Latest / Neon Protocol / The Human Side of Immersive Tech
Transcript
- Gene Feldman: Tonight on Neon Protocol, we're diving straight into the systems shaping what comes next. I'm Gene Feldman and tonight we're also joined by Ron Thompson, Lucky Gobindrom, Damon Shackelford and Mike Van. Together we're the Neon Protocol team that's gonna be exploring XR, AI, spatial computing and the various infrastructures that make them real. We're here to break down what's working, what's changing and what's about to break open. So in this episode, the Neon Protocol we're going to sit down with Bobby Carlton of FS Studios to dig into psychology behind immersive learning. Together, ⁓ we're going to explore why XR experiences can accelerate skill development and how organizations are using them to solve real world challenges. And what it actually takes for design training to design training that changes behavior. The one thing I like is Bobby brings a very grounded practical view of where immersive tech is headed and really why it represents a fundamental shift in the human learn in human learning, not just another trend. And I say this from practical experience because as much as people credit me either being an OG or being, you know, having these very developed XR projects in the past, Bobby has been my really one of my mentors and my inspiration. So I'm excited, Bobby, for you to join the show today. Really, I credit you for some of my first sparks. And so ⁓ I could introduce you and I would just gush all over how cool I think you are, but I'll let you introduce yourself and what you'd like to share. And welcome to the program. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Well, thanks for having me everyone. appreciate being on the show, especially here on May 4th, Star Wars Day. So that's, you know, when I got the message, I was like, I can't resist. How do I say no to Gene Feldman and crew on Star Wars Day? So that's great being on the show. You got your best Palpatine, if anything. Mike Vann: you Damon Shackelford: Exactly, part of the nefarious plan. Gene Feldman: Absolutely. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: in our fully operational podcast. Mike Vann: Thanks. Bobby Carlton: So, yeah, so I remember meeting Eugene back in the day I was working for the Elliott Mazze. I was running, I was director of a project called BR Learned before then. ⁓ Just to give good background, I worked for Apple for like 10 years. I was doing education technology, ⁓ specifically for Apple product and Apple software. And... ⁓ And then when I left there, I went over to ⁓ Elliot, Elliot Mazzee at the Mazzee Center, did work with him. We did a lot of VR training at the time. ⁓ We had a DK1. We were one of the first to get a DK1. It's sitting right down here. ⁓ we got the version that was signed by the whole team. ⁓ so we started digging into it and... We were working with corporate learners and leaders and then doing work with the military on sort of at the time VR adoption. What were the steps, what was involved? Did that for a bunch of years. ⁓ Partnered with Elliot ⁓ beyond that first year. I was doing work with like Motorola and Siemens and just getting a lot of different work in that area. And then since then, I will say that as XR technology change and we saw the sort of landscape of VR shift slightly, know, obviously AR technology came as well. ⁓ I began to pivot myself, you know, still very much involved with XR training and virtual reality and what's going on with the hardware and how people are approaching learning. But I had shifted more to the sort of the digital twinning synthetic data robotics side, which still leverages headsets and still leverages AR technology. And so that's where I am now at FS Studio. So we do a lot of that type of digital solutions work, which again includes not just like the physical AI work and synthetic data and all that, but it does include virtual reality and augmented reality solutions when our clients ask for that. And we still see a good amount of it. Obviously, as you guys know, ⁓ the landscape of VR training has changed. I remember we went to that, what I used to call like the wild west of VR. If you remember where it was like when HTC was holding these like poshie New York City events, inviting, and at that time I was writing for VR scouts. yeah, so I was getting invited to these like poshie, like pop-up events. Damon Shackelford: Yes. Gene Feldman: I remember. Bobby Carlton: where they were like, try out the HTC Cosmos, try out this, the new Pico headset. And you'd go to these activations. And I remember going to the Microsoft ⁓ HoloLens 2 launch in this place I could never even imagine living in, in Manhattan. was in lower Manhattan, this like beautiful four story apartments with a pool in it. And they were doing... like hololens to activations. Damon Shackelford: Wow. Gene Feldman: I still remember when we were at OC6 and they just announced Horizon and Meta, well, it was Facebook at the time, but at the time they had a physical model of the entire Horizon world laid out as a physical model. So you could actually walk around it in real life and see it. Yeah. And it's kind of one those things that now, and this kind of is actually where I kind of want to the conversation because it almost seems like Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Gene Feldman: what was the coolest toy in the room that really sparked a lot of attention. And by you with writing with VR Scott, which I think you've had the opportunity to see so much, you know. Bobby Carlton: I was very lucky. was, I was gonna say the VR scout gig was, if anything, opened up a lot of doors for me. Mike Vann: Yep, access, yep. Gene Feldman: Yeah. So I guess the question, you know, I mean, with the trends of it, you know, I mean, you getting into, you know, still robots still doing VR. Are you noticing a trend? You know, I know some of the times we've talked about where HQ is kind of seeing VR now as this add on luxury item. Whereas the factories now who've always been kind of our Achilles heel, cause we never had a really good solution or had the safety glasses. Now they're actually showing interest. by dipping their toes in the AI world and seeing where they can take it. kind of curious what your thoughts are, where you've seen it based on your experience. Bobby Carlton: Mm-hmm. Yes. Well, think, you mentioned AI, obviously AI is a massive tool right now and everybody is trying to leverage, you know, how is AI, whether it's co-pilot, you know, whether it's omniverse or something, know, physical AI. And physical AI, you know, is that sort of that bridges that gap between the digital solution and the actual hardware, you know, the robot or the conveyor system. And that's where I think, you know, where I think virtual reality was trying to gap. You know, there were, there, I think there were companies who were like, you know, this technology is going to change the learning process by gapping the digital content, you know, the, the second life type of experiences. And, and, and, and I think, it, just, it, it struggled to find a spot, but physical AI seems to have found that spot. Damon Shackelford: you Bobby Carlton: But the interesting thing is because of that, it's now kind of pulling in virtual reality, right? It's now pulling in augmented reality. you're starting to see, yes, Meta seems to have abandoned, not totally abandoned, but they've sort of shifted their priorities on VR, but they haven't completely given up on VR. And matter of fact, they're still very much ⁓ pursuing wearables because they're looking at like that type of technology. Damon Shackelford: Mm. Bobby Carlton: And I think the term VR has changed for them. It doesn't have to be sort of what we thought VR was, like this immersive virtual content, but VR could be. in audio experience. could be through wearables. It could be sort of like this experience where you're getting some sort of information or data through a device. so that the virtual world is sort of been... Damon Shackelford: You Bobby Carlton: exploded out of what we see through a headset, if that makes sense. And so physical AI or AI tools is starting to kind of pull all those aspects into it. And so that's where I think we're in an interesting space, in my opinion, with that. Damon Shackelford: Hmph. Gene Feldman: No, I agree because I think you know, especially as now you're hearing that Google's teaming up with ⁓ I just linked out ⁓ Bobby Carlton: you Gene