AI is going to be like, oh, you're a good guy.
- 35:50David Mandel: Right.
- 35:50R: You're good.
- 35:51R: You're all okay.
- 35:52David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 35:52David Mandel: But part of, you know, specifically to this is I've been I've been we've been working to train the Safety Nexus AI and constantly comparing it to untrained AI and the answers are really different.
- 36:07David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 36:07R: They're very dangerous.
- 36:08David Mandel: Trevor Burrus And and one of the places it's different is it doesn't know how untrained AI doesn't know how to deal with this kind of situation.
- 36:15David Mandel: And it follows this cultural slash professional narrative.
- 36:20David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Right.
- 36:20David Mandel: And doesn't question it.
- 36:22David Mandel: And safe and together gives you tangible, concrete methodologies to not only question the practice, but change the practice.
- 36:34David Mandel: And that's so critical.
- 36:36R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: And powerfully not to change the practice in a structural way that knocks up against things like forms or your mandated actions, but that really just changes language.
- 36:49R: It changes the focus of the language.
- 36:51R: And that is really in your control.
- 36:53R: That's in your control.
- 36:54R: Even in the report context that you're all existing in, even in the different documentation worlds that we all have to live in, and we all have to live in documentation worlds, you can change your language.
- 37:07R: Now there is going to be mandated language that you have to use, terms that are culturally applied, that are more about the culture of that organization.
- 37:18R: It is not necessary to use the words denial or failure to protect.
- 37:24R: That is a cultural thing.
- 37:26R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 37:26David Mandel: Right.
- 37:26David Mandel: These are a lot of things are within your control.
- 37:29David Mandel: That's the good news for professionals, is it's within your control to change today.
- 37:35David Mandel: So my invitation is for next week or next month is to do your practice without ever writing down or using the word with another professional or using it with a survivor themselves, the word denial with about survivors.
- 37:49R: Take it out of your own.
- 37:50David Mandel: And take it out and see what it shift in the way you work.
- 37:53R: Auto-delete, auto-delete, auto-delete, auto-delete.
- 37:56David Mandel: All right.
- 37:57David Mandel: So this has been our far-reaching, but also very narrowly focused.
- 38:02R: It was very narrowly focused.
- 38:03R: This is not one of our deep dives.
- 38:05R: Did you know that our listeners prefer at least an hour of conversation?
- 38:10David Mandel: Oh my God.
- 38:11R: I know.
- 38:11R: Right?
- 38:12R: They like the chitter chatter.
- 38:13David Mandel: They like the chitter chatter.
- 38:15David Mandel: So anyway, I don't know how long this one was.
- 38:17David Mandel: But I really appreciate your land acknowledgement and and I think we're going to have to start doing video so people can see, particularly see you and the passion and the feeling you bring to the conversation.
- 38:34David Mandel: And to see more of our dynamic, I guess, might be might be interesting and illuminating.
- 38:39David Mandel: But you uh if you like this, please, please like it on the platform you're listening.
- 38:45David Mandel: Please share it.
- 38:47David Mandel: Please make comments.
- 38:48David Mandel: All these things increase our listenership, to be honest, and really let us know what's going on.
- 38:52David Mandel: Yeah.
- 38:54R: Please, please, please make an audio clip of me going and loop it on a button whenever you hear the word denial or failure to protect.
- 39:04David Mandel: Really?
- 39:04David Mandel: Okay.
- 39:05David Mandel: This is what are you doing?
- 39:06David Mandel: Are you gonna make a meme?
- 39:06David Mandel: Are you gonna make I will.
- 39:08David Mandel: Okay.
- 39:08R: I will make media for this.
- 39:09R: You'll make media.
- 39:10David Mandel: I will make media for this.
- 39:11David Mandel: So you've been listening to Partner with Survivor.
- 39:14David Mandel: And who are you?
- 39:15David Mandel: I'm David Mandel still.
- 39:17R: And my name is Ruth Raimundo.
- 39:19R: And we are out.
- 39:23David Mandel: Out.