Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #13: The Independents, Rule Changes, Preseason Polls and Week 0 Preview
Transcript
- 0:11Hello and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:15This is episode 13, where I'll be previewing the final two teams for 2026, our two independents.
- 0:21There are some rule changes that we need to discuss regarding the college football playoff.
- 0:25I'll talk a little bit about the preseason polls, and lastly, I'll discuss the most important of the eight week zero games for the CSR.
- 0:33There will be two independent programs in 2026, Notre Dame and Connecticut, but that number was recently much higher.
- 0:39While most recent college football fans are used to two, maybe three independents in a single season, there have been years with several more.
- 0:46As recently as 2013, there were six independent teams throughout the college football world.
- 0:51And while independence from conference affiliation is becoming less frequent, there are reasons where a team may be forced to become an independent, usually conference alignment issues or teams moving up to the FBS.
- 1:02UConn is of the former, having been forced into independence when they moved to the Big East for basketball, and the American Conference would not allow them to remain as a football-only member.
- 1:11Notre Dame, meanwhile, maintains nationwide popularity plus its own network TV deal with NBC, making it unlikely Notre Dame has any reason to join a conference in the near future.
- 1:21Most previously independent teams have elected to join conferences for two primary reasons, a guaranteed share of television and bowl revenues and ease of scheduling.
- 1:30Because Notre Dame and UConn are not in a conference, the common sense rankings treat them a little differently.
- 1:35The value of a win and a loss against an independent is the average of the conferences of the teams they've played to that point in the season.
- 1:42So, if we look at Notre Dame's 2025 end-of-season schedule as an example, they played six ACC schools, two Big Ten, two SEC, one American, and one Mountain West.
- 1:53Their value, for sake of calculation of the teams they face, are then six parts ACC, two parts Big Ten, two parts SEC, one part American, and one part Mountain West.
- 2:04If we average all those up, that put their value at nearly same as the Big Ten and Big 12 for 2025.
- 2:09The same is true for the calculations for UConn.
- 2:12We just had slightly less difficult schedule of opponents, so their value was a little bit less.
- 2:16So, let me preview both these independent schools for 2026.
- 2:21The Notre Dame Fighting Irish were the first team to miss the college football playoff last season.
- 2:27They finished eleventh in the college football playoff rankings and twelfth in the final CSR.
- 2:31They were usurped by Miami for the final at-large CFP spot and consequently removed themselves from bowl consideration.
- 2:39Marcus Freeman is back to lead the Irish for season five in South Bend.
- 2:42Offensive coordinator Mike Denbrock is in year three of his current stint with the school.
- 2:47Chris Ash will return for year two at DC, and he'll be joined by co-defensive coordinator in twenty twenty-six in Aaron Henry.
- 2:54Notre Dame scored early and often last season, posting over forty-one points per game behind only North Texas nationwide.
- 3:00Four hundred fifty-eight yards of offense in their average game and turning the ball over just ten times all season allowed them to be a part of the CFP conversation.
- 3:09On defense, Notre Dame allowed fewer than eighteen points per game and ranked in the top twenty-five nationwide for yards allowed.
- 3:16Notre Dame found just seven players in the portal in the off-season but will welcome thirty new freshmen to the sideline.
- 3:21Francis Briwu is a D-lineman that looks to factor into stopping opposing rushers.
- 3:25Quincy Porter and Milan Graham are two new receivers for Heisman hopeful CJ Carr to throw to this season.
- 3:31Notre Dame's schedule this year includes three Big Ten teams, six ACC teams, BYU from the Big Twelve, then Navy and Rice from the American.
- 3:39The value they'll bring to teams they play will be the weighted average of each of those conferences through the week they've played.
- 3:45For example, since they play Wisconsin in week one, they will be considered equal to a Big Ten team through that first game.
- 3:51After playing Rice in week two, they'll then be the average between a Big Ten and American team after two games.
- 3:56That trend will continue throughout the rest of the season.
- 3:59Likely a result of not playing any SEC schools in twenty twenty-six, considering the SEC was the top conference by a wide margin in twenty twenty-five, Notre Dame's schedule is in the middle of the FBS for twenty twenty-six.
- 4:11They'll slot in slightly easier than Tulane from the American and Kansas from the Big Twelve.
- 4:15The Fighting Irish will play four of the bottom five teams from the ACC last season, plus dates with Miami and SMU in November.
- 4:22Their three Big Ten opponents are from the bottom half of the conference.
- 4:25BYU and Navy were both impressive, while Rice should be an easy win.
- 4:30If Notre Dame doesn't get ten wins, it'll be a failed season.
- 4:33But eleven wins or even an undefeated season is on the table.