Feldman: The Sunglass Company. Bobby Carlton: ⁓ I know the problem. Ron: Gucci. Gucci. Gene Feldman: Just yeah, I was just talking about with somebody the other day. Ron was bringing it up. ⁓ Gucci, you know, now that you're seeing other brands now starting to actually get into it, you know, that it didn't take long for Oak or for Oakley to follow suit. You know, so you're seeing, and you're seeing some, what I like to say is you're seeing these everyday use cases that. Ron: The Gucci? Damon Shackelford: ⁓ Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Gene Feldman: VR, even though it was great and we were all great champions for it, it lacked it. was either, it just didn't have, to me, didn't have the flexibility just to put it on and go. There was too much, there's still too much preparation for it. Bobby Carlton: That is so on the spot. Again, I have the meta glasses and I love them. They're not ⁓ the displays because I don't need the displays. I need to be able to get a text message, send a text message, answer phone calls, listen to music, ask the AI. Though the AI is not the greatest, the AI does help. The live translations actually works pretty well. The ⁓ conversation focus is a feature I never thought I would ever use. Not sure if you're aware, but so the glasses for conversation focus, if I'm in a crowded room, I can activate it and it uses the mic to then amplify the person in front of me. So I get that matter restaurant, I can actually hear them all. It's a little tinny, but it's not but again, it's not perfect. But I think that, you know, where VR was difficult because it wasn't that. Mike Vann: Yeah, it's pretty good. Bobby Carlton: throw it on and go, right? mean, and it wasn't easy. Unfortunately, that was one of its biggest roadblocks. It just wasn't easy. wasn't, if you talk to trainers, talk, if you talk to someone on the ground of a manufacturing company who saw the potential of virtual reality, they're like, VR is gonna change training and this is how we're gonna do it. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Bobby Carlton: and they are selling it to the stakeholders. Right, Gene, exactly. But then you have the people at the top, the people who are doing the math and they're like, wait a minute. So how long does it take for someone to put on the VR headset and then learn the process? Okay, few minutes. Now they're like, well, okay, few minutes times 500 employees. They're like, well, that's starting to add up. And then now they're wondering. Plus, now you have to buy the headsets. then there's the individuals who maybe they're not as savvy as some, and they take 10 minutes to learn the headset. And I think that's where VR struggled, in my opinion. ⁓ And... But the potential, like what you could do with it and what you could do in it was amazing. You were able to change the learner's perspective. You were able to evoke an emotion, obviously. You were able to ⁓ evoke... challenges where, where if they failed, they felt like we're, ⁓ my God, I'm, I could get electrocuted. Like, cause they truly felt that, that, that, that, that the psychology, right. This is what we're talking about in psychology of VR training. Like training itself, you know, is already like, like a mind fuck. Can I say that? Can I swear on this podcast? Gene Feldman: Absolutely. Absolutely. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Ha ha! Damon Shackelford: ⁓ the AI will beep it. It'll be a MINE POOP! Gene Feldman: No, no, absolutely. Cause like I said, yeah, this is strictly, this is us talking. This is what people, to me, I think these are the conversations that people are getting new into the field want to hear. They don't want to hear the, know, we're creating synergies. No, we're cause yeah, cause Bobby Carlton: Yes! Okay. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: What? Gene Feldman: I agree with you. mean, we have, it's like spaghetti. We have thrown VR at almost everything that we could possibly think of to try to find that in over the years. Bobby Carlton: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mike Vann: So let me ask a question for Bobby. ⁓ So Bobby, Mike Van, ⁓ Agents of Play. We work with large enterprise companies to ⁓ develop immersive and now a lot of AI and we're starting to get into physical AI as well. We have a lot of enterprise partners asking for education about how to think about physical AI across their workspace. With all that said is physical AI and robotics, the third or forthcoming of VR headsets through training, through synthetic data and training of humanoid robots. Damon Shackelford: Third or fourth coming. I wish Bob were here to hear that. Gene Feldman: The third coming. love how you put that. Bobby Carlton: Thank Mike Vann: I mean, we're going through cycles, right? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hahaha Mike Vann: It could be the thing. Bobby Carlton: Well, you know, I think I was definitely in that bucket for a while, right? Where like, this is a great story. So I I talked about Elliot earlier, Elliot Mazze, Gene, and you guys maybe know Elliot Mazze, maybe you don't, but Elliot was considered this, I think he's a brilliant man, a ⁓ learning guru, like this guy. Gene Feldman: You Damon Shackelford: You Gene Feldman: Yeah, the, the bit in learning and the learning world, the best way to sum them up, he is the one who created the phrase e-learning. Bobby Carlton: Yes, he is the guy. so Elliot and I worked for Elliot and Elliot, ⁓ I remember ⁓ when I first joined his team and Elliot and I before then we used to nerd out. We'd sit at the coffee shop and we'd nerd about like technology and. Damon Shackelford: Hmm. ⁓ Bobby Carlton: And we talked a lot about like second life. talked about the potential of, you know, how, how learning and education could change. so we really jammed and got along really well. And so when I became ⁓ a manager, a director of this project called VR learn for him, he, know, we started having these conversations and, ⁓ I was really sort of caught up in the excitement of virtual reality, you know, like that, like, this is going to change everything. This is, this is going in and he stopped me. And this is honestly ⁓ something that I walked away with and I held onto. And he just looked at me said, stop advocating for this technology. He's like, the moment you advocate for VR, you might as well be working at ⁓ a store selling underwear to someone who just says, I want underwear. ⁓ And he was right in that. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: that like I needed to start poking holes. He's like, I'm bringing you here because I need you to, like you asked these questions in our coffee shop conversations. I need you to ask those questions. I don't need you to advocate for it. I need you to poke holes in it. I need you to say, where does it work? And so Mike, to go back to you, like, do I see virtual reality through physical AI being the sort of like fifth coming, sixth coming of VR? Through that lens of Elliot? What's that? Yeah, through that lens of Elliot, I would say that there, and I know it's gonna sound negative, but there is nothing. Gene Feldman: You Damon Shackelford: It's AI math. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hahaha Gene Feldman: Absolutely. Bobby Carlton: that's going to push VR technology into the place where I think that sort of the VR advocates want it to be. It just won't happen. But I do think that there is a place for VR technology. I do think, and I'm speaking of VR as in the sense of headset VR, immersive, yeah, fully immersive. Mike Vann: sets. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: fully immersive. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: that yes, there is a place for that. I do think with, as I mean, look at tele-op robotics training, right? I mean, how that's where we're training robots simply by putting out a VR headset and then we're capturing our hand motion, we're doing tasks and that data is using training robots. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: So Bobby, question for you. So basically, mean, as you know, we're like training humans and machines for the same future sort of kind of, right? Like ⁓ XR helps people rehearse high stakes moments. Physical AI helps machines understand and act in the real world. The overlap is simulation, right? At the core, like digital twins, synthetic data, spatial computing, and immersive environments where humans and AI can both learn and both realities get expensive, but like, know, Bobby Carlton: This is it. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It's sort of the way they connect, right? Bobby Carlton: Yeah, yeah. mean, that's the thing. That's where, again, going back to the physical AI, that's where I think it's interesting that physical AI, again, was sort of like this one thought process, but now we're starting to see how it's stretching out into other ways. The human element, the robotics element, the training element, the data collection element. Gene Feldman: No, and, and this actually gets to kind of a good point. Cause for me, I've always argued that AI can never understand the human condition, but for us with our human condition, we need AI to be more than just words on a screen. You know, when I see work, when I see AI, that's words on a screen, honestly, my first thought it goes to mother and alien. You know, it's, you know, or war games, you know, I don't want to play a game. I. Bobby Carlton: Hmm. Gene Feldman: You know, I, want to talk to somebody. And even when, you know, war games, you know, all of us that watched the movie, the minute he put the phone on and all of a sudden we could hear the computer. was like revolutionary for us at the time. Bobby Carlton: Sure. Yeah. I think that goes back to the subject matter of what we're talking about, the psychology of VR training or digital immersive training, right? I think I was starting to say earlier, when someone says I have to do training, it's instantly a negative thing. Like, oh, Jesus, how long is it going to be? Do I have to do this every year? yeah, how many videos? Do I to take a test at the end? It is so, so, so Mike Vann: many videos. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: I end with like, this sucks. Damon Shackelford: Right, right. and HR and all the things we hate about those sorts of organizations looking over your shoulder. Gene Feldman: absolutely, absolutely. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It does, it sucks terribly. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. I think it's really interesting. It's more of a hatred for HR. Gene Feldman: Absolutely. that's, yeah, I think that's where I come at from the other perspective than everybody else. I'm the one you guys all hate because I'm the one that's writing the training. Yeah. And I made Cheat because I have access to the database of answers, but I think, I think we're. Damon Shackelford: Hahaha! Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Ha Damon Shackelford: But there's training and then there's training, know, that bad taste kind of training. That's that corpority, mandatory, gobbledygook that we all have to do on an annual basis because some lawyer somewhere won a case. We hate it. We hate it. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hotch out! Bobby Carlton: Right. But, Lucky Lance K Gobindram: So what should learning and development leaders be paying attention to right now then? Is the future of training still courseware or is it moving toward dynamic simulation in real time practice environments, right? Like, you know, this is a verdict that I think is debatable in so many ways. I spent my day at AI conference and there was a huge argument. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. I think that is one of those things where it depends on who you talk to, who you ask, right? It's like going to a Knicks fan, being like, who's the greatest basketball team in the world? And they're going be like, it's the fucking Knicks. Who do you fucking think is the best? it's like, but the fact is, it depends on who you talk to. Damon Shackelford: Well said, well said! Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Ha ⁓ There is no debate there, gentlemen. Damon Shackelford: There is none. Bobby Carlton: Because you are an advocate for the Knicks, right? you, you, you, that, and I think that applies to, like, we can, I mean, we can tie it to Star Wars, right? New Hope, Empire Strikes Back, that's my Star Wars. That's my generation of Star Wars. You asked my stepson, his generation of Star Wars is Clone Wars. And he's gonna tell me. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Yeah. Bobby Carlton: clonored with the best Star Wars and you can't tell me differently. You ask my daughter and she's gonna say, oh yeah, you I love the Force Awakens. You know, like, it is each generation's, each individual's perspective of like, ownership. And I think with training, know, lucky, did you answer your question in my opinion, this is just, I'm just one cog in the wheel of many cogs. Damon Shackelford: Same thing in my household, yep. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Sure. Bobby Carlton: But I think it all depends on who you ask for, are they? Are they the stakeholder? they on the floor? And does virtual reality training or does traditional training matter? You asked my wife who's an HR, she works HR for a huge AEC company. They're like, no one does immersive training. They're like, we don't do that. You do training like this, and that's how they do it. ⁓ Damon Shackelford: Mmm. Yeah. Wow. Wow. Gene Feldman: It, it, it's very much a push back to instructor led lecture training because it, it's the most, yeah, it's the most efficient way to deliberate. But this is where I kind of think about it. And since it's star Wars day and we've kind of danced around star Wars, I'm really going to bring, I'm really bringing it forefront because I've argued that physical AI in this kind of where I was going with the, you know, our human connect condition is the C three PO R two D two. Bobby Carlton: And use the drug, you You should know. Yeah. Gene Feldman: are the greatest examples of working AI within humanity or alien, amenity, however, whatever the creatures are. But you watch the idea that George Lucas presented. It's very much like how Gene Roddenberry presented the tri quarter. He presented these droids that had, they were trained for function, but they were also trained to have some adaptability to apply that function to other things, but they didn't take over. we did. And the last thing we did is we didn't follow them blindly. You know, I mean, having C3PO the way he was, okay, I'm not going to follow this robot blindly, but you know, he, they're providing assistance to us. And I, and I think that's where. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Mike Vann: Thank Damon Shackelford: Alright. Gene Feldman: As we get into this physical AI that I think of what if that we could have a combination of having an AI trainer that can deliver a consistent message each and every time that can be that captivating way or that you can adjust it say 60 % of this class is learning dominant style behavior or not learning. Listening. I'm hoping they're all learning. They're listening dominant. Bobby Carlton: It was the eighth one. Gene Feldman: So the AI can adjust on the fly its delivery method to adjust the predominant learners in that class. ⁓ Bobby Carlton: Yeah, know, Agendic avatars, right? And we're talking about like, there's a, like, you know, we've seen meta-human work. Unreal Engine has an SDK that, you know, and there's some amazing meta-human work out there. But I think, I will say some of the conversations that we're having with clients is like, they, you who are looking for that sort of, training mechanism with Agendic AI, with photo-realistic avatars. Like they, They want, you know, they're like, Hey, we're not abandoning sort of virtual reality solutions and technology and training. We just want it to be more human-like, which is a really odd thing to ask in my opinion. Like you're like, you're telling me you want a digital solution that you want to be more human-like. And then, so why don't you just have a human do it? And this is a great example. I remember I was talking to a friend of mine who works at Home Depot. He's a Home Depot employee. He's not, and there's nothing to do with technology. He's a buddy of mine. Mike Vann: Mm-hmm. Bobby Carlton: we get beers together, we nerd out on horror movies and sci-fi. And he asked me one day, like, what do do? And I'm like, well, know, this is back when I was deep in the VR days working at Mazy Center. And he's like, what do you do? And I'm like, oh, you know, like, I, you know, we explore, you know, these digital solutions for training, how to train, you know, change training through full 360 immersive worlds. put on a headset. Damon Shackelford: Hahaha Bobby Carlton: And then, you know, and he's like, well, what do do with this? And I was like, well, you you do the task like you, you know, like you're doing all the tasks and you learn how to do it. I think, well, why don't you just do that in the real world? Like, why do you do it? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: ⁓ But like, isn't that just like, know, it's XR and like spatial is just a content format, right? It creates a rehearsal layer, right? And like, I get it, we want them to be more human. don't know, sometimes I think like, you cause this is all, live in braveness at this point and like, it's not even about like them looking more real. It's like, okay, them stuttering, them having inflection, them pushing back in the real world, right? It's like, these are the types of things that make them more human, making mistakes, right? Being human. Damon Shackelford: Exist. Exist. Exist. Bobby Carlton: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Mike Vann: Making mistakes, right? Being human. Yeah. Bobby Carlton: Making a choice. Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: And when you get that right, all of sudden the human mind forgets that guy looks like a cartoon and he's getting real world play and practice. You're getting rid of the practice tax on the business, right? Bobby Carlton: I think that's really good point. And I think that's where I think some VR training went wrong. It was like too on the spot, like, wait, rehearsed perfect. Like it needs to be able to have this component where in the middle of the training, I have a question. Like I have a question. Like remember Elliot, he was like, he'd be talking and I want to my hand. And I think with VR training that I've seen, was never a, it was like, they tell you what to do, you do it. And then you get the, A, B, choose A, B and C. And then it tells you you did wrong, you did right. But. But that's where I think experiences could improve. And I think with AI tools, Agenda AI, physical AI, ⁓ wow. large language models, you know, that again, we'll start to kind of bring that together. It's like Captain Kirk, right? And Captain Kirk can't do everything on the enterprise, but he, he, he brought in like experts to surround him. And I think with, with AI, physical AI, it's like, okay, now this is like the center and now it's bringing the other elements into the training where now we're, I think we could be that place where the training, as you say, Lucky, you, you know, like it makes mistakes, it'll stop, it'll answer a question. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah, I mean, we've all seen AI avatars that feel dead on arrival, right? Like, you know, like the branching dialogues that feel like choose your own adventure book or chatbot interactions that feel robotic, right? It's the worst, right? Like, it's got to be authentic, right? It's got to be driven by a principle that believability beats intelligence, right? It's not even about that. A brilliant answer delivered in a robotic cadence breaks immersion instantly, but a slightly imperfect response. Damon Shackelford: Too much literature. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. ⁓ my God, the worst. ⁓ Mike Vann: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Ha ha ha! Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: one with like realistic hesitation, emotional memory, genuine body language, that changes behavior, right? Bobby Carlton: That changes the hit. ⁓ yeah, yeah. And I think that's what's, again, I think that's where VR sort of maybe missed the mark. But at the same time, VR came at a very odd early time. know, I used to... Damon Shackelford: Mm. Bobby Carlton: You know, I used to kind of say how before virtual reality, like, you know, technology was always the answer to a problem, right? I love hot coffee. I love to drink hot coffee at home, but now I want to go in my car while I'm not going to put a mug in my car. The phone was like, Hey, I will create a portable mug. Right. And they have this mug, you know, and the answer was technology. Technology said, no, drink, but no, wait, now when I drive the coffee splash, I got to make a lid. And if you remember the old Dunkin' Donuts lid, right? The flat lid, being a top off, those sucked. And people complained about it. The answer was, turn to technology and now let's make the lid so it's like a volcano. it was, we, technology was always the answer to a problem. then for me, VR was a solution that they were like, well, we don't know what the problem is, but we got the solution. So let's just try to make it work everywhere. Damon Shackelford: Hmm. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Terrible. Gene Feldman: Yeah, and I think it ⁓ good Bobby Carlton: And unfortunately, I think that's where in that early stage of virtual reality training and education sort of, I don't want to say failed, but just sort of like couldn't find traction in my opinion. But I do think if VR came out today, where like if it came out today, but I think it be a much different story. Yeah. Gene Feldman: Well, well, it Lucky Lance K Gobindram: world. AI first, leaner, changes everything, right? Gene Feldman: Absolutely. And I think the three disruptions that XR experienced throughout the past couple of years didn't help, know, from going, you know, from first week, you know, we entered the pandemic, which was a sweet spot for VR because of remote work and what we could do. But then NFTs reared their ugly head and, and everybody jumped on the profit bandwagon, you know, and I'm still going, I could just screenshot your NFT and have it for free. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. ⁓ my god. Yeah. Right. I own that. Gene Feldman: And yeah, and then all of a sudden you get into, okay, we get out of the pandemic. We have to return back to the office quest for business closes, you know? So now the support system for what we had, because for me, you know, pushing it in office, the last thing you're anybody's going to want it when you want interaction is 30 people in cubes, all on VR headsets. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Yeah. I think that was, I think that was a hard sell. You know, the thinking about like, again, as an employer, like, are people wearing headsets? Like what's going on? Like, wait, what are you, what are they looking at? You know, what are they doing? And then, and then once we got past that hump, and then there was like that big push of like getting headsets on the floor of the manufacturing. There was no way the liability that, that, yeah. Gene Feldman: Cough Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It's dangerous. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Bobby Carlton: Like, ⁓ Gene's training on the floor, the VR headset. But don't worry, because the Path 2 cameras are so good. what? ⁓ Damon Shackelford: You Mike Vann: Okay. Gene Feldman: But that's okay, if my battery dies, I can still feel. Bobby Carlton: So I just think that... Yeah, You know, yeah, I've got this four-pound battery up in the back of my head. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ gosh. ⁓ Lucky Lance K Gobindram: I got a backup battery, Gene, come on. Swap it. It's a hard swap. Gene Feldman: It's a hot swap. Damon Shackelford: I hit a pack in my head Gene Feldman: That's all you want to do when you're hanging off a Raptor is hot swap a VR battery. Bobby Carlton: you Yeah, hold on a second, I'm swapping a battery. ⁓ Gene Feldman: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ Mike Vann: So let me bring it all the way back around to Star Wars. So the space industry and everything we're hearing about space and going to the moon and creating fab factories, we're going to build ⁓ humanoid, we're going to build robotics. Yeah, we're going to build stuff on the moon and then we're going to go to Mars and we're going to fab there. Where does XR, where does all of this fit into actually making all of that stuff happen? mean, again, it feels like Damon Shackelford: Hmm. data centers in orbit. Mike Vann: there's a role there. It's just that all of these tools that everyone here has been pushing on for 20 years, that's where it's going to find a home. Bobby Carlton: ⁓ I agree. mean, and that's where like the tele app work is going to be super. super important. That's where the layer of the VR headset or the again or the AR glasses, know, Snapchat, you know, their glasses and displays. Teleop is going to be ⁓ that tool, again, either used for the VR training for the data collection or for the, you know, the sort of jumping in on the fly to help unstick a robot in a situation. take over the Mike Vann: Just take over the body through the headset. Bobby Carlton: body move it yet and get it unstuck. know, mean, Waymo, for example, I mean, you those autonomous vehicles, ⁓ they, ⁓ you know, they have the ability, if it gets a situation where the passenger jump in, you know, hit a button and then someone can then, you know, remote into the vehicle. ⁓ And I've seen those with those, even those, the little food delivery robots, you know, that's, ⁓ and if need be, Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Human jumps in. Bobby Carlton: You know that they could, you know, I mean, use a VR headset, right? To sort of help guide the robot out of a situation. So there's definitely a layer there. I don't, you know, I do think virtual reality, I think as the hardware improves, I mean, you know, I think that as ⁓ the approach, like, know, streaming content to a headset versus having the content live on the headset, I think is going to help push, push, you know, VR into that next sort of ⁓ evolution of where it should be. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: Thank Lucky Lance K Gobindram: NVIDIA is doing some great work with that, right? Bringing things from the cloud to the device. It's making leaps and bounds. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Yeah. mean, HoloLite is, I mean, they're one company, they're really doing amazing things with, I mean, I have no ownership of them. That's just me just saying that they... But the fact that they're leveraging everything at AWS or on the web. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: But it's impressive, it's very impressive. Damon Shackelford: Hahaha! Bobby Carlton: And then just streaming it to a headset allows you to have that fidelity and that robust type of immersive experience, either through the Apple Vision Pro or an HTC or Quest 3. interesting times for sure. I don't know you guys have an Apple Vision Pro. I I have one. I don't use it as much. Damon Shackelford: for Lucky Lance K Gobindram: I do. I use it a lot actually. Mike Vann: It hasn't been out of the case in a couple of months. I feel badly about that, but I haven't used it in a bit. Damon Shackelford: Nah. Ha Lucky Lance K Gobindram: You know, I was using it pretty heavily when I was practicing. Oh, with the basketball game tonight, it's a good opportunity, You could set courtside. Gene Feldman: It's. Damon Shackelford: ran out of movies. Gene Feldman: Yeah, from- Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah, I was going to say for me, other than watching Apple TV for foundation. Bobby Carlton: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: You know, I used that pretty heavily to meet with my team. Damon Shackelford: Yeah, amazing visuals. Gene Feldman: But, but I think Apple, but I think Apple TV left a bad, I mean, even though was a great device and I've really been thinking about a lot lately cause the Gucci announcement, it just, was to me, it was high end, but I think it also was very misleading in that there were, you know, there's 300 apps ready to go. They're iPad apps. It. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Unless I want to watch air traffic control, I'm not really seeing anything different on this, you know? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: to that. Bobby Carlton: You don't want to watch your separate control? Damon Shackelford: These are not the apps you're looking for. Gene Feldman: Yeah, I mean- Lucky Lance K Gobindram: The NBA app is really impressive, to be honest with you. And on the Vision Pro, it's really impressive. There's been some other ones that are sports related that really impressive. But I think the killer use case of the Vision Pro is none of that, right? It's actually the personas. Like the fact that can gauze you and splat yourself and it looks like you, and I can take a meeting and you can be in my room. We could pull up a deck and practice what we're gonna do on stage together, or play chess, whatever it may be. But like, the presence is crazy. Mike Vann: Yeah, it is. Bobby Carlton: Mm-hmm. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. It is. It's an amazing... I absolutely agree. And to kind of piggyback off of what you're saying there, like there's parts of the Apple Vision Pro that I think are mind blowing. Like again, the presence. And I even think about the meta displays, right? The glasses themselves are impressive, not as impressive as the neural wristband. I think the neural wristband is going to be a massive, I think that's like the secret sauce that metas like, okay, like that's something that's probably more evolutionary than the display glasses. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah, crazy. Bobby Carlton: themselves. think having that and what Metta could possibly do with them, think will open up lot of ⁓ sort of ways for training, for ⁓ getting together with people, for connecting in different ways. So yeah, I think that that wristband is impressive. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: For sure. I think John Ternes is gonna turn it off, guys. think him coming to CEO of Apple is gonna have waves. Bobby Carlton: He's an interesting guy, yeah. He's got an interesting background. I'm not sure what Star Wars generation he is, whether he... He looks like a preples guy to me. Damon Shackelford: You know him? Gene Feldman: Hahaha! Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hahaha! Gene Feldman: You know what? He's an Apple. He's a Star Trek fan. Damon Shackelford: Noooo Lucky Lance K Gobindram: ⁓ come on! Bobby Carlton: I mean Gene Feldman: Hey, you know what they get? Hey, you can't argue. They gave us the tri quarter, man. It's they are star track. Bobby Carlton: I mean, Star Trek was right. gave us, They, they, the, the, the holodeck, right? I mean, I mean, yeah. But that's what VR kind of gave us, right? Is the holodeck. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: He's got to be in his 50s. Damon Shackelford: Gosh, yes, everybody in VR dreamed about the holotech. Gene Feldman: ⁓ but it Damon Shackelford: It was, yeah. Gene Feldman: And, seeing where, ⁓ Carrie's team with, ⁓ the igloo rooms over the past couple of weeks has been outstanding because they had their big 2.0 release, you know, and they're actually trying to get to it. It's not the full hologram, but I agree with you because one of the things, you know, I always think about is VR it right now that what hurts it is, is a solitary experience, shared reflection. So it's like going to a movie with somebody. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Bobby Carlton: Mm-hmm. Mm. Gene Feldman: I don't go to movie with somebody to talk to them during the movie. I know I'm weird like that. I go to talk to them either before or after the movie, especially after the movie, because I come from the generation where you go with your friends to a kung fu movie and you come out kicking everybody. Yeah, I am part of that generation where after the film, the best part going to the movie with your friends was acting it out afterwards. Bobby Carlton: What's wrong with you? ⁓ Yeah, like in the parking lot. right. Damon Shackelford: You Bobby Carlton: ⁓ I, yeah, I remember seeing Batman and all of us coming out, we're all Batman, just like... ⁓ Damon Shackelford: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah! Cause nobody wants to be Robin! Damon Shackelford: Yeah, well, right. Well, I mean, go all the way back to the original Star Wars. We all went home, we got on our bicycles, they were suddenly X-Wings and we were knocking each other off with sticks that we called lightsabers. Every one of us. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Yeah. But I think, yes, but yeah. that's what I think is the, again, going back to the psychology of training, right? That's what I think VR was trying to get. They were like, they were like, I want to give people that excitement that, of like, I'm in that world. Like I just saw Star Wars and I not, this stick is now a lightsaber. Yeah. Gene Feldman: Absolutely. Damon Shackelford: Yep, yep, yep, that common cultural moment. Yep. Gene Feldman: Yeah, absolutely. And that's where I think the holodeck gets into it is because the experiences that have the most impact are typically shared experience, shared reflection. You know, it's like an escape room. Escape rooms excite people because everybody's engaged, you know, except for the one person sitting in the corner and said, I figured it out in the first five minutes. You know, there was always that one person. Bobby Carlton: What? You're a fool, you! Gene Feldman: You know, but other than that, it's it's about creating that experience where I'm not in a headset isolated. You know, it's social. Bobby Carlton: I think, yeah, you know, the, where I think VR got it really good, got it right, was the social side of it, right? The VR, you ⁓ know, alt space VR, right? People were like hanging out, you know, there used to be those events, they still host those events in alt space. I think I did a couple, I did one on the solo movie, like, yeah. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ wow. Bobby Carlton: ⁓ But that's where I think they got it right. And I think on the training side, if there was a way, they tried to, they tried to get like these like, ⁓ doing all the like like virtual reality language lessons, right? And getting people in the room and you're just talking and. That's where I think it found some decent footing. And I always wish that Enterprise Solutions, ⁓ Gene looking at you and your work, your password, why you guys did not lean heavier into using a rec room or using ⁓ VR chat or something to be like, because that's what Second Life was, right? That's where Elliot saw Second Life. was like, I see the potential of this Damon Shackelford: Hmm. Bobby Carlton: world being corporate learning. Damon Shackelford: Mm. Gene Feldman: There were a couple in the enterprise, there were a couple of setbacks that just really killed us. The first one was teams. When teams came in, cause teams, cause at first we were actually partnering with spatial. So I was with spatial back when they were, I mean, do you even have legs? It was, it was just strung together, but it was, it was, it was such a neat idea. And so really tried using spatial, but then, um, Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Bobby Carlton: It's Gene Feldman: Meta decide not to use spatial and go to horizon. So what we thought was going to be our system turned out, okay, well now it's a little in between. And unfortunately, when you mentioned a social system set up by Facebook, people tend to not like it. absolutely. So it was an instant no. And then we were promised mesh from Microsoft for years. Okay, you got mesh coming. Bobby Carlton: Yeah, yeah, there was a lot of ⁓ Damon Shackelford: corporate security especially. Mike Vann: Yep. Bobby Carlton: Yeah, yeah. I got that. Gene Feldman: That the office was there. I remember setting up my office in it and I was so excited because what a great way to do virtual one-on-ones and virtual coaching sessions. You know, and then, ⁓ mesh pulled and, and in the midst of that, trying to get the headsets onto an enterprise network really is a red tape nightmare. Cause one of the things that I found, especially for the global companies, Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Is they want one device for everybody? Bobby Carlton: Mm-hmm. Damon Shackelford: Well that and they were under some really super tight cyber attacks at that point so they had to harden and harden fast. The easiest way to harden is just to say no to everything, everything, the whole universe. No, you start it no and you go down. Gene Feldman: Absolutely. And so. Yep. Absolutely. Mike Vann: What? Bobby Carlton: You can't go any further than nope. Gene Feldman: Yeah. And you, and then you have, yeah. But the problem is you, you also had two headsets, the Pico and the Quest. 50 % of people that you ask hate meta. Hate, they cringe when you say the name. I'm looking at somebody right now, every time I say it is right. I'm not going to say a name. I would never call Ron out like that. Damon Shackelford: Hahaha Bobby Carlton: Who is that person? Damon Shackelford: Ha ha ha ha! Mike Vann: Thank Lucky Lance K Gobindram: hahahaha ⁓ Gene Feldman: But then you have the other side that absolutely will not go with Pico because of its ties to bite dance. So now you've got these two different companies, you know, that you've got enterprises that only want one device. And until you can get past that, just, it kind of gets dead on arrival. And honestly, you know, I mean, I'm a victim of it, you know. Bobby Carlton: We're done. Damon Shackelford: Ha Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Gene Feldman: The times got tough and it was, it was always a running joke that I staked my entire career on XR at my former company. And when they pulled the plug, it, yeah, it was done. Bobby Carlton: The biggest roadblock, I think we were talking about it, is compliance. I think the biggest struggle with VR will always be that, ⁓ not to call it HR, but my wife is leaving the channel. Is it compliance to how the company is ⁓ run? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah Damon Shackelford: She's listening! Bobby Carlton: you know, are you doing everything? then yes, security, cybersecurity is a big part of it, right? And then like this headset versus that headset, right? Meta did not make it easy because they're like, ⁓ you want to use a headset? Enterprise training? Well, you got to spend so much a year per headset. And they're like, okay, like why are we on top of buying headsets? I now have to buy a seat, right? And the CTOs and the CFOs were like, just do training how we always did training. Why are we trying to bring in this layer that costs us all this extra money when we've been doing it like this for 50 years? But, yeah. Gene Feldman: Absolutely. I mean, it comes back down to the economics of it. The most economical thing is just put people in a room, train them or create an e-learning and just throw it out there and hope it sticks. Bobby Carlton: I mean, it's like, but again, and you could be weaponized with the data. You could be like, but the data says they learn faster, they retain the information, and they're gonna be like, that's great. How much is that gonna cost us? it... Lucky Lance K Gobindram: you Mike Vann: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Bingo. Bingo. was the... No. But they didn't listen to that argument. I pounded that argument for years and years and years in a value cost driven company. No, was Bobby's right. was always, what's it going to cost us? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: How much is it going to save them is the better answer. Mike Vann: That's right. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. What's it going to cost us? Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah. I mean, I still, I still remember, ⁓ Metta did a whole case study on me on saving money by travel, by having a factory tour. And I mean, so I even had the hard, hard data to validate it. And it, and what Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Yeah. We even grabbed some EBITDA, right? Actual EBIT. Nope, not good enough. Gene Feldman: Yeah. No, because it's not selling products. Bobby Carlton: You can show them. You can be like, hey, this is where this is going to be so valuable. And they're going be like, I agree with you. What numbers agree? That is so valuable. But how much is it going to cost us again? Does it slow up the current training process? ⁓ it does? What's the adoption for that? ⁓ really? And again, they're not spinning the tires. They're spinning the money. They're like, shh. And they're seeing money fly all around everywhere. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Bingo. Bingo. Gene Feldman: Yeah. But, and then once it catches on, now they're behind the gun and just literally throwing money at the problem. Damon Shackelford: which is what they're doing with AI. ⁓ Bobby Carlton: Yeah, I think, I think you guys as corporate people, you guys know, like the moment there's that door opening of like that negative, like creak, all of a sudden like, oh man, like, wait a minute, time out. Damon Shackelford: You Gene Feldman: it's a very CYA. To be a change leader, that's the thing is that a lot of people only cover their butt in this. Damon Shackelford: So good. Ugh! Mike Vann: Maybe, listen, I mean, we've seen this. ⁓ Maybe the right way is to start with revenue, is to help the guys and ladies selling and sales enablement and the teams that need really immersive sales support. ⁓ Maybe the right way in for the tools and the hardware is drive revenue and then you can spread it across the organization. But I think 15 years ago, wasn't, we're there now. Damon Shackelford: make it a profit center. Yeah. Yeah. I always thought so too. Yeah. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Mike Vann: Now we can send salespeople out with a kit or send kits out to the prospective customers to do really immersive, cool things. And if that works, right? If that works, you can drive actual revenue, which maybe is the right way to enter. Bobby Carlton: No, but see, you're talking about KPIs, which to all of us, those, KPIs are the fuel of the gods, right? You know who doesn't give a shit about KPIs? Is the fucking workers. They're like, they're the ones who like, they're they're like, Damon Shackelford: can't even spell KPI. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: I show up like, you know, like I, like it's my second job. I show up, you know, from like after work. I don't give a fuck about KPIs. It's like, they don't care. They don't care. And so that's, and it's unfortunate because if they did care. then I think you'd see that like, I think those upper leaders being like, maybe we should start to really listen, like Mike's got a point, know, Ron said, maybe that's, like if the people on the ground, right, all of a sudden cared about their key performance indicator. Yeah, yeah. ⁓ Mike Vann: Yeah, demanded it, yeah. Damon Shackelford: Yeah, Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It'd be different conversation for sure. Bobby Carlton: It doesn't matter if it you like, man, keep your credit score up, your KPIs up, you're make money. That's what it is. Damon Shackelford: And make money. I mean Mike's Mike's argument is strong, right? Everybody's in business to make money. So if you know, yeah Mike Vann: Listen, the closest we are to the revenue with any of our projects, if you get success, inevitably that trajectory is much better than any other cost centers in a company. If you're close to the revenue, it's a good place to be. Bobby Carlton: Mm-hmm. Damon Shackelford: Yep, never time. Bobby Carlton: Yeah, but again. Gene Feldman: Yeah. I mean, the way it was always explained to me is I need to justify how this pushes product off of a shelf. That's what it comes down to. Bobby Carlton: Yeah, right. How are you going to sell more bags of food? How can we be better about ⁓ being prepared for the next winter? Look at the data. And I do think there's visualized data, whether it's through virtual reality or augmented reality or through graphs. I think that the data is super important. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah, telling the story. It's a huge part of it, Bobby Carlton: Yeah, but I do think there's a disconnect, right? Because there's two parts of the business, right? There's the decision makers, there's the people who are doing the training. But then again, then there's the people who just who are no disrespect to people working the floor of a supermarket or a Target or a But again, they're a different type of person and how they view the company and how they view training is completely different. And that's where I think also that when it came to training and using virtual reality, we just assumed that those folks were going to be totally cool with it. Wrong. They're like, well, I'm not cool with that. you know. Damon Shackelford: That reminds me of a story. I'm sorry, I'm just gonna take a quick rabbit trail. I talking to a guy at another plant site down in Texas. He was a trainer. He was kind of like the Gene Feldman version for that site. He was all in on VR. He loved it, wanted it, went to some of his guys to get them into it and train them. And they're like, no, no, I'm not putting that shit on. Gene Feldman: Ugh. I, I still remember when I took it the first time I ever took it to a factory. had my Oculus, ⁓ Rift. Okay. This is the, yeah, this is going old school. And I had the, I, and I made sure to download the game wrecked that allowed you to rebuild the V8 engine at the time. And I'm like, I'm going to show them what you can do was possible within 10 minutes. I was carrying my gear out. Like I was fired from office space. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Wow. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: We lost him. Damon Shackelford: You Gene Feldman: You know, I'm just like, where's my red stapler? ⁓ I'm done. I'm done. Thank you. Bobby Carlton: Really? Damon Shackelford: And VR was so weird because you also had stories that went the other way, right? You walked into a room and you thought it was gonna be hostile and then the next thing you know they're like, wow, this is like Universal Soldier. I love this. Okay, I've got no rhyme or reason here. Some people hate me, some people love me. What's going on? Bobby Carlton: Yeah, this is way different. Gene Feldman: ⁓ yeah, and- Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It depends on who's on the other side, man. know, like it's very case by case. Damon Shackelford: And who, yeah, exactly, exactly. Bobby Carlton: What was it the remember and I remember one of the one of the early VR experiences I loved was the experience it was we'll go to the Star Wars that with the Millennium Falcon flies above you and lands on you have to help you ever play that one I think it was on the it was on the rift There's one experience yeah, yeah, you had to like press a couple buttons right and then and at the end you had like the star to push open you had a lightsaber and you kind of deflected but Gene Feldman: Yeah, it was just one of the experiences. There was no interaction. Yeah. Damon Shackelford: It wasn't one of the games? Huh. Bobby Carlton: It was this whole experience with the Millennium Falcon flew above you and then landed, you know, and Han Solo would be like, Hey kid, like, you know, you to these couple of buttons cause the landing gear is stuck and you did, it was a small task, but you did it. And I remember I played that for a friend of mine and she was like, this is game changing. But then I was like, Oh, now check this out. And it was like a VR training for like building something. She's like, well, this is dumb. Gene Feldman: Yeah. And yeah, because when people get into it, the last thing they want to do is work. They want, they want, they want to play with it. Bobby Carlton: That's right. Because work is work. Work is work. Doesn't matter. Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Yeah, yeah, right, ⁓ yeah, ⁓ yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Gaming's amazing in VR. It's been amazing. It's still amazing. Content construction has been amazing. still is. Work is very different. right. You're trying to retrain people's behaviors. Retraining behavior is hard. It's really difficult. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Gene Feldman: ⁓ yeah. mean, and I, I mean, look at smartphones. mean, smartphones, you know, merged from the Blackberry was supposed to give us more work, but now it's one of the biggest distractions at work we could have ever hoped for. Between TikTok videos, Wordle, and. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. ⁓ Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Mm. Yeah. Yeah. Whirlpool. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Spatial is gonna be the same thing, It's like nobody's paying you to have it, right? When it's a form factor change, it's gonna change. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ yeah, he's with, yeah, Mike's wearing his ribbons. Yeah. Mike Vann: Yeah, well, mean, everyone's going to have the glasses and they're going to be in all different form factors. These are the Evan realities, which don't, you know, don't. Yeah, they don't have cameras, right? And they don't, you know, they're they're they're actually a really nice setup. They do some things really well. They have the translation and they have a little bit of, you know, a little bit of a display. They're really good. Yeah. But everyone's going to have this stuff. So, I mean, Bobby Carlton: Yup. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: So good. teleprompter. The teleprompter is amazing. Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Gene Feldman: No, yeah, and why like is they're not as evasive as the because I've seen your displays on you and your displays looks like you just got out the military. Mike Vann: you Bobby Carlton: Is that an insult or a compliment? I can't tell. ⁓ Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah, they're not sleek. They're not sleek at all, man. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Mike Vann: They're not. Damon Shackelford: They call those birth control glasses, don't you Gene? Mike Vann: Got ⁓ all. Gene Feldman: I've heard that. Mike Vann: ⁓ Lucky Lance K Gobindram: No. Damon Shackelford: BCGs, yeah, that is the actual term. Bobby Carlton: ⁓ my god. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: But you just wait for those gentle monster ones and the scoochy ones by Android. They're gonna be slick, right? Bobby Carlton: I- Yeah. Yeah. Well, I do think that I do think VR, you know, I and we've been seeing a lot of it lately, right? VR is dead. People will be like, VR is dead. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: And that's been a conversation, but I'm on the side that it's not that. And I actually think we're actually in this sort of new horizon, right? The force awakens, right? This idea that I do think there is a sort of like where technology is going, where Google is going, and where, again, meta, know, Gucci Ray-Ban glasses, and I think with wearables. Damon Shackelford: Ha ha! Bobby Carlton: I think that virtual reality is, if anything, has now started to emerge slightly different. And it's now finding some decent footing in places where... it makes sense. And I do think like it's going to have this sort of like, I don't want to say crawl back moments, because that's like maybe but it's going to have this like new moments. It's not gonna be like Boba Fett coming out of the pit and having the book of Boba Fett moment. It's going to have this new moment where it's going to be this, I think it's going to find better footing in industries. Gene Feldman: No. I kind of look at we're in the rebuilding. Yeah, we're in the rebuilding years. It's like watching a sports team or a franchise. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: agree, you know, like. Damon Shackelford: It'll have a ta-ha moment. Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: If. Bobby Carlton: Like my New York Giants, we're rebuilding years. Gene Feldman: Yeah, it's like the Harley-Davidson AMF years. ⁓ Lucky Lance K Gobindram: No Damon Shackelford: Except the Knicks. The Knicks are always good. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Come on, we're up right now guys, we're winning. Sidebar, I've been watching the score. But no, it's like a PC, it's a PC revolution, right? You gotta think about it. you can't take, everybody's got bastardized picture because of a cell phone. Somebody paid you to have one of those super computers in your pocket. Bobby Carlton: Yeah, yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: No way paid you to have a computer. You look at the inflection care of an adoption of a computer. It took a long time. 30 plus years still, it's like everywhere, right? This is similar, right? And like, you know, there's a lot of nonsense out there, know, the Vision Pro is dead, they're killing. Come on, man, they sold 650,000 AVPs in the last year. That's 2.5 billion on the low end. That's not real big numbers, but big numbers by anybody else, right? Bobby Carlton: Yeah. Gene Feldman: ⁓ and especially they didn't need to manufacture one in the entire year. Bobby Carlton: What? Damon Shackelford: They were just selling the stuff in the warehouses? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah, but it's still crazy. You think about it, right? Like it's chipping away slowly. Bobby Carlton: It is, it is. I remember like, I can't remember what Zuckerberg, think it was maybe OC6, but I remember he was on stage and said, virtual reality technology is the fastest growing technology at the time. it was, was like the adoption of then of VR technology and how it evolved was the fastest growing, which is why he jumped all over it. But I also think that maybe was what held it back because it grew so fast that industries couldn't have time enough to figure out how to adopt it. But here we are now, know, 2026, we've had since 2015, we've had a long time of like, figuring out that now new technology can come out. And just look at how AI, right, the adoption of AI tools shot right up, but people were prepared for it because they had a path and... Damon Shackelford: ⁓ my gosh. Yeah. Bobby Carlton: I think VR coming back with AI, with these new tools, think now has this roadmap. And now, I think has that potential of like, we have a foundation, here's where it can go. And I think with hardware, with VR, AI solutions, it's no longer sort of like a what is VR question, right? Now military knows what it is, everyone knows what it is. And we're beyond that. And now it's like, okay. How does that look? What does that look like in my learning and development? What does that look like in my onboarding? What does that look like in my recruiting process? What does that look like in my offboarding process? What does it look like on my transferring ⁓ knowledge to younger employees? And we have a foundation for it. And I think, so I think this idea is like, that digital solutions VR, AR, XR, whatever want to call it. can slowly move into the right places on industries and get that adoption. So now then, all of us, our company, we're getting that business. We're able to work with, get those training in, get that development in. And that's where I think, and younger kids, right? They're tech savvy, but they're the future of employment. They're the future of employees. So. Damon Shackelford: you That's right. Yeah. Wow. That sounds like a great ⁓ end note on a great podcast, Gene. Aren't we at time? Gene Feldman: and their rule and We are at time, ⁓ which yeah, that, that is a great point. Usually we ask all of our guests to end with kind of their final protocol. And honestly, we were capturing that. That was great because it great one, because I remember him giving me a relatively same speech years ago and. Damon Shackelford: Ugh. ⁓ was a pretty good protocol. Bobby Carlton: Ha ha ha! Hahaha Mike Vann: Thank Gene Feldman: Absolutely. And, you know, and to me, this is very reminiscent of the conversation we had with Bob Stone where, you know, he outdates us and it's just the same kind of issues that we keep kind of running in circles around and keep trying to address as technology. So, but with that, ⁓ we are at time. First off, thank you to all of our panel and our protocol members. ⁓ lucky Mike, Ron and Damon really appreciate you guys joining today. And Bobby, seriously, thank you so much. Just to let you know, if you ever want to join again, be a fly on the wall, be a part of the panel. Bobby Carlton: ⁓ man. Anytime. Thank you guys for letting me be on your show. This is great. Gene Feldman: Yeah, you're more than welcome. There's a seat always here for you, my friend. Mike Vann: Thanks, Bobby. Damon Shackelford: We're a show now! Bobby Carlton: I can be a great fly in the wall, but I really appreciate this, ⁓ having it like being part of the show. love talk, love talking about this. I mean, I apologize if I talked too much, but it's something that, ⁓ you know, that, that ⁓ I've been working in this industry for a long time and, ⁓ you know, I'm not ready to let it go. Mike Vann: Love it. Damon Shackelford: You Gene Feldman: I think we're all in CPR mode at the moment. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah. Bobby Carlton: There you go. Clear. ⁓ Gene Feldman: So, but ⁓ absolutely. You know what? Coming on season three of the pit, saving XR. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hahaha Mike Vann: ⁓ That's a good one. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ jeez! Bobby Carlton: you Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Great job! Unbelievable. Gene Feldman: Isn't it? It's a fantastic show. And why I love Tuesday. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ Well, at least you didn't go to like Revenge of the VR or you know something, you know XR returns, a new hope. There you go. Bobby Carlton: There we go. Well, May 4th, everyone. Gene Feldman: Absolutely. And on that note, thank you guys for joining. If you like, please subscribe on Spotify, Apple music, and YouTube. We'll talk to everybody soon. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: You Bobby Carlton: Thanks everyone, appreciate you. Ron: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: And there's no such thing. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Bye guys. Mike Vann: Thanks, Bobby.