- 4:36Seeing as the entire CFP qualification procedure changed to accommodate the Fighting Irish, it's playoff berth or bust in twenty twenty-six.
- 4:45The Connecticut Huskies went nine and three in 2025, ending the season on a four-game win streak.
- 4:50The Huskies have now gone bowling three of the past four years after going just one and 11 in 2021.
- 4:56Jason Candle takes over the reins of the Connecticut team, entering his first season after shifting over from Toledo.
- 5:02Both coordinators will be new as well.
- 5:04Nunzio Campanil will run the offense and Ryan Manilak the defense.
- 5:08UConn scored the fifteenth most points in the country last season, averaging thirty-five per game.
- 5:13They also committed the fewest turnovers nationwide, giving opposing defenses the ball just twice all season.
- 5:19Each of the Huskies' three losses came in overtime, meaning if they could have played just a shred of defense, there was an undefeated season lurking.
- 5:26Connecticut will welcome fifty-six new transfers this season, one of the largest recruiting classes in the country.
- 5:32With nearly every position seeing new faces, not just at starter, but as the next man up, it may take a few games for Husky fans to get used to the new roster.
- 5:39Jake Merklinger is the top transfer and will be that starting quarterback come week one.
- 5:44Kevon Sherman will be a linebacker on a defense that will likely have one hundred percent starter turnover from 2025.
- 5:51UConn will play one of the easiest schedules in the country outside the Mountain West and MAC.
- 5:55Their schedule contains three Sun Belt teams, two MAC teams, two Mountain West, one Big Ten, and one American team, covering an impressive five of the ten conferences among their eleven FBS games.
- 6:06Their toughest games when looking at the 2025 CSR will be the three against the Sun Belt.
- 6:11James Madison, Old Dominion, and Southern Miss were three of the top four teams from that conference in 2025.
- 6:18Nine wins was a surprise for Connecticut last season, but a return to a nine-win season would be less surprising in 2026.
- 6:24Expect the Huskies to be comfortably bowling this season.
- 6:28And that concludes our previews for each of the one hundred and thirty-eight FBS teams for 2026.
- 6:34With the season starting in just days, there are a few rule changes that need to be noted before the season starts.
- 6:40First, the college football playoff is still at twelve teams, the third year at that number.
- 6:44However, there have been conversations about what it looks like in 2027 and beyond.
- 6:49The decision seems to be between a sixteen-team model, maintaining current qualification rules, expanding at-large bids and getting rid of byes, or a twenty-four-team model, which would likely eliminate the conference championships and potentially push the college football calendar into February.
- 7:04But none of that is set to happen this year.
- 7:07So what is happening in 2026?
- 7:10First, it is no longer the five best conference champions.
- 7:13After last year with the ACC championship going to eight and five Duke, selection criteria has changed to specifically include the Power Four conference winners.
- 7:21Another update is there must be at least five conferences included, but not necessarily conference champions.
- 7:27The highest ranked group of five team, whether or not it won its championship, will also get invited to the college football playoff.
- 7:34Notre Dame's status is also updated.
- 7:36If Notre Dame is in the top twelve, then it is guaranteed to go to the playoff, potentially taking a spot from a team ranked ahead of it.
- 7:42So let's work with a doomsday scenario given these new constraints.
- 7:46Let's say the 2025 Duke situation happens in all the Power Four conferences.
- 7:50A team that goes 0 and 3 out of conference, but 8 and 1 in conference play wins on the first Saturday in December to secure an auto bid.
- 7:57Multiply that out by the four Power Four conferences.
- 8:00Now we have four necessary conference champions outside the final CFP top twelve.
- 8:05Additionally, the top group of five team finishes eleven and two outside the top twelve.
- 8:09Notre Dame, if they're ranked eleventh just like last year, is also guaranteed a spot.
- 8:13So the seventh, eighth, ninth, tenth, and twelfth ranked teams in the final CFP rankings would be replaced by teams ranked below them.
- 8:20Personally, I don't feel as though it's an appropriate method if in a twelve-team playoff if it could, in theory, omit the seventh-ranked team.
- 8:29Other updates to college football that have been announced since we last played a meaningful game include a new eligibility framework.
- 8:35Previously, you could play four years in your sport over a five-year period, allowing for one redshirt year.
- 8:40There were, however, specific waivers given by the NCAA to athletes who had extenuating circumstances impact a year of eligibility.
- 8:48If you go back to twenty ten, Case Keenum was one such case, having suffered a season-ending injury after already having used his redshirt year.
- 8:54He then broke all sorts of passing records for college football quarterbacks.
- 8:58A more recent example was Diego Pavia, who was granted an injunction to play a sixth year of college football in twenty twenty-five, then nearly won the Heisman.
- 9:07Trinidad Chambliss, early this past off-season, received an injunction in a Mississippi state court to allow him to play in twenty twenty-six, saying he was unfairly denied a traditional medical waiver for a sixth year.
- 9:17With the new NCAA rule that’s been dubbed five for five, several athletes from the twenty twenty-two high school graduating class have been flooding the US legal system, saying they’ve been improperly treated by the NCAA, and there are several situations where they’re being allowed to play.
- 9:31I’ll do my best to summarize the legal status of such claims, but keep in mind I am nowhere near a legal expert.
- 9:37A nationwide lawsuit handled by a district court judge in Denver granted a nationwide preliminary injunction.
- 9:43It declared all high school class of twenty twenty-two athletes who had already played in four seasons, allowing them to play a fifth.
- 9:50The US Court of Appeals, less than two weeks before the season is set to start, froze that injunction pending a full appeal.
- 9:56That puts the class of twenty-two athletes in limbo, making them ineligible at the moment for the upcoming season.
- 10:01This is different, however, than several state-level lawsuits that were passed.
- 10:06This includes temporary restraining orders and injunctions passed by individual states that are independent of the US Court of Appeals decision.
- 10:13One particular lawsuit in Kentucky allows quarterback Thomas Castellanos, previously of Florida State and Boston College, to play a fifth season.
- 10:21It also allowed two University of Louisville players, D’Angelo Hutchinson and Jabari Mack, to return to the Cardinals for season five.
- 10:28The most alarming instance of bending the NCAA’s rules took place just days prior to this podcast release.
- 10:33The Cleveland Browns of the NFL waived undrafted tight end Daquan Wright and as part of a state-level lawsuit in the state of Louisiana, that player is now expected to suit up for the LSU Tigers this fall.
- 10:44You heard me correctly.
- 10:45A player that was on an NFL team will be playing college football in 2026 All these issues, plus NIL and the ever more crowded transfer portal, has made collegiate sports an absolute mess.
- 10:56While I won’t be going down any potential future rabbit holes, the next couple of years will likely determine the future of college sports.
- 11:02And if all that isn’t enough, starting in twenty twenty-seven, the FBS college football season will extend earlier by one week, starting the week before Labor Day.
- 11:10Teams will now play twelve games over fourteen weeks, still concluding the weekend of Thanksgiving.
- 11:16After all that, the on-the-field rule changes almost seem irrelevant.
- 11:20There will be nothing looking incredibly different in 2026.
- 11:22Offensive pass interference is now 10 yards instead of 15, and there are new rules surrounding the suspensions of players who've been ejected for targeting.
- 11:30Everything else on the field is minor, and most casual fans will not notice Next up, I want to talk about the preseason polls.
- 11:37The AP poll was released a few weeks before week zero, as is its custom, but let me reiterate the idiocy that accompanies a preseason poll.
- 11:46By the Associated Press' own standard, voters are meant to vote based on, quote,"performance, not program reputation or preseason speculation," end quote.
- 11:56Let me say that again.
- 11:57They ask voters to vote based on performance, not program reputation or preseason speculation.
- 12:03What is the preseason poll if not speculation?
- 12:06How in the world are preseason polls a thing?
- 12:10I said this in episode one, and I'll say it again.
- 12:12The polls, especially early in the season, but frequently later in the year, are a way for brand names and the big conferences to prop up their games each week.
- 12:21It behooves a conference, and through the conference, the TV networks, to say,"We have nine of the top 25 teams," or,"We have two top 10 matchups on our network this week." But the actual ranking, the number next to their name, especially in the preseason, means nothing.
- 12:37But if that number next to your team's name means that much to you, then the top five in the AP poll were Ohio State, Oregon, Georgia, Texas, and Notre Dame.
- 12:48Last year's two national finalists were up next with Indiana at number six and Miami at seven.
- 12:54The SEC led the way with nine of their 16 teams being deemed worthy of a number.
- 12:59The Big Ten followed with eight, the Big 12 four, ACC with three, and then Notre Dame grabbing a spot as an independent.
- 13:06Every single ranked team is from a Power Four conference, further emphasizing the point of the preseason poll, to give those conferences a prop up.
- 13:14The top teams from the Group of six, all of whom show up under others receiving votes, were Boise State, Navy, UNLV, and New Mexico.
- 13:22There were a total of 10 Group of six teams that received at least one vote, and I want to give a huge shout-out to poll voter David Briggs from the Toledo Blade who had Western Michigan in his preseason number 25 spot.
- 13:32I think the Broncos make a run at the college football playoff this year.
- 13:36Feel free to keep these receipts.
- 13:39So let's dive into what should be impacting poll voters as the season progresses on the field performance.
- 13:45That performance will begin with the season's appetizer on August twenty-ninth.
- 13:49There will be eight games played to start the year.
- 13:51That's the most in week zero since there were eleven in twenty twenty-two.
- 13:54First, let's answer the question as to why teams get to play a week ahead of time.
- 13:58There are three reasons of which two will be used in twenty twenty-six.
- 14:02The first reason is aptly named the Hawaii Rule, which impacts six of the eight games in week zero.
- 14:07Any team that has a game scheduled to play at Hawaii, whether conference or non-conference, can play a game a week early to allow for an additional buy throughout the season to make up for the exhaustion of travel.
- 14:18This also applies to Hawaii, so you will almost always see the Rainbow Warriors playing in week zero.
- 14:23An additional component of the Hawaii rule is the ability to play a thirteenth game to make up for the cost of traveling to and from Hawaii.
- 14:30There will be one team playing at Hawaii who will be playing a thirteenth game this season.
- 14:34That is San Jose State.
- 14:36The second reason teams can play in week zero is if they're playing internationally.
- 14:40This is why the other two matchups are being played a week early.
- 14:43Any team playing internationally due to travel time and distance is also allowed to start seasons in week zero.
- 14:49This applies to TCU and North Carolina who are playing in Dublin, Ireland.
- 14:53This also applied to the Virginia NC State game.
- 14:55It was originally scheduled for Rio de Janeiro, but was moved back to the States too late to adjust both teams' schedules.
- 15:02The third reason is for very specific cases in which conference realignment creates scheduling issues.
- 15:07The NCAA has also granted waivers in very specific cases in which its two nationally recognized blue bloods and they move it for broadcast reasons.
- 15:14No week zero games fall under this category in twenty twenty-six.
- 15:18As for the actual games, the ACC has the most teams playing with five.
- 15:22The Mountain West, not coincidentally Hawaii's conference, has four.
- 15:26Conference USA has two.
- 15:28The MAC has two.
- 15:29Then the Big Ten, Big Twelve and American each have one.
- 15:32When the Common Sense rankings look for the most impactful games of the week, it looks at the conferences that don't play many times throughout the season, not necessarily highly ranked teams or interesting personnel matchups.
- 15:43The biggest showdown of Week Zero is Stanford and Hawaii, as it's one of just two matchups between the ACC and Mountain West this season.
- 15:50Hawaii won the matchup last year at home and propelled the Mountain West to a winning record over the ACC in twenty twenty-five, lowering the value of an ACC win and increasing the value of a Mountain West win in the CSR.
- 16:01The ACC will play CU at SA three times in twenty twenty-six, the first of which is Florida State, New Mexico State in Week Zero.
- 16:09While the two conferences will play five times, any non-conference Power Four matchup is one to keep an eye on, and the first of those games will also kick off the season.
- 16:17TCU and North Carolina will play in Dublin to begin the season at noon on ESPN on Saturday.
- 16:22We'll have a potential for eight two-and-oh teams after Week One, with wins against two FBS opponents.
- 16:28The other eight teams playing in Week Zero are either on bye in Week Two or play an FCS school.
- 16:32The best chance for a team to jump to an early CSR lead is either Florida State or Stanford, who each have a conference game in Week One following their Week Zero tilt.
- 16:42Non-conference matchup numbers are at an all-time low.
- 16:45With the SEC and most of the ACC going to a nine-game schedule, there are fewer inter-conference games to be played.
- 16:51With one hundred twenty-five of the one hundred thirty-eight teams playing at least one FCS opponent this season, we're having to work with very limited information between the conferences.
- 17:00I can understand how this lack of data points could be considered a detriment to the Common Sense rankings.
- 17:05CSR conference strength is entirely dependent upon head-to-head records against the other nine conferences.
- 17:11I will reiterate that within a single season, head-to-head conference records are truly the only way to determine which conferences are the strongest.
- 17:18Any assumptions that were made before the season should be put to rest by play on the field.
- 17:22If you're a college football junkie like I am, you've been ready for this Saturday's warm-up slate since Indiana raised the College Football Playoff trophy.
- 17:29I hope you all enjoy the return to the field.
- 17:31If you're looking for more interaction with the Common Sense rankings, follow@commonsenserankings on the socials and check out commonsenserankings.com for weekly updates.
- 17:40I'll be back after the dust settles on Week Zero to recap the impact of results in the Common Sense rankings and preview Week One matchups.
- 17:47Until then, as you go about your day today, please use some common sense.